18 ms·
Got a Hot Seller on Amazon? Prepare for Amazon to Make One Too
- bitL 11y agoYes, it happens all the time on Amazon. Not only Amazon itself, but also other companies observing hot sellers (there is an API for that), then "cloning" the item and ordering manufacturing in Shenzhen. If you complain to Amazon, your selling privileges might be removed... Amazon desperately needs a competitor.
- eganist 11y agoYup, and they've (as far as I've heard -- could be wrong) threatened to blacklist sellers who move to upstarts like Jet or even if they sell more prominently on eBay. Perhaps I don't know the definition of anticompetitive, but I feel like this fits the bill.
- ikeboy 11y agoI haven't heard that. They have a rule that you can't sell items elsewhere for less than you're selling them on Amazon for, but otherwise there's no restrictions.
- eganist 11y agoThe Jet threat came to a friend of mine, but I think you're right regarding selling items for less. There are a few mitigations for that specific restriction which have allowed some sellers to continue selling on multiple channels, but though some are likely obvious, I'm pretty sure I signed my right away to talk about said mitigations in public. If not, I'll reply back with more. Will have to check.
- Someone1234 11y ago> They have a rule that you can't sell items elsewhere That's a pretty anti-competitive rule if true. Essentially it means you cannot sell on Jet.com because of how Jet.com's pricing is calculacted (any product COULD be cheaper on there if you stack enough of them).
- ikeboy 11y agoYou can limit the quantity on Jet, and you can put the price high enough that even with stacking it comes at to parity with Amazon. Or you could have similar stacking discounts by creating multipacks on Amazon. See https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=1161240 https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=... near the end.
- bitL 11y agoForm a Nevada-based LLC specifically for selling on Jet for $500; ignore Amazon.
- ikeboy 11y agoSure, as long as they aren't the same name, and you have a way to ship those orders separately from Amazon ones. But then don't complain if Amazon finds out and bans you.
- bitL 11y agoUsual stuff when dealing with Amazon - never use the same browser/IP address/geographical location with two different accounts. Use different VPNs for different accounts/companies. Doable. Only the paranoid survive.
- gherkin0 11y ago> and you have a way to ship those orders separately from Amazon ones What do you mean by this? How likely would it be for a seller to even be in a position to ship orders from multiple websites in the same box? And how would Amazon find out without buying things on competitor websites and checking return addresses?
- ikeboy 11y ago>How likely would it be for a seller to even be in a position to ship orders from multiple websites in the same box? And how would Amazon find out without buying things on competitor websites and checking return addresses? Well firstly if you do something stupid like FBA multi-channel fulfilment, AZ may catch on. I don't mean shipping different orders together, I mean shipping from the same warehouse. If the value is significant, I wouldn't put it past amazon to place a test order. Probably unlikely, but when you're breaking your business agreements, do it properly. I have heard horror stories of people doing well selling some product buying from the manufacturer, and Amazon went to the manufacturer and bought on condition they don't sell the product to anyone else.
- jhall1468 11y ago> If you complain to Amazon About what, exactly? Amazon isn't in the business of deciding trademark/copyright/patent disputes. If a clone of a product is violating IP, then you need to handle it legally. If there is no IP to protect, then you made a mistake.
- bitL 11y agoSure, but we all know costs of a litigation which most sellers on Amazon can't afford - Amazon takes most of the profit, 15% default fees leave very little to normal sellers, usually under 5% as the (re-)pricing competition is now algorithmic, resembling HFT. Then if you want to have your product featured on Amazon (meaning your offer will be the default one even if it is more expensive than somebody else's), you need to contact the category manager and it's up to their discretion to decide (which reeks of a high potential of corruption/profit sharing etc). On one hand it's pretty cool you can automate price responses and very beneficial to the customer, on the other the game has an increasing risk of being rigged.
- jhall1468 11y ago> Sure, but we all know costs of a litigation which most sellers on Amazon can't afford That's an excellent argument for changing how patent litigation works, but that has nothing to do with Amazon. > Amazon takes most of the profit, 15% default fees leave very little to normal sellers The trade-off being potentially billions of eyes on your product. Again, that has nothing to do with IP.
- vtlynch 11y agoNo. If Amazon is willfully allowing clones that violate IP or other rights, then it is 100% in their interest to take action on that.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIt's only a clone if they're violating a brand or other trademark. Otherwise, folks are just upset that their product has now turned into a commodity.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoIn theory though, if Amazon is making a superior product that's cheaper, isn't that what competition is supposed to achieve? I've bought a few AmazonBasics(cables, mostly) and have been pleased with the quality, but it could be radically different with other products.
- Bjorkbat 11y agoBut that's the thing, it's a little bit questionable for Amazon to be a competitor. They started out as a partner that offered a retail platform for Rain Design, only to turn around and come up with a cheaper product. Even though it's perfectly legal, there's still an expectation of trust, which they've violated. Would you sell products on a platform knowing that if you were too successful the people operating the platform would turn around and come out with a cheaper product? I wouldn't.
- chrisgd 11y agoIt is questionable because no one has been able to do it before. Free markets yada yada. . . I would sell a product until I couldn't sell any more regardless of the risk. If only copyrights on media properties were this fluid.
- mintone 11y agoAbsolutely not true. Supermarket own-brand has been around for years and years, along with department store own-brands. The original brand sells based on brand reputation and (perceived) quality of product. This is exactly the same.
- deelowe 11y agoNo only that, walmart will use their purchasing power to force manufacturers to make products specifically for them. Examples of this include things like specific SKUs that are smaller so that walmart can sell similar products at a lower price (e.g. 12oz versus 16oz).
- 11y ago
- mooreds 11y agoHow is this different than the private labels of major grocery stores?
- tamana 11y agoPrivate label products are generally made by the same manufacturer as premium label.
- mooreds 11y agoSo if Amazon contracted with same manufacturer and just took some of the margin for distribution, that'd be OK (or at least less bad)?
- Falcon9 11y agoYeah, most manufacturers would be happy with that deal. It isn't what Amazon is doing though. When I sell to CostCo, I'm very happy to manufacture their house-branded vitamin C in exchange for them carrying my premium name brand vitamin C in stores as well. I make money on both products. (Heck, I as the manufacturer pay money out of my own pocket to advertise that CostCo branded vitamin C.)
- roasm 11y agoHow do we know that this isn't what Amazon is doing? Maybe they're not doing it with the specific product in the original post, but they're not directly manufacturing all the products under their brand. They're going to some supplier/manufacturer. Private label manufacturing deals are as secretive as possible so the owner of the market (in this case, Amazon) can change the supplier when it suits them giving them leverage in the negotiation. I'd bet you can find that exact AmazonBasics cable you just bought from the same supplier with a different name on Amazon, too.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoYikes. Makes me wonder what kind of recourse could be possible. Often I see a lot of "death to IP protections!" chants around here, which makes this situation all the more interesting. In my view this is a pretty clear 'derivative' infringment, and if there's enough of them, could there be a class-action approach to signing up those who can make the connection? "Ripping-shit-off" isn't a very pleasant business model in my opinion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jhall1468 11y ago> In my view this is a pretty clear 'derivative' infringment That's copyright law. This is a patented product. As long as your product doesn't infringe on the patent, it's not an infringement.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoI get that distinction, and wonder why the patent isn't solid enough to pursue action against what looks like a direct imitation. If a copy can get so close but still avoid 'infringement' then the patent isn't doing its function properly. Strange.
- pravda 11y agoI wonder how you can get a patent on a laptop stand. I assume it is a design patent.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThat's what I would gather as well...sounds like, well, maybe they didn't. Or they didn't get a very good one? Tough to tell, I feel for them though.
- brianwawok 11y agoExcept in many cases there was no rip off involved. Very common example: Someone sees something on alibaba that looks cool. Say an apple peeler for $.50. So they buy 10k of them, slap on a label that says BlahBlah Inc, and sell on Amazon for $10. Maybe they give away 500 of them on review sites to build up some reviews for the brand BlahBlah Inc apple peelers. Other people buy the same thing from alibaba, slap a different label on, sell for $8. If Amazon goes straight to the manufacturer and asks for it in a different color to sell for $5 under the "Amazon Basics" label.. who really got ripped off? The invention was already there. The wholesaler was already there. It is just shifting around who gets what piece of the profit pie. Can see 100s of these kind of sellers on /r/FulfillmentByAmazon
- cylinder 11y agoE-Tailer was an odd word choice in the headline. I read a few paragraphs in still trying to learn more about the company "E-Tailer."
- vnchr 11y agoAgreed. Seems like they were dancing around naming Amazon in the title.
- tantalor 11y agoHuh? "Amazon" is the 6th word of the title.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThe title makes more sense as: "Got a Hot Seller on Amazon? Prepare for Amazon to Make One Too"
- pwython 11y agoOr even "the e-tailor."
- mooreds 11y agoMaybe they didn't want the word Amazon in the title twice? Was weird. Who uses the term e-tailer anymore anyway? Seems like a blast of fresh air from 1999.
- themodelplumber 11y agoThis was an oddly-worded comment. I read two sentences and still didn't understand anything about the referenced "E-Tailer" corporation. Is this what upvotes have come to?
- dang 11y agoSounds like we need some title redundancy in the title.
- jamescun 11y agoI feel for Rain Design (I love my mStand); however is this any different to your average supermarket offering lower priced own-brand competitors to their other stock?
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI think the mixed incentives problem is becoming more and more glaring with each passing day. Want to write an app that people use on their phone? Awesome. Become an Apple Dev or a Droid Dev. It's the lottery: the providers love you playing, but only about 1-in-100 make it, and "making it" is not about quality. The garden is too big to be manually cultivated, so the winners are the ones that can play the algorithm. Have a site online you'd like people to visit? If you're advertising it, you're going through Google or Facebook. Just be sure you don't accidentally flip any yellow flags with them. If you do, they can yank your advertising and you're talking to a robot trying to get it back. Unless you're big, of course. Or you can play the algorithm. How about if you sell a physical product? What if you've been selling it for years? Well, you gotta go to Amazon. They own internet product sales. But guess what? If you switch to a provider, you don't have an email list, you don't have a unique internet address, you don't provide a unique experience, and whatever you do has just become a commodity. And we're back to the algorithm thing again, because if you can source, package, and sell it on Amazon? Somebody else can too. Probably cheaper. Maybe it has high quality parts. Maybe not. There's far too many products for Amazon to manually curate, so you're back to worshiping the algorithm. The algorithm provides traffic, it provides recommendations, it provides an indication of quality text content -- it provides sales. Make a mistake in the old brick and mortar days? Go change your sign. Deal with complaints through the BBB. Make a mistake now? Sure, there's recourse. Sometimes. It's all about the algorithm. And we can't tell you what's in the algorithm, because if we did? Everybody would be gaming it. Like they are now. The algorithm rules all. Cross it and die.
- mooreds 11y ago> The algorithm rules all. > Cross it and die. Or, differentiate, use these awesome platforms as a traffic source or branding help, focus on direct to the consumer sales and loyalty, and/or build a better product and keep doing so. Middle men have been around for millennia, these new ones are just that much more efficient. But small fry have more resources now too.
- brianwawok 11y agoSo what was this like 30 years ago? No algo with no internet. You make a business, you try to sell it around your town. If you do really awesome you can get 75% of X business in your town. If you do really really really awesome maybe you can franchise it across the country. But most people topped out at ruling a town. Now we are competing on a world market. Gains are much bigger, but everyone has 500 competitors. You tend to get nothing or $billions. Good for the consumer I think, as they can get the best version of X. Not so good for the 499 other businesses that close.
- personlurking 11y agoAlso relevant from 2 months ago: "Company Makes $70M Selling Random Stuff on Amazon" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11186289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11186289 I also remember another somewhat 'recent' article about a secretive company doing what AmazonBasics is doing now but I can't locate it.
- ikeboy 11y agohttps://www.fastcompany.com/3021229/chaim-pikarski-the-amazon-whisperer https://www.fastcompany.com/3021229/chaim-pikarski-the-amazo...?
- personlurking 11y agothat's the one!
- danvoell 11y agoNot sure why this leaves such a bad taste in my mouth. Obviously, a lot of major retailers already do this. It just seems like Amazon can do this at a much bigger scale and/or at the same scale as Walmart and end up putting a lot of people out of business.
- themartorana 11y agoBecause Amazon claims to be your partner in business when they're really using you until they have no more need for you. Other major retailers may compete with each other with similar items, but they're not partners, they're competitors.
- chrisgd 11y agoIs there anything different with Costco offering a Kirkland Signature anything after they see that product flying off the shelves? Kirkland signature olive oil, balsamic vinegar, coffee, shirts, shoes, peanut butter. Even newer products like air popped quinoa chips or coconut water. If you see something new in everyone's cart one day, two months later there is a kirkland signature brand.
- aroch 11y agoI think one way it is, at least a little, different is Costco is frequently purchasing those products from the original vendor in bulk and handling the packaging / distribution themselves. As a result, $NameBrand is making money on both the branded and generic versions of ProductX.
- EdHominem 11y agoOne $NameBrand is, the rest are not. So for all companies except that chosen one, this is the same; brand-name products being undercut by (someone else's) no-name.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- imaginenore 11y agoGood. Competition is what keeps the quality high and prices low.
- aetherson 11y agoYeah, seriously: "Oh my god, a laptop stand is now being produced at half the price of the previous one! The sky is falling!"
- thesmileyone 11y agoNo, because when the competition goes bankrupt, they put their prices up and quality no longer matters. And thus, evil corporation monopolys form.
- dubcanada 11y agoThis isn't exactly news... This has been happening since we began selling stuff. You know how to combat that, keep the price the same, and make a name for yourself as the best laptop stand around. People still buy all kinds of US made products even though there are China made versions for 50-70% off.
- tamana 11y agoThis isn't really a Made In US vs China thing. Almost nothing sold in US is made in US.
- dubcanada 11y agoYes it is, this is the exact same thing. There are shop out there that sell knock off purses and watches (exactly the same as on Amazon) yet people still go to Louis Vuitton and buy their purses. It's a free market, people are welcome to remake a product with a slight change and sell it.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Almost nothing sold in US is made in US. Almost nothing, huh? http://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-manufacturing-dead-output-has-doubled-in-three-decades-2016-03-28 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-manufacturing-dead-outpu...
- vblord 11y agoUnfortunately this type of behavior is not uncommon with Amazon's business practices. The book "The Everything Store" by Brad Stone was a very good book. But it also shows how Amazon deploys these types of business practices. With the huge market share Amazon has, it has crushed many smaller business just by selling cheaper products. For example, it took a huge loss on selling Diapers just to destroy a competitor. Because it has so many resources, it can do these types of things.
- mooreds 11y ago> Rain Design’s Tai has resigned himself to the competitive threat from Amazon and says he can withstand it if he’s able to foster customer loyalty. And how do you best do that? Build your own channel and don't depend on Amazon.
- cylinder 11y agoBut everyone is looking on Amazon first. I know I would. Most have Prime and want to use it above anything else. Prime isn't sustainable on its own. Amazon can make the loss and still convince investors to stick around. Mom and Pop can't ship you something via airplane for free AND cut price by half.
- willholloway 11y agoWhat's needed is a competitor to Prime thats federated. I would love a one click payment processor that had my cc and shipping info that was low fee, and available on independent web sites. The small amount of friction of putting in shipping address/cc makes me look to Amazon first.
- incongruity 11y agoThe other big draw to Amazon, for me, is the reviews. I know it's not perfect, but by and large, items with 4 or 5 star reviews tend to be good. Going outside Amazon leaves me without that, most of the time. Add that to your federated system and I'm sold.
- mooreds 11y agoI think that'd be great. Would be a great opportunity for some other retailer to do this. Wal-mart? Target?
- triangleman 11y agoShopRunner was giving out 1-year trials and extended them every year for quite a while. I almost never used them.
- djrogers 11y ago
- kristianc 11y agoAWS is a gigantic platform for doing just this. It's not just a retail thing.
- shostack 11y agoIs there any evidence of this? I have to admit, the amount of data Amazon would have about the intimate inner workings of companies using AWS is terrifying.
- kristianc 11y agoIt's hard to be sure that that's what Amazon is doing with AWS, but Simon Wardley has done some detailed and compelling analysis to suggest that they are and why. One of Wardley's central theses is that it would make little sense for Amazon to do AWS if not to act as a sensing engine: http://blog.gardeviance.org/2014/03/understanding-ecosystems-part-i-of-ii.html?m=1 http://blog.gardeviance.org/2014/03/understanding-ecosystems...
- arprocter 11y agoOnline retail is always a race to the bottom, as mostly all anyone cares about is price. When I was in the business, it was a continual hunt for new/unknown products we could sell at a decent profit before other sellers got on them and the margin got trashed. For a niche product it seems a little odd that Amazon would make their version half the price. Then again, they may argue that theirs is a 'budget' version, and thus it doesn't compete with the original.
- csours 11y agoUg. I know exactly what you are saying, but at least some people also care about quality; however, in the race to the bottom it is very difficult for the customer to assess quality and for the supplier/manufacturer to maintain quality. I don't know if there is a solution to this.
- bitL 11y agoI think most e-commerce companies end up the following: -1-2 person companies where one person does competitive software and the other hunts for products with good margins to sell - large established companies with special deals with e-tailers no small sellers can compete with
- cc438 11y agoThe reason AmazonBasic's offerings tend to dominate their respective markets isn't because they are the cheapest option. They dominate because they are the cheapest option which you can trust to work and continue working for whatever is considered a reasonable lifespan for that category of good. You're right in that people care about quality, it's just that quality products don't have to cost as much as you think they do.
- LoSboccacc 11y agogot a camera stand. averageish quality at discount price, and I think that's a very good formula, perfect fit for an online seller. not to shoddy to get a bad name, good enough for what it does and priced among the cheapo option of which is the better.
- drpgq 11y agoI wonder what happens when people give low ratings to Amazon basics items.
- joemi 11y agoIf you're suggesting giving low ratings as a reaction to what Amazon's done and not because it's actually a bad product, I really wish you'd reconsider. Seems like a rather slippery slope, to start basing product reviews on something other than the products.
- programminggeek 11y agoPretty much everybody selling on amazon should expect this. It's not exactly news.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoIsn't this similar to what Grocery stores have done for years? Cereal, pasta, bread, canned goods, you name it, there's a store brand.
- overcast 11y agoBig difference with food, is that it's usually not quite as tasty. They cut corners to make it cheap. Whether that translates into some silly plastic thing Amazon is taking over production of, I don't know.
- joemi 11y agoI always thought the store brands of things like that weren't independently developed, but just batches of the product it's cloning that didn't pass that company's standards or something like that.
- overcast 11y agoEither case, they certainly don't taste the same in my experience.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoYeah, I doubt Amazon is cutting any corners. /s
- awinter-py 11y agoAMZN's growth prospects increasingly resemble abuse. Half their success at breaking into new business is consumer trust / lock-in. ('they already have my address & payment info, let's do business with them again'). The situation isn't as nice for their merchant customers; this is amazon's achilles heel. Companies like crowdsupply are the leading edge of a trend to use logistics & sales smarts to help merchants rather than compete with them. amazon has ridden the wave of consolidation until now, but let's cross our fingers that the tendency will toggle to diversification.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- massysett 11y ago'they already have my address & payment info, let's do business with them again' I had hoped Apple Pay would help here. I order a lot on the phone. No way I am going to input address, payment info, and create a password just so I can spend $15 on something from the phone. I will just buy Amazon or wait to go to the store. With Apple Pay I would think the address info could be transmitted to the merchant and I could pay with my thumbprint. The hoopla on Apple Pay was on point of sale transactions, but that was a yawn to me--saves me a swipe, who cares? It's shopping on the phone that needs a boost. But it seems few online merchants take Apple Pay and Apple has no easy way to find those that do. I guess Google Shopping is going for this problem but it doesn't deliver to my area.
- chatmasta 11y agoWatchya gonna do about it? Amazon makes merchants an "offer they can't refuse." Fear of Amazon cloning your product (whether physical via Amazon Basics, or virtual via AWS) is not enough reason to avoid selling on Amazon altogether. If your product is easily cloned by Amazon, and you cannot afford to sell it for less than Amazon, then you do not deserve to have the dominant market position. A good, sustainable product is more than just marketing and engineering. It must also be defensible, meaning you need to have an advantage in either product-development (patents, expertise, first-mover advantages) or supply-chain (exclusive manufacturing contracts, access to greater economies of scale). It's almost impossible to beat Amazon in the supply-chain economics, unless you have a highly specialized product and deals with the manufacturer, so you are left to compete in product development. Your product needs to be sufficiently innovative and defensible in order to avoid Amazon cloning it.
- x5n1 11y agoAmazon has economy of scale, it can make deals for more units and therefore drive down the cost. It also has negotiating and brand power to coerce suppliers to give a better price much like Wal-mart. Amazon competing with its own retailers is a stupid idea and will cause many of them to pull away. Say you offer 1,000 products. Do you really want Amazon knowing which ones are popular? Just like everything else is now the case with Amazon. You can't build your own business on someone else's platform. Hell if they start stealing data from AWS from their competitors I would run like hell away from their services. What you are going to do about it is run away from Amazon. That's what.
- chatmasta 11y agoSure, you can run away from Amazon. But then you lose the marketing, fulfillment, and shipping channels offered by Amazon that you cannot possibly achieve yourself. Many customers will only purchase from Amazon, not some janky online store where they need to enter their credit card number. So you lose those. And you could contract with custom fulfillment centers and achieve two day shipping, but you're not going to be able to offer the shipping for free (prime), and the fulfillment will cost you more than Amazon unless you're moving huge volume. If you offer 1,000 products, as you say, then you're in the wrong business. Did you develop every one of those products? I highly doubt it. So you are just a store selling thousands of products from different manufacturers. In that sense, you are a competitor to Amazon. How can you possible beat them? You've already lost. The article is not referring to selling thousands of products, it's referring to developing and selling one single, specialized product, and then getting it "stolen" by Amazon. In this case, you are not originally competing with Amazon, but rather using their platform to sell your product. Once they clone your product, then you are competing with Amazon. At that point, if you have not established defensibility, you deserve to be undercut by Amazon. There are many ways to establish defensibility: patents (Amazon cannot clone your product without paying a license fee); branding (customers will only buy your product, not some cheap clone); custom development (Amazon cannot clone your product without hiring specialized experts). If you are selling some cheap run-of-the-mill product from China, and all you have for defensibility is branding, then you are going to lose to Amazon. But if you have invested years of experience and engineering talent into a custom product protected by strong patents, and branded it well enough that customers know the product is only good if it comes from you, then you will beat Amazon and you can sell to their customers without worrying about getting cloned.
- MicroBerto 11y agoI have it on good authority that supplements will be coming too. Probably starting with basics like a multivitamin.... No clue how deep they'll go though.
- tomp 11y agoSo... one company is upset that another company has entered their market, after they've been scamming consumers, selling a $20 item for $40 for years? Color me shocked.
- ericabiz 11y agoJust like Shake Shack is "scamming" people by selling an $8 burger when McDonald's sells a burger for 99 cents. What scammers! (sarcasm)
- tomp 11y agoShake Shack doesn't complain about McDonald's entering its market.
- EdHominem 11y agoRight - if Shake Shake complained about the $0.99 hamburger, it would be implying "... which is a perfect substitute for our $8 burger." The issue isn't two laptop stands. It's that one laptop stand is claimed to be a rip-off of another - ie too similar. But it's cheaper so if it's too similar than the first one was a rip-off for the consumer. (ie same product, worse price.) Yes, one man's rip-off is another man's profit margin but nobody is owed their margin. They can't expect anyone else to cry when their market-control is broken.
- fabulist 11y agoI think the issue is that Amazon has access to their sales numbers. Normally a competitor would have to put in work to infer your sales numbers from, say, an incrementing identifier in the receipt, and you would have some recourse (prevent information from leaking as best you can). It seems to me there is an obvious conflict of interest. Consider this; if an employee left to work for a competitor and took such precise information about online sales with them, it would be illegal.
- tmaly 11y agoFor me there are positives and negatives to this type of move. The small mom and pop stores are supporting local jobs in some cases. In other cases where the product is mass produced overseas, I would prefer the lower priced Amazon Basics product. CVS a pharmacy in my area does something like this. The slot on the shelf for the brand name product you want is usually empty. The generic CVS brand of that same product is fully stocked right next to it. I sometimes just go to a non-chain pharmacy just so I can get the brand I want.
- learc83 11y ago>I sometimes just go to a non-chain pharmacy just so I can get the brand I want. Is this for drugs or something else? Generic drugs are regulated by the FDA and have to be completely identical to brand name drugs.
- 542458 11y agoThe medical ingredients are identical. Everything else may or may not be. You might want children's medication in a given flavour, or the "fast acting" delivery mechanism that may not be available in the generic format.
- Tenhundfeld 11y agoNot OP but I see it for many different types of items. Think bandages, ankle wraps, mouth wash, antacids, OTC pain relievers, etc. You might say that antacids and OTC pain relievers are drugs, and that's fair. But there are other concerns besides the active ingredients. For example, I might prefer the taste of Tums to CVS brand. Or for a personally-true example, I used to find the CVS brand ibuprofen gelcaps to have a funny, sour smell that I didn't notice with Advil. (I don't notice that anymore.) Or my grandmother used to buy a specific brand of some contact lens cleaner (can't remember which), because she found the top much easier to open. The point is it's not always about the efficacy of the drug; sometimes it's about the overall experience.
- conductr 11y agoI've noticed this issue too. Some people prefer to use a brand like Tylenol instead of the store brand acetaminophen. But the store will just not keep the Tylenol stocked to force you to by their brand. They are both the same acetaminophen. However, I do notice that with some meds the store brand isn't an equal because they don't make the gel tabs I prefer (because it's more fast acting than the chalky white tabs), specifically talking OTC allergy meds
- gmantom 11y agoAmazon is a lot like China. You go make your stuff in China it's cheap, they have the factories, the facilities. You do well. Once they, in China and at Amazon, notice that what you're doing is selling quite well they make the same thing and cut you out. Edit: Spelling.
- tn13 11y agoIf you have a successful product there will always be a competitor. I think that is a good thing.
- Kiro 11y agoI've never understood how that Rain stand could cost so much and still be so popular (I have one myself). At first I thought it was an official Apple stand but no.
- rdl 11y agoI'm wary of business models built around just selling hardware, long term -- it seems like hardware + service combination is the way to prevent this kind of activity from vendors, ghost shift manufacturing, other counterfeiting, and such. Also good for the consumer in a lot of cases. The problem is the products run the risk of being orphaned if the manufacturer stops supporting them at some future date.
- fabulist 11y agoWhy is this legal? Aren't they using their dominance in one market to enter another market? Isn't that what antitrust suits are for? I'm not being rhetorical, I'm actually asking.
- djrogers 11y agoIt's not an anti-trust case because there are literally thousands of other retailers - both online and brick&mortar. Amazon has nowhere near a monopoly on anything here, they are running a store. Just like walmart, target, costco, Safeway, etc - all of which have their own house brands.
- fabulist 11y agoI find it incredibly hard to believe that Amazon is not a monopoly. This Forbes[0] article from 2013 states that Amazon had more sales than it's next 12 competitors combined, and that it's sales were growing faster than overall online sales. If we take this as read, that means Amazon is probably more dominant in 2016 than it was in 2013. That doesn't seem like meaningful competition, that seems like the other retailers are keeling over. [0] http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2013/09/01/fascinating-number-amazon-is-larger-than-the-next-dozen-internet-retailers-combined/#15e9fc00581b http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2013/09/01/fascinati...
- joemi 11y agoAmazon would do (and probably still does) this in another way, too. When I was selling on Amazon for a bookstore, our strategy was try to find books that Amazon didn't have on the site, then sell them, and if any sold well we'd send massive quantities to Fulfillment By Amazon so we'd sell a lot and not have to ship each copy individually. The first time this happened, we sold something really well for 5 or 6 months, and then it stopped selling completely. Turns out Amazon started carrying it and was selling it far below list price. Then it happened again with another book after a few months of good sales. And then again. After the third or fourth time Amazon suddenly undercut us like that, we gave up on the practice, since between the already low FBA margins and the cost of returning all the unsold products to us (and the publisher) since we couldn't move them anymore, we weren't making enough for it to be worth the effort.
- mindotus 11y agoOuch, what did you guys end up doing? Move to your own platform?
- rpgmaker 11y agoRight, because everyone just has their own "platform". And one that can compete with Amazon no less.
- joemi 11y agoWe stopped shipping things to FBA. Sadly we still had to sell on Amazon since it's the best way to sell books online, even with their shenanigans. But without FBA benefits there's no way to compete with Amazons deep discounts on new books, so we pretty much only sold used books. It feels absolutely horrible knowing that the only way to make any money online with books is to sell on your biggest competitor's site.
- thefastlane 11y agoeveryone hates banks but, come on, AMZN is about as filthy of a corporation as they come.
- mesh 11y agoRelated PlanetMoney episode: Episode 586: How Stuff Gets Cheaper http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/11/28/366793693/episode-586-how-stuff-gets-cheaper http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/11/28/366793693/episo...
- merb 11y agoI don't see the competition, I would still buy the non Amazon Basic one. The only time I grab a Amazon Basic product when I don't need it a "long" time. actually even the amazon basic batteries are worse than any cheap vatra. if people would care about quality they would mostly spend less money on rebuying the same damn thing. btw. on the german website the amazon basic thing looks very different when I search for laptop stands (only a direct search 'AmazonBasic laptop stand' would give me the thing in the news and actually even then there is another competitor that isn't Amazon and 10 € cheaper than the Rain Design). it is more close to a product by hama which was there LONG LONG before the Rain Design product. Also Rain Design has sometimes flaws. According to buyers, sometimes you get scratches or rough edges. For 50 bucks thats definiv a NoGo!
- sunstone 11y agoLike Bezos needs to move in on a niche aluminium computer stand business. Pick on someone your own size Jeff.
- morgante 11y agoWelcome to capitalism, supercharged. There's a reason that in the long run economic profit of firms is theoretically 0. If you're making substantial margin off a product, and doing so in volume, other companies will naturally want to compete with you to sell it. You either have to innovate faster than them (and thus win customer loyalty) or get into a brutal price competition which pushes both your profits to 0. Keeping your products off Amazon isn't even a defense against this. It's hard to keep a lucrative product secret for long. Cash cows eventually moo. Your margin is Amazon's opportunity. Get used to it.
- transfire 11y agoAnti-trust action is going have to come down on Amazon eventually.
- thesmileyone 11y agoThey have been doing stuff like this for ages. If you sell a product on amazon and they decide they want in, you are forced to give them your source or they terminate you. Then they go to your source (or more likely their source) and buy in bulk then undercut you or minimise your listing... and so you are priced out of the market.