15 ms·
For life expectancy, money matters
- emodendroket 11y agoIs this news to anyone?
- amelius 11y agoThe numbers are.
- b0t 11y agoWhile it is an obvious truth, it's nice to have some statistics to back up the notion.
- emodendroket 11y agoFair enough.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoI wonder whether they accounted for suicide. I'd expect the rates to be higher in the rust belt.
- limaoscarjuliet 11y agoOr, perhaps, people who have health issues make less money? Correlation is not causation.
- alkonaut 11y agoWhen it goes both ways it can be called a "spiral" or "trap". Poverty does that on a wide range of issues.
- ikeboy 11y agoOr something else contributes to both income and health (intelligence seems like a good candidate, there's a similar multi year life expectancy difference between the high and low ends). I wonder how much simply controlling for parents' money and health would make this go away, although that doesn't separate effects from monetary inheritance.
- ikeboy 11y agoAlthough poverty might affect intelligence (I'm not sure the current state of research. Definitely there's a correlation, but I don't know whether genetics fully explains it or whether we can point a causal arrow from poverty to lower IQ.)
- gadders 11y agoCommon sense would appear to suggest that, on the whole, lower IQ could be a cause for poverty.
- ikeboy 11y agoSure, but some have suggested the reverse as well.
- emodendroket 11y agoWhy do we need to study anything at all when we can just rely on our self-serving intuitions?
- gadders 11y agoSo you think having an IQ below 100 wouldn't hamper you in the job market?
- emodendroket 11y agoDepends on the work; not all work requires you to be a genius. But simply saying it's "obvious" that that must be one of the prime drivers of poverty strikes me as 1) not that obvious at all 2) self-serving
- dschiptsov 11y agoPeople with weak immune system, autoimmune diseases, bad habits related disorders (almost everything, including depressions) etc, would be outperformed by top achievers (outliers), but they would be in the "average" region. It is the same model as IQ, where wast majority are average.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoCorrelation doesn't equal causation. I'd bet that an alcoholic millionaire would have a shorter life expectancy than a healthy street sweeper. It isn't money that matters, it's the cultural norms.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoIndirect causation is still causation. Two people have heart-attacks in middle age after eating cheeseburgers their whole lives. One of them doesn't have health-insurance, and dies, perhaps having never even received good health advice from a yearly check-up. The other is well-off, and so gets stabilized in the hospital and eventually provided with heart surgery (and a whole load of admonishments regarding lifestyle).
- ZenoArrow 11y agoAs I said before, it's about the cultural norms, which is exactly what you've just described. For an example showing that money and cultural norms are not necessarily linked, take a look at Ikaria: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/28/magazine/the-island-where-people-forget-to-die.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/28/magazine/the-island-where-...
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoWhat cultural norms? We're talking about two men who made exactly the same bad lifestyle choices. And I know a number of living candidates to be both these guys!
- joefarish 11y agoAn alcoholic millionaire having a shorter life expectancy than a healthy street sweeper doesn't mean there isn't a correlation between wealth and life expectancy.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoI never denied that correlations could exist, but correlation is not the same as causation. In other words, you can have overlap, but one doesn't cause the other. In terms of causation, stress can influence life expectancy, and lack of wealth can affect stress (which is especially exacerbated if a country doesn't have public healthcare). Quality of food and water can also be an issue in a society with stark inequality. That's basically as far as it goes. Poor people can be healthier than rich people. If wealth was a dominant cause of better health then that outcome would be unlikely.
- okket 11y agoCall me a heretic, but a 10-15 years discrepancy at a baseline of 70+ years life expectancy does not sound that scary or problematic to me.
- thomasahle 11y agoWith a median yearly household income of $51,939, that's up to $779,085 you only get if you're rich.
- imtringued 11y agoI think his argument is that you've already retired at that age and it's to be expected that your live will end in a few years.
- jimmytidey 11y agoAs a comparison, if a containment in the water supply caused 10-15 year reduction in life expectancy, that would be considered a crisis, and there would be outrage.
- emodendroket 11y agoReally? You wouldn't be concerned about your life being shortened by a decade and a half, then?
- timje1 11y agoUnfortunately ageing doesn't tend to be 'some years tacked on the end', it tends to be literally getting older at a different rate. So some 40 year-olds are physically 30, and other 40 year-olds are physically 55. (going by length of telomeres, physical fitness, etc etc). So these people that die earlier have a shorted 'prime of their life' as well.
- mdemare 11y ago"Low-income residents in wealthy areas, such as New York City and San Francisco, have life expectancies significantly longer than those in poorer regions." That's somewhat surprising. I wonder if the reverse holds - do rich people in poorer regions have shorter life expectancies than in richer regions?
- manibatra 11y agoCould be. Richer regions would have better health care, emergency services, sanitation, etc
- jpadkins 11y agobeyond basic healthcare, better healthcare has surprisingly low effect on life spans.
- nappy-doo 11y agodo you have a citation? This seems like an incredible result, and I would love to hear more!
- coldtea 11y agoI've seen it established too, though I don't have the citation either. But doesn't seem too "incredible", it's mostly the typical notion of "diminishing returns" we see everywhere.
- dschiptsov 11y agoObviously rich could afford fresh, non-junk food, less toxic environments, better ecology (less polluted, less crowded areas with better water sources - less infections, less hazards, etc). Mere environment matters a lot. Update: What is wrong with that? Look how rich segregate themselves and where they used to live. Also ask any sociologist or comparative historian.
- yummyfajitas 11y ago
- chatwinra 11y agoFor me, this is the most important aspect of this paper: "People say, ‘Americans are living longer, so we ought to delay the age of retirement,’ but … it’s a little bit unfair to say to low-income people that they’re going to get Social Security and Medicare for fewer years because investment bankers are living longer.”" As the divide between the rich and poor keeps growing [1], we need to start doing something about it in all areas, and this seems like a really important finding for that. [1]http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/employment/in-it-together-why-less-inequality-benefits-all_9789264235120-en http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/employment/in-it-together-why-l...
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAccording to the original article, life expectancy differences "were not significantly correlated with access to medical care, physical environmental factors, income inequality, or labor market conditions." https://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=2513561 https://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=2513561 So in fact doing something about the "divide between the rich and poor" is unlikely to help. It might even be counterproductive if it reduces income (which is highly correlated) and if this effect is causal.
- chatwinra 11y agoThe point you're referring to relates specifically to geographic differences. From the results section: "inequality in life expectancy increased over time. Between 2001 and 2014, life expectancy increased by 2.34 years for men and 2.91 years for women in the top 5% of the income distribution, but by only 0.32 years for men and 0.04 years for women in the bottom 5% (P < .001 for the differences for both sexes)." So I think the co-authors had a point when they talked about retirement age!
- yummyfajitas 11y agoSee Figure 8 for numbers on "Population-weighted univariate Pearson correlations estimated between local area characteristics and race- and ethnicity-adjusted expected age at death for 40-year-olds in the bottom income quartile." The CIs for income inequality (as well as health care factors and local labor market conditions) do not exclude zero.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoMy go-to story whenever anyone says "money can't buy happiness" is this: A good friend of mine was diagnosed with Liver Cancer around the same time as Steve Jobs. Both lived near SF, and both were put on the waiting list for transplants around the same time (+- 2 months). She was young, very sick and otherwise healthy so was a good candidate to be high on the list. Then I heard about Steve "moving" to Tennessee [1] to get on a different, shorter transplant list - and thus receiving the transplant needed. She died shortly after, never receiving a transplant, while Jobs lived two more years. This is not a complaint or gripe about fairness, but just a demonstration of how two very different people in a very similar predicament had massively different outcomes based almost entirely on wealth, fame and power. Money buys access, which create options, which enable health, freedom and longevity. It's so simple and obvious I don't know how people can argue otherwise. [1] http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/southern-transplants-how-apple-ceo-steve-jobs-got-the-liver-he-needed-in-memphis-ep-307208860-329010091.html http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/southern-transplants-ho... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=od6Nq_bN_XY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=od6Nq_bN_XY
- nxzero 11y agoAs if someone is able to simply decide to be Steve Jobs, as wealthy he was, etc.
- emodendroket 11y agoWhat does "deciding" have to do with it?
- nxzero 11y agoMy understanding of your comment is that instead of my position that it is illogical to believe everyone can be as wealthy as Jobs, that everyone should get the same medical care regardless of how much money they have to spend. Right? If so, unclear to me how such a position would play out in the real world. Please explain.
- 11y ago
- lionsgate 11y agoOne can wonder how much comes down to poorer people eating junk food, smoking and alcohol abuse. I've never been that well of, but at the same time I've never afforded to smoke or drink a lot. In fact nowadays I do neither. Makes you wonder how some can being poor.
- lazyjones 11y agoThis. A lot of habits that make people ill, also make them poor. I'm well-off but in relatively poor health and don't see how I could "buy" a significantly better life expectancy at this point. Sure, a shorter organ transplant list helps in some cases (not mine though), but that specific advantage can't explain 15 years on average (while smoking alone counts for 10 years or so).
- whiddershins 11y agoI believe they said that eve controlling for such obvious factors didn't explain it.
- kamaal 11y agoI think eating fat, smoking or other kinds of addictions are a deeper symptom of depression or some other kind of a mental infinite loop from which the addiction gives you a pause. I remember an instance in school, I asked my friend why he smoked or indulged in drinking. His answer was simply it was just not possible to go on with life without it. He had a myriad of relationships with girls, and dozen problems at home, he was a troubled kid and got into trouble often at school. A lot of what I understood- smoking gave him a pause from all that. I would wonder poor people might be more prone to this sort of stuff due to the very obvious reasons. However this sort of addiction can happen due to various other reasons too. For eg read this: https://www.quora.com/Im-22-year-old-Indian-guy-and-I-need-your-suggestions-to-come-out-of-this-situation-Please-read-the-description/answer/Saurav-Karanjai?share=1 https://www.quora.com/Im-22-year-old-Indian-guy-and-I-need-y... Even smart, intelligent people can be trapped into addictions of various kinds from which it can be hard to break out.
- ommunist 11y agoIt looks like Universal Income will not drastically improve life expectancy.
- reasonattlm 11y agoPeople fixate over these tiny things, little differences in the arrangement of deck chairs, as they are dying of a medical condition called aging, that might be controlled and prevented entirely if enough of them stopped fixating on tiny things and started helping to fund rejuvenation therapies. There are startup companies now, today, working on the first rejuvenation treatments that address one of the actual root causes of aging. Oisin Biotechnologies and UNITY Biotechnology. Look them up, look up the senescent cell clearance methodologies they are turning from labwork to clinical treatment. These therapies will not cost very much when ready, simple mass-produced infusions. Yet what is in the news and the thing that people pay attention to? Tiny differences in the status quo, who has a better deck chair as the ship is going down. It is a frustrating thing to be living in the human condition.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoDidn't you post this exact thing last night?
- reasonattlm 11y agoIt is an important thing to say. Among the less attractive aspects of human nature are a fixation with what is rather than what can be, the tendency to limit the definition of success and desired outcomes to whatever the best of the present options might be, and a burning desire to tear down those who have more than you rather than work to create more for everyone. Even in an age of rapid, radical change driven by advancing technology, the vast majority of people focus entirely on the distribution of present assets and opportunities, giving little to no thought to the much larger set of assets and opportunities that we could create for tomorrow. You see this in the vastly greater attention given to any evidence for distributions and correlations in life expectancy between populations today, and the tiny amount of attention and support given to the production of rejuvenation therapies to greatly increase life for everyone at a modest cost. Given the realization of SENS rejuvenation treatments, the first of which are already under development in startup companies, and most of which will take the form of comparatively low-cost, mass-produced infusions, ten year variations in longevity due to lifestyle choices or access to medicine will be swamped, made irrelevant and small.
- givan 11y agoEverybody works hard to make money so they can live longer and better then they realize they forgot to live.
- sb8244 11y agoMy argument (currently) is that money can buy a housing location next to your office. Completely removing a commute is a pretty big happiness booster.
- the_gastropod 11y agoThis is pretty interesting, given the article about NY's poor being healthier than other poor Americans that was on the front page of HN yesterday [1]. I wonder how much of this can be attributed to environmental factors (long commutes to work, few quality grocery stores, violent crime, etc.) I'm glad there seems to be a fair bit of interest in figuring this mess out. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/11/upshot/poor-new-yorkers-tend-to-live-longer-than-other-poor-americans.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/11/upshot/poor-new-yorkers-te...
- justsaysmthng 11y agoI think the conclusion can also be read like this: A social system were everything is for money is deadly for some. I wonder if the same conclusion can be replicated in countries with more social protections (Scandinavia for example).
- ars 11y agoIt would be interesting to correlate this with IQ. It's well known that higher IQ correlates with greater income. I wonder if higher IQ also correlates with better health. Even more interesting is if being around people with (on average) higher IQ, correlates with better health by osmosis of sorts, by people picking up good habits from those around them.
- idanoeman 11y agoYep. And both of those correlations have plausible causations in both directions. * Higher income -> less likelihood of lead poisoning -> higher intelligence * Higher intelligence -> more success in job market -> higher income * Better health as a child -> better brain development -> higher intelligence * Higher intelligence -> more likely to exercise, eat healthy -> better health
- monkeypizza 11y agoThere is tons of research on this. Higher IQ at young ages, independent of social class, strongly predicts health outcomes. Since it also predicts income, and since a big part of IQ can be predicted before birth, IQ seems to be the real driver here. From here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_epidemiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_epidemiology A strong inverse correlation between early life intelligence and mortality has been shown across different populations, in different countries, and in different epochs."[3][4][5] A study of one million Swedish men found showed "a strong link between cognitive ability and the risk of death."[6][7][8][9] A similar study of 4,289 former US soldiers showed a similar relationship between IQ and mortality.[7][8][10] The strong correlation between intelligence and mortality has raised questions as to how better public education could delay mortality.[11] There is a known inverse correlation between socioeconomic position and health. A 2006 study found that controlling for IQ caused a marked reduction in this association.[12] Research in Scotland has shown that a 15-point lower IQ meant people had a fifth less chance of seeing their 76th birthday, while those with a 30-point disadvantage were 37% less likely than those with a higher IQ to live that long.[13]
- CuriouslyC 11y agoNote that the centenarian populations of various blue zones are not typically high income - in fact, many of them are members of rural, agrarian communities. Eat good food, get plenty of exercise, and try to relax and be gracious.
- pmlnr 11y agoCome to Europe. We have cookies.
- stared 11y agoIt is useful to look at the comparison between countries: - just static graphics: http://static.gapminder.org/files/vector-graphics/gapminder-world-2013.pdf http://static.gapminder.org/files/vector-graphics/gapminder-... - interactive, new data: http://www.gapminder.org/tools/bubbles#_state_marker_size%2F_label_extent@:0&:1;;&axis%2F_y_zoomedMin:45.8;&axis%2F_x_zoomedMin:543.53&zoomedMax:140375.09 http://www.gapminder.org/tools/bubbles#_state_marker_size%2F... - text: http://www.gapminder.org/posters/gapminder-world-2013/ http://www.gapminder.org/posters/gapminder-world-2013/ To be honest, since there is variation between countries (for Russia vs Japan it is ~20 years!) it would be really surprising if there were no variation within countries (especially as uneven economically as US).
- tn13 11y agoThis does not surprise me anyone. Richer people can afford better life in general, better healthcare, better spouses etc. etc. It would be a surprise if they dont live longer than others.
- ori_b 11y agoHaving money is strictly better than not having money. This is not something that is in question. Money doesn't solve all problems in life. However, nearly every problem that exists without money will be no worse with money. The reverse is not true.
- known 11y agoAnother good reason for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income