21 ms·
The Housing Market in San Francisco and Ideas to Fix It
- jakelarkin 11y agoAnother political solution is for the state government to step in. Growing regional housing and transit is a prisoner's dilemma in the sense that no individual municipality wants put up it's fair share of the cost and necessary changes in zoning. Metro areas with highly fragmented governance like the Bay Area deal with these issues very poorly. http://www.vox.com/2016/4/6/11370258/honan-zoning-reform-bill http://www.vox.com/2016/4/6/11370258/honan-zoning-reform-bil...
- bdhe 11y agoI think a tragedy of the commons is a better description of the problem (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons) than the Prisoner's dilemma (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner%27s_dilemma). Individual home owners in the cities and towns dotting the Bay Area are still better off not coöperating with each other to increase housing supply.
- paulsutter 11y agoOne issue he doesn't mention is traffic congestion. A potential remedy could be a significant tax on parking. Perhaps very significant. Parking is ugly and a blight on the city, as well as a tremendous waste of space that could be more effectively used for housing.
- mmagin 11y agoYou already have SF placing a maximum (not a minimum) amount on how much parking is built per new housing unit. Theoretically people are supposed to use mass transit more as a result, but the city government repeatedly cripples SFMTA, as I understand it.
- zt 11y ago(I'm the author). Traffic is a big problem -- as is parking. Public transit investments do have to correspond with building housing, but too often the lack of one is used as an excuse not to expand the other. We have to start somewhere. As I said in the post, public transit deserves it own analysis -- I was already in the thousands of words just on housing! -- maybe that will be next.
- xenadu02 11y agoIndeed. In the current Prop-13, anti-tax environment you simply cannot propose building infrastructure to support future needs. The need must already exist and be bad enough to get people to vote for taxes to pay for improvements. Muni will not be extending T to Fisherman's Wharf, nor BART building a 2nd trans-bay tube and line through the Richmond/19th Ave unless the bay area can manage this housing problem and bring in more residents to pay for it.
- Zhenya 11y agoInstead of taxing people (negative reinforcement), build better (or at least function) transit with the absurd amount of tax dollars already generated(positive reinforcement). Taxing parking(which is already done) is something only 2 groups of people will/can support: 1) Those without a car ( can afford to live close to work,take uber, rent cars - high income people) 2) Those who can afford the tax (high income people) So no, this is most definitely not the solution.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoYou don't have to tax it. The city doesn't even charge for metered parking spaces on Sundays. Just pricing these would be a huge first step.
- richmarr 11y agoI'd be interested to see projections of earthquake casualties before and after this increase in housing density.
- nickhalfasleep 11y agoMorbidly, I think a big earthquake will be the turning point for housing in the Bay Area. After a 6.5+, just about all the brick buildings will be degraded to the point of no return. We might see plenty of new steel / wood construction with the rebuilt (or 3d-printed) facades of old buildings, with new heights and efficiencies inside (better lighting, accessability, modularity).
- shostack 11y agoI've often thought it might take a natural disaster to fix things a bit. But realistically, at this point I'd expect investors to circle the aftermath like vultures waiting to throw money at whatever they could. There might be a small downturn, but then things will get right back up there. My hypothesis is that it would only slightly dent demand for the area. And that says nothing about all the single story wood-framed ranches in the Peninsula which would largely be fine.
- mng2 11y agoWe already had Loma Prieta in 1989. You don't see very many bricks in the Bay Area, compared to back east.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoIn the Loma Prieta quake it wasn't FiDi skyscrapers that collapsed.
- thedevil 11y agoWhile I agree with the post, I think the need for more housing is obvious and the root problem is political. If you find a way to solve the political problem, I'd be impressed.
- zt 11y agoI'm the author: I agree with you. I believe there are political solutions. Putting ideas out there to see if anyone agrees with me is the first step, hopefully not the last.
- thedevil 11y agoProps to you for organizing a discussion as a first step. And best of luck solving the problem. If I still lived in the Bay Area, I'd show up for support.
- ryguytilidie 11y agoBiggest issue for me is public transit. If BART was more reliable/faster, it would be easy for people to live in Berkeley, Oakland, San Leandro or anywhere along the line. I actually bought a house in Richmond because it was cheap and I could BART into the city. What was once a 30 minute ride usually takes a little over 40 now. We really need to fix transit in the bay area. More ferries would be great imo.
- mahyarm 11y agoFerries are even slower and less reliable in my experience. If you didn't live where the track died, then you would still say BART is more reliable. I've noticed BART is less reliable in the edges vs the core of SF, berkeley and downtown oakland
- joshrotenberg 11y agoI ride (and complain about) BART regularly to/from SF from the Berkeley/El Cerrito area. The truth is that it's still pretty reliable, though having lived where I am now since 2004 the decline in reliability and increase in crowding clearly isn't going to stop. One alternative is AC Transit's transbay service, which I swore by for many years. Unfortunately the increase in road traffic has that option declining as well. There has been talk in the past about a Berkeley Marina/Albany Bulb ferry, but to my knowledge there are no current plans. I haven't ridden the ferry many times from other places, but I'd like to think that having that as an option would get a decent amount of ridership as well as possibly reduce the load on the roads and tracks. The lack of any ferry service connecting the East Bay between Jack London Square in Oakland and Vallejo is pretty surprising. Judging from the fact that a morning commute-time BART train starting in Richmond is typically standing room only by El Cerrito Plaza (third stop on the line), I'd say the demand for alternatives is definitely there, so there must be financial/political/engineering reasons that there are no ferries from other parts of the East Bay.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- ModernMech 11y agoThe folly with arguments blaming San Francisco for the problem is the fact that the entire Bay area is priced at an insane level. Take another look at this [1] BART map with corresponding home prices for each stop. Yeah, it's cheaper to live outside of the city, but it's still crazy expensive. The median sale price for a house in Pittsburg is $430,000, with a 62 min commute into SF. If you live 62 minutes outside of say, Pittsburgh PA, you can certainly expect your median home will cost ~$120,000 or less [2]. It's been my experience that while square footage cost may go down outside the city, you really end up paying around the same rent for a larger space. So if you can't afford a $3000/mo rent in the city, you probably still can't afford the $2800/mo rent you'll pay in Daly City. I expect what would really happen if SF just went all in building new housing, is that prices would drop in the city slightly, allowing people to move back into the city, thus increasing demand and increasing prices back to where they were. The places where rent would drop are the suburbs, where people were pushed out to initially. A way to look at it would be that SF's sphere of rent influence would end up shrinking, but the magnitude of the epicenter remains unaffected. [1] - http://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit-stop http://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit-... [2] - http://files.zillowstatic.com/research/public/realestate/ZHVI.Pittsburgh.394982.pdf http://files.zillowstatic.com/research/public/realestate/ZHV...
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoYep, the East Bay is quickly losing its status as the cheap overflow for San Francisco. A lot of the Peninsula and Santa Clara County is bad too.
- runchberries 11y agoYeah. In Palo Alto my crappy 1 bedroom apartment that I was living in 3 years ago was in the middle of suburban jungle (no restaurants or shops for a few miles in any direction) and was $1650. I looked last week and it was $2500. That was a crappy place. If you want to live by downtown PA (university Ave) its right around $2800-3000 for a 1 bedroom, for places with 20 year old appliances and no upgrades. The peninsula is just as bad because of school preferences, etc. New engineers getting hired in MV and PA literally can't afford to live by themselves in a 1 bedroom. That is fucked.
- exabrial 11y agoI think a $25 minimum wage hike would definitely fix it..........
- epoxyhockey 11y agoHousing affordability is a nation-wide problem. Since the housing bust of 2007, little new housing stock has been added, save for oil & gas boomtowns of Texas and North Dakota. We are all now competing for limited housing in most every major metropolitan area. The solution is for every city to build more housing, not just SF. Unfortunately, new housing starts have only recovered to 1993 levels. http://www.macrotrends.net/1314/housing-starts-historical-chart http://www.macrotrends.net/1314/housing-starts-historical-ch...
- mikeyouse 11y agoIt's even more striking if you adjust for population: https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/fredgraph.png?g=45EC https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/fredgraph.png?g=... That's just a quick look of housing starts / population but we've steadily been building fewer houses and the whole thing fell of a cliff during the financial crisis. Even in the recovery, we're off the chart.
- marknutter 11y agoThe only way to fix the housing market in San Francisco without destroying what people love about living there is to reduce the number of people living in San Francisco. And the most direct and effective way of doing that is to destroy the ridiculous bias against remote working. For all the innovative, intelligent, talented people in the Valley that we haven't yet figured out how to work together to build software without physically being in the same room is pathetic. We'll look back on this in the same way we look back on child labor and seven day work weeks.
- beatpanda 11y agoI think you're wrong about this. Low-height buildings are not what I loved about living in San Francisco. I think San Francisco would become a dramatically more livable city if you just replaced some of the single-family homes in the Sunset with triplexes, for instance. But you're also right that there isn't a defensible reason for forcing so many people to move here to take jobs in the tech industry. Lots of people would live elsewhere and work remotely if they had the chance.
- tribaal 11y agoI'm surprised and a little saddened that this is not higher up. The root cause of the problem is that there are too many people wanting to move to San Fransisco because that's where the (tech) jobs are. Spread out the jobs to spread out the people?
- marknutter 11y agoI'm saddened, but not surprised. Like I said, there's a really weird bias that a lot of otherwise progressive and intelligent people have against remote work, and I've never heard any convincing arguments from people who've tried both that one way is categorically better than the other. Perhaps it will take something as extreme as a major environmental or economic catastrophe to warm people up to the idea because people seem to be clinging to the old ways for silly reasons.
- mdb333 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_%281978%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_%281... Good thoughts. You failed to mention Prop 13 which was put into place a long time ago and simply doesn't make sense anymore. It's at least part of the reason it is so affordable (in relative terms) for rich people to keep second homes here when they bought them years ago. We live in a building of 60 units where probably at least a third of those are absentee owners. They're rich enough and the cost to maintain is so low that they don't even need or want to rent those units out. We've seen our neighbors only 2-3 times in past 2 years... but if you look at the property tax bills of folks who bought 10-20+ years ago they are minuscule and are only adjusted upon sale of the property. In our case, we're paying easily 4x what the previous owners were. We moved from DC couple years back which is also very expensive but their tax valuations are re-assessed on a regular basis so you don't have this huge disparity in what the rich old people are paying in prop tax vs the young not quite rich people are. If values and property taxes were reassessed every 3 years or so this would put more pressure on these absentee owners to either sell or rent their units thus increasing existing inventory as well as adding to the city's coffers.
- jjav 11y ago> are only adjusted upon sale of the property While often repeated, that is incorrect. In reality property tax goes up 2% every year under prop 13.
- seattle_spring 11y agoWhich is insignificant compared to yearly property appreciation in the same area.
- rsync 11y agoLet's please test your intellectual honesty, shall we ? You are indeed correct that in our very modern era, the 2% ratchet under prop13 is less than what we see California real estate appreciating at. So would you indeed support rebates and/or clawbacks and/or negative property tax increases if California was to ever see sustained drops in valuation ? I own property in California as well as in other states and I can tell you that the property taxes sure go upwards very easily ... not so much the other way around ...
- pascalxus 11y agoI agree with the author for the most part: the ideal solution is to build lots more housing - it's the morally and ethically correct thing to do. But, SF lacks the political will to do this and we need to accept that. the 2nd best solution would be to get tech companies out of SF. I hate this solution as much as the author, but I think it's worth considering. There's no reason why tech companies must be in SF, when there's so much Software engineering talent in the rest of the US where housing is much more accessible. I can understand large companies with big budgets paying top dollar moving to SF - they can out compete other companies for talent. But, I have no sympathies for software companies that can't find labor in SF because they went to the worst possible housing location offering modest compensation.
- refriedbeans3 11y agoIn theory, this could alleviate some of the issues you are seeing in SF, but in practice this is not something many tech companies founded here would do. Most new tech companies are being started by people already working in the industry, and the industry is located in Silicon Valley, with epicenter now being in SF. So it just doesn't make sense from a competitive perspective for most companies to move out of the Bay when there's no better place for "tech". To me, the most logical conclusion is to organize and create the political will to create the housing necessary to alleviate prices. This could be on a regional level - building more housing throughout the east bay and peninsula, or organizing on the city level to re-zone and re-develop parts of the city that can most easily support denser development. Not everyone will like it but as long as you have more people than the anti-more-housing crowd and are organized to vote, it can be done.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoI've seen recent comments on HN that some people are considering it a sign of shrewdness and intelligence that some companies aren't locating themselves in SF.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Fede_V 11y agoHousing in SF is an incredibly powerful illustration of the danger of letting things get so bad that the usual remedies no longer apply. Basically: - Traditionally, the proper fix for a shortage of housing is to build more houses. Just lift the existing regulations, and let the free market do what it does best: take care of the demand at an efficient price. - However, after years and years of very slow building, the amount of pent up demand is such that even if builders were allowed to construct houses, the houses would almost all be built for the very well off. The amount of houses you'd have to build before you started constructing truly affordable housing is immense. - People that are in rent regulated apartments have absolutely nothing to gain from more construction. However, even poor people that have no stable housing also have almost nothing to gain from new construction because their only realistic chance of having affordable rent is through subsidies or semi-public housing in the medium term. - The people that have the most to gain are the moderately well off who can afford SF rents, but cannot find housing at the existing market rate. Basically - politicians and residents let the situation with housing in SF get so absolutely bad that free-market based solutions would take a crazy amount of time to create affordable housing for poor people. At this point, I'm not sure there even are good solutions, especially if you limit yourself to what is politically feasable. The lesson to draw from this is that you should never let the situation get so bad that people at the bottom stop caring completely about improving policy. In this case, the right policy (build A LOT more houses) would barely help poor people because the supply/demand curve is so out of wack. The very people that should benefit the most from improving the housing situation are instead opposing it - for fairly rational reasons.
- golergka 11y agoIt sounds like you think that only the poor people problems with housing should be solved, and if someone is better off and can't find an apartment due to crazy demand, his problems don't concern you and solving his problems counts for nothing.
- dionidium 11y agoI'll just say that it doesn't sound like that to me at all
- crdoconnor 11y agoOh boy, yet another article claiming that if only private investors were regulated less then "all of our problems would be solved". These will never get old. >The only way to fix it is through a radical change in our housing policy: a change that encourages (a lot of) building. No, the only way to fix it is to actually build a lot of housing. If you have trouble imagining what that would look at, take one look at Singapore. To make this happen requires pitchforks, eminent domain, and political will not economic tweaks to building policy. >Incorrect claim 2: Investment capital will never build affordable housing Not incorrect at all. Affordable housing meets the demand for a place to live by the middle class but it doesn't meet the demand of the ultra wealthy for a yield bearing asset. The "lack of demand" for affordable housing is a facet of massive wealth inequality and the treatment of living places as yield bearing assets. >The forces behind those aren't singular movements or collectively one movement alone. ZIRP is pretty much behind most of it. If you want somebody to point a pitchfork at, Ben Bernanke or Janet Yellen are as good a target as any. They are largely responsible for homes being transformed into mostly investment vehicles that provide living space from vice versa.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rkayg 11y agoGreat article. How can we turn your ideas into reality?
- Decade 11y agoStart by voting. Read those tedious propositions and those small offices, and vote on every one of them. Supervisor Julie Christensen was pushed out by anti-housing Aaron Peskin with the approval of 12% of District 3’s residents. And don’t take the shortcut of just voting whichever way your Democrat or Republican voters guide tells you to vote. Join, or at least follow, a political action group like SFBARF[0]. And when they mention some special committee, then don’t just go to a couple meetings and otherwise leave it alone. You’re supposed to be part of the community. Actually learn from and provide your own input to that community. If you have some free time, then find what else the SF Planning Department has been doing[1], and attend their public hearings. [0]http://www.sfbarf.org http://www.sfbarf.org [1]http://sf-planning.org http://sf-planning.org
- Animats 11y ago"We are on a self-imposed path leading to only one place: a city that is entirely rich and, more or less, entirely white." Sounds like a plan. The problem is this. SF is built out; to build something, you have to demolish something first. So the alternative is high-rise housing. High-rise low-income housing, especially high-rise low-income housing, has been a disaster in the US. Chicago had to demolish the Robert Taylor Homes, a mile long strip of high-rises. Here's a list of failed high-rise housing projects.[1] "You can't stack poor people who drink.", as one author wrote. The boom may be cyclical. SF after the first dot-com collapse in 2001, had low traffic and lots of vacancies. After the 2008 crash, there were tens of thousands of houses in foreclosure and for-sale signs everywhere. That could happen again. Twitter and Uber aren't profitable and are going to get hit by economic reality at some point soon. [1] http://newsone.com/1555245/most-infamous-public-housing-projects/ http://newsone.com/1555245/most-infamous-public-housing-proj...
- BurningFrog 11y agoto build something, you have to demolish something first Yes, of course. That is how all healthy big cities work. So the alternative is high-rise housing Well, replacing 1-2 stories with 4-8 stories is probably optimal for current SF. Not sure I'd call those high rises.
- Animats 11y agoSF has gone the other way, replacing 4-8 story public housing with 2 story public housing. You can see examples just south of Japantown. Crime rate went down.
- tptacek 11y agoHold on. Chicago demolished the Taylor houses, but not because they were tall; Chicago continues to build high-rise housing. I went to high school across the street from the ABLA projects. Most of those were low-rise buildings. They got demolished, too. Nobody is proposing to build high-rise housing projects. I moved out of San Francisco at the end of 2001, and it was (for the time) nosebleed expensive. It's obviously gotten much worse since then, but even at the end of the first bubble it was notoriously expensive, and gentrification was a top-of-mind concern for the whole area.
- tlogan 11y agoExcellent article. The solution is that we need more housing. The problem is that politicians do not allow that - and that is not going to change. Why? Because existing rich people do not want that. Not sure what we can do here...
- paulpauper 11y agoWe are on a self-imposed path leading to only one place: a city that is entirely rich and, more or less, entirely white. I want to live in a beautiful, multiethnic, socioeconomically mixed community. A city where people of low, moderate, and high incomes live together, and people of different ethnicities interact. I guess he's never heard of Chinatown. SF is one of the most most ethnically diverse cities in the country. http://theculturetrip.com/north-america/usa/california/articles/the-10-most-multicultural-cities-in-the-world/ http://theculturetrip.com/north-america/usa/california/artic... Also 'white' does not imply 'rich', as there are many regions in America that are predominantly white and very poor, Appalachian region being one.
- tlogan 11y agoDid you know that Valencia St was full of latinos? Or are you saying that as long as there is something called "Chinatown" it is ok to kick all Mexicans out?
- Maarten88 11y agoI visited San Francisco last week (for the Microsoft Build conference). Having read here on HN about the housing problems and high rents I was surprised to see quite a lot of poorly maintained buildings, if you go a bit outside the centre. From my perspective, there seems lots of room for building and improvement. They could take down blocks and build more densely while improving quality. As in all US cities, a lot of room is used by cars. Looking at my hometown Amsterdam, there are places like Java Eiland, (https://www.amsterdam.nl/javaeiland/ https://www.amsterdam.nl/javaeiland/) an old harbor dock where they built 8500 high quality appartments housing 18.000 people, on an area of only 1.3km x 130m. I think solutions like that could work in San Francisco too.
- henrikschroder 11y agoI'm also from northern Europe, and the average housing standard here is absolutely crap compared to where I'm from. For fun, try browsing apartments here on craigslist and you'll get to see the interiors as well. And when you then look at the prices of these things, it all seems like a cruel joke. If you just visited the conference you probably didn't see Mission Bay, but they are doing the same here as in most other coastal cities, i.e. repurposing old harbour industrial zones and building large apartment buildings, it's just way, way too little, too late. But I agree with you that there are so many city blocks that currently house a bunch of poorly maintained two-story buildings that should just be demolished and replaced with a single modern, tall residential building. There is nothing of value to preserve there.
- 650REDHAIR 11y agoThe Mission Bay properties are also ridiculously expensive and the first few buildings were basically student/PhD housing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- khuey 11y agoYou can make a ton of money by renting your property regardless of whether the building is well maintained or not, so why bother?
- capkutay 11y agoIf you care about SF housing, please just show up to Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors meetings. Better yet, start or join a grassroots group of at least 10-15 people and thoughtfully present all your ideas without coming off as insensitive towards the homeless or low-income individuals. There's TONS of room for public input in SF, it's what makes our planning process unique. In many cases, this leads to a deficit in housing because planning is so sensitive to the request of those who actually show up to meetings and make their case.
- socrates2016 11y agoRich people with money vs rich people with property. The poor people have mostly been driven out already. There is plenty of housing for tech workers. The problem is it's not hip enough: bay view, outer mission, outer sunset, outer richmond, portola valley, etc...
- iolothebard 11y agoDude, he doesn't even see the Asian people in SF. Poor guy, he's missing out on some amazing yoga pants based on my experience :-)
- beavisthegenius 11y agoThe problem is NIMBYs. No one wants their view ruined so The City has height restrictions. Developers want to max out profit and only build luxury high rises downtown. New developments in Daly City, South San Francisco, San Carlos, San Mateo, Pacifica et al. don't go anywhere because Peninsula, East Bay & South Bay suburbanites don't want to expand a borough like New York City. Comparisons to NYC are difficult because NYC is one city. To truly accomodate the demand for Bay Area housing, we can't just focus on San Francisco. Per Wikipedia, Manhattan has ~1.6MM people in ~22 sq mi of land. We need many, many more taller buildings. Try getting current landowners to change the 3 story restriction. 1. My goal for San Francisco is a diverse city The City was diverse before the tech boom. The tech boom is pushing people out. Contrast the population of San Francisco with San Jose. Why is SJ more diverse? The white, suburbanites move to SF not SJ because they want NYC on the West Coast. A city of 860k vs 8mm have much more opportunity to have diversity. Again, there needs to be coordination across multiple municipalities that simply don't want to work together. "I want to live in a beautiful, multiethnic, socioeconomically mixed community. A city where people of low, moderate, and high incomes live together, and people of different ethnicities interact." You should have moved here 20 years ago and then you would understand why long time residents hate the newcomers. 2. A little self awareness about my my role and position in San Francisco You grew up poor but aren't now. Super. 3. The cause of our housing problem is huge demand in the face of limited supply There were population exoduses for many years. The demand is relatively new problem. If you had been here in 2002, landlords were begging you to rent in SF. Granted, you graduated college in 2009 so you wouldn't know that but believe me, this is a recent problem caused by recent graduates. I want to keep responding to your posts but I'm too tired. This isn't NYC and there aren't 5 boroughs that are able to be coordinated for building codes and transportation. This isn't an easy fix and, forgive me, I find your youthful perspective insulting as you have no idea how long these issues have been brewing. Chris Daly was a big proponent of affordable housing. Read up on him.
- PaulHoule 11y ago(11) If you love it, be ready to leave it. If investors in the area are not willing to look outside, politicans and others in the San Francisco area know they have enough leverage on you that they can keep following the same failed policies. Only when you stop the policy of redlining 99% of America and show San Francisco there is a real threat the jobs will move away will any reform be possible.
- rasengan0 11y agoAnother answer to the housing crisis: https://youtu.be/JDoPmj-BIEA https://youtu.be/JDoPmj-BIEA SF ain't Brooklyn Folks can't buy groceries at Uber People matter, profits don't When you've been around long enough, it will begin to make sense
- lubujackson 11y agoI keep saying these same arguments put forth (add more affordable housing!) but the reality is that there are very specific laws that cause the crazy prices here and it ISN'T because of a lack of housing. It's lack of liquidity. First there is Prop 13, which is the Ponzi scheme that let's older owners pay basically the same tax rate forever. This means that landlords have little reason to repair or sell properties. Which goes hand-in-hand with all the tenant protections that make it virtually impossible to vacate a tenant. And because landlords can't raise rents beyond a tiny margin each year (1% or so), they might have tenants paying 1/4 or less the going rate for an apartment, making it even less likely that they will reinvest in improving their building. So what happens? Anyone who has been living in the same rental for the past 5 years is pretty much locked in to their apartment now, no matter what. Every single tenant in SF who hasn't moved within the last 5 years is NOT MOVING UNLESS THEY NEED TO. Because they are paying about 50% less than the going rate. So those people will not move, which means their apartment won't be available for others, which means the supply of housing is significantly lower than it should be. Just as new homeowners in SF are paying some of the taxes that existing homeowners should pay, new renters are paying some of the rent that should be paid by existing renters.
- x0x0 11y agoFact: units built after 1979 are not rent controlled. Fact: neither are single family homes, including most condos if you moved in after 1 jan 1986 (30 years ago).
- davidw 11y agoThere's a lot of coverage of this kind of thing on http://marketurbanism.com/ http://marketurbanism.com/ for those interested in following it more. I think it's one of the issues facing a lot of cities in the US right now.
- avatar299 11y agoBlaming Prop 13 is silly. Look at the rest of the state, housing prices are relatively sane in places like san diego, and downright cheap in the inland empire, orange copunty, anaheim, etc etc. Oh, all those places have to deal with Prop 13 as well. San Francisco(and the bay area overall) has consistently chosen to restrict their supply for housing for years. Obviously this would culminate into higher prices in the future, but to many people live in denial. They would rather pretend that AirBnB is the real problem, or that Prop 13 is distorting the market(but of course, rent control is not rolleyes)
- thescriptkiddie 11y ago> housing prices are relatively sane in places like san diego Consider that the median house price in San Diego is higher than New York or Los Angeles: http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/Median-Home-Prices-in-27-Cities http://www.advisorperspectives.com/dshort/commentaries/Media...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ChiCommTroll 11y agoOf course Prop 13 is distorting prices. It affects all kinds of things. It limits the revenue stream of local governments, causing them to do things like encourage big box store development to get more sales tax. Prop 13 has tons of unintended consequences. Or maybe its framers knew exactly what they were doing. I ALSO think rent control and airbnb distorts prices too. The Airbnb threat maybe overblown, who knows, but airbnb has maintained in the past they have no way of telling cities how many customers they. Databases are hard I guess.
- rsmsky1 11y agoIs San Francisco really on a path to becoming almost entirely white? I thought a large portion of the Sunset and Richmond were Asian and it had a much larger Asian percentage than other cities?
- m0llusk 11y agoSan Francisco is around 40% Chinese. If you look at indicators like unemployment, single parent births, education level the Chinese population is as different from the Caucasian population as Caucasians are from Black Americans. Chinese make a very strong and strangely unrecognized contribution to San Francisco economically and socially.
- muzz 11y agoSunset and Richmond districts seem to be ignored in almost every discussion of San Francisco.
- simulate 11y agoIf you live in San Francisco, you can vote on May 10 to make some of Zac Townsend's suggested fixes a reality. Here's the slate card to see how: http://www.sfyimby.org/slate/ http://www.sfyimby.org/slate/
- SonjaKT 11y agoYeah and if you don't live in San Francisco, you can tell one friend who does live there to vote. Seriously, we don't need that many people to make a big difference this time. It's worth it for you to get _one_ more person to vote.
- youngButEager 11y agoWe hardly ever see consideration of the other party in these debates. Tenants cry about high rents. What about supply and demand? There are two main causes of supply problems: (1) tough building permitting, anti-building policy seemingly; (2) shortage of willing landlords. If I have $5 million dollars to invest, will I invest in San Francisco where (unless I buy post-1979, and 75% of units are rent controlled in SF) -- or will I invest where I can make a return on the investment? Shortage of willing landlords. Shortage of new construction. Almost no one talks about the shortage of willing landlords. It's as if people think "owners have their apartment buildings, they HAVE to be landlords." NO. See here: http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2011/05/because-of-rent-control-sf-has-31000.html http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2011/05/because-of-rent-control-... - If you make it very difficult/nearly impossible for restaurants to make money, SHORTAGE OF WILLING RESTAUARANT OWNERS. - If you make it very difficult/nearly impossible for dentists to make money, SHORTAGE OF WILLING DENTISTS And so on. The reason no one considers how to entice more landlords (ie. to increase the supply of units) is -- everyone probably thinks "landlords have no choice. They MUST rent their units." It's NOT TRUE. When public policy acknowledges this point -- maybe we can all stop believing "we don't need to entice landlords -- they have units, they MUST rent them out (so we can control and limit their business).
- kajecounterhack 11y agoI am perceived to be part of the problem. Not attacking, just commenting: maybe rephrase? I'm similar to you but despite background / origin we're still part of the problem. We are rich enough to live in the mission and shop at bi-rite and we displace poorer folks (who, as you observed, are often from ethnic minorities, with backgrounds different from ours). Having come from modest beginnings doesn't make us less the problem. That said, I think it does help to make us more aware of how unfair the system is.
- massemphasis 11y agoUmm fuck San Francisco. The error is the concentration of focus, and not necessarily the talent.
- kriro 11y agoInteresting article but I think the demand side also needs some more reexamination. It is very strange that SV mantra is "teams need to move there". Doubly silly since we're mostly talking about software companies. If you break that mentality some of the demand issues will go away. It feels like a very dogmatic mantra "it just works better". VCs should try to reexamine and disrupt startup financing by not being clustered in one place (which is one of the top arguments for moving to SV other than talent pol being there which is kind of self fulfilling). "Move to where your initial customers live" would be a decent counter-mantra. Make it a differentiator as a VC that you come to the startup and don't make them come to you.