15 ms·
The future is arriving too fast
- ipsin 11y agoAt this point, Netflix is almost like the streaming company that acquired a plastic disc company, and hasn't quite gotten around to killing it yet. Search also feels biased towards streaming, to the point where it will suggest several "not even close" streaming movies before the literal title that you're searching for.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jim-greer 11y ago> Search also feels biased towards streaming, to the point where it will suggest several "not even close" streaming movies before the literal title that you're searching for. This is not true if you have a DVD plan. There's a big "add" button next to the dvd-only results. http://i.imgur.com/oSU4Yzh.png http://i.imgur.com/oSU4Yzh.png I agree with your main point though.
- MichaelGG 11y agoI think Netflix intentionally provides bad suggestions. The last week I've tried several times to use Netflix. In each instance, I spend 10+ minutes trying to find something, fail, and give up. Netflix "recommends" stuff that it rates at 1 star. Terrible junk. And they don't even have the decency to make it easy to see 3rd party ratings or trailers. And if you start something that sucks, it's hard to tell it to stop showing it to you. They also removed the easy way to mark "Not Interested". It's become a much worse experience, perhaps bounded by their limited catalog. They must know this. They must see the stats on how long people spend browsing vs cancellation rates.
- nkurz 11y agoI'm also confused by their approach to interface. Perhaps there is some hidden benefit to having people accidentally start watching films when they just want to learn more about it, even if they immediately stop? Maybe it somehow satisfies some arcane distribution requirement in a way that saves them licensing fees on the more popular films? Maybe it helps some department improve some metric that some other department cares about?
- intrasight 11y agobittorrent = new plastic circle
- pietro 11y agoNot for movies that we old people like. Either the movies are not to be found, or the quality is lousy, or it's seeded by one person with a dial-up connection.
- Kristine1975 11y agoReddit's OpenDirectories subreddit sometimes has non-bittorrent servers with older movies in what I assume is good quality (judging from the file size). Of course that's not a solution for when you want to watch a movie in the next few hours.
- tekklloneer 11y agoThe future's been arriving too fast since velocipedes (bikes) were corrupting our youth. This sounds more like a business problem Netflix has invented to solve a (to them) bigger business problem, and such tactics have always existed.
- karlshea 11y agoThe unfortunate part of this situation is that the only good content Netflix has is their own TV shows. They don't have rights to stream any decent movies, those are all still just discs. Exactly one time in the last three years when I've gone to search for a movie I wanted to watch was it available for streaming.
- cmrx64 11y agoI can't help but agree. Increasingly, things I want to watch just aren't there. It didn't feel like this five years ago. Then, it felt like most anything I wanted to watch was there. Maybe my taste has changed.
- azinman2 11y agoThey have like 1 woody Allen movie avail for streaming. Enough said.
- nostrademons 11y agoIt might be that the movie studios feel threatened and have decided that they're not going to help Netflix replace them anymore.
- Johnny555 11y agoThat was probably back before Netflix lost the Starz catalog, they had a lot of decent movies: http://money.cnn.com/2012/02/29/technology/netflix_starz/ http://money.cnn.com/2012/02/29/technology/netflix_starz/
- losvedir 11y agoI was shocked the other day when I tried to watch Lilyhammer, one of Netflix's own TV shows, while in Singapore - it's not available! I can understand licensing issues for other content, but their own? Why would they do that?
- mschuster91 11y agoUsually, it's background music licensing issues.
- dc2 11y agoSome small part of me was hoping this post was a little deeper than Netflix.
- simula67 11y ago> The mobile version of Netflix’s site also has no provision for managing plastic. Has he tried switching to Firefox and use the 'Request Desktop Site' option ?
- rcthompson 11y agoPretending not to be a mobile device is not a solution for a deficient mobile site, it's a workaround.
- simula67 11y agoAgreed, I was not contradicting the author.
- jim-greer 11y agoYou can also do this on Chrome and Safari. It's a "share" option for Safari, bizarrely.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoI didn't even realise they had it in the share menu. You can also access it by holding the refresh icon in the address bar.
- didibus 11y agoThis guy is missing out on the present waiting for a future where Netflix has all content availaible to stream for 9.99$ a month. As far as I know, you can stream much more content from say Amazon, Google Play, iTunes, Crackle, etc. Just need to be willing to pay. You can also buy plastic discs from a lot of places. And if you don't want to pay, you can torrent the world. So I don't really understand what's his complaints about? He preferred it when Netflix was a mail rental company? I doubt that's worthy of HN.
- tomc1985 11y agoNot worthy of HN? How? He wants to watch old movies, now. (Not in the future.) He used to be able to but now he can't. Tech "innovation" took that away from him. That is an opinion worthy of HN. On another note: personally, many don't want to deal with Netflix+Amazon+Hulu+whoever. This attitude that one should have faith in the streaming market is an affront and slap-in-the-face to collectors, people with shitty internet, critics, teachers, historians, archivists, remixers, and anyone else with an interest in private use or working with the bits. Sure, additional services can be provisioned to fill in those gaps... but those gaps never existed when data sharing was about files and not streaming services. This business model of the cloud looks more and more like windshield-repairmen walking around parking lots with baseball bats at 3 A.M.
- jim-greer 11y ago> He used to be able to but now he can't. Netflix will still send you DVDs in the mail. They just don't promote them much. If you're a digital subscriber the disc add-on starts at $5/month. You can also download Jupiter Ascending from iTunes for $15 (though you can't rent it). It does suck that there's no DRM-free way to buy a movie online. But, again, no worse than the DVD-only era.
- wiradikusuma 11y agoOnly in certain countries.
- davemel37 11y agoOn this note, I met an entrepreneur in Maryland making hundreds of millions by buying (or getting for free) used music cassette tapes and scratched cds, and cleaning them up, repackaging them and selling them at gas stations throughout the US. There is still gold in them circle things and them thar hills.
- NegativeLatency 11y agoScratched cassette tapes?
- davemel37 11y agoscratched cds. They buff out the scratches, repackage it and sell it for a few bucks at truck stops and gas stations through America.
- copperx 11y agoI understand how some people might buy CDs, but I can't believe there is a multimillion market out there for them. Maybe he made his millions one or two decades ago?
- onion2k 11y agoNew cars only started getting streaming or aux audio input capabilities in the past 5 years. Most people still own CDs to play when they're driving because they have no other option.
- ewzimm 11y agoAn FM transmitter that attaches to a smartphone gives a perfectly clear signal, costs less than $7, and only requires a cigarette lighter, standard in cars since the 1920's, and FM radio, standard since the 50's.
- 11y ago
- raldi 11y agoIt's possible Netflix is crippling your experience on purpose, to provide leverage in their negotiations with content owners.
- gozur88 11y agoNetflix can buy DVDs at retail prices and rent them out over and over. If it want to put pressure on content companies it wants the DVD part of the business to be as robust as possible. That way it can say "We'd love to stream your stuff, but we don't really need to. We're really sort of doing you a favor here."
- okyup 11y agoWe are the mindless, soulless, mass of consumers and we are the future! New is good, old is bad. Forget the past, forget history - we are forging the future without any of that! An ideal future! Quality is measured in Megapixels, truth is what our prophets tell us, and individuality be damned. Now off to the future we head for the sake of it! Follow us over this cliff - redemption lies at the bottom. Anyone who claims otherwise is a racist troll! Don't get left behind, old man. You will surely be a miserable person without the latest apps on the latest iGadget. Besides, there is no place in our ideal world for people like you.
- stephengillie 11y agoEverything that's new is old already.
- iamben 11y agoA friend works in TV and film and deals with the licensing for this kind of thing. It seems like a colossal disaster at best. It's complicated, convoluted and greedy. We've discussed it many times before, but it doesn't look like the TV/film industries will ever get themselves to a Spotify-esque point. Which is a shame, because it'll be to their own detriment (as it will be for the music industry again, if 'stars' persist in exclusivity for streaming rights) when people revert back to torrents (as one comment here has already stated). The fact is, most people are prepared to pay for a VOD and/or music service. We just don't want to pay for 3 of them. Money aside, it just isn't convenient. "Can we listen to The Beatles? Yes, I'm not sure whether it's on cassette, CD or vinyl, so search through all three collections, then make sure the appropriate player is plugged in. If it's not there, we'll need to look at buying the minidisk. Or shoplifting it." Anyway, I appreciate the point of the article wasn't purely a rant about VOD/DVDs, and it was a point well made.
- draw_down 11y agoI doubt anyone in entertainment thinks that avoiding the fate of the music industry would be a shame. Spotify is great for us users but there's no money in music anymore (not that that is specifically Spotify's fault).
- edraferi 11y agoI wonder how much of that is simply due to an explosion of supply driving prices down. It's so much cheaper to record and distribute music that there's no scarcity at all.
- slang800 11y agoI'm inclined to agree with this - I've got a backlog of albums to listen to, either recommended by friends, new releases by artists I already know I like, or from monthly playlists like BIRP. According to Banshee, it would take me about a month of 24/7 listening to hear all of it once. By the time I polish off that backlog, I'm sure that I will have found another couple hundred albums to replace it. So, right now my biggest problem is search and categorization by mood, rather than supply or even discovery.
- adamzerner 11y agoAs demand goes down, supply will too. There comes a point where it isn't worth making something anymore. Those that demand it still will miss out. To me, this is an acceptable outcome of capitalism. But I don't think that's what the article is saying. I think it's saying, "There's a difference between wanting and liking (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incentive_salience https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incentive_salience). Demand is determined by wanting, not liking, and so that's what the market responds to. People don't do a good job of wanting what they like, and thus the market is reducing supply too quickly." Ie. plastic circles (and their analogs) really make people happy. If people were smarter, they'd realize this demand for them would be higher. But because they're mistaken, supply falls too quickly. I agree, but don't know of a solution.
- seandoe 11y agois this guy serious? Ambitious title for some lame words that leave my heart weeping. Could've searched and completed a torrent download before finishing the second sentence. Obviously not many people experience your roadblock, otherwise there would be a market and it would be filled. Maybe there is a market. Get off your ass and get to work. I thought this article was on some Wait but Why, AI, tipping point or something.
- seandoe 11y agois this guy serious? Ambitious title for some lame words that leave my heart weeping. Could've searched and completed a torrent download before finishing the second sentence. Obviously not many people experience your roadblock, otherwise there would be a market and it would be filled. Maybe there is a market. Get off your ass and get to work. ...I thought this article was going to be on some Wait but Why, AI, tipping point or something.
- MaysonL 11y agoOn the contrary, the future isn't arriving anywhere nearly fast enough. I'm old too – but when I was a teenager, I expected that by now there would be a moonbase or three, not to mention thriving orbital colonies, Mars expeditions, self-driving cars for sale, solar power satellites, and maybe even brain-to-computer direct interfaces or augmented reality a la Rainbows End. The future ain't what it used to be, dammit!
- Filthy_casual 11y agoAnd flying cars. Jetsons lied.
- berntb 11y agoThat should finally be close? Just add drones and self driving cars together. Soon we will have drones to deliver larger stuff than a small package from Amazon, so all the basic parts will be there. Take a drone which can carry two people's weight and put a transparent box with a door on it. Add small wheels and some minimal parking capacity. Add a parachute for emergencies. (Note that there won't be a long educations for pilots. You just choose an address in Google Maps. If the drone can land vertically you might have to select a flat area at the destination, but it should be negotiated (along with parking fee) before going there.) Instead of flying cars I'd rather have the cheap launch capacity of the Shuttle, which must have set some record when it was ~ two orders of a magnitude more expensive per pound than promised. :-( With so low launch costs we would finally get real giant space telescopes and an industrial infrastructure outside the atmosphere.
- kaybe 11y agoYou're describing a small autonomous helicopter. (We have lots of experience with the helicopter part at least.)
- berntb 11y agoThat was my explicit point in the first two sentences. The parts are here. Add a transparent box to a soon existing drone, add self-driving and you have a flying car. Military drones fly themselves already. There will be routing systems for drones when e.g. Amazon starts to deliver packets to the home. And so on. (But not necessarily helicopter. Note the "If the drone can land vertically". You could do this with a drone air plane. If the transparent box (passenger compartment) is moved automatically to/from an automated taxi to a drone, you have a point-to-point taxi service anywhere.) Edit: The next logical step is a trailer home with solar energy -- move it anywhere with a taxi large helicopter airlift. Drones deliver groceries, while you enjoy the view from your mountain top, far from any roads.
- onion2k 11y agoA different way to look at the author's point is that rather than Netflix streaming everything the problem is actually that they don't maintain feature parity between their desktop and mobile websites. If he could manage his disc queue from his smartphone he wouldn't have neededto write this blog post. And that is a very valid point - huge numbers of people use their phone as their primary way to access the internet, so having features that are only available to desktop users alienates a big chunk of your market. For a company the size of Netflix to fail in this regard is quite irksome.
- jim-greer 11y agoThese people need to learn about "request desktop site on mobile". It's buried in Safari, but still doable. > For a company the size of Netflix to fail in this regard is quite irksome. As a shareholder, I applaud them for not spending resources to include little-used features on their mobile site. Being a big company doesn't mean you can do all things for all people.
- onion2k 11y agoBeing a big company doesn't mean you can do all things for all people. No, but that doesn't change the fact it can be really annoying for users. Annoying enough for them to write a blog post in some cases.
- dclowd9901 11y agoRequest desktop quite often fails. I'm assuming the browser is passing a desktop use agent so I can't imagine why it does. But it seems to happen more on sites with the "m" subdomain.
- jim-greer 11y agoI've never seen it work on a site with an m subdomain. But Netflix serves both sites from www. Edit: I take it back. Somehow it works right on my own site, Kongregate. I wonder what the trick is? Edit: The trick seems to be a session variable that remembers the browser used to say it was mobile. Then a request to 'm' with desktop headers should redirect to 'www'.
- shmerl 11y ago> Streaming may be preferable in some cases, but it’s clearly not the only means of distributing some movies. That remains the plastic circle. What's still lacking are digital stores which sell video files. DRM-free. Who needs circles if you can have a file and use it any way you want? But DRM poison prevents the future. So I wouldn't say it's arriving too fast. It's arriving way too slow.
- jobigoud 11y agoThis exactly. None of my machines can read plastic circles anymore anyway. Behind the stream and the physical object there is a file that could be downloaded.
- Aleman360 11y agoBut why buy a movie when you can just rent it on demand? That way you're not locked in to a particular format or quality level and don't have to worry about backups.
- shmerl 11y ago> But why buy a movie when you can just rent it on demand? If it's something I like, I prefer to have a backup of it and watch it where I want and how I want. I always do that with music, games and e-books. If it's one time use, then not making backups is more acceptable. You can ask same question about physical books. Why buy it and not just get it in the library? Similar answer will apply. Secondly, unless that streaming is using some ubiquitous cross platform technology (like Web browser without DRM garbage), it won't be available on many platforms and will be tied to provided application. DRM-free file makes it platform independent. Thirdly, I find it weird that streaming should be equated to inability to get a DRM-free file. Streaming is simply convenience (no need to download). But it shouldn't preclude ability to download itself. They are not contradictory, except in the mind of DRM pushers. For instance GOG's failed video service provides ability to stream video, and download it as well. Equating streaming to renting is incorrect.
- tomc1985 11y agoThis is relatable on a couple of aspects... First, that the advances of technology are outpacing the scenarios which they are used. As I have voiced elsewhere here, it is alarming to see billions and trillions of dollars flowing towards people who seem incapable of balancing, let-alone considering, the higher-order consequences of their actions, like, say, shutting-down the home-automation systems your customers bought as a consequence of being absorbed by a competitor. Or, denying random people things and services they used to have access to. More disturbingly, it seems that many do see these later effects, and they're sacrificing their customers' interests on the altar of the almighty dollar. Is this really what we want? Secondly, modern media consumption via streaming is simpler, yes, if you're a first-world citizen with money and typical interests. It does a disservice to people who do not fit this mold, and they are legion. The older, peer-to-peer model of file-sharing (and, in some cases, sneakernets) thrives and survives in this adverse environment, in addition to providing personal independence and privacy. Thirdly, the chain of variables in a streaming economy is so much longer than a world of plastic shiny discs. As an example, to watch a movie via a DVD you bought or rented, you need: * viewing device with electricity and a screen (one-time cost) * a DVD player, properly connected (one-time cost) * software on said device able to execute and play the disc (one-time cost and not even a consideration historically) * the disc, in a workable condition (edit: and a compatible region), and the funds or means to acquire it (one-time cost) * knowledge to operate the DVD player ... and thats it. Compare with Netflix, Hulu, et al: * viewing device with electricity, internet access, and a screen (one-time cost) * a working, high-bandwidth internet account that can reach your servers with an acceptable latency (recurring cost) * a current account with your service provider(s) of choice (1x+ recurring cost) * current software, able to execute, on said device (recurring cost due to updates) * a provider that is online and accessible * knowledge to operate the media player, but also possibly the web browser, on a phone, or tablet, or computer (one-time cost) * knowledge of current account credentials (sometimes difficult for some) The cost side of streaming media is so much higer, and entails significant recurring obligations. If you can't pay your streaming bill, much of this goes away. There are many more points of failure. This is simply unacceptable in many parts of the world.
- brusch64 11y agoWell you forgot the region code problem the DVD had. At least in the beginning it was really hard to get around this. It's definitely easier if you were in region 1 and only wanted to watch content for this. But in the beginning it was pretty hard to get around that if you were living somewhere else. I've bought a region 1 DVD (beeing in a region 2 land) and had to reflash my DVD drive to play this DVD. And don't get me started on store bought DVDs which were in English and German, but if you wanted to watch the English version you had to watch it with subtitles.
- jim-greer 11y agoIn this thread - a lot of people who don't have a Netflix DVD plan saying that it's hard to use their DVD plan.
- deepnet 11y agoSo in a bar he gets a Movie recomendation, send a SMS to his home server which dumps the stream, rips and burns it to a plastic disk, ready when he gets home. If he can't code hire a dev, $200 should suffice. I found the problem in the past was licensing 'issues' prevented whole swathes of old movies ever being shown in the UK - this is pretty efficiently fixed now. Solving the legal issues is a separate problem that was trivially solved for previous disruptive innovations. Compulsory blanket licenses, existing media taxes, distribution agencies - just like when radio & libraries were innovations would allow outdated laws to catch up with technological reality. Maximalist copyright is an anti-capitalist protection racket devised by ancient distribution monopolies.
- nkurz 11y agoI think you misunderstand. He's not objecting to streaming and does not prefer a physical DVD. Instead, he's saying that the movies he is recommended are rarely available for streaming. If he could legally stream the movie rather than waiting for a DVD in the mail, he would do so.
- deepnet 11y agoI beg to differ, my last sentence suggests compulsory licensing to solve this. Pay musicians just like radio & libraries from the existing media taxes. This would allow all modern expression and access.
- cbeach 11y agoBack in the DVD/Bluray era, I wonder how many hundreds on tonnes of plastic was consumed, and how much carbon was burnt shipping it? And how much of that now sits in landfill?
- dcw303 11y agoThe Netflix ambition of a smorgasbord streaming product has slammed straight into the reality of the murky world of internationally licensed content. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it" The public has seen the future with Spotify, and wonder why video can't be the same. But there are a lot of people with influential positions in the industry whose livelihood depend on this red tape. Byzantine licensing laws fund entire departments of faceless middlemen, greedy regional affiliates and dark armies of lawyers. Music wasn't particularly different, it's just that we are further along in the capitulating-industry-dinosaur story there.
- AlisdairO 11y agoIn fairness, the raw product of music has the advantage of being very cheap to produce. A lot of the value that the industry provides is in marketing. There's also an extent to which bands can afford to give away music on generous terms, because they can use it to publicise other, non-reproducible forms of entertainment like gigs. By contrast, with the exception of a small minority of films that rake in on merchandising, in the movie/tv industry the film is the only real product. That product is extremely expensive to make. If everyone only streamed Netflix to consume video, the industry would have to drastically reduce investment in making original content. That might be an acceptable outcome to many people, but I can see why the industry would want/need to fight it.
- guelo 11y agoThe weird thing about the law that we ended up with is that if you receive the digital bits via a plastic circle you can do whatever you want with them including make money off of them without giving any of it to the copyright owner. But if you receive the bits via the internet the copyright holder can get you thrown in jail if you try to hand the bits off to anybody else. It makes no sense but Hollywood outmaneuvered everybody on the lobbying in the 90s and it seems this is what we're stuck with going forward as they get their rules codified into international trade agreements that will last decades.
- edraferi 11y agoNot entirely true. You can't use a DVD for a public showing, for example.
- jim-greer 11y agoTo paraphrase Louis CK: Everything is amazing and some people aren't happy. The amazing new things make them forget that the crappier old things are still around. They just need to look underneath the big pile of amazing new things.
- everyone 11y agoSolution: Just torrent stuff :)
- imtringued 11y agoWell to be honest they don't even want my money anyway.
- elementalest 11y agoThe biggest hindrance in the country where I live is licensing agreements. Companies buy exclusive rights to popular content, limit it to their restrictive and expensive platform/service. This license will often last from 6 months to a year. I'm tired of getting the, "this content is not available in your region" because its either unlicensed or been elusively licensed. I understand the benefits of exclusivity in distinguishing products, but rather than 6-12 months (or sometimes more), it should be more like 2 weeks, or a month. Unlike exclusivity on xbox/ps4/pc, where the content is specifically designed for those platforms, there is no technical reason for exclusivity for media content. Half the time the rights holders don't even license some content for my country until a few weeks to months later. Occasionally, not at all. They could license it on netflix for my country, or other similar service, but refuse to do so. Yet this is in spite of netflix having a license for the same content in the US, or other regions. With the internet, regional licensing just makes no sense for digital goods. A service like netflix should be able to obtain a license for content and distribute it to whom ever they want to, where ever they are. The only barriers to this are artificial. So while the future may be rushing forward, in many ways, we are partially stuck in the past, held back by archaic and antiquated systems of past generations that are unable to let go. Its a matter of perspective. For some the future isn't coming soon enough, for others its rushing by.
- jim-greer 11y agoAgreed! But it's perverse to blame Netflix for any of this, as OP and others seem to.
- sievebrain 11y agoContent is rarely/never designed specifically for a games console. Game engines are always mostly portable and the porting costs are quite low. Video game exclusivity, when it happens, is nearly always a business decision to try and boost the popularity of the platform. The main problem is that the big audiences are still on the older platforms, not Netflix or equivalents (and if all audiences moved from older providers which are at least competing, to Netflix, would that really be better? Or just replacing the devil you know with the devil you don't?)
- tempodox 11y agoAn iMac doesn't even have a CD/DVD drive any more. And the movies that I want aren't offered for sale, but only for rental. Apple is destroying my present.
- stock_toaster 11y agoCan't you still buy the "USB SuperDrive" accessory thing?
- tempodox 11y agoYes, increasing the clutter. iMac is a failed design that forces me to add mess and clutter in order to get to an appropriate functionality. The computer itself is not extensible and hardly serviceable. The alternative, Mac Pro, is now only for rich people.
- zeveb 11y agoWhy not just get a nice Linux desktop or laptop? Free software, all the functionality one could need, and every one I've seen has an optical drive.
- is39 11y agoUse dvd.netflix.com from mobile.
- ansible 11y agoYes. So the basis of this rant is a poor UX decision on the part of Netflix. It would be fine to sort of hide that there are discs... if my account didn't include that. But if it does, there should at least be a button somewhere near the top that takes me to the DVD website from the normal mobile / streaming website. There's certainly one going the other way!
- thenomad 11y agoI do wonder whether the licensing snafu that is the movie world is, in the long term, going to kill it or at least badly damage it as an artform. We already know it's hideous and irritating from a consumer's point of view. But what you may not know is that it's horrendous from a creator's point of view too, at least if you're making a film with a less than $20m budget. And that accounts for a great deal of the talent entering the industry. In order to sell a film the conventional way, you have to visit multiple film markets to meet potential buyers, do a festival run for social proof (and go to all those festivals), potentially pay out of your pocket for a cinema run, negotiate with a bunch of people who all have far more information than you do as to the value of your film, employ third parties (sales agents) who have a near-universal reputation as crooks, and finally, quite likely sue to get anything beyond the advance you're promised. (And other stuff. Lots of other stuff, which I'm not going into here. Masters, E&O insurance, delivery formats...) Selling a film - not making it, just selling the finished thing - takes 1-2 years, and can easily require a $50k budget. (Yes, you can sell the film as an MP4 from your own website. But the problem is that people won't buy it because that's not how the public are used to getting their films. At a film festival I recently attended, a very respected sales agent - and that's a rare breed - asked the audience and other panel members if they knew of anyone who had made a profit selling their narrative film digitally from their own site. Nobody did.) By contrast, selling a book involves uploading that book to Amazon, setting a price, and promoting it. If you're being thorough about your launch process it might take 3 weeks. I've been a filmmaker for 20 years. I'm currently dipping my toe in the world of games development, for pretty much exactly these reasons.
- aluhut 11y ago> At a film festival I recently attended, a very respected sales agent - and that's a rare breed - asked the audience and other panel members if they knew of anyone who had made a profit selling their narrative film digitally from their own site. Nobody did. Has that ever happen at all? I didn't hear about that yet.
- thenomad 11y agoVarious people have tried it, but it usually works somewhere between "not well" and "terribly". Although information flow in the film world is so limited that it might well be there's someone out there who has cracked it and is making a healthy profit - they're just not telling anyone.
- TorKlingberg 11y agoThe DVD mailing is really a separate business from the streaming. Netflix were right trying to split it off. Unfortunately they did it too early and there was a big backlash. Had they waited a year or two longer few would have cared. Qwikster would have been a separate company with its own leadership and its own app, focused on those who want plastic circles in the mail. Ok, you would need two subscriptions if you want both services, but I am sure there would be a cross-promotion package deal.
- kruczek 11y ago> Apple killed the floppy What'd Apple do to kill the floppy? I remember that floppies really only died after pendrives became common. Even with CDs before, there were still floppies around, since it wasn't as simple to copy data to CD (not to mention lack of removal).
- tyingq 11y agoI assume the reference is to the 1998 release of the iMac G3...the first popular mainstream PC without a floppy drive.
- cletus 11y agoThe tl;dr is "Netflix has no way to request 'plastic discs' via the mobile app or mobile website". I guess that's fair. Personally I don't even own a device that can play "plastic discs" anymore, which I think is kinda the point (of Netflix not making that a first class use case). Some commenters for some reason have seemingly just taken the title and extrapolating to the entire content industry (did all these people actually click on the link?). A lesser point is finding content. Movie A is on Netflix and Amazon. Movie B is on Hulu. Movie C is on plastic discs only. This is a general problem (for consumers) as the content producers fight the inevitable commoditization. The movie industry is suffering not from piracy or streaming (IMHO) but from TV. Streaming and "plastic discs" made long form serial content viable. There's something deeply satisfying about the almost 48 hours of Breaking Bad vs the 2-2.5 of almost all movies (most of which these days seem to just regurgitate the same superhero formula time and again). Additionally, good TV can be produced pretty cheaply too compared to any modern movie budget.
- Aleman360 11y agoHold down Apple TV mic button, say movie name, rent movie from cheapest available service and start streaming instantly. The future is here, it's just a different business model than music.
- dragonwriter 11y agoNetflix only supports DVD queue management from its desktop page. That's a mildly annoying work if a particular service (but since the desktop page world fine on mobile, only mildly annoying), and hardly worth the overblown drama of this article, which is our histrionics.
- _nickwhite 11y agoI expected the last sentence to read "And I was born in 1980."
- lobo_tuerto 11y agoSo young?
- 6stringmerc 11y agoBecause I am also old (getting there, okay), I remember doing this thing called 'writing stuff down' on like a bar napkin and then going home to my PC and looking something up, like little plastic discs that could be sent to me. Yes, I frequently still carry around an analog user interface communication device...yeah, a pen. Just sayin'.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- carsongross 11y agoA good friend has an extensive pirated media content library. He insists, and I believe him, that this is not primarily because he is unwilling to pay for the content, but simply because getting it on demand through a commercial channel is too difficult and inconsistent.
- jimbokun 11y agoJust decided to go through a ton of super hero movies with my kids, mostly catching up with the Marvel time line. Impossible without the Netflix Plastic Circle service. Overall, the First Sale Doctrine makes the Plastic Circle service much more valuable than the Netflix Bits service, in my opinion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine Seems more and more difficult to find something we haven't seen, appropriate for all of us to watch, and decent artistic quality on streaming. I think our need for immediate gratification is leading us to give up long established legal rights. Watching bad content because we're too lazy to put something good in our queue and wait for the plastic circle to arrive.
- JeremyNT 11y agoWe recently encountered a situation where (brought to mind by recent political events) my wife wanted to watch Bob Roberts[0], an obscure "mockumentary" about an outrageous wealthy political candidate. I'd never heard of it. She asked around, and almost none of her friends had either. She was so insistent regarding its relevance that we set up a viewing party to see it. Being naive, we both assumed it could be streamed... somewhere. We haven't used those plastic discs in a while either, but we figured we would not need them. We didn't know whether Netflix would have it, but we figured somebody would take our money so we could see it. Nobody. Nowhere. It was completely unavailable. I figured that the rights were tied up to keep those physical discs moving from shelves. I thought I'd run to the nearest big box store and pick it up. I went to their web site to see if they had it. Nope. Not there. I mean, I suppose you can imagine how my story ends: I go to a shady looking site where I can find this particular movie for free and have it saved on my hard drive with no restrictions. Just as I was becoming annoyed with the future, I was reminded of how senseless this problem is. It was a good movie, and it was good that our friends could enjoy it. But it's easy to imagine a future where it disappears forever, for everybody. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Roberts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Roberts