6 ms·
The fist $100,000 income isn't taxed this way[1]. And it's not abhorrent. If you earned enough money to think it's advantageous to lose one of the most valuab
by colechristensen 11y ago
The fist $100,000 income isn't taxed this way[1].
And it's not abhorrent. If you earned enough money to think it's advantageous to lose one of the most valuable passports in the world, you probably earned that money in large parts due to the support of the people and infrastructure of the United States. You don't get to drop your duties once you win big.
[1] $97,600 for 2013, $99,200 for 2014 and $100,800 for 2015
- x5n1 11y agoEmpire costs money to build. Your money.
- lowpro 11y agoAmerican Imperialism at its finest. "Since we're the best country in the world, you couldn't have possibly become rich without us, and therefore you must pay to leave us!"
- colechristensen 11y agoGreatness aside, you probably couldn't have become rich without roads, national defense, clean water...
- ionised 11y agoThose things aren't exclusive to the US.
- colechristensen 11y agoYes, but if you earned your billion on the backs of US peoples and infrastructure, you have to pay a toll when you leave.
- sushid 11y agoBut what if you weren't even born in the US, much less have ever set foot in the US. Do you think it's fair to "pay a toll" when you're working in a foreign country?
- cr1895 11y agoI don't think that's what he's saying. I think we are talking past each other, myself included. a) cole seems to specifically be talking about very wealthy people who did work and earn money in the US but who renounced citizenship largely for tax purposes (e.g. Eduardo Saverin) b) cole talks about the foreign-earned income exclusion, which is misplaced (for people like (a) this is very different from income earned on investments and for wealth which is subject to the exit tax) There's a smattering of outright incorrect things too like having to pay taxes for 10 years after renouncing.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tn13 11y agoFor that the person has already paid his taxes and he has paid for nonsensical wars elsewhere too.
- adventured 11y agoYou're intentionally blowing the parent's comment dramatically out of proportion to what was actually said, as a cheap excuse to bash America. The parent never proclaimed America was the best in any regard, nor hinted at such an attitude. Nobody needs to think their country is the best just to implement negative tax policies. All it indicates at a base level is the desire to maximize tax revenue. That goes for countries with extremely high tax rates on high income, which is semi-common in the developed world: it does not necessarily mean those nations must think their country is the best, therefore they can tax the rich whatever they like and said rich won't leave.
- mineshaftgap 11y agoCheap excuses to bash America is standard fair on HN. Europe is going to lose their mind when America makes them pay their own way in the world, and it will be very ugly for the poor confused bastards.
- eropple 11y agoI have no real opinion on whether territorial versus worldwide taxation is correct, but I think this is incorrect. It's not "you couldn't have possibly," it's "you didn't." You're welcome to renounce your citizenship if you want to disprove the didn't part.
- wavefunction 11y ago@lowpro Imperialism doesn't work that way. Don't the door hit you on the way out though.
- easytiger 11y agoWell, you are a conceited jingoist if ever i saw one.
- dang 11y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News, regardless of how wrong a person is. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't do this. The idea here is to post civilly and substantively, or not at all. You might (re-)read the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- wnevets 11y agoits very typical for people to want their cake and eat it too. They want the benefits of having the US passport but don't want to pay for it.
- cr1895 11y agoOr, consider that when you're born in the US you become a US citizen. There was a fuss in the Netherlands recently where some Dutch people who were born in the US but were only there very briefly as a baby, and as such lived a Dutch life in the Netherlands. The article I linked goes into how much of an absolute pain it is to renounce citizenship. Article in Dutch: http://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2044332-amerikaanse-belastingdienst-maakt-jacht-op-nederlanders.html http://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2044332-amerikaanse-belastin...
- AlgorithmicTime 11y agoIf you're born in America, you're American. It's very simple.
- davidw 11y agoThere are benefits to being a Japanese, French, German, Norwegian, Australian or whatever citizen, yet none of them pay taxes at home if they reside in the US. They pay taxes where they live and work.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoNot sure Boris Johnson (who has dual nationality) would agree when the IRS wanted their share of his mothers estate. How woudl you feel if HMRC wanted a share of your parents estate.
- cr1895 11y ago>you probably earned that money in large parts due to the support of the people and infrastructure of the United States Or, you know, not. It's ridiculous to suggest that if you earn money abroad, American people and infrastructure are largely responsible for your success. It's in Dutch, but feel free to translate: http://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2044332-amerikaanse-belastingdienst-maakt-jacht-op-nederlanders.html http://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2044332-amerikaanse-belastin...
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe claim was "probably". Anecdotes aren't very helpful here, only statistics. For example, I could say that if you're an American citizen you probably have brown eyes. A million counterexamples wouldn't make that wrong. Edit: Why so many downvotes? I'm not saying he's right, just that cr1895 is arguing against a totally different claim.
- colechristensen 11y agoI was talking about people renouncing their US citizenship to avoid American taxes. That article is talking about renouncing their US citizenship to avoid an administrative nightmare. The people mentioned in that article probably owed little to nothing, but just didn't realize or didn't handle the finer details of their dual-citizenship very well.
- cr1895 11y agoFirst I think it was unfair of me to assume that you meant income earned abroad when reading it again you didn't actually specify. I don't think that's what you were implying, that if you were financially successful in another country the American people are somehow responsible. If you renounce your US citizenship you don't just get to erase all your existing tax obligations and if you're wealthy enough (i.e., the IRS assumes you're renouncing for tax purposes) you pay an exit tax. At what point is one's "duty" to the American public satisfied? Why are Americans so exceptional in this regard, where practically every other country in the developed world lacks taxation by citizenship? https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal-considerations/us-citizenship-laws-policies/renunciation-of-citizenship.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal-considerati... Just to put things in perspective: Last year 4,279 people renounced their US citizenship. It's a big increase, up 20% from the year prior. However, it's minuscule when you compare to the 8.7 million non-military Americans who live abroad. Less than 0.05%. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_diaspora#Number_of_U.S._citizens_living_abroad https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_diaspora#Number_of_... http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/08/news/americans-citizenship-renunciation/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/08/news/americans-citizenship-r...
- siberianbear 11y agoThat's only true for "earned" income. Income from dividends, interest, capital gains, etc is still taxed from the first dollar just as if you were residing in the USA. Furthermore, if you earn income as a freelancer, it's likely that you still have to pay self-employment tax.
- pg_is_a_butt 11y ago> you probably earned that money in large parts due to the support of the people and infrastructure of the United States. You don't get to drop your duties once you win big. i agree. the american people and their infrastructure owe their existence to the british crown. so, anytime you can send that check, that would be great.
- gozur88 11y agoThe problem is according to US law you still have to pay US income taxes for ten years after you renounce your citizenship. Not to mention the fact that you paid taxes for "the support of the people and infrastructure of the United States" when you lived there.
- brobinson 11y ago>you still have to pay US income taxes for ten years after you renounce your citizenship Do you have a source for this? I've never heard about it. All I know is they make sure your last N years of taxes are in order, charge you expatriation tax (if required), and ensure you have no unpaid federal student loans.
- gozur88 11y agoIt's in the wiki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriation_tax#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriation_tax#United_States "Under the new law, any individual who had a net worth of $2 million or an average income tax liability of $139,000 for the five previous years[10] who renounces his or her citizenship is automatically assumed to have done so for tax avoidance reasons and is subject to additional taxes. Furthermore, with certain exceptions covered expatriates who spend at least 31 days in the United States in any year during the 10-year period following expatriation were subject to US taxation as if they were U.S. citizens or resident aliens." The key there is "assumed to have done so for tax avoidance reasons". I would note this is a guideline, and the IRS can make the same determination for other reasons. Basically if you pay nontrivial amounts of taxes before you expatriate the USG assumes you should keep paying.
- BurningFrog 11y agoIf it's such a common sense rule, how come no other country does it?