7 ms·
Our legal system has created limited liability corporations to improve economic efficiency, and then a network of regulations to keep corporations from doing ba
by btilly 11y ago
Our legal system has created limited liability corporations to improve economic efficiency, and then a network of regulations to keep corporations from doing bad things that liability might dissuade a normal person from doing. We lurch between economically damaging regulations after something really bad happens, to regulatory capture after industry lobbying gets the attention of politicians.
It seems to me that the whole thing is a mess that doesn't work very well.
Here is my alternate proposal. Corporations who engage in risky long-term behavior should have to purchase long-term insurance to cover liability for what they are doing. These insurance contracts would be on terms set by insurers.
Behind the scenes insurers could cover these contracts by putting money into index funds. The fund would cover liability, the cost ensuring compliance with insurance terms, and after the period was up, would pay off investors.
These funds would therefore trade at a discount to regular index funds that represents market estimates of the present value of future liability. Therefore the insurance costs to companies would be a free market estimate of the cost to others of what you are doing.
And voila! Very little regulation. No regulatory capture. And people will get compensation. (And LLCs can remain limited liability.)
- cortesoft 11y agoThis makes a lot of sense, but I see a few issues. One, you say 'risky long-term behavior'... so how do we define something as being risky? If I am a corporation who wants to take risky long term behavior, why wouldn't I just hide the risk? If the bad thing happens, oh well, they have limited liability... if the bad thing doesn't happen, sweet we got to take the risk and not pay for insurance! If we say every corporation needs insurance, and that insurance company is supposed to take unlimited liability for the corporation that they are insuring, then this insurance is going to be CRAZY expensive. The insurers are running huge risks, since the possible liability is infinite. If we say the the liability is capped at some number, then we are back to the same issue where the company taking the risky behavior is not liable for the full damage.
- btilly 11y agoI would say that deliberately hiding risks is grounds for piercing the corporate veil and making shareholders personally liable. :-) Obviously in practice there needs to be a cap. But the cap should be set high enough to cover the upper limit of the claims that reasonably could happen. Which means that the cap needs to be astronomically high. For example if you're potentially affecting the health of a town, you should be able to compensate them for their actual losses. Including the cost of supporting sick people on disability for the rest of their lives. Like it or not that is the actual potential liability of your action. You shouldn't have to pay anything like that up front. But if 1% of fracking wells leak, and 1% of those leaks get into a town's water supply, then yes, you may have to be ready to compensate dozens of people for the cost of medical care and years of disability.
- guelo 11y agoIf I understand you correctly under this scheme a person injured by fracking would have to file an insurance claim for damages. But insurance companies don't like paying claims, so then the injured party has to sue some giant battalion of highly paid insurance lawyers. The people that persist through the legal gauntlet for years would finally get a fraction of the actual damages because damages are defined very strictly in that they don't take into account a host of external factors, including things like the livability of a town for your grandkids. All of this under-payment of claims is calculated into the market's original risk calculation of the insurance policy because this is how insurance companies and the legal system have performed historically. So the end result would be that frackers get to destroy small towns for less than the actual value of the destroyed town.
- chongli 11y agoThat's still not a great solution. If you gave me the choice between an insurance settlement and a loved one NOT dying from contaminated water, I'll take the loved one every time.
- btilly 11y agoHowever if you said we couldn't engage in any activity that could kill people, your loved ones would die due to causes that technology can save. A balance has to be achieved that allows productive activity to make our lives better, while providing incentives to make the side effects of that activity not harm us.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y ago> However if you said we couldn't engage in any activity that could kill people, your loved ones would die due to causes that technology can save. Would you mind expanding on how the first part of that sentence relates to the second part? Are you proposing the argument "We can't have cars because they might kill people" is valid? I don't think so. Whereas "We can't have fracking because it poisons the ground water" seems reasonable. Benzene is a known human carcinogen[1][2] You write of a balance and propose that a way to achieve balance is to financially compensate, via an insurance, people, but how do you limit the liability of the insurance? Can people four generations hence make a claim too? 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_IARC_Group_1_carcinogens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_IARC_Group_1_carcinoge... 2. http://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancercauses/othercarcinogens/generalinformationaboutcarcinogens/known-and-probable-human-carcinogens http://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancercauses/othercarcinogens/g...
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Whereas "We can't have fracking because it poisons the ground water" seems reasonable. Benzene is a known human carcinogen[1][2] How many people die in auto accidents as compared to Benzene originated cancers? Cars kill humans on a vast scale. They even sometimes kill people who want nothing to do with cars, like pedestrians, or cyclists. If your success metric is "lives saved", then pulling cars off the road is the sure winner, no? I'm not saying deliberately leaking Benzene into the water system and vehicular accidents are the same. I'm saying this problem is difficult.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Corporations who engage in risky long-term behavior should have to purchase long-term insurance to cover liability for what they are doing Startups engage in "risky long-term behavior" all the time. It would be prohibitively expensive for them to have to purchase insurance, especially when they're insuring against risks that aren't well-defined in the first place.
- btilly 11y agoSo you want to limit your long-term costs with limited liability, and your short-term costs with no insurance. And you also want to be free to engage in behavior that puts MY life at risk? And you see nothing wrong with this??? If you want to reap potential rewards for your behavior, you also need to take responsibility for the potential costs.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> And you also want to be free to engage in behavior that puts MY life at risk? And you see nothing wrong with this??? You're putting a lot of words in my mouth. > If you want to reap potential rewards for your behavior, you also need to take responsibility for the potential costs. "Potential costs" (ie, risks) are very difficult to define in advance. You can sometimes identify them after-the-fact, but having to wait until afterwards defeats the whole point of insurance in the first place.
- akiselev 11y agoWhat words, exactly, is he putting into your mouth?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 11y agoWe're talking about enviromental risks. If your startup can't afford the insurance then maybe your startup should stop dumping lead into our rivers.
- clumsysmurf 11y ago> It seems to me that the whole thing is a mess that doesn't work very well. Fritjof Capra discusses how areas of science have transitioned from a reductionistic / mechanical approach to a more systems approach - but law has not kept up and still treats parts of the world as disconnected, an individual's right, protected by the state. http://www.amazon.com/The-Ecology-Law-Toward-Community/dp/1626562067 http://www.amazon.com/The-Ecology-Law-Toward-Community/dp/16...
- late2part 11y agoWho defines what is risky? This seems ultracapitalist - someone profits from estimating risk and leaves the injured free to sue.
- Retra 11y agoRisk is a natural phenomena. You don't need someone to define it, it's already perfectly well defined. You just need people to understand it.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThat's a primary job of insurance companies. It depends on the risk, but for frequently-encountered circumstances, you'll have significant amounts of historical data on risks, usually expressed as financial costs, associated with various scenarios and outcomes. Where things get tricky are where you're dealing with small n or very-large-impact, or both, events. It's easy to get insurance for automobiles, or homeowners, or healthcare, as there are large numbers of policies and extensive history. The risks are known. Insurance companies typically exclude coverage for acts of war. Some events such as floods or major storms (hurricanes / typhoons) or earthquakes cover large areas and may overwhelm even large insurers. Rare instance risks -- tech, industry, spaceflight -- are also hard. But such projects do usually get underwritten.
- late2part 11y agoIn fact, the insurance jobs don't define what is risky - rather they measure the amount of risk. The OP proposed regulation to force "risky" businesses to have insurance. The question remains - who gets to decide who is risky and who isn't? In this scheme, does every enterprise require insurance in totality, not just the risky ones?
- kafkaesq 11y agoHere is my alternate proposal. Corporations who engage in risky long-term behavior should have to purchase long-term insurance to cover liability for what they are doing. These insurance contracts would be on terms set by insurers. And voila! Very little regulation. No regulatory capture. And people will get compensation. No. The whole point is that these "risky behaviors" are quite capable of inflicting damages (such as the permanent contamination of water tables in certain areas) that can't possibly be compensated by the any conceivable "insurance payout". Such behaviors (once identified) should be strictly prohibited. Economic penalties against the corporate entities (aka "regulation") will of course never be sufficient. The only effective deterrent is jail time for for the decision makers (in addition to complete confiscation of their personal assets). And BTW by "jail time" I mean serious jail time, as in multiple decades of jail time, and/or life sentences if necessary. Flipping back in the chronology of your post a bit: We lurch between economically damaging regulations after something really bad happens, to regulatory capture after industry lobbying gets the attention of politicians. I agree with you wholeheartedly about the need to stop lurching. That's why we need to get serious about criminal penalties for this kind of behavior -- not to throw in the towel and entrust the safety of our irreplaceable freshwater resources wondrous self-regulating powers of the insurance industry. The environment is not a casino, in other words. This is the health of uncounted generations we're talking about -- which will come into being long after any of these massive insurance payouts your proposal would seem to bank on could have possibly had any ameliorative effect.
- sitkack 11y agoSome mistakes can only happen once. Money doesn't fix that class of mistake.
- narrator 11y agoOne of the most annoying cliche arguments in American political discourse is that money is the universal 100% effective solution to all problems. We just had a nuke plant melt down? That's going to just cost a lot of money! We want to provide universal top quality free on-demand healthcare for everyone? Just quadruple spending and change absolutely nothing else! We want to colonize mars in 10 years. That will just be a few trillion. No problem! Nine women working together to have a baby in 1 month? Just a few billion in government R&D bucks and we'll have it solved in a jiffy!
- chris_va 11y agoIronically, that is exactly what happens in the oil industry.
- btilly 11y agoIt happens for oil spills. But I don't believe it happens for fracking.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThere's actually very little risk in fracking itself. Unfortunately, the movie "Gasland" made a real mess of the term.
- tremon 11y agoDo you mean that in the sense that there's also "very little risk in operating a nuclear power plant"? As in, we know how to do it safely and contained (perfect world scenario), but there's a lot of risk in non-optional secondary processes?
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI don't mean anything utopian. I mean that my understanding is that environmental risk due to fracking is very carefully monitored and can be controlled to some acceptable epsilon. FWIW, there IS very little risk of operating a nuclear power plant. Incidents, while spectacular, are extremely rare. They say ( whoever "they" is ) that molten salt and other technologies are safer yet.
- stinos 11y agoIt's a plan, but it's still driven by economy, and still allows disasters to occur. The only thing it does is pay off victims from such disasters (if I understand you correctly) - the victims wouldn't be victims if disasters didn't happen in the first place. How about just not going anywhere near risky behaviour when it comes to the environment and/or people, ans simply disallow any such thing from happening unless companies can provide sufficient proof it won't cause damage? It's far from a perfect system either (see pharma) but should in the end lead to less damage.
- amelius 11y ago> Corporations who engage in risky long-term behavior should have to purchase long-term insurance to cover liability for what they are doing. What prevents them from starting a subsidiary insurance company, who can go bankrupt with them in the case of a catastrophe?
- forgetsusername 11y ago>What prevents them from starting a subsidiary insurance company, who can go bankrupt with them in the case of a catastrophe? You regulate where and from whom they're able to purchase insurance from. Maybe they buy it from the government.
- touristtam 11y agoYes but would it be better to prevent such behaviour in the first place? Trashing a piece of land and the ecosystem on top of it isn't easily fixable and might prove to be very costly financially and time wise.