12 ms·
Sex Is a Coping Mechanism
- guard-of-terra 11y ago"Ask any biologist—sex seems like a waste" Stopped reading after this. If it's straw man, it's an especially stupid one. If she is serious, that's not even funny.
- gus_massa 11y agoYou should continue. The article discuss the relation between the nucleus ADN, the mitochondrial ADN and sex. I'm still not convinced about the conclusions, but it's an interesting theory. I really don't like the title, it looks like a confusing linkbait. Following the unofficial extended guidelines, I suggest the subtitle that is much better: "Did sexual reproduction evolve to keep up with mitochondrial mutation? "
- breakingcups 11y agoPerhaps you should continue reading the article to find out.
- oolongCat 11y agoWelcome to the internet, where people only read half the story and make up opinions :P
- 0xFFC 11y agoOff topic.I am student and in last year I felt this drawback.I spent almost all of my day reading internet (scientific material, watching courses).But recently I can feel internet makes person a shallow, without deep understanding about topics.(I don't know how to express clearly). I recently completely switched from internet to reading exclusively book/papers.
- pygy_ 11y agoThe article is full of gross approximations and falsehoods. The author later states things like That link lies in the fact that mitochondria are not just cellular batteries. Billions of years ago they were actually independent organisms. They are an example of how the human body is not entirely “human.” and (quoting someone else): “Until recently, science has basically ignored the fact that we are all walking around with two genomes in every cell,” Dowling says, “that of our own nuclear genome, and that of the mitochondria.”
- pessimist 11y agoBoth the statements in quotes are true.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoThey are both unfalsifiable and bizzare.
- dmichulke 11y agoAnother reason why sexual reproduction is efficient is that it enables division of labour. A mother needs to provide a complete eco-system (uterus) for the baby to live and grow which affects even the hormonal system. A man doesn't need this, so he can use this energy or "program space" in his genome for other things. It's one of Dawkins theses in his superb book "The selfish gene" [1] where he basically reduces evolution to game theory (without explicity saying so). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Selfish_Gene
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoThat extends to the genders' respective role in society as well, at least in humans - men being the hunters or soldiers and dying a lot, that is. On the other hand though, in e.g. lions, it's the females that go out hunting the most. I'm not sure what the logic is there. Maybe the males die a lot in fights for dominance and territory so they get to be lazy?
- juliendorra 11y agoUp until recently, women died a lot… giving birth. (It really comes to life when you read about history and queens or the classic plays and fairytales where there's so many remarried older men)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dmichulke 11y agoMaybe the lion case is also a "social effect" since a male lion is either completely alone or he is the leader of a pack of not so few females + cubs. I suppose the lone lions hunt for themselves (and you probably didn't count those) while the leader of a pack doesn't need to because he is the respected, well, leader.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoIt's almost as if these "just-so" stories don't have any actual predictive power.
- pja 11y ago“Until recently, science has basically ignored the fact that we are all walking around with two genomes in every cell,” Dowling says, “that of our own nuclear genome, and that of the mitochondria.” Really? I was taught about mitochondria in considerable detail as part of the biology part of my undergrad science degree & mitochondria have clearly been studied pretty intensively. That’s not to say that there aren’t gaps in our knowledge or new things to learn, but the idea that the mitochondria have just been ignored is clearly untrue. I guess some researchers feel it necessary to talk up their own research though - it’s a labrat eat labrat world out there.
- debacle 11y agoIn my high school biology class, which I would assume is still the highest level of biology most people complete, mitochondrial DNA wasn't even mentioned. Many high school level science courses are rife with disinformation.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoI definitely was taught quite a bit about mitochondria in grade 10 (Canadian) high school biology, in the early 90s. We were even told about at-the-time-speculative-now-accepted theories that mitochondria were the result of a primitive "capture" of a prokaryotic cell by the first early proto-eukaryotes.
- ergothus 11y agoIt might depend on what you consider "ignored". Shortly after Dolly the Sheep became famous, Ian Wilmut (one of the main people of that project) visited my university for a talk, and I asked him if he was concerned about the impact of mitochondrial differences between the genetic donor and the host egg. He was quite dismissive, saying (IIRC) "mitochondria are responsible for at most 5% phenotypical expression". To me that sounded like a lot (and I had asked the question because I expected mitochondrial differences to really matter) but he did not share my view. So, yes, if Dr. Wilmut's reaction was typical, I think it's fair to call that "ignored". Not "unknown", but ignored.
- PepeGomez 11y agoThat is blatantly false. Sex speeds up evolution exponentially with population size. With sex, each beneficial mutation can spread across the species even after arising only once. With asexual reproduction, beneficial mutations are confined to that particular strain. Sex is enormously beneficial for the ability to evolve and adapt quickly. This has been confirmed by mathematical models.
- lukasLansky 11y agoI downvoted you because although individual points of the article can argued, the text is certainly not "blatantly false" and the overall dismissive attitude is harmful to potential discussion about nuances of the issue. I would recommend you to read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium for a start.
- PepeGomez 11y agoIt's premise, that the costs of sex obviously outweigh the benefits, is false. Sex is an extremely advantageous ability. There is no discussion to be had, because the assumed problem doesn't in fact exist. What does punctuated equilibrum have to do with it?
- Confusion 11y agoThat's not its premise. Its premise is that the benefits tend to be subtle and become evident only over many generations, [while] its costs are heavy and immediate and so sex *seems* like a waste emphasis mine. Your reading of the article is extremely uncharitable.
- PepeGomez 11y agoThe costs aren't heavy, the math in the article is wrong. Yes, each of your offspring will have half of your genes, but twice as many offspring counts as yours.
- themartorana 11y agoBy "coping mechanism" I originally clicked to read how it helps us cope with the crushing reality that is life...
- yason 11y agoAll that is probably true, but the thesis has one flaw. While the benefits of sexual reproduction tend to be subtle and become evident only over many generations, its costs are heavy and immediate. But isn't the "flaw" already taken care of: the heavy and immediate costs are very much compensated by the pleasure and high stimulus which are as immediate as anyone who has gone through puberty knows. (And which are not unknown in the non-human part of the animal world either.)
- mulle_nat 11y agoMisread this as "Sex is a Copying Mechanism". Thought "duh!".
- jballanc 11y agoWhile it is definitely too soon to consider this hypothesis even close to settled, it's not as far out as it might seem at first glance. Indeed, what we evolutionary biologists have always said is that the cost of sex is compensated for by robustness in the face of evolutionary pressure. All this group is saying, in essence, is that instead of that pressure coming in the form of infrequent external events (plagues, floods, asteroids, etc.), it is present for every generation in the form of dealing with mitochondria that don't quite fit any longer. An interesting idea, to be sure.
- conceit 11y ago> Mitochondria are purely a maternal gift. Sperm do not pass them on; only a mother’s egg does. Some species' sperm do pass mitochondria successfully. Human sperm passes mitochondrial dna, but the egg kills it off.
- ergothus 11y agoI think you meant the reverse Re: humans. I'm interested in this though: do you know any examples off the top of your head where the male passes on mitochondria? I thought the primary reasoning is that sperm is little more than DNA with a tail and engine attached. (poetically speaking)
- conceit 11y agoWhat reverse? No, I don't know.
- ergothus 11y agoAh...I misunderstood your comment and I misunderstood how it works. I thought human sperm had no mitochondria. Turns out that is dramatically not the case, but the sperm's mitochondria is killed off by the egg, and that's exactly what you said. I had thought you were saying the sperm had mitochondria and the egg killed THE EGGs mitochondria off. My mistake.
- ommunist 11y agoThere is a typo in the title. Sex is a Copying Mechanism. We just fail to produce good copies, since the mechanism is broken.
- mangeletti 11y agoThis is part of a greater dehumanization[1] agenda by the parts of the US media industry. I don't have a conspiracy theory about why this is or who is behind it, but it's been going on for a few years now. Once your reticular activating system's habituation filter has opened up on something like this, you cannot not notice such articles when they pop up. I mean, click-bait or not, the idea of referring to an innate part of the biology of animal life as a "coping mechanism" automatically leads to a form of nihilism. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehumanization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehumanization
- spacehome 11y agoI'm not so sure it's an explicit conspiracy. I think it's just an outgrowth of Nihilism -- just what naturally occurs when you're jaded towards all the traditional narratives that give meaning to life.
- mangeletti 11y agoThat's an interesting take on it. Also, thinking about how we've come to a scientific understanding of most of the things that were previously sacred magic of sorts perhaps gives us a sense of being above all of it. I'm not religious and I'm certainly not a proponent of orthodoxy in nearly any aspect of life, but I always feel that trying to transcend naturally existing things is a fool's errand. One example is illustrated by our recent understanding of antibiotics and how they destroy our gut biome, and how that might be a really big problem.
- hodwik 11y ago>"That's an interesting take on it. " You say that like it's novel... It's been the almost universally accepted opinion in philosophy for the last 100 years or more that post-Enlightenment man is Nihilist because he denies his traditional narratives. It's the big story of the 20th century. Everything from Nazism and WW2, to the divorce rate has been blamed on it... Where have you been?
- 11y ago
- jokoon 11y agoMakes me think of the god meme, which reads "makes sex great -- forbids it".
- rbobby 11y agoSex is how to hotfix mitochondria.
- penny 11y agoSex and death are both metabolic hacks. They offset one another in the bioenergetic arms race tripped by the costs of complexity. Think about it.