13 ms·
After Cash: All Fun and Games Until Somebody Loses a Bank Account
- gd1 11y agoThere's been a deluge of anti-cash articles post Davos, and it's no mystery as to why. Not because it helps to prevent crime, or is more convenient, or any of these other reasons. Simply because you can't implement negative interest rates in a deflation event if your citizens have access to cash.
- zekevermillion 11y agoI agree about the motivation, partially. I think that reducing cash use in transactions is also of interest to regulators to make it more difficult for people to hide income from tax authorities, or to engage in illegal transactions. Some countries have already successfully implemented negative rates without banning cash, though they are certainly looking into it.
- mfairbank 11y agoI see this mentioned often, but it just isn't the case. In order to effectively implement negative interest rates, we will have to modify the exchange rate between physical cash and bank deposits to remove the incentive to hoard physical cash above the amounts needed for normal daily activity, but we will not need to ban it outright. This paper[0] from the International Monetary Fund explains in more detail the steps banks will take to implement the changes. [0] http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp15224.pdf http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp15224.pdf
- guard-of-terra 11y agoWhoa, the guys who wrote this paper should get treatment not dissimilar as people who helped design and build Nazi death camps. People will just ditch banks and return to exchanging physical currency in their transactions. Why would you need electronic money if it incurs additional fees?
- rvense 11y agoBanks want cash banned because they spend a lot of money handling it. Also a cashless economy where the banks own all the infrastructure is more opportunities for them to make money. Basically we're setting up a system where private entities will be able to tax and control participation in the economy, and we're doing it without any sort of debate except over how annoying coins are. Personally I'm not very impressed.
- vaadu 11y agoCash also makes bank account confiscation less profitable. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_levy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_levy
- retrogradeorbit 11y ago"Most of us are already moving toward a cashless society -- not because we care about the crime-fighting, but because the stuff is darned inconvenient." What on earth are they talking about? Why do people keep saying cash is inconvenient, as if saying it makes it true? It is, in my experience, extremely convenient. It is the most convenient form of payment, person to person. I owe money to my friend. Do you have a pay-pass terminal? Oh you don't. Let's just log into our bank accounts. Let me make sure I got your BSB number and account number right. etc. I want to give some money to the homeless beggar. Excuse me, do you have your bank details? Cash is king for a reason: Convenience.
- conanbatt 11y agoYou haven't been to argentina then. Money is an inconvenience every single day. Handling change, and having to have dozens of bills in your wallet all the time is a hassle. Visiting an ATM every couple of days, or running short of cash and being unable to pay for anything. Cash has other inconveniences cards dont have , and viceversa.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoArgentina is a living proof that cash is the king. Until very recently, as a visitor you will be losing 30% of value if you withdraw funds from ATM or pay with card, as opposed to bringing USD cash and exchanging it on street.
- oska 11y agoYou'll do even better if you 'bring' bitcoins with you for exchange.
- pbreit 11y agoProbably referring to things like buying stuff online or paying several hundred or thousand dollars.
- retrogradeorbit 11y ago
- julie1 11y agoWell the problem is you may not want your bank to gamble your money. And governments refused to separate financial activities of banks with their depots missions in most places. Leaving 98% of your actual money playing on markets on stuff you would not have wished to invest in the first place. Like the junk bonds and US mortage from 2007 that are still there in the bilans. It is as if our arms are bent to deposit our money in less than trustable places without guarantees. Are they trying to prevent banks from bankrupting or what? You also may not want government to be able to seize your money like it was done in Malta or in Greece. Banks are privately owned entities I do not trust. I have the right to not entrust my money to thieves and parasites without a minimum of security on my savings. Especially when they could bankrupt.
- mnw21cam 11y agoThe difference in law between a bank and any other company that looks after your money for you (for example, a pre-payment for goods) is that a bank is allowed to add your money to its central assets and do what it likes with it, whereas any other company has to keep your money in a separate account until it returns either it or the goods you wanted in exchange. Lots of people think this is the other way round. This means that if a bank goes under, the bank's creditors get to keep your money, and you get to claim back under your country's guarantee scheme, whereas if a different company goes under, your money in its separate account is protected from creditors, and should be returned to you. A while back I got a random letter written in German that I had to ask a friend to translate for me. Turns out that a few years ago I had pre-paid for some computer equipment that was under development in Germany. The company director had played fast and loose with the rules and used my money to (fail to) develop the product, before the company went bankrupt. Because of this breach of the rules, the company lost its limited status, and the director was personally responsible for the debt to everyone.
- fieryeagle 11y agoTL;DR cashless with anonymity and decentralisation. Sounds like Bitcoin.
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoBitcoin isn't anonymous. You pay someone and can look at every transaction they ever made.
- mbil 11y agoBTC's supposed to be pseudoanonymous: The traditional banking model achieves a level of privacy by limiting access to information to the parties involved and the trusted third party. The necessity to announce all transactions publicly precludes this method, but privacy can still be maintained by breaking the flow of information in another place: by keeping public keys anonymous. The public can see that someone is sending an amount to someone else, but without information linking the transaction to anyone. ... As an additional firewall, a new key pair should be used for each transaction to keep them from being linked to a common owner. Some linking is still unavoidable with multi-input transactions, which necessarily reveal that their inputs were owned by the same owner. The risk is that if the owner of a key is revealed, linking could reveal other transactions that belonged to the same owner https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- fieryeagle 11y agoOnly if I publish my address and leave patterns behind. Agree that it's debatable then again, wouldn't you agree that in a relative sense, pseudo-anonymous is better than bank accounts tied to your name?
- majewsky 11y agoIt depends. Pseudo-anonymity can give a (possibly false) sense of security. With bank accounts tied to your name, at least you definitely know that "they" can trace it back to you at every time, whereas with pseudo-anonymity you might never know if you're fully anonymous.
- OneOneOneOne 11y agoElectronic government controlled bank accounts seem like a good idea. It is good our government would never violate our freedom.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoLosing access to your accounts would effectively excommunicate you economically. I suspect this is considered a feature, not a bug.
- bcg1 11y agoIn person, I always use cash whenever possible. It saves business owners 3% or so on processing fees, so they can keep prices lower. I suppose there is the possibility that they might forget to declare that transaction and not have to pay federal taxes on it... but that wouldn't break my heart and potentially it would keep the money within the community. "Cashless society" is a cute idea for tech enthusiasts living in urban areas (nothing wrong with that btw) but it is not feasible for most of the places where I find myself.
- pjc50 11y agoIt saves business owners 3% or so on processing fees Banks charge business owners to deposit nontrivial amounts of cash too, especially in the form of coins.
- majewsky 11y agoAlso, cash has its builtin handling costs. It needs to be handled and counted by cashiers, which usually takes more time than an electronic payment transaction (iff the electronic transactions go smoothly). I don't have any insight on how much costs this is actually causing BTW. But I recall handling costs for businesses being an argument in the debate to abolish pennies (in the US) or 1ct/2ct coints (in Europe).
- thesimon 11y ago> But I recall handling costs for businesses being an argument in the debate to abolish pennies (in the US) or 1ct/2ct coints (in Europe). FWIW, the merchants in one city in Germany are currently trying to stop accepting 1ct/2ct coins, because the bank charges the merchants 1ct per coin to deposit, so they aren't making any money on it.
- DiffEq 11y agoNot any bank I have ever had dealings with. Smaller local banks tend not to be so fee happy.
- bcg1 11y ago
- tzs 11y agoSpeaking of losing a bank account...I'm curious how safe in the US bank accounts insured by FDIC are. I understand that it works well in the classic case of an insolvent bank where the problem is that the bank mismanaged its resources (too many bad loans, for example) and so doesn't have the money to cover deposits. In such a case the bank has full records of everything that happened, and auditors could come in and figure out exactly how much is owed to whom. But what would happen if online attackers got into a bank's systems and completely pwned the bank, having free run of the system for several months. Suppose they wiped all the live data, and managed to also wipe a few months of backup data. How would FDIC figure out who lost what from insured accounts if the bank itself no longer has records covering that?
- hammock 11y agoOne reason not to opt for Paperless.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoAccount holders should be able to submit affidavits of their own accounts.
- singlow 11y agoThe FDIC does not insure against fraud, theft or accounting errors. It only protects against bank insolvency due to under-capitalization.
- mcherm 11y agoThat isn't QUITE true. There are enough details that I can only speak in generalities, but in general, ordinary consumer accounts are indemnified against fraud and theft by the bank itself. US law requires that banks cover all or nearly all of a customer's losses to most sorts of fraud and theft (which it is depends on the kind of payment system) so long as it is a regular consumer account (small business accounts, for instance, may be out of luck) and the customer reports it within certain legally mandated time frames. If the fraud is so extensive that the bank cannot afford to reimburse all of the customers, then the bank is undercapitalized and will be taken over by the FDIC.
- Animats 11y agoWhat makes you think cash is anonymous? In China, ATMs record the serial numbers of the bills they dispense.[1] 80% of ATMs in Beijing, Shanghai, Nanjing and Guangzhou had this feature in 2013, and it was supposed to be rolled out nationwide by the end of 2015. There's no secret about this; you can ask the ATM to print the serial numbers of the bills it dispenses on your receipt. Now being rolled out in China: ATMs with face recognition.[2] [1] http://hkmb.hktdc.com/en/1X09V6YK/hktdc-research/ATMs-to-provide-banknote-serial-numbers http://hkmb.hktdc.com/en/1X09V6YK/hktdc-research/ATMs-to-pro... [2] http://en.yibada.com/articles/35951/20150601/china-worlds-first-atm-with-facial-recognition-detect-fake-bank-notes.htm http://en.yibada.com/articles/35951/20150601/china-worlds-fi...
- adrusi 11y agoBecause not all cash transactions go through ATMs. When friends are splitting bills, or lending each other money, or two people are just selling a piece of furniture, the trail gets lost. In the US that's enough to establish reasonable doubt.
- dublinben 11y agoIt is utterly trivial to launder cash to avoid this kind of tracking. Pay for a $1 pack of gum with a $20, and now you have $19 in clean cash. Rinse and repeat as necessary.
- pjc50 11y agoTrivial for small amounts, not trivial for large amounts. In China it's all about the "ants moving house" of capital flight.
- csense 11y agoUnfortunately with civil forfeiture, the situation with cash isn't much better. (E.g. the case of a black kid who carried $10,000 cash, his life savings, to move across the country, ended having the money taken by police and never returned, he was cooperative with officers and never accused or even arrested.)
- dheera 11y agoThe biggest problem I see coming with "cashless societies" is severe technological fragmentation. For mobile payments, in China you can get around with WeChat Pay and AliPay; in USA you use PayPal, Apple Pay, Android Pay, Samsung Pay, Venmo, and probably a few others I'm forgetting. In Australia you have PayWave. What about plastic? In Singapore you have NETS, in USA you have Amex, Visa, MasterCard, in China you have UnionPay, ... And guess what? None of these systems talk to each other. Even PayPal USA doesn't talk to PayPal China for goodness sake. Most payment systems require local addresses and phone numbers to even register an account, so if you're a short-term tourist or business traveller, you're out of luck. If you're a frequent international traveller, cashless societies are going to be absolute hell unless we come up with some kind of internationally-standardized protocol, which doesn't seem to be happening any time soon because each payment system has a corporate agenda behind it.
- SyneRyder 11y agoI'm not sure what you mean about those systems not talking to each other? I can take my Australian PayWave cards (which are actually Visa, Mastercard & Amex) and use them in Singapore and across Europe. I was using them in Sweden, Denmark, Germany, Austria & Slovakia. Cashless makes travelling easier. It's far easier than managing different currency for each country: SEK, DKK, SGD, EUR, AUD, some USD for those US trips, and all the small change you can't get rid of in each country. Why not use the same tap-to-pay cards that you use when at home, considering they work everywhere? If you mean receiving money from someone while travelling, perhaps that is a more awkward case right now. But Paypal seems to work across many countries.
- dheera 11y ago> Cashless makes travelling easier. When it works, yes. I believe you about Europe, and perhaps Australia and Europe are politically and culturally friendly enough with each other that the businesses there made it work. But try Japan, China, Korea, for example. My Visa card wouldn't work in Japan, and in China UnionPay is pretty much the name of the game. Also not to mention, every time I use my Visa card abroad, the fraud center tries to call me to "verify" transactions. They always call my US number (like, hello, I'm abroad, I probably can't take calls). My phone answers with a recording that says the only way to reach me is by e-mail. They don't e-mail (we're in the 21st century, hello). Then they disable my account, rendering me unable to pay for my meal in some foreign country where I can't speak the language. Then I have to call the Visa customer center, from the middle of the street, yelling my social security number and card number in open public space, "verify" some stupid transactions that I have no way to verify without logging into my account at a computer, to get my card reactivated again before I can pay and leave. Great security they have, making customers yell personal information over the phone instead of typing it in. And yes, I tell them I'm leaving the country before I do. But they still do this. And their geography sucks. I told them I was travelling throughout Eastern Europe once and they disabled my card in Bosnia because they didn't know it was a part of the region I was travelling to. So now, whenever I travel, I carry a spare $1K USD in cash or traveller's checks, split up and stashed on different parts of my person and luggage, for emergency situations like this, so at the very least I can buy a one-way flight ticket home if all other electronic payment fails. Cashless just doesn't work, yet.
- e12e 11y agoAbout losing a bank account: "HSBC shuts accounts of Muslim organisations, including Finsbury Park mosque": http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/30/hsbc-shuts-accounts-muslim-organisations-finsbury-park-mosque http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/30/hsbc-shuts-acco...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- frik 11y agoWho is behind the recent cashless movement? Which group? Who wants to profit? The huge population who will be on the looser side, is evident. It's not surprising that lesser educated people would find it convenient to not have cash. Though those don't understand what they would loose in the first place. Cash means freedom, no one can spy on what you spend your money on. And a big part of the money is still spend every day in the real world on location, and the smaller part online. Also cash cannot loose value as easily over night or even vanish without a trace (banks are private and can go bankrupt). It's very easy to keep track of your spending, when you use cash for all location payments (banks of course would like to loan you money). And remember, there was a time when banks were a new thing, and to catch consumers they provided bank accounts and services for free. Back then, you got your money from your employer in cash. Suddenly, employers started to pay out the money only to bank accounts you were locked in to the back system and of course they started to charge you for bank account and all their "services" incl ATM and cards.
- majewsky 11y agoThe dominant explanation among leftist economists in Europe is that banks wants to set negative interest rates on consumer bank accounts. But that only works when cash is eliminated. Otherwise, negative interest would cause a bank run because keeping the money at home in cash is literally more profitable than leaving it in the bank account.
- brohee 11y agoThe interest rate is already de facto negative, 0% interest rate and fees on checking accounts. People still use them, because they value the convenience.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoSo basically, the protocol they use for monetary policy doesn't work, so they're trying to prevent deflation by eliminating cash.
- distances 11y agoJust replying to the last part -- I have two bank accounts, I don't pay any fees or charges whatsoever. Over here banks usually make the majority of profits from loans and mortgages, and investment fees. I suppose it makes sense to keep the daily banking charges to a minimum to ensure the happy customers will come to them with their financing needs.
- junto 11y agoI am lucky to live in a safe area. I don't like the tracking capabilities of debit and credit cards. I don't want my bank to know what kinds of shops I like to shop in, or how I chose to spend my money.I don't want a profile. As a result I love cash. The only time I use cards is online or larger purchases where I can't easily carry around that much cash. Cash has been around for thousands of years. I doubt it can be removed from our society without a great deal of backlash. That is a very good thing in my opinion.
- klez 11y ago> I doubt it can be removed from our society without a great deal of backlash This is the reason there's so much talk about going cashless these days. It's being propagandized so there's less friction when they decide it should happen.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoThis is a topic that always fascinates me on HN. HN typically is in favour of privacy, and against surveillance. Then is equally enthusiastic about cashless apps which have a transaction record for every tiny amount. I don't understand :) I'll generally buy most day to day items with cash and a card just for online. I don't find it any way inconvenient - there's an ATM at the supermarket and near all the shops I visit. Amongst children and friends I don't see any evidence of a move to cashless either. They'll still take notes for a night out and make sure to leave enough for the cab home, or go to the hole in the wall first. They'll use a bank app to pay back a random £20 borrowed.
- ersii 11y agoThe article claims Swedes and Sweden "are making the shift". That's currently false, but it's something that could happen. Perhaps I'm reading it too strictly, but as they were mentioning the National bank of Korea in the same paragraph.. The current set of laws and regulations in Sweden mandates that cash are legal tender and that there is an obligation for the Riksbank (National bank) to make sure there is "enough cash" available. There is currently no proposed changes to those laws in the direction of scaling down cash. There are however proposed changes in the making that will make cash more available than they currently are. The chief of the Riksbank (National Bank / "Federal reserve") have an article in one of the major newspapers about this very subject, published today [1]. [1]: http://www.dn.se/debatt/bankerna-maste-ansvara-for-kundernas-kontantbehov/ http://www.dn.se/debatt/bankerna-maste-ansvara-for-kundernas... (In Swedish)
- Shaanie 11y agoIf you read the linked article it's more about a social shift than driven by law. I.e, many individuals are foregoing cash for cards, to the point where churches and 'homeless' now accept cards.
- sleepychu 11y agoGot a link for 'homeless' accepting cards?
- ersii 11y ago"Stefan Wikberg, 65, was homeless for four years after losing his job as an I.T. technician. He has a place to live now and sells magazines for Situation Stockholm, a charitable organization, and began using a mobile card reader to take payments, after noticing that almost no one carried cash." This excerpt is from the article [1] linked in the Bloomberg article [2] [1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/busines/international/in-sweden-a-cash-free-future-nears.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/busines/international/in-s... [2]: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-03-15/the-end-of-cash-and-the-rise-of-government-power http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2016-03-15/the-end-of-...
- ersii 11y agoRegardless of your opinion if we're going to have or would want a cashless society or not - the article glosses over a lot of negative aspects. The article mentions crime as a main motivator to shifting away from cash. The amount of robberies/muggings have gone down, but card theft and fraud is sky-rocketing. I would be interested to hear more about how kidnapping/extortion have fared in comparison as well. The article mentions that retail crime will be just a memory after we've shifted away from cash. There has been plenty of retail card theft and fraud stemming from hacked retailed networks and hacked/rigged payment terminals during the last three years (2013-2016). The article mentions that shifting away from cash would give the governments of the world a leg up in controlling our usage of money. I have nothing to object to there, but would like to add that it also gives private companies a leg up in controlling our usage of money as well. Both from the perspective of knowing where we spend and what we spend on - but also as they can terminate the contract to any retailer or payment processor at basically any time. Sure, not everyone is Wikileaks - but when you've broken the principle, it could happen to anyone.
- paulajohnson 11y agoHence Bitcoin
- johnchristopher 11y agoI am puzzled to see the majority of comments here favouring an all bank/electronic solution that leaks an insane amount of metadata to the regular players [0] (bank, gov., etc.) because it's the opposite of what I usually read in the regular encryption submissions regarding privacy (and defence against the prying eyes of a government). [0] who gives what amount of money to who and when for instance
- noja 11y agoBy "cash" they means "government issued cash". Ban government issued cash, and you'll get alternative hard cash appearing. Or barter.
- faebi 11y agoRecently my Debit Card didn't work anymore and the process to get a new one didn't work correctly. It meant I was without cash and possibilty to get my cash for more than 4 weeks. It showed my very hard how depent we are on those systems.
- opium_tea 11y agoCouldn't you go to the bank with your passport? That's the fallback solution in the UK.
- faebi 11y agoYes, but my bank is a small one in my old home area. Now I am living in a far aways city without this bank. Also I was only on sundays in my old home area and had no possibilty to go there on a weekday.
- faebi 11y agoInterestingly Switzerland goes into both directions. We are going more and more into a cashless society and also our banking system is quite modern. On the otherside the amount of 1000Fr bills issued in switzerland is getting more and more. It means cash's main purpose will move to bigger amounts of money.
- atemerev 11y agoHere in Switzerland: — The largest cash note is 1000 Fr. (slightly more than $1000). It is readily accepted everywhere and I can pay for coffee with it and get change. (The coffee will be around $4, or $7 for vanilla latte in Starbucks). — My ATM daily cash withdrawal limit is 75000 Fr. (not a typo). I dream of hitting it once, but I'm not that rich. — I can go to the nearest bank and buy a physical gold bar, from 1g to 12 kg, for cash, no questions asked, no papers needed. And sell it later at the same place, with only a nominal fee taken (if still in original package). And I like it this way. When I travel in any other country, it looks strange to me when even a 100€ bill is frowned upon and probably won't be accepted.
- askyourmother 11y agoI agree with you 200% here, but the HN crowd don't seem to be able to even conceive that once cash is gone, it only takes a glitch, a bug (in software? Surely not!), or a malicious action by bank or state, and then you are left in a rather desperate state. Today the bank can, and had recently, make mistakes, but o can still buy food on the way home thanks to cash. Life can go on, even when "computer says no".
- atemerev 11y agoNot even malicious. Just a mistake or law misinterpretation. Banking software systems may seem relatively logical (spoiler: they are very NOT), but legal structure around payments, compliance, taxes, insurance etc. is a mess. Tax returns are commonplace (this means that mistakes in taxation happens all the time). Currently, if there a mistake, you can challenge it, then pay. What governments want is taking money first, then you can try to challenge it. I'd say no thanks.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoAnother thing people overlook is that when all peoples money is in the bank, then banks are free to raise all the "fees" they need to "handle" your money. Also if all peoples money is in the bank, then government can choose what ever tax rate they please and just take the money by simple transaction.
- 11y ago
- theknarf 11y agoBitcoin (or some other altcoin/cryptocurrency) would be the answer then.
- gedrap 11y agoI haven't seen anyone mentioning what happens in a cashless society if your card is broken/lost. I've lost my card, went to a bank, showed my passport, got enough cash for a couple of weeks and got card replacement in a few days. What would happen if the society was cashless? Would I get a new card immediately?
- guard-of-terra 11y agoYou can get a prepaid card with some amount, I guess.
- ptype 11y agoVisa and mastercard are already skimming a portion of all payments via their systems. So if we are moving to a cashless society, should this not be state owned infrastructure? Imagine a future where no cash exists and the large banks and card networks coown the infrastructure for all payments, taking their cut. I feel that cash is an important competitor to prevent this from happening. but unfortunately as with most things it's use it or lose it.
- yitchelle 11y agoHere in my small German town that I am living in. Shops that accepts debit cards only made an appearances about 15 years ago. Before that, cash is the only way. Credit cards are still very much not in vogue in my town. Actually, even in larger shops like Ikea, credit cards are not accepted.
- thirdsun 11y agoThat mirrors my impression as well - here in Germany credit cards just became mildly common but customers are still far from being expected to carry one. Debit cards however, are very common, however they won't help you when getting a beer at sunday league football or visiting the local bakery.
- thesimon 11y ago>Debit cards however, are very common, Agree. Sadly most of the times the stores are only accepting the shitty domestic "girocard" scheme and not international brands of debit crds. >visiting the local bakery. Kamps usually accepts credit cards, even contactless.
- thesimon 11y ago> Actually, even in larger shops like Ikea, credit cards are not accepted. Some IKEAs accept credit cards, whereas others don't. IIRC it depends on how close they are to the border.
- yitchelle 11y agoMust be quite rare then, the Ikeas in Köln (x2), Düsseldorf, Essen are still sans credit card. The ones just over the border in Holland do accept credit cards.
- dsq 11y agoupdate accounts set balance=0 where name='name_of_person_disliked_by_senior_official';
- nissimk 11y agoPeople have been saying bitcoin here, but without spelling it out. Bitcoin is digital money. One of the most important properties is that you don't have to trust any other party to protect it for you. This makes it similar to cash. If you have cash in your teapot, someone has to physically force their way into your home to seize the cash. If your money is all digital in banks, it can be easily seized or frozen by the bank or the government. With bitcoin, you have digital money that cannot be easily siezed or lost due to a failure of some organization. Unfortunately, nobody knows how to make it scale yet where it will be usable by a large number of people and still maintain this "trustless" quality. Hopefully all of the smart people currently working on the scalability issues will solve this problem and we can move to a digital cash future.
- ikeboy 11y ago>Even if these sorts of crimes are replaced by electronic thefts of equivalent value, Why would they be of equivalent value? Consider how much harder it was to steal $100 million in cash, how much more planning it took, if even possible.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoYou need to grow up and put your big boy or girl pants on and keep enough cash on you for day to day transactions and stop slowing everyone down when doing small transactions.
- amatix 11y agoElectronic (particularly Paywave/Apple Pay/NFC) is miles faster than me & a shop assistant both mucking around counting coins, let alone queueing up at ATM machines or the "don't you have anything smaller?" conversations. He says having moved from New Zealand to the UK in the last 6 months. Cash is a constant PITA here for me. I'm of the generation where as kids ('90s) we used EFTPOS (electronic debit system which took an absolute maximum of 10 seconds including manual retailer and customer actions) to buy ~US$0.30 chocolate bars from corner shops. That was helped by both the retailers and customers essentially paying no transaction fees. (Doesn't apply to PayWave, but that's another story and the customer expectations are the same)
- cr1895 11y agoFunny. I was thinking the exact opposite the other day in line at the grocery store while the person in front of me was fumbling with cash. Your condecension adds nothing, by the way.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoEver seen a busy pub or coffee shop where serving is being slowed down while they wait for the 1 or or two card readers. If your not grown up enough to mange your fiances so you can keep £50 -100 in change to mange incidental day to day expenses dont be surprised if people treat you with condecension.
- xupybd 11y agoIt has nothing to do with being grown up, if done right electronic transactions are faster and easier. I'm surprised to see condescension here on hacker news, I normally don't see that here.
- throwaway21816 11y agoYeah just convert all of your excess labor into bits, now they dont even have to print money and distribute it. Unlimited inflation time!
- frogpelt 11y agoCash is just a medium of exchange. Sure, outright theft may become less lucrative. But if cash completely goes away, black markets can and probably will start using their own medium of exchange.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoEven if "cashless" works perfectly, now you've constrained the entire economy to either the formal electronic currency or barter. Or maybe something like wampum, an informal improvement on barter. One need only look to the history of the United States before the greenback to see it. People do business outside the formal economy. They do cash only business. Unemployed/underemployed don't simply stop breathing. Since we have a high U6 number, the hubris of even considering this is breathtaking. Stretching a metaphor too far, "cashless" is censoring the economy. What happens when the economy perceives this and routes around it?
- forgottenpass 11y ago"How Complex Systems Fail" http://web.mit.edu/2.75/resources/random/How%20Complex%20Systems%20Fail.pdf http://web.mit.edu/2.75/resources/random/How%20Complex%20Sys... A no-cash system, beside all the other downsides, reduces and sometimes outright removes the ability for humans to alter and/or workaround the system when systematic failure modes are discovered. And that's just unintended consequences, forget about perverse incentives. This is the same reason I think augments that posit privacy is unnecessary because enough downstream controls will somehow account for all "bad" things that could happen. It's a scam, pushed by unscrupulous hucksters for their advantage at the cost of everyone else.