11 ms·
Bitcoin transaction processing takes up to 10 hours
- lojack 11y agoIs there anything preventing an implementation vote by the miners? I would think that convincing 50% of miners would be all it takes to change these types of features.
- dogecoinbase 11y agoUp to a point, miners have an incentive to increase transaction delays in order to drive up fees (which they receive).
- CyberDildonics 11y agoMiners can't increase transaction delays in practicality because they need their blocks to propagate to be able to capture the mining fees.
- aianus 11y ago> Miners can't increase transaction delays in practicality because they need their blocks to propagate to be able to capture the mining fees. They get the mining fees regardless of whether they include your transaction or any others for that matter.
- lololomg 11y agoThe miners get the Block Reward without including transactions but they earn extra Transaction Fees for each fee-bearing transaction they include in the block too.
- colejohnson66 11y agoIIRC, The majority of the blocks are "mined" in China where they continue using the "old" fork of Bitcoin instead of the "new" fork that upped the block size. I would assume they're resistant to change as keeping the block size down can, over time, force the transaction fees up (bringing in more cash for the miners)
- ilaksh 11y agoChina has people in both camps.
- 21 11y agoI find it funny how all talk about decentralization, but ignore the fact that most mining is in China, a known bastion of freedom. Yesterday it made illegal movies depicting homosexuality or one night stands. Tomorrow it might decide to make bitcoin mining illegal (as it has forbidden some forms of bitcoin trading in the past)
- Nutmog 11y agoAll kinds of silly things are illegal in China, even copyright infringement, but that doesn't mean the police are breaking down people's doors and confiscating their computers. People flagrantly do many of the illegal things anyway. So I'd say, yes China really is a bastion of freedom - just a different kind of freedom than what westerners think. Economic freedom, rather than political freedom.
- zanny 11y agoThat is what Classic is, except they are using 75% as their consensus threshold (it is arbitrary though - if you maintain 51% of hash power you can dictate the protocol).
- matthewbauer 11y agoIt's not really 51%. The miners are supposed to accept the "tallest" chain. So you can get lucky and mine a block then change the rules and sneak in some breaking change (like a larger block). No one else will accept it unless you can keep mining quicker than everyone else and eventually convince everybody that yours is the "true" blockchain so everyone else should switch. The thing is if you have less than 50% of hash power, it's extremely unlikely you'll be successful because 50%+ other miners disagree. Once you get above 50%, you're chances go up but you're still playing with fire here because just a short period of bad luck can end up breaking your "fork". Even at 75% there would be some big issues with the 25% left behind who might not initially realize what's happening (and maybe get lucky).
- sanswork 11y agoIf you do something like a larger block it doesn't matter if you have the longest chain because no one will be relaying it.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe fork accepting more kinds of block is probably going to be jittery and broken right at the switchover no matter what. The percentage only affects how fast things stabilize. 60% would be fine after a couple hours. Requiring 75% or more is to smooth things on a political level.
- TD-Linux 11y ago>The miners are supposed to accept the "tallest" chain. The tallest valid chain. A chain with block sizes exceeding the max won't be considered valid.
- adrianmacneil 11y agoBecause it's a consensus rule (enforced by every fully validating node), it would require a backwards incompatible change (hard fork) to be implemented by every single miner, exchange, wallet and merchant. Only soft forks (which are backwards compatible) can be rolled out with a 51% miner vote. Bitcoin Classic is trying to gain support for a hard fork with 75% miner vote, but in reality this would also require every exchange, wallet and merchant to pledge their support, or risk creating a network split with two separate currencies.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 11y agoBrian Armstrong also just posted this: https://medium.com/@barmstrong/what-happened-at-the-satoshi-roundtable-6c11a10d8cdf https://medium.com/@barmstrong/what-happened-at-the-satoshi-... Bitcoin is starting to look like "decentralization" at its worst. Pretty much the only asset ever in existence that hasn't fallen in price due to uncertainty. Regarding "the halving", how in the world could you design in a doubling of expenses on some arbitrary date in the future? That didn't make any sense to me.
- ikeboy 11y agoIt's not a doubling of expenses, it's a halfing of reward. The reward is meant to go to zero eventually, and halves every four years.
- dllthomas 11y agoA halving of reward per unit of expense is a doubling of expenses per unit reward. That said, it is neither - it is a halving of extra reward on top of transaction fees.
- eordano 11y agoAlso, "reward" is not appropriate. It has been historically referred to as "miner subsidy": it was intended to be a way to make mining attractive for early adopters.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- matthewbauer 11y agoThis may be a little unpopular here, but I really appreciate the conservative approach by the Bitcoin core team. There's a lot of cryptocurrencies out there and Bitcoin's dominance is from its long history and staying power. Bitcoin needs to have a near majority of agreement for any breaking change or else its risking its own dominance. Hopefully, transaction fees become less over time, but regardless they're necessary to prevent spam. No matter how big of blocks you have, you're always going to have a spam problem and the Bitcoin forks have yet to show how bigger blocks will mean faster transactions.
- ggreer 11y agoExcept they're not being conservative. Core's approach has been to introduce new complexities such as replace-by-fee[1] and segregated witness[2]. These are much bigger changes to Bitcoin than a one-time increase of the max block size. 1. https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0125.mediawiki https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0125.mediawi... 2. https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0144.mediawiki https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0144.mediawi...
- ikeboy 11y agoThe first is just putting in code that had been part of Bitcoin since the beginning, temporarily removed due to DoS concerns, and re-added once those concerns had been alleviated by requiring a higher fee. The second is being implemented as a soft fork, while a block size increase would be a hard fork. Soft forks have been done many times while hard forks have no precedent. Why do you consider that a bigger change? Soft forks are "optional", a backwards compatible change, while hard forks aren't.
- ggreer 11y agoThe problem with RBF is that (in some cases) it can allow double-spends with older receiving software. If the receiver accepts zero-confirmation transactions, the sender can send one transaction, wait for the receiver to accept it, then send another transaction with a higher fee and a different receiver. In other words: RBF may be opt-in, but it decreases security for wallets that don't support it. The problem with SegWit is that it isn't ready. A few days ago, SegWit caused testnet to fork. The cause has been identified and fixed, but it will still be months before SegWit is trusted enough for production use. While Bitcoin has never had an intentional hard fork, it has had an accidental one.[1] It was chaotic, but not world-ending. In contrast, Classic requires 750 out of the last 1000 mined blocks to trigger, and it has a month-long grace period before accepting larger blocks. It would be a well-known and predictable switchover. 1. https://bitcoin.org/en/alert/2013-03-11-chain-fork https://bitcoin.org/en/alert/2013-03-11-chain-fork
- al_chemist 11y agoWhy it takes so long? Because network is being DoSed. How? By sending a lot of small transaction to fill out blocks - they also pay for those transactions. Why? Well, to prove the point. "You need bigger block, you need our fork". DDoS - the best weapon of Internet, still undefeated.
- eterm 11y agoThey're paying, so who gets to declare them a "ddos". Also if <2 transactions per second is "ddos" then the protocol is flawed.
- stale2002 11y agoLol wut? It's the classic nodes being DOSed. Also, the whole network being full isn't even supposed to be a problem, according to Core. Prices will just rise? Correct?
- makomk 11y agoThis has been going on, on and off, since before Classic and XT and all the others were announced. Someone's been spending a fairly substantial amount in transaction fees to send spam transactions in order to "prove" that the block size needs to be increased and openly bragging about it.
- PascalsMugger 11y agoDoesn't the action actually prove the point? At the very least, it's proof that the network is vulnerable to this kind of attack. Seeing as it has been ongoing, it can't be that expensive to do, since it isn't really going to result in a financial payoff for the attacker.
- yxitcti 11y agoCoinbase has an interest to increase the block size so that the protocol can be further centralized, making people more reliant on their centralized bitcoin as a service business. Honestly, the whole bitcoin ecosystem is a sinking ship at this point. The protocol is broken and there are too many vested interests to properly fix it. It's time to move over to Ethereum.
- snitko 11y agoWhy is it a sinking ship? I can still send money to anyone anywhere in the world for a very low fee relatively fast, without any restrictions, long forms or questions asked. I don't know what do you think Bitcoin's value is to people, but I surely know what value it has for me personally.
- yxitcti 11y agoSinking doesn't imply fully sunk. Yes, bitcoin is still semi-useable but it's becoming less and less so. Meanwhile businesses are chomping at the bit to bring it fully under their control so they can profit more from it. There are much better alternatives.
- NhanH 11y agoHow financially invested are you in Ethereum?
- yxitcti 11y agoNot at all. I hold about $5 worth of bitcoin, but that's it.
- snitko 11y agoSemi-usable? How so? I regularly buy things with Bitcoin and I haven't noticed any decline in products and services being offered for Bitcoin. Expedia still accepts it. Cheapair still accepts it. Dell still accepts it. Many other large and small businesses accept it. Yes, it's not the same level of penetration as credit cards, but CC have been around since when? And Bitcoin? Have a sense of proportion.
- exolymph 11y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but doesn't this just mean that fees have to be higher? Welcome to markets, where technical constraints and supply/demand dynamics both influence price.
- gruez 11y agoExactly. The issue is that people are to accustomed to paying little to no fees, so nobody wants to pay a few cents more for faster confirmations.
- replies_to_all 11y agoMy transaction just cost nearly $1, so yeh, thats a lot of cents for some people, and the point is that it is an unnecessary constraint.
- Tideflat 11y agoHaving little or no fees was supposed to be one of the big advantages of bitcoin compared to traditional financial transactions.
- lololomg 11y agoYea this is really not a big problem. Currently people are using Bitcoin to move around amounts as small as a tiny fraction of a cent. That's just a waste of blockchain space. We all know there needs to be a transaction fee to stop these so-called 'dust transactions'
- dontscale 11y agoThe tone of the article is objective, but surely Coindesk has an interest in Bitcoin Classic. I read it as nothing more than propaganda. I don't have a side one way or another, and I don't own bitcoin. But, it's ridiculous to see these bitcoin 'companies' taking such desperate measures. Given the nature of all the characters I've seen come out of the woodwork thus far, it is not surprising.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoThey have an interest in bitcoin working, I'm not sure what other ulterior motives you think they have to the actual protocol.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jalfresi 11y agoControl?
- CyberDildonics 11y agoYou think coinbase wants to control the protocol? How would they do that exactly? The best way we've seen so far is to stuff the developer list with people you've bought off and alienate the others, which is what blockstream is doing and what is happening right now.
- Animats 11y agoIt's a free market. If you pay a higher transaction fee, your transaction gets processed sooner. Typical transaction fees are now $0.04. The big spike seems to be over, anyway.[1] Median time never exceeded 13 minutes. Note that this does not include no-fee transaction requests. There may be an attack underway which involves lots of tiny transactions that may never clear. One of the purposes of the fee is to discourage such spamming. [1] https://blockchain.info/charts/avg-confirmation-time?timespan=180days&showDataPoints=false&daysAverageString=1&show_header=true&scale=0&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/avg-confirmation-time?timespa...
- alfiedotwtf 11y agoEveryone loves to talk about the free market, but then are shocked when price discovery raises fees with high volume load
- danharaj 11y agoIt is a market. I don't think the word 'free' adds anything, except to perhaps avoid analyzing why the market has the structure that it does. Changing the block size changes the market. If the market is currently free, would it still be free if the block size were increased? I think yes. There's no distinguished natural market structure for bitcoin, like all markets. What do you mean by free? Is the market efficient in the technical sense? Is it as useful as it could be in the human sense? I wouldn't be surprised either way of the answer to the first question, but i'm pretty sure there's a whole 'lotta people who think bitcoin would be more useful to humans if the block size were changed.
- tyre 11y agoFree means there aren't external factors interfering with market dynamics. While this drama affects transaction times and scalability, it doesn't fundamentally change the supply/demand curve. Transactions offering the highest fee get processed first and rising demand (of transactions) with stable supply (of processors) raises prices like it should. A non-free market would be something like if Core developers' transactions got moved to the front of the line regardless of transaction fee.
- buttershakes 11y agoThis is a really complicated discussion, that has been splashed all over reddit and other forums for the last year. The reality is that the network is rapidly approaching if it hasn't already exceeded capacity at 1 MB. This doesn't break the network, but it ends up with load sheddding (people who no longer transact) and worse, people who transact but due to rapidly changing fees have to wait in line indefinitely to get their first confirmation. The mempool will eventually randomly eject transactions, but this can cause issues for wallets and other services. To say that centralization increases dramatically at 2 MB just isn't the case. Once people stop running full nodes because they don't believe in Bitcoin's potential as a transaction network then what? This is all about control, who gets to control the fate of the Bitcoin network, and right now that battle is being waged between large well funded companies each of which has its own vision for what Bitcoin is. Development should under no circumstances be centralized with one entity, but there you have it. The only people who benefit from bitcoin being unable to scale are those who want it to simply be a digital gold / store of value, and those that sell alternative solutions for various markets. This is just going to lead to capital flight from Bitcoin into alternative networks that have a growth potential despite being inferior at the moment.
- xkarga00 11y agoThat's exactly the reason why I believe in the potential of Decred. https://www.decred.org/ https://www.decred.org/
- completereset 11y agoAnd how is Decred better exactly at scaling?
- xkarga00 11y agoIt doesn't need to be at this stage. It's better at governance by combining PoW and PoS mining ie. everybody has a saying on what the next block will be. It only remains to be seen if it will fulfill its potential.
- 11y ago
- julie1 11y agoYou don't have to be smart to understand the universe is resource bound. Bitcoin core seems to have made a money that has a "resource" like behaviour. The more you mine it, the more it costs. They seem to have a concern about a virtual currency that unlike real ones can prevent some "non realistic" transaction behaviours that are not compliant with the real world. Transactions are never free. And the bigger a system is the more a a transaction costs. What frightens me is the High Tech business trying to piggy back on a pretty sane currency and want to influence for their personal interests the system in a way that might deserve the economy globally. Are all High Tech companies sociopaths just caring about nothing but their private benefits built upon other's works?
- 21 11y ago> Are all High Tech companies sociopaths just caring about nothing but their private benefits built upon other's works? That's pretty much how all the world works. Capitalism at it's best. As a side node, bitcoin is a "pretty sane currency" only in the mind of gold bugs and conspirationists. There's a reason we moved from an inflexible currency (gold) to a flexible one ("printed" money)
- scient 11y agoWelcome to the real world, where companies are ran for profit, not for some "greater good". I can safely assume you have never owned a company. How would you feel if you would not get paid for your work, but it would instead be handed out to homeless people for the greater good (as an example)?
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "How would you feel if you would not get paid for your work, but it would instead be handed out to homeless people for the greater good (as an example)" Why can't I have both? For example, the taxes the company pays could cover looking after homeless people.
- julie1 11y agoYou unsafely assumed. I had more than one business. As a former small business owner I know very well how workers and small companies are being put in an unfair competition, especially because bigger companies have de facto monopolies and the support of both administrations and governments to play dirty. Especially by having hidden subsidies or regulation unfairly protecting their business and weakening others. I think as someone who was taxed 40% as a worker, 50% as a business owner, I have the right to be scandalized at the fiscal contribution of any so called successful businesses (google, apple, fb, ms, jp morgan ...). Fuck, this is clearly fiscal inequity. What triggered revolution in USA and France. When competition is not fair it is not a liberal system anymore. And when wealthy kids get wealthy by birth and citizens find it remarkable, I guess people forgot why and how the citizens of the USA created their own country. USA was despising the priviledge system and wished for a system where every one had a fair chance to compete for their success (except the black slaves).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 11y agoIf your transaction eventually got confirmed, contact the vendor with the transaction hash. The last three times I used bitcoin, I had to do this; I've yet to be refused by a vendor.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- beaner 11y agoThis doesn't make any sense. Why would a company intentionally screw over its customers over such a trivial issue? Their window is 15 minutes because of bitcoin's tendency to fluctuate in price. If the network hasn't delivered your transaction, there's literally nothing they can do. Shouldn't you contact the merchant for a refund?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kang 11y ago"up to" being the key word in the title. Don't pay enough fees and it'll take even days.
- look_lookatme 11y agoIf companies like Coinbase, which live and die by the health of the Bitcoin ecosystem, have taken so much capital, why can they not solve this problem by spending money to shore up the health of bitcoin ecosystem (I assume this requires adding processing power)? I don't know anything about Bitcoin, so maybe it's just unfeasible.
- al_chemist 11y agoThis is the paradox. Coinbase does not gain anything if bitcoin gets better. Their business is "we make bitcoin use easier". If both users are Coinbase customers, their transaction is done outside of blockchain. Their goal is to have more users and wonky or slow transactions outside of their servers helps them.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoThey are. Coinbase has several bitcoin devs on their payroll, and they have thrown their support behind a scaling plan that includes bigger blocks.
- nullc 11y agoIf they do, these parties are not disclosing it AFAIK.
- look_lookatme 11y agoWow why am I being downvoted?
- nonuby 11y agoDoes Ethereum have the same scaling issue if a group setup a direct currency on it?
- jackgavigan 11y agoI think this vindicates the banks' decision to build their own blockchains instead of building on top of the Bitcoin blockchain.
- oleganza 11y agoI can't help but notice that the only news about Bitcoin that ever enter HN front page are some sort of drama, or "issue with bitcoin". There are a lot of truly great things going on in the space, yet these are carefully kept off the mainstream news outlets and even HN.
- aminorex 11y agoWhich is part of the reason why I think taking the long side in the brewing short squeeze in XMR will be brilliant for me.