19 ms·
Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
- pfg 11y agoTo me the most bizarre part of this story is the argument that this didn't constitute an unlawful search because there is no reasonable expectation of privacy for Tor users: > [...] it is the Court's understanding that in order for a prospective user to use the Tor network they must disclose information, including their IP addresses [...] such a submission is made despite the understanding communicated by the Tor Project that the Tor network has vulnerabilities and that users might not remain anonymous. Under these circumstances Tor users clearly lack a reasonable expectation of privacy [...]
- fixermark 11y agoI believe the argument is more focused than that: there is no expectation that one's IP address is private when the process of connecting to a server involves disclosing the IP address as the respond-to destination. I have a hard time seeing a flaw in that reasoning.
- tux3 11y agoThe whole Internet Protocol is based on sending packets with your public IP, by a stretch of that logic are we supposed to understand that no privacy should be expected on all of the Internet? This argument seems sketchy at best.
- chatmasta 11y agoThat seems like a decent assumption to me. When your IP talks to another on the Internet, you no longer have any control over the metadata of that connection. It will show up in the logs of the other IP, and the owner of that IP is free to do anything with those logs. It seems far more naive to assume there is an expectation of privacy on the Internet.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoSo the government mining of all meta data sent to any third party (including all texts, phone calls, and internet usage) is fine? Also, what about the data itself. You are putting the data on lines you don't own, so that is all fine too, no?
- fixermark 11y agoThat's why you encrypt your data, and assume it is not secure if it is not encrypted. "Here, third party, please have my meaningless binary blob. You may do with it as you wish. Thank you for transiting it across your network in accordance with the TCP/IP protocol."
- Matt3o12_ 11y agoThird party: "You're welcome! Since you seem to be very interested in that specific subject (the destination IP address happens to map to a site specified for that subject), we sold this information to Google and they will now show more ads regarding that subject." No, seriously. I believe it is good practice to encrypt all data over all kind of wires (public or not). However, most of the time, we do not encrypt metadata, which can be just about as useful as the actual data (and way easier to analyze). Do you really think that any government cares much about what you say to a specific person? They only care that you talk to that person, when you talked to that person, and how frequently you talked to that person. The same goes for almost anything. If your ISP were interested in your data, they would actually value metadata a lot more then the actual payload because metadata can be analyzed quite easily and reliably. Tor was (and still is) your only protection against these kinds of attacks because your ISP only knows you're talking to some Tor nodes, the Tor nodes can see very few of the websites you visit (or email recipients you send to) because you will use another nodes for the next website/email, and the website will not know who you are if you don't authenticate because many requests can come from that Tor node.
- fixermark 11y agoSeems like Tor is demonstrably not as good protection as people hope it to be. Hm.
- hellbanner 11y agoYes, but in the case of onion routing, the IP address is masked by layers of the onion. It's understandable that Layer 3 knows Layer 2, that Layer 2 knows Layer 1 and that Layer 1 knows the originator. But Layer 2, 3 and the website should not know Layer 1 by design. Defeating this is akin, IMHO, to circumventing a lock by photographing the key that you don't own.
- pyre 11y agoThat seems like a slightly different legal argument that breach of privacy though.
- fixermark 11y agoNot at the base layer, not at all. That's why commercial traffic is handled by secure encryption, and not an elaborate fabric of internationally-agreed-upon laws that will assign fair and standardized punishments to people for snooping each other's IP packets on an open wifi router without permission of the packet sender.
- sliverstorm 11y agoWell, at least in who you talk to. You can encrypt the content. Perhaps like visiting your cult friend. You have an expectation of privacy for what you say in his house, but the fact that you traveled to his house does not have an expectation of privacy.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhat privacy can you expect? Do a tracert to see the reporting nodes that your packets talk to before getting to their recipient. All of those nodes know about your packets, as do whomever are running them.
- pfg 11y agoWhy do they specifically mention the fact that the Tor Project warns about possible vulnerabilities? There's a reasonable expectation of privacy in a hotel room, for example[1]. To me this argument reads like: "The hotel owner cannot guarantee that a previous patron hasn't left a listening device in your room, so there's no reasonable expectation of privacy." [1]: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1718669 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1718669
- dotnetchris 11y agoYou have a reasonable expectation of privacy inside an abode. If a patron left a recording device, they likely would be in violation of Federal and/or State laws.
- pfg 11y agoThe same could be said for certain vulnerabilities in Tor: Exploiting them could be illegal under the CFAA (unless you're a LEA with a warrant).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jimrandomh 11y agoNo, avoiding the need to disclose one's IP address is the entire point of Tor! Yes, the Tor project does warn about ways in which this could fail. It does this in the tone of a lock-maker warning about power drills.
- ikeboy 11y agoThey're giving over the information to a third party, which usually destroys any 4th amendment rights. The fact that the third party was actually three different parties who only got a piece (or six, when using hidden services) doesn't seem like it would change the law. If I split data into 6 pieces and handed it to 6 different people, the government can take those 6 pieces and put them together without violating my rights. I don't see why Tor would be any different. In fact, this particular vulnerability IIRC involved the researchers acting as both the exit node and the guard node, and finding a way to pass a message between the two so they'd notice when they're in the same circuit. That seems even better legally than my analogy above. They didn't need to take any data, the victims connected to them and gave them the info.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>They're giving over the information to a third party, which usually destroys any 4th amendment rights. Same reason that there is no need for a warrant to collect phone calls since you are handing data over to the phone companies to carry between you and the other party(ies). Also the same reason the government can shift through your mail, since the items are in the possession of a third party (you likely gave the items to the government itself). To me this makes as much sense as the argument that since a plane carrying people can fly over you, it is perfectly reasonable to put a blimp with an extremely high zoom camera on that spies on your home constantly, detecting not just visible light, but also infrared. Also, since when you talk things vibrate, and since it is possible to view those vibrations though a window, I'm actually broadcasting my speech to the public and thus don't have any expectation of privacy.
- ikeboy 11y agoNote that this is only talking constitutionally. The government is free to pass laws that disallow such gathering, or simply not pass laws that allow it. IIRC collecting mail is not in fact legal without a warrant, and only photographing the outside (which anyone who handles it can see) is allowed. I do think the fact that any member of the public can collect data legally means the government should be able to as well.
- 11y ago
- samstave 11y agoCan someone tell me where to have a reasonable expectation of privacy?
- DanBC 11y agoWhen you speak to a doctor; when you speak to a lawyer that you're paying for.
- dotnetchris 11y agoAdd Priest
- justinjlynn 11y agoOnly if you're a lawyer... and you're their lawyer... and you're talking about their legal matters.
- bediger4000 11y agoSpeaking to a medical doctor isn't necessarily confidential. I believe there are some categories of things that doctors must report to authorities, and that varies from US state to state. Wikipedia says: "In the United States, the Federal Rules of Evidence do not recognize doctor–patient privilege."
- PascalsMugger 11y agoBut not if you're speaking to them over the Internet.
- fixermark 11y agoRight. If you're doing that, I'd recommend making sure that the tools you're using to communicate with them can encrypt your messages and their messages using some protocol that only the intended recipient can reverse. Public-private key encryption seems to generally be a good approach. Look for the "padlock" icon in your browser before talking to your doctor about Viagra. ;)
- rayiner 11y agoYou're cutting out the most important parts: > The Court agrees with the government that applicable Ninth Circuit authority precludes the defendant’s success on his motion. SEI’s identification of the defendant’s IP address because of his use of the Tor network did not constitute a search subject to Fourth Amendment scrutiny. The Court reaches this conclusion primarily upon reliance on United States v. Forrester, 512 F.2d 500 (9th Cir. 2007). In Forrester, the court clearly enunciated that: “Internet users have no expectation of privacy in ...the IP address of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information.” Id. at 510. > In the instant case, it is the Court’s understanding that in order for a prospective user to use the Tor network they must disclose information, including their IP addresses, to unknown individuals running Tor nodes, so that their communications can be directed toward their destinations. Under such a system, an individual would necessarily be disclosing his identifying information to complete strangers. Again, according to the parties’ submissions, such a submission is made despite the understanding communicated by the Tor Project that the Tor network has vulnerabilities and that users might not remain anonymous. Under these circumstances Tor users clearly lack a reasonable expectation of privacy in their IP addresses while using the Tor network. In other words, they are taking a significant gamble on any real expectation of privacy under these circumstances. > [...] > The evidence before this Court indicates that SEI obtained the defendant’s IP address while he was using the Tor network and SEI was operating nodes on that network, and not by any access to his computer. SEI got the IP addresses because the Defendant's computer communicated that information to SEI. You can imagine that the briefing went something like this: Government: there is no expectation of privacy because connecting to Tor involves giving out your IP address to random people on the Internet. Defendant: but the purpose of Tor is to hide your IP address from anyone that might matter. Government: well obviously that didn't work because we figured out his IP address. The point of vulnerabilities isn't the basis for the Court's opinion--it's just a rebuttal to the idea that Tor is supposed to keep your IP address secret even though it necessarily involves giving it to at least some untrusted nodes.
- ikeboy 11y agoHuh. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/12/what-you-need-to-know-about-the-third-party-doctrine/282721/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/12/what-y... says >Importantly, my defense of the third-party doctrine implies an important limit: The doctrine should apply when the third party is a recipient of information, but it should not apply when the third party is merely a conduit for information intended for someone else. Sourced from http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/the_data_question_should_the_third-party_records_doctrine_be_revisited/ http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/the_data_question... The linked argument (which is one half of a debate), argues that the third party doctrine should apply to things that you wouldn't be able to hide without third parties. So metadata is covered, because you can't hide who you communicate with, but content is not. The data collected here is metadata (who connected to the site), so it seems they would consider it collectable legally.
- sathackr 11y agoIP addresses are routinely subpoenaed. Ask the operator of any popular file sharing site how many subpoenas they get from copyright lawyers. Some large ISPs have entire departments dedicated to servicing subpoenas from law enforcement. Just because you used Tor doesn't make your IP address invulnerable to subpoena. If I connect through 7 proxies and do something illegal, my IP is no less subject to subpoena than if I weren't to use a proxy at all. If I stand in my front yard, in view of my neighbors, put on a mask, then I go rob a store, wearing that same mask, I don't have a reasonable expectation of privacy as to my identity while wearing the mask. This case is far less controversial than the recent one where the FBI hacked all the pervert's computers. It may be an issue of ethics at CMU, but, not an issue with 4th/5th amendments.
- mSparks 11y agoDo US courts still consider an ip address as personal information?
- jackgavigan 11y ago> Jones claimed that IP addresses, and even those of Tor users, are public, and that Tor users lack a reasonable expectation of privacy. This is an interesting judgment. Tor's purpose is to provide privacy. The fact that it may have vulnerabilities (as all software does) doesn't mean that a person using Tor doesn't expect that it will provide them with privacy.
- forgotpwtomain 11y agoYes, it seems like a rather naive construction. Analogously your email server might have vulnerabilities, therefore you have no reasonable expectation of privacy for any emails you have stored there.
- DSMan195276 11y agoI think you're conflating two different points. Just because providing privacy is Tor's intended purpose doesn't mean it's reasonable to assume it provides privacy in the 4th amendment sense, when it still involves sending your data to Tor nodes. The argument is that public IP's are inherently not private because you have to give that information up to a separate entity to make any sort of communication. I'd wager that's the "vulnerability" they're referencing - That you don't know who is running the Tor nodes, and by extension can't assume your IP will stay private if you're freely giving away your IP address to them. By voluntarily giving that information up, there is no reason to expect that the Tor server you're connecting too will keep that information private anymore then a Facebook server would, even if we would like/hope that to be the case. The person who owns the Tor server is well within their rights to keep a log of every IP connected to their server. You also have no control over the node which makes the actual connection to the outside world - In which case that server can equally log anything it wants about that connection. If the same person controls both servers and puts two-and-two together and figures out you made a connection to website X, they haven't violated your 4th amendment rights because you voluntarily gave that information up by connecting to the Tor network without checking who you were giving that information too. Tor's intended goal is to provide privacy, but that doesn't mean it gives you a legal expectation to privacy, which I think is what they're getting at. The reality is that third-party entities that can do whatever they want with the data you voluntarily give them - The fact that they're Tor nodes doesn't change this.
- wsothr 11y agoSo the information was obtained by subpoena from a university research program that is federally funded. Thinking back to the HeartBleed incident, does this set a precedent for the government to subpoena information related to private keys that may have been exposed due to a software vulnerability and recorded as part of a federally funded university security research lab investigation into said vulnerability? Given that HeartBleed was so public, the likelihood of private keys and certificates not being revoked is pretty low. But what about the next major software vulnerability that doesn't have the same publicity? Or extrapolating even further, what about DNA that may be collected and kept by entities receiving federal funding. Say healthcare funding? Does that entitle the government to access?
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agoFrom Tor's front page: What is Tor? Tor is free software and an open network that helps you defend against traffic analysis, a form of network surveillance that threatens personal freedom and privacy, confidential business activities and relationships, and state security. So, if the users of a service whose explicit mission statement is to provide anonymity and privacy apparently do not have "reasonable expectation of privacy," who does? Are they going to argue next that the private owner of a wifi-capable laptop has no expectation of privacy in their own home because the webcam could be conceivably hacked and remotely activated?
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoSince they didn't verify all code on the laptop, and since the EULA said that they don't actually own the code, only rights to use the code, then there is no reasonable expectation of privacy using the laptop.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoSo anyone using a computer with any proprietary software on it has no expectation of privacy?
- stsp 11y agoThere is no clear line where total privacy starts and ends with technology currently available on the consumer market. Even if you don't use any proprietary software at all (which is very difficult to do for most people), your privacy could, in principle, still be compromised by the underlying hardware.
- michael_storm 11y agoThere's no absolute expectation of privacy on the laptop. There's definitely a reasonable one, unless someone wants to argue that a layman independently verifying every bit of code and every silicon gate in it is "reasonable". Is there a reasonable expectation that my new car won't explode when I turn the ignition, if I haven't stripped and rebuilt it to verify every part?
- maesho 11y agoWas the vulnerability made public? Was it patched?
- pfg 11y agoIt's covered in this blog post[1]. Some mitigations are in place now. [1]: https://blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-security-advisory-relay-early-traffic-confirmation-attack/ https://blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-security-advisory-relay...
- x5n1 11y agoFunny to see people arguing about archaic laws passed by people in the 1700s. As if the people in the 1700s knew anything about the world in which we live, or could possibly have any foresight about what is good and what is not good. It's similar to religious laws where people argue about what some Prophet said as applying for all time. We can see the flaw in that, we can't see that we do the exact same thing with a country's Constitution. As if the Constitution is some holy document passed by God himself that is right and on the basis of which, I guess God, we can challenge the government which has real power. That's the way I see religion in general, of the little man with no power creating an imaginary God, a LORD of the universe, with which they can challenge people that have real power and make them behave. Guess what people with real power don't care about your imagination.
- ikeboy 11y agoSee http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm
- bcook 11y agoYou are right. Intelligent minds have only existed for a few dozen years. Nothing can be learned from the thinkers of the distant past (anything beyond 31 years, in my very personal experience). /s No offense, but your ideas deserve criticism, if not only for the overtones of hate on religion & God. (I say this as a Christian athiest.)
- user_0001 11y ago>if not only for the overtones of hate on religion & God. (I say this as a Christian athiest.) and? Why should they have special protection over things? Why cannot some other made up, modified over the years stories be held in such high regard?
- bcook 11y agoHate is retarded. Reason is golden. I was critcizing the hatred. The object of the hate is unimportant. Drop the emotion and share the logic. The OP's entire rant was an unfounded strawman attack on religion.
- _archon_ 11y agoWhy isn't the first line of the Tor EULA or info page (and I wondered the same about Lavabit email) "This software/service is intended to provide its users a reasonable expectation of privacy under US and international law." Or some such. It's unreasonable to expect every user of a tech service to understand how it all works so they can know their level of legal protection. Phone taps require a warrant even if the phone user doesn't know how switching or tapping works. What's wrong with this idea?
- wlesieutre 11y ago(Not a lawyer but) I don't think it legally holds any water, once your data is out on the public network it's out on the public network. It's the electronic equivalent of a sticker on your car that says "This car is intended to provide its users a reasonable expectation of privacy under US and international law."
- ViViDboarder 11y agoWhen I make a phone call it routes through a public network. Tapping a phone is illegal due to my expectation that the call is private. I dunno. I've seen some good arguments either way here, and I'm also not a lawyer.
- fixermark 11y agoI wonder if that would impose liability on the tor project itself or tor node runners. If it did, you can substitute out this SEI story with the CIA just secretly directing multiple tor node owners to run special versions of their software without notifying users.
- twblalock 11y agoI could put a sign on my living room wall that says "Anyone who sees this sign owes me $100." Do you think that would hold up in court? Of course it wouldn't. Asserting something does not make it true. Your example is as trivial as mine, from a legal point of view -- you can't create constitutional rights that don't exist simply by asserting them. The courts decide where people have an expectation of privacy; you can't just create that expectation by writing it down.
- pasbesoin 11y agoIf you don't own the physical layer, sooner or later you're screwed. (My comment is not meant to reflect on the merits or dismerits of the particular use in question. It's a general statement.)
- chinathrow 11y agoIf you work in research like that - how can you sleep at night? This is a real question - I haven't been able to ask someone directly involved in unmasking users like that.
- nhf 11y agoFrom the perspective of a current CMU student: the Software Engineering Institute (SEI) here is the responsible party here. Note that they are separate from the main ("academic") school of CS. They are a federally-funded research and development center, essentially a computing-focused contractor and consultant for the DoD (see more here: http://www.sei.cmu.edu/about/organization/workingwithanFFRDC.cfm http://www.sei.cmu.edu/about/organization/workingwithanFFRDC...). So, in short, the people at the SEI sleep as well as the people at Raytheon or Lockheed Martin that build the drones, or the folks at Alcatel-Lucent who helped the NSA way back, or maybe even the guys way back at Los Alamos. It's not like some grad students or CS professor got strong-armed into doing this. It's literally their job to do this kind of work for the DoD and other government offices. While the ethics of this line of work are certainly up for debate, they knew exactly what they were getting into.
- thrillgore 11y agoThe subject of ethics in computer science is mostly unstudied, and broadly ignored. When I studied it, it basically boiled down to the arguments about patents. We never discussed IBM's involvement with the Gestapo, or the Apartheid South Africa Government.
- majke 11y agoI must admit the description is pretty opaque for me. Can someone translate this to simple english? What "subpoena" is in this context? What most likely actually happened?
- smokeyj 11y agoI'm less interested in the courts interpretation of reasonable than why my personal liberty depends on such a subjective term. If the bill of rights is entirely subjective, it might as well say "We the people have rights.. and stuff. Y'know man?". Note to the next framers of a constitutional republic. Include some notion of objective unit and functional tests.
- Laaw 11y agoYou don't "have" any personal liberties. You are not born with rights, you are gifted them by a benevolent society. That society can easily lose its benevolence, and take your rights away, and there is absolutely nothing you'd be able to do about it. You might hold a differing view, but the fact is, reality works as I've described. Delude yourself all you want, but your rights do hinge on the imperfect and subjective manner in which your benevolent rulers have granted them to you. They have not granted you absolute rights, specifically laid out, but they have done better than, "rights.. and stuff."
- diskcat 11y ago>You are not born with rights This argument is really semantic. The line always devolve to the tautological "the only rules of the universe are physical rules"
- sitkack 11y agoDon't forget Bitcoin. If didn't happen on the block chain it didn't happen.
- Laaw 11y agoThat's not tautological at all. Also, it's not really true. There are plenty of rules. What I'm saying is the only "unalienable" rules are the laws of the physical universe. Every other rule is a construct of society and people, and as such, is not guaranteed in the way as stated by the previous commenter. It's just something I believe is worth keeping in mind when talking about your "right to privacy", specifically. There are many prominent public figures who actually don't believe you have that right at all, and when we remember that rights (as we're referring to them) are granted only by the grace of the state, if the members of the state don't believe you have a right, then you simply don't. The argument here should be more about whether or not it's in the state's best interest to grant the right to privacy to its citizens, and I think there's a pretty strong argument in favor of that, but simply stating "I have a right!" doesn't illuminate that argument very much.
- ianremsen 11y agoOne minor thing: consider showing motherboard.vice.com as a separate domain?