16 ms·
What Google Cloud needs is a better sales story. AWS consistently beats out Google in this respect. This story is welcomed and there should be more success stor
by latchkey 11y ago
What Google Cloud needs is a better sales story. AWS consistently beats out Google in this respect. This story is welcomed and there should be more success stories published like this.
My business is a heavy GC user (AppEngine, Datastore, CloudStorage, BQ, ComputeEngine, ManagedVM) and I couldn't imagine achieving what we have achieved in such a short amount of time on any other platform.
We (myself and another guy) started at zero and shipped our product in 3 months on what is effectively an infinitely auto-scalable platform where we don't have to do any devops or carry a pager. I'd much rather work on features than chores. =) 4 months later and we've had profitable growth and zero downtime (knock on wood) and we're hiring.
Thanks Google!
- tn13 11y agoOne of the reasons I avoid Google is because they have taken lot of pain to make their customer care totally suck. I mean even IRS and Comcast support does better compared to Google. I published a very critical release to my Android app few weeks back and realized that it was not getting published at all. It took me a month to get the problem resolved. I don't want to buy a cloud service where the support might be nothing more than bunch of "Help yourself" pages.
- latchkey 11y agoThey have a paid support service that is actually pretty good. It sounds like you're avoiding the generic Google in the same way you'd not buy something from Amazon vs. using AWS.
- tn13 11y agoAs I said Google's reputation is what made me not even bother to try. We all know that AWS and AZURE both are state of art and very competitively priced. If Google wants to beat them they have to win the perception war too. (OR reduce prices substantially).
- boulos 11y agoI don't agree that AWS and Azure are actually competitively priced with Compute Engine anymore. Following our price cut last May and our custom VM shapes, we're often 40% cheaper: http://googlecloudplatform.blogspot.com/2016/01/Happy-New-Year-from-Google-Cloud-Platform-still-the-price-performance-leader-in-public-cloudom-google-cloud.html http://googlecloudplatform.blogspot.com/2016/01/Happy-New-Ye... that's a massive lead (and it's sadly not commonly known). So I agree with you, we need to do better in the perception war, but Compute Engine is hands down the leader in cloud pricing. Disclosure: I work on Compute Engine (and care a lot about our prices).
- boundlessdreamz 11y agoGCE pricing is great but GCS is not. It is much more expensive than S3 or cloudfront (2.5x - 1.3x) when you consider per request costs. I have brought this up a couple of times on HN to Google cloud employees but nothing has changed. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10442654 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10442654 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10187600 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10187600 Other problem areas for GCS compared to S3/Cloudfront 1. SSL support for custom domains in GCS is lacking. 2. Also SSL does not work for domain-named bucket when using <bucket>.storage.googleapis.com/<object> form. You can only use https://storage.googleapis.com/<bucket>/ https://storage.googleapis.com/<bucket>/ This makes using SSL for a static site hosted in SSL very difficult because you can't use relative URLs. Cloudfront has solved it by using URLs of the form http(s)://xxxxxxx.cloudfront.net/<object>
- boulos 11y agoThat's fair, our native egress pricing is higher. We've chosen to partner with folks like CloudFlare for what we call CDN Interconnect (https://cloud.google.com/interconnect/cdn-interconnect https://cloud.google.com/interconnect/cdn-interconnect) although this was a somewhat recent announcement. As far as GCS pricing goes (rather than egress), I think we've been more cautious on the "cost per op" but really led again on cost per byte. This was especially true when we launched Nearline, triggering AWS to launch S3-IA (but with lots of caveats like small files and still a 25% higher base rate). While not integrated directly into GCS / GCP, does going through CloudFlare alleviate some of your concern?
- boulos 11y agoWe offer paid support for Cloud (http://cloud.google.com/support http://cloud.google.com/support) that let you trade off responsive time (e.g., 4 hours vs 1) for price. The support personnel (and engineering!) also do best effort scanning of Stack Overflow, Server Fault, and per-product mailing lists. You can get links to those here: https://cloud.google.com/support/#community https://cloud.google.com/support/#community. Disclaimer: I work on Compute Engine, but not in Support (though I do jump in and support customers!)
- voltagex_ 11y agoWhat kind of support am I going to get if I'm just tinkering with the platform? Maybe I'm just used to AWS but I always found the GCE interface (at least for launching VMs) a lot more difficult to use.
- boulos 11y agoSorry to hear that. Is there something specific about our current console you find hard to use? Perhaps I'm used to both (and I'm biased) but I like our create instance page just fine. Like I mentioned above, we do have active communities on Stack Overflow, per-product mailing lists (in this case https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/gce-discussion https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/gce-discussion) and Server Fault.
- voltagex_ 11y agoI'll have to try again. The last time I tried to use GCE I had to create some kind of linked project before I could even start to create a VM.
- seanp2k2 11y agoDid not know about this. To me, Google has a terrible reputation when it comes to support and keeping products with large numbers of users running. Edit: (posted too soon) my main concerns with putting anything on GC are around support, continued support / long-term commitment to the platform, ease of switching (App Engine was a very bad on boarding experience for me when I tried it a few years ago and required lots of GCE-specific ways of doing things in the code), and pricing differences that might make it cost way more in subtle ways to run a thing on GC. I think it'd be good for Google to start fixing their story around support and commitment to products with everything else under the Google brand before people will be wanting to risk their infrastructure with that brand.
- nrh 11y agoSpotifier here. One of the big risks that we identified with the Google partnership was exactly this: Google isn't exactly known for awesome customer service. We've been very pleasantly surprised. The cloud team has been pretty awesome to work with, including lots of engineer<->engineer contact, walk-throughs of systems and code for critical dependencies, and solid support and collaboration. Exceeded our expectations.
- tn13 11y agoI am not surprised. Spotify is a big company. The question is will it work exactly same for Joe's Inc.
- stegro32 11y agoWe are much smaller, but also use the Google paid support. I'd echo the sentiment here: my experience of the paid support for GCP has been universally excellent across Compute Engine, App Engine, BigQuery and Cloud Storage. This is across 30ish tickets, some of them quite complex.
- nulltype 11y agoI use the lowest level of paid support, I think it is the silver plan, and have observed similarly high quality levels of support. Sometimes you get a lower level support dude and have to convince him that your issue is real, but overall the support is good.
- marincounty 11y agoI've had problems with their customer support. It got to the point, I just gave up, and left my videos on YouTube. (My problem was that slick move they made when they bought YouTube, and messed with the login names.) I just try to forget they are up there. I got to one person at Google, and when they realized I didn't want to advertise, it was "Go to the help boards. I don't deal with that stuff." Do I still use their products--yes, but don't trust them like I used to. I usually avoid customer service like the flu virus, but thought Google would be different? I guess they are big enough to not care?
- asuffield 11y ago(Tedious disclaimer: my opinions only, not representing anybody else or my employer. I work at Google, not on YouTube) There is a big difference between paying for one of the support offerings, versus being a free user. The status of free users is approximately: free access to the product but no support. If you want customer service then you need to open your wallet. It's important to separate "I think the support was bad", which would be very interesting to a lot of people who work here, from "I didn't pay for the product so I didn't receive it". Did you pay for support?
- melted 11y agoYou seem to have forgotten to plug your product.
- latchkey 11y agoI'm sure you can figure it out. =)
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoI think he was ironic?
- is_this_tinder 11y agoIt's IBM.
- liveoneggs 11y ago> infinitely auto-scalable platform where we don't have to do any devops or carry a pager You never know what you don't measure and test
- latchkey 11y agoAre you implying that we don't measure and test? We do and I'm very happy with the results. =) StackDriver, Google Cloud console, Intercom, Mixpanel and Pingdom are all being used as well.
- liveoneggs 11y agoIf that's the case then you might actually be "doing devops". If pingdom is notifying you via sms then you may also be carrying a pager.
- latchkey 11y agoTouché -- That said, we don't have pinggom tied to SMS, just email. =) Pingom is just an external tool for us to graph uptime from other parts of the world. If we're down there is plenty of other alerting to notify us (mostly through Slack). That said, there isn't much we can do other than wait for Google to fix it. It is part of the trade off that we have to consider, I'm paying Google for devops instead of paying a team to do it for me. If you've ever had to hire a 24/7 support/devops staff, it is a much easier hiring proposition to just rely on Google to do that for us.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> That said, there isn't much we can do other than wait for Google to fix it. IE. "Cloud ops"
- justinjlynn 11y agoIndeed, I do wish we'd stop with all of the verbal gymnastics and just say we're doing ops correctly. "We don't do ops" usually means "We don't find ops to be troublesome because we do it correctly". No group of people needs dedicated janitorial staff if everyone picks up and dusts occasionally. Of course, you know what this implies.
- obulpathi 11y agoTrue, while other providers focus on DevOps, Google Cloud strives for NoOps. They should do more marketing on that.
- latchkey 11y agoOur company motto is that we will strive to never hire a devops role and will work to design and engineer our platform in a way that backs up that claim.
- thepumpkin1979 11y agoYou also forgot to include a link to your hiring page in your website, too bad you're not hiring remotely https://angel.co/gearlaunch/jobs https://angel.co/gearlaunch/jobs
- latchkey 11y agoI want to see your lovely face in the office every day. =)
- S4M 11y agoMan, you should consider remote options at least for the Customer Success given how low you're paying (is $50K really livable in San Francisco?).
- seanp2k2 11y agoDepends on your standard of living. A studio apartment there goes for around $2500/month these days with no parking or utilities. Agreed that remote would be a nice option.
- ska 11y agoPaying $2500/mo for rent alone on a $50k salary is crazy.
- bskinny129 11y agoThat's why no one does it. They have roommates
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- shoyer 11y agoand/or they live in the East Bay, where rent is still much more affordable.
- thibaut_barrere 11y agoI've been relying on multiple Cloud offerings (including PaaS, IaaS etc) outside Google for many years, but for some unclear reason, I cannot manage to consider Google a reliable partner for a type of hosting or another, at this point. I would love to be proven wrong really, because I often look at their GC offering, and I /really/ want to dive in, yet I feel that I would risk having to migrate quickly in 2 weeks at some point because they are changing things significantly (either shutting down or other major change). So to my question: for how long have these services been around in a fashion that is stable (feature-wise, quality-wise etc)? Is there anyone here with a longer history of using Google Cloud offering, able to comment on this? EDIT: thanks to everyone who replied below. I think I'll give it a try :-)
- latchkey 11y agoI should add, I've been on top of AppEngine for about 4 years now. This is my second business on it.
- nanoojaboo 11y agobut what's your businesss (that you're hiring for)
- obulpathi 11y agoI have been running my website on AppEngine for 6+ years now. No problems at all.
- arouzrokh 11y agoThank you obulpathi and glad to hear this. Can you also take a look at our new docs here: cloud.google.com/appengine/docs/ and let me know what you think? This is an iterative effort of course, so more changes to come. Thanks again!
- boulos 11y agoFor Google Cloud products that have made it to General Availability (GA), we have a one-year deprecation policy (https://cloud.google.com/terms/ https://cloud.google.com/terms/, Section 7.2). That is, if we're going to make some big change, we give you a 1 year heads up. Disclaimer: I work on Compute Engine, but I'm not a lawyer ;).
- simonebrunozzi 11y agoYou could have done the same on AWS (source: I have worked at AWS for 6 years, and know GCP very well)
- vgt 11y agoThat is true. And, as Spotify found out, what Spotify does can also happen in its own Data Centers :) Google does give an additional level of comfort - seamless scaling, No-Ops, powerful Big Data tools, flexibility. I'm going to shamelessly promote one of my opinions on this topic when it comes to BigQuery: https://cloud.google.com/blog/big-data/2016/02/visualizing-the-mechanics-of-on-demand-pricing-in-big-data-technologies https://cloud.google.com/blog/big-data/2016/02/visualizing-t...
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Google does give an additional level of comfort - seamless scaling, No-Ops, powerful Big Data tools, flexibility. I'm going to bookmark this comment and come back to it when Google decides its getting out of the "cloud" compute business.
- kodisha 11y agoHmm, sounds interesting. Why do you think they will do so?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoIts not their core business. Google constantly exits businesses unless they explode in profitability. As someone who currently uses AWS, it would take an act of god for me to move over to Google Cloud, even if the tools were better and even with the cost of some services (nearline storage) cheaper than AWS. I'm not just paying for a service. I'm paying because I know AWS is in it for the long haul. This is great for Spotify, just as AWS was great for Netflix (considering both services are terrible at representing true workloads; they're both just control planes serving static content, videos or music). I don't see it dragging a ton of business into Google, just making their acquisitions easier for people who decide to start on GCP or migrate in. Just my two cents.
- Hermel 11y agoAre you happy with the performance of AppEngine? I have tried it last summer and was quite disappointed. CPU-bound programs that completed in a few seconds on my own computer took about ten times as long on AppEngine despite similar nominal specs (GHz and RAM).
- obulpathi 11y agoApp Engine expects your web apps to return almost immediately (in a matter of few ms). For anything that takes longer, you need to use task queues in App Engine. Or maybe try AppEngine Managed VM's?
- oaktowner 11y agoApp Engine requests time out after 60 seconds (that's 60000 ms). https://cloud.google.com/appengine/articles/deadlineexceedederrors https://cloud.google.com/appengine/articles/deadlineexceeded... (I work at Google, but not on App Engine)
- colonelxc 11y agoThey don't have to if you use Basic or Manual Scaling (Then they can run up to 24 hours). https://cloud.google.com/appengine/docs/java/modules/#Java_Instance_scaling_and_class https://cloud.google.com/appengine/docs/java/modules/#Java_I... If you run multiple modules at once (some serving the frontend, some for longer tasks w/task queues), you can have the best of both worlds and use different scaling options for each. (I also work at Google, but also not on App Engine)
- boulos 11y agoIf you like the App Engine model, but want a "full computer worth of horsepower", you might want to consider our "Managed VM" environment built on top of Compute Engine: https://cloud.google.com/appengine/docs/managed-vms/ https://cloud.google.com/appengine/docs/managed-vms/ Disclaimer: I work on Compute Engine.
- 11y ago
- dheera 11y agoThe main reason I tend to shy away from GC is that it's blocked in China. AWS isn't (which also means Heroku isn't blocked since Heroku runs on AWS, so I use AWS for IaaS and Heroku for PaaS). If you plan to offer multi-lingual content, anticipate having viewers in that part of the world, and your content isn't something they would be interested in blocking, it's just a practicality worth factoring in. Another reason is that I find the GC console a mess. I had to simultaneously use two versions of the console to get different tasks done; they didn't have one console that had all features of the system. Heroku was a lot cleaner and easier to navigate in this respect.
- devy 11y agoOn the contrary, GC is NOT entire blocked in China. Some of the Google services (including GC console / dashboard) are indeed blocked but GC's IP address pool and the applications running on GC does seem to be accessible in China. My company is running mostly on Google Cloud and I had just returned from a trip in China where I've verified it.
- verst 11y agoIn my experience (3 months in Shanghai at the end of last year) AWS does occasionally get blocked or severely slowed down in China. I'd say it was inaccessible about 5% of the time (for significant periods of time). You can of course run in the AWS Beijing region which requires you to have a Chinese business presence with a ICP license. It'll be interesting to see what happens now that Google is expanding its presence in China [1]. I ran into some Googlers on the Maps team while in Shanghai - not likely a coincidence. [1]: http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34698642 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34698642
- boulos 11y agoThe old App Engine / API / Admin console era is over. All tasks have been migrated to https://console.cloud.google.com/ https://console.cloud.google.com/ including some of the last App Engine specific administration things.
- lobster_johnson 11y ago
- samstave 11y agoI'm on mobile so this initial response will be short: AWS' core product is AWS. They do a damn fine job of providing this. GC's core is "who knows what" - they do a damn poor job of even making an offering if switch thousands and thousands of servers to - let alone thousands and thousands of man hours. Ironically, Google has massive domain knowledge of how to run infra... Yet clueless how to adopt and support and foster companies other than google. It sucks. But I've been in the business of fork lifting many people to aws, for all the reasons you'd expect: Find me a single ops eng on the market who has done scale in GC? Nope. EDIT: may I please have a rebuttal?
- foxylad 11y ago> Find me a single ops eng on the market who has done scale in GC? Every user of appengine, for a start. You need to code to their datastore, but apart from that scaling is practically infinite - and completely invisible. We don't need to configure, provision or even * understand * load balancers or geographically redundant servers. Concrete examples? The royal wedding website was served from appengine a few years back; I imagine you'd be impressed with how that scaled from nothing to phenomenal traffic loads and back again. And Khan Academy, Snapchat, and now Spotify ought to meet your definition of "done scale".
- samstave 11y agoWonderful response!!! Thank you, I'm not trying to be obtuse, I do want to understand who is doing what and where. I also want to understand the cost doffs as a Well.
- vgt 11y agoI hope that you see the irony of your argument in this thread :)
- samstave 11y agoHonest request:! Please enlighten me..
- abrookewood 11y agoWhat's your product by the way?
- slantview 11y agoAccording to his github it's https://www.gearlaunch.com/ https://www.gearlaunch.com/
- latchkey 11y agoWhich still isn't very descriptive, sorry. We are working on a website. Angel might be a bit more of a description. https://angel.co/gearlaunch https://angel.co/gearlaunch Anything more, feel free to contact me privately. =) We are not stealth, but we also aren't the type of company that goes around pushing ourselves down people's throats. The people who are primarily interested in our product know about us through other channels. That said, we are building the website out more really more from a hiring perspective. It is hard to hire people when all they get is a logo on a homepage. For now, just know that we are a startup that is actually profitable, building a great product that people want and we're growing like mad.
- nickbauman 11y agoMy experience with upper management is that Google isn't "serious" about their cloud offerings based on how much of Amazon's profit margin is tied up in AWS. It's an enragingly pointyhaired sentiment to deal with.
- boulos 11y agoWho's upper management? As I mentioned in another thread, we acquired Diane Greene's company so that she would run Cloud and Apps at Google, back in November: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/20/technology/google-picks-diane-greene-to-expand-its-cloud-business.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/20/technology/google-picks-di... and Sundar (CEO) and Ruth (CFO) mentioned Cloud a lot on Alphabet's most recent earnings call. I'm not disagreeing that AWS is massively important to Amazon, but to say that Google (and Alphabet) aren't serious about Cloud is incorrect.
- nickbauman 11y agoMy clients' upper management. It's a common sentiment as you can see from other threads in this post. Google has a persistent credibility problem in the cloud services market. It drives me crazy (full disc: I'm a GCP certified engineer and I work 100% in AWS. I really miss AppEngine, BigQuery and Datastore.)
- chm 11y agoI assume your business is GearLaunch? If so, why do I need to enable javascript just to see the landing page, which is just a logo...? I'm curious if this was intended, or a consequence of the framework you're using (e.g. Meteor). Edit: It seems to be on purpose, with the use of noscript tags.
- latchkey 11y agoIt is 2016 and ok to run JavaScript, the Internet works much better with it. I promise not to hack your flip phone. =)
- chm 11y agoI run three browsers with varying levels of "openness". It just happened that I visited your website while using NoScript. Turned it off for your site, but I was only greeted by a logo. So my interest was genuine - not trying to be snarky. Why do you force JS to show a logo? And I also don't really know what your company does...
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoIt's 2016 and Hacker News, this very site, works fine w/o JS (except for search). That's how I'm using it right now. That's how I've always used it. I can access most of the sites I routinely visit without JS. E.g. The New York Times works better w/o JS because it doesn't block articles or count how many I've read. And I don't really care if you you will or will not try to hack me if I visit your site with JS on. There are countless other sites who will try exactly that, so why shouldn't my default be "NO"? And if it's not the sites themselves, it's the shitty ad networks they all use; I don't trust those at all. IMO it's the epitome of hipster arrogance to display nothing useful to people w/o JS.
- latchkey 11y ago"hipster arrogance." Ha. I'm 42, got my first email address in 1991 and hardly a hipster. I own a fixie because I used to race on velodromes. What is the word for people who use the internet in some purposely crippled fashion, just so that they can complain about things not working for them? =)
- sumedh 11y agoYour website is just a logo and nothing else, how exactly are you growing. What is your business model?
- Axsuul 11y agoGearLaunch provides merchants with software that allows them to build and run online storefronts, and also manages production, logistics and customer service for all products sold. GearLaunch is the only e-commerce software provider to cover the entire value chain, enabling marketers to focus on marketing. https://angel.co/gearlaunch https://angel.co/gearlaunch
- BogusIKnow 11y agoAWS has Werner Vogels who is not a CTO but a tech salesman on every conference.
- Mayzie 11y agoThe only thing that is stopping us from having Google Cloud is lack of an Australian data centre. I'd love to be on Google Cloud, but requirements prevent us from doing so unfortunately :-/
- boulos 11y agoLegal requirements? Internal company ones? Latency? ;)
- benjaminRRR 11y agoLatency is a huge one for AU. With AWS in SYD you can easily cover BNE, SYD, MEL and even AKL. The difference from SIN or TPE is very noticeable. SYD to PER and SIN to PER is negligible.
- Facens 11y ago"profitable growth"? :puzzled:
- DominikR 11y agoWould you mind sharing with us what product you have shipped? I just like to see what other people can achieve in 3 months of time, it's kind of a motivation for me :)
- udkl 11y agoBetter sales story AND marketing. Look at the names themselves CloudStorage Vs Redshift/s3, ComputeEngine Vs EC2. Cookies vs. Oreo. AWS service names are a brand in themselves while Google service names are too generic.
- boulos 11y agoWe internally use our three letter acronyms all the time: GCS, GCE, GAE, GKE (which itself is a pretty clever joke about the K being for Kubernetes).