11 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg Backs Apple in Its Refusal to Unlock iPhone
- pcurve 11y agoThis is an interesting tug of war. Considering 50% of Americans are taking the opposite stance, the SV elites are in the minority. (35%) Yet no pro-government business executive has emerged. I guess it's a risky position to take. I have a feeling the government will eventually figure out a way to get its way without our realizing.
- Consultant32452 11y agoI would be absolutely shocked if the government didn't have numerous ways to get into any information on any commercial phone. What they don't have is a simple device that average joe agent has access to at the local office, and of course his civilian police force compatriot.
- newjersey 11y agoJust a suspicion but I imagine the narrative that FBI, DEA, ATF, IRS or any federal agency is frustrated that the NSA won't share its toys with them has some truth to it. Of course, it makes sense. Complying to very single request would leave NSA as mere peons.
- Consultant32452 11y agoIt was just a couple years ago that the FBI was lamenting the fact that it was having trouble hiring hackers because they all smoke pot. I only cite that as it asserts that the FBI does in fact employ teams of digital hackers. The NSA surely has better/more, but if the FBI needs into an iPhone I'm sure they could do it on their own.
- newjersey 11y agoI don't know anything about the FBI or the NSA but I doubt the FBI would have remotely the same budget for zero day bugs. (:
- uptown 11y agoI consider the "50% of Americans" stat to be useless. This is a complicated topic for technologists to grasp. To expect the general public to understand the implications of what they're being asked in order to provide an informed answer is a stretch.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoespecially when the answer is loaded (the think of the terrorist/children/drugs trick)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 11y agoIt is a complicated topic but we can't just ignore general public that takes on position without realizing its implications. For decades, general public had opposed marijuana, even when half of them have used them before.
- karmelapple 11y agoCorrect. The court of public opinion may not sway technologists, but it will determine what law makers feel the need to propose, based on their constituents demands. We have to make it very easy for the general public to understand what's going on at an incredibly simple, "oh I get it" gut level. Simple words communicated simply will go a long ways to showing the importance of keeping good security practices in place in our tech.
- zajd 11y agoDo you really think that constituent demands are what drives law creation?
- lazaroclapp 11y agoTo a degree, yes. But even if you take a more pessimistic stance and assume that lawmakers have an agenda that is entirely divorced from that of their constituents, they still need to manufacture consent[1]. Which means that if you get enough voters to be strongly opposed to something, it does have an effect beyond what a small group of highly informed critics can have. The political system is neither perfect, nor useless, is somewhere in between, and I say so as someone who comes from a country with political process that leans way more towards 'broken' than the U.S. one does. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- zepto 11y ago50% of Americans can only take the opposite stance if they know what stance they are taking. The reporting on the poll doesn't reveal any screening questions to determine whether the respondents understand the issues at stake. If they don't understand the issue, then the 50% is answering a question about something else. If they asked the question "Should Apple make it easier for terrorists and foreign hackers to access information on American phones", I suspect less than 50% would say yes.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoComplying with the FBI's request does not make it easier for terrorists and foreign hackers to access data on American phones. This is a case where having a little bit of knowledge leads to a wildly inaccurate conclusion, similar to Greenwald's original PRISM reporting.
- Spivak 11y agoIt sure does if that signed malicious firmware ever got out. And it will eventually since once it's written it will be requested by every police department and federal agency for ever increasing trivial cases. Every government in the world will want access to that piece of code. If Apple really can tie the firmware to a specific piece of hardware with no possibility of it being modified I would be impressed but even still a little cautious.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThe FBI has given Apple the option of brute-forcing the phone for them. In that case, the build never leaves Apple, just like the build that Apple has previously used to extract unencrypted data from iPhones. Making the build not-modifiable is easy. That's what's stopping the FBI from modifying the existing build to remove the wipe rule.
- oldmanjay 11y agoWhere do you get the idea Apple made a special build to extract unencrypted data?
- msabalau 11y agoDespite nearly a year of campaigning, 6 months of extensive political coverage, non-stop advertising, and series of debates with large audiences when push came to shove a third of New Hampshire primary voters decided in the last few days before election. Perhaps it's a bit premature to treat people's responses to a quickie poll as evidence that people are "taking an opposite stance" as opposed to giving their immediate impression. It seems likely that Apple, Google and Facebook could make a case that would persuade people, especially with the support of the EFF, ACLU, and Amnesty International.
- tn13 11y agoThat 50% stat is made up stat. 50% Americans probably cant spell "encryption" properly. It is very easy to make people bend over and grease up by threatening them that some bad people are planning to kill them. Defending liberty does not need 50%. You need few extremely vocal people willing to fight the good battle and help the discourse.
- neom 11y agoGiven what I saw when I was at DO, everyone should back apple in their refusal to unlock the iPhone.
- ceocoder 11y agoApologies, what is DO?
- gschrader 11y agoAs a DO (digital ocean) customer, care to elaborate?
- neom 11y agoUnder penalty of prosecution, not really. All I can say is that they genuinely do their best to protect you. For me it's that they have to spent a lot of resource (fiscal and other) to protect you from what is in my opinion: really sketchy shameful shit on the US and many other government's part. If people want to really know why tech companies are at the point of enough is enough, it's because many governments continually try to twist laws/regulations/random stuff/whatever they want/made up shit in an attempt to get what they want. Eventually becomes boring, annoying and very expensive telling them they're wrong.
- jsmthrowaway 11y ago> Under penalty of perjury, not really. Since you're quite obviously having to dance around how to communicate the fact that you've received NSLs and invocations of CALEA that made you feel queasy (I feel your pain for similar, vague, hypothetical reasons), perjury isn't the legal concept that you're after there. You want 18 USC 2709, and for those keeping score at home, to my knowledge nobody has been prosecuted for violating (C)(1) which would test that law on appeal. The Internet Archive famously challenged the nondisclosure itself and won, which is a bit different. I honestly don't know with what they'd charge you. Obstruction, maybe, but there's enough national security buzzwords in the (again, I've heard) letters and law to give me pause on considering civil disobedience there. The law does say in 18 USC 3511 that they can invoke a district court to force compliance, and then contempt can follow. But unclear on the nondisclosure part in the absence of a court order, and that's scary. (BTW, IANAL, just an ex-hoster with a penchant for policy, and I'd love to hear someone like rayiner's view on this.)
- mc_hammer 11y agoyou could also say that a PR campaign putting all our trust into apple with a behind-doors deal to actually privately share that information is worth even more to both parties. you could also argue that the NSA has the data already and would know if it even needs to be unlocked. If not, someone is smart enough to know: it still makes for a good PR campaign.
- pbreit 11y agoI feel like my positioned has changed a bit now that it is clearer the iPhone is owned by the same party that wants to recover the data?
- Etheryte 11y agoThis comment doesn't seem to make any sense whatsoever, care to expand on what you meant?
- pbreit 11y agoI was originally wholly on the side of Apple since I place an exceedingly high value on privacy and against government intrusion. But now that I understand that the phone is the county's, it seems more like a case of a phone owner just wanting to recover their own data. Thanks for the downvote, though!
- fleshweasel 11y agoThey were eventually able to get into the phone without the backdoor. The shooter's employer was able to change the iCloud password on it because they issued the phone in the first place. The FBI initially wanted to get in by having Apple build a backdoor that could be used to defeat the security on ANY iPhone-- that's the bad thing, and it's still a bad thing. And re: "thanks for the downvote"-- stop digging when you're in a hole.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- avdempsey 11y agoSure, as far as the FBI getting this being reasonable I don't think we need to go much further than the user being a butcher of humans. But there's no way for Apple to comply with this order without putting everyone else in danger either through the exploit leaking (and what an incentive to steal that exploit there would be!) or the legal precedent leading to our government (or others!) asking for more.
- 11y ago
- tbabb 11y agoWhat kind of a democracy do we live in where we rely on corporations to protect the people from an overreaching government?
- dpweb 11y agoWe're seeing a real power struggle between these powerful tech corps and governments. What was really revealing was Tim Cook's answer on 60 minutes when pinned down about Apple's international tax strategies - why don't you being this money back to the US thereby making it taxable. His answer essentially: because I don't want to. Privacy, tax avoidance, H1Bs - more showdowns to come.
- traskjd 11y ago>> because I don't want to. Well, he also doesn't HAVE to. If you don't HAVE to do something, especially if it's beneficial to not do that thing, why would you?
- empressplay 11y agoBecause you're a good person, perhaps?
- hueving 11y agoThat's not how taxes work. Why don't you donate extra money to the government that there is no law saying you have to pay?
- sigzero 11y agoNothing revealing about that. It's an obvious stance for Apple to take. Change the tax laws.
- USANEEDSHELP 11y agoThe US of A is not a democracy it's supposed to be a republic. When companies act as the mouthpiece for the people, they are not doing so because they are protecting the people. They are doing it to protect their own interests (corporatism) and any company that is speaking out in this situation, is merely playing lip service to the people (consumers/products). There's nothing they can do. They are at the mercy of the government, laws and any types of intimidation that may be applied by the any agency of the state. Only the people of the US of A can rise up and make a true difference. We must stop believing that we are here to serve the state (government). We must stand up and demand that the state serve the people.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI don't often find reason to praise Facebook, but this would be one. When news of the FBI's demands to Apple first appeared, I hoped to hear from Google, Twitter, Facebook, and Amazon, as online service providers. Mozilla and Wikimedia as related infrastructure. Also Samsung, LG, Lenovo, and Dell, as hardware providers, and T-Mobile as a mobile services provider (AT&T and Verizon are assumed to be in the tank with the FBI/NSA/CIA). This puts the list of supporters at Twitter, Google, and Facebook. Good work. Waiting on Microsoft and Amazon. https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/PyMCaHdEUen https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/PyMCaHdE...
- vinay427 11y agoWhy is Mozilla not on your list of supporters? http://www.npr.org/2016/02/19/467318811/mozilla-foundation-backs-apple-in-encryption-case-with-federal-government http://www.npr.org/2016/02/19/467318811/mozilla-foundation-b...
- dredmorbius 11y agoI wasn't aware they'd put out a statement. I was rather hoping they had. Thank you.
- partiallypro 11y agoMicrosoft did put out a statement that was industry wide, not just Apple. I don't know why people want Microsoft to specifically name Apple when Apple is one of dozens the government wants backdoors from.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThanks, do you have a link?
- partiallypro 11y agohttp://www.newsweek.com/google-microsoft-and-facebook-back-apple-encryption-battle-fbi-428014 http://www.newsweek.com/google-microsoft-and-facebook-back-a...
- rconti 11y ago>“I don’t think building back doors is the way to go, so we’re pretty sympathetic to Tim and Apple,” said Mr. Zuckerberg Shortened the article for ya.
- exodust 11y agoNice one. And not only that, but "backdoor" isn't accurate. It's not what has been requested. "Backdoor" sounds more provocative though, and helps build numbers for the Apple side of the debate. If Apple can crack the phone open, let's see it happen. And then after that, they should improve iOS security so not even Apple can crack it. I'm not impressed that Apple can if they wanted to, build in a system to weaken my phone's security. They should patch that opportunity in the next release.
- whybroke 11y agoBackdoor is not what is not mentioned today but it is what will be sought when Apple does make an unbreakable phone. If a loudly media backed ruling to force Apple to comply with the FBI is then followed by Apple making a phone which makes it impossible to comply with such requests in the future, it will much easier to get legislation or rulings requiring the all phones have an inbuilt backdoor. This is why the FBI is forcing Apple specifically to do what they or another organization (eg McAfee) might do. Especially since the phone in question, while spectacular from a media perspective, probably has very little interesting on it.
- vectorjohn 11y agoWhat Apple should have done is quietly comply and NOT set a precedent. Then quietly make it impossible to comply on later phones. Instead they're making a scene about an issue they probably will and should lose.
- aljones 11y agoThe order came from a public court. According to an article in the nytimes Apple asked the FBI to keep it secret.
- alttab 11y agoThis article does nothing to explain anything that Zuckerberg said that might illuminate his position. All he said, according to this article, was: "I don’t think building back doors is the way to go, so we’re pretty sympathetic to Tim and Apple.” “It’s disappointing to the mission that we’re trying to do.” We're talking about a company that gives away your information to FBI, CIA, and publicly via an API. Of course they are going about it the wrong way - you just simply give them the data to begin with, as a business model.
- gaelian 11y ago"While these companies have said they would comply, when legally obliged to, with handing over information on their users, they say they believe that creating technological back doors to their digital systems can lead to potential abuse by governments worldwide." This article is overlooking that it's not only governments that people would have to worry about if intentional backdoors are implemented.
- ryan-allen 11y agoFacebook don't encrypt our private chats to my knowledge and I have read articles of immigration agents having access to private Facebook chats [1]. So given this seems to be the case, isn't Zuck a huge hypocrite and this is just a PR stunt? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5864427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5864427
- veeranimous 11y agoI might be conspirator here. but I heard Apple did worked with govt several incidents. This whole thing appears like a setup to trust these corporations who's bread and butter is selling our data for profit.(where does ethics come here?). a company which bought WhatsApp for billions of dollars and providing service for free is not doing a charity. especially it's stock holders won't be happy about it. it appears like a setup to gain trust on these corporations which govt, corporations continue to use. I don't have a problem personally, if it helps to catch a terrorist. but I dont trust profit based corporations talking about ethics. it's just a PR stunt.
- bunkydoo 11y agoZuckerberg seems to be a bit of a fair weathered fan for privacy. Facebook has traditionally been very if not entirely compliant with providing government agencies with data. Due to a couple occurances with my personal use of Facebook, I have found that it is quite likely that they even do extracurricular surveillance as well. Just my opinion
- giancarlostoro 11y agoIf we want to keep fighting issues like these we need all tech companies / CEO's to voice the issues with these problems and all future tech related problems, these lawmakers really shouldn't be allowed to make laws without the backing of all / most / reasonable number of the tech giants, just because "GoDaddy" supports it isn't good enough, if "enemies" are on the same page with a bill then you might be in the right direction.
- robbiet480 11y agoAnyone have video of this yet?
- noelsusman 11y agoCan somebody explain to me why Apple couldn't create this exploited OS and restrict it to only run on the specific device in question? If that's the case, then they could post the source code on Github and it wouldn't make any difference. Modifying the code to remove the device restrictions would invalidate the signature and any iPhone would refuse to run it. Isn't that the whole point of code signing? I'm finding it hard to see how Apple's stance is anything other than meaningless grandstanding. Since the vulnerability already exists, the security of similar iPhones is currently reliant on the security of Apple's private signing key. After releasing this exploited OS, the security of similar iPhones would still rely on the security of Apple's private signing key. Nothing at all would change, it's Apple's fault for allowing this vulnerability to be there in the first place. Where am I wrong on this? I've been hoping Apple would answer this question for me but instead I've just gotten more hyperbole.
- AlexanderRB 11y agoThere isn't any fool proof way to single out this device from any other. There are certainly ways they could try and build something that relied on checking the serial number, or something of the like reported by the hardware. But then someone could just build a hardware level hack, to make any other device report it's serial number as if it was this phone.
- noelsusman 11y agoSurely there must be a way to securely identify an iPhone by more than just its serial number. If that's not the case then isn't that a security issue on its own?
- vehementi 11y agoNot if nothing really relies on that serial number, right?
- Pyxl101 11y agoThey probably could build a version of the OS that worked only for single devices. In the latest court case about San Bernadino, that's what the FBI is asking for. There's a unique device id, as I understand it, that the OS could detect. I believe that Apple is opposing it on principle, and out of concern of the precedent that it would set. Once it's been done once, the fact that it's been done will significantly lower the bar for it to be done in other circumstances.
- haberman 11y agoI'm really trying to figure out what this case is really about, vs. what the players are saying it is about. The government says it just wants to unlock this one iPhone. But is it really just looking for a legal precedent in a case that the public is likely to support the unlocking? Apple says is it afraid of creating a "master key" that could fall into the wrong hands. But doesn't it already have such a key, in the form of a signing key controlling what payloads the iPhone will agree to load? Is Apple primarily concerned with both precedent and perception of security on its phones? I personally feel that any mechanism by which iPhones could be unlocked with a warrant -- but only with a warrant (ie. the gov't physically lacks the capability to do it themselves) -- is a good compromise. It's in Apple's interest to push back on such requests, so you have two powerful and well-funded entities adversarially fighting to define the line of what can get unlocked and what can't. Now NSL's, those are a whole different kettle of fish.
- Bud 11y agoThe problem is that there is no mechanism by which iPhones can have a back door, but only for the good guys and only with a warrant. That does not exist. And it never can exist. There is no grey area for compromise here. The encryption is either secure and free of known backdoors—and thus it grants real security—or it isn't, and it doesn't.
- vectorjohn 11y agoYou are making that up. Of course there is such a mechanism. What do you think software signing is but a way for the good guys and only the good guys to run code on your device? It's exactly the same. All Apple has to do is make a piece of software that only runs on this phone and sign it. Then nobody can be attacked except this one phone. And it had to go through a warrant and all! And to your last point: this software is not secure. That's why we have this backdoor option.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago
- droopybuns 11y agoGood for Mark. Not an easy position to justify to shareholders. I can think of one ceo who is outrageously cowardly in contrast. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/att-ceo-wont-join-tim-cook-in-fight-against-encryption-backdoors/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/01/att-ceo-wont-join...
- studentrob 11y agoThat's unsurprising. Didn't Snowden say AT&T was always willing to help the NSA? Plus their CEO studied accounting. When you see a tech company led by someone without an engineering degree or somewhat similar experience, its days are numbered.
- tlrobinson 11y agoMark Klein did first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- acqq 11y agoDon't forget, one of the issues is: on which legal basis is Apple requested to help: The question is, is this act (the whole text follows): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Writs_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Writs_Act "(a) The Supreme Court and all courts established by Act of Congress may issue all writs necessary or appropriate in aid of their respective jurisdictions and agreeable to the usages and principles of law. (b) An alternative writ or rule nisi may be issued by a justice or judge of a court which has jurisdiction." a reasonable legal ground in this case to demand from a company to change their products, in this case make a special version of the operating system? Is this act good to mean "we can order anything to anybody"? Especially when there is "the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act of 1992" (CALEA). "All Writs" appears to be too dangerous to be used for precedents like this one, "change your products to help us." What is the next requested change going to be? Give us the change you've made ("obviously not an "unnecessary burden" anymore"). Make more changes, permanently. ("you've agreed already before!").
- citizensixteen 11y agoMore on All Writs Act of 1789. The Dangerous All Writs Act Precedent in the Apple Encryption Case http://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson/a-dangerous-all-writ-precedent-in-the-apple-case?mbid=social_twitter http://www.newyorker.com/news/amy-davidson/a-dangerous-all-w... "Tim Cook, the C.E.O. of Apple, which has been ordered to help the F.B.I. get into the cell phone of the San Bernardino shooters, wrote in an angry open letter this week that “the U.S. government has asked us for something we simply do not have, and something we consider too dangerous to create.” The second part of that formulation has rightly received a great deal of attention: Should a back door be built into devices that are used for encrypted communications? Would that keep us safe from terrorists, or merely make everyone more vulnerable to hackers, as well as to mass government surveillance? But the first part is also potentially insidious, for reasons that go well beyond privacy rights. The simple but strange question here is exactly the one that Cook formulates. What happens when the government goes to court to demand that you give it something that you do not have? No one has it, in fact, because it doesn’t exist. What if the government then proceeds to order you to construct, design, invent, or somehow conjure up the thing it wants? Must you?"
- 11y ago
- melted 11y agoPrediction: within 2 years Apple will have iPhone 7s, on which no one can bypass the encryption no matter what. All they'd have to do is put secure enclave software into ROM burned at the factory, and make it self-destruct if it's tampered with. "Sorry officer, not even we can bypass exponential back-off on this CPU."
- keitmo 11y agoI'm not much for conspiracy theories, so I decided to make my own. <tinfoil> What if the FBI's request is just a ruse to obscure the fact that the NSA has already unlocked & decrypted the phone and found evidence needed in the criminal charges? </tinfoil>
- DeepYogurt 11y agoGood.
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoPlease call your representative and senators about this. Not email, not mail - call. Even if it means holding for half an hour. It makes a difference, and they need to hear us.
- PascalsMugger 11y agoThe nightmare scenario is as follows. Sure, unlocking this one phone sounds pretty reasonable. Apple will maintain control of the unlock mechanism, the FBI gets it warrant obliged, end of story. This is what the government side is spinning (see the nytimes op-ed today from William Bratton, NYC police commissioner). The reality is that is not the end of the story. New York City has already said they have 200 phones waiting to be unlocked. Given an FBI win in the case, and Apple building the unlock mechanism, there's no reasonable defense against these unlocks. And this is just one city. I wonder how many full time Apple employees would be required to service the steady flow of requests from law enforcement across the world to unlock phones. Hundreds? Thousands? I'm sure they already have law enforcement liaisons, but we're talking a whole other level of commitment in order to essentially create a worldwide law enforcement IT help desk. Somewhere during the process of industrializing the unlocking of phones, a lot of people are going to start saying it would make sense if Apple would just provide the ability to unlock directly to law enforcement agencies. That would solve the problem of law enforcement heavily burdening Apple with all these requests. Assuming Apple capitulated to that (presumably forced to capitulate because I doubt Tim Cook would do it willingly), we finally reach the nightmare scenario where access to the unlocker is no longer strictly enforceable and it's only a matter of time to where criminals have it. This is a true Pandora's Box, because there's no patch that will plug this hole. This is a true slippery slope, in that its progression is all but assured. The only thing capable of stopping it is to have hardware that is incapable of having an unlocker created for it. Hopefully that's where we're at with newer phones, although that seems to not be fully confirmed. It's one thing for law enforcement to make Apple open a lock it has the capability to open. It's another to require that Apple make their product less secure than they otherwise would make it. I don't see that happening through the courts. At the very least, it would require an act of congress, probably followed with a lengthy court battle over the constitionality of such a requirement.
- nickik 11y agoApple should just build their sysyem so that it can not be backdoored. Make the TrustedZone non upgradable or give the signingkey to the use (Smartcard in the package of the phone). User can either keep or destroy the key, as they see fit. More security for everybody. No backdoors. The FBI can as for speciak version all they want. To be sure, they could still ask apple for a prober backdoor, but at least they can anker it to a individuel case.
- Iv 11y agoOk, a few question for someone who has been a bit too depressed to follow the latest evolutions since the Snowden revelations: - If the NSA approached Apple to ask for the same, would it be legal for Apple to talk about it? To refuse it? - Hasn't the NSA already done that? - Would the Chinese government allow a non-backdoored iPhone on their market? I am sorry but I really do not see any reason to believe that Apple's devices are not already rooted to the core. This one FBI issue seems to be a perfect PR occasion.
- romanovcode 11y agoIt's really is a win-win situation for both parties: Apple gets to be shown as a customer-knight in shining armor defending their customers to the bone. Government gets to convince public that they don't already have the data.
- yyyuuu 11y agoI really wonder sometimes about the great gap there lies between the problems that we face in third world v/s the problems that are faced by people in first world countries. Here in Delhi, and even more so in rural parts of India, connectivity to services like internet,banking,healthcare etc. is still a luxury for the majority. Most people here wouldn't even understand this hot issue of iPhone unlocking request by FBI. When I see folks on HN, indulge passionately in discussing the most minute detail of this Apple issue, I really wonder how long would it take for my country (or for that matter, the majority of the world population that still lives in poverty and distress) to come to a stage where we can start thinking about the next basic right that comes once you have achieved the food, water, shelter part of life, that being privacy.
- touristtam 11y agoI am with you on that, despite the fact that I am part of the rich 20% world population [1]. But you will probably find this issue to be drown soon enough under the flow of other first world news our media love to swamp us with. That being said, I believe part of the issue is the balance of power has changed into corporate hands with marketing taking a front role into leading us (the mass of consumers). The morale values that were one of the corner stones of previous institutions like the Church or the State to motivate nations are now just another commodity traded openly by economical actors that have but one goal: the bottom line. Should we find a way to coerce those ruling private entities that are corporation into performing actions that would benefit the rest of the society, we might actually be able to spread the wealth a bit better. Until then, you and me are bound to fight over the left overs of those new overlords. Sorry for the long rant, which is partly ironic. [1]: http://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/oct/13/half-world-wealth-in-hands-population-inequality-report http://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/oct/13/half-world-weal...
- vehementi 11y agoYeah, but you probably don't want to advance and arrive at the first world (forgive my butchering) to find that we've fucked it all up
- Falkon1313 11y agoWhat I'm not seeing people talk about is whether the FBI should be allowed to force someone to do something unethical, immoral, and/or criminal. Generally speaking, breaking into a system that you aren't authorized to access, or creating and distributing tools that allow other people to do so, is considered 'bad'. Shouldn't Apple have every right to say no, that's wrong, I'm not going to do that? Governments have ordered people to do bad things before. How do you view those who justified their evil actions with excuses like "I was just following orders" or "just doing my job"? Is it right for our government to put people into that situation -- not just government employees or their targets/adversaries, but neutral 3rd parties? If a policeman ordered you to do something repulsively bad that would harm your family, friends, and neighbors, would you not want to be able to say no? That view doesn't require any great technical knowledge of cryptography or hardware/software/etc. Pretty much anyone could understand it. Yet no one seems to be mentioning it.
- Mikho 11y agoActually FBI has device owner permission to access the information. There is nothing immoral here. Immoral here is Apple reaction and time wasting while there could be information to stop next terrorist attack. The situation is like owner of a device forgetting his code and ask a phone maker to help unlock the device the user owns to get info. FBI does not ask for some backdoor or unique access key. FBI does not ask to get access to unauthorized private information. FBI ask for Apple to not brick the phone and not erase all information while FBI tries different device locking codes—FBI does not want to crack the encryption. It is not about cracking encryption at all. In this particular case Apple is doing wrong and it looks like a PR show. It is not about encryption, it is not about backdoor, it is not about universal key to access private information, it is not about surveillance, it is not about privacy, and it is not about unauthorized access. It's about getting to potentially life saving information that FBI has official permission to get from the device owner.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Mikho 11y agoOne of the interesting issues here is that national security depends on the corporation decision and the actually corporation can access the information on the device, but does not want to help the government to protect people from potential terrorist attack. FBI does not ask for backdoor codes and does not ask for breaking encryption and does not ask access to unauthorized info—the phone owner granted the permission. The only thing FBI ask is to not brick the phone and not erase the info while it tries different device locking code combination. There is nothing here that would break privacy or encryption.