9 ms·
Venezuela is on the brink of a complete economic collapse
- m0skit0 11y agoI will do some Nostradamus here: when Venezuela stops being leftist, oil prices will suddenly and surprisingly rise.
- nitrogen 11y agoInteresting. Are you suggesting that the current production glut is an orchestrated move to topple Venezuela's government?
- m0skit0 11y agoNot only because of Venezuela. As usual the simple yet effective "Qui bono" ("Who benefits") question can clear things up: The US and allies: - US and the EU are really not affected by low oil prices, you can even argue it is good for them since they're net importers. Also they have strong industrialized diversified economies, so they're hardly vulnerable on one single spot. - Saudi Arabia: can stand short-to-medium term low oil prices as already shown on the 70s crisis. About US "enemies": - Russia: badly hit, a big oil exporter, but unlikely to be weakened much since it can rely on other exports. - Venezuela: the most badly hit since more than 80% of its income is from oil, and having lost a charismatic leader replaced by a relatively unknown one, it's the right time to tighten the rope. - Iran: you don't want to give them a huge influx of petro-dollars just after lifting the sanctions. - China: since the beginning of the oil price plunging, it has shown difficulties to keep up and lately its stocks are free-falling. So clearly a net geopolitical gain for US and its allies. Also the political instability of Middle East and Libya chaotic situation brings more cheaper oil, so all this looks like was part of this same plan: get rid of annoying governments (Chavez/Maduro, Gaddafi and Al-Assad) and weaken others (Iran and its allies: Yemen, shiite Irak government) while getting cheaper oil which in turn weakens other enemies like Venezuela and China and helps ailing allies like the EU. Not a bad plan at all I think. And people that think politics and economics are not related are either naive or didn't read much History. It's called "economic policy" for a reason.
- AndrewBissell 11y agoSo, your claim is that the global price of oil is being manipulated lower solely to punish Venezuela for having a Chavista-style government? Allow me to indulge in some counter-prognostication. Shale technology will cap the oil price at $50-$60 per barrel in perpetuity. Since the Chavistas rely on a price far higher than this to fund their theft and largesse, their system will be revealed to be no more economically sustainable than the dozens of other socialist revolutions that have been tried.
- m0skit0 11y agoI'm not defending reliance on high oil price as a good long-term strategy. In any case the money was used to improve the living standard of a lot of people, and that's something I cannot disagree with. Still I would have used that money to diversify the economy reliance on oil and make sure we had funds for the future, but that doesn't make the same political impact. And the dozens of other socialist revolutions that have been tried all failed because they have been all boycotted by capitalist nations, with war, arms race, space races, illegal embargoes, and whatnot, not because the socialist system is not sustainable. Socialism cannot compete with capitalism in term of generating huge amount of capital and growth because it is not the goal of the socialist system. Still, examples like Cuba with a 50-year embargo from the world superpower manages to have the best health of all latinamerica, and even a lower children mortality than the USA. I totally disagree that this is a failure. The USSR also went from a absolute monarchy slavery behind-time empire to a world economic and military superpower with one of the best health and education systems in ~30 years, which is an unparalleled impressive feat.
- stupidcar 11y agoUm, what? Are you saying the members of OPEC are more concerned about regime change in Venezuela than their own economic survival? You'll have to explain how that one works.
- m0skit0 11y agoOPEC never was a tight group. They hardly agree on anything or consult each other for production strategies. Also OPEC has not that much weight on world oil production any more. And also most OPEC countries are more interested in better relation with the USA than any OPEC strategies.
- api 11y ago"Why not? The answer is that Chávez turned the state-owned oil company from being professionally run to being barely run. People who knew what they were doing were replaced with people who were loyal to the regime, and profits came out but new investment didn't go in." This is a classic "that never works" maneuver. The USA did the same thing to some extent when it "de-Baath-ified" Iraq, which shows that this is a thing that doesn't work regardless of whether you are "left wing" or "right wing" and it doesn't even work when the USA does it. It also sometimes fails in the corporate world, such as when an "activist investor" replaces everyone who knows what they're doing in a company or a lot of people are fired in an acquisition.
- krisdol 11y ago>This is a classic "that never works" maneuver Funny how this argument starts to fall apart when you look at all the failing oil & fracking companies in the US, which were run by people who knew what they were doing and had no socialist petro regime to be loyal to and no activist investors.
- clock_tower 11y agoThey're only failing because it costs them $35 to produce a barrel of oil, and the price of oil is currently well below that. If it recovers, they'll recover.
- SilasX 11y agoAn economy that can fail because of a lower price of oil is itself a failure. It's like saying, "yeah, our high traffic e-commerce site is only failing because an intern tripped over a server power cord". No, failure is when tripping over a power cord is enough to make you fail.
- clock_tower 11y agoNot an economy, but individual businesses. The better analogy in computer services would be if your e-commerce site made $100 per hour and took 1 kilowatt to run, but then the price of electricity rose to $101 per kilowatt-hour. As soon as the price fell back below $100, you'd be back in business -- the same is true of the fracking companies as soon as the price of oil rises.
- bobby_9x 11y ago"Now, there's nothing wrong with that — in fact, it's a good idea in general" When you are spending more money than the money coming into the system, which happens with almost all socialist systems (because commerce is severely restricted), it collapses.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIs there an economy in existence that doesn't run a deficit? I don't think it is possible under current monetary regimes.
- api 11y agoOnly petro-states and places with little economy to speak of as far as I know. Net debt equals net savings, so the vast majority of developed economies run deficits because somebody has to soak up the surplus they create. But Venezuela was a petro state. See my other post for the real reason for their collapse.
- psuter 11y agoIf you believe this list [1], South Korea, Germany, Switzerland, among others (I've informally excluded tiny and oil-rich ones). [1] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2222rank.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/...
- jsprogrammer 11y agoHeh, downmods for a question. Classic HN. Anyway, I checked out the first country (South Korea) in your source. 2014-12-31 estimate of outstanding debt is $424.5 Billion with a credit stock of ~$2.4 trillion. If you want to only analyze receipts over a short period of time, then I'd guess you can find a positive period for most countries.
- tomp 11y ago> When you are spending more money than the money coming into the system, which happens with almost all socialist systems You mean, like the USA?
- sremani 11y agoThe Cubans did not run to Americans out of love, they saw the writing on the wall that their patron/sponsor in Venezuela was a sinking ship. This was long time coming but things will not really settle down or improve in VZ until 2019, when PDSV will be vacated out of power, but one can hope that can happen early. The Oil bust and Venezuela creating a welfare state around $100/barrel (along with the corruption) led to this crisis. This is the cost of Leftist Populism. Some ones got to pay, and usually it is the populace. Caracas is probably most violent City in Americas, today. People in US clamoring for leftist populism should take deep look at Venezuela.
- kaonashi 11y agoNo details as to why you're making this causal link, just post hoc propter hoc, eh?
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoFor it to actually be post hoc, I think you'd have to show ideological bias, when at least the WaPo story looks pretty straight up. Price of oil is the prime mover here, and Venezuela has big problems because of it. The Resource Curse is a real thing...
- TheBiv 11y agoOil represents 95%[1] of Venezuela's export earnings. When 95% comes from a single source and that source loses 1/3rd of it's value in a short amount of time then its straightforward to understand why Venezuela is in this situation. >>People in US clamoring for leftist populism should take deep look at Venezuela. I don't see a reason to bring your political leanings into a discussion of straightforward economic cause and effects. [1] http://www.opec.org/opec_web/en/about_us/171.htm http://www.opec.org/opec_web/en/about_us/171.htm
- Quinner 11y agoThe troubles in Venezuela started while the oil price was still high. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortages_in_Venezuela https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortages_in_Venezuela
- masterleep 11y agoWho could ever have predicted that socialism would destroy the economy?
- fiatjaf 11y agoYou're right. That was totally unexpected.
- kentrado 11y agoEvery time some flavour of socialism fails, out of the woodwork they come: See? Socialism doesn't work, Capitalism is perfect. Every time some flavour of socialism succeds: Hmm... Yea those Scandinavians are a ticking bomb, any day now they are going to fail. (40 years later)... Any day now...
- pmelendez 11y ago> Hmm... Yea those Scandinavians are a ticking bomb, Most Scandinavians countries are kingdoms ( I think only Finland is actually a republic) and when people talk about socialism they usually have Marxism-Leninism in mind. The Nordic model [1] relies on the free market to have a welfare state, which contrast with Marx's ideas of state and social classes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model
- Apocryphon 11y agoNot in America. In America, people think anything involving public spending is socialism. We also don't know what social democracy is and we define "liberalism" in a different way from everyone else on the planet.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> when people talk about socialism they usually have Marxism-Leninism in mind. Er, what? Socialism is much more than just Marxism even in the broad sense, and Leninist vanguardism ("Marxism-Leninism") is not particularly significant in modern socialism. About the only thing from even Marxism in the broad sense that is fairly broadly common throughout all of what people talk about under the umbrella "socialism" is the broad outline of the critique of concerns/problems with capitalism, but the actual alternatives vary considerably.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- _Marak_ 11y agoNo surprises here. You can look at base points for Venezuela credit default swaps in 2014. http://money.cnn.com/2014/12/12/investing/venezuela-russia-default-wall-street/ http://money.cnn.com/2014/12/12/investing/venezuela-russia-d... http://i2.cdn.turner.com/money/dam/assets/141212155648-venezuela-credit-default-1024x576.jpg http://i2.cdn.turner.com/money/dam/assets/141212155648-venez... Wall Street has been betting against Venezuela for two years.
- rickitan 11y agoI'm a Software Engineer born and raised in Venezuela. I moved to Canada one year ago. Ask me anything!
- fiatjaf 11y agoSince when were you experimenting shortages on Venezuela? How serious are these shortages? Do small shops survive in Venezuela? How?
- rickitan 11y agoThe shortages are extremely serious at this moment. We're having a humanitarian crisis because medicines can't be found, people use social media to ask for medicines. The government limited the days where you can go to the super market to the last digit of the "Social Security Number". So if yours end in 0 or 1 then you must buy on Monday. And nothing guarantees that you will find what you're looking for. Lines outside supermarkets take 2 hours or more and they only sell you a limited amount of items. 1 Chicken per week. The government also installed finger print scanners to make sure that you don't buy more than you're allowed. All this measures are failing and will fail, because the problem is that they destroyed the private industry making us heavily relay on imports. Now that the price of the oil is down there is not enough money to import, so there's simply not enough food, medicines, etc.
- fiatjaf 11y agoWhat about the small business? :P
- rickitan 11y agoSmall business are on their knees. They are just surviving and living paycheck by paycheck. They sell whatever they get access too. Their profits are worth nothing in dollars (if they manage to have profits). An inflation projected to be 700% this year makes it extremely hard to survive, you need to adjust your prices every hour. Nobody is doing well in Venezuela, except the corrupt people in the government who keep stealing money.
- johnrob 11y ago>> The first step was when Hugo Chávez's socialist government started spending more money on the poor, with everything from two-cent gasoline to free housing. That sounds exactly like the kind of thing we (HN crowd) have been dreaming about. Hopefully we don't end up reading a similar comment down the road about the US!
- nitrogen 11y agoI think it's pretty clear that any US policies will be more sophisticated than "create insane price subsidies on a product produced by a dying state-owned company". What really matters is not "money on the poor", but economic diversity and sustainability. Let's not latch on to political catchphrases designed to short circuit critical discussion. When people suggest things like basic income on HN, there is always discussion of how to fund it sustainably.
- chadnickbok 11y agoI think there's a marked difference between conversations about basic income and "two-cent gasoline". In this case, direct market manipulation of specific goods paid for by a budget entirely reliant on the price of oil being at historical highs doesn't seem like good policy, even to those who'd vote for Bernie Sanders!
- marcosdumay 11y agoI don't remember ever reading a post on HN of somebody wanting an entirely state owned economy. Also, you are accusing the "just give them money, and stop babysitting adults" crowd of supporting cronist populist micromanaged social programs.
- fiatjaf 11y agoI really wish to hear from people who support leftist causes what they think of this and if there's anything, any hypothetical event, that they would accept, if happened, as a proof that leftist policies are bad.
- cjbprime 11y agoWhat do you mean by leftist? It's obviously a continuum -- many successful European countries self-describe their governments as socialist and it's working well for them. If you only think of the corrupt and incompetent governments as the leftist ones, it's a truism that their policies are failing.
- mvaliente2001 11y agoI'm not sure if I qualify as leftist, but I can answer your questions. Is there anything that makes me accept that leftists plicies are bad? Yes. Evidence, like Venezuela's example, prove that some leftists policies are bad. The current government and the policies it have taken are the only responsible for the current inflation and product scarcety. But that doesn't mean that every leftist policy is bad. For example, the Venezuela government started programs to eliminate analphabetism, increased the number of doctors and free hospitals (in a program with the help of Cuba), reduced the infant death rate, increased the education budget, the access to potable water and other things like that. Granted, none of these measures are leftist per se, but also, these are not the things a right wing government cares about (at least not our right wing governments). I think the reason so many people in Latin America is leftist is not ideology. It's simply that the other option is not liberalism, free markets and laisse faire. The alternative is chronism, medieval institutions (feudalism is alive in a lot of places), privatization of earnings and nationalization of loses.
- fiatjaf 11y agoThank you for being the only one to answer my question. But let me make another one. We will not agree on an answer, you don't even have to reply if you don't want, but I want to ask anyway: you don't see any relationship between the reasoning behind free hospitals and the Venezuela economic collapse?
- aristus 11y agoIt's fun to use these situations as proof of one political belief or another, but I suggest looking deeper than "socialism" or "leftism". Chavez tapped a popular anger that was the direct result of mismanagement by the previous 30 years of government that was decidedly not leftist. The mood was so bad that Chavez was forgiven for a coup attempt and allowed to run for president. Think about that for a second. The AD-COPEI regime in power from the 60s to the 90s was so discredited that a literal traitor was elected to replace them. Venezuela's problem is not political flavor, it's the oil curse itself. I have family there, and it is quite bad. The economy is stuck in several sorts of cleft stick: Saudi Arabia's game of chicken with the rest of OPEC, the mismanagement called out in the article, the hangover of Chavez policies (which were necessary for popular support), and of course the military-narco complex always in the wings.
- awl130 11y agothe oil curse? come on. natural resources are neither a blessing or curse. norway is a small country with lots of oil and isn't a disaster. i don't know what the problem is but don't blame it on oil.
- guyzero 11y agoA curse is literally what economists call these situations. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse
- legulere 11y agoAnother name would be Dutch disease: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease
- MarkPNeyer 11y agoImagine having the ability to see and hear the thoughts of everyone around you. You'd either be a superhero, the best politician, running a sane, stable, healthy 'democracy' where people who were upset had things fixed just the right way - or you'd be a crumbled mess, an incoherent madman. There's no middle ground. With a singularly outsized ability like that, you simply could not function in a 'normal life.' Perhaps huge oil revenues are like that - without a stable cultural and political setup to use the resources wisely and for the benefit of the whole community (norway) - perhaps the only other course is a totally connected political mafia that extracts the value of the primary resource for itself and its supporters. A history of colonialism would set the country up for the second track.
- epx 11y agoA .vn minister said recently that toothpaste was difficult to find in stores because people were brushing their teeth 3x a day, which is "obviously too much, 1x at night is enough". It is incredible how stupid things a person allows him/herself to say when paid to do it.
- ipince 11y agoWell, the media mischaracterized what she said in order for it to sound more shocking. What she actually said was that people use more medication than they need, in general. Still preposterous, but I'm saddened that the media makes these outlandish claims that only hurt its credibility in the long run.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- scardine 11y agoPopulism is the best regime until the money runs out and no one is left to shake down. A lot of damage was done in Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia and Venezuela.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoVenezula is a really interesting example in my mind. Here is a country which has all of the fundamental things it needs to be a vibrant, robust, and generally great country and yet it isn't one. It has natural resources which are in demand, and for which the tools and techniques to convert them into exchangable goods is well understood. It has few serious military threats from its neighbors and so militarily its primarily responsible for civil and criminal activities, and it has nominally "easy" access to nearby markets for trade goods (importing things it doesn't have domestically). But it also has people in "charge" to have no idea how running a country even works much less the forces that act on it. And as many anti-libertarians will point out, the lack of a competent government does not result in a paradise emerging from the work of motivated individual actors within. And understanding that, go back to the founding of the US and its fits and starts trying to go from being a colony to being a country, and most importantly the constraints on their own actions that everyone had to agree to in order to get the Constitution done. Try to understand why that worked is an interesting (and perhaps vital) exercise. Was it the people? Their values? Their education? Their understanding? Was it coincidence or luck? I find myself desperate to know why one institution works and another fails. Both large like nation-states, and small like companies. How is it "no big deal" for some companies to get a new CEO and catastrophic for others?
- solipsism 11y agoHow is it "no big deal" for some companies to get a new CEO and catastrophic for others? It probably doesn't satisfy, but isn't one answer to this question: "Because there are countless convoluted variables"? This would depend on the outgoing CEO, the incoming CEO, every key employee, the state of the company, the company's sector, the state of the economy, etc. I guess you're looking for consistent rules of thumb, but is it possible that there are too many factors for their to be any good rules of thumb?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoHaving joined IBM which has a process for everything (including evolving management, and making changes at the top) which was very very different than Sun which was evolution by attrition (for example once Ed Zander figured out that Scott McNealy wasn't going to give him a shot at being CEO he went to Motorola) which was different than NetApp where some positional changes (CEO) seemed managed while others (CTO and VP Eng) did not. And then there are processes like military command or the US Constitution which have their own components. For example you can't run for the office "Speaker of the house" in the US Congress you have to be voted into it by a set of peers who are all nominally eligible for the job. Similarly with Pope, anyone in the College of Cardinals can be elected as I understand it. Not so much for Dali Lama though. Organizations are only as strong as the people who make them up, but creating tools to manage that set of people for the greater good of the organization, that is an interesting question. How do you quell damaging voices while amplifying the voice of people making forward progress? Countries are the same way, monarchies can fail suddenly with the coronation of a bad monarch, but democracies tend to survive such games. Rome had been around for centuries but as more and more power congealed into a single individual it became more and more unstable. It is like you have to walk into a room where anyone else can get you removed, and still get stuff done.
- cgrubb 11y agoThe Venezuela wikipedia page makes it sounds as if the Bolivarian Revolution is a repeat of history: The election of Carlos Andrés Pérez in 1973 coincided with the 1973 oil crisis, in which Venezuela's income exploded as oil prices soared; oil industries were nationalized in 1976. This led to massive increases in public spending, but also increases in external debts, which continued into the 1980s when the collapse of oil prices during the 1980s crippled the Venezuelan economy. As the government started to devalue the currency in February 1983 to face its financial obligations, Venezuelans' real standards of living fell dramatically. A number of failed economic policies and increasing corruption in government led to rising poverty and crime, worsening social indicators, and increased political instability.
- dang 11y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11001169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11001169
- dpeterson 11y ago"Sure socialism didn't work for them; but with a little finesse, we'll do it better" (says every socialist ever).
- researcher7 11y agoAnother socialist utopia collapsing? Shocked, shocked I tell you.