10 ms·
How to Raise a Creative Child. Step One: Back Off
- jgrahamc 11y agoFrom its inception in 1942 until 1994, the search recognized more than 2000 precocious teenagers as finalists. But just 1 percent ended up making the National Academy of Sciences, and just eight have won Nobel Prizes. Just eight have won Nobel Prizes? What a bunch of dunces. But wait, only 870 people have ever won a Nobel Prize. So these numbskulls have only managed to win 1% of all Nobel Prizes ever. If your parenting standard is "Nobel Prize or the gutter" there's a serious problem.
- jeffwass 11y agoYeah, strange thresholds for success. They mention just 1% have won Nobel Prizes, and then in the next sentence say "For every Lisa Randall who revolutionizes theoretical physics, there are many dozens who fall far short of their potential." Lisa Randall didn't win a Nobel Prize in physics (yet), though she is in he National Academy of Sciences. So I guess you must have one or the other honour to be judged a success. Meanwhile her collaborator Raman Sundrum (of the Randall-Sundrum model, which Lisa Randall is most famous for) is neither a Nobel laureate nor on the National Academy of Sciences. But one day if he does win the Nobel, his Success status changes overnight?
- glaberficken 11y agoI came here to write the same =)
- artpepper 11y agoAlso, the article segues to fostering creativity without ever coming back to the question of whether those kids are more successful as adults. So having fewer rules supposedly leads to more creative children, but do those kids do well later in life? Article doesn't say. I'm basically sympathetic to the more "hands off" parenting style being discussed. But the article really doesn't make its case.
- pappyo 11y ago>So having fewer rules supposedly leads to more creative children, but do those kids do well later in life? Is having no rules a steadfast rule? Chew on that one for a while :) And while you're thinking about that, realize that most children growing up in poor environments don't have many rules to follow. Few people would consider poor communities as bastions of creativity (not to say there isn't creative things happening in these communities, just they are not perceived that way). The problem with this article and others like it is the subjects - children - are not one thing in a vacuum. Some children will thrive in a structureless home life. But most won't. Some children will thrive with rigid structure. But most won't. So what's the answer? It depends on the kid. From my experience, most children need some sort of structure in their lives. They simply don't have the faculties to deal with the complexity of how life is today. That's what the parent is for. But to go overboard with rules generally doesn't work very well either.
- samshih 11y agoI feel that raising your child like so (having fewer rules) in fact parallels doing well later in life. The measure of success, especially here on hacker news, feels heavily skewed towards making money, success in the Silicon Valley, etc. But while some creative lifestyles may not make enough money (poets, writers, artists) I would argue that they would end up living more fulfilling lives, following their intrinsic motivations rather than any socially constructed notion of success.
- pappyo 11y agoMy point was children, in the abstract, are easy to overgeneralize. In reality, it's difficult to say how any given child will react to any given stimuli. Few rules might work for one child but not the next...and there is no rhyme or reason to it. Children are complicated things. Just as adults are complicated things.
- sitkack 11y agoIn raising my own child in this manner, I am not so much fostering creativity, but not suppressing the person who is already there. We should enable everyone to be the best possible person. We raise or lower all of those around us.
- x5n1 11y agoI see these sort of parents mostly as scumbags that accomplish little on their own and pass the burden of their own failings to their kids. Parents should expect at most their kids to achieve their level of success and no more. That's reasonable expectation. Anything more than that is a lottery and a fluke.
- notmonsters 11y agoIt's actually unreasonable for parents these days to expect that kids will achieve their own level of success, because the distribution of rewards in society now fall so much more disproportionally to the handful at the very top of any field than they did in their parent's generation, and the generation before that. "Nobel prize or the gutter" is merely a logical conclusion in a world where only the very best at anything are valued.
- phkahler 11y ago>> It's actually unreasonable for parents these days to expect that kids will achieve their own level of success, because the distribution of rewards in society now fall so much more disproportionally to the handful at the very top of any field than they did in their parent's generation, and the generation before that. That's meritocracy.
- bobby_9x 11y agoI disagree. It's the same. Its just that too many people expect more of the reward, for less of the work and never realized just how much work it actually took to achieve these rewards in the first place. I see it all the time with people trying to start businesses. They see the success stories and want a rich and profitable company in less than a year. I believe it's the result of perceived instant gratification on the Internet and from the idea that started in the early 90s that 'everyone needs a trophy', which I saw first-hand. I’ve met so many college graduates that either want a six-figure income right out of school, a management position within 6 months, or a flex schedule at every job. It's not just a want, they feel entitled to it. It's why Bernie Sanders is so popular among the youth: he's promising many rewards without any of the work.
- lordnacho 11y agoAnd also consider people who win a science Nobel tend to be pretty old. Suppose you have to be ~55 or so to win one, you'd have to be born latest in ~1960, probably doing the contest in the late 1970s. And I would guess the field of finalists got bigger as the contest got older.
- tosseraccount 11y agoYou may have to be 55 or so; but the work was done 20 years ago. "What's more, after 1985 about 60% of physics, 52% of chemistry, and 49% of medicine prizes were awarded following a post-discovery delay of more than 20 years." [ source : http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/magazine/physicstoday/news/10.1063/PT.5.2012 http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/magazine/physicstoday/n... ]
- dynofuz 11y agoi dont have kids but, .4% rate of winning the nobel prize is way better than the 0.00000124% rate of the rest of the world. And "stepping back" may lead to much less success than pushing a kid to practice and i'd take that risk of .4% creativity vs the rest of the population.
- icn2 11y agoLots of people just don't get it :).
- cfcef 11y agoSimilar to how people mention the Terman study didn't enrol two future Nobelists because they just barely missed the cutoff and so this proves IQ tests are bunk. It would have been much better to cite the SMPY longitudinal results for a meaningful idea of how child prodigies fare.
- ap22213 11y agoI had to look up Terman and SMPY [1]. I scanned it, and it seems to suggest that IQ 'is kind of bunk' - that it's more effective to evaluate mathematical reasoning, alone. But, what I find more interesting is that not all mathematically precocious achieve, and very many achievers were not mathematically precocious. So, what's going on in the middle? It's cool to see that 2000 kids out of 400M were high achievers, but how do we get, say, 1M high achievers out of the next 400M? [1] https://my.vanderbilt.edu/smpy/files/2013/01/Article-PS-Lubinski-et-al-2014-DEC-FINAL.pdf https://my.vanderbilt.edu/smpy/files/2013/01/Article-PS-Lubi...
- ap22213 11y agoAlso, the data from SMPY seems odd. I took their achievement percentages (# of individuals in top positions 40 years later), and did some rough calculations. The SMPY cohorts seemed to perform much better than if one had randomly selected a 'top %1' individual from the total U.S. population. So, either the longitudinal study had an effect on the cohorts, or their original sampling method was biased.
- tomaskafka 11y agoBy filtering out the 399M and telling them they suck (eg on standard test) so they should not even try. Then you'll have 1M of post traumatic survivors to label as high achievers. Well that's what schools do today.
- cfcef 11y agoSimilar to how people mention the Terman study didn't enrol two future Nobelists because they just barely missed the cutoff and so this proves IQ tests are bunk. It would have been much better to cite the SMPY longitudinal results for a meaningful idea of how child prodigies fare.
- memracom 11y agoYeah, Bill Gates never won the Nobel prize. Neither did Steve Jobs. Or Donald Trump for that matter. Look carefully at a normal curve. If your kid is slightly above average, say C+, then they are doing better than 50% of the poulation. That is already pretty good. By all means, encourage and assist them to do better than that, but lay off the judgements. A Happy kid who runs a daycare center in the city, is someone that you should be proud of, because believe me, society in general is proud of people like that and does not judge them because they failed to win a Nobel prize. If your kid can wake up every morning and honestly say, every day in every way I am getting better and better and better, then you are a superlative parent.
- kozukumi 11y agoYes! I was a C student. I had it drummed into me that wasn't good enough. It took me many years to realise I am good enough and to work past all that negative re-enforcement that was thrown at me every day for several years. Now I have a great job, a lovely wife and two beautiful children. I live in a lovely house in west London. I am financially independent and I love going to work every morning. If that isn't "good enough" then god knows what is!
- uiri 11y agoAll 8 of those Nobel Prizes were won by individuals who were finalists in 1968 or earlier. So for half of the years in that date range, not a single finalist has been awarded a Nobel Prize. Since 3 of those Nobel Prizes have been in the last 15 years, it is likely too early to tell what the final percentage of Nobel Laureates is among those 2000 finalists.
- shas3 11y agoSpurious cherry-picked statistics. I'm pretty sure most Westinghouse / Intel winners are doing exceptionally well, being in the top 1-10% of the society. A couple of such articles I'm reminded of: 1. Statistician Andrew Gelman's batch of math Olympiad campers: http://andrewgelman.com/2015/03/17/1980-math-olympiad-program-now/ http://andrewgelman.com/2015/03/17/1980-math-olympiad-progra... 2. Indian IIT exam toppers: http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/where-are-they-now http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/where-are-they... 3. Famous Intel talent winners: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Science_Talent_Search https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Science_Talent_Search Nobel Prizes are a cherry-picked metric. Yeah, not all prodigies become adult geniuses. But the article grossly overstates the problem.
- Joof 11y agoI worked in a lab with a professor who spent a portion of time training new graduate students to be creative again (tons of handouts on it and so on). It can be taught to some degree; our brains don't just stop changing completely in adulthood (its just harder). Also 8/2000 got Nobel prizes? Thats some pretty good odds.
- polskibus 11y agoDo you have any references to books or research on stimulating creative thinking in adults that you could share?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fishnchips 11y agoIt would be great to see some data about results of alternative education that's supposed to foster creativity: Montessori, democratic schools etc.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoLived in a place where montessori was basically the only way of schooling and parenting was extremely hands off. Turns out children like structure and without one they ends up forming gangs at an alarming rate. Most grow out of it, but the pack mentality remains fostering xenophobia, while some other never get out of it and it's a huge social problem. Won't name and shame so don't ask. I think some freedom to experiment is good, as long as one also gets plenty positive role models and strong sense of what's wrong.
- fishnchips 11y agoInteresting point. In Ireland almost every creche brands itself as Montessori but it's quite different (as in more relaxed) than what you'd see in California. Though what you're describing does not sound like Ireland.
- watmough 11y agoIf you have children on the Autism Spectrum, structure and expectations and continuous nurturing will help them hugely.
- artpepper 11y agoI wondered about the "average of fewer than one rule" cited in the article. Some parents have zero rules? I consider myself a pretty liberal parent and we definitely have more than one rule. e.g., Don't be mean, brush your teeth, be careful crossing the street, take your shoes off inside the house. Even if you generalize those to "be good to others and to yourself," that's still a rule!
- themartorana 11y agoI wonder if "don't smash that block into the TV" counts as a rule? Or "don't eat that knife"? Or "don't play in traffic?" Or any other common sense thing that helps keep a young child alive for more than 24 hours? This article is silly and evokes an extreme to try to make a point.
- Nemant 11y agoJust had my first baby 2 weeks ago. I guess I'll be returning that Haskell book I bought for him...
- fishnchips 11y agoTrue that, you'll be better off with Python for the first few months, at least until weening.
- nier 11y agoDon’t you think hardware development might be a better start? My daughter’s 10 months old and still can’t read, let alone pick reasonable variable names. But she’s been able to hold the soldering iron for at least 6 months and I believe I see progress.
- fishnchips 11y agoDid you plug it in?
- nier 11y agoThere is little sense in doing that at this time. That’s just my personal opinion. The way I see it, she needs three skills to succeed. First, hold it the right way up and realize this thing is not an eye poker or lollipop. Second, develop a steady hand. The doctor says alcohol is bad for her, so there seems to be no easy way. Third and last but not least, learn resistor markings. I’m praying she didn’t inherit my color blindness. When we’re there we can playfully discover Ohm’s Laws by letting her gut decide on the right voltage and current applied to her circuits. It’s going to be magic.
- 50CNT 11y agoI've heard that at 12 months Duplo's and Visual VHDL/Verilog editors become suitable for the child. You can get them started on very simple PLDs, move on to FPGAs along with some more palatable Assembly. If the child cannot solder BGAs by age 2, you may want to consult a child psychologist to check for development problems. They may suggest Agile or Kaizen, or a number of other frameworks to keep your daughter on her milestones.
- sanxiyn 11y agoI think genetics is a big confounding variable here. If creative parents enforce fewer rules and creative parents have creative children, creative children will have fewer rules even if having fewer rules has nothing to do with creativity. In this scenario, if some atypical creative parents enforce many rules their children will still be creative, and backing off won't help your children if you are not creative.
- eloisant 11y agoNot just genetics, but there may be thousands of things that parents of creative children do in addition to have few rules.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dschiptsov 11y agoVariety of experiences is the key. Traveling, big collection of coffee table books (these photo books of India and Himalaya are so wonderful), classical music, of course, and dance (much better than sports). Then a child will make her own patterns out of it. Restricted, repetitive behavior is the root of all evil.
- themartorana 11y agoExcept where it applies to bathing, eating, sleeping, practicing dance and sports, learning basics like the alphabet and how to read, math, and pretty much everything else that makes this generalization rather silly. I do agree with the bit about a wealth of experiences, though.
- sbardle 11y agoMost children are creative. I taught in a school for a year and there was only one child who had zero creativity (the exercise was to write a film plot and he basically reproduced the "Cool Runnings" story). But the school system has had to prepare kids for adult life and repetitive boring jobs. That may change as the machines take over, so like Baudelaire we can truly become lovers of clouds.
- Jonathanks 11y agoThe article reminds me of this: "Your children are not your children. They are the sons and daughters of Life's longing for itself. They come through you but not from you, And though they are with you they belong not to you. You may give them your love but not your thoughts, for they have their own thoughts. You may house their bodies but not their souls, For their souls dwell in the house of tomorrow, which you cannot visit, not even in your dreams. You may strive to be like them, but seek not to make them like you. For life goes not backward nor tarries with yesterday. You are the bow from which your children as living arrows are sent forth. The archer sees the mark upon the path of the infinite, and He bends you with His might that His arrow may go swift and far. Let your bending in the archer's hand be for gladness; For even as He loves the arrow that flies, so He loves also the bow that is stable." * - "The Prophet" (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1951) p.17-18. Most parents that enforce their own ideals and values on their children are narcissistic. They either do not love their children or have so poor an understanding of love itself that they cannot love properly.
- redblacktree 11y agoDo you have children? If you don't teach them values, where do they get them from?
- mhandley 11y agoThey learn values by the example you set, but that doesn't mean they share your interests.
- fao_ 11y agoMost children learn a lot of habits and values by unconsciously picking them up off their parents. They learn from your actions what is correct and incorrect behavior without you having to directly teach it. Good behaviour is comprised of the union of two sets: behaviour that you allow, and behaviour that you partake in. If these sets overlap then you can be pretty sure that your child will learn 'good behaviour' as defined by you. I would also add that many beneficial social movements favouring equality among humans have been contested by adults who were brought up to share their parents' values. I hesitate to say that most children do not care about colour or sexuality until they are taught by their parents that differences are bad, or see their parents reactions to people who are 'different'.
- libria 11y ago> They become doctors who heal their patients without fighting to fix the broken medical system or lawyers who defend clients on unfair charges but do not try to transform the laws themselves. The author assumes many parents intend their children to be pioneers in their field. Despite the memes, many asian parents largely steer their children to conservative paths: work hard, risk little, and grow steady wealth. The child may not become a household name, but they are unlikely to end up bankrupt either and the parents are content for the child to securely occupy the upper-middle class. There's not really a push for the child to be "the next Steve Jobs" so long as they get enough ammo to 1-up the local parents at the next social.
- d0m 11y agoYeah, that sentence made me cringe. If they become good doctors that's already a massive win for our society and for them, but that sentence make it sound like they're losers.
- witty_username 11y agoBy Asian you mean CJK right?
- libria 11y agoYes, I should specify east asian. By my perception at least Indian asians have a more entrepreneurial spirit and I see more of them as founders. I admire that, and I'd be interested to hear how their upbringing differs, ie, what ways they were encouraged, pressures, values.
- paulddraper 11y agoIDK what groups the author had in mind, but that group is the vast majority of Asians (if you exclude the Indian subcontinent). It's also the majority of Asian-Americans, if you add Vietnamese.
- pcote 11y ago>> First, can’t practice itself blind us to ways to improve our area of study? Research reveals that the more we practice, the more we become entrenched — trapped in familiar ways of thinking. The only way practice traps you in familiar ways of thinking is if you focus practice only on the things that are familiar to you. Letting Anki help schedule your practices is a way to avoid this. Here is what I do. - Review phase: Do exercises based on whatever is up for review. - Attack the weakness phase: Spend extra time reteaching yourself the stuff one you feel you did poorly on. - Project phase: As you work on interesting challenging projects, add new Anki cards as you encounter and learn new things. It's a good technique which I think could be accessible to a lot of children. Let them choose the area of interest. Just instill in them a sense of discipline in whatever area THEY choose to pursue.
- patsplat 11y agoYesterday I taped a piece of paper down on the kitchen table and got out the crayons. Was asked for a Yellow Submarine so held my 3 year old's hand and drew one with him. He was almost ecstatic at having an image appear from his hand. Creativity is a mix of confidence, encouragement, hand holding, and structure.
- jloughry 11y agoWhat a great way of teaching to draw! I would not have thought of that. Thanks for the idea.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- julianpye 11y agoI believe in the creative power of boredom. Boredom and lack of distractions amongst kids create the most creative environment and nurture real interest and exploration. Today's kids are oversaturated with distractions and their lives are fully planned around activities. So they live according to templates, but not according to their own motivators. Then again, having a child myself (10 months old) I have noticed many parents have so many activities and things planned themselves that they distract their children (read consume content on iPads) in order to pacify them. It's a circle.
- arca_vorago 11y agoI have to agree with this. I grew up in a village (pop < 250) in the mountains, and those were some of the most creative years of my life. When the entire town jokes that watching grass grow or paint dry is a fun thing to do in summer, you quickly learn to entertain yourself in novel ways. As a side note, one other thing I think this has done is make me comfortable with silence. During the summer break when I would do long camping trips, sometimes I could go days without speaking, and I enjoyed it. Now I see people all around who seem to need and want something going on at all times. Since I no longer live in the mountains, meditation outside helps assuage my need for silence and solitude, but I am considering building an isolation tank. On subject, I agree that freedom begets creativity. I love that I could mark a place on the forest service map, list my supplies, and say "if Im not back by sundown on day 3, then call the forest service". Thats a level of independence and freedom that was encouraged in my family that has served me well in many areas since.
- BatFastard 11y agoGo rent an isolation tank, as someone who built one. They take up a lot of space, changing water, filling with epson salts, etc is a not fun. But maybe there are better systems nowadays, I built mine in the 80s. I had to move it once, I had a friend who owned a herse and we loaded it on top. Must have looked like we were carrying the coffin of a 1500 pound man.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoI posted almost exactly the same comment back in November. I think boredom and unstructured time without any parents around was one of the most important parts of my own childhood. Kids are so good at entertaining themselves with basically nothing! Its uncomfortable for kids to be bored but they quickly learn the entertain themselves, especially when around other kids. Its actually kind of amazing. They never learn this skill if they aren't given the chance. Scott Adams (Dilbert guy) says that boredom is what gave him his creativity.
- codingdave 11y agoCreative people tend to set their own goals. Winning Nobel Prizes or revolutionizing a field might not be what they want out of life. A 'boring' day job that supports the family can be the perfect tool to let you spend the rest of your time on hobbies and passions. I am an underachiever in my career, to be sure. But I have made a lot of art, climbed many mountains, hiked what seems like every trail in Colorado, and learned a few crafts, while also maintaining a marriage and raising a family. I'm happy with my life, no matter what the world thinks of it.
- sanoli 11y agoI don't even want anymore for my kids to win Nobel prizes or the equivalent in other fields. If it becomes their passion, sure, I'll support them. But I won't push them to be the absolute best, or wathever it is that tiger parents supposedly are doing to make their kids geniuses or CEOs. I'm pretty sure I don't even want that life for them, as the CEOs and the geniuses I've met either led very stressful lives or were downright assholes (but I'm sure there are many exceptions). I found out, soon after my first one was born (I have two), that all I wish for them is: a happy and meaningful life, health, and that they have a good heart. If they never amount to nothing money/carrer wise, well, so what?
- moultano 11y agohttps://twitter.com/SteveStuWill/status/692474630205001728 https://twitter.com/SteveStuWill/status/692474630205001728 One of the most consistently replicated findings of behavioral genetics is that the environment shared by siblings (parenting) has no effect.
- awl130 11y agothat link is great
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zardgiv 11y agoDon't you find it disturbing that behavioral genetics, as a field, is unable to find actual genetic evidence for its most replicated correlations? (See the response to your linked article.) Rather than reevaluating their assumptions, instead they've decided to punt to the idea that it _must_ be that it's actually many small effects that they just happen to be unable to measure? Additionally, if you were a parent, what would be the practical advice from this finding?
- moultano 11y agoMostly I find that it keeps me from worrying too much. My wife and I can just do our best and not be concerned that we are causing irreparable damage. (It also keeps me from caring about parenting fads like TFA. Whatever works for our family is probably good enough.)
- zardgiv 11y agoYou didn't answer my first question. Additionally, why would you do your best, though? As you said, it has zero impact.
- zardgiv 11y agoI'll take the lack of response as an admission that you were at best unaware and are now embarrassed by your ignorance, or at worst don't actually believe what you're posting as fact on the internet.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- awl130 11y ago"just" 8 have won nobels and "just" 1% end up in the national academy of sciences? this is unimpressive compared to what? this article is just bad science and lazy writing. before we can even entertain his conjecture we need two data sets, easily calculable by anyone with freshman college math: x% of child prodigies become nobel prize winners or national science foundation award winners. the distribution of other scientific achievements for such prodigies has a median of y and spread of z. a% of STEM college graduates become nobel prize winners / national academy members. the distribution of other accolades is b with a spread of c. x,y,z compares how with a,b,c the results can be interpreted different ways but at least we have a starting point for rational discussion. the rest of his article is mere conjecture with emotional posturing with an agenda.
- geebee 11y agoI like the headline, but I felt the rest of the article didn't really live up to it. The setup is intriguing - for instance, the notion that micromanaged children will become excellent concert violinists, but may not become ground breaking classical composers (let alone the next Bob Dylan). The example put forth in the article to support this assertion is... Itzak Perlman. A wonderful violinist and (I don't know him at all, this is what I've read) a generous spirit as well. But aside form a foray into jazz that I thought wasn't especially notable, Perlman's greatness is more or less as a concert violinist. Interesting to hear he was rejected from music school, but this seems a very odd example. Why not focus on someone like Stefan Grapelli, who started playing at an older age, asked a busker in the paris metro how to play the violin (who laughed the question)? Why not look into the careers and lives of musicians who made their mark through creativity rather than virtuosity? I really like violin, from a lot of angles. I enjoy the amazing precision of the great classical musicians, but I do find myself even more intrigued by musicians like Steve Wickham (who played with U2 and the water boys, among others). I do tend to agree with the article that the micromanagement many young classical musicians go through in their quest to play perfectly may indeed vastly reduce the possibility that the musician will be able to put together an interesting track for "Sunday Bloody Sunday" or collaborate with a rock musician to produce something like Fisherman's Blues. These things may in fact be inversely correlated. There's a lot here, unfortunately, I just don't think it was explored in interesting directions by the article.
- kzhahou 11y agoI'm glad NYT writer and so many HN posters finally figured out the correct way to raise kids, and are sharing it here. I thought we'd have to wait another 5000 years for it.
- fishnchips 11y agohttp://www.salon.com/2015/11/22/snark_is_good_for_you_science_reveals_the_surprising_benefits_of_sarcasm_partner/ http://www.salon.com/2015/11/22/snark_is_good_for_you_scienc...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- andrewclunn 11y agoIf you don't give your kids an ethical framework, then the TV, their teachers, or their peers will. Unique people tend to not conform to standards? Not shocking at all, but this article is ridiculous. It's not the lawyer's job to rewrite how the criminal justice system works. It's not the doctor's job to reform healthcare laws. This is some anachronistic thinking that somehow thinks that people exist in vacuums. If the "cost" of parents bothering to actually raise their kids is that we're given more people who competently perform their jobs, then so be it. That's more important than getting some new style of architecture anyways.
- red_admiral 11y agoOf all the examples they could have chosen to support their argument, this one made me chuckle: "The gifted learn to play magnificent Mozart melodies, but rarely compose their own original scores." Unlike, er, Mozart himself who had what we might today call a Tiger Father and yet seemed quite capable of creativity.
- trusche 11y agoThere's a bit more context a few paragraphs on: > Mozart showed interest in music before taking lessons, not the other way around.
- VLM 11y agoA question for the journalist, how long would you expect your culture and society and economy to survive if all 2000 were actually "revolutionary adult creators"? Another good question is why smart people have to be slaves. If a smart person wants to spend their life meditating, or serving the poor, or in a religious vocation, the journalists unhappiness about their decision is sad for the journalist, but I'm not really seeing the problem for the person. I'd even double down, and in a culture that's strongly anti-intellectual, a smart dude might very well see that his best course thru life of maximized happiness and love, is a non- or less- intellectual career. Sort of an "Atlas Shrugged" attitude. A "winner takes all" system doesn't motivate everyone, much like the lottery, the winners are those who don't play.
- ilostmykeys 11y agoEmpathy is the highest form of understanding. When raising a child, i would certainly start there. That's all that is needed from a parent: genuine, and fully embodied empathy. Backing off is not the answer. Neither is controlling. Engaging empathically is all that we as parents need to do. There are two concepts here: engagement And empathy. True empathy is easier to achieve in parent->child relationship than any other kind of relationship. Engage empathically. The child will lead their own growth as a conversation with you, the parent, and their environment. So listening deeply (beneath the words and behavior) to the child is the first order of business, not backing off. Parengs should spend time being with their kids rather than take time away from their kids to write crappy articles or comment on HN (An advise that I should take, too, obviouslh :)
- cgriswald 11y agoEmpathy is always a good place to start; and I generally agree with what you've said. However... > True empathy is easier to achieve in parent->child relationship than any other kind of relationship. I disagree with the above statement. Empathy is easiest when attachments are fewest. This does not describe the typical parent-child relationship. I think parent->child empathy may be easy for many because they are very much like their children and their children are going through very similar experiences to their own. I, on the other hand, have lead a very different life than the life my child is very fortunate to be living. I am fortunate my child is similar to me in many aspects so I do get glimpses of understanding; but my child is also very different from me so it is not always easy. Not to toot my own horn, but people have praised me for both my empathy towards others and my parenting skills. I work very hard at being a good parent. I am very attentive. I listen. I consult. I read. I think, and I act. But I find empathy to be probably most difficult in this relationship than in any other I've had.
- ilostmykeys 11y agoI too think you're a very good parent because you are engaging with the goal of arriving af empathy, no matter how hard may be. That's the key I suppose, not how hard or easy it is. Thanks.
- tomlock 11y ago>>Child prodigies rarely become adult geniuses who change the world. But, this is equally true of other children as well!
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoSure, but you normally have higher expectations from prodigies and geniuses.
- tomlock 11y ago>>Child prodigies rarely become adult geniuses who change the world. But, this is equally true of other children as well!
- zamland 11y agoI have a different interpretation. Most of the muscles that a parent gives to a child are the structured muscles to prevent one from failing. College, grad school are in some sense insurance. Therefore most of the upper middle class upbringing is guaranteeing insurance of a person's middle life or retirement. Whereas the muscles that you learn from being independent are the muscles from conceptualizing, taking risks, creating, and learning from the experience. This is a completely different muscle than previous set of muscles. It's not really about letting go or being too controlling. It's about building the right set of mental models so that someone can guide and create their own lives.
- xenophon 11y agoThe argument that this article makes is somewhat muddled, but if I'm understanding correctly: child prodigies don't end up advancing their fields to the extent that their early talent might suggest because by and large they're not original/creative, which is because they learned at an early age to conform to well-defined standards of success instead of pushing the envelope. So we get "excellent sheep," or masters of using ordinary methods who still receive nice but ordinary results. But 0.5% of the Westinghouse pool winning Nobels is still far better than the population average. What this article tells me is something that seems pretty obvious: that raw ability is correlated to being recognized by society for acts of genius, but so are other things, including both the "thinking out of the box"-ness that the author trumpets as well as entirely extrinsic and random factors (ie the Nobel committee likes you, your style of work or area of focus happens to align with or be amplified by a prevailing intellectual trend, etc). Prodigies don't always succeed in pushing the enelope because it's vanishingly unlikely for anyone to do so; they still do a sight better at it than most.
- Kinnard 11y agoWhat exactly qualifies as "creative" is not well defined . . .
- Kinnard 11y agoWhat exactly qualifies as "creative" is not well defined . . .
- gonyea 11y agoHow to Raise a ???? Child. Step One: Nobody knows what the fuck they're doing.
- David774 11y agoHi everyone reading this, am here to give thanks to Dr BLESSING for the Lottery and luck spell she cast for me, From taxes USA. I want to Thank Dr BLESSING for helping me. SHE help me to win a lottery and the contract i was working toward since last year i got a call last week that the contract has be approve to me. I don't know how to thank her,she has really done allot for me. she is the best spell caster i have ever meet, and you can give her a try she can still help you out in anything that is bothering you, if you want to contact her here is her email address {drblessingherbalhealinghome@gmail.com ) thanks once again.
- David774 11y agoHi everyone reading this, am here to give thanks to Dr BLESSING for the Lottery and luck spell she cast for me, From taxes USA. I want to Thank Dr BLESSING for helping me. SHE help me to win a lottery and the contract i was working toward since last year i got a call last week that the contract has be approve to me. I don't know how to thank her,she has really done allot for me. she is the best spell caster i have ever meet, and you can give her a try she can still help you out in anything that is bothering you, if you want to contact her here is her email address {drblessingherbalhealinghome@gmail.com ) thanks once again.