17 ms·
Iran Complies with Nuclear Deal; Sanctions Are Lifted
- agorabinary 11y agoA great lecture on Iran: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtELk8S3dhU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rtELk8S3dhU Really gives some perspective on an oft-misunderstood place.
- nashashmi 11y agoI would use this video to respond every comment here. But then that would be quite annoying.
- lingben 11y agoWhile Rick Steves is a warm and wonderful person he is no authority on Iran. He visited Iran and was carefully stage managed to present only the positive side of things and completely ignore the rest. He is not a historian, he is not a sociologist, he is not an orientalist, he has zero credentials or background which would make him in any way an authority or a source of insight. He went to Iran and had a great time visiting different cities and sites. And he talked to many people, while government minders were close by but off camera. Therefore, this presentation is what it is: an anecdotal account of one man's carefully choreographed visit to a country. And I'll add that I'm saying this as an Iranian - I wish I didn't have to add that but it seems that sometimes good intentioned people see anything negative written about Iran or a 'brown' country and automatically think it is motivated by racism or bigotry.
- markdown 11y ago> He visited Iran and was carefully stage managed to present only the positive side of things and completely ignore the rest. The US govt has been "informing" us about the negative side of things for decades. We had nothing new to learn about that side. To show us the other side was what was and is needed.
- lingben 11y agoActually it was human rights organizations and other NGOs which were reporting on the brutal realities of Iran and asking the US, Canada, Europe and the UN to take action about the extrajudicial assassinations, the lack of due process, the tortures, etc. The 'other side' is what the other side has always been. Normal people going on about their lives. The same is true for North Korea or Burma, etc. People are people. No one has a personal grudge against Iranians as a people or individuals. The government however should be held accountable and justice demands consequences for their actions.
- markdown 11y ago> Normal people going on about their lives. The same is true for North Korea or Burma, etc. Most people in the world realise this, but then most people aren't residents of the United States. If online commentary is anything to go by, US citizens have been totally brainwashed by government propaganda. I mean, your president called those countries the "Axis of Evil". Think about that for a minute.
- krapp 11y ago> If online commentary is anything to go by, US citizens have been totally brainwashed by government propaganda. The internet, like the US, is a large and diverse place, with varying political, cultural and intellectual identities. You're just cherry picking to assemble a strawman "ignorant, brainwashed American" to knock down, but as straw Americans go, if it depends on internet comments to provide an unbiased reflection of reality, it's not very substantive. If online commentary were anything to go by, the earth is flat and space-jews did 9/11.
- markdown 11y agoWould you accept that most Americans believe what their government tells them? I mean, politicians on the campaign trail can't be trusted, but when the head honchos of the US "defence" forces, the Secretary of State, and the President of the United States stands in front of the nations media and talk about the foreign bogeymen who're out to get them, would you accept that most Americans believe them? Then you have the Fox News and dozens of right wing radio talk shows pounding on the same drums... creating more fear about these foreign evils who hate them "for their freedoms" and who "want to impose sharia law on the world. The propaganda machine in the US is extremely efficient... so well oiled that most people don't see it. Even the moving parts of the machine believe that they're doing good and aren't out to fool anyone. This type of brainwashing is less the Pyongyang brand, and more of the type that the beauty product companies use to tell women they're too fat.
- nashashmi 11y ago> He is not a historian, he is not a sociologist, he is not an orientalist, he has zero credentials or background which would make him in any way an authority or a source of insight. He has traveled the world and visited lots of countries and viewed them with an open mind. He can make comparisons and contrasts. He can derive lessons as he did in the video where he touted the benefits of church/state separation. I think he has some expertise now. And definitely more than the theoretical historians, sociologists, orientalists who have never been in the field like he has. > while government minders were close by but off camera. Never mentioned this on camera. But he did mention that security would often inquire and investigate what he was up to. > was carefully stage managed He was not really stage managed. His focus was on the Iranian side of Iran, the human side, not the government side. And if he found information that he could not document, he spoke about it. That is not 'stage managed'.
- lingben 11y agoIran is an authoritarian country like North Korea. No foreign press is allowed in without first requesting a special permit. Among the information they have to present is who they are and what they are planning on reporting on. This is the first filter. For example, if you request a press pass to enter Iran and report on the persecution of Bahais, don't be surprised if you are turned down. But once allowed in, that's not the end of it. They are monitored and carefully managed to only present the positive. Also, who they speak to and what they say and hear is also monitored. This is well known and routine. Therefore, to think that a choreographed and superficial 'feel good' anecdotal video like Rick Steve's presents anything approaching reality is the height of naivete.
- agorabinary 11y agoIf you had watched the video you would see the parts where he addresses your critiques. He explores the everyday life of many different Iranians, particularly those in the urban areas, and makes efforts to highlight the positive and negative attitudes towards the West. You don't have to have a doctorate in Iranian studies to learn and understand for yourself that Western media's portrayal of Iran is deeply biased. Of course, Iran's portrayal of the West is equally biased. The key is to listen to the grievances of both sides within the context of a historical understanding and form judgments from there. This is exactly what Rick Steves has done. Steves mentions in his video that every schoolboy and girl know of the 1953 coup and the CIA's involvement. The vast majority of Americans are entirely oblivious of this event when forming opinions of Iran. Isn't this valuable information for Steves to communicate with his Western audience?
- vonklaus 11y agoMakes a lot of sense. The scrawny kid with low self esteem who has a bad family life so he lashes out from time to time, is entirely ostracized by all the popular kids until he agrees to turn in his red ruder bb gun.
- noir_lord 11y agoNot sure I'd call the US scrawny.
- Retric 11y agoThe sad thing is Iran used to be reasonably liberal in the 1960's. Based on pictures from that time period, but politics got really ugly. IMO, it's a classic case of nut-jobs on both sides of a boarder causing pain for a wide range of people.
- gotchange 11y agoThat's true to some extent but only in urban areas. Rural areas where Khomeni drew his huge support from were in dreadful conditions and as reactionary and conservative as they get.
- api 11y agoThere was a general global religious reactionary backlash in the 70s and 80s. Over here we got the moral majority and such.
- c3534l 11y agoMaybe overthrowing their democratic government and replacing it with a brutal dictatorship wasn't the most intelligent thing the American government did.
- refurb 11y agoYou need to a bit more reading. The US/UK did not "overthrow" a democratically elected gov't. Mossadegh's gov't had become very unpopular and there were mass protests across the country. I agree that the US/UK fully supported the Shah in his attempt to take over the gov't, but overall the effect was more a nudge than a bullet to the head.
- HillRat 11y agoIt was social liberalism masking a particularly virulent and corrupt regime under the Shah. The greatest mistake the West made in dealing with modern Iran was to support the coup against Mossadeqh; it ushered in a period of political oppression that even CIA admitted was unsustainable, and which led inexorably to the Bazaari-Clericalist revolution. (Khomeini's supporters weren't the only anti-establishment revolutionaries, but they seized the reins of power first and then began systematically reducing the liberal and Marxist opposition.)
- joezydeco 11y agoCrude oil is expected to fall another $2-$3 on Monday after this news. Curious what that will do to the rest of the market.
- msoad 11y agoOne very welcome change is reconnection of SWIFT network to Iran. You can't believe how hard it is right now to send money to Iran. This hit me when I had to transfer money to my family in their extremely hard times, when my brother had an accident and needed cash for treatments. I hope this trend continues and Iran comes back to the international scene. It's good for everyone. Iran is very similar to Israel. Most of people are normal but there is a small percentage of extremist who have a lot of voice. Lucky for Israel they have a better constitution and governance model.
- kobayashi 11y agoIsrael and Iran are far from alike. It's likely true that Iranians are, to our best knowledge, some of the most reasonable and liberal-minded in the Middle East, but Israel does not simply have a "better constitution and governance model". In Iran, the extremists are running the place, and are a large segment of society. In Israel, extremists are marginalized, and even the degree of their extremism is less than that of the Iranian leadership. I am less welcoming of the news that Iran will be reconnected to SWIFT, as I think that the real good news would be the downfall of the Mullahs and the rise of a representative, reasonable Iranian government, in peace with its neighbours and its own citizens.
- msoad 11y agoIt's proven (North Korea) that crippling a country's economy does not lead to downfall of its government. I wish it was that simple though!
- kobayashi 11y agoOne country (DPRK) does not make a rule. An besides, the DPRK and the Islamic Republic of Iran are very different regimes with very different citizenry. Iranians, by and large, do not believe in a death cult of personality surrounding their leaders, and can be much more critical of governmental choices.
- 11y ago
- tyre 11y agoThis is terrific news! As with the tearing down of the Berlin Wall, opening up countries to the world's economy and ideas is the first step towards democracy. The implications of this are tremendous (not in order of importance): 1) Oil prices will continue to fall as Iran is able to supply the global markets. Many oil states rely on money from natural resources to preserve monarchies. Money for freedom only works so long as the money keeps flowing. 2) Our (US) reliance on Saudi Arabia will diminish as there are now two powers in the region to work with. Having strong relations with both Shiite and Sunni powers in the Middle East will likely reduce sectarian violence. We're light years from being out of the woods, but this is big step in the right direction. 3) The Iranian people will gain access to the world economy. From a human rights perspective, they are the biggest winners here. As with Sunni/Shiite relations, no doubt a long way to go (the Ayatollah is a tyrant,) but you gotta celebrate the wins when you can. 4) De-escalation of our conflict with Iran. We saw it with Iraq, Vietnam, and Korea. Invasion + nation building is sexy, but highly ineffective. Having one less nuclear power that calls for our destruction is certainly a nice to have. 5) Shows Americans that diplomacy can work. Iranians don't hate Americans, they hate what America represents. To them, we represent a superpower that gives little to no thought of anyone else's sovereignty. We assassinated their democratically elected leader and backed the Shah, which got us into this mess. Diplomacy is far less sexy and easily criticized, but that's a huge part of getting this deal done. Note: Many of these are over-simplified. Nonetheless, this is a pretty big deal and a cause for celebration.
- amalag 11y agoI have been very neutral towards Obama ( I voted third party in both recent national elections) and don't like how cozy he is with corporate interests, but he has impressed me with what he has accomplished. Iran, Cuba, Healthcare and a few other programs that may have had some initial resistance but are in the best interests of the US and will be an enduring legacy.
- tyre 11y agoOn a more speculative note, regarding Saudi Arabia, this could indirectly lead to the declassification of the full 9/11 report. We know that SA was heavily involved but absolutely could not risk our relationship with them by releasing the full findings. Perhaps now that we have more options in the Middle East, we can recalibrate towards the truth. (Left out of original comment because this is wild speculation.)
- gotchange 11y ago> Iran will use the roughly $100 billion in frozen assets it will receive to support terrorism and other misadventures. > Iran’s support for terrorism, its imprisonment of dissidents and even some Americans, its meddling in Iraq and Syria and its arms trade. Funny that Saudi Arabia is guilty of all the above if not 10X worse but not a single word from those republicans. This speaks volumes of the power of the Saudi lobby in the US political system and how their wealth could influence decisions and policies in the US.
- nashashmi 11y ago> This speaks volume of the power of the Saudi lobby ... or it shows the systematic hate for Iran.
- enraged_camel 11y agoWhy "or"? Can't it be both?
- irrelative 11y ago| != ^
- joezydeco 11y agoExcept that allowing Iran to export even more oil keeps the price of crude down on the floor. Saudi Arabia can't survive oil staying at $30 for the next decade. So maybe this is an end-run around the Saudis and letting things sort themselves out naturally?
- mapt 11y agoFrom what I understand? Saudi Arabia has plenty of money banked; They can survive a decade without the sort of windfall profits they've enjoyed. "SAMA's net foreign assets totaled $628 billion in November, down from a record high of $737 billion in August 2014," The marginal price to produce a barrel of Saudi crude is still the lowest in the world, at just three USD. What's going die out once the equipment is worn out (or require extensive subsidy) are marginal plays in developed countries like Canada, the US, and the North Sea, the Arctic, the deep offshore drilling, tight or heavy oil, tar sands, tar shales, smaller fields without economies of scale, and all forms of biodiesel & ethanol (yes, even the most efficient, Brazilian ethanol). All the oil-dependent economies are going to suffer and compensate monetarily, by drawing down sovereign wealth or cutting expenditures, but the harder bound is the level at which it makes economic sense to stop drilling. Production prices in the above settings are high enough that they just can't make money at $30/barrel, which is a whole other category of problem than not making enough money to feed the government budget which has ballooned only in the last decade taking advantage of higher prices. http://knoema.com/vyronoe/cost-of-oil-production-by-country http://knoema.com/vyronoe/cost-of-oil-production-by-country
- 1024core 11y agoI don't know why we're so ensconced in Saudi arms. Iran is much more liberal than Saudi Arabia; and Iran doesn't export the fundamentalist interpretation of Islam (Wahabbism) which is causing headaches all over the world. Now I'll sit back and wait for the "but... but... Iran said they would wipe Israel off the map!!!1!" crowd.
- lingben 11y agoThis is such an ignorant statement that it is difficult to decide how exactly to unpack it. As an Iranian let me attempt to do so anyway: First, Iran is Shia, not Sunni. So, no, they are not Wahabi. Just like the Queen of England is not Catholic but rather Anglican (Protestant). Second, it is arguable whether Iran is more liberal than Saudi Arabia. In some instances it is. In others it is not. This is a matter of religious debate. Just like Saudi Arabia, as a Muslim, you can not simply stop being a Muslim or convert to another religion or become an atheist. Iran also has consistently persecuted non-Shia Muslims (including Sunnis, Sufis, Ahmadiys, etc.) as well as the Bahais who are the largest religious minority in Iran. The reality is that Iran implements Sharia just like Saudi Arabia. They chop off hands, blind people, hang people in public hangings off cranes, etc. The Iranian version of Sharia is a little different than that of Saudi Arabia. This is because they are Shia and have a different version of Islam, not because they are full of sugar and spice and everything nice. Third, Iran certainly does exports their version of Islam just like Saudi Arabia. The most obvious one right now is Yemen where the Houthis are being used by Iran as a proxy to fight Saudi Arabia. But Iran has also funded Shia Muslims in Nigeria [1] and elsewhere in Africa. They also created and continue to fund Hizbollah to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars a year as well as shiploads of weapons and explosives which Hizbollah uses as a terrorist organization to perpetrate untold atrocities. Iran has also perpetrated many acts of aggression and terrorism globally: Kenya, Thailand, Argentina (AMIA bombing), Paraguay, etc. [2] [1] http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/12/23/nigeria-s-khomeini-spreading-iran-s-revolution-to-africa.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/12/23/nigeria-s-k... [2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/africaandindianocean/kenya/10033351/Iranians-guilty-of-Kenya-bomb-plot.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/africaandindianoce... [2] for more complete list, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_and_state-sponsored_terrorism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_and_state-sponsored_terro... It is only as a consequence of a wholesale ignorance of the reality of the Iranian regime, its government's motivating philosophy, and its brutal autocratic and dictatorial grip on power that someone could say what you've just said. If this comes across as a sharp response it is because I'm tired of people giving Iran a pass by way of a false comparison to Saudi Arabia and/or misunderstanding or not taking the time in the first place to inform themselves about the realities of the current regime. As an Iranian who has had family members and friends of my family imprisoned on trumped up charges, tortured and killed and their property seized (to then be charged for the bullet that killed them) it is unconscionable to give such a blood soaked regime a pass of any kind.[3] [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_fee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullet_fee
- audessuscest 11y agoThey always did. It's just that now we agree to recognize it...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jameslk 11y agoNow if only we could do away with the double standard and hold Isreal responsible for their nuclear escapades[0] too. 0. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_and_Israel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_and_Israel
- TheGuyWhoCodes 11y agoIsrael never publicly announced the willing and need to destroy another country, and it doesn't not support terror organization with monetary and military aid, it has never carried out terror attacks specially targeted at civilians. So yes double standards indeed.
- quinnchr 11y agoActually Israel has a long history of state sponsored terrorism, see Irgun and their incorporation into the IDF at the dawn of Israeli statehood. In fact they haven't just supported terrorism, they've used direct military action to intentionally kill civilians: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qibya_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qibya_massacre And they even currently support terrorist organizations that specifically target civilians: http://rockcenter.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/02/08/10354553-israel-teams-with-terror-group-to-kill-irans-nuclear-scientists-us-officials-tell-nbc-news http://rockcenter.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/02/08/10354553-isra...
- TheGuyWhoCodes 11y agoAnd the US had slaves, Europe murdered millions of people in Africa and the Americas. 48 is ancient history. The actions of a single military unit going out of control (which can be argued) is not indicative mind set of the country and government. There is a difference between directly attacking civilians and "punitive expeditions" and you have to put the whole incident in the context of the times in the 60's I wouldn't say a nuclear scientist working on an atomic bomb is an innocent civilian, these are rumors, nothing more and even if are true so what? Iran say they are terrorist because they are anti state organization.
- salimmadjd 11y agoThis is a tremendous news politically and economically. Economics - 1 - the price of oil has been declining since the IranDeal was signed. In US alone the annual savings as result of cheaper gas and cheaper food (food production costs is strongly tied to gas prices) is about $500B/year (from $4/gallon - $2/gallon). Basically providing additional $500B in spending money in US. 2 - globally, the lower price of food and gas can potentially provide additional spending money. 3 - Iran has crumbling infrastructure and need numerous foreign contractors to rebuild (European and Chinese have already signed up). Sadly US companies will not be able to participate. 4 - Iran has potential for a large consumer market. Politically - 1 - US will finally have a second option (let's call it the second front) in middle east. We in US have been keeping a blind eye toward Saudis, their indirect financing of ISIS and all types of jihadist fighters in region from Libya, Syria, Africa, Afghanistan, etc. 2 - Iran will be tapped into helping stabilize Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria (there is already talks of providing and exist for Assad) 3 - Iran's gas can provide a hedge (at least the fear of an Iranian pipeline) against Russia. This probably wont happen as Iran relies more on Russia than Europe and will probably maintain that role, but that's a possibility. 4 - The open Iran is forced to further integrate globally. This has always been the fear of the hardliners and it'll be resisted by some within, however, there seem to be an understanding that stopping progress is a futile task. 5 - One of the largest women secondary eduction (close to 70% of college students are women), it will eventually play out as a potential model for other regional muslim countries to emulate. 6 - It will force Saudis to change. Saudis are extremely worried about the IranDeal. But their biggest existential threat is not militarily, but culturally. From having 70% women college students, to hybrid system of government. Iran socioeconomic role, will put pressure internally on Saudi rulers and it will force them make uncomfortable changes or face internal turmoil.
- jernfrost 11y agoVery interesting with the high number of women in college. In the long run I think they will bury Saudi Arabia. Once oil runs out Saudi will have nothing but Iran will have a much stronger foundation to build on. They already got lots of industry like car manufacture.
- bane 11y agoThis an incredibly subtle deal. - Iran gets access to global markets, and in time tourism (there's an incredible number of amazingly beautiful things in Iran for tourists to see, from ancient to modern ski resorts) - Iranian oil will keep prices in the toilet, this is basically a way for the U.S. to punish Saudi Arabia for decades of support for various maleficent actors. Except it doesn't involve an invasion, a takeover, or anything else beyond economic sabotage. The Saudis have also had decades to form a more diverse economy, and for various reasons haven't managed to do it...this has kept them vulnerable to this kind of action and it helps free the the major users of Saudi oil from "vendor lock-in" - It demonstrates that cool, calm, collected diplomacy can actually work. However, many people will forget that the U.S. and Iran have been fighting a proxy war for decades. It hasn't been a hot war, but Stuxnet, various revolutionary movements and so on have been bits of that war. This isn't just Iran throwing in the towel because the sanctions finally worked, its because all of the other major leverage points Iran could muster were defeated. - While the sanctions by themselves failed to work, they helped create a political climate inside of Iran that favored this outcome instead of having another go at saber rattling. - This helps provide a mildly more palatable "friend" in the region than Pakistan
- mschuster91 11y ago> - Iranian oil will keep prices in the toilet, this is basically a way for the U.S. to punish Saudi Arabia for decades of support for various maleficent actors. While I'd certainly support letting SA rot to pieces for their misdeeds, SA alone could with a single move end the low oil prices. It's more like SA wants to screw over both Russia and the US, because neither country can produce oil at 10$ per barrel like SA can. > It hasn't been a hot war, but Stuxnet, various revolutionary movements and so on have been bits of that war. Stuxnet was Israeli with US cooperation, iirc. Not that this makes stuff any better. Only problem is that Israel can and will ignore US opinions if they feel threatened. Unfortunately, Israel is in possession of nuclear bombs and their current government is extremely right-wing; I'm not sure if Israel won't escalate the war to "really hot" now that a deal has passed and they will be afraid that Iran will try to subvert it.
- chadzawistowski 11y ago
- rajacombinator 11y agoNice (surprising) to see some let up in the US's brutal war of aggression against Iran!
- bronz 11y agoSo what did he mean when he said that Iran would be able to access its holdings abroad? "A senior American official said Saturday that Iran will be able to access about $50 billion of a reported $100 billion in holdings abroad, although others have used higher estimates."
- mikeyouse 11y agoPrior to the sanctions, Iran had billions of dollars invested in foreign banks and infrastructure. Their access to this money was cut off when the sanctions were put into place and we're slowly allowing them access. Here's an article from 2014 with more detail: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-assets-usa-idUSBREA0G0LR20140117 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-assets-usa-idUSBREA0G...
- bronz 11y agoThank you.
- refurb 11y agoAccess money that is outside of Iran. Most countries have assets in other countries. Preventing the movement of this money is pretty typical form of sanctions.
- TheGuyWhoCodes 11y agoThis is the worst news this year. More money for terror, seems legit.
- agorabinary 11y agoThe single best way to reduce terrorism, civil strife, and violence in general is greater prosperity. Keeping people poor, ignorant and frustrated is a guarantee of future terrorism.
- TheGuyWhoCodes 11y agoIf only that new found prosperity wouldn't be used directly for terrorism I would agree with you. Lack of prosperity and poor education, didn't contribute to the sanctions been put on Iran but of direct action by the government. Lifting them will not help Iran become western democracy or less fanatic it's left wing bullshit.
- amalag 11y agoIran is state sponsor of terrorism but probably less than Pakistan whom the US government funds a lot more. The Taliban is sheltered and supported in Pakistan. Iran would be a far better strategic ally. Their Israel obsession can be cured, it is not pathological. The Iran population is probably a lot more favorable to the US than Pakistan. Iranians are actually a lot more secular, the government is a lot more fanatic than the average person. That is not true in other countries. The US needs to help shape Iran's future. An adversial relationship is not the best for that.
- TheGuyWhoCodes 11y agoHaha, I have been down voted to oblivion... I guess that what you get for not using a throwaway... This is only good for big corporations going to cash in on a new land of fresh business opportunities, pure greed.
- jernfrost 11y agoVery exciting news, that made me happy about the news for a change. I am confident we can make Iran into a normal country if we show them some good will. It is a country full of all political stripes like anywhere else. The confrontational policies of the past has emboldened the Iranian hardliners. It is time to embolden the moderates and reformers in Iran! When you read about the details of Iranian society, it is very clear that they have a huge amount of potential. Regular Iranians are the most positive to the west in the region. Religion is in strong decline there. They got a lot of real industry there. They are big car manufacturers e.g. They have more scientific output than the whole Arab world combined. Their strain of Islam is not as extremist as the one found among the gulf states like Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Jemen etc. We got to give the Iranians reasons to believe that playing well with the west will give them a lot more benefits than antagonizing Israel. I support Israel's existence but I really wish they had a more moderate and constructive leader than Bibbi. He really comes across as a deranged conspiracy theorist. To make real progress we really need to get Iran and Israel to make the peace.