14 ms·
The cold fusion horizon
- mannykannot 11y agoIt seems that philosophers are not immune to scam artists. I am surprised by this particular example, but only a little bit.
- baq 11y agohave you even read the article?
- mannykannot 11y agoYes, and I have also read other sources, especially with regard to Rossi. e.g: http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1306/1306.6364.pdf http://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1306/1306.6364.pdf http://www.sott.net/article/241427-E-Cat-Cold-Fusion-Machine-Claims-of-Fraud-Heating-Up http://www.sott.net/article/241427-E-Cat-Cold-Fusion-Machine...
- msandford 11y agoThen I hope you see the irony in your comment, and why the first reply was a little incredulous. I'm not defending Rossi, BTW. The odds are very, very, very good that it's another scam. But it's not impossible that he's on to something and that's exactly what the article's author points to, along with lamenting how tragic it would be if cold fusion turned out to be real and we wasted 20 years not pursuing it because of the reputation trap.
- mannykannot 11y agoI am wondering if we read the same article. The author uncritically cites already-discredited studies in favor of the E-Cat without noting the doubt that surrounds them, and only mentions fraud as being so improbable as to effectively dismiss it. He is apparently literally salivating over his expectation that he will be proved right. FWIW, I know cold fusion is not definitively ruled out by physics, I would be thrilled if it were realized, I think it is a valid area of research and I always thought that Pons and Fleischmann were treated far too harshly, but ignoring strong indications of fraud is only going to make that case harder to make. I hope you can see that these are not mutually contradictory opinions.
- paganel 11y agoI know almost nothing about cold fusion and theoretical physics in general, but as a guy who has read some Popper and Hume I'll chime in with an obviously subjective opinion, and say that after reading all the HN comments and parts of the article the first thought that came to my mind was this: "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence". Interestingly enough that exact quote is present in TFA, but in a manner that makes it debatable: > This is not to deny that there is truth in the principle popularised by Carl Sagan, that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. We should certainly be very cautious about such surprising claims, unless and until we amass a great deal of evidence. But this is not a good reason for ignoring such evidence in the first place, or refusing to contemplate the possibility that it might exist Paragraphs like this one remind me of a work-colleague of mine, who I try to convince from time to time during our cigarette breaks that aliens have not visited our planet and that they're not just "about to arrive", impending asteroid apocalypse be damned. At which point she almost always responds to me like this: "paganel, yours are valid opinions, but we cannot refuse to contemplate the possibility that one day they may arrive". This also reminds me of how early Christians actually believed that the second arrival of Christ was just around the corner. Whatever this guy writes about and whatever he believes in, it is not about science.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "Whatever this guy writes about and whatever he believes in, it is not about science." You say that, but you're ignoring the thrust of his argument. Let's say, for argument's sake, that the results from Rossi's experiment seem somewhat dubious. Easy to dismiss a single flawed experiment, right? However, there have been at least four separate reproductions of the experiment results since then (article mentions reports of similar results from Sweden, Italy, Russia and China). The main question raised by the article can be summarised as: If evidence of a reproducible experiment with unexplained results exists, which is usually a key indicator that the experiment warrants further investigation, why is there sometimes reluctance to investigate when this reproducibility comes along? Science is not served well by dogma. Interesting results can come from unexpected places. The wilful ignorance of the reproducibility is the issue here.
- roywiggins 11y agoBut that's a Pascal's Mugging, isn't it? How unlikely does a claim of LENR have to be, exactly, before we can dismiss it out of hand?
- Retra 11y agoIt would be more tragic to have smart people investigating something that is very likely a fraud, when they could be doing something more productive.
- mizzao 11y agoI understand the argument about the sociological reputation trap, but a little more reading about Rossi's research turns up some very fishy evidence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_Catalyzer In particular, the copper supposedly generated by the fusion of hydrogen and nickel has an isotopic composition very similar to that of natural copper, rather than what one would expect from byproducts of nuclear reactions. As a result, it's much more likely that copper comes from a conventional source rather than actual nuclear fusion. It also doesn't help that Rossi has been convicted of fraud for purportedly inventing dubious devices in the past. In particular, he "created" a system for turning toxic waste into oil, but this turned out to be just dumping the waste into the environment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_(entrepreneur) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_(entrepreneur) I'm all for avoiding groupthink in scientific research, but this might not be the right story on which to base that argument.
- sparkzilla 11y agoIt's somewhat ironic to say you want to avoid groupthink and then to cite Wikipedia as your source.
- leoc 11y agoWell, here's another source. Here's what the most prominent full-time pro-LENR advocate/journalist these days thinks of Rossi: http://newenergytimes.com/v2/sr/RossiECat/Andrea-Rossi-Energy-Catalyzer-Investigation-Index.shtml http://newenergytimes.com/v2/sr/RossiECat/Andrea-Rossi-Energ...
- marshray 11y agoI was open minded about Rossi and the 'E Cat' until I saw that video. Like, where is the measuring equipment? He has a multimeter measuring the current coming out of the wall, but is not taking a simultaneous measurement of the voltage. Sure, OK, I guess we'll assume it's 220 V from the power company, and figure it's drawing about 750 W (about half the power of a full size microwave oven). But then on the output side, he has a rubber hose with a tiny amount of steam coming out. Maybe even less that what you would expect from a 750W tea kettle. They have to hold it up against a tshirt to measure it. They have a thermometer on the input water reservoir but for some reason don't even bother measuring either the temperature or mass-flow rate of the output? This video is not demonstrating the measurement techniques of a credible scientist. I would not let this guy service my home air conditioning unit.
- djsumdog 11y agoA good documentary to watch is Fire from Water. There has been a lot of work into LENR and a lot of it is positive. Toyota dedicated a two years research division to it. The trouble is it's not consistent, and when excess heart is recorded, we're not sure why. I'm sure this is of those fields that needs a "eureka" moment where some group figures out what might be simple missing pieces.
- extrapickles 11y agoIf cold fusion research was tested with more accuracy, it would be a more respectable thing to research (or at least not laughed out of the room). All of the tests on cold fusion/LENR devices never seem to use appropriate measurement tools for the measured range, much less the gold standard methods for counting energy in/out, leading to enough error you could hide a truck. No more calculating energy from thermal camera pictures from 1 side of the device without checking periodically if the heat output is uniform. Similarly, they like to use 3-phase input power when a standard wall-plug power would do. Measuring 3 Phase power in these cases is like trying to measure the weight of a person using a truck scale. Also you can do more shenanigans with 3 phase that the meter wouldn't pick up, which due to the history of scams in this field is even more important that the power being fed to the device is proved to not have anything funny going on. I'd like for cold fusion to be true, but in order for them to be taken seriously, they need to test the devices with much more rigor.
- Shivetya 11y agoReading this reminds me of the controversy with the Cannae Drive
- Animats 11y agoThis cold fusion guy supposedly has a 1MW plant in test at an industrial site. That should be verifiable. Nobody seems to know if Theranos' technology actually works, even the investors. With a multi-billion valuation, that's a big problem. Nobody seems to be sure whether the D-Wave quantum computer really does anything "quantum", even though they've shipped products. How did we get to the point where we can't even verify claims for supposedly working technologies?
- Snowdax 11y agoWhen "fake it until you make it" is a widely spread mantra, people get good at the "fake it" part.
- taberiand 11y agoAnd then realise, you never actually have to make it
- TeMPOraL 11y agoSee: the startup industry. You'll either die or get acquihired before your product will have to start to make some sense (in terms of being actually useful).
- debacle 11y agoNo real entrepreneur wants to be acquihired. It's a massive loss of freedom.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThen most startup founders are not "real entrepreneurs". Most people go for startups because it's a get-rich scheme, and whatever product that startup does is a throwaway thing, means to an end.
- 11y ago
- limaoscarjuliet 11y agoAfter some study of reactionless drive, I'm somewhat ready to accept that there is a lot to be learned about physics: http://www.gizmag.com/cannae-reactionless-drive-space-propulsion/33210/ http://www.gizmag.com/cannae-reactionless-drive-space-propul... I'm certainly open minded about LENR, although the "free" energy attract a lot of shady characters.
- simonh 11y agoHe says that failing to recreate Fleischmann and Pons' findings isn't enough reason to doubt their claims because recreating results is tricky, and implies that therefore we have no actual reason to doubt that they achieved cold fusion. But we do. Not only did their apparatus, according to their own measurements, not produce any of the radiation that would be an unavoidable byproduct of fusion, but the core also didn't contain any fusion byproducts. As a result I think it's perfectly reasonable to conclude that they could not possibly, in any if their experiments, have achieved Fusion. If their measurements of excess heat are true, whatever it's source was, it wasn't fusion.
- snowwrestler 11y agoI don't think the point of this piece is to claim Fleischmann and Pons actually succeeded. I think the point is that there is a difference between the failure of a particular experiment, and proving that all experiments in cold fusion will fail. Fleischmann and Pons was certainly not the only science experiment to produce a false positive in 1989, but it was a huge, public failure, in a research area that is filled with cranks (easy energy). I agree with the article's author that it probably tarnished an area of research that, while far-fetched, should not be automatically dismissed as impossible.
- simonh 11y agoI don't think many people are saying it's impossible. I'm not. But given the history I think its reasonable, before treating any claims in this area as credible, to either want a clear theoretical basis for a given experiment or unambiguous details on how to repeat a compelling result. In the absence of either or preferably both of those, all we are dealing with is uncorroborated and unverifiable claims which we have no reason to take seriously.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoBut that would be interesting in itself. P&N made the PR mistake of calling their process "cold fusion." If they'd called it "unexpected heat we can't explain" they'd have encountered much less hostility. Then the question wouldn't have been "Where are the neutrons?" but "Can this be replicated?" followed by "Can this be used for energy generation?" Social taint my be true strong a description. But there's huge hostility in science to experimental effects that appear to challenge existing theories without also providing a completed new theory that makes predictions and can be falsified. The further away from the mainstream the effects appear, the more hostility they generate. Which is why claiming to have found cold fusion as a result of unreliable experiments and a complete absence of a finished theory was professional suicide - even though there seems to be some kind of phenomenon there. Or at least enough of a phenomenon to be worth investigating.
- dkbrk 11y agoI think there's definitely a cultural problem where the outcome of an experiment is associated with the reputation of the scientist who performed it. We see this in the bias to publish only positive results - as though if an experiment did not make findings of significance it is a failing of the scientist who performed it - and we see this in the reluctance of many scientists to investigate that which would be very surprising if found to be true. The NASA research into the EmDrive is an excellent example of this. The discovery of a method of propulsion which does not consume onboard mass yet achieves energy efficiencies greater than that of a photon rocket would be extremely surprising, which makes it all the more important that apparent effects such as these are investigated. The correct response on seeing an unexpected experimental result is not to ignore it or to assume the experiment is wrong (although that should be treated with a high probability), but to report it and to systematically investigate the discrepancy until either the unexpected result is confirmed with a degree of evidence commensurate with its unexpectedness or the error is discovered. Extreme skepticism can be equally as bad as extreme gullibility, and it is extremely discourteous to imply or to assume the existence of fraud, or to attack the character of the researcher unless there is overwhelming evidence supporting such an aspersion. Even if it might by probabilistically justified to promote the possibility of fraud on the part of the scientist to the most likely explanation for an unexpected result, this has negative externalities on entire scientific fields and forces researchers to "stake their reputations" on publishing surprising results, which is just the sort of perverse situation we should strive to avoid.
- snowwrestler 11y agoThe NASA EmDrive research is what I thought of, as well. I found the vehemence and personal nature of the attacks on those results to be surprising, disappointing, and beyond the bounds of typical rational skepticism. Sure, it will probably turn out to be nothing, but NASA is not trying scam us. Not every investigation of weird results is a scam.
- powera 11y agoIf this is such a credible or important result, why are none of the articles about it ever from NASA or quoting NASA?
- mschuster91 11y agohold short, wasn't it proven months ago that the E-Cat "worked" by using the ground return for powering a second heating coil?
- mannykannot 11y agoAs far as I know, it hasn't been proven, as the requisite access has not been granted. Of course, Rossi could easily have disproved it as soon as the issue was raised, if it were not so. Edit: The posited arrangement is diagrammed and described here, along with other reasons to doubt: http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2013/05/21/the-e-cat-is-back-and-people-are-still-falling-for-it/ http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2013/05/21/the-e-cat...
- ScottBurson 11y agoGreat article. I'm not going to defend Rossi, but what happened in 1989 was a travesty. Yes, Pons and Fleischmann were premature in their annnouncement. But they didn't deserve to be made pariahs, and there were others whose careers were destroyed for so much as publicly entertaining the possibility that cold fusion might be made to work. Edward Teller, on the other hand, was old enough not to care: Around 1992, McKubre says, he was summoned for an audience with legendary physicist Edward Teller. "He asked probing questions, in better depth, I think, than anyone else on the planet. You could see what a giant intellect he must have been in his time. I was subjected to this interrogation for four hours. At the end of it Teller said that he did not think that cold fusion was a reality, but if it were, he could account for it with a very small change in the laws of physics as he understood them, and it would prove to be an example of nuclear catalysis at an interface. I still don't understand what he meant by that, but I'm quite willing to believe that it's correct." [0] It really shows how political and, frankly, corrupt Big Science is. As this article points out, failure to replicate proves nothing. The charitable reading is that Pons and Fleischmann didn't even know for sure what properties of the alloy they were using were critical to the reaction, though they had some ideas. That possibility should have been considered. [0] http://www.wired.com/1998/11/coldfusion/ http://www.wired.com/1998/11/coldfusion/
- Retric 11y agoEarly announcements would have been one thing, but all evidence points to these guys committing flat out fraud.
- marshray 11y agoDo you have a good link where I can read about this evidence?
- ScottBurson 11y agoWhat evidence is that?
- PeCaN 11y agoEvidence? As far as I can tell the only 'fraudulent' thing they did was jump to the conclusion of "WE MADE ENERGY WITH COLD FUSION" when they probably should've announced their result with "looks like we have some unexplained heat". They most probably were, however, understandably rather excited.
- poelzi 11y agoDatabase with cold fusion papers (very comprehensive): http://lenr-canr.org/index/Summary/Summary.php http://lenr-canr.org/index/Summary/Summary.php The BSM-SG model describes LENR fusion very well, most of the reported experiments implement one ore more of the theoretical mechanisms for successful fusion. http://www.amazon.com/Structural-Physics-Nuclear-Fusion-BSM-SG/dp/1482620030/ref=asap_bc?ie=UTF8 http://www.amazon.com/Structural-Physics-Nuclear-Fusion-BSM-... But does not make so much sense without understanding the main book.
- yc1010 11y agoThat reminds me, whatever happened to that perpetual energy machines from those "Steorn" lads from Dublin? edit: never mind I see they are still around somehow (and managed to waste millions in process) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steorn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steorn http://orbo.com/ http://orbo.com/ ------------ "Welcome to the online shop for Orbo technology, home of our "never die" battery technology-based products. We're excited to move towards bringing the first of our products to market in 2016 and revolutionising the world of consumer electronics. The battery is dead." ------------ Oo
- tommoor 11y agoAh yes.. If I'd invented a source of perpetual energy, this is exactly how I'd commercialize it too: http://orbo.com/products/ophone http://orbo.com/products/ophone
- dgreisen 11y agoThe key sentence: We are like a thirsty town, desperate for a new water supply. Our human inclination is to talk ourselves into believing the mirage. Add in the inevitable snake oil salesmen... As scientists, the more we desperately, wish for a thing to be true, the more we must demand of the evidence.
- sebringj 11y agoAt first I was like please die, cold fusion from Adobe. Then I was like oh. Nevermind.
- orthecreedence 11y agoYes, hopefully Adobe Coldfusion's "horizon" will be an event horizon.
- gnarbarian 11y agoI seem to be trapped in an orbit quite near the even horizon where time has slowed to a crawl. (5 years into a CF project)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAs you say it, I notice some parallels. A small team promotes ColdFusion as a revolution that goes against standard practices and is totally better. Most call bullshit on that with some uptake and research. A fringe builds new tech on top of ColdFusion & replications (open-source). All kinds of new, proven stuff comes out of both mainstream and comp sci over the decades. Occasionally, sales people still crop up talking about ColdFusion as a real benefit for developers. They've seen people kick ass with it. Then, the rest of us were like: "Oh, nevermind."
- rdtsc 11y agoBased on watching videos and reading about other stuff he's done: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_%28entrepreneur%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_%28entrepreneur%2... I vote for this being a scam. A very clever scam but another scam. There is in fact whole cottage industry centered around energy and battery technology. The audience for this is not us or other scientists but investors. It is about demos, videos, secrets, lots of tubes and wires, flickering lights, acting like they just discovered free energy and will revolutionize the world of physics. The goal is to make people with money believe you. In general, just because people have money doesn't mean they also know science and thus many are targets of scam artists. But the "art" part in scam art is to also pick an area that is not too confusing (brain surgery, genetics, something too theoretical, etc) or too hard but something seemingly simple -- "we make energy", "we have a new battery", "a device that produces more energy than it consumes" etc.
- steven2012 11y agoThe same thing goes for those that would dare to dispute string theory or human-caused global warming. Trying to publish any papers that defy either of those canons will likely end your career.
- MCRed 11y agoIn some circumstances yes, but I think actually that most of the papers out there disprove AGW, it's just that nobody reads them. I've read many papers given to me by AGW proponents that they claim support AGW, and in every case they don't and in most they actually support the opposite conclusion. (as do most of the scientists who have signed petitions.) As a political movement, global warming doesn't need science, politicians and advocates just declare it "settled" and thus feel they don't have to defend their claims.
- joe_the_user 11y agoOne big argument against free energy at low temperatures is that if it was possible then the natural world would have already discovered it. The other argument is that if someone has a free energy device, they actually shouldn't need to convince anyone, they could just hook it to the grid, get paid for the power, use the money to build more devices, repeat until they had a serious power company. And then they start bargaining.
- chc4 11y agoI'm not sure that argument against it holds up. For all we know some Deuterium and Palladium are hanging out in the cosmos undergoing fusion, and we would have no idea about it. There are real room temperature fusion methods[0] that can also happen in nature, but even if that method was break-even it doesn't mean Mother Nature would exploit it due to the difficulty of starting the reaction. Getting paid for power and getting enough seed money to build more generators does involve convincing people, as well, and is pretty much what Rossi has been doing. He even started his own energy company, iirc, and has been selling self-contained "generators" to people. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion
- stan_rogers 11y agoGetting paid for power doesn't involve convincing anyone but the power meter in most jurisdictions; utilities are required by law to buy customer-created surplus.
- rdtsc 11y ago> Getting paid for power and getting enough seed money to build more generators does involve convincing people, He is clearly not trying to convince anyone serious by disallowing scientists to measure using their own equipment and on their own terms and conditions. Energy production is not hard to measure and people have been metering electrical enenergy for many decades now. So far is obstructing and preventing such scrutiny. He is trying to convince only rich people to give him money. If you look at that as his goal, he is doing all the right steps in that direction. > He even started his own energy company, iirc, and has been selling self-contained "generators" to people. How many people have bought and used his device to generate power?
- jon_richards 11y agoI dislike the whole opening about "superluminal neutrinos". That announcement was asking for others to identify the issue with the testing rig, as they figured there was one but could not find it themselves. As far as I know, the only ones to claim the existence of superluminal neutrinos were the media. I agree that there is an unacceptable stigma against certain fields of research (look at how long it is taking to test the EM drive, which has been reproduced how many times already?), but I don't see a problem in not believing someone already convicted of fraud when they claim to have discovered something but won't let you see how it works. Until findings are reproduced, I give this the same level of credibility I give this guy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fEJtsC5sVZA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fEJtsC5sVZA
- powera 11y ago"There are credible reports that a 1MW version of his device, producing many times the energy that it consumes, has been on trial in an industrial plant in North Carolina for months, with good results so far." - This. This is why scientists are skeptical. "Is there a plant" isn't a hard scientific question. We don't need or care about "credible reports". It's there or it isn't. And if you refuse to admit one way or another, you're almost certainly lying about the whole damn thing.
- jacquesm 11y agoThis article is funny. It tries to do an end-run around any criticism of the subject matter by constructing an elaborate piece of work to establish that if you don't agree with the basic premise of low energy nuclear reactions there must be something pathologically wrong with you. And you are not only suffering from a defect, no you are doubly wrong, because having LENR would be such a great thing for the world. For me it is simple. If someone shows up with a working LENR device (or even any device, who cares how it works as long as it is safe) that really outputs considerable power and they are willing to sell me that power at a rate that is lower than what my electricity company charges then I'll be more than happy to sign up. Until then they, their investors and promoters should do what they can not to raise expectations beyond those that they can readily prove, no matter what the benefit to mankind and no matter how many scientists got unfairly (if so) railroaded for fudging their numbers and defrauding investors. Cold fusion, zero point energy, unicorns.
- rdtsc 11y agoYap. This is almost certainly a scam. As long as there are rich people, there will be scam artists selling them "cold fusion", "infinite energy machines", it is fascinating to watch these happen. This also creates an interesting market, just like scam artists look for marks that other scammers have deceived, there is probably someone taking notes which investors are buying into the story. Those people would be good targets for the future. "Hey psst, I got a this scientist friend working for NASA that is building a flying car running on weak nuclear force energy, he just need a bit of funding".
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> ""cold fusion", "infinite energy machines"" I don't think it's fair to lump those two together. I think we all accept the energy potential in fusion is there, and it also seems possible that the most efficient way to tap that energy is one we have yet to fully understand. The most efficient method could be found under the 'cold fusion' umbrella, and even if these methods turn out to be a different process than fusion, we still may end up learning something new anyway. For example, sonoluminescence has been linked to fusion before, but even if the processes involved end up being different to fusion, it's still an interesting process: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJolILUbdNw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJolILUbdNw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonoluminescence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonoluminescence The point is, it doesn't serve us to dismiss fields of scientific research that have some chance of bringing us a new understanding of the science involved, even if we end up scrambling around in the dark for a long time.
- rdtsc 11y agoBased on watching videos and reading about other stuff he's done: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_%28entrepreneur%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea_Rossi_%28entrepreneur%2... I vote for this being a scam. A very clever scam but another scam. There is in fact whole cottage industry centered around energy and battery technology. The audience for this is not us or other scientists but investors. It is about demos, videos, secrets, lots of tubes and wires, flickering lights, acting like they just discovered free energy and will revolutionize the world of physics. The goal is to make people with money believe you. In general, just because people have money doesn't mean they also know science and thus many are targets of scam artists. But the "art" part in scam art is to also pick an area that is not too confusing (brain surgery, genetics, something too theoretical, etc) or too hard but something seemingly simple -- "we make energy", "we have a new battery", "a device that produces more energy than it consumes" etc.
- dkural 11y agoThis finally puts aeon.co on my 'never read' list. What a poorly fact-checked piece of writing.
- mrfusion 11y agoI recently was excited to find out that cold fusion is actually real. Check it out: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion No one ever seems to mention it but it seems like it could be a promising avenue someday.
- imaginenore 11y agoIf Rossi's device really worked, he would be a moron to sell it or even show it to anybody. You can start an energy company, start small at the beginning, provide something like water heating for a small neighborhood. Then use your profits to grow exponentially until you take everyone else out of business. If you have such a device, you're only really limited by the chemical supplies (nickel powder?).
- rdlecler1 11y agoThe article seems to be lost on a large number of commenters who are asserting (or almost asserting) that this is a scam because (1) Rossi seems to have a dubious history (I'm only going by the comments, not my own investigation) and (2) Rossi is secretive (3) Rossi is not a notable scientist from a top-tier University (4) Rossi comes across as overconfident. This is what the article is pointing out. The author is saying that in this case the cost of a false positive is so incredibly low and the benefit of a positive result is so high that we should be more willing to lower our guard a little more. These kind of quick reflex objections based on red flags will be useful 99.99% of the time, but major scientific advances only occur 0.01% of the time and so maybe humanity would benefit more if we loosened up a bit on our skepticism, especially surrounding the person or the field and focus more on the science.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe quick reflex is an optimization, if it is true the proof will surface on its own strength, until then you can safely ignore it. After all, unless he's actually discovered something you're wasting your time. The burden of proof is rightly on the one making outrageous claims, there is no burden of sufferance because the positive benefits are so high. They'll be there regardless of whether one believes, after all, it works or it does not. See also: ubeam, theranos, moller and so on.
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "The quick reflex is an optimization" That's not what's happening here. The optimal response in terms of saving time is to stay neutral until stronger proof arrives. What's happening instead is people being hostile to research being conducted in a way they disagree with, or by people they disagree with. That negativity takes energy.
- rdtsc 11y agoThere is almost no reason to give him the benefit of the doubt. You could watch tv instead or go for a walk than listen to him and you'd spend your time better. Who he is matters and his past matters as well. I (some no name from the Internet) can't walk in to a public University and say, I want to be a physics professor. Sure, there is a 0.000001% I maybe be qualified and be a great professor. But my background doesn't warrant them even listning to me talk about it. They'd have as good a chance finding a professor by picking randomly from a phone book. Same thing here with this guy. > but major scientific advances only occur 0.01% ...so maybe humanity would benefit more if we loosened up a bit Yeah sure. We can loosen up a bit and maybe give NASA or some college professors random grants to go study this in more detail. As far as Rossi, we'd probably have a better chance discovering cold fusion just by taking a walk and stumbling on it. So no, in his case, based on what I've seen, it is not worth loosing up.
- gweinberg 11y agoThe article claims Rossi was given a US patent. A patent is supposed to allow a person of ordinary skill in the art to make and use the claimed invention, so in principle it should be easy to test his claims. Of course, if it works the tester will have to pay royalties.
- sdlm 11y agoCompletely different field- but I think Charles Darwin's way of "crippling potential criticism of one’s ideas by taking charge of all conceivable counterarguments" is a great example of how important rhetoric is, especially in such 'biased' areas. Just imagine what would have happened to his idea of Evolution if he had not been such a rhetoric genius. https://www.brainpickings.org/2015/11/11/adam-gopnik-angels-and-ages-darwin/ https://www.brainpickings.org/2015/11/11/adam-gopnik-angels-... "[...] the other great feature of Darwin’s prose, and the organization of his great book, is the welcome he provides for the opposed idea. This is, or ought to be, a standard practice, but few people have practiced it with his sincerity — and, at times, his guile. The habit of “sympathetic summary,” what philosophers now call the “principle of charity,” is essential to all the sciences."
- RogtamBar 11y agoRossi is very fishy, and he has no clue why his 'invention' works. Scratch that. However, these two Swedish professors Lidgren and Lundin were involved in testing Rossi's claims a few years back. Lundin is a plasma physicist at the Swedish institute for Space Physics, and has a long publication record. (https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22rickard+lundin%22&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5 https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22rickard+lundin%22&hl...) Now they've published a paper: "Nuclear Spallation and Neutron Capture Induced by Ponderomotive Wave Forcing" Here: http://www.irf.se/Publications/?dbfile=IRF%20Scientific%20Reports&dbsec=Administration http://www.irf.se/Publications/?dbfile=IRF%20Scientific%20Re... They're saying essentially that they can use heat and EM field to resonance to make solid-state materials expel a neutron. They call this "thermal neutron spallation". Which is a pretty bold statement of an entirely novel concept. They've said they're setting up an experiment to demonstrate this novel form of neutron spallation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 11y ago> They've said they're setting up an experiment to demonstrate this novel form of neutron spallation. They'd need to have some results besides Rossi and then others would need to replicate it, and then replicate it again by yet another team for it to start being believable and taken seriously. Not a physicist, just a regular computer programmer, but reading that paper I see some pretty serious claims -- matter transmutting to different elements (isotope formation), neutron emission and capture, at 2000'C environment, there are claims about having 1-10 kWh generators running for years with a few grams of fuel only.
- scotty79 11y agoRossi contraption is just that (or not, as long as it's not scientifically open no-one should care). What I'm curious about is this: http://animpossibleinvention.com/2015/10/15/swedish-scientists-claim-lenr-explanation-break-through/ http://animpossibleinvention.com/2015/10/15/swedish-scientis... Guys basically claim they found a way to create free neutrons at lowest possible energy cost, published a paper and even ran some initial experiments.
- tomconroy 11y agoCould someone explain how Rossi's device is different from recent fusion reactor experiments? http://www.ipp.mpg.de/3984226/12_15 http://www.ipp.mpg.de/3984226/12_15
- intrasight 11y agoI am confused as to the author's justification for seeming to give credence to a thoroughly discredited person. It would have been a better article if he had just stuck with "the science says it is possible just not probable" instead of discussing Rossi. And no mention of Pistol Shrimp - I am disappointed.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWhy Pistol Shrimp? Other than them being cool as heck if the claims about them are true.
- nkurz 11y agoI can't find any high-quality single page that gives the history, but here's a low-quality one that explains the connection: http://twistedphysics.typepad.com/cocktail_party_physics/2007/06/running_hot_and.html http://twistedphysics.typepad.com/cocktail_party_physics/200... Basically, pistol shrimp "attacks" produce a small burst of light (sonoluminesence). There was a theory that this was actually a form of fusion (sonofusion). There were some studies done that demonstrated this (Taleyarkhan, 2002). But there were lots of irregularities about the study (Naranjo, 2006), and like cold fusion it's been (mostly?) discredited.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI like her writing style. Fun read. Never heard of sonofusion or thought about using sonoluminesence for it. Sounds like some potential albeit with careful measurements & checks. Something that odd & difficult to measure is likely to trip people up anyway. Just the nature of the thing.
- youngButEager 11y agoRossi is a known liar. He has been jailed for it. It has been far too long for independent confirmation of the claim. After all, it's in his best interest to be proven correct. He is a fraud. The fact that he's taken outside investment means he's a convincing fraud. And that is how he puts food on his table. Not from commercializing his 'findings.' He'd be a wealthy man indeed, years ago, had this turned out to be true. It's thus in his best interest to line up/support independent verification -- for years now -- and yet no independent verification exists. Move on, it's bunk.
- anupshinde 11y agoLENR, if possible, will have a much bigger impact on global economy - may even transform the way economies works. Its not just clean energy, but think about the impacts of artificial transmutation. Also if LENR is possible, it also means that some or all of the biological life possesses this capacity and it could be an undiscovered fundamental natural occurrence. BUT - all of this sounds too good to be true :( Fundamental discoveries have pretty much slowed down and it is very natural to be skeptical about these.
- mrb 11y agoI really wish people would stop discarding the idea of nickel-hydrogen cold fusion just because Rossi has a bad reputation. So I am happy when I see cautiously positive articles like this one. Firstly, those who research this domain are fully aware that cold fusion is impossible according to theoretical physics. But experiments trump theory. And as I have written about it 4 years ago (http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=61 http://blog.zorinaq.com/?e=61) the fact is there are experiments conducted by multiple other groups of researchers that demonstrate anomalous heat being produced by nickel-hydrogen cells. Not only this anomalous heat cannot be explained by current physics but there are clues that nuclear fusion is taking place (some nickel atoms being transformed into copper atoms). Unfortunately the controversy about this entire area of research is amplified by the fact that many of these experiments are very hard to reproduce. Research has made some progress over the last 4 years, and my opinion has not changed: whatever mechanism is taking place, it seems to be able to unleash fantastic amounts of energy from very little material. We just need more researchers to look at into it and understand it.
- powera 11y agoOn the other hand, there aren't billions of dollars to be made in a cottage industry from cranks claiming that fusion-like setups cause things to actually get cooler or that some form of reverse-fusion occurs. So if you have enough people looking hard enough and only publishing the best results, you'll definitely get "experiments" which show "anomalous heat". And they will definitely be "hard to reproduce" since they're just noise.
- aetherson 11y agoI don't disbelieve in cold fusion, the EM drive, superluminal anything, solve-all-problems nanotech, or the singularity because of the reputation of scientists. I disbelieve them because pessimism. They're just such... "wouldn't it be great if" results. Wouldn't it be great if we had cheap, limitless, clean energy? Wouldn't it be great if we were not subject to the tyranny of the rocket equation? Wouldn't it be great if the stars really were in reach? Wouldn't it be great if all material needs were going to be met in the next generation? Wouldn't it be great if we were going to achieve godhead? It would be great. It's so great that I just don't see it happening. It sounds like a myth people tell themselves. This is admittedly not a logically coherent dismissal. But you can't derive anything from base principles, and if you have to have a heuristic, I think it's a more useful heuristic than a reputation-based one.
- murbard2 11y agoWouldn't it be great if we could produce fertilizer out of air? Wouldn't it be great if we could get energy by just digging in the ground? Wouldn't it be great if we could just prevent polio with a simple injection? Wouldn't it be great if we could travel by just flying over the ocean?
- aetherson 11y agoSure. It's a heuristic, not a logical proof. And, I mean, we can't get energy just by digging in the ground. We didn't just poof, start flying over the ocean. We don't produce fertilizer just poof out of the air. Also: we knew before the Wright brothers that heavier-than-air flight was possible (birds). We didn't go from nothing to oil-fired modern powerplants in one step. If someone had claimed to generate electricity from something random in the ground -- even inefficiently -- without piggybacking on centuries of preexisting power generation technology, I'd probably have been skeptical. And my skepticism would probably have been justified.
- murbard2 11y agoWe know from biology that nanoscale factories are feasible, we know from human intelligence that AI is feasible, we know from Newtonian mechanics that space elevators are feasible, we know from stars that fusion is feasible.
- sandebert 11y agoConsidering this intersects Rossi, the E-Cat reactor and Sweden, it might be interesting to know that Rossi and his claimed invention is quite controversial in Swedish media. Searching for his name on Sveriges Radio (Swedish Public Radio): http://sverigesradio.se/sida/sok.aspx?q=andrea+rossi http://sverigesradio.se/sida/sok.aspx?q=andrea+rossi ...gives these results (with my very short translated snippets): --------------- Blind faith in cold fusion (2014-05-27) "Andrea Rossi claims his machine works using cold fusion, yet scientists cannot look into the machine or get all test data. Even though this, established Swedish physicists have written positive reports about Rossis machine." http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/375904?programid=412 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/375904?programid=412 --------------- Scientists helped suspected con-man to sell miracle machine (2014-05-27) "I realize he's using us." http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=406&artikel=5872983 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=406&arti... --------------- Negative results were never published (2014-05-28) "Andrea Rossi's alleged miracle machine, the E-Cat reactor, has been tested at Uppsala University. But no results of the test or the circumstances surrounding it have been published. Even at the [Swedish] Natural History Museum has an important study been made to suggest that Rossi's allegations are not true. Again, nothing have been published." http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/375957?programid=41 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/375957?programid=41 --------------- Andrea Rossi paid air plane tickets for Swedish scientists to Italy (2014-05-30) "The visit resulted in a very positive report" http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=406&artikel=5876160 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=406&arti... --------------- Swedish scientists on paid trip for E-Cat reactor (2014-06-17) "A believer ignores all arguments. Despite all the warning bells a half-dozen researchers at Uppsala University and the Royal Institute of Technology continue to cooperate with Andrea Rossi to try to find out about his alleged power device email catalyst functions." http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/396095?programid=412 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/avsnitt/396095?programid=412 --------------- All of the links above contains the actual radio episodes, in Swedish only though. There are more articles about him in Swedish media, these are just from our NPR. And please understand that my translated snippets are just meant to give a small taste of the content of the radio episode, you obviously need to listen to it go get the full content. :)
- blazespin 11y agoWow, 154 comments and complete and utter cluelessness. Yikes. Seriously people, why are you commenting on a complex subject you clearly know very very little about? I suggest you go read the articles on lenr-canr.org before any further commenting. Better yet, get back to your day job. You have no idea how little you know about this subject. http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/mt-stupid.png http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/mt-s... Fact: Cold fusion is a phenomenon that has been studied by 100s of scientists and replicated 1000s of times by folks as diverse as the Navy and Toyota and published in many many different and respected journals.
- SAM4321 11y agoGET READY THE COLD FUSION TRAIN IS ABOUT TO LEAVE THE STATION
- SAM4321 11y agoGET READY THE COLD FUSION TRAIN IS ABOUT TO LEAVE THE STATION.
- brianmcconnell 11y agoCold Fusion is _real_. It powered my website back in the 1990s. Where have all of you been since then?