9 ms·
A visualisation of all of the money in the world
- retube 11y agoThe derivatives piece is totally wrong of course. Gross Notional is a completely meaningless number - it does not represent what value is owed or how much risk there is. E.g GS could have 1tr of gross notional of derivatives with JP but with zero risk or monies owed if the positions all offset (as indeed in real life they do, banks run very little net exposure). But of course newspapers and grotty rags like to perpetuate this narrative that derivatives are going to blow up the world.
- jliptzin 11y agoI was thinking the exact same thing and came here to point this out.
- daveguy 11y agoWell, to be fair, derivatives almost did blow up the world in 2008. Definitely overestimated in terms of impact, but really something we should have a better handle on.
- retube 11y agoExcept that derivatives were not the cause of the financial crisis. Over-enthusiastic mortgage lending to poor borrowers caused the financial crisis.
- RobertoG 11y agoOver-enthusiastic mortgage lending to poor borrowers without risk, because the risk was wisely managed and diversified through perfectly designed, financial, innovative products that covered all the bases (for a nice commission, of course).
- retube 11y agoYes but those products (Mortgage backed Securities) are cash products, like a bond or equity, NOT a derivative.
- RobertoG 11y agoDepends on the definition. The wikipedia editors think it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_%28finance%29#Mortgage-backed_securities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_%28finance%29#Mortg...
- skylan_q 11y agoThe mortgages everything was based on were junk, because they were guaranteed by the GSEs that couldn't handle the rate and size of the defaults on junk mortgages. Everything based on junk mortgages were junk.
- daveguy 11y agoThat is one part of it. Those mortgages could be blended into derivatives, which could then be run up in a speculative bubble. Pretending there was a single cause for the financial crisis is a little disingenuous on both our parts.
- retube 11y agowhat does "blended into derivatives" mean? Yes mortgages were sold on a packaged up into MBS (Mortgage back securities), but these are cash products, like a bond or equity, NOT a derivative.
- maxerickson 11y agoThere were MBSs built by splitting bundles of other MBSs into various tranches. Those certainly seem to be derivatives. What would they be called if they aren't derivatives?
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoPortfolios. There are synthetic MBSs, too. Those are derivatives. They were also relatively uncommon.
- retube 11y ago> What would they be called if they aren't derivatives? Securitised bonds, which is a cash product. The distinction between a cash & derivative product is really simple - one is leveraged the other isn't. E.g if I buy 100m of MBS I actually have to cough up 100m in cash - I am buying both the interest and principal repayments of the underlying mortgages. On the other hand if I enter into an interest rate swap with 100m notional I don't pay anything at all (assuming traded at spot market levels, and ignoring initial margin). The risk, or sensitivity, to interest rates is the same on both, but am only paying out cash for the securitised bond. Hence the bond, or MBS is "cash" and the swap is "derivative".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jackcosgrove 11y agoDerivatives did exacerbate the unwinding of the mortgage mess, because the chain of title was so convoluted. I've read reports of people who were given homes in south Florida because the owners of mortgage debt were unable to finish foreclosure proceedings before the statute of limitations ran out. That is an extreme case, but the milder case of banks being landlords when that's not what they're good at, plus borrowers being stuck in foreclosure limbo longer than should be necessary, introduces unnecessary friction in the economy that wastes time and money. This could be the self-regulating limit for derivatives - the legal time required to unwind them in the case of mass redemptions, bounded by the business cycle length and statute of limitations for a locality.
- mullingitover 11y agoWeren't the banks selling each other credit default swaps they couldn't cover, such that the moment a single bank went under it triggered the collapse of the entire banking system? Blaming the mortgage lending is like saying, "I didn't blow up the neighborhood with my unsupervised warehouse full of explosives, it was those damn kids playing with matches!"
- sxcurry 11y agoSome economists call this view "The Big Lie". See Krugman's column today: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/18/opinion/the-big-short-housing-bubbles-and-retold-lies.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/18/opinion/the-big-short-hou...
- hueylewis0 11y agoThis. Makes me question the rest of the graphic's accuracy.
- jackcosgrove 11y agoI understand how positions can offset and cancel each other out. What I don't understand is if the notional value is never fully redeemed, why use leverage at all? That is, if only the spot prices are used to actually exchange money, why inflate the value of a trade with leverage? I apologize if I'm misusing terms - I'm not a finance expert. The only explanation I can think of is that leverage is used to exploit dumb money that isn't hedged correctly. In which case, leverage is a barrier to entry that diminishes the number of participants in a market and reinforces cartel behavior. Which I would think is a bad thing.
- asbromberg 11y agoWell, leverage is kind of a separate is from whether or not your entering into a derivative contract or making an investment in the underlying asset. Bu the simple answer is, the more you lever up any investment, the more money you stand to make.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoOr lose.
- retube 11y agoThe notional is purely a reference amount. For the vast majority of derivatives the notional amount is never exchanged (cross-currency basis swaps being a notable exception). E.g a simple interest rate swap: I agree to pay you 2% per annum on a reference notional of 100m for 10 years, and in exchange you pay me libor referencing the same notional. At the end of first year let's say libor fixes at 1.98%. Hence I pay you a net 0.02% (2% - 1.98%) of 100m, i.e 20,000. We do this every year for 10 years. It is just a way to hedge interest rate exposure - e.g I have borrowed 100m paying a Libor-linked interest rate and don't want to run the risk that Libor spikes to 10% or whatever. There's nothing complicated about this, at least in principle. Derivatives just allow people to hedge out exposures they don't want.
- jackcosgrove 11y ago
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoGood, concise illustration from Reddit: "If Powerball sells 1 million tickets at 2$ each, where the jackpot is worth 200,000,000$, is the size of that market 2M$ or 200 trillion $" [1] [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/3xb2xh/all_of_the_worlds_money_and_markets_in_one/cy3b623 https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/3xb2xh/all_of_th...
- rayiner 11y agoI'll note that the article doesn't have a giant box for the combined value of all insurance policies, maybe because it's obvious that having $100,000 liability policy for your car insurance doesn't sound technical and scary like "derivative." What blows my mind is that it seems like everyone in the media has taken this obviously incorrect premise and run with it.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe problem with derivatives is that they are functionally very similar or identical to insurance. But, because they are sold under a different name, the capital requirements for selling insurance do not apply. Insurance is less scary for a reason. Higher capital requirements, and less concentration of risk, means that insurance can't blow up the world economy.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThat's not a market at all. That's a $198,000,000 giveaway.
- xixi77 11y agoWell, not quite -- if odds of winning are in fact around 1 in 200MM or less, there is no market failure here. Their point would still stand if they sold 100MM tickets though, so as not to confuse the two issues (ie. the notional amount and the expected value), perhaps it would have been a better example that way.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago
- demallien 11y agoIf this was true, Lehman Brothers would still be in operation today. Derivatives, by their very nature, are harder to truly evaluate in terms of value, and the chance of them going horribly wrong has already been demonstrated as being non-zero (see GFC).
- retube 11y agoLehman went bust because liquidity in the credit markets dried up - i.e they were unable to roll short-term financing to fund longer-dated balance sheet. The markets thought Lehman had big exposure to the US residential and commercial mortgages, hence they couldn't borrow, hence they went bust. A shame because they weren't actually bankrupt - PWC has now recovered 100% of liabilities with assets to spare.
- jackcosgrove 11y agoHow long did the recovery take? PWC recovered those assets now, rather than then. In the mean time there was a huge reflation of the stock and housing markets, powered by the Federal Reserve in the short term and a return of confidence in the medium term. You can't treat mass psychology as an externality. Austerian policies rely in part on disciplining debtors to restore confidence in market transparency and the rule of law. If thousands of households lost their homes when their cash flow could not meet their debt payments, why shouldn't a bank go bankrupt when its cash flow cannot meet its debt payments? Lehman was just the bank that couldn't find a seat when the music stopped, and that's fair.
- AngrySkillzz 11y agoYes, but that has nothing to do with the notional value of derivatives or derivatives "blowing up." They had a liquidity crisis because of fear; people stopped trusting their commercial paper and were skeptical of lending to them with repos backed by difficult-to-value mortgage-backed securities.
- demallien 11y ago"The markets thought Lehman had big exposure to the US residential and commercial mortgages, hence they couldn't borrow, hence they went bust." This is the sort of thing I mean when I say derivatives are hard to evaluate correctly. So yeah, Lehmans totally went bust because of their large amounts of trading in CDS.
- chishaku 11y agoComparisons of gross national to other measures of value or risk aside, isn't the point that the risks inherent in this magnitude of derivatives trading are simply not understood? "Blowing up the world" might be hyperbole. On the other hand, these markets are mostly unregulated. Does anyone really understand the systemic risk posed by this segment of the market?
- lordnacho 11y agoThis is exactly right. People are confusing risk with notional. There's no risk adjustment anywhere, but clearly the values need to be adjusted for how much they might change. The cash will be (by construction) the same tomorrow, but the shares could easily vary by a few percent.
- scyclow 11y agoI agree with this, but let's not forget about the counterparty risk making the interconnected financial system so fragile. If GS offsets its [long position with JP] with a [short position with Citi], and Citi goes under, GS is screwed.
- retube 11y agoyeah but most interbank dealing is collaterised now so little counterparty credit risk left (altho this does arguably just shift counterparty risk to funding risk, but that's another story...)
- api 11y agoIn a more ELI5 sense, would it be true to say that derivatives are not "real money" in the same sense that company valuations are not? Company valuations are projections created through some combination of extrapolation of growth or value and (often in the earlier stages) just agreeing on a number to make the percentages and such work out correctly. They are expressed as a dollar amount but those are not real dollars.
- msvan 11y agoAny book recommendations for someone without a background in finance who wants to understand more about derivatives and related concepts?
- vadman 11y agoVeale is one of the widely recommended authors: http://www.amazon.com/Stuart-R.-Veale/e/B001IOBOR0 http://www.amazon.com/Stuart-R.-Veale/e/B001IOBOR0 specifically this book: http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=veale+stocks+bonds http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dst...
- criley2 11y ago"But of course newspapers and grotty rags like to perpetuate this narrative that derivatives are going to blow up the world." It's no secret that Warren Buffet is strongly against these derivative products and considers them to be one of the most dangerous financial products in history. So why is he "perpetuating the narrative" as you dismissively claim? I want to bring him up because you're hiding behind attacking the newspaper and "rags", so let's instead point to one of the most successful investors in modern history who agrees. Why is he wrong? Please don't hide behind dismissal and attacks, as a man of Warren Buffets caliber has proven through real world demonstration that he possess a vast understanding of these markets and products.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cheez 11y agoSomething as simple as a swap is a derivative. Swaps are common and no doubt some of Warren Buffet's businesses use FX swaps to avoid being exposed to currency fluctuations. What would be intensely interesting would be if that derivatives number was broken down by type of derivative. That would be something worth discussing.
- steveplace 11y agoBuffett trades derivatives.
- hodwik 11y agoBuffet doesn't like what he can't value.
- resc1440 11y agoNormally you're right that no net exposure implies no risk. However, you've completely forgotten the financial crisis? Counterparty risk can completely destroy the idea of "all positions are offset". If I buy a derivative and then re-sell it for a profit, that's fine until the people I bought it from suddenly go under, and now my position is not protected anymore!
- hodwik 11y agoRead this critique on Reddit this morning. Thought it was interesting. Sharing here: "Ah, this misleading derivatives stuff again... In two steps: Firstly, I'll use as an example something called an interest rate swap. If you have a loan with floating rate interest payments, then this lets you change that to a fixed interest rate of say 4%. As follows: The lender requires you to pay floating rate interest. The swap is an agreement with a third party derivatives guy that you should receive a floating rate from him and pay fixed to him. So every month you will receive whatever the floating rate is from the derivatives guy, and pay a fixed rate to him - and the floating you receive pass on to the guy charging interest on the loan. For example: the loan has a floating rate payment which at the moment is 4%, and you agree with the derivatives guy that you should pay him a fixed rate of 4% and will receive whatever the floating rate is. If the floating rate rises to 8%, then you pay the derivatives guy 4% and receive 8% and pass those 8% on to the lender. If the floating rate falls to 2%, you pay the derivatives guy 4% and receive 2% and pass those on to the lender. But 4% of what? For the calculation to work, you need a monetary amount to calculate 4% of. That is the notional. You receive cash of the floating rate * the notional, and pay cash 4% * the notional. You need some way to translate the percent into actual cash payments and that happens through the notional. If your loan is 10m, then the notional amount you want is probably 10m. If you only want half fixed half floating, then you can set the notional amount to 5m. But the notional amount is just the basis used for calculation. It's not "money". It's a figure plugged into a formula. The notional isn't put into the bank and can't be withdrawn from it, and at the end of the period of interest payments the notional isn't there anymore because its only purpose was to calculate those interest payments. If someone wanted to they could break that entire counting system by simply making a swap with a notional of 1 centillion dollars and deciding the payment isi equal to 5% * notional / 1 centillion. If you wanted to swap 100m USD you would need 100m of these contracts for a notional of 100 million centillion dollars. The actual money changing hands is nowhere near the notional. Secondly: Sometimes people use derivatives for speculation. What they can do is enter a contract and then after prices change they enter the opposite contract. For example: contracts for oil 6 months from now are $50 per barrel. Someone buys contracts for 50 million barrels. Then the price changes to $60 per barrel. He then sells contracts for 50 million barrels. The only practical effect of this trade is that he receives a cash sum today. In 6 months nothing happens - they are automatically matched and offset. In this case the notional amount would be the price of 50 million barrels of oil times 2. Now, it's possible to do this at high speed. So rather than wait until the next day, he enters a contract and then the opposite seconds or milliseconds from each other. As long as the buying and the selling is for the same amount, this could make for an arbitrarily high notional. There are absolutely risks in derivatives. For example, what happens if one party loses enough money to go bankrupt and all the bonds they placed as security for that event isn't enough to cover the loss. But the notional amount is not a good place to start to understand risks. Like, every type of derivative will have its own rules for how the notional translates into actual cash - e.g. for an oil contract it would be the full value of the oil, and for an interest rape swap it would just be the amount that's multiplied by the percentage. Not someone who works with this daily, but covered it quite well in studies."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DennisP 11y agoInteresting that there's more debt than money. Apparently a lot of money is borrowed to lend out.
- RobertoG 11y agoMoney is govern liability, so is already debt when is created. Also, all the debt is a liability for the debtor but an asset for the creditor. We could just change the label in the graph.
- jackcosgrove 11y agoDebt is backed by assets, which were undercounted by this graphic. I'd be very interested to see the estimated value of residential real estate compared to the derivatives market.
- DennisP 11y agoYes but if I get a mortgage, the amount of debt issued is equal to the amount of money I get by taking on that debt. The fact that the debt is secured by the real estate doesn't change that.
- bunnymancer 11y agoDebt grows over time. Money doesn't. Sadly. Interest is interesting, so to speak.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Money doesn't. Of course it does: https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/M1SL https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/M1SL
- harryh 11y agoMoney is debt.
- DennisP 11y ago
- nopinsight 11y agoConsidering that the nominal value of above-ground gold reserves is comparable to that of commercial real estate worldwide, it looks overvalue to me. There is so much productive use of commercial real estate, while gold is at best a medium of exchange and quite an inconvenient one relative to coins and banknotes. (Gold's industrial value is much lower than this and arguably its psychic value would not hold up well without its liquidity as money.)
- djhn 11y agoIf it looks overvalued to you, you should short it and test your intuition. Any amount that fits your risk profile.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoI imagined for whatever reason that if one would account the 'global economy' as a closed system then debt + value would come at a balance. Didn't consider derivates as holding such a huge value. That also mean most of the debt is backed by gambling with production yield, which is scary.
- Someone1234 11y agoI'm surprised Bill Gates is the richest individual again. I thought he gave away so much money that it pushed him off the top #5 list a while ago? Is his fortune largely tied to Microsoft's share price?
- pmelendez 11y agoActually no... most of his fortune is split in several other investment since a while ago. I guess being friends with Warren Buffett helps :)
- logicallee 11y agoit would be funny if Bill Gates' bridge hobby ended up making him $30,000,000,000 over his lifetime. (he was buffett's bridge partner.)
- cs702 11y agoFun mental experiment: Should the world ever value the global stock of Bitcoin similarly to gold, Bitcoin's market capitalization would increase by around 1,300 times, from ~$6 billion to ~$7.8 trillion, and the price per Bitcoin would increase from around $460/BTC to around $600,000/BTC, give or take. If this sounds "crazy," consider that in many ways, Bitcoin is more convenient than physical gold: it's cheaper to secure, transport, and hide; and unlike gold, it's backup-able. -- On a related note, here are some additional thoughts on Bitcoin I wrote four years ago, when its price was $9/BTC: https://cs702.wordpress.com/2011/05/29/on-the-potential-adoption-and-price-appreciation-of-bitcoin-in-the-long-run/ https://cs702.wordpress.com/2011/05/29/on-the-potential-adop...
- bunnymancer 11y agoBitcoin is, however, unlike gold, not a physically limited resource, which is what makes gold a more functional trading goods. The entire concept of economy relies on the belief that an item without value can be used to represent value. Which is only accomplished through the belief of rarity.
- Hortinstein 11y agoBitcoin does have a mechanism to mirror this though. The rate of discovery halves every 4 years and only 21 million will ever be issued. When the blockchain was started 50 Bitcoins per block were awarded until november 2012 when it was halved to 25. It is predicted to half again in 2017. https://en.bitcoin.it/w/index.php?title=Controlled_supply&redirect=no https://en.bitcoin.it/w/index.php?title=Controlled_supply&re...
- morgante 11y agoBitcoin is just as rare as gold (in fact, rarer). Mining only happens at a certain rate (you can't just materialize Bitcoins out of thin air) and it is capped at 21 million total.
- mynameisvlad 11y agoYou do know where gold comes from, right? From real, physical mines. It's not like you can materialize it out of thin air either (well, strictly speaking, you can, but it's not feasible currently) and there's a limited supply; however much is in the earth.
- Raphmedia 11y agoxkcd did it before https://xkcd.com/980/ https://xkcd.com/980/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- david927 11y agoAccording to this, there are 1 billion ounces (35,000 tonnes) of silver and 186,000 tonnes of gold. But... I thought gold was rarer than silver. Edit: I wonder if it has something to do with the fact that silver (unlike gold) is consumed in manufacturing processes such as photography.
- andrepd 11y agoIn a similar vein, going more in-depth: https://xkcd.com/980/ https://xkcd.com/980/
- alejohausner 11y agoI like xkcd's visualization better, because the quantities are displayed logarithmically: each part of xkcd's visualization uses squares which represent 1000 times more money than the previous part's squares.
- Twisell 11y agoI immediately though about this XKCD post. Does they mention it in the article? Not going to say it's a ripoff, but I can't imagine that the didn't get inspired by it.
- byteorder 11y agoMy experience is that big tech company jobs are much better than at the typical startup. I got my first job working for one of the big 3 tech companies a couple of years ago after a long string of startups that failed or fizzled going back to the dot-com days. I always felt like I was making reasonable-to-good base salary at startups with the potential to hit it big with stock options. Starting my job as a regular IC at big tech company was immediately an eye opener. Out of the gate my base salary was 10% higher than I made as a manager at my most recent startup. With bonus and publicly traded stock value after a year, I was making ~50% more and stock becoming even more valuable over time. My first startup was great as I went in at 25 with no college and only self taught tech skills. In hindsight, this was a great (probably only) way to start but pivoting to big tech would have been a better move instead of trying to strike it rich at a startup.
- nsajko 11y agoWrong thread.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- swiley 11y agoCan't zoom.
- xixi77 11y agoNice chart, although it would be really important to see references to the data sources and more notes on methodology (at the very least, they should have included dates on which the valuations were measured! Also, how exactly do we define "debt" and how is it computed/where is it referenced from?) Also, the "Rest of the World" stock market capitalization is much larger than I would have expected, since it seems to exclude the largest exchanges (US+Europe+China+Japan). It would be nice to see a more detailed breakdown of that; perhaps I should do one :) I would guess India+Brazil should be pretty large combined, and there are probably companies with tiny & illiquid float trading on obscure exchanges, but large capitalizations. And yes, as another commenter noted, using the notional for derivatives valuation is really quite misleading -- I guess this is the easiest number to compute, and is probably the one supporting the point they are trying to make, but there should at least be more of a note telling people about it. Still, nice work! It's good to see things in perspective.
- graham1776 11y agoAs the commercial real estate guy, I am wondering where resisdential real estate is. Also think there are quite a few asset classes left out of this chart (although it is awesome!). CalPERS (one of the largest worldwide pension funds) does an awesome annual report showing thier holdings. For me it is an awesome way to see all the different ways one can invest. Link: https://www.calpers.ca.gov/docs/forms-publications/annual-investment-report-2014.pdf https://www.calpers.ca.gov/docs/forms-publications/annual-in...
- kazinator 11y agoSo now if we just square that, we get all evil in the world!
- simonswords82 11y agoWhen I scrolled down and saw that derivatives were so large by an order of magnitude I was reminded of this awesome 2010 Oscar winning documentary that I only watched a couple of weeks ago: Inside Job: https://archive.org/details/cpb20120505a https://archive.org/details/cpb20120505a It's about how US executives created the financial crisis back in 2008 and is pretty relevant here. I'd well recommend watching it...some of the information provided is uniquely depressing and terrifying.
- MichaelGG 11y agoWow, really puts into perspective the quote on Starfighters.io: Willie Sutton: "I rob banks because that's where the money is." You: "Amateur."
- ChicagoDave 11y agoOnce you taste the life of self-employment, you will never go back to working as an employee.