5 ms·
The thing I'm still looking for: proof that VR has crossed from novelty to something useful. Maybe somebody here has seen it? Take drones as an example. For ye
by wpietri 11y ago
The thing I'm still looking for: proof that VR has crossed from novelty to something useful. Maybe somebody here has seen it?
Take drones as an example. For years, people were buying them purely on novelty value. But now you can see actual commercial demand in agriculture and in filmmaking.
As a counterexample, take Google Glass. Tens or hundreds of thousands of units sold. But every time I asked somebody what they were using it for, I got answers like "it's so cool!" Once the novelty value wore off, they got put in drawers and never used again.
As a third, take smartwatches. When the Pebble came out, it was all novelty hype. But gradually people found uses. It's not a massive revolution, but there's enough of a market there for a small number of companies to have modest success.
So far, everything I've seen for VR mirrors the '90s wave of VR enthusiasm: lots of "erhmegerd 3D" and "think of the future", but no evidence of workaday value. People have theories of what that will be, but no proof. It could be too early, of course; sometimes technologies take time to find markets. But by now with hundreds of thousands of devices in circulation, I'd expect to see some proof from early commercial adopters. Is it out there?
- danielvf 11y agoElite Dangerous is really fun with a Rift. It's not a novelty that you tire if after an hour, it's fundamentally a better experience. Taking of the rift after an hour or two in Elite Dangerous makes everything on your screen feel flat and lifeless. It's like the difference between the color and black and white portions of the Wizard of Oz.
- wpietri 11y agoAh, this is in the neighborhood of what I'm after, thanks. Personal testimonial is good, but what I'm looking for is evidence that a significant number of people are paying up for this experience and continue to do so. As an example, consider 3D movies and television sets. For a while, many vendors were touting them as the next big thing, and you could find plenty of people who'd talk about well done 3D as an amazing experience. But now it's the rare movie that bothers with 3D, and manufacturers have mostly given up. There just was never the significant consumer enthusiasm that there was around, say, color film and color television.
- bsenftner 11y agoI believe the killer app is going to be journalism, and not really VR but simply 360 video streamed from political and social hotspots around the globe. Political uprising in country X? Celebrity overdose/break-up/marriage? Observe in real time as if you are there via captured 360 video. For the technologists interested in virtual world virtual reality, it will be a let down. But for the majority of the public, 360 video will be VR. It will get more interesting for us technologists when multiple 360 video streams captured in the same space can be merged in a Photosynth like fashion to create a true virtual space one can navigate independent of any individual 360 video stream. That will be very much "true RV" and of actual places and actual events. Journalism is, IMHO, the VR killer app.
- wpietri 11y agoNo offense, but this is in the "think of the future" category. It's an interesting idea, but ideas definitely aren't proof.
- modeless 11y agoVR has a clear application in 3D modeling and CAD. I believe VR could make 3D modeling as accessible as word processing. The software doesn't exist yet, but it will come.
- wpietri 11y agoThat is a plausible theory, but it is definitely not the proof I'm seeking. Stereoscopic 3D has had 150 years of people saying it will change X. But so far it has never changed X.
- modeless 11y agoHave you used an HTC Vive or Oculus Touch controller?
- wpietri 11y agoIf I had, it wouldn't matter. Lots of smart people have been sucked in by novelty experiences to say, "OMG REVOLUTION" and then been wrong. E.g., Google Glass or the Segway. Heck, I thought Gopher [1] was the best thing ever and would change the world [2]. And I've made the mistake a number of times since. With, e.g., Jobs's NeXT. [3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gopher_%28protocol%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gopher_%28protocol%29 [2] And it was the best thing ever, but that's not enough to change the world. [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXT_Computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeXT_Computer
- modeless 11y agoWell if you always wait for market confirmation before getting involved with something you'll never reap the benefits of getting in early. Personally I have a bit more confidence in my own ability to tell the BS from the real deal. If other people were wrong about the Segway or Google Glass that doesn't necrssarily make me wrong about VR.
- wpietri 11y ago
- 1457389 11y agoI think we may be seeing the beginning of that proof in the way the Gear VR sold out in hours.
- wpietri 11y agoDefinitely not. Google Glass was always in high demand -- by people who had never used it. Brewster stereoscopes [1] were a smash hit at the Great Exhibition of 1851 [2]. 250,000 were sold in short order. But they fell out of fashion soon enough. 3D has a long history of being an exciting innovation that will change everything. But so far, the most successful and long-lasting stereoscopic product is the ViewMaster, which has become a sort of eternal novelty. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereoscope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereoscope [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Exhibition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Exhibition
- corysama 11y agohttp://archvirtual.com http://archvirtual.com is an early VR commercial success story. Early, as in they jumped on board as soon as the DK1 was released.
- wpietri 11y agoInteresting! From their website, I'm not seeing anything that I'd consider useful proof. Plenty of people were successful selling Brewster stereoscopes, but that was basically a novelty business, not something with sustained commercial or recreational use.
- hammerandtongs 11y agoYou seem to be somewhat conflating "mass consumer adoption" and "useful". I'm not a fan of Facebook's mass consumer adoption strategy, I don't think it's ready. I am very long VR over time but I think we are at the Palm Pilot stage not the iphone stage. Metaphors are not precise in these matters but perhaps that one is useful to you. The input devices are a huge part of the story for VR and the 3d/VR wand controllers ie Oculus Touch and the Steam Lighthouse controllers are only in the hands of a few hundred people at this point. We've had 2-3 years of tens of thousands of headsets but terrible input solutions so far. That has produced shoddy demos and kiosk applications because of the lack of good input into the 3d environment. Facebook is doubling down on this terribleness by going to mass consumer launch using xbox one controllers. As others have mentioned, VR is transformative when the input solution fits. Elite Dangerous with HOTAS controllers. Several driving games with steering wheels, Dirt Rally is great fun. Amazing experiences for more serious simulation games. With proper 3d wands there are a number of new serious game types that will be very compelling but the content needs to be designed from scratch with VR input in mind. As the serious creative applications (ie Blender or Maya3d, CAD/engineering,medical/science visualization, music etc.) actually get accurately tracked 3d wands I think we will see some transformative creation experiences. After laying out vertexes in a properly designed VR application I think people won't go back, for example. Trading desks and financial sectors probably have a lot of territory to explore as the screen pixel density improves. TLDR; The money in VR is largely seeking AngryBirdsVR but I don't think that's going to happen soonish.
- wpietri 11y agoJust to be clear, I'm not looking for mass consumer adoption. I'm looking for the initial signals that prove that somebody is getting sufficient value that it's not just a novelty. E.g., the agricultural uses of drones are not mass market, but they're not just "OMG drone". The Palm Pilot is an interesting example, but as somebody who had one, they were actually getting used. I used mine daily. When I broke my first, I bought a second. There was also quite a lot of third-party software, including a robust commercial market. E.g.: https://web.archive.org/web/19991003055719/http://www.zenithair.com/ppilot/ https://web.archive.org/web/19991003055719/http://www.zenith...
- rfnozama 11y agoThere are plenty of applications for it outside of gaming. For example: a company I know of is using it to demo planned building improvements (or entirely new structures) to clients and investors. Being able to see and move through a virtual environment can really help sell an idea.