12 ms·
You know how to reduce drunk driving? Invest in public transportation. Poor people won't be able to afford self driving cars for quite some time. The US is a c
by djsumdog 11y ago
You know how to reduce drunk driving? Invest in public transportation.
Poor people won't be able to afford self driving cars for quite some time. The US is a country where it's very difficult to live without a car, except in certain major cities.
I'm not excusing this woman's behaviour. She lacks major responsibility. But the world is full of irresponsible people, and building good public infrastructure helps in so many ways that there's no excuse not to build it.
- dublinclontarf 11y agoOnly poor people drink drive? I'm a software engineer in the UK and I've known plenty of people who've driven home after a few.
- marcosdumay 11y agoWay to not get it. A decade after you solve your problem of how to get home when drunk, some poor fellow may still hit your because there are also irresponsible people that can not afford a self driven car.
- pvdebbe 11y agoYou did not read carefully. Parent implied that the poor cannot afford self-driving vehicles any time soon.
- akerro 11y agoWhat has self-driving car to do it with? The police was called from an automates system that's in most of new cars sold in Europe for a few years now.
- themartorana 11y agoEverything? If the car was self driving this woman would likely be home and not in a jail cell?
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoBy common sense you are right. By law, given you can be charged with drunk driving even if the vehicle is off and you are just sleeping in it, I suspect that drunk driving laws will stick around even when the car is doing the driving. This is especially true for areas that drunk driving fines are a revenue stream.
- johncolanduoni 11y agoNo, but better public transportation can be used by a wider range of people than self-driving cars. It's possible some very wealthy people (read: already a minority) may feel it's beneath them, but even then I doubt that will be a universal view.
- aianus 11y agoDriving a car in the US is so ridiculously cheap compared to the rest of the world that only really poor people and crackheads seem to take the bus (outside SF and NYC). The difference in demographics on public transit in Seattle was striking compared to Toronto where car insurance runs $3,000 a year and gas costs 50% more. Public transportation is just not going to happen in the US unless driving gets way more expensive.
- johncolanduoni 11y ago> only really poor people and crackheads seem to take the bus (outside SF and NYC) Note that you chose the top two of the cities in the US in terms of locations accessible by public transit. Of course people won't use it if it can't get them where they need to go, and they'll probably just drive if there are only a few locations it services. This tends to compound itself because the low usage means trains/buses run less often, making it even less useful (e.g. LA). The price of car ownership definitely factors in, as it results in a lack of necessity for public transportation, but it doesn't mean people wouldn't prefer it if it's available. The price difference between an unlimited metro pass ($116/month in NY, $83/month in SF) and owning a car is still very wide.
- aianus 11y agoHaving a car is a lot more useful and comfortable than public transit, though. So there really needs to be a huge difference in cost to justify spending money on public transit when you could just spend a bit more and have your own car. We see that in SF and NYC where the traffic and parking situations make driving very expensive in time and money. But elsewhere in the country? Even if it had great coverage, it wouldn't be worth the time and discomfort to take it just to save ~$200 a month (or less, if you routinely drive family members around).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wiredfool 11y agoRan across a PSA from the early 70's recently that advised people not to have that 5th pint before driving home from the pub. What's acceptable changes over very long time frames.
- voidz 11y agoYeah, drunks in public transportation never cause any problems. There are of course no drunk train drivers ever, either. Excuse my sarcasm. It's caused by how I think you're ignoring the actual problem: alcohol. You're suggesting a workaround that doesn't even make sense. Alcohol abuse causes behavioural problems that go much further than public transportation can ever solve. We should address the core of the issue ranher than fighting its symptoms. I'm not for a ban on alcohol, I am however for ending the taboo around talking about it.
- willvarfar 11y agoIn Italy, for example, it is socially unacceptable to be drunk. Social stigma will change people's habits? How do we make lack of control with alcohol a social no-no?
- parasubvert 11y agoDid I imagine those drunk Italian dinner parties?
- tluyben2 11y agoEh? Where in Italy because besides falling down drunk which is socially unaccepted mostly everywhere I do not think this is true?
- morgante 11y ago> In Italy, for example, it is socially unacceptable to be drunk. I think you and I have different definitions of drunk. Whenever I visit my family in Italy, we all get drunk. Not falling down drunk—we still carry on conversations and navigate the city with ease, but I also wouldn't trust us to drive in that state.
- aaronem 11y agoIt's a lot harder for a drunk train rider to kill someone than a drunk driver. You also seem to conflate any use of alcohol with abuse of alcohol, which is at the very least kind of odd. Sure, some people act like assholes when they're drunk. Some people, often the same people, also act like assholes when they're sober. I'm not sure it makes sense to identify the problem as drunkenness, instead of assholishness.
- paulsutter 11y agoUber has made a big impact already. http://dailysignal.com/2015/08/20/drunk-driving-is-down-in-california-thanks-to-uber/ http://dailysignal.com/2015/08/20/drunk-driving-is-down-in-c...
- themartorana 11y agoThat's huge. I'm an Uber supporter (in the abstract sense, not the shady business practices sense) and love using it or service like it. But all the "cabs in my city suck!" hand waving I do is nothing compared to this. It does make me wonder though, why? Because UberX is cheaper, so more people opt in that wouldn't even pay for a cab?
- moron4hire 11y agoIt's also faster. I have yet to wait more than 5 minutes for an Uber driver, whereas regular taxis take at least half an hour to show up after calling them, assuming I know a number to call.
- dennisnedry 11y agoWhat city do you live in? All I have to do is go outside and flag down the multitudes of cabs waiting to pick somebody up.
- diabeetusman 11y agoI know in my city, Norwalk, CT, there are Ubers you can call, but no taxis driving around looking for a faire. Same with Stamford, CT, a city that's slightly larger and somewhat near Norwalk.
- moron4hire 11y agoI've had this problem in most of Philadelphia when I was living there and now most of DC. Their respective city centers are easy places to grab a cab, but they're also not living spaces and I tend to get around to most areas of the city.
- willvarfar 11y agoCan poor people afford to buy a new car? If not, how old is the car when they buy it? In Sweden used cars are typically brought by their second buyer when they are 3 years old. As software is so cheap to duplicate, why can't all cars be self-driving? Given the magnitude of traffic deaths, why can't all cars just be self-driving immediately? Why make it a premium thing that only the rich can afford? Then within a few years, even poor people who buy second-hand cars will have self-driving models.
- chrismbarr 11y agoThere's a lot more to a self-diving car than just software, there is a ton of needed sensors and other hardware. Let's say an expensive self-driving car is around $100,000 new, even buying that car used 3 years later would be out of the budget for many people.
- willvarfar 11y agoYou are conflating cost and price? Self-driving cars will be expensive because they will be marketed as a premium product to maximize profit. Sometimes public service must trump? Disclaimer: I live in Sweden, so my perspective may offend you ;)
- JupiterMoon 11y agoCost and price are the same thing. Maybe you mean cost/price and worth/value?
- cjhveal 11y agoPrice is the amount the consumer pays, while cost is the price the business pays. It may cost me $5 to produce a product, which I could then sell at a price of $7, for a profit of $2.
- willvarfar 11y agoIsn't the definition of "profit" literally the difference between cost and price? http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/101314/what-difference-between-cost-and-price.asp http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/101314/what-differen... My point is the BoM of self-driving sensors and cpus for a car is not actually that great. The new Teslas and Volvos don't have fancy lidar scanners like the Google cars have. The other day I was passenger in a automatic-breaking-at-intersections Volvo. We did not put that to the test. But its 'just' higher-precision parking sensors that are cheap and ubiquitous now.
- 746F7475 11y agoNo reason to drive while drunk and people who are driving drunk will do so no matter how much public transportation there is just as people who wont drive won't drive even if there was no busses, trains or taxis.
- xyzzyz 11y agopeople who are driving drunk will do so no matter how much public transportation there is This is pretty unconvincing. I've only driven after drinking alcohol twice, and both of these occasions were in the US (just for the record, I drank only a drink or two). In my home country I've always driven 100% sober, every single time.
- 746F7475 11y agoIf I've drank anything in the past 24 hours there is no amount of money you can offer me to drive a car. There are fundamental differences like that.
- lawnchair_larry 11y agoThat's not necessary. Driving after having a drink is normal. It's drunk driving that is a problem.
- roel_v 11y ago"Driving after having a drink is normal." Uh, no it's not.
- ChoGGi 11y agoHaving a beer than driving home after work is quite normal.
- nucleardog 11y agoHaving a glass of wine with dinner then driving home afterwards is quite normal...
- onion2k 11y agoYou know how to reduce drunk driving? I've got the answer to this: Mandate that car manufacturers have to weld a 10 inch steel spike to the centre of the steering wheel. The number of people are willing to take unnecessary risks would fall considerably.
- thecatspaw 11y agobut that 10 inch steel spike also applies to sober responsible people.
- onion2k 11y agoIt does, yes. Everyone would be incentivised to drive as safely as possible.
- logfromblammo 11y agoI would be incentivized to grab a large cutting wheel for my rotary tool and remove the completely unnecessary safety hazard. The spike itself would be strategically relocated to the sidewall of a tire belonging to a person who wrote the bill mandating them.
- i80and 11y agoI know you're kidding, but that would ALSO nail people that are rear-ended by inattentive drivers behind them.
- philh 11y agoObviously, you just need sensors in the rear crumple zone that cause the spike to collapse.
- Bud 11y agoThis would only further encourage our nation's epidemic of slouching and other bad postural habits. ;)
- kailuowang 11y agoIf the car is self driving there is less need to own a car. Selfdriving taxi will be significantly cheaper than current taxi. A privately operating self driving taxi system might be even more economic than building an extensive public transportation system that covers the typical spread-out American cities. It is probably cheaper than owning a car.
- bjacobel 11y agoThis is Uber's vision and the reason they're aggressively poaching roboticists from academia. http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/09/13/magazine/uber-would-like-to-buy-your-robotics-department.html?referer=&_r=0 http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/09/13/magazine/uber-would-lik...
- kailuowang 11y agoIt will be really interesting to see who would be the first organization running automated Taxi. I think as long as Google isn't dumb enough to let go its pioneer engineering team members they are still the front runner. The only thing is that they don't have the a manufacturing capability. Now that they poached Tesla's lead engineer in the area, a Tesla - Google join force is actually more likely, Tesla has more need for Google now.
- JustSomeNobody 11y ago>> ... Invest in public transportation. >> ... The US is a country where it's very difficult to live without a car, except in certain major cities. In order to do this, we need to rethink how we design cities. Right now, unless, as you point out, you live in a major city, it just isn't well laid out for public transportation. No amount of retrofitting is going to help. City planners need to take public transportation into account when they issue new building permits, etc. They need to encourage business to build closer so people can use public transport. Here in the south, thought needs to be put into thunderstorms. We can have afternoon thunderstorms with 50MPH winds and deadly lightning pop up very quickly. You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess.
- jlebrech 11y agothe solution even though people won't like it is to put a tax on fuel and reinvest that into public transport, or give people 'miles' they can use with public transport so they don't feel robbed.
- noxToken 11y ago> the solution even though people won't like it is to put a tax on fuel There already is an excise tax on fuel in a lot of places. I can't say what that revenue is specifically allocated towards, but the tax exists nonetheless.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y agoIn the US gas taxes are very low and don't even cover the costs of our highways. Local roads are paid for mostly with local taxes. It's hard to quantify exactly the subsidy per passenger mile while driving, whereas it's very easy to do the same for transit. The system we have makes drivers feel as though they are paying their fair share while transit riders are not. They don't see the share of their local taxes going to roads.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>City planners need to take public transportation into account when they issue new building permits, etc. They need to encourage business to build closer so people can use public transport. The problem we have today is too much planning, from the smallest rural town to the biggest metropolis. Planning has gone from the simple but noble goals of ensuring public safety and efficient flow of goods and services to dictating lifestyle and trying to preserve things exactly as they are. The typical suburb or sprawling city, for instance, doesn't merely not take into account public transit in zoning and approval processes, it actively allows only sprawling designs. Minimum setbacks, floor area ratio limits, side, front, and back yard requirements, minimum parking requirements, and height limits all act to make it so nothing but sprawl is even legally possible. I can point to numerous examples of these sorts of regulation from all over the United States in cities big and small, from New York to Nome. Yes, this includes places like Houston where it is claimed that there is no zoning but land use control is still Stalnist. This is all based on a 1950s utopian vision where all people everywhere would have cars, cars would just be extensions of people, and we'd all be able to live in a comfortable middle class suburb the next state over because modern planning would ensure no traffic could ever happen. It would also ensure those pesky apartments full of those 'others' would have limited density, so they'd be packed away in some ungodly corner of the world where everyone else wouldn't have to see them. This power is still used today as a de facto tool of modern segregationists who are concerned not merely with race, but also class and even taste and lifestyle. Reducing the power of these local regulators so that urban planning once again becomes a boring profession concerned with public safety and the movement of people, goods, and services and not a way to enforce a very specific 1950s utopian lifestyle would go a huge way to fixing sprawl in America. >You can't have people out waiting on public transport in that mess. Until about the 1950s, people in the South did wait on public transportation. Look up the timetables and maps of the old railroads, interurbans, and streetcars. You'd be amazed how far reaching public transportation in the US was. Many of the cities of consequence in the South sprung up around the railroads. Atlanta, for instance, used to be known as 'Terminus' as it was the end of the line for a railroad with nothing else nearby. The city was built around it, grew rapidly, and eventually the state capital was moved there. Streetcars further fueled growth. This is a story repeated all throughout the South and the rest of the US.
- devonkim 11y agoA great deal of the maladies in the US in particular occur outside economically viable areas of public infrastructure projects (high poverty, violence, substance abuse, etc). Drunk driving is alarmingly common outside major metro areas but they're just not caught as often due to less strict / able police forces (never mind the small town tyrannies like with the Alice Walton drunk driving case resulting in the dismissal of the officer that pulled her over). A lot of these regions don't want a lick of public infrastructure due to cultural reasons as well. So how can we expect stubborn grandparents to admit they have "a problem" and have them do the equivalent of putting themselves in a nursing home metaphorically speaking? This is a major political problem at the root of a lot of the US's internal conflicts in my view having lived near the rural Southeast a lot as someone from the suburban west coast.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>The US is a country where it's very difficult to live without a car, except in certain major cities. This is by design. As I mentioned in another comment, there was this 1950s utopian ideal amongst American planners that we'd all own cars, we could live tens of miles away from the city where we worked, modern planning would ensure traffic was amazing, and we could avoid all that nasty density business and all the 'others' that come with it. No longer would white men have to live near black men. We could all just drive away to the suburbs where restrictive covenants meant we couldn't even sell to black people and restrictive zoning forcing large lot single family homes would ensure that, even if we could legally sell to them, they wouldn't be able to afford to live there anyways. Racially motivated covenants can't be enforced any longer, but the land use control mechanisms put in place to ensure no poor people move to the pristine suburb still exist. It is unfortunate that the Supreme Court upheld these laws, even sharing in their legal opinions that apartments are evil and a drain on society, so of course we should ban them. If they had not upheld these laws, or these laws did not exist in the first place, I'm sure the US would have maintained its public transit friendly character to a great extent. Even LA had one of the largest, if not the largest, rail systems in the world. Imagine that.
- workitout 11y ago>> No longer would white men have to live near black men. Today's youth think the suburbs was about race now? It was about a lot of people don't actually like living in a concrete jungle, that was what it was about.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>Today's youth think the suburbs was about race now? It was about a lot of people don't actually like living in a concrete jungle, that was what it was about. Race was a huge motivator. Why else would we have racial covenants? Funny how the growth of suburbs came at roughly the same time that schools started integrating and integration accelerated suburban growth. We had Federal suburban housing subsidies available almost exclusively for whites. We have a name for this phenomenon: White Flight. Pre-1950s we had racial covenants, but we didn't social engineer lifestyles in suburbs to build them around cars. Streetcar suburbs for instance looked similar to the cities they were connected to. Smaller and less dense, but walkable urban places in their own right. Look at places like Del Ray, Alexandria, Virginia for an example. In cities themselves we tended to build highways in poor, mostly minority, neighborhoods. The white neighborhoods wouldn't be leveled nearly as often.
- melling 11y ago"PORT ST. LUCIE, Fla" Population 171,000. We aren't going to get good mass transit in "small" cities. It's painful enough in NYC, best public transit in America, where there are millions of people. Need to make a connection and it'll take an hour to get anywhere. I've lived 4 miles from work and it took 45 minutes on average to commute into Manhattan.
- code4life 11y agoThe more drunk people take public transportation, the more I'd want to avoid it. The more I'd want my wife to avoid it. Private business is good at solving problems with out the need for government intervention and higher taxes. If you are going to get drunk and you need to get from point A to point B, use Uber or call a taxi.
- existencebox 11y agoI agree with your former and latter point, but since I heard the middle point plenty (private business good at etc. without intervention and taxes) at BEST that's a very optimistic generalization. Taxis in fact are a _result_ of govt intervention (medallions) and uber's business practices, regardless of what you feel on the company, have not always been the solution people want (see many threads on "contractor" treatment, etc; not necessarily my own opinion but in this context the broader sentiment seems more relevant). Govt intervention results in certain downsides, private business implementation others, I don't even have a great thought as to which is better or worse (yes, it's a cop out, but I'll defend that cop out as that it's the "great question of most governments" that I'm dodging), but it seems shortsighted to state "A does it better" (for either side) (I hope this doesn't read as shutting down any rebuttal, not my intention. Feel free to challenge any of the above)
- zo1 11y agoHave you considered approaching your dilemma from a moral perspective rather than a utilitarian/efficiency one? It may very well be that the two sides have different efficiency profiles, but one outweighs the other in terms of being more moral.
- existencebox 11y agoAt the risk of driving this question into the bowels of philosophy, I'm VERY hesitant to drive anything from a moral argument, because I don't trust most judgements of morality, my own included. I can establish the empirical success of certain things by many metrics, a moral metric is not one of them. (I have and do regularly approach the question of "what is the utility / what should be my preference in terms of a moral metric", but again this seems to be like the prior "great question of X" but where X is religion/philosophy instead of govt.) There are certainly times when a moral argument is attractive (and which I would pragmatically chose, especially in the many cases when there are material impacts against which a certain moral stance would oppose) but if we're having a conceptual discussion, I generally avoid that, and even in the cases when I would support a moral argument, I often seek other justifications of more utilitarian nature to try and support the moral suggestion.
- jusben1369 11y agoI now use Uber on the weekend to go out to dinner with my wife and never have to worry about whether I'm ok to have a second or third drink. If we go to a relatively local restaurant I'm paying around $7 each way for the two of us. There's very little chance drunk (especially female) folks are going to ride public transport nor do they need to. I wish I could go find the article but a few months back I read that in LA lawyers specializing in defending drink driving cases have been decimated by Uber usage. Their case load is halving meaning the number of lawyers needed is halving. And that of course is a good thing in general. I'm a big big believer in public infrastructure. But I would never support another penny going into public transport now. Any sort of meaningful project started today would take 5 - 15 years to come to market. Small,medium and large electric vehicles summoned by a mobile device and wired to the network will be mainstream by then and much more efficient. They'll crash less (never) and always choose the optimum route. Private networks for the win here. The economics have changed.
- gluelogic 11y agoYes, but then you're forcing sober people to commute with the intoxicated, which opens up a whole different set of problems.
- Agustus 11y agoHow long of an event horizon are you looking for? As long as we do not have another Cash for Clunkers boondoggle [1] the propagation of used vehicles down through the system will start occurring by 2030. [2] Are you willing to have the government force a solution on the populace which will essentially disappear in ten years? Additionally, the low-income individuals will have access to Uber for self-driving cars. [iUber] Better advocacy would be spent finding out how Uber will get low-income individuals without a smartphone access to it. 1. Cash for Clunkers destroyed vehicles that would have gone to lower-income individuals and upset the used vehicle market driving prices up to new vehicle prices. 2. Assuming a 2020 release date, and following a similar curve of ABS brake adoption of ten years, then by 2030 low-income individuals will start to have access to self-driving vehicles. Maybe earlier as the software rolls out or at-home implementations of the technology can be adapted.
- jrock08 11y agoWhy is a personally owned self driving car a better solution than robust public transit? Self driving cars still are inefficient if they need to be parked and likely don't magically solve congestion if they take up as much space as current cars on the road.
- Shivetya 11y agothis would not fix people like her of which too many still exist. many people don't understand they are impaired or worse think their driving skills are better than everyone else. plus many cities have bus routes that shut down over night and may not serve all areas in need. then to top it off, will they get you where you need to be. So cab, uber, and similar, are a good solution and could proactively be called by bars and restaurants who notice visibly impaired patrons; though I would not put a legal burden for them to do so as people ultimately need to be responsible for self
- s73v3r 11y agoAt the same time, we have Uber and Lyft.
- mmanfrin 11y agoAs a bay area native, I've always felt that BART ending at a bit after midnight has surely caused DUI deaths. It is s frustrating when we are so close to having good public transit, but we're held back for whatever silly reason.
- colmvp 11y agoDrinkers have to adapt to the situation. Be it in SF or any other city where mass transit closes before bars, if I know I'm in a situation where I need to drive myself, then I'm going to severely limit my drinking, if drink at all.
- danans 11y agoThe reason isn't actually so silly. Because BART is a single track-per-direction system, they have to shut the system down in order to do nightly track maintenance. The decision to make the system single-track was made when BART was planned in the 60s. http://www.bart.gov/guide/latenight http://www.bart.gov/guide/latenight