7 ms·
Something came up last time Sourceforge was discussed here, namely "why are projects still using it?"... I'm the project lead for LXQt (http://lxqt.org http://
by scrollaway 11y ago
Something came up last time Sourceforge was discussed here, namely "why are projects still using it?"...
I'm the project lead for LXQt (http://lxqt.org http://lxqt.org). We inherited some infrastructure legacy from LXDE, which was hosted on sourceforge. Today, we have moved most of the legacy to Github but we're still using Sourceforge's mailing list system.
We're moving to a self-hosted mailman3 instance but it's been excruciatingly painful. Email is not fun to deal with.
So I'm pitching this to bored devs and entrepreneurs: Help us, and many other projects, by creating a "Github for mailing lists" with a web client featuring a clean high quality UI, easily browsable/linkable archives, etc. Make it open source, make it self-hostable, stuff in enterprise support. Make it quick and easy to create new lists.
This model can work. It's not unheard of either (cf. Discourse), but it just hasn't been executed properly yet, or is forum-only and does not support email properly. Right now, the UX of mailing list software is like IRC's. Very raw. If it were made more seamless, more approachable, overall easier, it would have a similar effect as Slack has had on unthreaded-async-topical-conversation.
PS: You should change your adblocker to uBlock Origin. It blocks Sourceforge as a malware risk.
- cuillevel3 11y agoDoes http://librelist.com/ http://librelist.com/ match your requirements? "It is a place for FOSS communities to discuss all the things they want without ads, censorship, signup requirements, bundled apps, or requirements that you use any particular email client or service."
- scrollaway 11y agoNot even close. Librelist's UX does not at all match what I describe.
- astrodust 11y agoDoes it install trojans in your binaries?
- scrollaway 11y agoHilarious.
- zensavona 11y agoIsn't this what Google Groups is used for? (what's different / lacking there? I'm of the age where I remember SourceForge as somewhere I would sometimes download things from as a young teenager but nothing more than that)
- scrollaway 11y agoYes, Google Groups is very close to what's needed - unfortunately, it's proprietary and Google doesn't really maintain it, it's only a matter of time it goes the way of Reader.
- joahua 11y agoFWIW, Google Groups powers email distribution lists for Gmail for Work. Or at least, the two are strongly linked. At this point, unlike Reader, there's real cash behind the functionality. It's possible they could just fold it into Gmail, I guess, but with other mail interfaces like Inbox popping up in the Google ecosystem it seems if anything they're trying not to shoehorn too much more into a flagship product. My guess is Groups will stick around for a while yet.
- scrollaway 11y agoThat's interesting, but it doesn't reassure me much. The infrastructure behind Groups may be in use, it doesn't stop Google from shutting the UI down.
- aldanor 11y agoWhy mailing lists are still quite massively popular in 2015?..
- pmlnr 11y agoHow would you replace them? ( Please don't say Slack. That is just _not_ a good replacement, especially for projects that needs publicly searchable archives. ) IMHO a publicly/semi-publicly logged irc channel would do just as well, but that's even more oldschool.
- noselasd 11y agoThe alternative is pretty much only online forums. Which imo. doesn't offer a lot of advantages, and most forum software is exceptionally bad (though yes, a few new and nicer ones are coming along)
- unixhero 11y agoDiscourse NodeBB and Vanilla comes to mind
- scrollaway 11y agoNone of them appropriately support mailing lists, though. Email-based communication is a big deal for devs which contribute on maybe 5+ projects at once and have to manage comms in one central place. As for Discourse's mockery of a mailing list mode, let's not even talk about it.
- swhipple 11y agoAre you familiar with DFeed [1] used by the D-Lang forum [2]? It is, in my opinion, one of the most usable web frontends for mailing lists (as well as a few other sources). [1] https://github.com/CyberShadow/DFeed https://github.com/CyberShadow/DFeed [2] http://forum.dlang.org/ http://forum.dlang.org/
- makomk 11y agoI've always found the Sourceforge mailing list archive interface to be one of the worst out there. Sure, it's a lot prettier than the raw, unstyled HTML of the Mailman default but it's just not nearly as usable.
- hannob 11y agoSavannah provides mailing lists. I don't want to advocate savannah too much, because the site isn't pretty, their interface is sometimes strange, they don't default to https, there are lots of reasons not to like it technically. But it's probably a place where you don't have to expect evils like supporting bundled Crapware. The FSF is behind it.
- scrollaway 11y agoHosting isn't the problem for us, UX is. We intend to self-host since we want to use @lists.lxde.org as an endpoint.
- IshKebab 11y agoD has the best mailing list interface in the world by an enormous margin. http://forum.dlang.org/ http://forum.dlang.org/ (The forum is a front-end to the mailing lists / newsgroups.)
- yitchelle 11y agoLooks nice! The source code running it - https://github.com/CyberShadow/DFeed https://github.com/CyberShadow/DFeed
- daurnimator 11y agoFWIW, I find the information density of this site quite low. When I visit these archives I'll generally read with via the gmane frame interface.
- eco 11y agoHit Settings in the top right then choose Horizontal or Vertical split.
- pjmlp 11y agoI love D's community to have their forums also accessible via NNTP.
- jnbiche 11y agoThe cool thing about D's forums/feed is how amazingly fast they are. I wish more web apps were designed like this, with a fast backend framework. Instead, it's all either slow, slow backend frameworks like Ruby, or even worse, these SPA applications that require extensive client-side JS processing before they show you the goods. Node is a step in the right direction for both problems: for the first, Node-based backend applications are faster than Ruby and Python, and for the client-side rendering problem, because Node can pre-render these SPA apps (which everyone should do for a serious production app that uses a framework/library like AngularJS or React for major client-side rendering). But a server application based on D or Rust, or even Go, is an even better solution to the slow backend framework issue. Unfortunately, no one has yet created a full-service framework like Rails or Django for any of those languages.
- jkot 11y agoSelf-hosting seems like overreaction for most open source project. I would just make regular backups/exports. Dealing with spam filters etc is a nightmare. My project is using Google Groups just fine. Do not list your group in public directory to prevent spam. Redis is moving from mailing list to Reddit. That seems to work for them.
- paulmd 11y agoHigh-profile projects actually can't stop. If you attempt to stop using Sourceforge, they will consider your account "abandoned" and continue mirroring the new site and serving downloads with their malware dropper included. So if you want to keep the malware out of your releases, you need to maintain control of your project by keeping SourceForge up to date. The GIMP project learned this the hard way: http://www.gimp.org/news/2015/05/27/gimp-projects-official-statement-on-sourceforges-actions/ http://www.gimp.org/news/2015/05/27/gimp-projects-official-s... Since they used to be the official source, their repository tend to have very high PageRank and they're essentially cashing in on it. Since the content they host is open-source, this is technically legal, but it's scummy as all hell.
- GrinningFool 11y agoWhen I had a project that I started on sf and later moved off, I kept the sf project technically alive, but removed all downloads. I updated with links to the project site. This was a BlackBerry project, though, and it wasn't something you could install on a desktop - that may have been a contributing factor, but I never had any problems with them continuing to host the content after I deleted it.
- Relys 11y ago"Since the content they host is open-source, this is technically legal, but it's scummy as all hell." If the project is licensed under GPLv3 (or any other strong copyleft license), wouldn't they be illegally hosting it because they are bundling their malware dropper with software that isn't compatible with the license?
- erlend_sh 11y ago> So I'm pitching this to bored devs and entrepreneurs: Help us, and many other projects, by creating a "Github for mailing lists" Hi. I'm from the Discourse team, and I recently "soft-pitched" an idea that seems very much in line with what you're looking for. https://meta.discourse.org/t/becoming-the-new-standard-discussion-tool-for-open-source-projects/26305/17?u=erlend_sh https://meta.discourse.org/t/becoming-the-new-standard-discu... Regardless of the above, we're gonna be doing a significant push for better mailing list features during the months to come, so any feedback you or any other open source projects may have, please nudge me on meta.discourse.org or send me an e-mail (my first name, erlend, at the company domain).
- rsync 11y ago"So I'm pitching this to bored devs and entrepreneurs: Help us, and many other projects, by creating a "Github for mailing lists" with a web client featuring a clean high quality UI, easily browsable/linkable archives, etc. Make it open source, make it self-hostable, stuff in enterprise support. Make it quick and easy to create new lists." Uggh ... really ? So the simple, clean, extremely fast loading HTML indexes of mailman/majordomo[1] aren't going to do it for you anymore ? Yes, I was getting so tired of one click getting me to a nice, clean index, ordered by year and month, and loading near-instantly. What a pain that's always been. Get. Off. My. Lawn. [1] https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-fs/ https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-fs/
- andrewmcwatters 11y agoI agree. Mailman is fantastic as it is. There's a technical brevity and image it gives off, and that's an important aspect of design. This isn't really a statement about usability or what's beautiful in design. I design user interfaces and creating a new UI for basically what mailman does would really just be an attempt at grabbing a different target audience. mailman has an image behind it. People associate with different images, and certain looks and feels make certain people gravitate towards them. The type of people I would want in my mailing list are the type of people that appreciate how mailman looks as-is. I try to practice great design where it matters most. A reskin of such software would be more aligned with the goals of junior designers and people who rehash weather apps with nice gradients on dribbble.
- scrollaway 11y agoHave you considered contacting Guiness World Records regarding the size of that horse you stand atop of? If you genuinely do want to practice great design, start by considering user needs and the reason why "reskinning" as you call it might be wanted, instead of dismissing anything you don't immediately understand as "pah, must be junior designers, those with fancy gradients and far less experience than me". No, seriously, what the hell.
- 11y ago