18 ms·
World on cusp of 'post-antibiotic era'
- DamnYuppie 11y agoWhile this does sound terrifying I believe the next step in combating these viruses will be precision immunotherapeutics. What I mean by this is that we do have the ability to create custom antibodies for a specific person for a specific virus or bodily activity. There are several companies working on this and are having great results using this to treat cancer, first among them is Imagen Biopharma, Inc.
- vox_mollis 11y agoCancer kills in months; sepsis kills in days. Do these techniques work on those timescales?
- DamnYuppie 11y agoMy understanding is that it would be use as an immunization ahead of time.
- ceejayoz 11y agoThat doesn't really fit with "custom antibodies for a specific person for a specific virus or bodily activity".
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWell, try this: You go to the doctor's office. They take a blood sample or a throat swab or whatever. They DNA sequence the bacteria they find. Then they give you antibiotics that will kill what you have.
- theandrewbailey 11y agoI didn't read anything related to viruses in this story.
- vectorjohn 11y agoAntibiotics don't do anything for viruses or cancer.
- cryoshon 11y ago"Bacteria becoming completely resistant to treatment - also known as the antibiotic apocalypse - could plunge medicine back into the dark ages." Probably not, for a number of reasons. The arms-race strategy of antibiotics vs drug resistance was doomed to fail from the start, as many know. The solution is counter intuitive: stop the arms race of stronger and stronger antibiotics completely, and the bacterial resistance to weaker antibiotics will be reduced over time. It's expensive for bacteria to keep antimicrobial genes around, and once the selective pressure of an antibiotic environment decreases, they'll lose the traits that confer resistance. It may even be possible to phase out one drug resistance trait at a time in multiple-drug-resistant populations. The horizontal gene transfer that the article mentions is really cool, but ultimately a non-sequitor when it comes to population-level infection control. This solution means temporarily accepting uncontrolled drug-resistant bacteria in some narrow cases, which is unpalatable, but this strat works in the petri dish.
- iamthepieman 11y agoThis sounds like a great idea but your last line is a death sentence to it. I think it would take the apocalypse you are dismissing before the solution you are recommending could be implemented.
- stupidcar 11y agoYou'd take an apocalypse where no antibiotics work, and everybody dies, against a solution where some antibiotics work, and some people die? Are you sure you've thought this through?
- iamthepieman 11y agoMy comment was not an opinion on the proposed solution. It was an opinion on the likelihood of such a solution actually being implemented by society.
- mooreds 11y agoDoes "this strat" work when your father/mother/son/daughter is in the hospital? Or are you (and I include in "you" any human being with the choice) going to want every antibiotic available for your loved one? Maybe I miss the point of your comment, but if not, I doubt it is a viable strategy.
- iamthepieman 11y agoI wonder what this will do to the short term evolution of our species. It's terribly morbid and I really don't think it will come to this but if many people start dying due to once easily treatable infections then it could rapidly (within a dozen generations or so) change how our immune system works. A mass dieoff of a species due to a single catastrophic event is unlikely to intensely select for certain traits. A flood amonsgst a non-swimming species is as likely to select for resillience or sleeping late in your tree or some other unpredicable attribute as it is for the "swimming" gene But constant intense pressure could easily single out favorable attributes and I wonder what those will be and what the side effects or emergent traits of those genes will be. Of course we are evolving via technology and society more rapidly than genetically so that could change everything.
- mrestko 11y agoYou mean a return to the wold before antiobiotics? The world that existed when my grandparents were born? I doubt the few generations of people born during the "antibiotic era" have any meaningful genetic traits connected with the use of antibiotics
- iamthepieman 11y agoYes, you're right of course. But clearly the few generations of the "antibiotic era" have had a much larger effect on the bacteria than us. We used antibiotic technology to "evolve" resistance to bacteria. Bacteria responded much more rapdily than we could have naturally and is now a different organism than what our grandparents had to contend with. Now our technological "evolution" is unable to keep up with natures and we face a new threat not an old one. One we helped to create.
- lucaspiller 11y agoJust to put things into perspective, the world population was around 2 billion when penicillin was discovered in 1928. Even without antibiotics we still know about things like sanitation and the importance of clean drinking water, so it's not exactly going back to the dark ages as the article suggests.
- stank345 11y agoIsn't it possible for us to invent/discover new antibiotics?
- adventured 11y agoThe value of which skyrockets as each older antibiotic becomes increasingly useless. That's being entirely ignored, seemingly in every article that talks about this problem. A recent example of a new antibiotic: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/new-antibiotic-dirt-soil-can-kill-drug-resistant-bacteria-180953828/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/new-antibiotic-... Or how about this: a break-through that goes beyond classic antibiotics. Something that hasn't been thought of yet. Not like humans have a history of accomplishing such feats, right? Not like the entire last century of medicine falls into that category. I can't think of a single example in modern history, in which our species has failed to think its way out of a major problem. X Y Z bad thing was supposed to take us down, or impede our progress, and we thought our way out of it. We'll continue to do that, and the overly dramatic forecasters of doom will continue to be wrong as they always are.
- jerrycabbage 11y agoYes! Finally someone who understands that science is more magic than anything. If you pray and hope things will always change. I invented a magic shoe that absords CO2. Once the patent is done Global Warming will be a thing of the past!
- brianlweiner 11y agoOne problem is bacteria develop resistance to the new drugs very quickly. Usually within 2-3 years. It's difficult to recoup your investment costs for a drug that has an effective use window that small.
- noir_lord 11y agoI think if you have a disease that is curable with an antibiotic that gets really out of control you will find that government funding will become much more of a factor. Been the government that threw a few billion bucks and saved thousands of (electorate) lives is a good vote winner. The cost of developing antibiotics is large (in the billions) but US defence spending is 600bn dollars, UK defence spending is 60-odd bn dollars. Governments should already be funding this stuff (imo) since the defence of the realm is theoretically their first goal.
- akkartik 11y agoAnybody know if there's any progress with ADEP4? http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2013/11/13/killing-sleeper-cells-and-superbugs-with-assassin-janitors http://phenomena.nationalgeographic.com/2013/11/13/killing-s...
- jarmitage 11y agoRadiolab did a great podcast on this recently http://www.radiolab.org/story/best-medicine/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/best-medicine/
- halviti 11y agoThere is a natural way to kill every single bacteria out there. They are called phages. For every bacteria, there is a phage that will kill it. Back in the Soviet Union they used this medical technology extensively to cure all sorts of things, and the hospitals in Georgia and surrounding areas would be sprayed down with phage to kill bacteria within the hospital corridors and rooms to prevent the hospitals themselves from becoming breeding grounds for bacteria. If you're interested in learning more I would recommend the 1997 BBC four documentary called 'The Virus that Cures'
- gue5t 11y agoQuack flags: "natural", silver bullet, forgotten techniques from the past, citation is a documentary
- iamthepieman 11y agoAgreed about the flags. However in this case it may be a false positive. http://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736(05)66759-1.pdf http://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736(... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3400130/pdf/fmicb-03-00238.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3400130/pdf/fmi... http://aac.asm.org/content/51/6/2156.long http://aac.asm.org/content/51/6/2156.long
- mbrock 11y agoA long comment on MetaFilter by someone doing their Ph.D. research on phage biology. http://metatalk.metafilter.com/21925/Interesting-Profiles#1012599 http://metatalk.metafilter.com/21925/Interesting-Profiles#10... Excerpt: > Over the last fifteen years or so, with the breakup of the Soviet Union and the exponentially growing crisis of antibiotic resistance, phage therapy is looking very exciting again. Unlike the ‘30s, we now have a decent understanding of phage biology as well as the infrastructure to keep phages cold until use, effective diagnostic tools, and most importantly, regulatory structures that shut out hucksters. The need is also dire, for example multi-drug resistant Staph infections kill more people in the United States than AIDS does. > Basic phage biology has also been undergoing a resurgence as we discover just how important phages are to the global ecosystem, they are indeed the dominant organism on Earth outnumbering anything else by two orders of magnitude. Indeed, despite being just ~125 nm tall (check this out for scale), if one were to stack the 1031 phages on the planet end to end you would get a tower that would stand 200 million lightyears tall. Our oceans are remarkably free of cellular life and the reason is phages, as well as the other the viruses of microbes. For example the growth and death of algae blooms are centrally mediated by viral dynamics. Meta-genomics studies of the oceans pull out more predicted phage proteins than anything else without some fancy filtering, and even then they get a bunch. Phages are also teaching us a lot about the primordial origins of life, they are after all proto-cellular organisms. > These days are exciting times to be interested in phages.
- zeveb 11y ago> They identified bacteria able to shrug off the drug of last resort - colistin - in patients and livestock in China. … > It is likely resistance emerged after colistin was overused in farm animals. What the heck? Shouldn't the antibiotic of last resort be used only as … a last resort? I can't believe that any farm animal would be worth the use of such a drug (although I suppose it's possible, were it the last of its breed or something).
- th0waway 11y agoThis is an instance where capitalism (and I am a capitalist) has gone awry - someone somewhere ran a PowerPoint slideshow showing they could make 'x' more dollars if they pre-emptively dosed livestock with antibiotics, and the PHB's said 'make it so'.
- j_jochem 11y agoHere, "last resort antibiotic" means that is given only if nothing else works, because it is too nephrotoxic for normal use. This has nothing to do with the inherent effectiveness of the drug, although it has probably become more effective through the disuse that resulted from its nephratoxicity. Bad journalism again.
- fredsted 11y agoIt seems like antibiotics like Colistin are uncontrolled in China, and perhaps very cheap? It seems like madness to use these last resort drugs on farm animals.
- mikeash 11y agoThe whole problem here (as with many other things) is that actions which are "madness" when looking at the big picture come from perfectly rational actions by individuals.
- liamconnell 11y agoNah I hate that kind of thinking. Someone or some group of people have to be deemed responsible. Here's my thought process with this: So in China, and every country there are a few relevant players. Farmers, farm owners, politicians, and scientists. Farmers (laborers) have to survive and most work wages so they arent accountable. Farm owners have to compete and if they dont they go out of business and someone will take their place so they're not really accountable. But its the law that makes the rules of the game and so it is the responsibility of the political class to avoid designing "tragedy of the commons" scenarios. There are at least SOME good-willed politicians who dont want things like antibiotic-apocolypse. The problem is that they have a ton of scientists whispering different things in their ears so they dont know what issues are big threats and which are scientists trying to get funding into their own field of study. Its therefore also the responsibility of the scientific community to effectively communicate with the political class. See? At least some people out there arent perfectly rational!
- jcfrei 11y agoI wonder: The arms race between bacteria and other organisms has gone on for a long long time, is there a defense mechanism against every bacteria? Because otherwise bacteria would be the only organism to inhabit this planet? Or is the only thing that historically prevented world domination by bacteria the lack of transportation to remote places? If that's the case then has the proliferation of mass transport ultimately shifted the odds in favor of bacteria? And are antibiotics a catalyst for the evolution of bacteria or its demise?
- Retric 11y agoIn terms of Biomass Bacteria are the dominate life form on the earth. The average person has over 1lb of Bacteria living in there body and vastly more bacterial cells than human cells.
- raziel2701 11y agoThis might be the influence of playing too much metal gear solid, but how far ahead is nanomachine research? I know some people use nanowires coated with certain human-compatible proteins to make them more appealing to osteosarcoma (bone cancer cells) so the cancer cells take in these nanowires. However implementation of a mechanism to target something like a bacterial infection is not something I've heard of.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThe thing you want to look at is biotech. Life is nothing but nanotechnology that we didn't build and we can't control yet. The hottest thing right now in fighting bacteria seems to be bacteriophages[0]. I've heard Russians had some success in R&D there, but I don't know much more. Maybe some knowledgable HNer could elaborate. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacteriophage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacteriophage