12 ms·
NASA Study: Mass Gains of Antarctic Ice Sheet Greater Than Losses
- madaxe_again 11y agoThis is interesting, and I've a few observations: 1) This is going to be used, fast, by the climate change denial camp to show "everything is OK", sad but true. 2) Increased snow and ice build up in the interior, while the ice shelves surrounding the continent disappear, will have unpredictable consequences. It's not necessarily a good thing. The increased mass in the interior will increase the rate of flow out of the centre - which could ultimately hasten thinning. 3) This article doesn't mention it, but the paper itself does - they do compensate for bedrock motion. Nice science.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DougN7 11y agoTo #1, I'm hardly a denier, but anytime I see everyone jump on a bandwagon, and start to see smugness (not referring to you), I wonder how much objectivity still exists. IMHO we probably are warming the world with all of our machines, but the history of science is full of cases where it didn't know as much as it claimed, so let's keep some humility in the discussion and admit we still don't infact know everything for certain.
- zwily 11y agoI'm in your boat. I wish more people were in that boat.
- digitalengineer 11y agoIt's getting crowded in here. We sure aren't doing this earth any favors, but I have my doubts to weather our machines are making this planet a warmer place. Everything moves in cycles.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Everything moves in cycles. Positive feedback loop systems tend to move in cycles, only each cycle has a greater amplitude than the previous one.
- kabouseng 11y agoNo positive feedback tends to catastrophically run away. Feedback with control elements can oscillate uncontrollably. For your comment to ring true it would mean that some control mechanism is present, I don't believe that to be the case unless you think humanity is that control element, i.e. drastically reduce our CO2 output at the top of the cycle and then increase it again at the bottom of the cycle.
- digitalengineer 11y agoI feel there is another source to our earth's temperature: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_cycle#/media/File:Carbon14_with_activity_labels.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_cycle#/media/File:Carbon...
- sd8f9iu 11y agoBut that is not what the problem is. In any scientific discipline, we never know anything for certain. Climate deniers are not saying, "we still don't know some things about climate change." They are denying the basic facts of climate change because they are ignorant or self-serving, or both. To not point this out and address it with equal fervor – especially given what's at stake – is just as much a slight to climate science. By all means, in the scientific field, maintain humility and approach each result with skepticism. But #1 is more a political problem than a scientific one. The nation's (and world's) response to climate change is vastly insufficient. As educated individuals in a high-tech field, we have a duty to call a spade a spade, and sometimes preemptively calling the opposition's bullshit is a means to this end.
- gaius 11y agoA "denier" is anyone who disagrees with Al Gore and Bono. Count me in.
- DCKing 11y agoThat is an attractive position to take. It seems there are two extremes, and the truth should be in the middle somewhere. However, it seems to me you don't quite appreciate how strong the case for the general picture of climate change really is. The evidence for it is so vast, coming from so many different sources, that it is really quite indisputable. That doesn't imply at all that the picture of it is complete, or that we know exactly how it works. This finding doesn't diminish the strength of other forms of evidence at all. It merely adds to our understanding of the details of climate change and the development of new insights on the details of climate change. Climate change theory isn't some young and untested field of science. People have been trying to disprove (that's what science is! that's what this study is doing!) climate change hypotheses for decades now, and what is left today is a proper scientific theory. Just because a lot of debate happens on the veracity of climate change findings doesn't mean that the proper thing to do is to take a 'nuanced' position. Not if it is not aligned with experimental evidence. It might feel counterintuitive to do in a political discussion - which is what climate change has sadly become - but when the discussion is about what's true, one should always look for the answers that are intellectually honest instead of those that are politically acceptable or 'balanced'. > the history of science is full of cases where it didn't know as much as it claimed, I don't think this is true at all. Name one such scientific consensus that was, like climate change, the result of different sources of experimental evidence, that turned out to completely wrong.
- source99 11y agoThe theory that people will be healthier by decreasing fat and increasing carbs has led to our current obesity epidemic. I would classify the science performed that got us to this point as fulfilling your requiremen.
- npunt 11y agoNutrition is an especially crude science with nothing approaching scientific theory, and a lot of disagreement. FDA recommendations like the food pyramid that recommend altering fats/carbs are the result of political consensus as much as science, and there are many counter-examples to the idea of high carbs / low fats in the diets of different peoples of the world.
- gaius 11y ago"Denier" is a loaded word, meant deliberately to evoke "Holocaust denier". I prefer skeptic. Because if you're not a skeptic, you're not a scientist.
- powera 11y agoWait, really? I would have guessed it referred to Galileo
- ageofwant 11y ago"Denier" is an appropriate label if no amount of evidence will be able to convince the "sceptic". A scientist should be able to change his mind based on the evidence. Deniers are unable to do this.
- gaius 11y agoWell we have more ice forming and still the label "denier" is being bandied about. Maybe there are fanatics on both sides?
- mikeash 11y agoThere are fanatics both for and against flat Earth theory, but that doesn't make the two sides equal nor imply the truth is somewhere in the middle.
- ageofwant 11y agoOf course there will be more ice, why would more moisture in the air lead to less ice ? I don't think you understand the models you are questioning. Maybe spend more time studying what they actually mean ? Also, while you're at it, have a look at the "Argument to Moderation" logical fallacy.
- asgard1024 11y ago> we probably are warming the world with all of our machines Probably very little compared to GH gases contribution, see here: http://skepticalscience.com/waste-heat-global-warming.htm http://skepticalscience.com/waste-heat-global-warming.htm There is a lot of energy coming to the Earth in the form of sunlight. We could power world economy with it many times over.
- ageofwant 11y agoAnd a lot leaving via infra-red radiation, unless of course you trap it somehow.
- valm- 11y agoNote that the greenhouse gases you mention are generated so we can run our machines.
- asgard1024 11y agoI am not sure I follow - this is what AGW theory is saying, that humans cause global warming by running civilization on carbon fuels. I just wanted to address possibly wrong belief of GP that waste heat can be the primary cause of GW.
- saalweachter 11y agoIt is relatively little, but it's actually something like 6%. The rate of change of the Earth's heat content is something like 250TW (on average); humans are currently using/generating around 16TW of energy. For comparison, the Earth's fiery core is about 45TW of radioactive decay and sunlight hitting Earth is about 173PW. Of course, we've historically increased our energy use by around 5% per year, so if that trend held (which you should expect about as much as any other exponential trend holding...), in about 50 years waste heat would begin outweighing greenhouse gasses.
- mikeash 11y agoThe smugness I see almost always comes from the skeptic/denier crowd, who just love to talk about how stupid people who believe in global warming are and how obvious it is that the whole thing is a hoax because of the global warming hiatus, or volcanoes, or because it snowed on Tuesday, or whatever. If objectivity is lacking, it is lacking almost exclusively because certain right-wing groups took a scientific issue, turned it into a political issue, and set their politics to oppose the science. Certainly, there exist fanatic, non-objective people on both sides. But they're not exactly common, and it gets tedious to see comments like yours in every discussion about this issue, and almost always directed at the reasonable people who actually look at the facts, and not at the the people who think climate change isn't science, who think that increased ice mass must be evidence against global warming regardless of the reason for it, or who think global temperatures stopped rising in 1998.
- merpnderp 11y agoWe have different experiences. I usually see the skeptic crowd talking about the science and the believer crowd talking about how fanatical the skeptics are. But you seem a reasonable person. Maybe you could help me understand the last 20 years of the UAH 6.0 data and the RSS data which matches it within +-.2C?
- mikeash 11y agoI'm not terribly familiar with these things, but they look like fairly straightforward temperature data. What is there to understand?
- merpnderp 11y agoBetween the two of them, they are the entirety of the satellite global atmospheric temperature data sets. If you run a linear regression on the TLT (total lower tropospheric) data from 1997 to current, you'll get a zero trend. If you allow for their level of confidence, you get a zero trend from 1994. These are two separate organizations, who's data (with UAH's 6.0 update) is within .2C of each other. UAH is University of Alabama in Huntsville in partnership with NASA. RSS is a private atmospheric research company. Both their data sets start in 1979. Without discounting their data, what theory of anthropogenic global warming accounts for this length of no warming during the period where 1/3rd of all man made CO2 was released into the atmosphere? I'm extremely curious and have had no luck getting an answer anywhere. The data is easy to find, but I can link it if you want to run it yourself. The UAH 6.0 data is still in Beta, but NASA started accounting for loss of orbit and are working on an updated record.
- jhspaybar 11y agoTo point 1, what would falsify the theory that humans are causing global warming and this is a bad thing. I've heard "weather isn't climate" a million times when there are snow storms, how is increasing ice mass not a mark against the theory of AGW?
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> what would falsify the theory that humans are causing global warming and this is a bad thing (emphasis original) Who cares? Once you've asked whether something is bad, why on earth would it matter whether humans are causing it? It matters to the environmentalist movement, because it is a tenet of that movement that the same change is good if not metaphysically related to humans but bad if it is. That's not a viewpoint I'd endorse, though.
- ja30278 11y agoBecause if we aren't causing it, then there's very little reason to make vast changes to our way of life in hopes of preventing it.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoSort of like how there's very little reason for Holland to try to prevent the ocean from coming in?
- yongjik 11y agoUsing solar panels to take hot shower instead of burning gas does not constitute "making vast changes to our way of life".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- npunt 11y agoThe argument you propose could be described as a fairness fallacy - I didn't do something bad, so bad things won't happen to me. Sometimes its worth preventing things we didn't cause, if they will nonetheless impact us in significant ways. An asteroid barreling toward earth would hardly be caused by us, but if we didn't try to prevent it, we'd share fate with dinosaurs.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 11y agowhat I have learned is that no amount of evidence to the contrary will convince one side or the other. It simply has become to controversial.
- Asbostos 11y agoThe trouble with climate change deniers is they turn everyone else into an equally unreasonable proponent. Look at these reactions to two pieces of evidence: Antarctica is losing ice from its ice sheets - It shows global warming is happening and things might get worse. Antarctica is gaining more ice than it's losing - We speculate that it might lead to another consequence that we haven't observed or modeled which would mean things still get worse. That's bias if I ever saw it. The fact is, we really don't know what will happen. Predictions range from 10m sea level rise in 50 years to nothing noticeable. It's a risk. A risk of things that might go very bad or might not. So we need to worry in case it does go bad. But the general public can't understand risk - they need black and white certainty which doesn't yet exist in this field. Proponents fear that people will choose black so they try to convince them it's white. Even though it's wrong, at least it seems like the safer choice of wrong.
- tsotha 11y ago>1) This is going to be used, fast, by the climate change denial camp to show "everything is OK", sad but true. Seems pretty fair, doesn't it? I mean, any decreases have certainly been used by AGW promoters to show "the sky is falling".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tsotha 11y agoIt's odd that we never heard about that when the polar bears were supposed to drown.
- fndjcndjezx 11y agoSo how do we reconcile this with recent observations that sea levels are rising?
- adventured 11y agoSupposedly it's explained through expansion from warming. I'm not a global climate scientist though, so I can't speak to the validity of that premise.
- baobabaobab 11y agoSea levels are rising 2.6-2.9mm per year. “The good news is that Antarctica is not currently contributing to sea level rise, but is taking 0.23 millimeters per year away,” Zwally said. “But this is also bad news. If the 0.27 millimeters per year of sea level rise attributed to Antarctica in the IPCC report is not really coming from Antarctica, there must be some other contribution to sea level rise that is not accounted for.” Complete conjecture, but my money is on IPCCs estimates for other sources being a little too conservative, not some entirely new explanation.
- kpil 11y agoYes, interesting question. (Other sources are what? Arctics? Heat expansion?) Anyway, I particularly like that they are doing observations rather than just faffing around with models. Models are good, but data is better.
- baobabaobab 11y agoThe other sources are glacial melt, heat expansion, and water storage on land decreasing. You need both the models and the data. Facts without theory answer only what happened, not why, you can't make projections without theory. Theory without facts... pretty obvious problem there.
- DanBC 11y agoGreenland is melting. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/10/27/world/greenland-is-melting-away.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/10/27/world/greenlan... ('greenland' in the search box returns a bunch of articles from a span of a few years)
- hirundo 11y ago> “At the end of the last Ice Age, the air became warmer and carried more moisture across the continent, doubling the amount of snow dropped on the ice sheet,” Zwally said. So there's a feedback mechanism that, as air temperatures rise, sequesters more liquid water that would otherwise raise sea levels. How will that be interpreted by the climate change alarmist camp as a portent of disaster?
- Daishiman 11y agoWell, since air temperatures are still rising, basically you're increasing, dramatically, the wet-bulb temperature of the atmosphere. You can survive 100-degree dry-bulb temperatures without problem, which is the reason why so many places of the world have a temperature above human core body temperature yet are still quite survivable. Now with wet bulb? Literally all these places can become literally unlivable for humans.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoThis study shows that the aggregate causes of sea level rise may be different from what we had guessed. However, it remains an amply demonstrated fact that global temperatures and sea levels are rising, even as the Antarctic ice sheet continues to grow. Why do you think that the former is a good reason to ignore the latter?
- gavanwoolery 11y agoMy usual friendly reminder -- the difference between faith and science (note this has nothing to do with what side of the debate you are on): Faith: X is true! Because! Science: Is X true? Are we certain? Lets try and find evidence counter to X. I see a lot of people (from each side) trying to prove their point, rather than disprove it.* The former is faith, the latter is science. * Not referring to people here, just the population in general
- esaym 11y ago"Faith" has a large definition behind it: http://1828.mshaffer.com/d/search/word,faith http://1828.mshaffer.com/d/search/word,faith Think of a similar word "faithful". Being faithful means you can be relied upon. When one is described as being faithful, there is normally some form of evidence behind it, whether tangible or not. And thus "faith" is the evidence of things unseen. You therefore can have "faith" in someone that is "faithful" because you know it to be true. You saw it, you felt it, you know it, ect.
- zkhalique 11y agoFaith usually has a reason behind it, as well. It's because you can rely on something, based on your past experience. Belief, in general, is a psychological attitude towards a claim.
- ubernostrum 11y agoScience: Is X true? Are we certain? Lets try and find evidence counter to X. Actually that's not the definition of science, it's a definition of science, and whether it is a complete definition of science depends heavily on one's thoughts on philosophy of science. Falsification as the central concept has at times been popular and at times unpopular; right now, it is less popular than it was, say, about eighty years ago.
- guscost 11y agoIf the very definition of science is subject to a vote, then by winning the vote you can throw out whatever principles you disagree with and redefine it to mean whatever you believe it to mean, right? Luckily it doesn't work like that at all. Science progresses when incorrect theories are falsified. No army of philosophers will ever be able to change that with a silly meta argument.
- zeckalpha 11y ago> But it might only take a few decades for Antarctica’s growth to reverse, according to Zwally. “If the losses of the Antarctic Peninsula and parts of West Antarctica continue to increase at the same rate they’ve been increasing for the last two decades, the losses will catch up with the long-term gain in East Antarctica in 20 or 30 years -- I don’t think there will be enough snowfall increase to offset these losses.” So while it's still increasing in mass, the current ∂∂m indicates it will start decreasing in 20-30 years.
- mturmon 11y agoI'm not at work, so I can't see the relevant articles, but I notice the linked study uses satellite altimetry. I'd be interested in the numbers for complementary techniques, in particular, gravitational mass anomalies from GRACE. Here's a link to an older comparative study: http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/igsoc/jog/2010/00000056/00000200/art00020 http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/igsoc/jog/2010/0000005... My understanding is that GRACE still was seeing Antarctic mass losses, but perhaps that has changed.
- blondie9x 11y agoGood news not all planetary patterns have been altered by humans, yet. Gives us a little more time down there. But we need to cut emissions quickly before this patterns reaches completion and the sea ice lost in west Antarctica causes significant sea level rise due to our burning of fossil fuels. The time to switch away from carbon based energy is now.
- pdonis 11y agoIt seems to me that this finding means that the "pattern" is not what you think it is.
- cristianpascu 11y agoAs a total noob, I'd say climate is a pretty complex problem to cheer at this as a 'good news'. Yes, there may be highly exaggerated attitudes on both sides, but scientific problems should addressed with data and verified scientific models. And I say this as an YEC. As opposed to science of the past, which poses specific epistemic issues, climate issues is something that can be observed now and here. Personally, I think that there are much more important problems on the table before sea level rise, but nevertheless, climate change or not, pollution should be addressed on all fronts.
- baobabaobab 11y agoThe West Antarctic Ice sheet is still flowing into the ocean, and accelerating. It's actually not even clear atmospheric warming is the ultimate cause. But it is clear that it's reached a literal tipping point. The glaciers have retreated past a point where the slope tips inland, and warm water is running down hill, melting the bottom. No amount of emissions reductions can stop it, we would need to pump heat away from the underside of the glaciers to slow it down. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:West_Antarctic_Collapse.ogg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:West_Antarctic_Collapse.o...
- buf 11y agoThis is an article that's going to get intensely mis-interpreted by the press and is going to sway public opinion in favor of non-anthropogenic global warming. While the study is solid, the fact remains that in spite of this ice gain, global sea levels ARE rising. Thermal expansion: When water heats up, it expands. About half of the past century's rise in sea level is attributable to warmer oceans simply occupying more space.
- Asbostos 11y agoSea level rise alone isn't a humanity-destroying disaster. It's just a bit of an expense having to build new buildings further inland. We've done a good job of building nearly every building on earth in the past 100 years. We'll probably manage to do it again in the next 100 years if we need to. We'll probably do it anyway even if we don't need to. Buildings are routinely demolished and replaced when they're too old.
- emocakes 11y agobut global warming
- m3talridl3y 11y agoAs a climate change believer, I'm getting worried that a lot of svientists out there are just telling us all what we want to hear. It's incredibly fun to tell people that the world is going to end in 20 tears due to climate change, but if the truth is that it's end in 500 years, then doctoring the facts to make things seem more dire is dangerous.
- williesleg 11y agoThe one constant thing about science over the history of science is that almost all science has been disproven over time. So the odds that current science is correct are almost nil. Science.
- narrator 11y agoWhere the rubber hits the road on the climate change debate is that the solution to climate change always includes carbon credits and cap and trade. These two combine to be a global tax administered by new supranational organizations that can alternatively bribe and control development and the standard of living of every country on the planet. The governance of these entities will likely go the way of the IMF and the World Bank. Thus, it's just too convenient of a way to administer an empire. No wonder the countries that would get the short end of all this, such as the BRICS, are skeptical. I realize we here in America have got to keep all these schemes going to keep the great balancing act we perform running the world moving right along. Heck, we need all the help we can get to keep the BRICS at an economic disadvantage. Too bad it's such a waste of smart people producing climate change B.S.
- adventured 11y agoThe US doesn't have to work very hard when it comes to the BRICS, they do it to themselves constantly. Putin takes over Russia, and proceeds to do absolutely nothing to develop the economy away from its commodity dependency. Instead, he falls back onto the focus on energy that doomed the USSR. The US dollar goes on a big run, China's growth slows, US oil producers add four million barrels per day, and just like that Russia sinks into the abyss again. Russians are now spending half their income on just food alone, with their economy collapsing by 1/3 in dollar terms in just 18 months. What did the US do to cause that? That's Russia's fault. The same goes for what is happening to Brazil right now. They rode the fake boom good times on the back of a debased US dollar. Now that fake boom is over, the weak dollar has gone away, and with that tide going out, so has Brazil's economy. Whose fault is that? It's only Brazil's fault. Did the US force China to take on tens of trillions in debt to fake economic growth where there was none after the global consumer crashed in 2008? Nope, just like Japan before them, they did it to themselves willingly so they wouldn't have to admit the party was over. The US hasn't had to do anything to these countries to hold them at an economic disadvantage, they're doing it to themselves.