9 ms·
MIT's free online classes can now lead to MicroMaster's degree
- SimplyUseless 11y agoThe same story submitted here a few days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10381464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10381464
- dang 11y agoReposts are ok if a story hasn't had significant attention yet. Once it has, we treat reposts as dupes. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cowsandmilk 11y agoyou also have to pay $150 for the verified certificate in the semester. and I believe that has to be paid before the semester starts.
- bentpins 11y agoIn a pilot project announced Wednesday, students will be able to take a semester of free online courses in one of MIT's graduate programs and then, if they pay a "modest fee" of about $1,500 and pass an exam, they will earn a MicroMaster's credential, the school said. If the trial fee is $1500, I'm not sure they'd go right back to $150
- anamexis 11y ago> The cost of the MicroMaster's includes $150 for each of the five online classes, plus up to $800 to take the exam. So, sounds like $150 up front for each course, and then $800 to tie it all up with the exam, for $1500 total.
- hackerboos 11y agoSlightly OT. The video embedded in the article talks about Tsinghua University beating MIT in rankings. This is a quantity vs quality since Tsinghua University churns out more research papers than MIT [1] because of the vast amount of students. [1] - http://qz.com/522471/the-real-reason-chinese-universities-are-climbing-the-ranks-in-engineering-and-beat-out-mit/ http://qz.com/522471/the-real-reason-chinese-universities-ar...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 11y agoTo be fair, Tsinghua is widely accepted as the second best university in all of China; the quality of the students is extremely high. The quality of the research is probably not so high.
- gojomo 11y agoAnd Tsinghua graduates figure disproportionately in the national leadership: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsinghua_clique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsinghua_clique I suppose it's a bit like if MIT grads were ~40% of the US cabinet or Senate committee chairs – rather than so many Ivy League lawyers.
- thaumasiotes 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C9_League https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C9_League As far as I know, the prestige university you go to if you want a specifically technical education is Shanghai Jiao Tong Daxue. (Don't take that as particularly authoritative; I'm mostly familiar with it as a contrast to Fudan.) But I don't believe Tsinghua is technically focused in the manner of MIT. It's very much part of China's Ivy League.
- netheril96 11y ago> To be fair, Tsinghua is widely accepted as the second best university in all of China Tsinghua University and Beijing University are both regarded as the best university in China, with different people ranking different one first. But in the area of CS, Tsinghua University is undeniably the first.
- 20years 11y agoThis is a step in the right direction. However the $33k for the 2nd semester is still out of reach for many. "As part of the pilot project, students who perform well in the online half can take an exam to apply for the second semester on campus. Those who get in would pay $33,000, about half the cost of the yearlong program." Would be nice to see them eventually offer affordable online courses & exams for 8 semesters.
- mattmanser 11y agoSeems far too much for an online-only degree, but I guess the danger is devaluing the MIT brand. And in essence I guess it is a sort of freemium structure.
- cheald 11y agoThe $33k is for an on-campus semister to complete the Master's, not the online MicroMaster's degree.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sbose78 11y ago>> danger is devaluing the MIT brand If more people have access to quality education, and they are eventually given a degree based on how they perform in the course, we should not be bothered about brand value. Educational institutions should cater to as many students as possible without compromising on quality.
- ryanmonroe 11y agoThere are a lot of degrees that aren't worth taking out a 33k student loan for, but a masters from MIT probably isn't one of them
- sdrothrock 11y agoExcept it's not a MA/MS from MIT, it's a MicroMaster's (μM? uM?). The name even makes it sound weird and worse than a regular MA/MS.
- sotojuan 11y agoIs this for their OpenCourse Ware thing? IMO MIT OCW is very underrated and looked over in favor of Coursera, which I've almost always found inferior.
- copperx 11y agoI've never taken a full class in either, but although Coursera seems more structured (they have quizzes, tests, homework autograders), my impression is that Coursera is more technically diluted. This is for the CS and stat courses I have tried.
- sotojuan 11y agoA lot of MIT OCW courses have all of those aside from the autograders, but the reason I prefer OCW to Coursera is because OCW is self-paced. Many Coursera courses move very slowly (not their fault since they're taking thousands of students), or move too fast and have too much "homework" for a 9-5er. What's worse, some don't let you get ahead! With OCW I can set my own times and pace myself for my kind of learning. I also prefer college lectures and books to Coursera lectures. Like you said, Coursera content can be too simple.
- jacalata 11y agoMost of the Coursera courses I take are actual college courses, like this algorithms one - https://class.coursera.org/algs4partI-009 https://class.coursera.org/algs4partI-009 They are a lot of work to keep up with, but the good ones have deadlines about a month past the 'end' of the course so you can work at a much slower pace.
- singingwolfboy 11y agoThis is part of MIT's partnership with edX, which is different from the OpenCourseWare initiative.
- maouida 11y agoThey did not mention whether non-US residents are included in this program or not.
- sandworm101 11y agoIsn't the point of having a degree that you don't have to explain it? Isn't it shorthand for "I know X"? I'm not sure I want to spend a year working on an "MIT micromasters" only to have every interviewer ask wtf.
- amelius 11y agoIt is MIT. People will know about it. Especially HR people.
- frozenport 11y agoYeah, and they might know its nothing like actually getting a real graduate degree from MIT. MIT has a ~10% acceptance rate from a self selected group of elite candidates.
- vessenes 11y agoI have some experience with admissions at elite universities, and I can say that they generally weight candidates who have proven they can get "A" grades at their university or an equivalent much more favorably than unknown candidates. In fact, with most even Ivy League Universities, if you don't get in, but can move into town, and arrange to take a hard class or two, and ace them, you would find your next application would be much more favorably received. MIT is laying out a different path for these graduate students; essentially: "Let's not have to take you at your word for how successful you can be...Show me you can pass this degree program upfront by doing half of it." I don't think it's in MIT's interests to dilute their brand by issuing shitty substandard degrees; instead, it seems much more likely that they are looking for ways to on-board many more quality students and keep their recruitment / admissions cost-to-successful-graduate ratio as low as possible. Hence the "We have 40 grads a year, industry wants thousands" quote.
- TTPrograms 11y agoYou could argue that based on this argument one should never construct a new educational program.
- tonomics 11y agoAnyone has more information about what subjects they'd offer? Honestly, it's surprising this took so long to happen.
- martin_bech 11y agoAs someone living in a country with free education, 33k is a metric shit ton of money. (Denmark) But always cool, with more options.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- obituary_latte 11y agoAs someone living in a country (USA) where knowledge (or the experience of such) is a commodity, 33k is still a metric ton fuck of money. Agreed: more options is more better (I failed my paid English requirements, btw).
- paulojreis 11y agoAs someone from a rather poorer but still with free-ish education (Portugal [1]), 33k is indeed a metric shit-megatonne of money. [1] Here, tuition fees in public higher education are around € 1k/yr.
- colechristensen 11y agoYour education is obviously not free, somebody (still you) is paying for it, just not directly. I wonder how the actual cost differs?
- kaybe 11y agoSo I googled it, and for Germany there seems to be a mean cost of 118,000 € per student for the whole degree. It is very different depending on degree and also university. Medicine is very expensive and half the money goes into educating doctors. The cost per year per student ranges between 5930 € and 12,170€ over the Bundesländer (counties), maybe depending on the degrees offered? [1] I found a number for the average cost in the US at US$36,564 per year [2], which today is 32,199 €. So, for Germany, it's about a third per year on average. edit: Is the US tuition the full cost? [1]http://www.spiegel.de/unispiegel/studium/grossbild-263275-288574.html http://www.spiegel.de/unispiegel/studium/grossbild-263275-28... [2]http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/how-much-does-it-cost-study-us http://www.topuniversities.com/student-info/student-finance/...
- agumonkey 11y agoI guess this is for poor isolated geniuses that will find ways to be sponsored the remaining $33K otherwise I don't see how this would work.
- tzm 11y agoHere's the direct link to MITx MicroMaster’s credential http://micromasters.mit.edu/ http://micromasters.mit.edu/
- xcopy 11y agoVery good step
- rebekah-aimee 11y agoThis has to be really cost-effective for MIT; I mean, they aren't really putting much in the way of resources towards these online students. But I think it's an attempt to solve a problem that's already in the process of evolving into a non-problem. Most of the good programmers I know just go to school mostly for the credentials and to socialize with other programmers there, and then go home and self-teach for actual skill. School centers around getting a job. But it's starting to become not the only way to get a job. (Leaving out startups, of course; you don't really need credentials there except to impress VCs.) Some companies are recognizing that formal education in programming is not very effective, and are paying more attention to StackOverflow and GitHub accounts and that sort of thing. Our work and expertise is becoming more visible through the Internet. That suggests that maybe we're not going to have to worry so much about credentials. My older brother is doing very well for himself as a developer, without any formal training past some classes in high school back in the 90s. As for myself, I'm leaving for Kansas City once I'm done with my Associate's degree, and I'm going to UMKC there... for a few semesters, until I find a job and/or a cofounder. I don't intend to finish the degree I'm going to sign up for. They let slip during my visit there that they're already having issues convincing students to finish their degrees rather than let themselves be hired out. But I do intend to go, in order to meet other programmers. That's the real power of universities: they collect bright, ambitious people and let them work together. Online classes don't have that power, and the credential problem is already being solved better, so I don't think this is going to go very far. But maybe it'll help accelerate the current solution by giving more credence to self-teaching and online study. Good try, but it'll probably be irrelevant in the end. Kind of begs the question of whether one could recreate the social aspect of universities and leave out the expense of formal classes as they are now? For instance, whether you could make a sort of hackerspace-modelled university where all the "classes" were projects that one student was looking for help with? I'd attend that. Hmm... sounds familiar, doesn't it? ;)
- chambo622 11y ago>> Kind of begs the question of whether one could recreate the social aspect of universities and leave out the expense of formal classes as they are now? For instance, whether you could make a sort of hackerspace-modelled university where all the "classes" were projects that one student was looking for help with? I'd attend that. Sounds kind of like Make School [1]. Will be interesting to see the outcomes for their first real 'class' of students. [1] https://www.makeschool.com/ https://www.makeschool.com/
- Pxtl 11y agoAll I can think of is the Micromasters transformers toy line.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- EugeneOZ 11y agoWill it help to get visa? I'm in :)
- Elizer0x0309 11y agoThey should just allow for exam taking for free and if you pass you need to pay a certain amount for the degree. At least it'll cut through the BS.
- F2468 11y agoExams will be proctored. That costs money. Who picks up the tab when a student fails?
- Elizer0x0309 11y agoOk, charge cheap exams, whatever the proctors cost + getting a room etc. (<$100)
- Futurebot 11y agoIf this is successful, perhaps they'd consider expanding this to a Bachelor's (MicroBachelors). It's a step in the right direction, at least. I've gone through a lot of the MIT OCW videos and notes, and by and large, the quality is very high. Promising.
- grumblestumble 11y agoI think that would be very useful for a lot of older tech types, like myself, who never bothered with a Bachelor's degree in the first place. I'm in the East Bay and there are a number of master-level programs that seem very interesting, but the idea of doing a 4-year undergrad degree at this point makes me want to stab my eyes out - I'm pushing 40, have kids, and doing fine in my career.
- Animats 11y agoBut "supply chain management"? It seems that three months buying parts in Shentzen, a month at the Port of Los Angeles, and an intership at Digi-Key or Mouser would be the path to expertise in that.
- grumblestumble 11y agoI spent eight years building software for global sourcing operations and supply chain management. It's both incredibly dull and incredibly intricate. As a result of designing and building the software, I have a fair amount of expertise in the field, but I'd never admit it to anyone.
- saintfiends 11y agoAre there no online undergraduate degree courses? Why is it always master's? For example Georgia Tech has online master's degrees but no undergraduate courses.
- erebus_rex 11y agoGetting employers to accept online bachelors is a lot harder than masters. Most jobs have bachelors requirements and an online degree will likely get flagged. But for a masters it can work as an added bonus.
- hack_mm 11y agoWhy do we care of showing degrees off and that gets counted in? "I have a board which says 'Alas, I graduated MBA from 'bla bla'" I would say, if we are able to show what we have built, or talk and convince intellectually as to what we are capable to build should matter more than any piece of paper. I do agree, there would be a problem of filtering the right ones for a job in lieu of a "paper degree", but I hope there comes a better way in the world to judge and educate people to be more innovative and building real incremental things rather than just getting 'paper degrees'
- m3talridl3y 11y agoMicroMasters? Is that like a Bachelor's without calling it a Bachelor's, so people keep paying exorbitant amounts of money to attend physical classes to ultimately get a piece of paper? Ok MIT.
- bzbarsky 11y agoIf you read the article, it clearly says that they let you do the first half of the Masters in this degree program online for much cheaper than doing it on campus. Then if you do well enough they give you a certificate for that part, and if you want you can do the second half of the Masters at that point, paying half of the normal amount you would pay for the full Masters degree. If nothing else, this restricts the set of people who end up paying for that second half to those who have already demonstrated they can handle the work.
- vessenes 11y agoIt also makes it more likely that their employers will foot the bill. Saying "I did the first half, here are my grades, please send me for the second" is a pretty compelling pitch.
- hack_mmmm 11y agoWell, Why do we care of showing degrees off and that gets counted in? "I have a board which says 'Alas, I graduated MBA from 'bla bla'" I would say, if we are able to show what we have built, or talk and convince intellectually as to what we are capable to build should matter more than any piece of paper. I do agree, there would be a problem of filtering the right ones for a job in lieu of a "paper degree", but I hope there comes a better way in the world to judge and educate people to be more innovative and building real incremental things rather than just getting 'paper degrees'"