14 ms·
When Schools Overlook Introverts
- danharaj 11y agoTop-down prescription of how children and teachers ought to run a school will always neglect particular groups and individuals. There is no one system or theory that meets the needs of everyone. One would think that the solution would be to decentralize the organization of schools and take a bottom-up approach, and not merely at the level of teachers, but at the level of students. Students deserve autonomy and a voice in their learning environment. Teachers deserve autonomy in designing curricula.
- lsiq 11y agoThis is nitpicking but, the A-level (the basement) at Regenstein library at the University of Chicago is not exactly a quiet reading area, it is typically loudest floor in the whole building.
- johnloeber 11y agoTypically the loudest floor is the ground [first] floor...
- lsiq 11y agoIt has been a few years since I graduated, but my impression is always that people were in general much more willing/allowed to talk in the A-level more than on any other floor. Sure the ground floor could get packed but the amount of dBs/person was higher in the A-level, so it would it be louder if it was actually packed as well. This likely also because the A-level has the cubicles in the back that were set up precisely for group work. In any case, it is misleading for the article to say that converting the A-level to a more collaborative environment is taking away from introverts'. Especially since the A-level is one of the louder rooms in one of the louder libraries.
- themodelplumber 11y agoAs a strong introvert I remember sitting in class, age 8 or so, and wishing with all my heart that I could have a big thick stone enclosure around my desk, extending halfway up to the ceiling. I was working on multiplication tables at the time and was feeling extremely overstimulated to the point where I couldn't focus (and to clarify, I didn't know I was overstimulated, or even that I couldn't focus, at the time). Since then I've learned more about introversion, and I now look back and recognize the brief moments when the school system tried to reach into my introvert life and make things easier. Unfortunately, by the time they filtered from administration down to me, these attempts (e.g. typology testing for career and school advice, or special workshops) were either so watered down as to be completely useless or so boring-sounding and voluntary that no student in their right mind would attend them without prodding.
- vinceguidry 11y ago> Unfortunately, by the time they filtered from administration down to me, these attempts (e.g. typology testing for career and school advice, or special workshops) were either so watered down as to be completely useless or so boring-sounding and voluntary that no student in their right mind would attend them without prodding. This is what I think of every time I hear people proposing changes to education. Nothing is going to work, because nothing can work, because nothing is going to look the same from ideation to implementation.
- vonmoltke 11y agoFunny, that's how I feel in open-plan offices...
- meatysnapper 11y agoOpen plan offices are the work of the devil + management + architecture. Probably the worst idea since "Let's delay our invasion of Russia a few months later in the fall".
- mildbow 11y agowell, it worked out for Russia :)
- cryoshon 11y agoI'd say that most paradigms of grade school style learning overlook introverts by default. There's usually some sort of grade-based participation bonus for speaking out and answering the teacher's questions as soon as they're posed. There's almost always group project components as well, in which introverts won't be able to shine as much. IMHO it's part of a larger system of not valuing introverts as a society. Being talkative gets people noticed, and being quiet gets people forgotten, and, as a result, neglected. I don't have any real solution to propose, just an observation that in most cases, introverts are worse off for their social disposition. Ambiverts are probably the best positioned for success, provided that they are able to play up their extraversion when around extroverts and play it down when around introverts.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI wonder if there will be a time when introverts are being viewed as a discriminated group. It's not OK to make disparaging remarks about people of certain races, sexual orientation and other groups but it seems to be OK to make negative remarks about introverted or shy people. When I hear about women having it difficult to make their way in tech professions I always remember how hard it was to be a shy teenager.
- cryoshon 11y agoYeah, I'd say introversion can have debilitating/disabling downsides (especially for younger people, from my own experience), but also a few powerful upsides when it comes to information processing and focused cognition. I don't really identify with the accepted negative remarks against introverts, though. The closest I can comment on is the perpetual "why are you so antisocial" line from childhood through adulthood, which is simultaneously infuriating and isolating. Children and young adults that are introverted are almost always constantly cajoled frequently to "be more social", and, of course, it's to their detriment to be so frequently indirectly reminded that they are outsiders. Of course, introverts are almost always going to be at a disadvantage in social skills, popularity contests, job interviews, etc-- and these things are far more critical to "success" than mere skill or intelligence. I'd say introverts are also usually slightly worse at the skill of having grit, too-- frequently there's something about having to struggle alone that makes failures more final. I imagine there's some great works waiting to be written regarding the experience of introversion from the 1980s to the present. The current crop of hackers are probably the first who have seen society go from viewing them as "antisocial" to "cool nerds".
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis is also why I'm so against the typical public school systems we've built in the US. Its a top-down beaurocratic system that does nothing but transfer wealth from the taxpayer to the teachers and their unions. Outcomes are piss poor in big cities and endless strikes for benefits and pay aren't wonderful things. Chicago is reeling from a pension crisis right now mostly due to corrupt deals with a corrupt teacher's union. A teacher's union with an average teacher's salary of $72,000 a year - for 9 months work in a very affordable city! How affordable? Our average household income is $43,000. We need more charter schools and alternative learning either funded by the state with existing tax dollars or attached to property tax breaks for parents using them instead of the standard public school. We've been fighting for more charter schools but they come slowly because of all the pro-union politics that many liberals, unfortunately, consider unquestionable. You'd think liberals would be on the side of alternate education, especially since there's so much research on different types of children responding better to these methods. As an introvert and somewhat of a non-standard learner, I got lucky that my parents were able to afford private school for me. I know a lot of other introverts didn't get so lucky and suffered badly in public school. Some of them are doing very poorly in life and I fully believe if they had different educations opportunities they'd be much better off. A top-down system that works only with extroverted neurotypicals is a huge disservice to children and the taxpayer.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- panzagl 11y agoYou are extrapolating one school system to the whole US. Chicago has chosen to organize its schools that way because it is one of the more corrupt cities in the country.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI'm really not. Captive money into public school systems is asinine. That taxpayer money should be put into a pot and then handed out to different school systems like charter schools and other alternative schools, not just straight into public schools. We've had a lot of success with our charter schools even in Chicago. Vouchers for private schools would be good too. Choice and competition work.
- talmand 11y agoIn some cases they aren't overlooked, they get suspended for being involved in a physical altercation (bully beat them up) just like any other student.
- yodsanklai 11y agoMy feeling is that school was an introvert heaven as compared to adult professional life.
- cryoshon 11y agoYeah, I get this feeling too, for the most part. One thing I've noticed about working in a professional setting is that social performance and actual job performance are incorrectly intertwined in people's minds. There's some sort of carryover of positive emotions from strong social interactions when people consider their coworkers work quality, leading to mediocre but savvy workers getting rave reviews.
- anon4 11y agoBut making people feel like they like you is pretty easy. You just interact with them now and again and prop up their ego, tell a joke and that's that. I mean, in case you don't have anything in common and don't like them much. If you do like them as a friend, then it should happen naturally.
- zephyrfalcon 11y ago"But making people feel like they like you is pretty easy." For an extrovert, yes. :) Or for the introvert who knows these things and knows how to do them credibly. For some of us, it's neither easy nor obvious. I have, of course, noticed these things too, in school- and work situations... If you are talkative, it's OK, but if you're not, you are "weird", "aloof", "arrogant", or people simply think you dislike them. Yes, you can learn to make superficial conversation, but personally it all feels really fake to me.
- cracoucax 11y ago>> but personally it all feels really fake to me. This. I am an introvert, and this is the crux of the problem to me. People have no problem whatsoever making smalltalk with persons they don't like, are happy to promote themselves on the web and whatnot as the best guy you can imagine, always feel entitled to give their opinions even if they have no idea about what is being talked about. It's all a fake friends, fake interesting lives, fake enthusiasm and popularity contest. If you don't participate in that shit or mention problems instead of being excited, you're singled out. Errors are forgotten easily and leave no trace on the inflated ego because they don't have the balls to look at themselves critically. But i'm the guy with issues, sure...
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoWhen schools overlook introverts, they grow up and write songs like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YR5ApYxkU-U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YR5ApYxkU-U (Pink Floyd)
- kazinator 11y agoWhat I mostly remember of school is that it grossly overlooked my great need to be elsewhere, doing something else with my time. I was greatly "extroverted": oriented toward that great exterior sprawling on the other side of the classroom's window panes.
- vvpan 11y agoSo, is "introvert" a real thing? I feel like it's just a big group of character traits that are all gathered under an umbrella term.
- izzydata 11y agoFrom what I understand there is only one thing that constitutes as introvert and that is a person who finds social interaction draining. They aren't necessarily shy, or not outgoing or anything, but they eventually need to get away from people. Opposite from that is an extrovert who finds being alone draining and needs people to to gain that back.
- vvpan 11y agoSure I've heard that definition. Yet it describes a "symptom", and not a process which it is a manifestation of. I just feel like the discussion about "introvert" is extremely shallow: here is a child, she's an "introvert". And it ends at that. We've started to use the word as a noun, but should we? I think I used to be not introverted as a child. Then, as I experienced the pressure of moving to another country during teens, I became more introverted. And now I am not.
- balabaster 11y agoAs someone who has "battled" introversion for much of my life, I can agree with the sentiment of the statement. I say battled because I feel like when I say I'm an introvert, people around me scoff because they feel I'm the farthest thing from an introvert. I'm happy to hold court with those who want to take part in my conversations and I strike up conversations with complete strangers on the train... I'm not particularly shy per se and I don't lack for confidence in my abilities or place in the world. But if I don't get "me time" on a daily basis, it would be like other people going without sleep. It's time to allow cognitive processing, but unlike sleep, it's conscious cognitive processing. I need this time to make sense of the world, ideas that would otherwise never be given enough thought to understand or process. Your statement has caused me some self reflection and I think I agree. I can't say upon reflection that I am either an introvert or extrovert. I find many types of personalities draining - as I'm sure we all do, even extroverts. I need time away from these personalities to recharge. Preferably time on my own to do my own thing, tinker, watch the world go by, but most of all think, uninterrupted or intruded upon. There are types of people that suck energy from other people. Those that require constant attention: Those that feed off your attention and will do whatever they feel they need to in order to absorb that from you. That is mentally exhausting to most of us. For me this includes people I've labelled (for better or worse) show offs - the 'look at me, don't you agree how clever/talented/awesome I am?' types. There are also types of people that recharge you. Those that give freely of their energy, but don't require your attention. They happily send their energy your way and then let it go, content to go back to what they were doing without a need for constant reassurance or input from you. They bounce in and out of conversation, make you laugh, engage with you, but don't constantly sap your energy. Just as content to share space and not talk as they are to converse with you. Having to be around people that constantly need or fight for your attention, always making noise, talking just to talk, interrupting your thought mid sentence; those that never appear to have any respect for the directives: If you don't have anything to say that improves upon the silence, don't say anything at all; and say as much as you can in as few words as possible. These are the kinds of people that drain everyone... we label people who can't put up with this for very long 'Introverts' and people that are this 'Extroverts' :P I say that tongue in cheek, I don't believe this is the definition of extroverts... extroverts just appear to be more immune to the energy sapping effect of this type of behavior. In reality, I don't believe that any of us are either of these things in totality. What I do believe we are, are people with varying levels of tolerance of other people invading our personal space or mental bubble uninvited; intruding on our thought processes and spoken word with few manners or thought for those on the receiving end of that behaviour.
- ryanobjc 11y agoI've often been told about the benefits of "group work" and "collaborative working" and thus "open plan offices" but I feel like that much energy can reduce the depth of knowledge and thought. You're replacing depth with breadth. The operating theory is that by offering a multitude of view points, you make up for the single thinker. And in areas of human dilemma, this can work. For example, consider marketing or other human-centric activities. But when the problem gets difficult, the essential superficial nature of this style of problem solving becomes apparent. This is where a single member then leaves the group, sequesters their self in solitude then emerges with the answer later.
- CIPHERSTONE 11y agoOpen plan offices are all about one thing: maximizing headcount per sq/ft. All designs focus on putting more people into the same amount of space. Assigning dedicating space to one person is not as efficient as making the space first come first server. IMHO organizations that embrace open plan offices need to 100% embrace work from home/telecommuting. Because after all, if you don's need to have a face to face, why do you need to be sitting in an open plan office space? Boggles the mind really.
- dreamdu5t 11y agoIntroversion/extroversion is a false dichotomy. There is no such thing, and no evidence fundamental personality types exist. Carl Jung's theories are unfalsifiable, untestable, and pseudoscientific. Promulgating this quackery is damaging to people who are labeled as such and go on to identify with it.
- vvpan 11y agoI fully agree. I've seen people (including myself) go through varying degrees of introversion based on external experiences. Identification can be a strongly limiting and a destructive power. When it comes to "introvert" reservations about fully identifying with a term seem to vanish for most people - those who identify and those who do not.
- Jtsummers 11y ago> Identification can be a strongly limiting and a destructive power. This cannot be emphasized enough. Sometimes identifying mental characteristics/behaviors can be very important (for instance, depression) in that it allows you to start examining it and trying to correct it, or build a career or social life that takes account of it. But many people latch onto non-disorder labels (like introversion) and use it to justify all their behavior ("I don't want to go out on Friday night because I'm an introvert." - spoken by many of my friends, even when going out just meant a night in playing board games that they originally suggested). This isn't true of all introverts, but many self-identified introverts that I've met the last several years exhibit behavior more in common with burnout and depression. They hold the dual views of wanting to do things with people (their friends at least) but refusing to go out because it means dealing with people (often those same friends). At some point, like I did, you have to figure out a healthy way to deal with your desire to have quiet time/alone time/whatever time in a way that doesn't frustrate the people you want in your life to the point that they end up leaving you behind. Or you need to find friends that you actually find yourself desiring more time with.
- SpaceCadetJones 11y agoWhat? Introversion/Extroversion certainly has evidence, and it's not just some quackery only Jung had things to say about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits I believe the strong+absolute dichotomy people try and present on the trait is false, but that's a misunderstanding of how personality traits interact in complex ways to produce behaviors. Some of my acquaintances might think I'm an extrovert, but that's because they've only seen me in particular environments and I'm mildly to strongly introverted but not absolutely. I know I personally found it relieving to learn some of the facets of introversion and know that I wasn't weird or broken and many people felt the same things that I did although I didn't realize it.
- csense 11y agoThinking back to my own middle/high school experiences, group work just gives the poor students a free pass to slack off, because they know the good students in their group will pick up the slack. I usually worked alone if the option was available, because if I worked in a group I'd almost always end up having to do / re-do everyone else's sub-par work anyway. It was the same workload either way, but working in a group would essentially be giving others "counterfeit" grades (based on my effort, not theirs), the existence of which necessarily devalues my "genuine" grade.
- smelendez 11y agoThis seems like such a universal experience, and looking back on it, teachers obviously know it's going on. I wonder how much their plans to train kids for the "real world" are shaped by working in such unusual environments themselves. I've never had a job where my performance is judged based on how a random group of teenagers I've been assigned to does on a project, but teachers certainly have.
- gohrt 11y agoMany professionals in the real world work in team environments where they depend on each other, and you can't just ignore your teammates bad work. This is certainly true in all but the smallest software shops.
- verbin217 11y agoRight but the usually accepted answer is not: I just give them bullshit to do or otherwise plan on having time to do their work if/when they don't do it sufficiently. That's the right answer. We just don't like it because it condemns people. We really need basic income so we can start being more ruthless about this. Honestly I think it could save some of these people from a downward spiral of bullshitting. They're just scared and we all know they have good reason to be so we give them a pass.
- gozo 11y agoIn my experience it's even more important in small software shops because you're going to be good at different things and there's no room for ego.
- relaytheurgency 11y agoWhen I was studying to be an educator I was often branded a heretic for challenging the new modes of teaching as being hypocritical and potentially unfounded. I never became an educator after student teaching. This article really puts into words my issues with group learning, project based learning, and all the other buzzwords flying around schools of education. I remember being a student in school and relishing the moments where I could be by myself and focus on whatever needed doing. Now students are lucky to have a moment of peace as they're prodded into unnatural learning environments meant to mimic a "real world" that frankly doesn't exist.
- balabaster 11y ago> "I used to think their ubiquitous earbuds were feeding their need for stimulation; now I wonder if they’re sometimes blocking out the noise." Most of the time my earbuds are in, I'm either listening to white noise or I'm not listening to anything at all... I put them in with the intention of listening to music, but never actually get as far as remembering to put the music on - and it's exactly for that, blocking out noise. Frequently, even if I have music playing, I'm not even listening to the music, I'm just drowning out distraction so I can concentrate.
- dataker 11y agoA more private DOES
- _moogs 11y agoBeing in a classroom full of noisy students raised my anxiety in elementary school. I wish I could ease myself in with groups instead of just being thrown in one with the most obnoxious kids. I'm in my twenties now and still dislike working in groups. I'm far more productive and mentally stress free when working in solidarity.
- bagelwhiteoff 11y agoA more private and individualist education is the only reason I succeeded in life. Before I came to the U.S, I went to South American private schools and it was a living nightmare. You breath collectivism and herd mentality is the only answer. Because I'd refuse to work with groups, my grades were terrible and teachers often recommended my parents to seek 'special education'. When I got in the U.S, I tested out of as many classes as possible and graduated HS at 15. If I had a talented child, I'd follow this map: http://image.slidesharecdn.com/gertjan-penelope-telemachos-and-odysseus-141125033528-conversion-gate02/95/penelope-telemachos-and-odysseus-18-638.jpg?cb=1416886594 http://image.slidesharecdn.com/gertjan-penelope-telemachos-a...
- scardine 11y agoI'm surprised nobody mentioned people diagnosed in the autistic spectrum, because so many are attracted to engineering and computer science - I guess there are many of us lurking around here...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dwd 11y agoThe issue really comes down to society still thinking introversion is a bad thing. You are often perceived to be shy and quiet or antisocial. Most introverts are neither of these, yet the labels persist and introversion like being left-handed was in the past is currently seen as something to be fixed.
- et2o 11y agoMinor correction: The A-level at the University of Chicago is already a floor where students are allowed to speak freely.
- abalashov 11y agoI wrote a critique of group work based on my own experiences with it in school and in university, echoing many of the same grievances against voiced in this discussion: http://likewise.am/2015/07/01/on-communication-skills-and-pedagogy/ http://likewise.am/2015/07/01/on-communication-skills-and-pe... I took particular issue with the alleged wisdom of putting students of very heterogenous levels together so that the better ones can serve as a "role model". However, my conclusion was that the best medicine is a return to more structured and - in some respects - authoritarian teaching methods centred around the lecture, not a different kind of diffuse self-motivated learning model.
- jokoon 11y agoI failed at several higher education schools in France PRECISELY because of group projects. All my scores were fine or high, except for those stupid team project which counted for a huge score coefficient. Failed so many job interviews because I don't have a degree or because I'm less social. The worst is when some director argued with me that human are a social species. Just like Susan Cain wrote about it, it really seems that there is a Salesman culture. It almost seems that we considers introverts to be handicapped.
- jasonkester 11y agoSorry to hear. But surely you have to agree that your introversion has handicapped you significantly in life? From your own story, it sounds like it stopped you from being able to complete a degree program and has cost you job opportunities. It sounds like something worth working on fixing or at least working around. I was a super shy kid and am still way on the introverted side of the spectrum. But I've learned to work on teams and to lead them. It's a skill, like any other. Much like you couldn't blame the paratroopers for rejecting you for refusing to jump out of planes, you can't really blame a school or employer for rejecting you if you refuse to learn to overcome your aversion to working with groups.
- jokoon 11y ago> Sorry to hear. But surely you have to agree that your introversion has handicapped you significantly in life? Not significantly. Yes, but which is the cause ? My personality or the standard people deems normal ? Not saying I'm normal, but maybe it's a chicken egg problem. There are tolerances and expectations at play. Oh and by handicapped I meant like introversion is overlooked as a mental illness, like lonely people are somehow retarded. > you can't really blame a school or employer for rejecting you if you refuse to learn to overcome your aversion to working with groups. I'm not blaming anybody, but at some point people have to learn about it and not just run with it like it's a standard. Also, higher education programs should not be meant to teach people how to work with groups. How do you really expect people to learn something technical by forcing them to socialize ?