6 ms·
How is it possible that the real emission is 40x the allowed limit? Wouldn't you see VW being the only manufacturer under the limit, and everyone else unable to
by lordnacho 11y ago
How is it possible that the real emission is 40x the allowed limit? Wouldn't you see VW being the only manufacturer under the limit, and everyone else unable to get the car approved? Or alternatively, everyone is cheating? Because you can imagine a world where some firms cheat to get 10-20-30% less than rated, so that they're in line with the industry.
But if VW's normal car is 40x worse than advertised, and most cars were close to the correct standard, wouldn't they just hire a guy who knew how to fix their cars? Did VW's internal testing test competitors' cars?
Is this going to explode across the industry?
Also, this isn't the only kind of test that a car goes through. There's crash tests, MPG tests, and all sorts of things that I wouldn't know about. If you can game an emissions test, you can game the crash test and the MPG test, which are probably both things people care about a fair bit more than emissions.
- ethagknight 11y agoThe researchers also tested a diesel BMW X5, which passed emissions tests. [0] I would guess that its just more expensive to implement, more steps in the filtration process, larger catalytic converters, etc. [0] http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/09/23/us-usa-volkswagen-researchers-idUSKCN0RM2D720150923 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/09/23/us-usa-volkswagen-...
- tobltobs 11y agoSmaller, cheaper cars are the problem. The bigger cars have a better catalysator system. All those compact diesel cars from Opel, VW, Renault, Peugeot, Nissan will have the same problem.
- junto 11y agoWhat is crazy is that the vast amount of people who buy these small diesels don't need them. You need long runs to get the particle filter hot enough to burn off. People buying these small diesels are buying them based on the fuel consumption benefits but then only doing short trips like 15 minute school runs. All they are doing is damaging the car.
- rconti 11y agoThere have also been no claims that the VW Touareg TDI failed. So 6cyl SUVs pass. There aren't many 4cyl diesels in the US. Chevy Cruze. New BMW 328d. I imagine the new 328d passes just fine, but supposedly the new-for-2016 VW E288 diesels do as well.. they just never got a chance to sell them!
- SystemOut 11y agoThe BMWs also use a urea based system that separates the NOx into Nitrogen and Oxygen and does it very well. However, those systems are expensive and add a lot of costs to the car. VW wouldn't be able to sell their TDI cars as cheaply if they had to incur this cost. That's why they pass and why they have passed alternative tests. I just bought a new GTI about a month ago...not sure if their gas cars will take a valuation hit or not due to VWs reputation hit. At least it wasn't a TDI Golf or I'd be extremely pissed.
- mzs 11y agoIt is why competitors like diesel Cruze had worse performance and others like Mazda did not quite bring to market. VW knew they could own the US diesel small passenger car market but they had to meet customer demands on fuel efficiency, performance, and price.
- TheGRS 11y agoI had read something about how diesel engines can use Urea to trap emissions, but it must be refilled frequently, so possibly other manufacturers are using that method. This is tested and proved to work well. However, VW was using another type of method to diminish emissions that has not been well proven. Source: a comment I read on Reddit, so take it with a grain of salt. Edit: found at least one source on how this works: http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1042727_adding-urea-to-clean-diesel-cars-can-i-just-pee-in-the-tank http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1042727_adding-urea-to-c...
- ju-st 11y agoIt's called "AdBlue": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust_fluid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust_fluid
- arprocter 11y agoThus why Merc calls theirs BlueTec
- mrich 11y agoAdBlue is also used in the latest Audi ultra TDI engines. It is supposed to be refilled during normal service (every 30000 km), unfortunately it does not last that long and you have to schedule an appointment much earlier. Refilling it yourself is apparently not possible since a software reset is necessary as well.
- superuser2 11y agoThe problem affects only diesel cars, and VW is the only company I've heard of selling a significant number of diesel passenger cars in the US.
- harperlee 11y agoThere are other countries in the world, and in some of those countries, there are significant numbers of diesel passenger cars.
- happyscrappy 11y agoEuropean emission standards are lax, and I would imagine the rest of the world even laxer. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-09-23/no-cheating-needed-europe-s-lax-laws-make-diesel-tests-a-snap http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-09-23/no-cheatin...
- TylerE 11y agoLike anything it's a trade off. Emissions and efficiency are usually conflicting goals. Automakers are under a ton of strain right now to achieve BOTH, which is essentially impossible. The VW TDIs are some of the only vehicles to even get close to the efficiency that will be required in just a few years, regardless of emissions.
- happyscrappy 11y agoExcept that poor air quality has a severe impact on people.
- TylerE 11y agoPoor is relative. Even a "bad" car by current standards would have been considered extremely clean even 5 years ago.
- 11y ago
- mhb 11y agoAlso, weren't the competing car companies curious about how they could also save money on their emissions systems and buy a VW to reverse engineer?
- mitchty 11y agoI bet they did and as soon as they saw why just decided to wait to see how long it took for them to get discovered. That or they decided to implement it too. Only way to know is to test car emissions.
- BashiBazouk 11y agoThe 4 cylinder TDI was for the economy range of vehicles. The more expensive models with bigger engines use urea tanks or BlueTec as Mercedes Benz politely calls it. More expensive to make and service, but those who buy more expensive vehicles expect these kind of added service costs. Those on the lower end do not.
- chad_c 11y ago>The 4 cylinder TDI was for the economy range of vehicles I have a 2014 Jetta TDI (4 cyl) with urea injection. I'm totally confused by the information surrounding what cars are affected.
- scott_karana 11y agoModel year vs production/purchase year probably doesn't help. As far as I understood, "model year 2015" cars (made/sold in 2014) are unaffected as of yet, because of the urea injection.
- BashiBazouk 11y agoI'm guessing that the cars with urea injection will be fine. It will be tested by the EPA and CARB if you are in California to make sure. Since the urea injection is there specifically to deal with the pollution this issue is causing, the only cheat I would imagine would be to lengthen the amount of time to change the urea tank and if that is the case, VW will be required to cover the added service costs.
- mzs 11y agoNot so sure myself, check-out page 63: http://www.theicct.org/use-emissions-testing-light-duty-diesel-vehicles-us http://www.theicct.org/use-emissions-testing-light-duty-dies... Car B was a 4cy VW diesel with urea from last year.
- jessaustin 11y agoI've driven several pickups that require diesel exhaust fluid. It's really not a big deal. If you don't want to pay $3/g for it at Walmart then go to a truck stop where you can get it from a pump for slightly less.
- malka 11y agoit's 40x from "faked condition test" to "road condition". And the "test condition" are totally unrealistic behavior on the road (such as 0-50km/h in 26 seconds) Most car are above the allowed limit in real situation.
- joshmoz 11y agoWhen I was car shopping the VW diesel numbers, for tdi sportwagen in particular, were impressive. Nothing else came close to VW's combination of power, space, and mileage. Now maybe there are people who know more about cars than I do and can dispute that, but that was my perception a couple of years ago. If I were the other car companies, I'd want to know exactly how VW was pulling that off. They must have looked into it, and surely they're not as easily misled as I apparently was (how would I know if VW was outright lying about the car?). This suggests to me that the other car companies must have known that VW was doing something wrong. The fact that they didn't rat VW out suggests to me that they were either doing the same thing (maybe not as aggressively as VW) or they hoped to get away with the same thing. The former seems more likely, and if that's true then I expect this to spread beyond VW soon.
- dragontamer 11y agoIt was a researcher from West Virginia who tested it. Researcher is on the record as "I didn't believe the results" and "I thought I made a mistake". Also, lol @ efficient market thesis because the results of his research were posted early 2014. EPA took a look at them, and being the slow bureaucracy that it is... took a year and a half to levy charges against Volkswagen. So this entire "surprise" was over a year in the making. It's been discussed publicly in research groups for a year and no one seemed to care till now.
- mzs 11y agoSlight correction, EPA was not slow to act. When they caught wind of this they approached VW who had one excuse after another: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/09/22/anatomy-of-volkswagons-deception-the-recall-that-never-fixed-any-cars/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/09/22/an...
- qubex 11y agoThe EMH predicts that unless the net probability of effects where totally zero there would be a move. I don't see evidence of there having been one.
- acveilleux 11y agoCollision tests can be gamed obviously by designing for the fixtures used... But the variety of fixtures in use and testing protocols imposes a decent all around level. It's hard to cheat when 3000 lbs of steel is crashed at 40mph against a concrete obstacle. Fuel consumption however, now that is rife for cheating by trading off performance for better fuel consumption in the ECU and automatic transmissions.
- downandout 11y agoAccording to [1]: "Volkswagen hasn't explained exactly why it cheated, but outside analysts have a good guess. The NOx emission controls likely degraded the cars' performance when they were switched on — the engines ran hotter, wore out more quickly, and got poorer mileage. Some experts have suggested that the emission controls may have affected the cars' torque and acceleration, making them less fun to drive. (Indeed, some individual car owners have been known to disable their cars' emission controls to boost performance, though this is against the law.)" So basically, they wanted the cars to have acceptable performance in real-world conditions, which pushes the emissions up. [1] http://www.vox.com/2015/9/21/9365667/volkswagen-clean-diesel-recall-passenger-cars http://www.vox.com/2015/9/21/9365667/volkswagen-clean-diesel...
- hinkley 11y agoWhen I got my Jetta TDI, it had a nasty stutter when the engine was cold. It's three blocks from my house to the arterial, and I had a couple of close calls when I tried to pull into traffic and nothing happened. When I took the car in for 10k miles they had a ROM upgrade that fixed the problem, but I'm wondering now if they cheated to do it.
- autobahn 11y ago40x is likely a massive overstatement. Nobody's actually released any actual numbers or data yet.
- mzs 11y agoCheck-out page 63, looks to be 40x on the graph: http://www.theicct.org/use-emissions-testing-light-duty-diesel-vehicles-us http://www.theicct.org/use-emissions-testing-light-duty-dies...
- chaostheory 11y agoLG has cheated Energy Star ratings with its refridgerators http://www.treehugger.com/clean-technology/lg-under-the-gun-for-cheating-on-energy-efficiency-testing.html http://www.treehugger.com/clean-technology/lg-under-the-gun-...