7 ms·
The Bitcoin Community Disagrees on What Happens Next
- jokoon 11y ago"Community" ? You mean a horde of tech speculators who would gladly get an opportunity benefit from having some insight about bitcoin just to benefit from it. I don't understand how there could really be a community that revolves around a crypto currency. It's just some people with a libertarian agenda, who don't like banks or government, and want to make money. I would gladly hear about the community of programmers who actually write code and try to design new decentralized technology. The "bitcoin community" is not that. I don't think you can find many expert on how bitcoin works. I would rather call those people finance tech entrepreneurs.
- qwertyboy 11y agoThe existence of "finance tech entrepreneurs", as you politely call them, and the fact that they are indeed very noisy, does not mean there isn't a community of programmers who actually write code and try to design new decentralized technology.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aianus 11y ago> It's just some people with a libertarian agenda, who don't like banks or government Sounds like a community to me.
- wpietri 11y agoIt depends. It takes more to form a community than a common descriptor. For example, consider "atheist". There isn't really an "atheist community", in that there's very little in common between atheist Buddhists, atheist Jews, former Catholics, apostate Muslims, atheist skeptics, atheist Unitarians, etc, etc. There are many communities that are accidentally or intentionally atheistic, of course. But that doesn't mean there's a community of atheists. Given both the Bitcoin and libertarian tendencies against centrality, I'd be really surprised to discover that there was really a single Bitcoin or libertarian community. I'd expect a number of relatively distinct communities that interact around common resources or interests. As an example, consider the Great Lakes. There isn't really a Great Lakes community; people in Toronto and Chicago don't have much sense of shared identity. But the shared resource demands joint action, so you see things like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes%E2%80%93Saint_Lawrence_River_Basin_Sustainable_Water_Resources_Agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes%E2%80%93Saint_Lawr...
- benihana 11y ago>I don't understand how there could really be a community that revolves around a crypto currency. "I admit to not understanding this thing, yet feel okay spouting off some smug opinions about it." Ok.
- brighton36 11y agoRight. There's an obvious community around bitcoin. If this guy doesn't understand why that community exists, then why would his opinion be relevant...
- adrianmacneil 11y ago> I would gladly hear about the community of programmers who actually write code and try to design new decentralized technology. The "bitcoin community" is not that. You obviously have not met any of the bitcoin core developers. There are many talented people pouring their time and energy into bitcoin, not because they have a libertarian agenda or want to get rich quick, but because they believe in building a new decentralized technology.
- jron 11y agobitcoin is a 256-bit number. Today, governments would like to regulate the usage of approximately 33,437,921 of these magic numbers. I'm guessing most of community can at least find humor in this.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThat's not really how they divide... And they don't care about the numbers in general, unlike certain other cases where people have tried to restrict numbers entirely. They just regulate transfers of control of value. You can communicate transfers of control of value with anything. Rocks, flags, numbers, dance. Doesn't mean governments want to regulate "magic rocks".
- jron 11y agoSure, you can represent private keys in many different formats and the keyspace is effectively 160-bit when brute forcing known addresses. I'm just making the point that unlike rocks and flags, bitcoin is intangible and more like speech. If I posted a number which happened to have a value of $14,001 USD in this post, I would be breaking the law. If I sold t-shirts with bitcoin private keys printed on them, I would be considered an unlicensed money transmitter by FinCEN.
- Dylan16807 11y agoSame thing could happen if you point out a safety deposit box you're giving away with a pin of 00000000. It's not really about the number, because I can say 0 all day.
- jron 11y agoUnlike bitcoin, nothing I say in this comment can change the ownership of a safety deposit box. A few more things: 1. Ownership of the deposit box is not define by pin holders 2. Deposit boxes are tangible 3. Deposit boxes and contents have intrinsic value 3. Forgetting a pin doesn't effectively destroy the box and contents 4. The security of a deposit box is not defined by only math I'm not trying to be pedantic, I'm just saying it is more complicated than that.
- brighton36 11y agoI'm pretty sure the value of Bitcoin is circumventing regulations. Similarly, I'm guessing the Bitcoin community doesn't care very much about whether a government agency classifies it as a currency, a commodity, or a potato. Note that most of the quoted people rarely if ever engage in commerce with Bitcoin - so I'm not sure why their opinion on regulation is terribly relevant.
- harigov 11y agoI guess the people noted in the article are the ones who are either influencing those who engage in commerce with bitcoin, or those who are building tools and platforms to enable such commerce to take place. Either way, I am not sure bitcoins value is derived only from the lack of regulations. Sooner or later all the regulations applicable to existing financial instruments will be applicable to bitcoin as well. I think the value stems from the universality of the currency and the inherent trust enforced enforced through encryption.
- facepalm 11y agoThe issue is in the way it is being taxed. For example in Germany, theoretically you have to collect VAT if you trade Bitcoin (at least if you do it professionally). I didn't know that before, but apparently only gold is exempt from that (and currencies). If you trade silver or some other stuff, you are liable for VAT. So it would be nice if Bitcoin would also be exempt from VAT, like gold or currencies.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe only tax in Bitcoin is the voluntary mining fee. If governments want to collect tax on Bitcoin transactions, they will need to run a mining farm.
- cwyers 11y agoTry telling the IRS that during an audit and see how long it takes for you to be in prison.
- calgoo 11y ago"It’s an OK commodity but it’s the equivalent of selling real estate on the moon. There’s no inherent value. I applaud the ability of speculators to make money from selling it to other people, but I don’t think even calling it a commodity is enough. It’s a kind of shadow asset." I love when people who are in finances say that bitcoin has no vale; when actual money today is so complex in determining its value that you could basically say its a virtual coin as well.
- rwmj 11y agoIt's also obviously not true with even the tiniest amount of research. If you want to buy something online anonymously, then you use Bitcoin. There's the value.
- amalcon 11y agoThe problem with this is that Bitcoin is just about the least anonymous thing ever. It only seems anonymous because nobody's built the infrastructure to track it yet.
- adrianmacneil 11y agoThis statement is a bit hyperbolic. Bitcoin isn't as anonymous as say cash, but it's a lot more anonymous than most online payment methods (excluding a few altcoins which can really just be seen as innovations in the bitcoin/blockchain space).
- brighton36 11y agoBitcoin will evolve to be exactly as fungible as is required to maintain its efficiency. As the cats build tracking tools, the mice will continue to expand on bitcoin's fungibility.
- m0v_eax 11y agoTumblers..
- wpietri 11y ago
- LAMike 11y agoThe way I view Bitcoin and money is like the OS wars of the past few decades. Up until this point the big OS's (Microsoft == USD, Apple == Yuan) have been copyrighted by the government. They control the updates, what is allowed on their platform, and the way developers make apps for that platform. Bitcoin is the Linux of the money system. An Open Source OS for money, where developers can build apps without asking permission, and the community actually has a say in the progress of the OS, whether that's a good or bad thing we'll find out.
- JesperRavn 11y agoThe economics professor stated As money, Bitcoin is terrible – a deeply deflationary currency that’s within a bubble. I'd like to expand on this a bit. The deflation issue is complex. It's hard to imagine a stable situation where money has a fixed supply. The simplest steady state one can imagine is constant economic growth r, which is also the real interest rate. If we further assume a constant velocity of money (so the total value of all money is a fixed percentage of GDP), then any currency where the total supply of currency was fixed, would have a deflation rate equal to the real interest rate. Therefore holding currency or zero interest bonds would be equivalent. But money has some transaction value that makes it more valuable than zero interest bonds, so this situation could not be an equilibrium. Most economists think that in practice there is no way to have a stable currency except by forcing inflation by printing money (which in the current implementation is injected into the economy by buying bonds). I don't think it is possible to create an inflationary currency except through central banks. So I really think that bitcoin faces long term problems.
- 1ris 11y agoI think the assumtion that within the next one or two centures the world wide economy comes to stand still and to not grow at all is nothing odd. If you extrapolate the current (last centureis ) energy usage, within that timeframe we are boiling this planet if we go on.
- vidarh 11y ago> I don't think it is possible to create an inflationary currency except through central banks. How so? A number of alt.coins has built in inflation, either through continuous mining, or via staking (such as ReddCoin) or a mix. There may certainly still be plenty of issues, such as lack of ability to adjust the rates without widespread consensus that might make it hard to respond to various situations, but making the currencies inflationary doesn't seem to be a problem.
- dllthomas 11y ago"I don't think it is possible to create an inflationary currency except through central banks." I don't see why that would be the case. Would not "Bitcoin, but the mining rewards don't decrease" be an inflationary currency?
- 1ris 11y ago>That means the regulator can now bring charges against any wrongdoers trading cryptocurrency futures and options. I didn't know there are options for Bitcoins. Does anybody know more about this?
- icebraining 11y agoThe reason we are discussing this aspect of Bitcoin is because the regulator of derivatives and futures (CFTC) recently ruled against a company (Coinflip, aka Derivabit) which was an exchange for those kinds of financial instruments for BTC. They made a Show HN some time ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7461343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7461343
- wired_devil 11y agoIt's a distibuted computer program. Now they want to charge it? Why? Because money.
- Animats 11y agoFrom the title, it looked like this was going to be about the block size controversy, where there is serious disagreement about what happens next. The article is more like "can anybody find a use case for this thing?" Bitcoin has had two runups driven by use cases - Silk Road I (drugs), and getting around China's exchange controls. Both were shut down. For most of 2015, Bitcoin has been around $225 ± 25. There were brief bubbles outside that range, and one big drop, but it came back to that trading range. So it's not interesting to speculators any more. Until someone finds a new use case, it's not likely to do much. There's been progress. Mark Karpeles, who ran Mt. Gox and apparently stole its funds, is in jail in Japan.
- adrianmacneil 11y agoActually, bitcoin is still being used to get around China's exchange controls. That is why there is so much investment in mining in China - mining equipment is treated as capital investment, and it's trivial to then sell the proceeds for USD. I would also guess that there are far more people using bitcoin on dark net marketplaces now than there ever were using Silk Road (mostly due to all the publicity), but I don't have any sources to back this up. I do agree that we are unlikely to see any significant changes in the price of bitcoin in the medium term though. In the long run, the price of bitcoin is mostly irrelevant when bitcoin is being used as a payment network anyway.
- Animats 11y ago"I would also guess that there are far more people using bitcoin on dark net marketplaces now than there ever were using Silk Road (mostly due to all the publicity), but I don't have any sources to back this up." Bitcoin transaction volume in dollars hasn't increased in 18 months. See this graph.[1] The two big spikes were in November 2013 and March 2014. Since then, not much. Bitcoin usage is not increasing. [1] https://blockchain.info/charts/estimated-transaction-volume-usd?timespan=2year&showDataPoints=false&daysAverageString=1&show_header=true&scale=0&address= https://blockchain.info/charts/estimated-transaction-volume-...
- adrianmacneil 11y agoThese recent articles make it sound like there has been a recent revelation by the "U.S. Government" that bitcoin has actually been a commodity all along. The reality is much more complicated. The federal government is made up of many different agencies, and each one is trying to figure out whether they should be regulating it, in case they may take the fall for not preventing the next big Mt. Gox style collapse or scam. While CFTC have recently decided that they should regulate bitcoin options as a commodity, the IRS have deemed bitcoin as property for capital gains tax purposes, but their FinCEN division (along with NYDFS and most other states) are regulating it very much as a currency under money transmission laws. In the end this doesn't really matter. The power of bitcoin is that it is decentralized, and, like the internet itself, if an individual is able to connect to the network, then they are able to make transactions with others, regardless of how liberal or oppressive their government is. TL;DR: Regulations will continue to make it increasingly difficult to run bitcoin businesses in the U.S., but that doesn't matter. Bitcoin's power will always come from the fact that it is a completely open network for individuals.