9 ms·
Apple, Google, and Microsoft are all solving the same problems
- Someone 11y ago1978: Apple, Atari, Commodore, and Tandy are all solving the same problems. Competition is what drives technology forward. The only thing that may have changed is that hardware developments now spread faster to other companies because a lot of it is outsourced. Software knowledge still spreads through diffusion through the movement of employees between companies, but also is sped up a bit because lots of scientific ideas are distributed through the Internet.
- coldcode 11y agoScience often solves the same problems over and over; each time you learn something new and knowledge moves forward. If everyone is an exclusive silo, no progress will ever happen.
- digi_owl 11y agoThe difference from then and now is patents. Gates himself admitted that if the current patent system had been in place back when MS got started, it would never have gotten off the ground.
- ambicapter 11y agoWhat has changed since then?
- digi_owl 11y agoBasically that software can be patented. Back during the 70s-80s, a specific set of code was covered by copyright. But the behavior encoded could be reverse engineered. A famous example is how Compaq clean room reverse engineered the BIOS of the IBM PC, thus opening up the market for the clones. In constrast there are all kinds of issues with using FAT (FAT32/ExFAT) variants on Android phones because MS have/had patents. And i think Android early on didn't offer things like pinch to zoom because Apple held a patent (not sure what happened there).
- lordnacho 11y agoI asked a patent lawyer in Switzerland about this, and the law is different to the US. Does that create any openings?
- digi_owl 11y agoIANAL, but i suspect it will depend on how much you want to trade with USA...
- realityking 11y agoNot if you want to sell your product in the US...
- cenal 11y agoUS Patent Office rejected the Apple Patent on Pinch to Zoom: http://www.pcworld.com/article/2045461/us-patent-office-rejects-claims-of-apple-pinch-to-zoom-patent.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2045461/us-patent-office-reje...
- digi_owl 11y agoFrom as late as 2013. It still produced a whole bunch of FUD back when Android 1.x devices were shipping. And a whole bunch of "see how inferior the Android offering is" articles...
- mojuba 11y ago> All these machinations and adjustments are precisely what Michael Dell sought to escape when he took his business private two years ago. Got me thinking, what keeps companies like Apple and Google from doing the same? What are the benefits of staying public for them? What would be the consequence of going private? I'm just very curious now.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coob 11y agoApple are buying back stock at quite a rate.
- iraphael 11y agoHow feasible/quick is it to completely buy your own company off again? I ask because the idea is funny in my head: Something that is valued at price x and has the capital (aka x moneys and then some) to pay for itself.
- dcwca 11y agoI think the implication with these huge companies is that erosion of shareholder trust is the same as the erosion of consumer trust.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 11y agoIf they remain as successful as they are now, going private will never be an option because doing so would cause complete erosion of trust by shareholders, customers, public, and world. They will become opaque entities, and it will become very difficult for them to operate globally. Putting that problem aside, at their current valuation, a group of investors will need to raise a huge amount of capital for relatively small return. Dell took it private because the market effectively wrote off Dell and it wasn't trading much more above the book value. So raising capital to cover the amount was not difficult because the company was still reasonably profitable with good cash flow.
- mcphage 11y agoTechnology doesn't exist to serve some engineer's intellectual masturbation. Technology exists to serve the needs of people. So yes, try things, experiment, create—but if it doesn't result in a useful product, don't sell it to people like it is. Technology isn't just about making things, it's about how people use the things it makes. And iterated improvement is just as important to technological advancement as big bang creations. Otherwise, we're left with a whole bunch of things that don't work all that well. And finally—technology has gone through a lot of changes in the last 10 years. Smartphones went from something almost nobody had, to something almost everyone has, and slowing down the changes a bit to let people adjust to the changes will help.
- ilaksh 11y agoTechnopolies on the road to techno-communism. We need to decentralize our systems.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoCommunism is supposed to be decentralized and democratic. I assume you mean the Soviet conception of communism was a traditional top-down rule from above. (It wasn't communism)
- happyscrappy 11y agoAre there any examples of democratic communism?
- Rexxar 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibbutz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibbutz I don't know if this count as "communist" but they are two type of collective egalitarian democratic organisations that have got some success.
- fixermark 11y agoHow do they scale? Workable solutions need to allow seven billion people to inter-operate.
- xorcist 11y agoNo known system scales to seven billion people. (Just try to calculate what it would mean for every family in the world to buy a car.) Why would you think that a political or economical system needs to be globally scalable to be useful? Or that it would even be desirable? It would be reasonable to believe that a family, a business or a city should not be governed in the same way a country or a planet is.
- bedhead 11y agoI'm supposed to believe that it was only at the exact moment that the public market put Dell's stock in the shitter that Michael Dell magically got religion regarding short-term earnings pressures or other related issues? Ha!! Give me a break, Dell was public for 25 years!!! Funny it never seemed to be an issue when his stock was doing well...
- mark_l_watson 11y agoVoice enabled UIs with some AI capability are the future, even if it is a little annoying hearing people talking to their phones or computers. It might seem like all three companies are duplicating effort and inventing the same things, but digital assistants that help us communicate easier, access great content easier, and get stuff done easier, are where human-computer interaction is headed.
- Fiahil 11y ago> Voice enabled UIs with some AI capability are the future I don't know if you are using voice enabled UIs, but from someone who's using public transportation to go to work in the morning, that's not "a little annoying", that's a big no-no. Talking to your watch spooks people around you like crazy, and having to repeat 2 or 3 times (because noise, eh) your command is just uncomfortable. Worst case ever is sending texts with that (as everybody is actively listening to what you are saying). Sure, these technologies make great marketing material, but apart from the glowing on-stage demos, the actual use case of voice control immediately dies when there's either other people or loud (and fully quiet) environments.
- jon-wood 11y agoSure, you might not want to dictate a text message on the train, but at home its a different kettle of fish. I find voice activation particularly useful in the kitchen - I regularly use it for things like setting a timer or converting units from recipes.
- mojuba 11y agoExactly, and I think mentally controlled UIs will have a greater appeal in some (distant) future for the same reasons. One interesting aspect of voice vs. tactile that remains overlooked is the amount of energy required for performing something with your phone. It is not at all obvious that voice is less energy consuming for us and thus more convenient. Never heard of any research that would prove it.
- something123 11y agopublic transport? What kind of peasant are you? This technology is designed for our self driving Tesla future
- petra 11y agoNot a serious article. Google is investing billions yearly in r&d for far reaching, very risky innovations. As for Microsoft and Apple ,we really don't know. Could we have predicted the iPhone in 2005 ? Do we know what kind of car Apple is working on ? Do we know about Microsoft "special projects" group which recruited someone from Darpa ? And than finally when we do know about innovative efforts , the author dismisses them out of hand: "Google’s Project Ara modular phone and Microsoft’s HoloLens AR headset, by contrast, are the tech equivalent of concept cars: supremely ambitious today, but years away from hitting the market in what will likely be a tamer, less revolutionary form."
- greggman 11y ago> Could we have predicted the iPhone in 2005 ? depends on what you mean by predict. It was pretty obvious that phone/data would be added to PDAs soon. It might not have been obvious that Apple would do it so well and take PDAs from a geek/niche thing to the mainstream.
- petra 11y agoYes ,i meant the iPhone as something Apple built.
- orkoden 11y agoAt that time the iPod was hugely successful. Phones got more and more features very quickly: web/wap browsers, e-mail, cameras, installable games. The Motorola ROKR was the first try at combining an iPod with a phone. It failed. Back then everybody was expecting an iPodPhone in the near future.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TomDavey 11y ago> It was pretty obvious that phone/data would be > added to PDAs soon. Indeed. I had a Handspring Visor with the cellular add-on in 2000. And then there were the Palm Treos, awesome PDAs plus phones with a thriving app ecosystem. What Apple did was add a touch rather than a stylus interface. And the rest is history.
- mpg33 11y agoStartups solve new problems. Large companies refine and scale the most popular of those solutions.
- caseysoftware 11y agoI'd like to note that these are the problem they're talking about and promoting. Who knows what they have behind the scenes that no one is covering for fear of being sued. Prior to the unveiling of the iPhone - January 2007, iirc - there were some rumors of a phone but mostly conjecture. It blindsided almost everyone. And when it launched, it redefined phone design. Pay attention to the PR and "leaks" all you want, but remember that their entire job is to talk about and promote the things they want you to know about..
- FireBeyond 11y ago"it redefined phone design". A shame that the LG Prada was released a month earlier - no lawsuit ever materialized, but for a while there was back and forth threatening about Apple's "inspiration".
- api 11y agoThe problem is not just that they're all solving the same problems, but that they are mostly solving them in the same way: put everything in the cloud, 'feudalize' the device, make everything free and then monetize the user, solve security and OS-rot problems by closing the ecosystem and enforcing conformity instead of by fixing the underlying problems with the platform that give rise to this entropy and insecurity. Read Zero to One, on competition and its downsides and the way you begin to 'clone' your competitors and nobody does anything interesting.
- ksk 11y agoWell there is overlap but then again, there is overlap in the functionality of a car and a truck too. I see Google as primarily solving the "problem" that they still don't have enough data on their users. I wish they didn't have to solve this problem. As an aside, theverge has become super annoying to read with their over the top advertising. Did they start doing this recently? http://i.imgur.com/YFY05gY.jpg http://i.imgur.com/YFY05gY.jpg