6 ms·
The Moral Argument for Doping in Sports
- LoSboccacc 11y agoMy problem with doping isn't moral. Is that in pursuit of sponsors people will literally kill their athletes, with or without their knowledge.
- mikeash 11y agoExactly. It's like safety regulations in car racing. Racers get put into a hard position where they have to choose between safety and winning, because safety equipment costs weight and money that could be used to go faster. Regulations eliminate that choice and allow people to compete while maintaining some baseline level of safety.
- karmakaze 11y agoI was just thinking F1. Think of doping as part of the man-machine system and regulations to limit all aspects of it. From developments at top levels of competition we can get trickle-down chem-tech that is of benefit for all.
- humbleMouse 11y agoWe could just start new sports leagues that allow doping. It would be interesting to watch the NFL if people were bigger and angrier than they already are.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 11y ago> We could just start new sports leagues that allow doping. The experience of powerlifting federations is that cheating will continue to happen in the tested versions of a sport. The cachet for winning "naturally" is higher.
- johnward 11y agoAre you suggesting that most professional leagues don't allow doping? The NFL is full of drugs they just sweep it under the rug until the public notices. Kind of like Professional Bodybuilding. Everyone knows they are on drugs but we just kind of ignore it. It seems like even the DEA ignores it until you make it so obvious they have to respond. I always finding it shocking when people think pro athletes don't do as much as they can get away with to be competitive.
- cromulent 11y agoI agree that it is similar to security theatre. The federations want to give the impression that they are clean without the pain of declaring their star athletes dirty. No-one has an interest in a failed test. They do have an interest in appearing to be clean.
- MaxScheiber 11y agoI don't necessarily have a problem with professional athletes doping in a black box, i.e. free of influencing others. Professionals should be fully aware of the health effects of "riding the bicycle," and it's hard for me to argue against telling people what they can do to their own bodies. I always thought, however, that the big issue with steroids was the role that athletes play in the lives of children and teenagers. It's really not okay for high school athletes to use steroids. I was under the impression that professional athletes using steroids influences budding athletes to use steroids both directly ("I can get to where Barry Bonds is by using steroids") and indirectly (feeling pressured to use PEDs in order to compete). I seem to remember this being a controversial topic in the news 10-15 years ago. Steroid use in professional bodybuilding isn't as big of a deal as steroid use in professional sports. While part of that is attributable to the goals of those respective fields, another part is attributable to bodybuilders not being widespread role models in the way that baseball or basketball players are.
- jsalit 11y agoThere's no such thing as doping without influencing others; the indirect influences alone affect the economics of the sport.
- nostrebored 11y agoExactly, you shift the goalpost for attainable performance and the minimal performance necessary to be professional. A good example of this is e-sports, where it's well known, especially among FPS players that people competing are using stimulants -- and this has been the status quo for more than a decade. Which might be neutral, if things like steroids/stimulants weren't so terrible for you, but they have noticable consequences for your health.
- Floegipoky 11y agoI don't buy the 'think of the children!' argument for a second. If a person wants to use, they're going to use, regardless of what drug or their age. What really causes problems is all the lies, misinformation, and unrealistic expectations about what they can achieve with or without drugs. People think that the drugs are magic and will close the gaps in their training. It really is all about training- as the article says, the drugs are used because the human body isn't able to recover quickly enough from the volume of training required of professional athletes; in most sports it has nothing to do with adding more muscle. In fact most athletes don't want to add muscle willy-nilly because it makes it harder to move. If professional athletes were able to honestly discuss the drugs that they use and their dosages I think it would make things safer for young athletes, because most people don't understand how low the dosages that they take are and it would PROVE that you can't replace hard training with drugs. There are young athletes now taking dosages that far exceed what even world class athletes would consider because there's no honest discussion around them, they can't make informed decisions. Tl;dr: Hiding information never makes people safer. If Barry Bonds published his training program and drug stack, nobody would ever be stupid enough to think that "I can get to where Barry Bonds is by using steroids"; instead it would prove that the only way to compete with Barry Bonds is to train your ass off.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoWhy are musicians allowed (and maybe expected) to use performance enhancing drugs, while athletes may not?
- jacques_chester 11y agoMusic isn't, in general, a head-to-head contest between individuals or teams with an objectively determinable way of keeping score.
- sageikosa 11y agoMoney: it keeps score so you don't have to.
- dynomight 11y agoWhy are fans of athletes allowed to drink and beer companies allowed to advertise with obvious sports oriented themes in their ads?
- function_seven 11y agoBecause music isn't a competition. It's a creative endeavor.
- kasey_junk 11y agoWhen musicians compete for positions in symphonies it is a competition.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoIt's not as if sports don't demand creativity.
- johnward 11y agoLife is a competition. There is definitely competition in music. People battle for spots in orchestras. People battle for commercial dollars, etc.
- 11y ago
- jacques_chester 11y agoI am not aware of any system of morality in which "but everyone else did it" is considered to be a watertight argument. I feel strongly about matter, having competed in weightlifting, because of the recent influx of steroid apologists into the weightlifting community. The question of whether PEDs should be allowed is distinct from whether they are allowed. A sport is an arbitrary collection of objectively determinable athletic trials. It doesn't really matter how they start. Two people want to see who is the "best" at something, so they compete. Eventually there is an argument about who won. Alex thinks Bob has cheated, because Bob used a technique or technology that Alex thinks grants an unfair advantage. So Alex and Bob agree to rules. These rules create the space of permissible actions in which the arbitrary trials take place. For example, for sprinting, the rules create a space in which driving a sports car is excluded. Eventually a name is attached. What is the sport? The sport is the rules. It follows that actions taken outside the rules, even if unobserved, are not part of that sport. Consider the sprinting example: if the stadium lights go out and I drive to the finish line in 5 seconds, did I win, given that nobody detected my action? No: I did not win. I was incorrectly observed to be first, but I did not win. If you argue that it's based on the observation, it still requires rules against which the observation is applied. If instead you argue that there are no rules, then you do not have a defined athletic trial -- you can sprint, I can throw, and both of us claim to be the best pistol shooter at the end of the contest. That is, sports is a positivist legal framework. There is no "real" sport outside of the rules. The rules are the sport. If you break them, even unobserved, then by definition you cannot win and have not won, even when you appeared to. The nature of modern professional sports being what it is, this means that most winners are the 20-something-th placegetter. But there's a reason we have separate words for "truth", "honour" and "glory".
- moron4hire 11y agoThis is how I've felt for a long time, but I think how a lot of PED apologists argue is that they believe they have a right to interpret the rules as they see fit, to find corner cases that the established rules do not cover and exploit them to their advantage. They are letter-of-lawyers versus spirit-of-lawyers. Is "Moneyball" cheating? Is playing for overall points rather than wins cheating (for series competitions, like racing)? So when it comes to the drug issue, if the rules say "no testosterone levels over a certain degree" rather than "no drugs", then the apologist would say using drugs is within the rules, if it doesn't raise testosterone levels above that predetermined degree. I don't agree, but it's difficult to say where one draws the line between poorly written rules and cheating.
- jraines 11y agoSo in fact, it [clean sport] is profoundly just what the Nazis would’ve admired—the strongest, the fittest, the most beautiful. self-Godwinning sophistry
- asimilator 11y agoYeah, this is where I stopped reading. It's such a juvenile way to argue.
- brayton 11y agoThe main issue I see is how do we allow adults to dope while keeping children/teens away from it? Or would doping even increase with children/teens if it were more widely acceptable amongst adults? When I was in high school there were plenty of athletes using steroids - so already happening. Although I do believe that number would increase especially within high schools.
- johnward 11y ago"Think of the children" is always the worst argument possible. This is about education as with all drugs and not that stupid "roid rage" video they made me watch with Ben Affleck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FvlIwuQBO8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FvlIwuQBO8 There was an assumption that legal weed in Colorado would lead to more children using but data suggest the opposite happened. http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2014/08/07/pot-use-among-colorado-teens-appears-to-drop-after-legalization http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2014/08/07/pot-use-among...
- moron4hire 11y agoIt's a bad argument, but I wouldn't say it's the worst. "Hitler thought of it first" is worse, but still probably not "the worst". "I am rubber, you are glue" is a good contender. "Such-and-such argument is the worst" is probably pretty high in the running, too.
- kmnc 11y agoYeah, but honestly if doping was allowed in pro sports its a much strong assumption that college and high school kids would dope more then if kids would smoke more legal weed. You cannot escape the reality that if doping is allowed then doping is required.
- johnward 11y ago> but honestly if doping was allowed in pro sports its a much strong assumption that college and high school kids would dope more then if kids would smoke more legal weed. No it's not.
- ClintEhrlich 11y agoMy perspective on performance-enhancing drugs has changed because of my involvement in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and mixed martial arts. When I was a teenager, I started training at a gym where several UFC fighters spoke openly with me about their use of steroids. And in the decade since then, I have experienced the pains of rigorous training and competition without PEDs, while also interacting with lots of grapplers who discussed how PEDs helped them. None of them believed that the competitive advantage from steroids comes from the additional muscular strength they provide during a fight or a jiu-jitsu match. Instead, the steroids allowed them to train with a frequency and intensity that is virtually impossible for natural competitors. This recuperative advantage is still "cheating," but it feels morally different in the sense that the athlete is enhancing his technique by training more, not using steroid-enabled strength to compensate for poor technique. (The same is not true of something like blood doping.) I'm not arguing that PEDs should necessarily be permitted in athletic competition. That would be my preference, but I recognize there are colorable reasons why we should avoid glamorizing the practice in the eyes of teens. However, as a sportsman, I respect a competitor who is willing to risk his health in exchange for the chance to train as hard as humanly possible.
- lazyant 11y agoAs "Faster, Higher, Stronger..." author explains, doping wouldn't level the field for everybody since drugs affect people very differently. The concept of "fairness" is arbitrary, he mentions the use of altitude tents for example (banned only in one country, it favours richer countries), but somewhere we need to draw the line.
- johnward 11y agoThere is no level playing field in genetics either. The idea that banning drugs creates a level playing field is also flawed.
- VOYD 11y agothe moral argument for cheating?
- MichaelGG 11y agoThe bigger fallout from doping and WADA is the "drugs are bad" story it pushes. This leads to things like "anti doping" in e-games. Or calling students using mind-enhancing drugs cheaters. We should wholeheartedly embrace people using medical technology to improve themselves, rather than being slaves to genetics and limited by the money they have for exotic training methods.
- kazinator 11y agoIt's a simple information problem: identify who the dopers are and put them into their own events, with separate record keeping. We can have a world record for a 100 meter doped sprint, and one for the undoped sprints. Already there are men's and women's separate records. In some sports there are additional categories, like weight range. Also age groups. Doping itself then isn't cheating, but rather competing, while doped, in an undoped category. Analogous as a man pretending to be a woman.
- basseq 11y agoJulian Savulescu has two arguments here: 1. Cheaters are going to cheat, and you can't catch everyone, so just allow cheating. ("So what the current system does is enable that, because it places constraints that are impossible to enforce.") This is a bullshit argument. If something's not completely enforceable (which nothing is), then just forget it. Some people don't pay taxes: dissolve the IRS. Some people commit murder: murder should be legal. You have to draw the line somewhere. People will push or cross the line, you will catch some, and life goes on. 2. Doping in sports should be a test case for human enhancement. This is a more reasonable argument. I'm not sure it's right, but reasonable people can discuss whether the intent of sport is "measuring personal accomplishment" and "test-bed for medical intervention". Note that a parallel argument is happening in Formula One: should teams be given more leeway to build cars so innovation occurs as a result of competition.