10 ms·
Chromebooks Gaining on iPads in School Sector
- abluecloud 11y agoI guess they're realising that they're slightly more useful than iPads, and cheaper.
- joezydeco 11y agoIt's all about Google Docs. My kids' elementary school has gone completely gDocs for word processing and presentations (teacher and student areas). No more thumb drives for collaboration, and bringing work home is transparent.
- tracker1 11y agoI don't think it has to be one thing... I think that they are less expensive, and more usable are big things... having a separate keyboard for typing on is definitely a better use case for many over an on-screen keypad that takes up half the screen. gDocs is probably a big influence as well... as an all around value, I really like the Chromebooks... from a security standpoint, I tend to like them for mom & granda even more... (with uBlock)
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoThey're also easier to centrally manage and are completely user agnostic devices. iPads can be made to be use agnostic devices also, but you have to disable almost all of the built in apps (since iCloud doesn't really accomplish it), and have people sign into some online service each time (e.g. GApps, Office 365, etc). There's something to be said for a device where you can just grab a new one off of the laptop cart, install nothing, and login as any user with the full experience available. Windows domain-connected PCs kinda accomplish that, but with a lot more management overhead.
- jdeibele 11y agoI never tried FireFox Portable ... hmmm, looks like it requires a Windows machine (or a Linux box running Wine) That might have been interesting if Mozilla had been able to get it to run on Macs. We have a spare/guest Chromebook and it's been nice to hand it to one of my two daughters when they've cracked the screen. I'm not in IT but I'm just imagining how much easier Chromebooks would make my life. Especially if the management software is even halfway-good.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jdeibele 11y agoMy daughter lost a morning's work because she didn't save her composition in Microsoft Word (I think) on a MacBook. She's used to Google Docs automatically saving everything for her on her Chromebook. I'm sure that Microsoft Word can be set to automatically save but somebody probably has to do that. And the school might have disabled it because the kids are sharing the MacBooks and still using thumb drives.
- Flimm 11y agoMicrosoft Word automatically saves backup copies of files, and has done for at least a decade.
- jdeibele 11y agoYes, but it seems reasonable that it would be turned off for laptops that are swapped every class, whether Windows or Macs (in this case). If Bobby or Betty just lets it save, now you have to find the laptop the doc was automatically saved to. Or maybe it was saved to the machine instead of her thumb drive and the IT guy just told her she lost it. I try to do tech support for my kids and parents hands-on because details that don't matter to them do matter to the OS or apps.
- kozukumi 11y agoOnce Microsoft's new Edge browser matures I could see a free, locked down version of Windows 10 being some serious competition for Chromebooks and iPads.
- andybak 11y agoI was going to say "Wouldn't it be too resource heavy?" - meaning the whole Windows baggage as opposed to the leaner ChromeOS. But then I considered that the resource usage of Chrome (or Edge for that matter) itself might be the single biggest factor.
- mtgx 11y agoWindows RT was supposed to be the "lean locked down Windows" experience for mobile devices - and it sucked performance wise on "tablet hardware" (which is what most cheap Chromebooks have anyway, whether it's ARM or Atom...sorry, I mean "New Celerons™").
- dagw 11y agoThey've got a version of Windows 10 that runs reasonably well on the Raspberry PI 2 and I imagine most chromebook like devices have better specs that the RPi2.
- mkj 11y agoNot exactly, it's Windows IoT which doesn't really have a GUI. I agree with the original comment, MS might follow suit with Edge.
- dagw 11y agoSure, but Windows IoT should be plenty good enough for Microsoft to build a ChromeOS clone on top of it.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y ago
- wodenokoto 11y agoIt's amazing how different different communities can be. I have never seen a chromebook in the wild that wasn't gifted by Google. Guess I live more sheltered than I thought!
- marktangotango 11y agoI picked one up and de-chromed it, upgraded the m2 sata, and installed ubuntu. Makes a decent and cheap dev machine.
- hahainternet 11y ago> It's amazing how different different communities can be. I have never seen a chromebook in the wild that wasn't gifted by Google. Sure you have, it's just they're barely noticable. Little black laptops with a web-browser open. Not all of them have big chrome logos on them.
- adamc 11y agoMy family owns three. I'm the only holdout (not a good platform for development or gaming). They are light and handle web pages fairly well, which is all most users seem to require.
- arianvanp 11y agoSince February we use chromebooks for taking exams at Utrecht University. The tests are just kiosk apps and the chromebooks are easily managed using Googles administrator tools. Works like a charm. Was cheap too. The whole project cost less than 200,000 euros to set up. Chromebooks are dirt cheap so when one breaks we simply replace it. I think we've got like 400-500 of them and are planning to get more because students are pretty happy with them. http://pers.uu.nl/studenten-digitaal-tentamen-toetsvoorziening/ http://pers.uu.nl/studenten-digitaal-tentamen-toetsvoorzieni... (Disclosure: I'm one of the students who helped set up all the chromebooks)
- jdeibele 11y agoIn your experience, what makes a Chromebook break? My two daughters love their Chromebooks but they both cracked their screens. I suspect one was picked up by the lid, which you can do with a tablet but not a laptop. I ended up replacing them both for about $40-$45 from Amazon or eBay. Replacement screens were pretty easy to put in, though I got impatient and yanked on the cable. Then I had to order a replacement cable. But those are relatively easy to come by as people take the parts from seriously broken Chromebooks and put them on eBay. Buying the Acer C720 line means tons of parts readily available. Not sure about other models or manufacturers.
- arianvanp 11y agoSince february we only had one chromebook break of 400. Reason was unclear. It just wouldn't boot. We use the Acer Chromebook 13's. they actually seem pretty abuse-resistent so far. I couldn't really tell you what makes a chromebook break as we haven't had so many cases yet...
- blazespin 11y agoThe great thing about chromebooks is less forced obsolescence, so fewer hw upgrades required.
- yoz-y 11y agoIf the only thing you ever use is a web browser, then you could use a years old iPad just fine. For students, keyboard is probably the biggest factor and for schools it is the price.
- atmosx 11y agoTablets, generally speaking, are for consuming content. Laptops are better devices for creating content...
- digi_owl 11y agoIn the end it all boils down to inputs. Once you hitch a keyboard onto a tablet, there is no functional diffrerence between it, a laptop, or this new iteration of the netbook.
- yoz-y 11y agoNot really. The tablets also lack any kind of mouse support (well, at least iPads do). A lot of software is optimised for mouse+keyboard, ton of it is optimised for touch input, but there are not that many that support touch + keyboard.
- jdeibele 11y agoI'd have thought so but my daughters prefer their Chromebooks to their Nooks running CyanogenMod. Part of that is the Chromebooks don't have to be held: the screen can be adjusted to the proper angle without a stand. They're sprawled on the floor or huddled in a chair. Some of that is that Flash works on Chromebooks, not on tablets. Eventually Flash will be dead but there are still times that I end up closing a browser tab because I don't have Flash installed for Safari on my MacBook. Part of it is that Chromebooks are faster than tablets. I find pages are much snappier on a Chromebook than my iPad Air. A huge chunk of that may be due to uBlock Origin on the Chromebooks and ad-blocking and tracking not available on iOS. iOS9 might make quite a difference.
- simonh 11y agoPerhaps generally speaking, but there's huge overlap. I've written tens of thousands of words worth of documents on my iPad and thousands of lines of Python code (in Pythonista). I find it very convenient to use on the train. There are excellent art, animation and music apps for tablets. My kids have an iPad Mini each, but the eldest is starting secondary school soon so I expect we'll need to get her a laptop soon. I think they complement each other. For the best of both woods, use both for the things here best at. Yes I know not everyone can afford that, but that doesn't stop it being true.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 11y agoCromebooks are in essence netbooks 2.0. Only this time round you have Google backing them from top to bottom, rather than hardware OEMs getting "good deals" from Intel and MS in exchange for dropping the concept.
- adamc 11y agoYes and no. The original netbooks claimed some ability to run native apps, but did it poorly. Chromebooks don't claim to be more than Chrome, but do that well. A small part of this is Google Docs, but a bigger part is the general rise of webapps.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y ago> The original netbooks claimed some ability to run native apps, but did it poorly. Back during the peak of the Netbook, my main PC went down. While I waited for parts I hooked up an ASUS Eee PC with Windows XP. Not only was it able to drive a 21" monitor, but also Skype video chat, my browser, and full screen YouTube without any stuttering or issues. Netbooks got a bad rep' but frankly they were incredible value for money and even to this day have a somewhat unique form factor. Sure, you can buy ultrabooks, but they're a lot bigger and still heavier, plus they cost $800-1000+. So I guess my only point is, sure, Netbooks are limited. They cannot game realistically, and full screen HD video is about the height of their potential. But they still do a lot of stuff extremely well, could run Office flawlessly, as could they run browsers. Chromebooks have limited functionality, but not because it HAS to be that way, but because that is the product Google is selling. That's fine, but let's not pretend that Netbook's inferiority was the reason. And even if we pretend that it was, the hardware today kicks what Netbooks had in the butt.
- beastman82 11y agonetbooks + SSD.
- jostmey 11y agoThe problem with a tablet is that it makes for a terrible input device. Tablets are awesome for media consumption, though.
- smackfu 11y agoYeah, once the kids are old enough that the majority of work is writing, iPads aren't great.
- melling 11y agoCan't you simply add a Bluetooth keyboard? I think cost is the major factor.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoSure. But now you have a two part device, with more that can go wrong, and broadly speaking a worse typing experience. There's something to be said for the stereotypical laptop form factor.
- melling 11y agoThere sure is something to be said... They're horrible keyboards. We're going to give more kids RSI. http://looknohands.me/ http://looknohands.me/ http://24ways.org/2014/dont-push-through-the-pain/ http://24ways.org/2014/dont-push-through-the-pain/ http://markmcb.com/2014/10/13/severe-hand-rsi-pain-and-recovery/ http://markmcb.com/2014/10/13/severe-hand-rsi-pain-and-recov... We need more wireless ergonomic keyboards. https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/the-model-01-an-heirloom-grade-keyboard-for-serious-typists/ https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/the-model-01-an-heir...
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoStill more expensive, still a smaller screen, a smaller and less able keyboard, still no mouse selection (e.g. a quick select these letters, copy and paste, takes much longer on an ipad), and you're now dealing with multiple parts and multiple batteries. I don't really see the appeal over a Chromebook. iPads I'd love for e.g. reading books, watching course material videos (e.g. the Treehouse app for watching programming videos is wonderful until you get to the coding challenges) etc, but for doing work a keyboard makes the iPad a bit better but it doesn't come close to closing the gap to a Chromebook in my opinion.
- CmonDev 11y agoFrom oversize iPods to glorified browser notebooks.
- imauld 11y agoI have a full installation of Ubuntu running on my glorified browser notebook and it can be used as a normal laptop. It performance can be a little slow when working with very large data sets but on the other hand it was just about $300 including tax so it was an enormously good deal. I love it.
- CmonDev 11y agoNo Linux distributive is mentioned in that article. I have no doubt that a combination of RAM, SSD and CPU can achieve great things with right software.
- benkuykendall 11y agoYep! And believe it or not, you can do a ton in the browser. Aside from heavy duty programmers and creatives, most people can do everything they need to in the browser. Pretty exciting, isn't it?
- gress 11y agoYou can do everything you need with a Pentium 90 PC running Windows 95. That doesn't make it exciting.
- amelius 11y agoI'm just amazed that in 2015 we can run videos on every possible platform, same for viewing pdf documents, and even web-based applications. But when it comes to simple "natively-integrated" applications, there is a clear divide in platforms.
- abalos 11y agoWell, one thing to consider is that "natively-integrated" applications are slowly losing ground to cloud-based applications. Look at the apps for Chrome - they run on Chromebooks, Mac, Windows, and Linux.
- jhardcastle 11y agoOur school (K-12, east coast, I'm IT director) has purchased hundreds of both devices in the past 4 years. We started with 3:1 iPads in the first year, distributed evenly throughout the school. We very quickly realized that the iPad is not the right device for any student who ever needs to type anything, and the "enterprise" management from the MDM providers (who are handcuffed by the atrocious tools, including Apple Configurator, that Apple provides) is pretty awful compared to the outstanding and couldn't-be-easier management through the Chrome Management Console. So now we purchase iPads for prekindergarten through second grade, and Chromebooks for 3 and 4. Starting in grade 5, we have a mandatory BYOD and the Chromebook is our recommended device. In the middle school (5-8) the Chromebook takes 65% of the market share (versus Apple 30% and other <5%). In the upper school (9-12) it's more a 50/50 split Apple/Google. It's just so hard to discount the functionality of a real keyboard in any school where typing (and consequently writing) matters. Google Docs on an iPad is still awful, despite lots of improvements in the past few years. Still, if it were up to me, the lack of management tools for the Apple side (each device requires a LOT of manipulation by hand to install apps, update software, manage accounts, etc) would be the deciding factor and I'd never buy another iPad again. Edit: I just wanted to clarify that our "BYOD" program 5-12 is a laptop program. That's 65% Chromebooks and ~30% Mac laptops in grades 5-8, not iPads. We don't allow the iPad for the program requirements, though we permit their use as long as the student also has a full-sized laptop.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y ago> Starting in grade 5, we have a mandatory BYOD and the Chromebook is our recommended device. Is this a public school or private? In a public school I cannot imagine that that is legal since it is highly regressive. And before you say a Chromebook is "only" $150-200, that is 1/2 of someone's pay cheque and many are living pay cheque to pay cheque as is. Even school uniforms are seen as a hardship for the poor. Doing freaking computers is just mind boggling to me.
- cableshaft 11y agoBuying a TI graphing calculator was mandatory for my math class in 7th grade ~20 years ago, and those were around $120, or $200 if adjusted for inflation. That was at a public school, and that was only useful for a single subject, not every class in school.
- pinaceae 11y agoMicrosoft could have been close to this, but Google is really executing here. Make no mistake, this is not about the Hardware - this is training kids on an office suite. GDocs as a long game against MS Office 365. Kids get older, habits and skills stay. Brought up on Gmail, GDocs they will have issues with Word, Excel. MS better step up.
- greggyb 11y agoWhile I agree in terms of casual use, it is important to note that for a power user, nothing can hold a candle to Microsoft Office. I speak primarily from experience in Excel, but I am sure there are points to be made across the suite. Excel as a business analyst's tool is far beyond any competitors. Especially since 2010, with the Power Pivot add-on, you get a seamless promotion path from analyst's desktop to a fully integrated BI solution across the enterprise. I know I might sound a bit fanboyish above, and I'll acknowledge that I speak from my position as a BI consultant for a Microsoft partner. This being said, I'm also in a position where I have seen that transition where an analyst's local Power Pivot workbook becomes the basis for an enterprise reporting solution using SSAS and Power BI + SSRS many times.
- Mikeb85 11y ago> Excel as a business analyst's tool is far beyond any competitors. Honestly, Excel (or any spreadsheet really) is quite clunky for a lot of these tasks. In most of my University classes (economics/finance stream) that require me to analyse data and present it, I use R (w/ R Studio), and it's far superior - both for parsing the data, and for presenting it (and of course R is standard for any statistics course beyond the intro courses). R can even create 'pivot tables' and many other interactive HTML widgets. And while we still learn Excel, we were also forced to learn Python and SQL.
- greggyb 11y agoI don't disagree with anything you've said. The fact of the matter is that the majority of business analysts and 100%[0] of the consumers of their analysis are only comfortable with a spreadsheet. I'd say less than 50% of the business analysts we see can do more than write a join in SQL, 90% dump data straight to Excel for processing and presentation. The remaining 10% will use whatever BI tool their company has decided on. [0] Close enough not to matter. Note: the percentages above are based on my experience consulting with primarily non-tech-related clients and are based on my casual observations and those of my coworkers. Microsoft Excel has a stranglehold on the niche we're discussing, because it hits the sweet spot of functionality and usability for the people who are doing this work in most companies.
- jdeibele 11y agoThe one thing that drives me mad about the Chromebooks is Google Cloud Print. We don't use it very often and every time we do, it's broken. I don't know if it's something in our Brother printer or on the Chromebooks and I really, really, really don't care. I just want to be able to connect the Chromebook to the printer and print. AirPrint, on the same printer, works every time from my MacBook. But it doesn't require a "printer manager" to figure out what the printer's IP # is, point a browser to it, login, then use the admin interface to give permission to people via email and those people to click on the email. It's Linux underneath so I don't understand why that can't be used to talk to CUPS or LPD or something similar in the same way the file system is used.
- joshrotenberg 11y agoMy boys have been using Chromebooks for school work both at home and in school for a couple years now, and we've had the same issue here. I don't think they print stuff up at school often (if ever). The silver lining is that now they have to share their work with me or my wife, so we get a chance to look at it before they can turn it in. But yeah, being able to print correctly would be real nice.
- Adaptive 11y agoGoogle Cloud Print is definitely a weak link in my opinion. I've set up a full chromebook deployment for my daughter's school including rollout of GCP, and there are still occasional hiccups with printing (for example management of a stuck queue is obfuscated). However it has improved a lot and management (once you get your head around it) is really great. For example, you can easily provision printers to either groups or devices, so teachers can be provisioned on the user level while students are restricted to printing from provisioned devices.
- tigeba 11y agoI have two kids in elementary school, K and 2nd grade. The last few years the school district has been experimenting with Chromebook carts they would send to various classrooms once or twice a week. This year, they went with Chromebooks for all students K-12. The kids bring them home in the evening and are expected to bring them to school every day. The K's have touch screen Chromebooks to help mitigate their lack of typing skills. I'm really interested to see how they will be using them. They have already been using google docs and they have both been talking about email. Maybe they will finally come to appreciate the vanity domains I registered for them when they were born :)
- mark_l_watson 11y agoOff topic (educational computers) but I have mixed feelings about Chromebooks. It seems like you give up a lot of privacy (potentially) but they are very secure. The security is great for kids in school, but are advertising profiles now being created for people when they are in K-12? (I love my Toshiba Chromebook 2, so I hope I don't sound too critical of the platform.)
- danieldk 11y agoWouldn't they be using Google Apps for Education (I don't know)? If so, the terms of that say that data covered by Apps will not be mined for ads: Google Apps for Education services don't collect or use student data for advertising purposes or create ads profiles. https://support.google.com/a/answer/139019?hl=en https://support.google.com/a/answer/139019?hl=en
- mark_l_watson 11y agoThanks, that is good to know. I wondered if google would have special terms for school kids.
- teacup50 11y agoThey're still collecting the user data. And they're building a familiarity and user reliance on cloud "apps".
- pjmlp 11y agoSo while people are up in arms with Windows 10 and latest 7/8 updates, they are ok with giving children information to Google!?
- Mikeb85 11y agoAnd what info are they giving to Google? Their search history for school projects which is collected and sorted by an algorithm?
- strange_quark 11y ago> And what info are they giving to Google? Their search history for school projects which is collected and sorted by an algorithm? They give all the same usage information and probably more than Windows 10 sends to Microsoft. If you don't thing Google is collecting insane amounts of data from Chromebooks, you're incredibly naive.
- Mikeb85 11y agoAnd if you are signed into Google (from any browser) they collect your information. Or if you use Gmail. It's what they use for many of their services. I guess the question I'm asking is more philosophical - if you 'opt in' to the Google ecosystem, why is this a bad thing? Up to now, there's been no indication Google abuses your data (unless you consider algos to show you ads as 'abuse'), or that it ever leaves Google's servers, or is ever even human-readable...
- strange_quark 11y ago> if you 'opt in' to the Google ecosystem, why is this a bad thing? In the same way, you 'opt in' to the Microsoft ecosystem by using Windows. The problem is everyone seems to give Google a free pass because of free stuff. What's crazy to me is that whenever Google expands the amount of information they collect, they're praised for being so innovate. I mean, one of the "best" new features of the next version of Android literally walks the entire view hierarchy on your phone and sends it all too Google's servers, but god forbid Microsoft collects some usage information and crash reports.