5 ms·
The article alludes to the fact that you remove marginal disincentives to work by doing something like this. Many existing systems have some form of means test,
by lordnacho 11y ago
The article alludes to the fact that you remove marginal disincentives to work by doing something like this. Many existing systems have some form of means test, which in practice results in very high effective tax rates.
Once we decide we want to support people on low incomes, there's a question of how the best way to do that is. The Nordics especially have built up enormous bureaucracies that in themselves cost a lot to administer various handouts and benefits. It might make more sense just to cut a cheque to everyone.
- daemin 11y agoI see that it could help people start their own businesses since at the worst case you'll end up back on the minimum income. So that takes one element of stress out of it and you can focus on the business more. I can see some arguments against this that would say the owner would be less hungry for success, and while that's true not every business that starts needs to be the next big thing.
- troels 11y agoIn practise, this is more or less the case already in the nordics. The social safety net is so wide that even if you fail spectacularly at life, you won't hit rock bottom.
- lordnacho 11y agoExcept if you do badly at business, you have to lose everything before they help you. If you have anything that can be turned into money, or your spouse does, you have to use that first. Another facet of the Nordic system, and not great for entrepreneurs.
- jensen123 11y agoOf course, one problem with the current bureaucratic system in the Nordic countries, is that some people slip through. If for example you start a personal company, and later fail, you won't get unemployment benefits (unless your company was a corporation and you hired yourself, of course). At least, that is the case in Norway.
- Hytosys 11y agoDo you know why that has occurred?
- jensen123 11y agoI find your question a bit unclear, but I'll try to answer. Even in a best-case scenario where the politicians who are creating the laws/rules are well-intentioned and really are trying their best, I guess it's impossible to think of every single real world scenario. Thus, there will always be people who will fall through a complicated safety net. As for why entrepreneurs aren't always covered in Norway? I'm just speculating here, but anyway: Since WW2, Norwegian politics has been dominated by The Labor Party (Arbeiderpartiet). They usually look out for ordinary workers, which tend to have it pretty good in Norway. Others groups, such as entrepreneurs, drug (ab)users, farmers etc. aren't always treated so well.
- Hytosys 11y agoInteresting. I would hope that the safety net is at least something like 90% successful, but I haven't done my studying at all. Thanks for your insight into exactly who falls through the net.
- pmjordan 11y agoThat's the case in many European countries with sophisticated welfare systems. In Austria, we can pay extra (I think ~1.5% of income) as self-employed to get unemployment benefits but I don't know how popular that option is in practice. Personally (as a highly employable, fairly senior software developer, so I'm unlikely to be out of a job as long as I can work) what's worse than lack of unemployment benefit is dealing with times of sickness. I suffered from Lyme disease for about 2 1/2 years until it was diagnosed properly and treated, and in addition to the reduced income due to being unable to work at times, and the extra cost of healthcare (despite the insurance it's not exactly free) in Austria, they still expect you to pre-pay taxes and pension & health insurance contributions based on your earnings 1-2 years ago. In theory you can claim some money for a few weeks if you get sick, but (a) you have to completely shut down any business activity for that time and (b) you have to be declared unable to work by a doctor. (Unlikely, considering the doctors were all telling me there was nothing wrong with me and it was "stress"…) A basic income would at least help deal with the reduced income due to sickness & extra costs due to healthcare. The pre-payment aspect is probably peculiar to Austria and apparently frequently bankrupts profitable small businesses.
- scotty79 11y agoWhat could be great about basic income is that you can safely fire a lot of bureaucrats without harming them. Some of them might even welcome the change from being paid to do meaningless job to being paid for literally nothing.
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoPurpose, or keeping busy at a minimum, is a tentpole of avoiding depression... even if it were seemingly "busywork."
- Sammi 11y agoThat's the thing. Meaningless busywork is making people stressed and depressed. Basic Income on the other hand would free people to pursue whatever purpose they themselves desire. You can make up your own meaningful job, cause you're already getting paid.
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoThat's a sweeping generalization which presumes far too much. It depends on the person. Some people enjoy monotonous factory work because it removes the burden of thinking. Other people need a manager because they don't want to, or can't, plan the next logical thing. Others need constant variety or don't like being told what to do. The other issue is that getting paid for a "meaningful job" which doesn't turn a profit is not going to scale. Millions of people suddenly wouldn't work in fast food, farm fields, industrial tanneries or meat processing plants because they're really shitty/dangerous/disgusting jobs. (But I'm sure some scary/crazy people enjoy them.) And, when people have infinite choices and opportunities, the Paradox of Choice comes in to play and people become even more dissatisfied. See also: Zillions of wealthy housewives in perpetual existential boredom (depression) filling psychology & psychiatry offices.
- scotty79 11y agoI don't think that paradox of choice results in more suffering than not having the choice at all when it comes to having a job. With basic income you have a bit more choice when it comes to picking a job. You no longer have to restrict yourself to sufficiently paid ones.
- eru 11y agoThey have to systems to assess people's income: the tax people and the welfare people. Might as well reduce that to one system, the tax people.
- jules 11y agoDoes running the welfare system actually cost a lot? Last time somebody claimed that about US social security another person responded with data showing that it's less than 1% overhead.
- PavlovsCat 11y agohttp://thinkbynumbers.org/government-spending/corporate-welfare/corporate-welfare-statistics-vs-social-welfare-statistics/ http://thinkbynumbers.org/government-spending/corporate-welf... > The final totals are $59 billion, 3 percent of the total federal budget, for regular welfare and $92 billion, 5 percent of the total federal budget, for corporations. (from 2006)
- maxerickson 11y agoGp is talking about the costs of administrating the programs, your numbers are the total costs.
- adventured 11y agoEven though that's not the admin costs in question, those numbers are drastically far off from the actual welfare system costs. In 2012, the US Govt. spent $80 billion just on the SNAP (food stamps) program alone. A total of over $100 billion went to welfare food programs.
- jvm 11y agoMeans testing actually increases the disincentive to work. Working usually results in greater income which can diminish the benefits. This amounts to an effective higher marginal tax rate, when benefits are removed as you earn more. It's hard to imagine a system that disincentivizes working more than means tested welfare. A few examples from SNAP can be found here [1], CBO study showing up to 80% marginal tax rates on the poor here [2]. This is precisely the insight driving basic income: by removing means testing, we can avoid perverse disincentives to work: higher income always results in higher pay. [1] http://taxfoundation.org/blog/high-implicit-marginal-tax-rates-make-life-difficult-poor http://taxfoundation.org/blog/high-implicit-marginal-tax-rat... [2] https://www.cbo.gov/publication/44621 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/44621
- pluma 11y agoIn Germany we have a welfare system that requires you to take on pretty much any job if you become unemployed. If you only qualify for low-income jobs this can mean you end up taking on a job that pays you below welfare and welfare actually has to bridge the gap and pay you the difference. This not only means you're working for the same money you would have if you didn't work, it also means there's pretty much no way for you to improve your income unless you can change jobs to a significantly better paid one. Even a raise or bonus wouldn't change your bottom line as the welfare is adjusted 1-to-1 for every cent you make. This is IMO the greates disincentive of our welfare system. There's no advantage to finding an actual job when you're on welfare and don't qualify for jobs that pay significantly more than welfare. It's unsurprising that some game the system by intentionally failing job interviews and doing ludicrous amounts of trainings instead of finding and getting a (low-paying) job. I don't know whether a blank check is the right solution here, but a frequently mentioned alternative for the skeptical is basically a negative income tax: for every two cents you make on top of basic income, you pay one cent (or whatever fraction -- the actual percentage is irrelevant to the idea as long as it's below 100%). This avoids the financial "dead zone" created by the 1-to-1 adjustments of the current welfare system.
- clavalle 11y agoBut then you have the problem of businesses catering to 'gap people' and scraping profit from those subsidized positions.
- mpg33 11y ago> The Nordics especially have built up enormous bureaucracies that in themselves cost a lot to administer various handouts and benefits. It might make more sense just to cut a cheque to everyone. Not only that you could argue that it is also more efficient to have the spending decisions done by the individual and not the state.