11 ms·
(1) Those nasty things inside car batteries are easily recycled and in fact are recycled more often than not (like 95%+) (2) Car batteries do not last only 3-4
by sandworm101 11y ago
(1) Those nasty things inside car batteries are easily recycled and in fact are recycled more often than not (like 95%+)
(2) Car batteries do not last only 3-4 years as per the OP. Car batteries can last decades. There are many variables, but the car in my battery is far older than 4 years. (lol)
(3) Replacing an easily-recyclable product with a less-recyclable one is no step forwards.
(4) XX addressed by OP comment, see below XX
This thing is a capacitor? What's the voltage potential in there? Any device with internals significantly beyond that may be a serious fire risk in a crash..
(5) Car batteries are not needlessly heavy, nor are they a stock size. Manufacturers do care about performance. If they thought the car could do with lighter battery they would use one. Have some respect for the thought behind stock engineering before replacing it.
(6) Shutting down the voltage supply can be a real pain. A "dead" battery generally still has enough juice to keep electronics ticking over. Cutting it completely is not like turning off a switch. It often means resetting/rebooting stuff once the voltage is restored. For some (BMW) it can even mean a trip to the dealership for a special new battery ritual.
http://www.bimmerforums.com/forum/showthread.php?1355106-Why-can-t-I-replace-my-own-battery http://www.bimmerforums.com/forum/showthread.php?1355106-Why...
- morcheeba 11y agoI don't get your (4). It's a capacitor + lithium battery. It's got to be nominally 12 volts, or else it wouldn't work in a car. Capacitors only charge to the voltage you apply -- in this case, 12v. I'm not sure if you mean voltage by "beyond that", but fire risk isn't really correlated with voltage - more with chemistry, energy, and fusing. As for (5), they clearly care about cost.
- sandworm101 11y agoI was thinking about the internals. They might have components with higher potentials that are then regulated down to 12v. In a crash, those could be a source of high-voltage shorts that might be a source of ignition.
- conjecTech 11y agoNo worries there. Everything is right around the 12V level. We can boost the voltage on the capacitors some, but we never exceed anything that the alternator is spitting out.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoBut a car alternator's output is nominally 13.8V.
- Dylan16807 11y ago13.8V is around the 12V level and is not high voltage. What are you objecting to?
- Eiriksmal 11y agoWhile I agree with points 1 and 2, I have a beef with point 5. Car manufacturers do whatever they can to shave costs, all over the car, all the time. Batteries are needlessly heavy because they are manufactured with the cheapest-possible components using the cheapest-possible technologies. They do put in a best-guess size to keep the median consumer masses happy, whether they drive the car once a month in Death Valley or six times a day in Duluth. You can buy lighter-weight, lower-capacity batteries to use in competitions where weight matters, or higher-technology batteries for use in angles where lead-acid will give up the ghost. Batteries are frequently moved by tuners to places where their weight has less of an affect on the car's suspension.
- nradov 11y agoThat's not really true any more. Due to increasingly strict fuel economy rules, every car manufacturer now has cost models to trade off weight versus cost and reliability. So they will pay a little more for lighter parts.
- blueintegral 11y agoYou're right! Lead acid car batteries are one of the great recycling success stories. What's interesting is that the volume of lead acid car batteries in the world is so high, that even at that high recycling rate, that still leaves 24 million pounds of lead each year from car batteries that don't get recycled. There's also been some problems recently with lead recycling plants contaminating the environment [1]. You're also right that it's more complicated to recycle lead than lithium batteries, but a recycling process does exist, and it's getting better thanks to the proliferation of lithium batteries in electric cars. It's actually got 6 capacitors in series (2.7V each). We don't charge them all the way up to 2.7V, so it's normally at about 13V on the terminals. We are super paranoid about safety. The EDLC caps we picked aren't a fire risk, since it's just carbon and a few mL of electrolyte. You're probably thinking of what electrolytic caps do when you reverse bias them, but EDLC caps are much nicer. The worst they'll do is vent the electrolyte, not explode. LiFePO4 batteries are also really stable and are used in electric vehicles all the time. [1]: http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2015/07/08/lead-contamination-near-exide-plant-may-be-worse-than-previously-thought/ http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2015/07/08/lead-contamination...
- CamperBob2 11y agoSome thoughts: The price point is impressive if you can sell at only ~$50 more than a standard lead-acid battery. If pressed to find a flaw, I think the biggest is one you've already identified: There’s one: you can’t run your lights and/or stereo as long with your engine turned off. Ohm’s battery reserve comes in at 10 amp hours; most lead-acid car batteries come in at about 45 amp hours. If you can run your stereo with your engine off for three hours on your current battery, you’d be able to run it on Ohm for less than an hour. Nobody with a modern car or SUV is going to get three hours' runtime for their accessory equipment. With the original equipment (AGM lead acid, 70 AH/450 CCA) battery in my two-seat passenger car, I'm lucky to get 15 minutes' worth of stereo/nav/etc. operation with the ignition off. There's no conceivable way that 10 AH is enough for this application. The more "luxurious" the car, and the newer it is, the worse this problem will be. Meanwhile, LiFePO4 battery cost will probably go in the opposite direction, leaving room for competitors to offer more power for less money. So I'd reconsider the size of the LiFePO4 battery, even if it makes the product cost a bit more. You need those high-end buyers. You're not going to sell these to Joe Sixpack for installation in his '98 F-150 pickup. And yes, your marketing materials are grossly exaggerating both the environmental problems with lead-acid batteries and their typical service life. There is clearly a global regulatory jihad against lead in all of its forms and uses, though, so you do have that going for you. Edit: Don't forget that auto stop/start is growing in popularity as well. I think it's actually mandatory in some (European?) markets. OEMs are moving toward "smarter" (read: DRM-locked) batteries to handle these additional requirements. I wonder if a better business model might be to offer recycling/rebuilding services that swap out lead plates for LiFePO4/supercap hardware in existing batteries?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- benihana 11y agoIt's crazy how applicable the Presumption of Stupidity article that was posted a couple of days ago has been. Your comment is basically a re-hashing of that post. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10034883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10034883
- stephengillie 11y agoWe presume stupidity because that's the default state of a person. You have to load instructions and data into a neuroprocessor, just like any other computer system. Case-in-point: Woolfe. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10047721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10047721
- omarforgotpwd 11y agoYou've got a car in your battery? Damn
- stcredzero 11y agoWith regards to 5, my understanding is that car batteries are as big as they are because of the need to have over-capacity for reliability. Lead acid batteries are actually kind of fragile in the grand scheme of things. Charge controller smarts can trump over-capacity in the right context, however.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoYou're right about the life. Who here has replaced a car battery after 3 years? My '89 Miata had the OEM battery (an AGM lead-acid battery), 25 years later.
- nathanb 11y agoIndeed. I wonder if Ohm works the same way, in that if you have an optimal driving pattern it will last you for 20 years. I suspect based on the Li-ion batteries in laptops and how poorly they last that the Ohm will have a much more predictable failure curve.
- Rebelgecko 11y agoIf you live somewhere hot, it can be rare to get even 5 years out of a battery (although if you buy ones with a 3 year warranty you may only be paying for a battery every 5 years or so)
- WalterBright 11y agoA lead acid battery will last a long time if it is never deep-cycled (i.e. run down). Always keep it topped up with charge.
- Kluny 11y ago(7) This doesn't apply to all performance cars, but in track racing where you really need to save every possible ounce, it's common to take the battery out altogether after starting the car and run it off the alternator.
- conjecTech 11y agoCo-founder here. Do the cars you're talking about use a distributor? The battery of a car works as a low pass filter for the alternator, and removing it entirely can cause huge spikes in the voltage it puts out. That can be destructive to just about any electronics it would be running. I've personally seen an accidental battery disconnect blow an ECU.
- Kluny 11y agoGood to know, thanks, I wasn't aware of that. I'm guessing the guys that I know who do this have either accounted for that or don't care.
- userbinator 11y agoThe grandparent poster could be talking about magneto or traditional points-based ignitions, which are still common in certain classes of racing cars.
- birdmanjeremy 11y agoI've never seen anyone do this. We just run lightweight batteries and keep the car on a tender.
- atourgates 11y agoIf you look at this purely from the standpoint of the benefit to a consumer, it doesn't seem like a great deal. You gain: * Auto-shutoff when your battery gets too low. * Possibly some increased lifespan * ~34lbs in weight reduction, which might deliver a small performance increase. You lose: * 78% of your battery capacity * $20-$150 on the purchase price of the battery Personally, I don't like the idea of paying more money for less battery capacity. If, however, Ohm came with a rock-solid 7-year replacement warranty, I might be able to get over that.
- baudehlo 11y agoWhen I bought my Civic Type-R it didn't even have an option for air conditioning due to the weight it added. For some types of car every pound (though they are called grams in the real world) counts. I suspect this will be popular in the lightweight performance car world.
- atourgates 11y agoFor sure losing 30+lbs is a big deal in the high-performance automotive world, and Ohm's price premium is nothing compared to, say, replacing structural elements with carbon fiber etc. But I don't think your average mass-market consumer is going to care much about 30lbs, or notice a difference in performance or handling if they did.
- baudehlo 11y agoI'm not sure why my comment got so downvoted, that's kind of weird as I was just stating facts. Absolutely the average buyer of a Camry is not going to care about this. But that wasn't at all my point. Some cars (more often in Europe/Japan where driving is more fun because they have corners), take weight seriously. I think car manufacturers might take this option seriously in their sport divisions.
- yellowapple 11y ago> I'm not sure why my comment got so downvoted Probably because of the "in the real world they're called 'grams'" remark. I vastly prefer metric over Imperial, too, but that came across as a tad snobbish, eh? I upvoted, though, for what it's worth; weight savings aren't just the purview of racecars.
- blueintegral 11y agoOh, one other thing I wanted to add: The 3-4 year lifetime of lead acid batteries is the average lifetime. There are certainly outliers, but if you go to the store and buy a lead acid today, the warranty is about 3 years. The BMW thing is interesting. The reason they do that little "ritual" is because they want to program the ECU to use a particular charging profile for your battery, and it needs to know the age of the battery and the type (AGM or not). That's to try to extend the lifetime of the battery. We don't really need to worry about that, since we handle all the charging profiles internally. One of our testers drives a BMW, so we're making sure that we can handle that and similar cases.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- balls187 11y ago> (2) Car batteries do not last only 3-4 years as per the OP. Car batteries can last decades. There are many variables, but the car in my battery is far older than 4 years. (lol) I have a 2003 VW GTi. Had the battery replaced for the first time late last year. The AAA Tech was surprised that I had over 10 years of use with the stock battery. Still, this product does seem interesting.
- WalterBright 11y ago> For some (BMW) it can even mean a trip to the dealership for a special new battery ritual. Really? That would kill any interest I'd have in a BMW. Heck, whenever I work on my car, the first thing I do is disconnect the battery.
- zevyoura 11y agoFew owners of modern luxury cars do their own maintenance.
- WalterBright 11y agoI find working on my car to be very relaxing after sitting in front of a computer all day. There's also something viscerally satisfying about it. Of course, that's why I'm an engineer :-)
- miahi 11y agoWorking on a car also means sitting in front of a computer nowadays.
- MertsA 11y agoNot really, BMWs have a battery management system that needs to be cleared of the learned calibration when the battery is replaced. If it's just disconnected and not replaced then you don't want to clear it. Also, if that were true it would make doing any work a terrible experience even for the dealerships. Heck the service manual probably says to disconnect the negative battery cable before changing windshield wipers.