16 ms·
A Miserable Debt-Free Life
- smpetrey 11y ago> In Australia the government gives much of the population “middle class welfare”, a few $100/week which covers much of my food and bills. We also have free public health care. So the country you live in helps. What a wonderful country.
- MSM 11y agoI imagine that has to play a HUGE part in how he's able to stay out of work. If it's exactly "a few hundred a week" that still adds up to ~15,600 a year. I know the cost of living is pretty high over there but that's a really healthy chunk of change to be able to count on.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoI very much support that, but I don't think it should be part of his equation. I'm totally for supporting those who need it, but making an equation saying 'look I don't need to work as much, I can live off of interest from $400k in capital and government welfare and a bit of work' obviously makes no sense, even if you take out the capital. Welfare shouldn't be part of any equation of how to make a living because it's a priori meant to be an exception for those who can't make a living, unless the country is on basic income which no country is as of yet.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RodericDay 11y agoIt's kinda cool that he mentions the kids throughout. So many greedy people feel attacked by this kind of thing, and react to the implicit allegation that they're being wasteful with condescension, muttering about the selfishness or oddness of not having kids, or then again about how much of a difference having to support a family makes and how unrealistic idealists are. As I heard it said once, Lawful evil: "I did it for my family".
- jessedhillon 11y ago> So many greedy people feel attacked... I think I found out why.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- VLM 11y agoCool, this is the FreeDV / Codec2 guy, did not know this side. Might find his commentary on Codec2 patent issues as interesting as his financial planning commentary.
- ksmithbaylor 11y ago> Until age 38 I was very focused on material accumulation. I had a Porsche 911 (called Helmut), several investment properties, a wife, and several pairs of trousers. Is anybody else disturbed by the inclusion of his wife in his list of material posessions?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- starfis 11y agoThat bothered me, too
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- helipad 11y agoDisturbed? Not really. Sounds like the author was pointing out his own flaws in terms of what he considered success at that point in his life.
- benihana 11y agoNo. He's realized the errors of his past ways and his thinking which included treating a human like a possession that is slightly more valuable than a few pairs of trousers. That's the joke. Sometimes jokes are hard because they reveal the dirty reality underlying them.
- ZeroFries 11y agoI think/hope he meant the extra material accumulation commonly associated with being married.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bshimmin 11y agoThe tone of the article is one of humorous self-deprecation, which is quite a common trait amongst Brits and Australians; to me, the inclusion of "a wife" in that sentence seems no more strange than his mention of "long pub lunches" as a highlight of his previous career in industry.
- jayess 11y ago10%/year investment return is virtually impossible these days.
- Artistry121 11y agoS&P 500 average return since the early 1900s has been 12%<. But... that includes volatility. Still it doesn't seem like an impossible number - the past 6 years have all met that growth target.
- msandford 11y agoThe last 6 years have been a bull market after a giant crash. What about the last 10 years?
- sz4kerto 11y agoS&P return since 2000 was 2.2% on average, 0.05% (!!) inflation-adjusted. Last decade was 5.3%, or 3.2% inflation adjusted.
- Artistry121 11y agoGood point - I took "these days" to mean the past few years.
- jcdavis 11y agoTotal return is ~4.3% nominal ~2% real annualized since Jan 2000, ~7.5% nominal ~5.4% real annualized since Jul 2005. Total return isn't a perfect measurement (particularly due to taxation of dividends), but its a much more useful number. Over a long term, dividend reinvestment makes a huge difference.
- mkozlows 11y ago"The S&P 500 index in its present form began on March 4, 1957" says Wikipedia. And its return since the 50s is 7% in real terms. And there were decades at a time (including the 2000-2010 period, where real return was -3.4%) that significantly underperformed that), so it's not even a reliable 7% a year, which you'd need for these calculations to work out.
- mkozlows 11y agoIt's cool that this guy is doing things that make him happy. But I'm extremely confident that he didn't do this by following the financial plan he blithely gives. Because a) good luck finding an investment that'll give you 10% consistently for decades, and b) even with that magic risk-free return, his plan takes 20 years (or 22 if you somehow don't have $10K stashed up as a youngster) and then c) leaves you on the edge of your expenses (as he defines them) and reliant on that consistent 10% return continuing forever. "Hey, if you find a magic investment, you can retire at 47 and then live in constant fear of penury!"
- Artistry121 11y agoI don't think you need a magic investment. Find a way to live on half of your after-tax income, save for ten to fifteen years the additional amount and put it in large, relatively safe dividend stocks (DJIA is a good place to look). Then you have retirement at the same level as pre-retirement with about a 4-5% withdrawal rate even if your investment returns only average about 5% per year through the accumulation and disbursement phase.
- eterm 11y ago"only" 5%? Even 5% would be incredible return to have if it were consistent and low risk.
- Artistry121 11y agoConsistent and low risk were not requirements. http://www.dogsofthedow.com/dogyrs.htm http://www.dogsofthedow.com/dogyrs.htm Using funds with dividends can smooth returns (although not always tax beneficially).
- bradleyjg 11y agoA 5% arithmetic average nominal return over a multi-decade time horizon is not too difficult to achieve with even fairly low risk tolerance for undershooting the target. Change any of those qualifiers and it becomes a different story.
- JamesBarney 11y agoHe unfortunately kept one of the biggest contributors to the success of his lifestyle a secret. How can you get consistent 10% return on your investment? Assuming a more realistic 6% nominal return - 2% inflation gives us a more realistic 4% real return. Running the numbers that way ends up with a measly $10,000 in interest after 20 years not a whopping $47,000.
- czbond 11y agoYou're using that as an excuse..
- msandford 11y agoOkay, so I'll make a spreadsheet where I assume a 50% annual return and then show it's so easy to retire in less than 10 years! For ANYBODY! On only $50 per month of savings! YOU'RE AN IDIOT FOR NOT DOING THIS! The point is that eventually a quantitative difference becomes a qualitative difference. Few people can make a 10% annual return and many, many fewer still can make a 50% annual return. But if you just buy index funds, it's fairly straightforward for just about anyone to make a 4% annual (real) return. Given the gigantic difference in how these curves grow over time, it's entirely fair to point this out.
- tunesmith 11y agoEven then... which index funds? At what allocation? And how often to rebalance? It's still way too easy to try and get into timing the market even if you just stick to index funds.
- fmorel 11y agoVanguard's Target Retirement funds are great for this. I make automatic monthly contributions and never worry about rebalancing.
- czbond 11y agoThat wasn't the point of the article, and you can get more than a 10% return. Sitting in the public markets doing what everyone else does wont' get you there. I've been down voted because of everyone's limited thoughts in what it takes to achieve this. Why do I know this? Because I'm in a very similar position as the author.
- rayiner 11y ago> I am not convinced there is any significant advantage from private schools I don't know what the schools are like in Adelaide, but in much of the U.S. the impetus for sending kids to private schools is not the quality of education per se, but the quality of the students. In Baltimore, where I live, you can either send your kids to private school, or send your kids to a school where some significant fraction of everyone is in a gang. Or you can move into one of the exorbitantly priced suburbs, increasing your carbon footprint and contributing to the exodus of middle class people that makes schools in the city such a disaster to begin with.
- habitue 11y agoBy sending your kids to a private school, aren't you contributing to the exodus from public schools that make schools in the city such a disaster to begin with?
- rayiner 11y agoIt's a collective action problem. I'd love for all the parents of my generation to move back into the city and send their kids to public school, so we could have schools where middle class values and culture dominate. But I won't if everyone else doesn't. The cost of that is potentially quite a bit more than the cost of private school: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1549711/Children-learn-most-from-peers-not-parents.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1549711/Children-lear....
- habitue 11y agoI get that, I just meant to point out it's a collective action problem in both cases. There are different trade-offs for you personally though which might make you pick one over the other.
- aetherson 11y agoOf course you are. But it's multiplayer Prisoner's Dilemma. You cooperating won't magically make everyone else start cooperating, it'll just mean that you're on the bad side of a cooperate/defect rewards box.
- derptron 11y agoHow vague is this article? Ok, he sits around all day "hacking" (an already overused term) without any mention of how he got any income in the first place, only how his investments are working out. Pretty useless.
- habitue 11y agoA lot of people seem to be attacking his numbers and his advice etc. But even if his explanations and suggestions are complete bunk, the fact that he's doing it serves as an existence proof that this kind of life is achievable. So if you're attracted to this kind of life, take it as evidence that not everyone works forever, and you can figure out how to do it too.
- anon1385 11y ago> the fact that he's doing it serves as an existence proof that this kind of life is achievable Real life lottery winners prove that winning the lottery is achievable. That doesn't make playing the lottery good financial advice.
- Artistry121 11y agoBut... he provides somewhat actionable advice that helps get there. The lottery example you provide is one in which even the winners can't give good advice on how to win.
- zajd 11y ago> the fact that he's doing it you mean the fact he says he's doing it... which is worthless
- Ollinson 11y agoWe know that the output which describes his life is true but the details of the input are dodgy at best. The input in this case matters a lot.
- mikeash 11y agoAre people unaware that early retirement is a real thing that happens to real people? I thought everybody already knew that it was possible in theory to retire early and spend a big chunk of your life not working. The hard part is figuring out how. The article's implicit advice of "get a highly paid job as an executive at a big company, and find investments which reliably return 10%" is useless for that.
- sz4kerto 11y agoAt the moment, relatively safe investments with 10% yields do not exist.
- aetherson 11y agoAt basically every moment, relatively safe investments with 10% real yields do not exist. For an investment to be relatively safe and give 10% real yield, that means that the economy as a whole has to grow at roughly 10% per year. That'd be awesome! We all would like that! But it's not something that ever really happens. Maybe if we discover strong AI or something.
- s3nnyy 11y agoIt is all about the savings-rate. If you save 50% of your net-income, you can take one month off for every month you work. If you have a ~80% savings-rate, you can take 8-9 months off for every month you work. Most people can not quadruple their income, but it is technically possible to live on way, way less than most people think. The guy in the post claims his expenses are 40k/year for a 2.5 person household. That is 16k/year per person, which is low. But it can be lower than this. Check out Jacob from http://earlyretirementextreme.com/how-i-live-on-7000-per-year.html http://earlyretirementextreme.com/how-i-live-on-7000-per-yea..., he lives off 7k per year in California and retired in his early 30s.
- Artistry121 11y agoThis blog and the book informed my lifestyle, my goals and how I see poverty/education/society. It's worth it for anyone to read.
- tw04 11y agoHow to live on $7k/year - don't have a pre-existing medical condition.
- sandworm101 11y agoOh look. Another wealthy person lecturing on the wisdom he has learned through wealth, that wealth is secondary to happiness and should be avoided. For the rest of us, lack of money is the root of most stress. Those with dependants cannot simply remove them from our lives (where is this guys wife now?). Our lives are not diminished by opportunities lost because we spent too much time at the office. They are diminished because we don't have enough money to pay the bills --> because we are not able to spend time at the office --> underemployment. I actually believe the 10% reference. But I also believe that he isn't being honest about where it is from. I smell a spendthrift trust or investment property that his is milking (ie taking rents but not paying the mortgage.) If this sounds like a rant, it is. I'm spending all day doing RSA submissions. I do this to chase business/clients/pad my resume. It's yet more time spent chasing work rather than actually doing the work. Welcome to the gig economy.
- zrail 11y ago> In Australia the government gives much of the population “middle class welfare”, a few $100/week which covers much of my food and bills. We also have free public health care. You don't need much when you have a social safety net, freely given to anyone who needs it.
- wycx 11y agoHe gets that middle class welfare due to his child. As a single male professional in Australia, I see none of that middle class welfare, unless I start speculating in real estate or taking advantage of superannuation concessions.
- Artistry121 11y agoIt's also a factor of what you choose to do in life. I don't know your specific circumstances - but as an attorney you probably took on a heavy debt load that adds bills that many others don't have. Many lawyers I know are chronically underemployed - and yet many more are going to school to compete with that diminished pool. Other than perhaps older parents are dependents a choice for most to take as dependents? If so - a non-financially-productive dependent is like a second mortgage - but it was a chosen one.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoI think the plan is patience and discipline. For some it may be to invest money over 10 years. For the average HN user it may mean to have the discipline to create a paid micro saas which requires little time to manage and keep working on it for several years. Invest $100 per week, or invest 2 hours per week, and grow your paid service x% yearly.
- xntrk 11y ago"invest at 10% (you get to work out where)" if you could really do this you wouldn't have to work (at the current rates environment). You could start selling bonds for say 7% return and collect 3% for free!
- stretchwithme 11y agoPerhaps it would be a lot easier to live as one pleases without having to pay the taxes required to subsidize $100/week and free health care for others. Perhaps it would be easier to earn a decent return on investments if your government doesn't subsidize borrowing so much that you earn less than a dollar a year in interest on your bank deposits. Maybe Australia doesn't do that and its banks pay a decent interest rate as a result?
- glibgil 11y agoThink about the old people and the retardeds.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoIt's either subsidize $100/week and free health care or subsidize food stamps, emergency health care, etc... The whole point of a society is to NOT act as an individual.
- stretchwithme 11y agoWithout individual action, a great many things would not exist. Some would say the point of having a society is to have rules that allow us to peacefully co-exist and trade with other. Its not to allow some to take advantage of others.
- harryh 11y agoIsn't is weird how some people in this thread say that the guy can only do it because of Australia's generous social programs. Meanwhile you think it would be easier if these didn't exist and taxes were lower. In reality I bet it's about as easy no matter what country you live in and what tax rates or social programs you have access to. Simply live a somewhat frugal life, save lots of money, and let the magic of compounding work over a decade or two. Rather than looking for excuses it's probably better to just get started.
- stretchwithme 11y agoI'm not searching for excuses. I'm a great saver and took several years off to work on apps and startups and a couple of book ideas. I'm very frugal. My last car lasted 15 years. Perhaps you'd be better off responding to what someone says instead of inventing imaginary motives.
- tswartz 11y agoIt seems that most people are immediately pointing to why the author is wrong or that his numbers are incorrect. I think we are missing the broader point that spending less than you make and saving consistently for 10+ years is going to help you have the financial freedom to work less. Save 15% of your income into retirement and you will be set. Another key point is to stop thinking that there is good debt (i.e car loan at 2%) and to stop the 'keeping up with the Joneses' mentality. If you need a loan to buy something besides a house, you probably can't afford it. Being debt free can give you a mental and emotional peace that is hard to find elsewhere.
- voxmatt 11y agoThe point is well taken, but sitting on my couch in PJs everyday would definitely make me very, very depressed; economic freedom or not. I'm very sincerely happy that this guy found his way, but I can confidently say that this is not for me.
- aswanson 11y agoExactly. A lot of people here are mistaking the trees from the forest (as programmers are wont to do), but the guy seems to be doing it, so he can't be that far from the truth.
- aswanson 11y agoAlong the lines of what you say about debt reminded me of this: http://jasonkelly.com/books/fsp/ http://jasonkelly.com/books/fsp/
- mikeash 11y agoIs it really all that interesting to say that if you save a big piece of your income, you will end up with a large pile of money which will greatly improve your financial position? I mean, I thought this was the sort of obvious thing that everybody knows, like that the sun rises in the morning. The hard part isn't knowing that you should save. The hard part is figuring out how to save, and figuring out where to put your savings. The article doesn't help at all in this respect. If the article is merely saying that you can improve your financial situation if you save a lot of money, then it's pointless. If the article is giving more specific advice than that then saying that you can improve your financial situation by specifically getting a great job as an executive and putting your savings into investments that are so good they're effectively magic, which is also pointless.
- inerte 11y agoSome people call it FIRE (Financial Independence Retire Early). There are many people doing it and several resources online about this. I would start visiting some of the sites on this sidebar https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence
- Artistry121 11y agoThere's a really cool tool: www.firecalc.com that will let you calculate your likelihood of being able to retire based on all previous permutations of stock market returns.
- econner 11y agoIt's very possible to retire within 10 years if you're frugal. Essentially if you save 65% of your after tax income you can retire in ~11 years assuming you do not increase spending in retirement. This model assumes a safe portfolio withdrawal rate of 4%. http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim...
- song 11y agoI agree with the comments, his 10% are way overestimated. Best I've ever did in a year was a bit below 7% across all my assets (but then maybe I'm just not very good at managing my money). That said, saving enough money to have such a life by 48 is easy for most people here. The easiest way to save is to keep spending like a student even when you start earning real money. That means avoiding the trap of wanting a bigger house, getting used to expensive food and restaurants, spending money in big brands and all the luxuries people start getting addicted as their salary go up. This goes with the second rule of thumb, never take on debt on depreciating assets. A mortgage for a house is fine, a loan for a TV is not. It's much easier not changing your lifestyle as income increase than suddenly trying to cut expenses. Of course this advice doesn't really work for people who are paid a low salary but for software developers who earn a multiple of the median income, saving like this is easy.
- pinewood74 11y agoIn 2009, the S&P 500 returned 23%, where were you then? It did similarly well in 2013. Are you picking stocks or something? Because you should settle down and just get some Index Funds from Vanguard. The Median 15 year annualized return on the S&P 500 since inception is 12%, back out 2% inflation and you're right at 10% returns. 10% returns are not unreasonable. Sure it's not going to be a flat 10% every year like the article, but annualized returns of 10% over 15-20 years is doable for everyone.
- maxxxxx 11y agoIf it's that doable why are there no funds that guarantee 8% every year? I would even buy a fund that gives me "only" 5% guaranteed. They can keep the other 5%.
- prewett 11y agoWhy would I guarantee something if I could avoid it? Investment returns are lumpy; some years you get +23%, other years you get -20% (probably 2008, for example), why would a fund manager offer a guarantee? An average of 10% over a long period is doable; Berkshire Hathaway has averaged +15% for 40 years. Just because fund don't guarantee something doesn't mean it isn't doable.
- parkaboy 11y agoIf you don't know who David Rowe is - his work is amazing. He's the main force behind Codec2, one of the few opensource ultra-low bitrate speech codecs out there. The project hit ~700 bps recently! (https://github.com/freedv/codec2/blob/master/src/codec2.h https://github.com/freedv/codec2/blob/master/src/codec2.h - I think it was actually at 400 bps @ one point, but I guess it got scaled back)
- stvswn 11y agoHmm.. it seems like most of his strategy depends on "middle class welfare," public healthcare, and public schools. I don't know much about Australian taxes, but I assume that with his low income and high savings he's paying less in taxes than he's taking from the public. And he's doing it because he likes the lifestyle, not because he fell on hard times. If I were an Australian taxpayer, I'd want to know why I should fund the early retirement of a tech exec.
- meapix 11y agosummary, country you live in helps. This guy is on welfare.
- astrange 11y agoI'm sure that let him quit his job a whole one year earlier.
- AdrianRossouw 11y agoThis is what I'd love to do one day. Have enough money so I can just build interesting things all the time.
- harryh 11y agoSave half your money for 15 years and you can do this. Depending on your financial situation you can probably do it faster. It's simple (though not easy). Don't just imagine this as some impossible dream. Make it a real goal and go for it! Go read http://mrmoneymustache.com http://mrmoneymustache.com
- Mz 11y agoHe's 48. I am 50. I know most folks here are in their 30's and 20's. Let me suggest the better takeaway is that if you want a particular lifestyle or personal outcome and you are persistent over time, you can do all kinds of things that look undoable to most people. His real secret is he made a decision to walk away from keeping up with The Jones' and stuck with it for many years. If you do the same, you can have similar outcomes by his age, assuming you want that. Some people do. Some people don't.
- mkiol 11y agoA guy I know retired in about 1970, and raised his family on his savings alone, which were about 200k. He says today his savings are mostly untouched (he lived off the interest, and his in recent years he reached the legal retirement age and receives a pension). To do so he: - Home schooled his kids - Had the benefit of free public healthcare - His kids (who most have now got university degrees) used government interest-free loans to pay for uni - He did take his family on a year long overseas trip back to his native country which cost about 40k - He didn't live in a house, but in a sailing boat!
- breischl 11y agoJeez, a whole room full of smart (or at least educated) people and half of them see "10% returns" and get completely wrapped around the axle. Use your brains a bit - the same concept applies at whatever return you happen to think is reasonable. Adjust the numbers appropriately, and you're all set. For example, a 4% withdrawal rate would have let retire into the teeth of the Great Depression and gone another 30 years without working a day. Adjust for your circumstances a bit, and you can make it last forever. Or get a little bit clever with variable withdrawal rates and you can increase the rate and make it last forever. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study