22 ms·
“It’s done, there is no way back. We tried, we failed”
- kelukelugames 11y agoHere is the steam page. http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ Remind me of Alice, which had some beautiful levels. http://store.steampowered.com/app/19680/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/19680/
- Sumaso 11y agoIt's a real shame, since I was really looking forward to this game! I suppose I should count myself fortunate that I didn't Kickstart Woolfe. Seeing these failed projects is grim reminder that just because you back something doesn't mean it will be delivered.
- cautious_int 11y agoSince you didn't back it back then, you can now buy it immediately on Steam. It looks like a functional game, and not a failed project.
- james-skemp 11y agoIt doesn't have a proper ending (obvious they were expecting a second in the series), but having played it I enjoyed it for what it was. With the bankruptcy, it's questionable where purchases of this will go to, so you might want to keep an eye on the game's Steam forum. (There was another game, the name of which escapes me, that had a similar issue, with it getting sold cheap, and the money wasn't going to the creators. I think it was this year's Steam sales, if anyone else recalls the game.)
- blakeyrat 11y agoIt wasn't "recent", but after Gamecock went bankrupt (good riddance!), their FPS title Legendary was on Steam for like a buck fifty. It's $3 now. I assume that was a creditor trying to squeeze every cent from it.
- BasDirks 11y ago"Oh I didn't get the toy I paid for". Really? That's what you're posting when a group of talented artists see their dream shattered?
- normloman 11y agoThe artists have no right to complain. They were the ones asking for money in the first place. They promised the public they would deliver on the "toy." They underestimated what it would take to make the game. The backers are not free of responsibility, but the artists also have to accept blame.
- scott_s 11y agoKeep in mind the game was delivered, and is available for purchase on Steam.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- arbitrage 11y agoQuote marks should be reserved for quoting things that people actually said. Sarcastic quote marks should be reserved to make fun of something someone actually did ... the person you're responding to said in fact that he didn't kick in on this project.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Really? That's what you're posting when a group of talented artists see their dream shattered? How, exactly, was their "dream shattered"? They raised money that (they thought) was sufficient, and got to work independently on a game they loved. That's more than a lot of people get. Apparently the game wasn't very good. No one is entitled to financial success.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoActually, more failing projects should be funded IMO - Kickstarter has been too much like a store for too long, which caused a lot of people to have overly high expectations for projects they backed.
- fr0styMatt2 11y agoThis. It doesn't help the perception that there are a lot of companies out there that seem to be using Kickstarter as a service for basically taking pre-orders though. Often I've thought "Why the heck is that big company with lots of money doing a Kickstarter? Isn't Kickstarter for people that wouldn't have the money to fund the project at all?". A whole other debate, I know.
- bluedino 11y agoWow. I'm not current on games but from an art standpoint that looks pretty good.
- blakeyrat 11y agoThat what amazed me about this, is it looks like they were basically creating a complete clone of Alice: Madness Returns. I mean, I know Alice didn't sell well, but surely someone pointed that out to them?
- facepalm 11y agoI'm confused - how is it failed if they launched it on Steam? Is that just a demo?
- kybernetyk 11y agoThe game doesn't sell well enough to cover running costs.
- facepalm 11y agoWhat are the running costs - does it have an online component? Or just the fees they have to pay to Steam?
- kybernetyk 11y agoThey had wages to pay. (IIRC they had somewhere from 5 - 10 full time employees).
- themoonbus 11y ago"But changing gameplay from 2D to 3D had a major impact on overall development cost (we found out a little too late)" Not to pile on, but this was very surprising to me... how could you not know that this would have a major impact?
- valarauca1 11y ago>Passion and commitment are not a substitue for experience The author explained more or less. Inexperience.
- jeremiep 11y agoI say the exact same thing about Agile practices, "methodologies and procedures are not a substitute for knowledge and experience." That message is a LOT harder to get through than it seems.
- karlkatzke 11y agoDigressing a little from the central topic -- Yeah, it's actually amazing how hard that message is to get through. And you even see a dichotomy where the HR side of a company will understand that and will go out of it's way to hire experienced people and retain them, but Product/Project Managers will completely discount them to the point of driving experienced people out of a business when the knowledge and experience says "Build it X way or you're in a world of hurt a year from now. I lived that once and I don't want to live it again." Or, put another way, "Security is not a feature the business needs at this time in this PII-heavy project."
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoOTOH, if they embraced the agile methodology, they could've said "We do not know how long it will take, it depends on our velocity which we haven't yet established". $72K for a team of 6-10 developing an AAA-level game is just unrealistic.
- jeremiep 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- greggman 11y agoI haven't played the game and I see the reviews are "mixed" on steam but looking at the video they certainly did an amazing job for such a small team. Of course at the end of the day it has to be a good game but they should still be really proud about how far they got. I hope they try again and apply whatever lessons they learned
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- spydum 11y agoIt says they are in bankruptcy and the IP for the game is for sale (no doubt to pay down what they borrowed). Someone else could buy it up and build it, but not them (unless they could come up with cash for their creditors)
- stephengillie 11y agoOh wow, that's an even worse tragedy.
- rdancer 11y agoNot 100% of it, though. The bankruptcy administrator will try to obtain the best price for the IP; it could well be that the best price is a pittance.
- coldpie 11y agoOT: Hey, it's greggman :) Big fan of many of the games you've worked on. Hope you're doing well.
- monological 11y agoHey! Of course I would find you commenting on HN! Did you end up finding a place to live or are you coming back to Tokyo :p I ended up going to Singapore and coming back.
- dmbaggett 11y agoI wanted to believe that a team of 6 to 10 people could make a game that looked and felt AAA. Boy was I wrong! When we made Crash Bandicoot (with a team of 7), it was already virtually impossible to make a AAA game with 6-10 people, and that was 20 years ago. I tell inexperienced entrepreneurs to take their honest best estimate and multiply by 10. Or, as Mark Cerny (our producer on Crash) used to tell us, "add one and increase the unit: 1 week = 2 months; 2 months = 3 years; 3 years = you're doomed". For a less anecdotal version, read The Mythical Man Month. (The factor he arrives at is 9.)
- jnardiello 11y agoSir, you made my days when I was a teenager. Thank you.
- ivanca 11y agoOfftpic but you worked on Crash Bandicoot!? That's so awesome. I loved each version of that game and it made our childhoods much more fun (at countries all over the world, just as an example I'm from Colombia)
- pixelbath 11y agoYou might enjoy this then: http://all-things-andy-gavin.com/2011/02/02/making-crash-bandicoot-part-1/ http://all-things-andy-gavin.com/2011/02/02/making-crash-ban...
- emilsedgh 11y agoConfirming from Iran :)
- dmbaggett 11y agoI never get tired of hearing that -- thank you! :)
- zarkone 11y agoI've tried and beat Crash Bandicoot and Crash Cart for the first time this year. (I'm 25, and neither me nor my friends had PS1 in my childhood). While playing this game I was like always been on the bleeding edge between difficulty, wishing to give up and encouragement... I mean, I just couldn't resist, -- I couldn't turn off the console, in spite of the fact that I had to re-run some levels about ~50-80 times to beat.. It was amazing, very challenging journey, i had always been feeling that arcade spirit while playing, which is such rarity nowdays.
- jebblue 11y agoI was watching that game, I like first person more but this is a beautiful game to be sure! There's so much competition out there, I wonder how big The Fun Pimps team is in comparison, I'd assumed around the same size.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tinco 11y agoHow is that squandered money? It's great that Flanders supports their game dev community. Why is 60k a lot of money for preproduction? It's absolutely peanuts. And yes, they actually managed to employ game developers and gave them valuable experience that most definitely is good for the Flanders games industry.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- song 11y agoI'm glad public money is spent on this. 60k is nothing on the scale of public money and is certainly peanuts when it comes to game budgets. And honestly, while it didn't sell well (and the market certainly is tough right now), the game in itself is not bad. It lacks polish and would have benefitted from a bigger budget but it's not a bad showing. Tale of Tales is another example of a studio who produced some very interesting games in term of Art. The path was a very interesting game and as influenced quite a few other games.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jules 11y agoDo you realize that while it wasn't successful, they did actually make a game? http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ For comparison, €60000 buys about 40cm = 0.0004km of highway.
- song 11y agoOff topic but I kind of hate it when someone replies and then deletes his comment. I wonder what he said in reply to my comment now (and what you replied to Jules)...
- felhr 11y agoProbably I am missing something but...Making a videogame (even an indie one) with 72.139 $? They were probably doomed from the very beginning.
- tinco 11y agoThey apparently had investors and attracted government subsidies.
- felhr 11y agoThat sounds very reasonable. In that case it would be great to know what kind of penalties they incur because no releasing.
- tinco 11y agoThey did release, so no penalties from the government, and they filed for bankruptcy so the investors probably just lost their money. I don't know about Belgian bankruptcy laws so no idea if there are personal consequences.
- jasonlotito 11y agoThe game is released. http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/
- CmonDev 11y agoThat would be about enough to hire about one person (providing there is profit sharing on the horizon).
- bko 11y ago> But we have literally no money whatsoever to pay for stamps, let alone print the artbooks and dvd-cases. How did this happen? Shouldn't that money have been allocated earlier? Did they spend every dollar thinking that this is the dollar that turns everything around. Maybe I just don't get the mentality of those looking to fund projects on Kickstarter.
- dudul 11y agoAgreed. I don't understand how they can not give anything at all to all the people who poured money into their kickstarted. What does it say about crowdfunding?
- coldpie 11y agoThat contributing money to an unfinished product is a risk, and that you may never see the result you expected from your investment. Which is exactly what everyone should have known before contributing. Weighing a team's experience and ability should be a major factor in deciding whether to back a project.
- micampe 11y agoIt says that people don't understand what Kickstarter is: you are investing in a project, not buying a product. Investments carry risk.
- dudul 11y agoTrue, but seriously the "we have everything ready in our basement but you can't get it cause we can't buy stamps" is f-ing lame. And as the previous poster mentioned, how do you not put this money aside to reward people who gave you money?
- markus2012 11y agoI don't think it's lame. It sounds like they are living through a train-wreck moving in slow motion that will last a few months - and perhaps much longer.
- kin 11y agoSo if the game is on Steam right now and I try to support them by buying a copy, where does the money go?
- haser_au 11y agoThe Intellectual Property (IP) will be listed as an 'asset' in the bankruptcy submission. Whoever picks up the IP will likely receive the money from the game on Steam, since they are the new owners of it. No different than if someone had bought out the studio (GRIN).
- rhino369 11y agoShort answer: their creditors. Long answer: depends on their circumstances in bankruptcy court. The company could potentially reemerge from bankruptcy with the creditors owning it. Or the court might rip the company apart and sell off assets to pay back creditors. The money Steam owes the company is just another asset.
- kkt262 11y agoIt's interesting that failure articles seem to always go up to #1 on HackerNews. Why is that?
- jordanlev 11y agoBecause people upvote them. (As to why they upvote them, I'm guessing it's because often we learn more from failures than from successes, and usually you don't hear about the failures as much as the successes).
- spydum 11y agoMy own theory: people who work in the computing field learn heavily from failure, and this is driven in deep into our practices early on. Think about when you first started learning to program: write code, attempt to compile, FAIL, make some adjustments, FAIL again, make more adjustments, successful compile. Execute, FAIL, make more adjustments, etc. This rapid failure/remediation cycle is somewhat unique, as it opens us to try new and innovative things without fear of failure: failing is just part of the learning process. Since failure is "cheap", we tend to gravitate to sucking up all information about failures, in the hopes of learning from it. Now think about most other trades: cooking/carpentry/plumbing/etc. When you fail, there are material losses. So that learning curve is expensive, and you often apprentice and learn from someone doing it correct, rather than trial and error (though you get a bit of both for sure). I suspect this is the same reason when really interesting Post-Mortems are posted, they shoot up, and lots of positive commentary around them. We all consume it, in hopes they prevent us from writing the same one in the future.
- gdulli 11y agoThere's more to learn from failure than from success.
- utku_karatas2 11y agoBecause failure stories tend to be more sincere and heartfelt than the success stories. It provokes the readers' emotions. Success stories usually won't include any dirty details, any shabby deals or the full naked truth of the events that underwent. No A-list actor will talk about the producer dick he sucked. You have a reputation to maintain after a success. In a failure on the other hand, you probably are at the rock bottom, have nothing to lose, no one to be afraid of.
- VikingCoder 11y agoSo, I wonder how much they'd sell all the assets and source for? Could we Kickstart a project to drop it all in the Public Domain?
- haser_au 11y agoI'd kick in.
- VikingCoder 11y agoI'd like someone in the industry to look at the code first, to Due Diligence that it's not just utter crap...
- rkangel 11y agoI'm actually finding it reassuring to see some of these 'our project failed, sorry' messages coming up. It reassures me that kickstarter is actually being used to fund new things, rather than just as a marketplace for existing products, where you don't even have to have found any capital up front.
- thenomad 11y agoThat's a very good point. I hope that backers take it the same way. New stuff is risky by definition - and KS has funded some pretty major successes on risky projects too (Oculus).
- justin66 11y agoI would feel a lot better having been a KS contributor to this than I would having been a KS contributor to Oculus. "Thank you for your contribution and now some other, better-connected investors and employees are going to make money off of their investment in us" is about the worst possible outcome of a Kickstart.
- fpgaminer 11y agoThis is exactly the problem with Kickstarter. Backers assume all the risks, but gain no benefit from success.
- shdon 11y agoI'm not sure I agree with that last bit. The rewards for backers are there for a reason. When it comes to software projects -- especially games, you can frequently have access to test and beta versions and get the final product (depending on your backing level, this may be at a price lower or higher than the retail price). Additionally, it usually means you get to follow along in the development process, maybe even provide input or feedback. Another common reward is being made into a character in the game or providing another piece of content. It may not sound like much, but it is a benefit. I for one got a real kick out of seeing my name in Broken Age's credit roll. I've backed quite a few Kickstarter projects and so far, none that were successfully funded have failed. Some still might and that would be disappointing, but I wouldn't regret backing them in the least. I have "bought" the fun of being a small part of something and watching things develop.
- ErikRogneby 11y agoSo the game did get created though right? It's $9.99 on Steam: http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/281940/ It sounds like while the game got made, they aren't profitable and can't afford to make good on the kickstarter rewards.
- dogma1138 11y agoThis was an episodic game they've released Vol 1 which was met with some quite poor reviews due to gameplay issues. They could not push out Vol 2 nor the Kickstarter rewards as they pretty much ran out of money. I actually wonder if in such cases Kickstarter shouldn't back the shipping or demand getting the a hold of the rewards and try to some how compensate the backers. Heck with the amount of projects which fail they can pretty much have a monthly loot crate going on with the crap received from failed kickstartups... Tho if they file for bankruptcy i wonder if giving the rewards away will not count against them as they devalued their fixed assets value just before or after filing for bankruptcy.
- lobo_tuerto 11y agoFrom TA: "What about our Kickstarter backers? The people that believed in us from the beginning? People we made promises too. People we have let down. Even worse… people we will not be able to give the full rewards they invested in. The crazy thing is, that we have most of the rewards ready for postage. All the backer stickers and letters of enlistment just need a stamp. All the poster sets printed, signed and ready. The artbook is ready to be printed, the soundtrack is ready for distribution, the DVD case is ready for production. But we have literally no money whatsoever to pay for stamps, let alone print the artbooks and dvd-cases." This could be a good closure. From comments: "Fredrik Waage: Please honor your backers who believed in your game by releasing the DRM-free version like you promised so linux backers (hopefully via WINE) and ppl who don't like steam can enjoy your game." Or maybe even go open source?
- paulsnar 11y agoThey say that the source is for sale along with the IP, so probably not
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> Or maybe even go open source? While that is the ideal way to close up a failed start-up (in my opinion anyway) I don't believe they would entertain that considering they're trying to sell the IP.
- billmalarky 11y agoLooks like they need to try to sell the IP first in order to pay back creditors.
- wvenable 11y agoSince they're filing for bankruptcy, they really can't go open source -- their IP needs to be sold to pay the creditors.
- adebtlawyer 11y agoMaybe, if there's anybody to buy it. It may be abandoned.
- agumonkey 11y agoIt's interesting to see the reactions here. The matchstick project ended up giving full refunds to the backers and yet they were trashed in the comments. While here people are showing lots of love even after the bankrupt notification.
- danso 11y agoI know Kickstarter failures are pretty common...but I submitted this one because I liked the refreshing straightforward admission of abject failure. The comments on the OP are pretty mild and supportive considering that the project isn't sending out any of its promised rewards, nevermind not finishing the game. I'd like to think that the OP's honesty is a factor in that.
- agumonkey 11y agoI don't know, I didn't pay attention to most of the failed projects, but the matchstick guys seemed honest enough (they too took a road to difficult for them). Especially considering they'd refund everybody. Yet people seemed quite angry.
- erikb 11y agoEnd users suck as investors. They think they already bought the product+rewards and feel it's quite painful that they still need to wait a few months before starting to use them. Hell, to say the truth although I'm a developer, when I paid something on Kickstarter I also feel that way...
- brudgers 11y agoIt's great to see people admitting their mistakes. On the other hand, the project was doomed from the start $50,000 just isn't enough money to produce a game, let alone a game and collateral merchandise. And the commitment to collateral merchandise for a project like this meant that effort that could have gone to making the game was committed to dealing with posters, printers and postage. There's a reason startups don't return dividends to early stage investors. There's a reason sophisticated early stage investors don't want their investments to pay dividends.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoWell I think people are getting the wrong impression here. They started this game in 2013 on their own money, got a subsidy to build a prototype that year, then in 2014 raised money from a loan in Belgium to finish the game. They communicated all of this in their Kickstarter. They then asked $50k I guess to finish up the game and expand the scope a little bit, and make some money on various rewards, but mainly I suppose as virtually all kickstarters nowadays: a presales platform. In that regard they succeeded. The game is finished, it's for sale, and the backers got their game. But the sales were also disappointing, and so they declared bankruptcy. The issue here is that they created stickers, dvd crap, soundtracks etc... Kickstarter backer rewards. And they can't ship them as they're bankrupt. The problem obviously is that they didn't earmark funds ahead. I think that's disrespectful towards the backers and it's a genuine complaint, but I don't feel it's very significant in the scheme of things. Kickstarters know the risks. And the creators of the game put their heart and soul into it and ended up bankrupt, yet did deliver the game. I think that's a fair compromise for the backers of the game, even if they don't end up getting their rewards, like an artbook or wallpaper which can be pretty sweet but I doubt anyone will lose sleep over it, while the creators must've lost a lot of sleep going through a bankruptcy. So this notion they raised $50k for 7 people to build a game in two months isn't really the case at all. Beyond that, your point on merchandise rings true but it depends on context. A soundtrack, artbook and wallpaper usually isn't a big deal. After all, the game has a soundtrack regardless, and they'd already produced tons of artwork in the process of modelling, you can see it on the kickstarter. The effort is printing and shipping it. But if someone is giving you a $20 premium to ship him a PDF you already have on your computer, would you say that's bad business? Not really, any smart indie will pay some highschooler $250 to take care of it, a small price to increase your budget by $10k or something to that effect. The issue is that some kickstarters go way overboard, and the reward/effort ratio plummets to below their IRR or even below 1. So it really depends, in this case I think it wasn't a bad decision as they promised rewards for things they already had laying around, they simply should've earmarked the funds.
- chazu 11y agoSad to see GRIN dissolve, I felt they were a very promising studio.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoI don't have data to back this up other than years of entrepreneurship. I'm sure someone could invest the time to dig-up the data and corroborate or refute my statement. I think game development must rank way up there with restaurants in terms of business failure rates. It might even be worst than restaurants but the data could be impossible to collect. Why? Because restaurant failures are a matter of public record while game developers more often fail privately. The data simply evaporates. It's a really tough business, even with money. For the most part lack of business experience and idealism or hubris can play a big role in this. The good old "the market is <insert big number> billions, if we only grab 0.1%" fallacy. To be sure, hubris and doing something because you love it has it's place and fortunes have been made because of this. That said, the cold hard reality is that the gaming industry is paved with the corpses of probably millions of entrepreneurial efforts who have tried and failed. Generally speaking, for most developers, I think there's far more money in developing games for those who have cash to burn (whether successfully or not) than to try to create the next blockbuster. As a small data point, years ago we were approached by a company to develop an iOS children's game for them. Lots of animation, sound, graphics creation, etc. They had no experience in software development at all. They wanted to convert this low budget cartoon character into a game because they convinced themselves they'd make millions with an app. We told them it would cost $50K to $250K (or more) and months of development depending on specs. Of course, they had no specifications. It would be impossible to understand costs without a solid spec. We also recommended they DO NOT develop this game and stick to their core business. In fact we pushed back hard on this point. I sat down with the CEO for a couple of hours to explain failure rates, challenges, issues, etc. They needed to fundamentally transform their company and were not equipped to do so at the time. I got an angry email from the CEO telling me we were crooks and how they found a company in India that could build them the entire game for just $15K in three months. What the hell did I know? Right? A year later, almost to the day, I got an email from the same CEO asking if we could meet. We did. He revealed they burned the $15K and got nothing more than a slideshow made with templates. They then found a larger company (also in India) and burned an additional $50K and got something that was buggy and wasn't even playable. By the time he asked me for a meeting they had burned through over $150K trying to have their game made and had nothing. They couldn't even submit it to the app store. They were nearly out of money. You could probably guess what happened next. He asked if we could fix it for $20K. I explained I'd be surprised if anyone would have any interest in touching that code-base for any amount of money. And, no, $20K couldn't even touch building the app they envisioned a year earlier. I repeated my recommendation to stick to their core business. Which they did. After learning an expensive lesson. Anyhow, long story to relate one type of scenario behind game development where ignorance and hubris meet a pile-o-cash and a bonfire follows. Sorry to see the Woolfe team fail. I don't think I am being a pessimist when I say this is far more likely to be the outcome with games. Kudos for trying. Move on. Quickly.
- aquanext 11y agoI think they are dead on about lack of experience being the cause here. You can't make a AAA game on $72,000 and 6 to 10 people. That's nuts. Just one person's salary is going to be 50-60k if they are paying people reasonably.
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago> You can't make a AAA game on $72,000 and 6 to 10 people. That's nuts. You've misunderstood what actually happened, the game had a different budget and timeframe.
- asciimo 11y agoThe artwork and character design is excellent. The concepts are strong. I would have backed it. I'm rewarded nonetheless with a strong warning to balance passion with pragmatism.
- Udo 11y ago> I guess our public silence the last few months already said a lot. While I can personally understand this reaction to having trouble, it's not healthy nor is it fair to cease communication in this way. A lot of promising projects announce difficulties by falling silent, including Limit Theory, which I was looking forward to seeing realized some day. Maybe crowdfunded projects need to shift to a mindset where it's expected to be upfront about problems. > So with a heavy heart I have to communicate that as of now the IP of Woolfe, all of the assets and source code is now for sale I said it before, but I'll gladly say it again: backing a Kickstarter project is a bet, not a pre-order. When I back a project, I calculate the odds and place my money accordingly, full well knowing it could be gone. As long as makers honestly tried to achieve something, I'm fine with failure. Not everybody sees it that way, though. It would be nice if new games on Kickstarter would include a pledge for their IP to enter public domain in case the project as a whole fails. Because the alternative being played out here is most likely not very helpful to anyone, including the defunct studio.
- breischl 11y agoI didn't fund Limit Theory, but I've been following it because it does look cool. You may have missed it, but the developer recently resurfaced. Hopefully he'll get things back on track... http://forums.ltheory.com/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=4492 http://forums.ltheory.com/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=4492
- Thimothy 11y agoThanks for sharing. I funded Limit Theory and by now had brushed it off as a failure. Glad to see some light coming from there, the project is really cool.
- jakejake 11y agoI think sometimes it's a case where things are bad, but the project owners have a few long shots out there and are hoping that one of them will come through. I guess in a perfect world, they would just write that as well.
- scott_s 11y ago
- paulhauggis 11y agoGames are extremely hard to get right, ship on time, and make an actual profit. This doesn't surprise me.
- roel_v 11y agoThe assets of this company are, essentially, worthless. I think the liquidator would jump for joy on a bid of, let's say, 5 or 10k euros for all IP of this game. I've seen cases where IP that cost orders of magnitude more to develop sell for less, sometimes under the condition 'you have to take the office inventory too, because otherwise I have to pay for getting it disposed of' (where 'I' is the liquidator). If anyone is motivated enough, it would take just 500-1000 people who would chip in some spare change to make this open source (I'm not interested in any of this, before anyone suggests it - just hinting to those mentioning 'open source').
- Kequc 11y agoMaybe they could do a kickstarter.
- roel_v 11y agoThat would be the (logistically) obvious route to take for an interested party, but I didn't want to suggest it out of fear of coming across as facetious :)
- JabavuAdams 11y agoSell them on the Unity Asset Store, TurboSquid, UE4 Marketplace, etc.
- mattdeboard 11y agoReally honest letter that is simultaneously an apology and an explanation, without making excuses. I wonder if more experienced game developers could have recognized the failure much further down the track and pulled the plug (or taken on a lot more funding?) before it took the company under. I also wonder, if this undertaking had been made in the US, would the outcome have been any different due to different... I dunno, funding laws or more available funding from traditional investors? Was the completeness of the failure of GRIN down to the fact they spent way more money than they had trying to prove a point (don't need to do pixel or highly stylized art) ? The game industry is interesting to me because of the nature of the problems they have to solve, but it is so damn brutal I don't want any part of it.
- player_1 11y agoWe don't even need more "cinematic platformers"on steam.
- mangeletti 11y agoSerious question: why not target a platform that's more similar to what Crash Bandicoot was built for, and then run it in some sort of Steam-compatible emulation layer[1]? This would have given you a potentially great game, and at least an MVP that you should sell and also show investors with a "imagine this with way better graphics!" pitch, instead of having great graphics without as much of a complete game, given limited time and resources. 1. I'm shooting from the hip, because I have zero game dev experience, and I know even know if this is possible, let alone whether it even makes sense (are 8-bit, etc. games more simple to build than those with modern graphics?).
- redbar0n 11y ago"I wanted to believe that a team of 6 to 10 people could make a game that looked and felt AAA. Boy was I wrong!" "In the video game industry, AAA (pronounced "triple A") is a classification term used for games with the highest development budgets and levels of promotion.[1][2][3][4]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AAA_(video_game_industry) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AAA_(video_game_industry) It should be obvious from this definition of an AAA game that 6-10 people in a small indie game studio can't make a game with 'the highest development budgets and levels of promotion'. It requires lots of $$$ and other resources, which an indie game company almost never has. "Wisdom begins with the definition of terms." - attributed to Socrates
- bagels 11y agoThe quote says "looked and felt AAA". The definition may preclude the game from 'being AAA' but not looking like and feeling like a AAA game, whatever that means in the first place.
- overgard 11y agoWow, my heart goes out to these guys, I guess they dropped the ball but obviously they really cared. It's hard to fault people when they made a good faith effort and came up short. I hope after things settle down and maybe they get some space away from this, they try again on a new project with a bit more wisdom. I think the lesson here (and this one really is probably important for entrepreneur types), is getting funded really should not be viewed as an achievement. It just means the stakes got higher.
- bobajeff 11y agoPeople are acting like the game wasn't able to be made. The issue is it was made but the sales didn't cover the costs. "At first we could not believe that our “baby” was not more successful, in our emotions we started looking for explanations not related to the game. Maybe gamers are just spoilt brats, bashing on everything, maybe there is an oversaturation of indie market, maybe all the free-to-play games by big studios are giving players a false sense of value. How could less than $10 be to expensive for a beautiful game like Woolfe? How could this be our fault? " "Of course none of the emotional excuses above are the reason of our mixed steam rating. We can only blame ourselves… " It's good to see someone excepting the fact that their game just wasn't good enough. Also nice to hear someone admit what a cop out blaming customers or the market is.
- vacri 11y agoLooking at some of the negative reviews on Steam, it's not a matter of entitled gamers (and gamers are the most self-entitled demographic in history...). Plenty of the negative reviews I've seen so far are long, and a prime criticism is the 2-hour gameplay time. A few also mention problems with bland gameplay. Everyone agrees that it's beautiful, but it doesn't matter how beautiful your game is if it's short with no replay and the gameplay isn't solid.
- methodover 11y agoThis is such a hard thing for me to read. Game development is so incredibly hard. It feels like a winner-takes-all game where the very top 1% have everything, and the rest have almost nothing. It's a shame that this studio has to fold. The game looks pretty good. You don't get to that point without having incredibly talented artists, programmers and managers, without having a team that's working pretty well together. And yeah, their reviews on steam aren't perfect -- but to me that doesn't seem that terrible. Everyone stumbles before they really catch their stride. It sounds like they just ran out of money, really. They ran out of time. They weren't given a real shot. What a shame. I see startups pop up all over the valley here that don't even have a tiny fraction of the ingenuity and talent of this company. It's a shame that our economy doesn't value art like this more. A real shame.
- sombremesa 11y agoIt's not just game development, it's almost any creative endeavor. "90% of everything is crap" - Sturgeon's "law". Now even if you end up making the 10% that isn't crap, you have to fight hard to get any attention. There is a huge amount of hustling involved. Even when you are an unprecedented genius, you will suffer immensely for lack of business and marketing skill. Where would Einstein be without Adler? Where would Newton be without Halley? That's just the way the world is (and has been, since time immemorial).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Animats 11y agoThey mention problems with collision detection, which indicates they were writing their own game engine. Why? There are good game engines available, and writing one is a big job.
- victorNicollet 11y agoCollision detection, in a platform game, is an user experience problem rather than a well-specified mathematical problem. If it feels like you should have landed on that ledge, you don't care what the capsule-versus-AABB test says: you expect me to "fix" the game.
- amyjess 11y ago> I guess our public silence the last few months already said a lot. It is not out of disrespect that our communication dropped to almost zero… it is out of shame. PG has actually written on this subject: http://www.paulgraham.com/die.html http://www.paulgraham.com/die.html Basically, if a company stops communicating, it's almost a sure sign that it's in its death throes, and if a company is doing well, it's going to try to reach out as much as possible so they can show off how well they're doing.
- jchomali 11y agoThanks for sharing your experience with us!
- mirimir 11y agoI'm reminded of the Chandler project, funded and directed by Mitch Kapor. The intention was Lotus Agenda, reimagined for the 21st century. But that didn't work out. See Dreaming in Code: Two Dozen Programmers, Three Years, 4,732 Bugs, and One Quest for Transcendent Software by Scott Rosenberg. It's a very sad story. I loved Agenda, and Chandler had so much damn potential! So it goes.
- marincounty 11y ago"What about our Kickstarter backers? The people that believed in us from the beginning? People we made promises too. People we have let down. Even worse… people we will not be able to give the full rewards they invested in. The crazy thing is, that we have most of the rewards ready for postage. All the backer stickers and letters of enlistment just need a stamp. All the poster sets printed, signed and ready. The artbook is ready to be printed, the soundtrack is ready for distribution, the DVD case is ready for production. But we have literally no money whatsoever to pay for stamps, let alone print the artbooks and dvd-cases. " I understand you failed. Find money for postage though? These were Kickstarter investors? You have money for a bankruptcy attorney? Just shopping around for a bankruptcy attorney can save thousands? (Maybe you are doing the legal in house?). My point is the Kickstarter Backers will appreciate a small gift of gratitude, and just might fund you in the future? I think most small companies know they are going under weeks--months in advance? I knew months for myself. There's nothing illegial about keeping a small fund for the last days of a business. Good luck, and with Capitalism, and all its risk-thank goodness for Bankruptcy. When I was younger, I didn't quite appreciate bankruptcy laws. I now keep a close ear out for any changes to bankruptcy laws.(There are entities that want to change the federal statutes. I knew the Obama administration wouldn't let lobbiests touch them. I worry about the next administration?) If I was to do it over again, I would have incorporated every business I ever started? I might have even incorporated my legal name right out of college--if legal?
- listic 11y agoThe story of Little Red Riding Hood just keeps on inspiring new takes. For instance, The Path by Tale of Tales has been done a couple of years earlier, to a wider critical acclaim; and in Belgium, no less. http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/the-path http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/the-path I wonder if the developers could possibly not have heard of them? There seemed to be quite some money in funding for artsy games in Belgium. Personally, I love games and I think both that and Kickstarter funding are needed to suppor more experimenting off the beaten path.
- DjangoBKN 11y agoThat was both scary and sad. As a fellow who is starting out to make a game too.
- erikb 11y agoLearn from it by thinking smaller. When you started out making GTA5+1 and in the end have a new Tetris you are still in the top 10% of people who tried, I think. Really, cut down everything you can and some you can't. Remember that the first iPhone came without copy&paste. Good luck!
- megablast 11y ago> But changing gameplay from 2D to 3D had a major impact on overall development cost Really? Did anyone not think that would be huge?
- w3ightl355 11y agoIt sounds like their heart was in the right place, an effort driven by passion, but they just ran into too many obstacles. If I had invested, I probably wouldn't feel so bad. It sounds like they tried - like they give it their best, sincere effort. That's all you can do, really.
- w3ightl355 11y agoIt sounds like their heart was in the right place, an effort driven by passion, but they just ran into too many obstacles. If I had invested, I probably wouldn't feel so bad. It sounds like they tried - like they give it their best, sincere effort. That's all you can do, really.
- z3t4 11y agoThis feels a bit weird, they have a ton of press and they are on steam for gods sake. This thread alone probably generated enough sales to pay for those post stamps.