11 ms·
Employees at Google, Yahoo, and Amazon lose nothing if they unionize
- digitalzombie 11y agoI would love it if they unionize. The only thing I dislike is protecting the bad apples such as police union or teacher union style tenured. I feel like company HR aren't there for you but for the company and unions are there for you. I was in a situation were I was harass by my boss and HR was never there for me. After twice reporting, there was an incident where I decided I'm going to quit because I couldn't handle the harassment. This was in a gov agency mind you and I regret not joining a union. We also had an option to take out of our paycheck a monthly fee for legal advice and retainers. I got that option just cause I thought it was a nice security I really don't know why I would need it. It turns out these retainers cannot help you legally against your boss or company btw.
- wmil 11y agoI actually think the worst bad habit of unions is taking over managerial functions -- eg scheduling, vacations. It effectively turns the union into a subcontractor, and employees start needing a union to protect them from the union.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThis actually happened to us. We were unionized by the government, and they've taken over our vacation, fitness, and various other gift benefits, which they are slowly taking away from us (vacation just got nipped). Otherwise, they just take money from our paycheck and do nothing useful. I personally think something dodgy is going on, but you don't argue with the government.
- astazangasta 11y agoHow can you be unionized by the government? That seems like a contradiction in terms to me...
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoMy world is full of contradictions. Well, the Chinese communist party, which is basically the government. All of us are supposed to be a part of a union; they let foreign tech companies slide for awhile but closed that loophole a couple of years ago. It is a trade union, but will "work closely with management to resolve any problems in a harmonious way." So not really what you would expect from a union in the west.
- palmer_eldritch 11y ago> So not really what you would expect from a union in the west Oh, you know, these days in the West, the big unions are more partners with the governments/employers than they are on the side of the workers. Many unions have become tools that exists only to perpetuate their own existence, instead of being tools for workers to organize and collectively defend their interests against those of their employers and governments.
- crdoconnor 11y agoIt's a union busting strategy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_union#China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_union#China
- omouse 11y agoThat's the biggest problem; when your union caves into the government/corps demands then you get screwed and yet you're still forced to pay union dues and be a member of that union. All the major unions in Ontario (Canada) actually maintained a wage freeze and gave up some benefits and vacation because of financial issues in the government; the only unions that had wage increases were the police unions. On the other hand, my buddy who's a construction worker gets a decent wage and great benefits because of his union. The last time their union leaders tried to screw things up for them, the union workers went on strike against that leader. >Otherwise, they just take money from our paycheck and do nothing useful Yep, that's par for the course for most governments whether they're liberal or conservative :)
- kelukelugames 11y agoJust want to point out it's not a feeling. It's a fact that HR is there for the company and not you.
- johnward 11y ago"I feel like company HR aren't there for you" That's because HR literally exists to protect the company from you. You don't report serious issues to HR. You hire a lawyer.
- hwstar 11y agoGood luck with that unless California AB 465 passes and is signed by governor Brown and upheld in federal court. (Note: There is some concern AB 465 might not survive a federal court challenge as it might conflict with the Federal Arbitration Act). Most employers make binding arbitration a necessary condition of employment. Binding arbitration makes it almost impossible to win a case against an employer.
- kelukelugames 11y agoBinding arbitration is not so binding especially in cases that violate federal law related to the EEOC or NLRB. I am in the middle of writing a post about this. Will share when done. I think HN really needs to learn employee rights.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I feel like company HR aren't there for you but for the company and unions are there for you. HR is paid by management to manage -- that is, assure that the company can get the most out of for the least cost -- the "human resources" of the company. Unions are paid by their members to assure that those members can get the most out of their employers for the least cost. From the employees point of view, it is quite literally true that HR is not there for you whereas unions are (or, more accurately, the union you are a member of, if any, is) there for you. > We also had an option to take out of our paycheck a monthly fee for legal advice and retainers. I got that option just cause I thought it was a nice security I really don't know why I would need it. It turns out these retainers cannot help you legally against your boss or company btw. Yeah, employer-arranged group legal services plans never cover any scenario where you are against your employer; they are something the company arranges so that employers can be less distracted from serving the company's interest by outside legal matters.
- rancur 11y agoI think if we could externalize the benefits of unions such that they don't protect the willfully lazy and don't hinder the brilliant, that might be the best of both worlds.
- philwelch 11y agoBut, like crdoconnor says, unions are an exercise in democracy--and the majority of the workforce are not brilliant.
- bpodgursky 11y agoEveryone loses union dues. High performers lose high compensation relative to the mean engineer. There are plenty more arguable things you can say engineers lose (stock option value with lost company competitiveness, etc) but I'm not going to bother with those. The top two are not arguable, which is enough to invalidate a simplistic clickbait title.
- fweespeech 11y agohttps://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage-fixing-cartel-involved-dozens-more-companies-over-one-million-employees/ https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage... Unions can fight this alot more effectively than engineers can. The simple fact is the large companies willingly and with full knowledge of the illegality, abuse their position, even when it comes to software engineers. Pretending you are protected when you can't afford a 6 figure lawsuit, isn't really true.
- bpodgursky 11y agoHow does this address either of my points? I do not want to get in a wider debate about unionization, I am stating that the title is clickbait and obviously false.
- fweespeech 11y ago"Losing" union dues and receiving legal protection in return that likely won't take anywhere near as long to resolve as that court case did isn't "losing" given we know for a fact that these companies are willing to abuse their position to the point of engaging in illegal activity. We pay the police too, is that really "losing"? Similarly, "high performers" aren't immune as they are the ones most affected since the various companies are going to try to recruit them from the others the most. A union that provides legal representation and a standardized process for appealing various issues that are clearly illegal [e.g. The link I posted] before it goes to court is possible without you having to negotiate specific salary tiers and the like.
- hiou 11y ago
- gadders 11y agoAre we supposed to flag this because MichaelOChurch the user id got banned? Not bothered either way, but wondered what the policy was.
- minimaxir 11y agomichaelochurch is not hellbanned: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=michaelochurch https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=michaelochurch EDIT: Didn't see dang's comment. So I'm not sure.
- gadders 11y agoI'm getting downvoted for even asking the question. Awesome.
- polarix 11y agoThat's really bad news if true. His perspective is crucial.
- eropple 11y agoHe earned it. I consider Michael an internet-friend, but I don't think that's defensible.
- michaelochurch2 11y agoOh for fuck's sake. The word "queynte" is probably related to the word "cunt" (and the word "quaint") but it's a different word. It doesn't even mean "vagina" although it was euphemistically used that way in and after the time of Chaucer. I could have just as easily used "assclown" or "taint-smear" or just "jerk", but, really, this stuff is just a distraction. Dan G's personal tantrums and high-horse nonsense aside, the fact is that if you take Google's evil stack-ranking system to another company, you're a horrible person. When people are literally destroying lives by the hundreds for their own malicious, personal amusement, the only thing that matters is stopping them-- not what people choose to call them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- appleflaxen 11y agoWhen I was in a unionized position, it was frustrating because I couldn't choose to not join (technically I guess I could, but the union and the employer had already agreed that non-union employees still paid 90+% of union dues to the union. why this is legal I have no idea). Anyway, the union (which I became part of because, hey, 10% difference) really didn't help me. They were an entity with lots of institutional power, but they all had their own agenda. It's not like they really had my best interests at heart. It just became one more level of power to answer to. It was really frustrating, and I was happy when I was able to leave.
- INTPenis 11y agoThat is terrible to hear because I am very pro-unions. I'm not sure I understand everything you said but I assume you're trying to say that employees who are not even members pay dues to the union from their salary. I don't understand this at all and this is not how we operate in sweden. So that's one major issue with policy in your country. I don't understand what you mean by 10% difference. The union does have a lot of power but in my experience most of it is used to negotiate salary raises every year and to advise members who need help with negotiating or general queries. So I've never felt that the union is another power I have to answer to in any way. The only way I can imagine them giving the impression of being "in the way" would be that the reason salary raises are delayed most years are due to the union negotiations. That hardly matters though as everyone still gets their salary raise retroactively, regardless of when the negotiations end. With most companies being connected to some sort of collective bargaining deal here, there's really not much reason to join a union. I am a member partly due to ideological reasons and partly due to the fact that managers still fear the unions here and I think that's how it should be. Without tuting my own horn, I've been a model employee for my It-career so far so I haven't had any need for the union. But should I ever lose my job, or need to enter into any difficult negotiating with my manager, I know they will help me. Because they've helped co-workers and other people around the country in good ways before.
- knodi123 11y ago> I don't understand what you mean by 10% difference. He's saying that there are union dues that union members pay, and NON-union employees still pay union dues, but 10% less.
- Kurtz79 11y agoUnions historically were organized by people that were individually very replaceable, could not find easily another job if fired, had limited education and means to fight for their rights and improve their condition. For this reasons ther employers could force upon them punishing work conditions and contracts, and unions allowed workers to leverage their number electing representatives that could organize them and would be better suited to negotiate with the employers. I fail to see any connection with engineers which can easily move between jobs, command decent salaries and benefits and are more than able to negotiate better conditons individually with their employers. Maybe a more suitable organization would resemble the medieval artisan and merchant guilds...
- crdoconnor 11y agoExplain why writers and actors are so different to engineers. Did Ronald Reagan fit your description? He was a union president.
- Kurtz79 11y ago"In 1925, the Masquers Club was formed by actors discontent with the grueling work hours at the Hollywood studios.[6] This was one of the major concerns which led to the creation of the Screen Actors Guild in 1933." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screen_Actors_Guild https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screen_Actors_Guild EDIT: I'm pretty sure that if "grueling work hours" and low salaries were enforced by employers to engineers there would be grounds to create a union.
- fweespeech 11y agohttps://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage-fixing-cartel-involved-dozens-more-companies-over-one-million-employees/ https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage... I mean, I guess, if you think you'll always be able to get lawyers to take cases like this on spec you have a point. I don't really think that is the case. We need a legal defense to deal with bullshit like this and a union is an effective way to get it.
- jberryman 11y ago
- oldmanjay 11y agounions are great when people want a paycheck but don't want the need to perform to be a part of the equation. I can see why that's tempting for a certain mindset, but it's a clear loser in every way except tickling those populist "worker" nerves so many seem to have.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoYeah, SAG has really stopped actors from performing. George Clooney just sits on his ass all day running out the clock until he can collect his paycheck. /s
- maxerickson 11y agoThey do! http://www.wikihow.com/Get-a-SAG-Card http://www.wikihow.com/Get-a-SAG-Card I mean, they don't stop SAG members from performing, but they do keep non members out of SAG shoots.
- conanbatt 11y agoI can't speak much for unions in the US, but in Argentina, unions eliminated child labor, introduced paid time off and reduced working hours from 90 to 40-50hs a week. When they protested for these things we consider today to be only reasonable, the conservative power at the time repressed public manifestations killing dozens of protesters. In the US, union leaders were forced to make a sworn statement regarding their political inclinations. Unions in the US are viewed very negatively, but as a political institution, it does solve some issues. I don't think a world without unions is a better world, though I wish they behaved more transparently than they do.
- steven777400 11y agoWe have a union for IT workers (including developers) at my workplace. I was only recently allowed to leave it as a result of becoming a supervisor. In my opinion, the union was manipulative and not beneficial to employee outcomes. They were first and foremost politicians who used union funds to support various unrelated political objectives and didn't really offer any substantive help or improvement with salary/benefits. After I left (completely in accordance with procedure and my position), the union sent me a threatening letter demanding that I continue sending them dues. As a very "left leaning" person politically, I'm totally pro-labor, but unions often only pay lip service to the employees they are supposed to benefit.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>We have a union for IT workers (including developers) at my workplace. I was only recently allowed to leave it as a result of becoming a supervisor. If you exit the union but still work at the company you're free riding on the higher benefits and wages negotiated by the union your coworkers paid for. If you really don't like unions that much you can leave and go work for a company that isn't unionized. It isn't like there's a shortage of them.
- netcan 11y agoThis is an incredibly arrogant argument for a union to be making. If a union gains membership by forcing employees to be union members, its claim to be legitimately representing employees becomes very weak, IMO. Closed shop tactics are ways for unions to gain power, often at the expense of labour. Also, once its place a union doesn't need to do much to win members. The incentives are all wrong. These things collapsed all over the world for a reason. The cheek of believing they "own" these benefits and should be payed by anyone who wants this job.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>This is an incredibly arrogant argument for a union to be making. If a union gains membership by forcing employees to be union members Workers vote to decide on whether to unionize. If you don't like the outcome of the vote, you can quit and go work for a non-union company. >its claim to be legitimately representing employees becomes very weak, IMO. You must hate democracy. >Closed shop tactics are ways for unions to gain power, often at the expense of labour No, closed shop tactics are a way for unions to gain power so that they can better represent labor. It prevents management from using divide and conquer against the workforce (their primary strategy). >These things collapsed all over the world for a reason. Because there has been a vicious campaign against them for decades. This is why wages are stagnant and profits are skyrocketing and the 0.01% own all the wealth.
- asuffield 11y agoI'm an engineer at Google. This article's description of stack ranking and perf is fundamentally and completely wrong. There is no stack ranking for perf ratings, there is no percentage of people that have to fail, and managers are not allowed or empowered to give people poor perf ratings in the way described here. I have no comment on the stuff about unions.
- winstonewert 11y agoAs another Google engineer, I have to concur. The author has no idea what he is talking about with respect to what happens at Google.
- michaelochurch2 11y agoMy information is as of 2011. When I was there, the percentage who had to fail fluctuated between 3 and 5 percent, based on market conditions, but I'd heard that it was higher than 5% in 2008-- a dishonest layoff under the guise of a "low performer initiative". I know next to nothing about what Perf is like as of 2015; my insights are 4 years out of date. I must ask, though: do they still call people assigned sub-3.0 scores "pillow biters"? Or did HR put the kibosh on that term-of-art? Personally, I hope it lives on; it means that Google management is being honest about how it views people.
- kami8845 11y agoAt this point I feel it'd be fair to make heavy revisions to the blog post. One must think, if you really were the expert you position yourself to be, you should've been able to talk to at least ONE person working in a BIG4 before putting your name underneath it all?
- Sven7 11y agoCome on. Google doesn't need to unionize cause they are the chosen ones made of special star dust. They believe what IBM employees at their hey day believed - in rainbows and ponies. And then what happened?
- asuffield 11y ago
- meesles 11y agoCan someone explain a bit more the actual current problem? I like to think that in our field of work, we prove ourselves by our abilities and nothing else. I feel like unions are first a way for the less competent to kind of hang in there and not have to try harder. I can see how it's a bit cut-throat currently, but if I'm protected then what do I have to gain by improving my skills? When I think of the industries that are heavily unionized, I picture demoralized workers with union leaders replacing their actual bosses and forcing the group to go along with things they would never find reasonable individually. Personally, not a fan of the article. Also this line: and nothing will be done about it so long as most software engineers remain apolitical cowards who refuse to fight for themselves.. Thanks...?
- RodericDay 11y ago> I like to think that in our field of work, we prove ourselves by our abilities and nothing else. How certain are you that the best developer you know is also the best paid? Is "being good at interviews/charming management" an ability that you consider important? How about "being well-connected"? Unions would not fix this. Badly run, they would swap charm for seniority. Well run, however, they would tackle the objective economic fact that in a negotiation between one human and an institution, there are information and resource asymmetries, which the larger entity will exploit to their advantage, and it would even the playing field a whole lot. Avoid fixating on silver bullets and try to think of the many ways in which the dynamics would change. I think unions would be a net positive for most developers, including tons of excellent performers without much mind for business who get taken advantage of by both management and slick-talking peers.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Unions would not fix this. Badly run, they would swap charm for seniority. The reason why unions often settle on age/experience as a way to measure seniority is because it's objective so it makes a decent compromise. If you leave it up to management they will usually end up rewarding/promoting those who pledge fealty to them over those who are more skilled, and union sympathizers will be singled out and punished no matter how skilled or productive.
- yarper 11y agoAside from labour issues and collective bargaining over employees getting "shafted", unions are the first to pick up unsafe working practices. As software and tech in general ingrains itself into society the risk of deadly mistakes becomes ever greater - people already die due to bugs, and we can't remove the possibility entirely but we should be damn sure when the finger is pointed at our profession that we've got it covered. The free market typically doesn't cause this kind of enlightenment.
- bmmayer1 11y agoUnionization is part of the free market, provided that it happens without compelled membership or coercion.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Aside from labour issues and collective bargaining over employees getting "shafted", unions are the first to pick up unsafe working practices. No, the opposite is true. http://inthesetimes.com/working/entry/5813/fatalities_higher_at_non-union_mineslike_masseys_upper_big_branch http://inthesetimes.com/working/entry/5813/fatalities_higher...
- yarper 11y agoThis is not evidence that unions make labour more dangerous. The last paragraph even in your link is this; "Tougher enforcement of laws, with higher penalties, and stronger safety standards are essential. But unionized miners have the power to enforce those standards before there's an accident, and they can prevent the speed-ups, overwork, and shortcuts that are common in non-union mines, like Upper Big Branch, and that contribute to the dangers of the job. If Congress and Obama want to do something to save miners' lives, they should first of all protect and strengthen their right to organize."
- crdoconnor 11y ago>This is not evidence that unions make labour more dangerous. No, it's evidence that unions help make laborers safer.
- outside1234 11y agoIn Germany they have this alternative structure called the work council. My understanding of it (I had 2-3 workers in Germany 5 years ago) was that it was essentially a union, but only the "good parts". They spoke up around things like stack ranking (and could vote it down) and generally acted as the "employee's HR". Everyone in the council also had to be an employee so you didn't have the overhead (or mob influences) of a traditional "pay in" union scheme. Anyone here from Germany that can describe it more and talk about what you like / dislike about this system?
- Sven7 11y agoAlso would like to hear from the Germans how their software billionaires think of unions? With unions I find it hard to imagine being able to gift 30 billion dollars to future Mark Zuckerbergs or Bill Gates.
- dennisgorelik 11y agoStep 1: Unionize software companies. Step 2: Turn Silicon Valley into Detroit.
- 6t6t6 11y agoThis kind of hate that Americans have for unions is something I will never understand. Unions have clear purpose: help the workers negotiate with the company with equal opportunities and prevent abuse from the employer. Companies have power, money and lawyers and, usually, a worker has none of those; so, if one day the worker has a conflict with the company, the Union will be there to assist the worker. I've been working in a couple of companies that had a Union (in Europe, not USA) and it has been always a good experience. The guys in the Union knew quite well how law works in the country and helped the employer to always keep a relationship between the employer and the employee according to the law. Unpaid overtime? Mmmm... it's not going to happen. Firing someone just because the manager doesn't like him? Nahhh.... Abusive boss? Mmm... Lets talk with him about the consequences of a Lawsuit for Bullying. Of course, if an employee did something really wrong, there was not much the Union could do for him. But the main thing is that the employee is always in inferiority when dealing with the employer, and the Unions are there to solve that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mtimjones 11y agoUnions at one time were necessary, but are now nothing more than a funds-sucking entity that promotes a single political party.