7 ms·
The Intercept: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/08/03/life-unmasking-british-eavesdroppers/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/08/03/life-unmasking.
by mirimir 11y ago
The Intercept: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/08/03/life-unmasking-british-eavesdroppers/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2015/08/03/life-unmasking...
There's lots of 1998-2001 stuff on cryptome.org :)
Total TFH then. Now, not so much :(
- happyscrappy 11y agoImagine what actually goes on now.
- mirimir 11y agoThey intercept just about everything, for sure. And they apparently do a decent job at triage. But the false positive paradox is still problematic.[0] Epidemiology is a bitch ;) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_positive_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_positive_paradox
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoI think it's more interesting to wonder how it's possible for the US to be surprised by movements like ISIS or by random shooters when surveillance is supposed to be total. Obviously there are many ways in which information can be lost between source and policy. But it's still strange that some events appear to be a complete surprise. If Snowden and Campbell are correct, they really shouldn't be.
- e12e 11y agoThere's the possibility that total electronic surveillance is real and that it's no good at countering the kind of threats it supposedly is used against. If you want conspiracy, consider this: what impact did the #occupy movement have on the world order? That certainly was more dangerous to the establishment than someone scaring the population with terror attacks. Or if you believe the official story: who are all the people assassinated with extra-legal (from an international law perspective, anyway) drone strikes in Yemen? Are they enemies of the US?
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> what impact did the #occupy movement have on the world order? Exactly none? People just shouted for a while, maybe burned a few cars, and then they got bored with it. Terror attack on the other hand tend to scare the living shit and every remaining ounce of rational thought out of people. People worldwide supported two wars over 9/11.
- jacquesm 11y agoMass surveillance may simply be less useful. There are people that use the fact that 'it works' as an argument pro-surveillance. I don't agree with that argument but it gets used quite frequently. Now imagine how bad it would be if all this mass surveillance went on and it wasn't even effective. That's no way to get a bigger budget next year. So Snowden and Campbell are likely correct and those that argue that 'it works' could very well be wrong at the same time.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt may be total, but there aren't enough resources to process absolutely everything. I'll grant you ISIS, but random shooters? That's hardly a national security threat. When you're running a secret surveillance program you probably don't want to go and tell police about every planned murder you discovered, because at some point people will start asking questions about how you know the things you do (or some Joe Random Officer will decide to disclose your program for a 5 minutes of fame in a late night show interview). I guess it does work, but they prioritize the threats (possibly still missing some important ones).
- a3n 11y agoThere are two problems with ISIS and surprise: 1. The internet is not (in my guess) as ubiquitous in the Middle East as it is in more developed societies. If you want to monitor everyone in that environment, you're limited to Stasi style personal informants. 2. As information flows up to policy makers, it's transformed, shaded or obscured to fit the world views and agendas of the agencies and individuals "analyzing ans summarizing" it and passing it up. Total Information Awareness is not for policy makers, it's for spies and law enforcement.
- mirimir 11y agoThat may well reflect the false positive paradox. Let's say that the US has total surveillance. When they're interested in rare events, they'll be overwhelmed by false positives, unless the rate of false positives is very low. And so they need to check out all of the hits, and that takes time.
- api 11y agoTime seems to have had a way of vindicating at least some tin foil hatters, yet people today are just as ready to dismiss as 'crazy conspiracy theory' any similar extrapolations or speculations. If you strip off the really genuinely nutty stuff, quite a bit of what I remember reading nutters talk about on places like Usenet alt.conspiracy in the 1990s is now reality. Some of what's now reality would have made them blush. The conspiranoids would have called you crazy if you'd suggested that everyone would be carrying devices that constantly report their location at all times to central servers owned by closely state-connected corporations -- and that people would accept this willingly and even pay out of pocket for these devices themselves.
- pdkl95 11y ago> dismiss as 'crazy conspiracy theory' This is simply a current example of the political strategy known as the paranoid style. Just like the fear about "reds" in McCarthyism and various right-wing groups that used racial fears for political gain, there has been a very succcessful application of the paranoid style against the very idea of investigating the intelligence community. If you (or anybody else) haven't read it, I suggest reading the original essay[1] on the subject. It may be over 50 year old, but it is probably one of the more important essays for understanding the modern (~post-WW2) American politics and how "conspiracy theory" has been used as a way of rallying people against "the enemy". [1] http://harpers.org/archive/1964/11/the-paranoid-style-in-american-politics/ http://harpers.org/archive/1964/11/the-paranoid-style-in-ame...
- tedunangst 11y ago> If you strip off the really genuinely nutty stuff, quite a bit of what I remember reading nutters talk about on places like Usenet alt.conspiracy in the 1990s is now reality. well, yeah. if you ignore all the crazy, what's left isn't crazy. why is that surprising? > The conspiranoids would have called you crazy if you'd suggested that everyone would be carrying devices that constantly report their location at all times would they? that seems like a pretty obvious consequence of carrying a cell phone. maybe my recollection is different, but i don't think people were saying "the government reads your email" was a crazy idea. they were saying "the government reads your email on their secret moon base staffed by hitler clones" was a crazy idea. if you want to make the argument that the hatters were right all along but were wrongly dismissed, find a specific claim that was made, and a specific counterclaim. these "right all along" discussions always slide into unfalsifiable generalities and strawmen.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI'm very reluctant to dismiss anything as tinfoilhattery nowadays. I always thought that people afraid of "chemtrails" are paranoid and believe obviously silly stories. Because why would anyone do that? And then very recently, on HN of all places, I learned that US Government did in fact spray bacteria on their own civilians for biowarfare research purposes, without the public knowing for decades. It's getting harder to distinguish the crazy from the truth. I still don't believe in faked Moon landing though.