61 ms·
"Top male fighters are wary of facing her." First of all, that's false. Top male fighters, in an actual match, would injure her. It would not be entertaining,
by adventured 11y ago
"Top male fighters are wary of facing her."
First of all, that's false. Top male fighters, in an actual match, would injure her. It would not be entertaining, it would be almost disgustingly brutal. One need look no further than what Cristiane Justino - using performance enhancing drugs - did to her opponents, to understand. Pound for pound, top male fighters are going to be between 50% and 100% stronger than Ronda.
I'm curious when this fantasy is going to stop being promoted? It seems to commonly be in every thread about her, across every site.
Even more interesting, is to analyze the origins of it, why it exists, and why people feel the need to keep it going. I can't decide if it's mostly fetish (a male fantasy of being dominated physically), or something else entirely.
- jhou2 11y agoShe routinely wins against male fighters in her training studio. Pound for pound, she wins regardless of her gender and perceived weakness.
- adventured 11y agoThe article said: top male fighters. She does not routinely win against top male fighters. And if you watch the YouTube videos of what you're talking about, her training sessions against men, they are not going full-steam against her, and they almost always have very sizable weight advantages - which is rule #1 of what you never do in fighting (and why Ronda hasn't yet fought Cyborg). In the case of Ronda vs Cyborg, you're talking a few pounds of difference, and she refuses to fight due to that gap - so you're trying to tell me she's having no problem against guys 30 and 40 pounds heavier in training (fails the logic test right off). Pound for pound she does not win regardless.
- ridruejo 11y ago"and she refuses to fight due to that gap" Err ... if you want to challenge the champion, you go down to her weight, not the other way around.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoBoth Rousey and Cyborg are champions, of bantamweight and featherweight respectively. There is no rule that one must go down in weight classes; Pacquiao, for example, went up.
- cgh 11y agoCris Cyborg is not the featherweight champion of the UFC because there is no featherweight division in the UFC. Rousey fights in the UFC. If Cyborg wants to fight Rousey, she has to come down in weight, leave Invicta and join the UFC.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAm I wrong in believing that she became the champion after beating Carano? It sounds like there are more details to MMA leagues than I'm aware of.
- jk215 11y agoCorrect. She beat Carano and eventually the league (Strikeforce) went out of business and got bought by the UFC. The UFC absorbed all fighter contracts. There is no 145 womens division so she had to cut to 135 or leave. She decided to leave. Now she is the 145 champion of Invicta (an all womens league) that is basically owned by the UFC now as well. If shes smart and wants a massive payday she will cut to 135 for the Rousey fight.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoThey're both champions actually, and it's more common for a fighter to go up than come down. Like say in boxing, the most powerful boxer in the entire sport right now, Mayweather, who'd been an undefeated world champ for almost two decades and the biggest star and earner in boxing, moved from welterweight to super welterweight to make the fight against Canelo. For Canelo to come down to welterweight would've been ridiculous and it'd never have happened. A catchweight fight could be reasonably expected in this situation, but coming down an entire division is very, very uncommon. The weird thing is that MMA doesn't seem to have a division in between theirs. For example in boxing you have lightweight which is 135, then you have super lightweight at 140, and then welterweight at 147. But Ronda fights at 135, and Cyborg fights at 145, there's no 140 in between. A catchweight fight at 140 makes a lot of sense, I think, coming down 10 pounds is crazy. Going up 10 pounds is also a lot, although we mustn't forget Ronda competed in the olympics (a much tougher competition in the sport she dedicated a much bigger part of her life to) at 154 pounds, so this notion 145 is suddenly too much, and that Cyborg just has to come down to 135 is pretty silly but whatever. It's not uncommon to compete at a lower weight than the olympics, but 20 pounds is a gigantic difference and it says she could easily go 10 pounds back up. And for a catchweight bout it'd only have to be 5. If that doesn't happen I think it's clear who doesn't want to take the fight. (Ronda)
- petegrif 11y agoI don't believe this for a second. Sparring is VERY different from fighting and those guys are taking it easy on her. This kind of thing is great for marketing to fans who don't know the sport but it's a fantasy.
- flipmonk 11y agoThis assumes your 50-100% estimate is correct. A figure which is the result of your bias that people are challenging.
- adventured 11y agoSo your theory is that men are not almost always substantially stronger than women pound for pound? It's not a bias, it's extremely well understood human physiology. Men and women are in fact very different in the strength department, men are vastly stronger.
- michaelchisari 11y agoThe problem with saying "men are stronger than women" is that we're not dealing with men and women, we're dealing with a specific woman, and a potential specific man. This is not about the aggregate, it's about the specific. I would put Rhonda's ground game up against plenty of bantamweight men. Striking is a different story, of course, but god help any fighter that hesitates and lets her attach on to anything. Watch her spar with Uriah Hall, and how easily she takes down an extremely athletic man with a 50 pound advantage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yYZfeDm_Ig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yYZfeDm_Ig I don't think this fight would ever happen, but dismissing Rhonda Rouseys potential with biological hand-waving is an insult to everything she's accomplished. And I'm saying this as someone who doesn't even particularly like her.
- mod 11y agoIn other cases, when talking about specific individuals--in particular, Olympic weightlifting record-holders--the gender difference is still very obvious.
- michaelchisari 11y agoMMA is extremely multi-faceted compared to weightlifting. There's a reason the Gracies dominated the sport for so long, and it had nothing to do with any kind of extraordinary upper body strength.
- balls187 11y agoI don't think TJ Dillawshaw (current Men's Bantamweight champ) vs Ronda Rousey would be a decisive victory for TJ. That said, the comparison is made, simply because there aren't any Women to compare Rousey too. In our need to classify how good Ronda Rousey is, we want to now compare her globally. Ronda has said herself she does not want to fight men. I concur with her, it's bad for the sport, and she has nothing to gain from it.
- zarkov99 11y agoTJ would beat her senseless and in very short order. Ronda is a fantastic athlete, surely the most dominant fighter we have ever seen, but she would be slower, weaker and vastly inferior in striking and wrestling technique. She would have absolutely no chance.
- JeremyBanks 11y agoIf Ronda tries to stand and fight TJ, like she fought last night, he would defeat her extremely quickly. Compare their movement and footwork in recent fights -- it's not remotely comparable. It might not be quite as one-sided if she can bring it to the ground, but I'd still expect his strength to dominate before long. It's disappointing that we'll probably never see Ronda realize her full potential because she doesn't face enough competitive pressure.
- anon8418 11y agoWith all due respect, but you have no idea what you're talking about. TJ would absolutely murder Ronda. There's been plenty of discussion about this on Sherdog and /r/mma... and even some historical precedent. I recall seeing a video awhile back of a then female undefeated kickboxing champion vs a journeyman fighter and while the female fighter showed more speed and skill, the physical advantage made the fight extremely lopsided.
- martin1975 11y ago> I don't think TJ Dillawshaw (current Men's Bantamweight > champ) vs Ronda Rousey would be a decisive victory for TJ. It won't be decisive. It would amount to an assassination. I'll let you figure out who would kill who.
- bmelton 11y agoTop male fighters are likely, actually wary of facing her for the same reason as they would be wary of facing a Royce Gracie. Much of her style negates much of their advantage, and despite everybody knowing full well that she's probably going to win with an armbar, it seems that nobody's yet figured out a way of preventing her from landing the armbar that they all know to look out for. That most of her wins are obvious, and still unpreventable is what makes her scary, and there are indeed plenty of guys she could beat in the octagon. On the whole, I definitely agree that many of those guys are probably paying her lip service, and that the level of challenge goes up incredibly when facing guys, especially those above Featherweight, but to be fair to her, I actually like her chances against much of the field in fly and bantamweights, minus those at the very top, perhaps.
- mcantelon 11y agoRousey won't fight Fox Fallon, a transgender female MMA fight who went through puberty as a man, so Rousey herself recognizes men have a biological advantage in the sport.
- pyre 11y ago> went through puberty as a man > men have a biological advantage I'm curious what biological advantage going through puberty as a male imparts that going through HRT doesn't take away.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoOur bodies are a hell of a lot more complicated than just adding some hormones here and blocking some hormones there.
- pyre 11y agoThat may be, but at the same time I would think there are only a limited amount of things that would affect your performance in the ring, at least to a significant effect.
- tbrownaw 11y ago"Top male fighters are wary of facing her." First of all, that's false. Gender stereotypes and attitudes being what they are, he can either look bad for beating up a girl or look bad for getting beat up by a girl. There is no good outcome. Pound for pound, top male fighters are going to be between 50% and 100% stronger than Ronda. Why? I thought the whole reason men tend to be stronger is that we're generally physically larger. As in more pounds of muscle to be strong with.
- adventured 11y agoNo, men are stronger at the exact same weight than women are, by a significant margin. I can't believe this is even an issue of debate or misunderstanding on HN. Go to any gym and watch a 5'6", 165 pound guy bench press, and then watch a woman at the same size with the same experience do so. Men can also jump higher and run faster than women at exactly the same physical measurements. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8477683 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8477683 "Strength and muscle characteristics were examined in biceps brachii and vastus lateralis of eight men and eight women. Measurements included motor unit number, size and activation and voluntary strength of the elbow flexors and knee extensors. Fiber areas and type were determined from needle biopsies and muscle areas by computerized tomographical scanning. The women were approximately 52% and 66% as strong as the men in the upper and lower body respectively. The men were also stronger relative to lean body mass." http://www.quora.com/Are-men-generally-physically-stronger-than-women http://www.quora.com/Are-men-generally-physically-stronger-t...
- balls187 11y ago> No, men are stronger at the exact same weight than women are, by a significant margin. This is indisputable. However, strength only in one factor, and there are many that contribute to the success in an MMA fight. There are also key differences in how you measure strength and how that matters in a fight. Daniel Cormier has significantly higher stats around olympic lifts, and routinely manhandles his opponents. Against former champion Jon Jones, however, Jones matched him, and was able to out wrestle the former olympian. Saying it more plainly, just because men are naturally stronger than women, doesn't mean that men are naturally better fighters.
- ridruejo 11y agoI would not be so sure or call it a fantasy. Ronda's grappling is at another level. Watch footage of her sparring with BJ Penn (the extended version). It is with the Gi and obviously not an actual MMA fight, but gives you an idea of what that looks like if she could take it to the ground early.
- Retozi 11y agoIt is a fantasy. Regarding the sparring between BJ Penn and her, it somewhat confirmed that he held back. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8TBlo3yPUM#t=51m11s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8TBlo3yPUM#t=51m11s There are various other videos of her rolling with other men (albeit bigger ones) like Mousasi and Luke Rockhold, and it is anything but competitive. I think the situation is pretty comparable to Serena Williams, who would win against most "regular" men, but not be able to provide a competitive match against roger federer.
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago> I think the situation is pretty comparable to Serena Williams, who would win against most "regular" men, but not be able to provide a competitive match against roger federer. Well what is regular? A regular professional would completely dominate her. Here's an anecdote of the only time she tried against a man. > During the 1998 Australian Open, sisters Serena and Venus Williams boasted that they could beat any man ranked outside the world's top 200. The challenge was accepted by Karsten Braasch, a German player ranked No 203 (his highest ranking was No 38). Before the matches, Braasch played a round of golf in the morning, drank a couple of beers, smoked a few cigarettes, and then played the Williams sisters for a set each, one after the other. He defeated Serena, 6-1, and Venus, 6-2. Serena said afterwards "I didn't know it would be that hard. I hit shots that would have been winners on the women's tour and he got to them easily." We're talking about two women here who ended up nr 1 players in the world (in fact Serena is the nr 1 right now, today), and were already top 10 players at that time. Of course if you mean by 'regular' to be just anyone, like me... then sure, but if you pick the average person from the street they'd lose to a 12 year old talent, let alone someone like Williams. As for Ronda, it's pretty well known men hold back when they spar her in all these videos for sure. She could absolutely trash us, but a professional male fighter wouldn't have a hard time at all, and he doesn't have to be world class. It's just the way it is and there's no shame in that. Just like there's no shame in a 10 year old losing to an adult, or a fully able-bodied beating a physically handicapped person, or a 15 year old beating the old and frail Mohammed Ali he is today, so what, there's a grand biological/physical difference there that has no basis in merit or talent or will and that is unsurmountable, nothing to be proud over for the winner and nothing to be ashamed over for the loser.
- petegrif 11y agoCorrect. It's totally false. This is true, btw, in most sports. A college tennis player would beat Serena.
- robotresearcher 11y agoSome data on elite male and female tennis matches: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Sexes_(tennis) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Sexes_(tennis) Man ranked 203 beats both Williams sisters in informal sets: http://observer.theguardian.com/osm/story/0,,543962,00.html http://observer.theguardian.com/osm/story/0,,543962,00.html
- clarkm 11y agoYep, and when the US U16 men's team scrimmaged the 2015 World Cup Champion USWNT, they won 8-0.
- bluecalm 11y agoThis is even true in mental sports like chess. Even after accounting for attendance rates the difference in strength is humongous. It seems men are just better at competitive activities although it's very unpopular position to take. It's in fact so unpopular that you can get papers claiming the opposite published despite very simple math errors in them, like this one: http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/276/1659/1161 http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/276/1659/1161 while arguing for opposite gets you shunned even if all you need to prove your point is high school level math and a rating list with attendance rates. In MMA it's not even interesting as men are way stronger, have better hand-eye coordination and way less body fat. I doubt she would have a chance again a local amateur small town champion let alone anyone competitive.
- skeesicks 11y agoI don't know if chess is a very good example since in that case there was a woman who was very clearly an outlier (as is Rousey) but able to compete against men, and reached a top ten ranking (Judit Polgár).
- zarkov99 11y agoYes, top, even middle of the road, male MMA fighters would destroy her. But the comment might be alluding to top fighters from other disciplines, specifically boxing, specifically Floyd Mayweather, who would absolutely get dominated by her.
- krick 11y agoIf it would be MMA — it's quite likely. By the arm bar, yes. If they would be boxing — Ronda would stay no chance. But then it's quite natural, you know. In the chess match between Kasparov and Mayweather, Kasparov would win as well. I guess.
- douche 11y agoMaybe not if it was chess boxing... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_boxing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_boxing
- krick 11y agoWell, if chess round is first and they play fast…
- zarkov99 11y agoYes, of course. But the difference is that Ronda would also decisively win a street fight with Maywheater - something that women are not supposed to be able to do and hence worth noting (and wonderful to see if it ever happened).
- krick 11y agoUhm, it's not like they are going to make a street fight, you know. And, by the way, street fights are quite different from MMA as well, and are done with pepper sprays, shockers, sucker punches, fingers to the eyes, teeth, bats, rocks, whatever… It really isn't for sure that an MMA champion would win a street fight against "just somebody". So, again, this argument is worth nothing and whole point is simply about marketing. As well as that "women are not supposed to be able to do" thing. I'm quite sure there are plenty of women which would take me in a fistfight, because, well, they train for that way more than I do. But if you are comparing men against women in the same sport… well, it's already discussed.
- fit2rule 11y agoI think its kind of sexist, to be honest, saying that "men are scared of her", like that is unusual or 'a thing'. Of course they're scared of her - she's a very badass fighter. But the fact that she's a woman seems to be some sort of reason for that fear - as if a strong, fierce, dominant fighter can't be female. Actually, I just think its plain sexist.
- bmelton 11y agoAs much as I am defending the notion that Rousey could beat a man with which she had a good matchup, the assertion that she could beat a top male champion is indeed far-fetched. As has been mentioned all over this thread, sexual dimorphism is a real thing, and not just something men made up to repress the lowly women. A strong, fierce, dominant fighter can absolutely be female. A strong, fierce, dominant fighter that is female and that could beat someone larger is exceedingly unlikely, and has absolutely nothing to do with sexism whatsoever.