5 ms·
This goes along with the news that Windows 10 backs up your drive encryption key by default, and that Microsoft can use it to decrypt your data. In "good faith
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
This goes along with the news that Windows 10 backs up your drive encryption key by default, and that Microsoft can use it to decrypt your data. In "good faith", of course.
- MichaelGG 11y agoFor most users, this protects them to a useful level. Most users don't think losing a password is a big deal and would be very upset to learn their data is lost because they forgot. That's an anti-feature. The number of people that'll be protected from leaving their laptop in a taxi, or home burglary, or selling/trading-in a device, or just snoopy relatives or acquaintances, etc. is large and MS absolutely made the right call here. Otherwise, you'd have "experts" giving advice to disable this feature or suffer data loss. Also, if they use OneDrive to back stuff up (like they should!), the security damage is already done as most juicy files will be unencrypted in MS's hosting and still subject to warrants.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> For most users, this protects them to a useful level. Most users don't think losing a password is a big deal and would be very upset to learn their data is lost because they forgot. That's an anti-feature. "Would you like to store a backup for your drive encryption password on Microsoft OneDrive? If you choose not to do so, and you forget your password, all of your data will be lost. [Yes/No]" And none of that warrants a ToS that says they can use that backup for anything other than helping you recover your data. > Also, if they use OneDrive to back stuff up (like they should!), the security damage is already done as most juicy files will be unencrypted in MS's hosting and still subject to warrants. Hence why client-side-encrypted backups are a good idea.
- mejari 11y ago>"Would you like to store a backup for your drive encryption password on Microsoft OneDrive? If you choose not to do so, and you forget your password, all of your data will be lost. [Yes/No]" You know when most people care about whether or not they can recover their data? It's not when someone asks them a Yes/No question, it's when they can't recover their data. And responding with "Well, remember 2 years ago when you clicked 'No'?" Doesn't really help.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoWhich is a great reason why we should be seeking better authentication systems than memorizing random passwords. Or providing people with another means of backup; for instance, provide options to both "back up via print" and "back up to USB device", in both cases providing something you could then store in a secure location.
- jeeva 11y agoWhich the Bitlocker stuff already does, when you run it manually. I suspect not with devices that come pre-encrypted - Surfaces, etc. I was going to say that the most likely thing folk have done is try to back up their key on the drive they encrypt - but last time I tried that due to not being on a network, I think the Bitlocker wizard refused to let me.
- simoncion 11y agoThen, don't make it a [Yes/No] question, make it an [Okay] with a barely noticeable "Change Advanced Settings" link; much like the dialog that the TFA complains about.
- MBCook 11y agoWhy show the non-prompt? The users who don't want it can turn it off later, as is the case now.
- simoncion 11y agoI want to encrypt my drive, but ensure that the encryption keys never leave systems that I physically control. I sure as hell don't want to encrypt my drive a second time because the default setting (that I could only change later, when I'm actually using the computer) for the drive encryption software was to upload the drive crypto key to The Cloud. Or am I misunderstanding your question?
- TillE 11y ago"Later", as in after the key is sent to Microsoft? Not very useful.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoThat's a new one on me. Bitlocker keys can be backed up to onedrive if you want, but you can also store them in a TPM or a smartcard (physical or virtual).
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSee http://thenextweb.com/microsoft/2015/07/29/wind-nos/ http://thenextweb.com/microsoft/2015/07/29/wind-nos/ ; "Windows 10 automatically encrypts the drive its installed on and generates a BitLocker recovery key. That’s backed up to your OneDrive account." Together with the ToS: "We will access, disclose and preserve personal data, including your content (such as the content of your emails, other private communications or files in private folders), when we have a good faith belief that doing so is necessary to protect our customers or enforce the terms governing the use of the services."
- the8472 11y ago> We will access, disclose and preserve personal data, including [...] files in private folders I don't see any language that restricts that to their cloud offerings. It's in the privacy statement that covers windows too. So unless i'm missing something they're granting themselves the right to disclose your harddrive to government agencies or their own legal department on a good-faith basis.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoEvery company that has access to your encryption keys can be prompted to give them up with a warrant. You can keep them from having the key. That's one way around it. Using hardware of some kind (and there are multiple.) You are also free to use another solution that might meet your strict requirements to personally review the encryption, filesystem, device driver, and memory management code of your operating system to verify it's operating to your specifications. There have literally never been so many options for the privacy minded person with the time to pour through a metric ton of C code.
- _delirium 11y agoI can see that one as a default for non-nefarious reasons. If you make it easy for non-specialist users to encrypt their machine, and there is no way for technical support to recover their data, you're going to inevitably end up with angry users. What's not as clear to me is whether you can change the default.