4 ms·
But shareholders are people who actually own the place. And if you own something, you are in charge: even if you own something collectively, and hire a manager
by golergka 11y ago
But shareholders are people who actually own the place. And if you own something, you are in charge: even if you own something collectively, and hire a manager to make immediate decisions, you have the power to [collectively] tell that manager what do you want him to do.
Abstract "business inetersts" only serve to earn money to business's owners in the end. Being a market leader is only a means to an end of making money for the owners. If the people who own the place decide, for whatever reason, that they don't need long-term development and want quick money now instead, let them be: it's their decision to make.
Now, it is possible that shareholders don't act in their true interests, and they should be thinking about long-term value instead, because that way they'll earn more money in the end. But it's them who you need to convince of that, and the argument should be structured completely differently. Blaming CEO of the company forthe fact that he does exactly what his collective bosses tell him to do, instead of thinking of abstract "business interests" (that exist just to earn money to his bosses) and employees (to whom his company is responsible only in the extents of their employment agreements) is ridiculous.
- jahnu 11y agoThere was an article recently on the BBC that shareholders there are only holding shares for an average of 6 months. Their motivations then become extremely short term. The Bank of England's chief economist has warned that this is slowing growth. http://www.bbc.com/news/business-33660426 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-33660426
- ucaetano 11y agoJust as slow and entrenched management is also slowing growth. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21642169-why-activist-investors-are-good-public-company-capitalisms-unlikely-heroes http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21642169-why-activist-... There are many ways to set up a company in a way that reduces the influence of activist investors and short-term holders. One is reducing liquidity (such as Berkshire). Another is setting up classes of shares (such as Google). Still, they only make sense when the company is profitable and paying nice dividends (or growing fast). When you IPO you're going to the market asking for money and offering growth or dividends in return. If you don't want to be subject to the conditions investors place on the capital, don't raise any and keep the company private. You can't have the cake (receive money from investors) and eat it too (not be subject to their demands).
- nindalf 11y agoGoing public is not always about raising money. Many startups are forced to go public because they have employees who want to cash in their stock. Once they become established companies, being able to offer stock options to employees is a considerable advantage.
- ucaetano 11y agoIn those cases, going public is a way to raise money to pay those employees. The company could easily buy back their shares if it had the cash available. In other words, they planned from the beginning to go public in the future as a way to pay for their current employees.
- golergka 11y agoSo, why do they have these motivations? Does this actually hurt shareholder's interests?
- simonh 11y agoExcept in practice shareholders are not a cohesive organisation capable of effectively directing the strategy of the company. That's why companies have managers. Nobody is saying that improving shareholder value is a bad thing, just that it should be sustainable and be based on genuine business fundamentals and not short termism. Think of it as consumer protection. If share values are driven up by short term financial tricks, new shareholders are being ripped off. The role of regulation here is to make sure that apropriate controls and disclosure is in place to make sure that those prospective new shareholders have the information they need to apropriately value what they are buying. Yes the onus on them is to research and understand their investment decisions, but equaly the onus is on the business and regulators to make sure it's possible for them to do obtain that information in clear and transparent way and that management incentives and corporate governanace rules are fit for purpose.
- golergka 11y ago> are not a cohesive organisation capable of effectively directing the strategy of the company They don't need to be: they just need to communicate their priorities to that manager. In this case, they communicated that they value short-term goals over long-term. > it should be sustainable and be based on genuine business fundamentals and not short termism Probably. I actually agree on that. My point is, that's shareholder's decision. And if you want to argue about that, you should talk to shareholders and explain that they decision hurt themselves. Don't talk to the manager and say that he's in the wrong, because that's not his level of responsibility. > If share values are driven up by short term financial tricks, new shareholders are being ripped off. Shareholders, by buying and selling the share values, dictate them. So, they are ripping off themselves. Again, I agree with that: but you should talk to them, not CEOs. > The role of regulation here is to make sure that apropriate controls and disclosure is in place to make sure that those prospective new shareholders have the information they need to apropriately value what they are buying. Yes the onus on them is to research and understand their investment decisions, but equaly the onus is on the business and regulators to make sure it's possible for them to do obtain that information in clear and transparent way and that management incentives and corporate governanace rules are fit for purpose. I must admit, I read the article on my phone, so I may have missed it, but did this discussion involve regulations?
- JohnTHaller 11y agoThe cult of shareholder value is all about EARNING MONEY THIS QUARTER NO MATTER WHAT AT THE EXPENSE OF ALL ELSE (including ethics, legality - at least in terms of expense for fines/lawyers, fairness, product quality, etc). In the long run, it's a destructive force of the market, but it's the way nearly all publicly-held companies go eventually. At least those that are majority owned by the public.
- venomsnake 11y agoA solution to shortermism - make sure that stock that has voting rights cannot be resold or optioned more than once per 2 years.
- golergka 11y agoIt is also a good application of single responsibility principle, which is widely regarded as a good thing in software development, because it helps build systems that are easy to worry about. You want some other values to be upholded to certain values? Create mechanisms that will translate these values to the value this component of the system is interested in. Actually, it's already done quite succesfully with regulation and fines. If you want one component of the system to care about a lot of different variables, on the other hand, that's an easy way to create an awful, bloated system where every component is supposed to take care about everything, and in the end, nothing works.
- cft 11y agoThis came from the separation of ownership from control, that happened in many American public companies in 1960s. In 2008 for example Ford did not receive bailouts, and it still has significant Ford family ownership, unlike GM (but like Toyota incidentally).
- lordnacho 11y agoSure, it's true when you own something you get to decide what to do with it. But I see the problem being a lack of optimism. You don't see what the company might do in the future, it all seems so risky. So instead of investing in new tech, you try to take what you have off the table. This has benefits to the managers: you can count dollars up front, and your business school education is basically about bean counting. Nobody will ever know that you could have made the next breakthrough. How many firms could have marketed the iPhone? Probably quite a few. (One of the best things about Steve Jobs is he didn't give up or sell Apple when they looked like they were in deep poop.) You can always claim it would have been risky because of such-and-such competitor, regulation, status quo, etc. Look at the corporate world now. They are all sitting on huge piles of cash, not knowing what to do with it. That's what a buyback is for, when you give up on thinking of new things to do, but you're happy to take credit for previous successful management's decisions. Fair enough that some businesses really are at the end of the line for whatever they do. But they can't all be. And we'll never know how much growth is slowed by bean counting: the trading of what you could have had for what you are afraid to lose.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoInvestors are quite happy to be optimistic and trust some companies to invest in the future. For example, Amazon and Facebook's share prices are not remotely justified by their cash flow. Qualcomm is just not one of the companies that investors are optimistic about. I'm curious though; if you thought Qualcomm was such a great buy before, did you buy shares? If you (and everyone else) had, that would have pushed prices up and everyone would have ignored Jana.
- tw04 11y agoShareholders only work when they both: Know what it is they own. Care about the long-term health of the company. The 401k could probably be blamed for the majority of the issues in the US. You have a chunk of your money removed from every paycheck, it goes to a magical place, and you make money that you will not see again until retirement. That's how it works for 99% of the public based on my experiences talking with friends/colleagues etc. The "magical place" is a blowhard whose sole goal is to maximize HIS profit, which means short-term gains that he can charge exorbitant fees for. The average American doesn't seem to know/care/want to know/care about where that money is going, as long as they see a positive return every quarter. And that's just bad for everyone.