7 ms·
Military exercise Black Dart to tackle nightmare drone scenario
- protomyth 11y ago"A Navy MH-60R Seahawk helicopter shot down an Outlaw surrogate threat drone with a .50-caliber gun, proving old-fashioned solutions can work fine against new-fangled threats." Why yes, bullets will destroy aircraft of many types. I get the feeling that someone building a scaled down version of the Phalanx CIWS to deal specifically with drones might get a fairly lucrative contract with the DOE.
- EvanAnderson 11y agoFor some reason I find the idea of a scaled-down Phalanx gun adorable.
- nooneelse 11y agoThe result of conditioning from playing Portal?
- EvanAnderson 11y agoPerhaps. I was right, though-- they're adorable-as-hell. http://www.steelnavy.com/CIWS.htm http://www.steelnavy.com/CIWS.htm
- SocksCanClose 11y agoI like this idea, but the challenge will be building effective ammunition (I suspect depleted uranium might not be the best option here) for frequent engagement, and minimal (read: no) collateral damage.
- marak830 11y agoId imagine a drone based short ranged flak weapon would be rather effective. Thinking about it though, i could get absolutely burried in details rrying to think of counters and counters-to-counters haha.
- protomyth 11y agoThe bigger problem would be the quick ID on the drone as opposed to a bird. You shoot down an eagle and you should expect to get hammered in the press. I would also expect some protests if you are constantly using radar.
- marak830 11y agoDamn i didnt even think of that. Radar would return differently id imagine, but then you would have people trying to match an eagles radar cross section haha.
- protomyth 11y agoI get the feeling the moving parts on a bird versus a drone could be your key identifies. After reading nogridbag's solution, I'm starting to think golf driving range nets[1] that are used to keep golf balls from flying into the road. You would need to put a top net and probably still have to have an active defense for that one drone to blow the net, the second to run into the plant situation. 1) http://www.gourock.com/golfbarrier.html http://www.gourock.com/golfbarrier.html
- nogridbag 11y agoPerhaps the birds aren't the problem, but the solution: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PzE6-WZtOi4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PzE6-WZtOi4
- protomyth 11y agoI would note that the birds did not exactly survive that encounter so you can expect some protests at your "bird swarm defense" grand opening. I would also imagine the method you use to make the birds take flight might also generate some publicity. Now, seagulls are not universally loved (quite the contrary), but I do believe you might get some pushback. It would probably work and be the cheapest solution.
- protomyth 11y agoI get the feeling you want something tough enough to take down the drone but not penetrating enough to be any danger to the concrete containment building. Thinking about it, shotgun shells should work. Flechette rounds would probably be a good choice.
- tomjen3 11y agoProbably, but I am not convinced it would work. According to their article their smallest drone category is the size of a small child. That means the crazyflie (https://www.bitcraze.io/crazyflie-2/ https://www.bitcraze.io/crazyflie-2/) is entirely outside of what they are considering. Which is too bad because it is pretty fast, computer controlled and absolutely tiny. Yes its take of weight is only 42 grams meaning you can pack about 15g of c4 on that thing and land it on somebodies head. Now I am not sure 15g is enough to do any serious damage, and I don't know if you can alter it to use frequency-hopping jamming-prof radio but I do know this: technology only gets better, faster and smaller. And it would really ruin my day if I was to hold a speech and 15g of c4 went of right over my head - especially since the attacker has a real chance of getting away with it.
- showerst 11y agoI'd bet 15g of explosives right at the rotor of a helicopter or intake of an airplane would be catastrophic.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoHow about 15g consisting of a potent toxin and a spray nozzle?
- moistgorilla 11y agoYou might as well shoot somebody if you are going to try to land a drone with c4 on their head
- tomjen3 11y agoNo, because you need line-of-sight from your position with the gun, whereas with the drone you need line of sight from the drone which, because it flies, has more options, including dropping straight down - fast and from an angle the authorities don't expect.
- nooneelse 11y agoWell this little video says it shows twice that amount, 1 oz, (https://youtu.be/AwyniA5ryhY?t=40 https://youtu.be/AwyniA5ryhY?t=40) for what that is worth. Doesn't look like something I would want going off near my head. But I would think slow/predictably moving and fixed targets are in more danger, since the attacker can get away with overloading the vehicle a bit (don't need the full flight envelope), and navigating to the target(s) becomes much easier. I'm thinking something like an stolen delivery/repairman van parked in a neighborhood, a few hours later the top opens, and out come some thermite delivering drones which fly to the top of houses and start setting the neighborhood aflame. Houses are easy to GPS target, lightly defended, and have a very high psychological impact.
- SocksCanClose 11y agoReaders of this would do well to pick up a copy of Ghost Fleet (http://www.ghostfleetbook.com http://www.ghostfleetbook.com).
- mirimir 11y agoUse small flying nats or flynks.[0] [0] Seveneves, by Neal Stephenson [http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/c2239856-f56d-11e4-bc6d-00144feab7de.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/c2239856-f56d-11e4-bc6d-00144feab7...]
- negamax 11y agoHow plausible is the scenario where dictator (or may be benevolent) low tech regimes simply end up killing all birds in secure areas..
- adventured 11y agoIt's typically far easier and cheaper to discourage them from that area. There are countless ways to do that.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThe Chinese did this in the late 50's with sparrows; they managed to bring them close to extinction in a (spectacularly failed) attempt to increase crop yields. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_Campaign
- IshKebab 11y ago> British officials are worried ISIS may try to bomb festival crowds using small drones Yeah this would be pretty bad. I'm not sure how you'd defend against this, other than relying on the fact that generally terrorists are pretty incompetent. http://primetime.unrealitytv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Glastonbury-Dolly-Parton-2.jpg http://primetime.unrealitytv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/0...
- bootload 11y ago"I'm not sure how you'd defend against this, " Jamming, RQ170 ~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid...
- IshKebab 11y agoWhat you're going to jam mobile phones and GPS at a music festival?
- Nemant 11y agoWhy even bother with this? Terrorists can just blow themselves up in a festival/concert/subway/bus anyway. In fact, you just need to leave a backpack with a pressure cooker with some nails and explosives like in Boston. No need for complicated technology and millions invested to try and counter this.
- threeseed 11y agoThere is security at festivals and concerts who do check bags. And in many busy subway/bus terminals there is manned police and lots of cameras. These are by no means significant deterrents but a drone is free to go anywhere, anytime with right now nothing to stop them.
- adventured 11y agoBecause this makes it far easier to both get away with it, and not kill yourself in the process. Today or in the near future, plant a bomb anywhere in public in a city and you're likely to end up on camera. If a terrorist can accomplish the same outcome while not killing their self (suicide), they get to keep killing; it net lowers the cost of terrorism dramatically. The biggest cost in suicide bombings directed at the developed world, is getting the bomb carrying person into location (immigration, housing), feeding the person, and the time it takes to arrange it all. Drones mean you bring one person in, and they get to take action potentially numerous times.
- bsaul 11y agoHacking the connexion from the drone to the pilot is doable, and has been done. You can take control of the drone itself and bring it back to anywhere you want. I've seen all that happen in a hackathon here in France, a few months ago. Now of course, everything's going to be easier after all drone makers have legal obligation to provide backdoors for police.
- icebraining 11y agoThere are already multiple open drone firmwares, so the legal obligation is moot. And "hacking the connection" only works if they aren't autonomous and if the commands aren't signed, which you can't assume. Of course, I'm talking about a military threat; to shut down idiots flying their Parrot AR near the airport and such, those countermeasures are certainly more than enough.
- techbio 11y ago"uses other than intended"
- clebio 11y agoI guess the nomenclature battle is lost. To me, a drone is a UAV, the key word being "autonomous". RC quadcopters and the like are "remotely operated". I suppose even the military's Predator is RO, though from a great distance. A drone ought to have some decision-making capability of its own. I wish we'd preserve the distinction, because we're very close to having consumer-grade autonomous technology to add on to RC vehicles (regardless of how many wheels or rotors they have). C.f. 3DR's Pixhawk, with features like return-to-home and "follow-me".
- jessriedel 11y agoI used to agree but I'm actually coming around. The distinction between having a pilot inside the craft and not is very discrete (not drone vs. drone) whereas the degree of autonomy is a continuous spectrum. How many craft can one operator control remotely at the same time before they each become individual drones?
- jjwiseman 11y agoThat's exactly correct: Autonomy is a spectrum. And a multirotor would fall out of the sky without at least some degree of autonomy.
- hwillis 11y agoUAV stands for unmanned aerial vehicle. Drone has never referred exclusively to autonomous vehicles.