33 ms·
How Berlin’s Futuristic Airport Became a $6B Embarrassment
- coldcode 11y agoBuilding an airport always is. Often it takes more money and a few decades to appreciate it. D/FW airport was a nightmare when it was built but it's pretty nice today. Denver's airport had tons of issues as well. Then again this seems on a much higher level of disaster, but should be familiar to anyone building large government software systems.
- hvs 11y agoDenver still has the issue that it's a 20 mile drive from downtown out of some misguided belief that the city was just going to instantly grow out to it.
- ramidarigaz 11y agoThat seems to be slooowwwwwwly improving, but honestly the biggest improvement for me will be the light rail from downtown.
- strictnein 11y agoAnd all the crazy artwork. The conspiracy theorists go nuts over it. http://mysteryoftheiniquity.com/2011/03/20/denver-international-airport-dia/ http://mysteryoftheiniquity.com/2011/03/20/denver-internatio...
- calbear81 11y agoI was really intrigued by the comment about how the Queen of England bought property near the airport which is apparently proof that the United States has never been an independent country but a pawn of good ol' England.
- Loughla 11y agoI love conspiracy theorists that see anything marked New World, and then immediately start in on how the new world order wants to kill/chip all of us. As if the existence of an elite group of puppet masters is just an established fact, and it's just the end result that the group wants that is up for debate. Delusions are terrifying.
- eric_the_read 11y agoI had no idea there were so many conspiracies about the airport, despite the fact that I fly out of it all the time. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Denver_Airport_conspiracy_theories http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Denver_Airport_conspiracy_theor... debunks several, though all it can really say about the art is, "Huh, yeah, that's weird. So what?" which isn't particularly dispositive. That demon horse scares the crap out of me, though.
- lotharbot 11y ago> "That demon horse scares the crap out of me, though" We call him "Blucifer". He killed his creator (really -- a piece of the sculpture fell on the artist's leg and severed an artery.) http://www.slate.com/blogs/atlas_obscura/2014/03/17/the_blue_mustang_is_part_of_several_conspiracy_theories_centered_on_denver.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/atlas_obscura/2014/03/17/the_blue...
- zzalpha 11y agoAt least they're finally building a light rail link to downtown Denver...
- krschultz 11y agoHonestly it's a PITA when you fly, but how often do you fly? I'd rather the airport be far from downtown than have the approach/departure routes right over populated neighborhoods. That gets really annoying really quickly.
- kjs3 11y ago> Honestly it's a PITA when you fly, but how often do you fly? I was a Delta Gold Medallion flyer for years (50k+ miles), and couple of times flirted with Platinum (75k+ miles). So...basically on a flight a couple of times a week, every week. There are large numbers of us. Denver is a pain in the ass.
- johnbeerboost 11y agoA couple of times a week? That doesn't really add up. I flew London to San Francisco and back just once a month - not several times a week - for a year and that was 130k miles.
- kjs3 11y agoAtlanta to Charlotte is about 215 miles. Atlanta to Tampa is 415. Atlanta to Denver is about 1200. Not everyone's commute is half way around the world.
- HNaTTY 11y agoFlying into Colorado Springs is a bit sketchy, there is often turbulence from the mountains when you're descending. I wouldn't be surprised if DIA being located so far east has something to do with that.
- MadManE 11y agoDIA was built so far away due to complaints of noise from the locals. The distance was intentional, however dumb.
- koenigdavidmj 11y agoWhen you build an airport near the city, it becomes impossible to expand. San Diego is a good example of this, a single-runway airport that's surrounded by the bay, I-5, the Marine Corps Recruit Depot, and a residential neighborhood. It's running near capacity and impossible to expand. There's simply nowhere to go.
- goodcanadian 11y agoTijuana! Actually, I thought it was just a proposal to link the airport with a foot bridge to the U.S., but it sounds like it is already under construction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_Border_Xpress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_Border_Xpress http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2015/feb/16/skybridge-pedestrian-tijuana-san-diego/ http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2015/feb/16/skybrid...
- peterfirefly 11y agoThey can expand into the water, adding an extra East-West strip. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Artificial_island_airports https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Artificial_island_air...
- koenigdavidmj 11y agoOrdinarily yes, but the bay might not be wide enough to fill in part of it, especially when you're trying to fit aircraft carriers through it.
- AaronIG 11y agoThat's unlikely an option due to North Island, though.
- leejoramo 11y agoDIA was also designed to be a high volume hub airport with a huge number of fights and massive expansion capacity without running into noise issues. I believe the vast majority of passengers are changing flights at DIA and never leave the airport. You can switch most flights without changing terminals.
- lotharbot 11y agoDIA was built far out specifically for noise and expansion -- with the understanding/hope that the city would never get particularly close to it. The big mistake was not connecting it to the city's light rail sooner.
- chadgeidel 11y agoThe road is a high-volume direct route and they are adding a rail line that goes directly to the airport. It's trivial to drive there and wouldn't be much different than if the airport was closer. Even if Denver doesn't grow to the airport, I don't see the downside of having an airport a few miles out of town.
- strictnein 11y agoNot a fan of DFW's terminal setup and roads. All that space and that tangle of off-ramps and on-ramps and bridges is the best they could do? Satellite shot: https://goo.gl/peXr25 https://goo.gl/peXr25
- vonmoltke 11y agoI think one of the key problems with the overall layout was the desire to run a toll road that connects TX-183 to the northern highways through the airport, and to use this road as the two entrances. They still could have designed the individual terminal layouts better though, as the road and garage layout of Terminal D shows.
- mturmon 11y agoHmm, this multi-terminal, spread-out, "park right by the gate" design reminded me of Kansas City International airport. Turns out this was a trend in airport design in the early 1970s - KCI opened in 1972 and DFW in 1973. TWA, among others, pushed this design.
- germanier 11y agoInterestingly they used a similar approach at Berlin Tegel airport, with the current terminal building opened in 1975 (which is supposed to be closed down after the airport featured here is ready).
- danvasquez29 11y agoIn my opinion Denver is a shitshow and my least favorite airport to fly into. I actively avoid layovers there.
- philfrasty 11y agoOne of the current running gags in Germany :) Simply make a reference to that airport and something that will never work and you are good to go. Edit: one of my favorite articles on that topic (German) http://www.der-postillon.com/2012/08/neue-zeitform-futur-iii-eingefuhrt-um.html http://www.der-postillon.com/2012/08/neue-zeitform-futur-iii...
- CurtHagenlocher 11y ago"At the very moment Merkel and her allies are hectoring the Greeks about their profligacy, the airport’s cost, borne by taxpayers, has tripled to €5.4 billion." So, which country does Germany want to borrow money from in order to cover the wasteful spending?
- criley2 11y agoAs with any country monetizing debt, they auction bonds to the highest bidder. The 'highest bidder' being the bidder accepting the least interest.
- c_lebesgue 11y agoGerman EUR bonds have the second lowest yields globally, with Switzerland being the leader. Also their ratings are higher than f. eg. the US bonds. So the German government does not really have to worry about borrowing money.
- gutnor 11y agoNot quite sure if it is still the case, but not so long ago Germany was borrowing money at negative interest rate.
- saalaa 11y agoNo, you got that wrong. Either their interest rates were compared to their growth, which may yield a positive return or you're mixing things up with the European Central Bank's decision to reduce the interest rate on deposits. Edit: mea culpa. Looks like you're right : http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/84a1ddc8-bce5-11e4-9902-00144feab7de.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/84a1ddc8-bce5-11e4-9902-00144feab7...
- therobot24 11y ago> "Professor, let me understand this," Loge said. "You are talking about having 800 people wearing orange vests, sitting on camping stools, holding thermoses filled with coffee, and shouting into their cell phones, 'Open the fire door'?" Loge refused the airport an operating license. Schwarz stood up and walked out without another word. Easily the best part of the article.
- troymc 11y agoI got a good chuckle out of the sentence: "Then they turned to the fire prevention system. Smoke now channels upward through chimneys, in accordance with the laws of physics."
- detaro 11y agoYeah, some politician got some "duh, stupid engineers" points out of that sentence. Completely ignoring the fact that the original design also pulled smoke down and was considered to be fine. Since these systems are active and suck the smoke out up or down doesn't matter all that much.
- chipotle_coyote 11y agoFrom the third paragraph: "Smoke evacuation canals designed to suck out smoke and replace it with fresh air failed to do either. In an actual fire, the inspectors determined, the main smoke vent might well implode." Assuming the inspectors were correct, the original design, at least as implemented, didn't work. While the "in accordance with the laws of physics" may be overly catty, a bit of searching around suggests that smoke evacuation dampers are generally placed on the ceiling, and it's not unreasonable to think that's because, well, smoke rises, isn't it?
- detaro 11y agoAFAIK the smoke was pulled in at the ceiling of the floors. And then sent downwards and vented out somewhere on the side instead of on top of the building. The original design was never tested, because the building as originally designed never existed. Each addition ordered up by Schwarz required shifting passenger flows through the terminal. That meant rebuilding walls, exits, emergency lights, ventilation systems, windows, elevators, and staircases. At one point, in 2009, outside controllers urged Schwarz and his engineering chief to shut down construction for half a year to give the architects and contractors time to coordinate efforts. That never happened, so there never was a complete design for the changed building, and the fire system wasn't properly replanned for the new situation. Which lead to issues like the collapsing pipes: They fitted stronger fans, but no-one realized that the pipes can't hold the higher pressure difference.
- nsns 11y agoBut is it only BER? As mentioned int the article - what about Stuttgart 21 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuttgart_21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuttgart_21) etc.? It is possible that these sites exist as new financial "loopholes", transferring tax-money from the government to private contractors without much oversight.
- pantalaimon 11y ago> It is possible that these sites exist as new financial "loopholes", transferring tax-money from the government to private contractors without much oversight. Yes, absolutely http://www.zeit.de/2015/29/imtech-flughafen-berlin-ber-verzoegerung http://www.zeit.de/2015/29/imtech-flughafen-berlin-ber-verzo... (article in German)
- masklinn 11y agoStuttgart 21 is mentioned in the article, as well as an unnamed concert hall in Hamburg.
- germanier 11y agoThe concert hall they refer to is the Elbphilharmonie which tripled its costs and construction time.
- this_user 11y agoCosts for the tax payer are actually more than seven times (789M EUR) the original estimate at the time construction began (114M EUR in 2007). The initial estimate in 2005 was even lower, foreseeing costs of below 100M for the tax payer with donations supposed to cover the difference.
- germanier 11y agoThanks, somehow I had the wrong number remembered.
- adrianb 11y ago
- germanier 11y agoThey seem to completely miss the story about Imtech's involvement that broke this week which sheds some lights on this catastrophe and is a tale of corruption: http://www.zeit.de/2015/29/imtech-flughafen-berlin-ber-verzoegerung/komplettansicht http://www.zeit.de/2015/29/imtech-flughafen-berlin-ber-verzo... Unfortunately I'm unable to find an English-language article on that at all. There is only this Imtech response: http://imtech.com/EN/corporate/Newsroom/Highlights/Imtech-response-to-media-attention-on-16-July-2015-about-legacy-issues.html http://imtech.com/EN/corporate/Newsroom/Highlights/Imtech-re...
- giarc 11y agoCan you provide an English summary?
- germanier 11y agoI try but don't hold me accountable for any inaccuracies. At the moment three public prosecutors independently investigate that companies practices which is rare in Germany: 1) A gigantic adventure park in Poland which was never supposed to be built 2) A cartel which allowed them to build two power plants 3) Falsification of balance sheets. Imtech is responsible for parts of the airport's construction – including the two parts which created most problems: the smoke extractor and the cabling. As the airport was close to be finished, opening date just days away, Imtech send fraudulent invoices they knew nobody would double-check. This is a practice that seems really common with such projects. Similar things happened a few years earlier: When the planning agency went bankrupt and it was known that due to regulatory changes the plans needed to be fixed they nonetheless went on to built the (now obsolete) parts – knowing they will be the company that will be called to fix it again. Additionally the work was done sloppily: Among the quoted examples were control boxes build too close together that you couldn't open their doors. What was really important for the company was that all invoices should be paid by the end of 2012 to include them in that years balance sheet – while delaying paying their workers until January. As time was running out they resorted to a bribe: In December 2012 an employee of Imtech gave an employee of the Berlin airport an envelope with 150 000 € at the side of the highway. Airport employees spend overtime during the christmas holidays so that all payments of 65 Mio. € could be processed. The article then goes on the describe the involvement of top management which indicate that this is done systematically. They also describe the two other projects from above. They also suggest that these projects look like a Ponzi scheme: A project's loss is paid by doing even crazier projects.
- bluecalm 11y agoThere is a joke in my country (Poland) about every little town needing: -an airport -an aquapark -a huge sport stadion All of them as a way to transfer some state/town money to political cronies. The sad part is that some of those make sense as an infrastructure improvement (most doesn't though, at least here) so it's easier to sell the idea to people. The way the business is done is to just pay 30%-50% more than it should cost and pocket the difference.
- raverbashing 11y agoThat's for the Amateurs, Professionals do a whole World Cup
- ubernostrum 11y agoAnd to get into the hall of fame, you do an Olympics.
- dugmartin 11y agoAnd to add a gold seal to your hall of fame certificate do an Olympics in Massachusetts.
- woobar 11y agoBrazil and Russia are going to outdo this. By hosting both World Cup and Olympics within a few years.
- raverbashing 11y agoRussia also had the Winter Olympics (and Snow when it's 10C outside is expensive)
- hkmurakami 11y agoLook no further than the $2.5 billion debacle that is the new Tokyo Olympic stadium. A rather lavish expenditure for a country that is deep in debt.
- Jean-Philipe 11y agoAs somebody from Berlin, I'm always happy when my hometown is on HN! Makes me feel proud.
- giarc 11y ago"Proud" - you read the article right?
- pantalaimon 11y agoIt's all about exposure :D
- tormeh 11y agoAll PR is good PR!
- skywritergr 11y agoThat's what i thought in the beginning of the crisis but now i'm reconsidering. (I'm Greek)
- _ak 11y agoYep, the proud feeling about Berlin's grandiose track record when it comes to corruption and incompetence in major construction projects.
- TillE 11y agoAside from the airport, I don't think Berlin is worse than any other major city. There are huge construction debacles for various reasons everywhere.
- _ak 11y agoNo, there's been a concentration of construction-related scandals with corruption, bribery, etc. in Berlin over the last 40 to 50 years.
- codeshaman 11y agoBribe the inspectors and open up on time - then somehow patch the problem later. Everyone wins. That's what they would do in a lot of places in the world. If a German airport, with a huge budget, has 150.000 defects of which 85k are serious, then what about airports in other countries, which don't make use of the world-famous german high quality standards ? What about airports in countries were things are solved with a bribe, a handshake and an evil smile ?
- slowmotiony 11y agoWorld-famous german high quality standards were a thing fifty years ago, from my experience this is often not the case any more.
- manishsharan 11y agoI am not sure what exactly you are insinuating but I would counter that more of thid world should aspire to German standards of engineering excellence rather than Germany falling to the standards of "other countries, which don't make use of the world-famous german high quality standards ".
- codeshaman 11y agoI was insinuating that airports in those countries might be tragic and dangerous.
- ghshephard 11y agoI realize that higher standards of fire and other safety measures make these systems more complicated, but you would think that with all the technology we have today for planning, engineering, communication, documentation, modeling and simulation - that these types of fiascos would become rarer and rarer. I wonder if anyone has looked at large scale projects like these over the last 100 years and determined what implications (if any) technology has had in reducing these issues.
- wlesieutre 11y agoWe have a lot of powerful software for building design these days, Autodesk's Revit suite being the big one. But as in software development, better tools just ends up meaning that clients demand things faster and cheaper, rather than better. There are some classes of problems that it definitely helps solve, like keeping the structural engineer and HVAC engineer from design conflicts where a beam and a duct go through each other. But everything needs to be done yesterday, so I'm not surprised that problems that can't be automatically identified are able to slip through. > “The people responsible for technical oversight were saying, ‘We cannot do this within this amount of time,’ and Schwarz would answer, ‘I don’t care,’ ” he says. Pretty much sums it up. EDIT: There's no excuse for the exposed high voltage wiring alongside the low voltage alarm systems though, that sounds like a contractor screwed up. I don't know the German electrical code, but generally in the US anything over 60V is classified as "class 1" wiring and it goes in a conduit. Typically this is a grounded metal tube so that you can't accidentally pound a nail through it, and if anything shorts to the conduit there's a safe path to ground until overcurrent protection trips. And if for some reason you have lower voltage "class 2" wiring running in the same conduit, those wires (and whatever else they split off to) are now considered class 1, even if they're only low current 24V signal wires or similar. They can no longer leave conduit and go anywhere else, on the off chance that it shorts to the line voltage wires it's sharing conduit with.
- mschuster91 11y agoAFAIK as long as you're only carrying a couple of 230V lines (3x1.5qmm NYM-J and friends) you're fine to use plastic tubes or tack them onto the walls, but as soon as you're mixing in non-power wiring you're required to lay them in separate tubes.
- jandrese 11y agoThis is exactly what you expect to happen when you're redesigning the building in the middle of construction. If the project manager can't say no then it's pretty much guaranteed to be a disaster. On the plus side, it seems like they've finally found someone competent to fix the mess and move the project forward.
- JimboOmega 11y agoWhat I don't quite get is that the problem keeping things from being fixed seems to be entirely related to the fire system. Meanwhile all the other issues like heavy equipment breaking tiles... none of that seems to be slowing it from opening. So how did all the other systems wind up being more or less ready?
- detaro 11y agoThe fire system was the thing that forced them to admit the delays and has gotten the biggest publicity, because failing the fire certification forbids them from doing anything except construction work. I don't think anyone had (or even has now) a clue if the other things actually were completely ready. Stuff like power lines in the wrong cable channels makes one suspect they weren't...
- venomsnake 11y agoI wonder what kind of austerity will be imposed on the poor Berliners for wasting so much money /s
- Xylakant 11y agoIt's a bit more complicated since the airport is a joint venture between Berlin, Brandenburg and the Federal Government which all hold roughly a third of the shares. And while it's an embarrassing waste of money the german constitution stipulates in Art. 109 Abs. 3 Satz 1 GG that starting 2016 the federal government cannot exceed 0.35% of the GDP in new debts and and starting 2020 the state governments are not allowed to take on new debts at all. So we'll have the austerity you're asking for soon enough.
- venomsnake 11y agoWell ... enjoy the show :( Too bad that this stupidity persists so much.
- Nacraile 11y agoFalse equivalence. Germany actually has the money it's wasting.
- pantalaimon 11y agoBerlin sure doesn't.
- neokya 11y agoUnlike Greece, Berlin is state in Germany :)
- ChrisArchitect 11y agosome discussion about this a few months ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9658581 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9658581 and this: http://istderberschonfertig.de/ http://istderberschonfertig.de/
- qwtel 11y agoBent Flyvbjerg studies these "megaprojects" and offers various explanations why a) they are being conducted in the first place despite the fact that b) they are usually any combination of over budget, behind schedule or below expectations in terms of their benefits. Here is an interview with him on EconTalk about the subject: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/05/bent_flyvbjerg.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/05/bent_flyvbjerg.html
- x0rg 11y agoThis is what happens with many software projects following crazy customers and waterfall approaches. Clearly we never speak about 6 billion, but hey, shit happens...
- philippnagel 11y agoCan you develop a big infrastructure project using agile methodologies?
- rqebmm 11y agoIT doesn't seem unreasonable to plan a project in stages, focusing on the most critical components in order, and only starting on the next once the first is ready. For instance with an airport you could build one terminal at a time. Obviously this would have limitations, but it could be a better system than trying to build a gigantic airport all at once, when it's already somewhat modular (i.e. terminals)
- rqebmm 11y agoIT doesn't seem unreasonable to plan a project in stages, focusing on the most critical components in order, and only starting on the next once the first is ready. For instance with an airport you could build one terminal at a time. Obviously this would have limitations, but it could be a better system than trying to build a gigantic airport all at once, when it's already somewhat modular (i.e. terminals)
- x0rg 11y agoI don't know anything about building an airport, but I guess you could try something. We tried to compare software to buildings for many years, maybe in a case like this the learnings from failing software projects can be somehow useful.
- kzhahou 11y agoI'm not sure there's any evidence that "agile," in any of its many forms, had a high success rate for very complex projects.
- x0rg 11y agoThis is what happens with many software projects following crazy customers and waterfall approaches. Clearly we never speak about 6 billion, but hey, shit happens...
- netcan 11y agoWhy do airports always need to be so ambitious? Usually the simple airports are best anyway.
- Kliment 11y agoThe worst thing about BER is that it's designed to replace Tegel, which is easily the most sensibly built major airport in Germany. Space-efficient, cheap to operate, high-throughput, built very quickly with limited resources to solve a specific problem.
- omnibrain 11y agoThe problem with Tegel is, that they neither built the second terminal ring nor the subway station. And there is no room for another runway.
- cmarschner 11y agoTegel has the charm of an old bus station, but efficient it is. My record was Berlin Schönhauser Allee to Munich East in 3 hours and 20 minutes. It can only get worse from there. The commute to BER alone will be at least 30-40 minutes longer.
- Kliment 11y agoWho gives a shit about "charm". Last year I had a connection that due to delays on the incoming flight left me with 8 minutes from the time we got shuttled into the terminal to the time my outgoing flight gate closed, and it wasn't even in the same terminal. I ran over to the other terminal, went through the insecurity controls, and made the flight, with several minutes of time to spare. I know of no other airport where something like that would be possible.
- RyJones 11y agoThey rarely get built, and everyone involved wants feathers for the nest.
- frik 11y agoI saw a ZDF TV docu about Berlin Airport last year. Very low-ceilinged halls and rooms means the cannot integrate gas purge and fire safety pipes and equipment. It seems so serious that an international experts in the docu suggested to rebuild parts of the airport buildings. And it seems weird that the airport will be already too small for the passenger traffic in 2017. Given that it should replace the former largest airport in the world Berlin Tempelhof and two other airports near Berlin. Several politicans have already been replaced because of scandals and multi-year delays. Shop space was already leased in ~2011 and employees already waited to begin their new work. It seems really a lot has gone wrong with BER. It would probably be cheaper to blow up the already too small buildings and build completely new ones or reactivate Tempelhof.
- schoen 11y agoWhen I last visited Berlin, I heard a joke about the airport's problems that I thought was very funny: "Niemand hat die Absicht, einen Flughafen zu errichten!" ('Nobody has the intention to build an airport!') Context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Wall#Construction_begins.2C_1961 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Wall#Construction_begin...
- mrich 11y agoThe other popular joke, after all these years and billions spent: "Let's just move Berlin to a functioning airport"
- hn9780470248775 11y agoMy favorite Berlin airport joke: "Did you hear about the new grammar reform? It includes a new tense, Futur III, to allow us to speak of the completion of Berlin/Brandenburg airport." http://www.der-postillon.com/2012/08/neue-zeitform-futur-iii-eingefuhrt-um.html http://www.der-postillon.com/2012/08/neue-zeitform-futur-iii...
- hkmurakami 11y agoI have actually heard many say the same thing about the California high speed rail project -- that it'll end up being a real estate handout after the project goes haywire midway.
- stffndtz 11y agoI am a german living in Berlin - and let me tell you, I feel deeply ashamed. Not because I am german, but because I have the impression that a lot of people involved, especially our once-so-admired former mayor Klaus Wowereit, are obsessed with money, and got caught in a swamp of corruption and were misleading the public. A year ago or so, it turned out that the folks responsible for all the mess (none of the board of course) we not to be found, because they were supporting a system were a subcontractor could hire another subcontractor and so forth, making it impossible for anyone to get a grip on what is going on. And that is not what I would expect from a billion dollar project run by some of the most trusted politicians and executives in our country. I flew home from Budapest a couple of weeks ago, and I was surprised to see that we were using the actual airstrip of BER. The flight was supposed to go to SXF (Berlin Schönefeld), but instead we landed on the new airstrip, driving by the not-yet-finished new airport. Can anyone tell me why? There's more to it though - starting with corruption [1] and going all the way to REBULDING the whole thing [2]. I'll stop here now - but I hope that there will be a lot more of critique towards those who made this a completely embarassing desaster. [sorry guys, links are in german. I'll try to find english ones] [1] http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/berlin-schoenefeld-korruption-am-flughafen-ber-die-akte-imtech/11464662.html http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/berlin-schoenefeld-korrupt... [2] http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/acht-milliarden-euro-baukosten-fuer-flughafen-ber-erwartet-12873893.html http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/acht-milliarden-euro-b...
- germanier 11y ago> I was surprised to see that we were using the actual airstrip of BER. The flight was supposed to go to SXF (Berlin Schönefeld), but instead we landed on the new airstrip, driving by the not-yet-finished new airport. Can anyone tell me why? They repurposed the south airstrip of SXF as the north airstrip of BER. As the north airstrip of SXF was dismantled for a highway this is the only remaining airstrip at SXF. For BER they built another additional one. Here's a map: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f8/Karte-_Flughafen_Berlin-Schönefeld_SXF.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f8/Karte-_F...
- stffndtz 11y ago
- wahsd 11y agoWhat people have to understand, for context, is that this project is kind of a pinnacle of failure and corruption that was born and fostered in the post-unification "reconstruction" of the formerly East German territories.
- Kenji 11y agoI don't understand why the state funds airports. If people want airports, there is a demand, and that demand is either big enough to fund an airport and is satisfied, or it isn't because people don't want to spend that kind of money. Seems to me like something the state shouldn't be involved in.
- MrBuddyCasino 11y agoThe theory that is taken out of the drawer in such occasions is that the airport will have "a positive economical impact on the whole region, so the calculation isn't that simple". Sometimes it works, but in most cases it doesn't.
- Kenji 11y agoIf "the calculation isn't that simple" how come the politicians think they can figure out the solution, but the collective hivemind of demand and offer by literally all participants of the economy cannot?
- losername 11y agoThey probably don't think that
- Retra 11y agoWhy would you believe thousands of people participating in an economy would come to a better solution than a few people making plans? About the only thing large masses of people ever seem to accomplish is throwing fuel into various metaphorical fires.
- MrBuddyCasino 11y agoEconomical advancement mean more jobs, more taxes, happier citizens. A privately controlled/financed airport doesn't care about those things, thus the mixed calculation leads to different results for state and private actors. Unfortunately, the numbers projected by the state actors are often unsound.
- 11y ago
- smhg 11y agoThis reminds me of the immer funny David Zuelke explaining the difference between "North Germany" and "South Germany" to a group of non-Germans. It was at an after-phpDay drink a few years ago. According to him, you can find the famous German Gründlichkeit in The South, with The North being the exact opposite. He used the Berlin airport as an example: "it was an endless failure". This was in 2011 or 2012. I wonder how strong opinionated South-Germans like him look at this today. I think for non-Germans the difference in Gründlichkeit is probably not noticeable :)
- leroy_masochist 11y agoThank you -- I don't speak German, and have just added Gründlichkeit to the list of German words I love. It joins Fingerspitzengefühl, Fremdschämen, Weltschmertz, Sitzpinkler, and Fernweh. I really need to learn your language.
- thomasz 11y agoI love aufheben and Zug, which both have roughly a billion meanings. Btw, you might like "The Awful German" by Mark Twain. http://usa.usembassy.de/classroom/Mark%20Twain/Mark%20Twain%20Awful%20Broschuere.pdf http://usa.usembassy.de/classroom/Mark%20Twain/Mark%20Twain%...
- orkoden 11y agoGemütlichkeit is another word to learn. If you come to Germany you can take part in any conversations just knowing genau and ach so. Genau - Exactly, I understand, I agree. Used to express agreement. Germans like to agree. Use freely in any conversation at any time. Ach so - really, I see. Can be used to express agreement, astonishment, realization, understanding, questioning depending on intonation and stress. Na - hello, how are you, hey. Can be used at any time to start or avoid a conversation.
- thomasz 11y agoBavaria is a dream come true for corrupt politicians and their cronies ("Spezlwirtschoft"), but at least there is not as much staggering incompetence. Still, I expect a major financial catastrophe if Munich ever gets the olympic games again.
- agumonkey 11y agoRidiculing Spain stillborn airports. <... and in the end Germany wins>
- mschuster91 11y agoAll I do is remembering EDDM, Munich's airport, which was finished on the day it was supposed to - and even better, they moved the entire technology of the old airport in a single night (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flughafen_M%C3%BCnchen#Inbetriebnahme https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flughafen_M%C3%BCnchen#Inbetri...).
- nomailing 11y agoGood to hear that the pirate party member Martin Delius is the head of the parliamentary committee leading the investigation. I'm wondering if we would be that informed if a member of another political party would be in charge, because one of the main programmatic points of the pirate party is transparency.
- unreal37 11y agoI love that there's 150,000 defects, 80,000 of them considered serious.
- bsimpson 11y agoI don't know how you even count that high, unless it's through extrapolation: "this nail was pounded incorrectly and there's 10 nails in a board and 1000 boards in this area, so 10,000 defects."
- jkldotio 11y agoAlso the guy who designed the smoke extractor system wasn't actually an engineer. Stern broke the story last year.[1] My German is pretty basic, but "Geschasster BER-Planer war nur technischer Zeichner ... Doch di Mauro ist kein Ingenieur, wie angenommen wurde" amounts to "Ousted BER-Planner was only a technical draftsman ... but di Mauro is not an engineer, as was thought". [1] [German] http://www.stern.de/wirtschaft/news/stern-exklusiv-geschasster-ber-planer-war-nur-technischer-zeichner-3184142.html http://www.stern.de/wirtschaft/news/stern-exklusiv-geschasst...
- a3n 11y agoGiven our various economic and political systems, is it just not possible to build something this large and complex, and have it all ready to go on the same day (whether on time or late)? I wonder if it would be better to build and contract these things in stages, in blocks of usefulness.
- anishkothari 11y agoI didn't read the article (too long and it's late) but something caught my eye. If you keep scrolling down, you hit the next article and the URL changes. How did they do that? Kudos
- manarth 11y agoIt's a HTML5/JS thing - 'pushState'. If you search for that, you'll find plenty of resources explaining it in better detail than I can.
- anishkothari 11y agoGreat, thank you!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Tomte 11y agoMy favorite feature of BER is that they have to run ghost trains through the subway tunnel underneath the airport. Because if nothing moves inside, no air circulates and they get a mold problem.
- sillygeese 11y agoIf you're in a position to hand out $5B of other people's money, do you think some people might want to bribe you to get it? What if you can only hand out $1M? Will someone still want to bribe you? -Of course, but he'll be a "smaller player" then. All public spending involves some sort of "corruption" [1] because it's always other people's money being spent, and there's always someone in charge of spending it. If you could pay $10 to get $100, wouldn't you do it? A bribe is an investment, and the tax money received in exchange is the ROI. [1] I put "corruption" in quotes because it's just the system working as intended. If the system were actually corrupted, it would somehow start working for the masses' benefit instead. Think about it. How do you benefit from someone else spending your money for you? Your money serves a means towards an end for whoever spends it, meaning he will be trying to benefit from spending it.
- forrestthewoods 11y ago"How do you benefit from someone else spending your money for you?" 1. Economy of scale 2. I can get 5% on my own but they can get 8%. If he invests my money for me for 1.5% then we both prosper. So there's at least 2 ways. There are more. Yes it's more complicated, but you asked and I answered.
- sillygeese 11y ago> 1. Economy of scale 2. I can get 5% on my own but they can get 8%. If he invests my money for me for 1.5% then we both prosper. First of all, "he" is not interested in your well-being, so he might as well get a good deal with a total price of X, but mark down X + Y as the expenses, and then pocket the difference. And second, free competition drives quality up and prices down, so you'll get a good deal that way too. There's plenty of "economy of scale" in millions of people seeking out the best deal on whatever.
- D_Alex 11y ago> If you could pay $10 to get $100, wouldn't you do it? Certainly not, if the $10 is a bribe. Would you? > A bribe is an investment... No, it is a criminal offence, in most places. And for good reason. Corruption does horrible things to the economy.
- lazyant 11y agoMore embarrassing is to build an airport with no demand and have it abandoned several years afterwards without any flights. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castellón–Costa_Azahar_Airport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castellón–Costa_Azahar_Airport