11 ms·
Has anyone here been pulled over for failing to signal a lane change?
by leereeves 11y ago
Has anyone here been pulled over for failing to signal a lane change?
- waterlesscloud 11y agoSure. It's something that happens all the time. It's an excuse to check for more serious violations. If everything passes a cursory check it'll be a warning, like he said, and you're on your way. Whatever else went on here, that part was not out of the ordinary.
- lsiebert 11y agoSure, but minor offenses are often a pretense for racial profiling, where the thing that attracted the cop's attention is driving while black. It's why young African Americans are more likely to be arrested for minor drug offenses, despite offending less then the average young white person. (see http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/04/the-blackwhite-marijuana-arrest-gap-in-nine-charts/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/04/t... ) And indeed if you look at the ACLU Report on disparities between whites and blacks for minor marijuana offenses, page 178 has Waller County, where this happened, as one of the ones with disparities in arrests above the national average. Note: It's a PDF: https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu-thewaronmarijuana-rel2.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu-thewaronmarijuana-rel...
- themartorana 11y agoThis is important. Manufacturing a reason to pull someone over after the decision to pull them over is incredibly easy. The original decision is often rooted in racial profiling.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>The original decision is often rooted in racial profiling. // How can you tell? Surely the point you're making is that the real reason for pulling the person over is not the one given, how then can you establish it's "racial profiling". I've been pulled over (UK) by police for having a stop light out, reasonable as it's a traffic violation. They asked the usual sort of questions and I got a "producer" (notice to produce various documents at a police station in the near future). How could you establish that this was because the officer was acting racist towards me? Telling the race of a person from behind when following their car seems quite hard. Statistics could show that more of a particular race were pulled over but that race could constitute a greater proportion of the local poor who being less able to keep their vehicles in good order are more likely to be stopped. That would create an apparent bias were there was none.
- lsiebert 11y agoI think you can control for socioeconomic class of the areas. Though I would argue that an area where black people are more likely to be unable to afford proper maintenance for their vehicles, are more likely to be poor in general, may be an area where other disadvantages (like the lower wealth per family and employment rate for African Americans, and were blacks got worse loan terms, or weren't allowed to rent or buy in better sections of town) may contribute to a systemic bias.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>It's an excuse to check for more serious violations. It's about time to do something about these context stops. They are just too easy for the weak-minded to abuse for their own ends.
- ansible 11y agoLook up the term "driving while black", though it happens to other groups too.
- Shivetya 11y agoThis certainly wasn't the case here and it a great many cases the officer won't be able to discern the race of driver until stopped. Now there may be some truth to the matter of what happens after a stop. As for the pull over, out of state tags and not signaling when a cop is coming up on you just makes you a good choice to pull over.
- cup 11y ago>This certainly wasn't the case here. How do we know? Isn't that by nature the nefarious issue with racism. It hides in plain sight.
- lsiebert 11y agoIndeed. Blatant honest racism is just one sort, but there is racism that is built into the system (like how white killers are mentally ill in the media, while black killers are called thugs), or unconsciously part of how you think (see http://www.forbes.com/sites/toddessig/2014/09/21/racism-from-ferguson-to-the-nba-to-you/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/toddessig/2014/09/21/racism-from... ). Note the following shows a 50% difference in call back rates based on name alone, with identical resumes, which is pretty relevant for techies looking at resumes. http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html
- mc808 11y agoThe latest meme is that black killers are 'thugs' while white killers are 'mentally ill' in the media. It doesn't take much effort to find the media calling mentally ill black killers mentally ill. http://www.clarionledger.com/story/news/2015/05/12/marvin-banks/27173563/ http://www.clarionledger.com/story/news/2015/05/12/marvin-ba... http://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/florida-executes-mentally-ill-killer-john http://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/florida-executes-mentally... http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-nypd-shooter-20141221-story.html http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-nypd-shooter-20141221-st...
- justonepost 11y agoYeah, I have. I was speeding once (dangerously, tbh, though it was 3am in the morning) but obviously the cop didn't get me on radar and wanted to pull me over and give me a ticket. I think getting irritated over a ticket like that is reasonable. Certainly, if I was a black civil rights activist I might get a little annoyed. I wonder though if there was something off about the license plate associated with the car. Does anyone know if this thing was completely clean?
- DanBC 11y ago> I think getting irritated over a ticket like that is reasonable. Can I just check: you think it's reasonable to be irritated after being stopped after being caught speeding? Or you think Sandra Bland is reasonable in being irritated?
- lcswi 11y agoRead the comment again, the irritation was not about getting stopped for speeding.
- jnbiche 11y agoNo, but I've been pulled over for absolutely no reason at all. I was let go without any issue, but something about me made the officer suspicious, although he couldn't find any reason to keep me. He asked me questions about what I was doing (I was driving home from work) and I answered them honestly and politely as possible, even after he wasn't able to provide an answer to my polite question, "what seems to be the problem, officer?". I know the consensus here is to refuse to answer any questions, but I think if I had tried that approach in this situation, I would have spent the night in jail (and maybe longer, depending on the availability of a judge). I was pretty pissed off at the time, but I only let myself show it after he let me go.
- eevilspock 11y agoI got pulled over for driving a Volvo while being non-white. The officer said it was because I didn't come to a full stop at the stop sign. Yes, that was probably just barely technically true at this deserted 4-way stop intersection with great visibility. He asked me what I did for a living. I should have refused to answer that as irrelevant and none-of-his-business, and I could easily have afforded the unjust consequences (unlike many people who are racially profiled), yet I still felt powerless and coerced to answer. I regret that. I was polite, cooperative, and with my wife. The officer was rude and menacing. The racial profiling and assumptions about how I could be driving a nice car were clear as day.
- ohitsdom 11y ago> He asked me what I did for a living. Wow, that's infuriating. Tough call what to do in that situation.
- jmadsen 11y agoanswer "I'm a lawyer" (nah, prolly better not)
- XenophileJKO 11y agoI would stick with "I work for the IRS".
- zamalek 11y agoA family member was fined for failing to indicate well in advance of turning a corner. Not the same thing but it's in the ball park. I've always thought you Americans were just complaining about "first world problems." However, between Charleston and Sandra Bland I am really sitting up and taking notice now: please continue to demand answers. These hate crimes simply cannot be a reality in advanced societies.
- catshirt 11y agoa big part of the problem is that a lot of Americans think these are "first world problems" too.
- ohitsdom 11y ago"Just don't break the law, you'll be fine."
- phkahler 11y ago>> a big part of the problem is that a lot of Americans think these are "first world problems" too. Hey man, Russia and China are first world countries too. But seriously, that's one of the most interesting comments I've seen on this.
- maxerickson 11y ago? First World originally meant the US and its allies: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_World The later confuzzled meaning, where First World is associated with being highly economically developed, also doesn't really apply to Russia and China: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BRIC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BRIC There is still a stark difference in economic productivity between Russia/China and the countries with high per capita GDP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PP...
- gadders 11y agoWhen I was a door-to-door salesman as a Summer student job in America, I got pulled over for "looking lost". I also got told off a few times for soliciting without a license.
- m_fayer 11y agoI went to university at New Paltz, NY, which is a college town with a reputation for parties, though nothing horrific. Around the town, there were huge numbers of police (especially compared to the small population of the town) all seemingly trolling for petty drug arrests. They would pull college kids over for stuff like this all the time and use it as an excuse to search the car. While I never got the lane change excuse, I have been pulled over for not coming to a full stop at a stop sign multiple times, when I was either sure that I did come to a full stop or brought the car to a barely perceptible crawl for a long time while checking for other vehicles. When the officer would realize there were no drugs to find in the vehicle, they'd often become belligerent.
- themartorana 11y agoI'm white and have been pulled over twice in North Carolina for having NJ plates on Route 95. It's a major drug corridor and being out of state had to mean we were running drugs. I was with my brother both times. We were shouted at, separated, patted down, and questioned repeatedly, trying to find some disparity in our stories and an excuse to search the truck. I imagine it would have been much worse/more aggressive if we were minorities.
- Jgrubb 11y agoMy wife and I have occasionally entertained the thought of moving from rural NJ up to New Paltz. Seems like a cool town when we visit. Not interested in bringing my family and my tax dollars up to a town with an overly large police force with not enough to do though, so thanks for the comment.
- m_fayer 11y agoI have to say though that New Paltz and its environs are a place whose loveliness far outweigh the dickish-cop and puking-frat-boy problems. I think if you're white and don't look student-age, you'll mostly be left alone. If amazing nature (the Shawangunk ridge), tight-knit community, lots of small businesses, a tiny walkable downtown core surrounded by what feels more rural than suburban, and vocal lefty-but-not-too-lefty culture mean anything to you, then do give it some thought. And the locals will tell you where the trick half-mile-long speed limit drops that you'll never notice until you're pulled over are.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 11y agoI've been pulled over (1997) while being a passenger in a older (1970sh) truck in Palo Alto at night. The officer was really friendly, asked what we were doing in the neighborhood (We were driving around slowly, looking for a house we were trying to visit), and wished us a good evening after confirming we were on the up-up. The driver (my friend) was hispanic, I'm a white guy. License and Tags were up to date - it was just a kind of crummy truck. I thought it was really weird, but he said that sort of thing had happened to him several times - he attributed it a lot more to the truck being in a nice neighborhood than him personally. On the flip side, a couple years earlier, when I had just moved to the Bay area in 1995 (from Vancouver,BC ) I had gotten a bit lost with friends, and had slowed down, and were stopping at various intersections in East Palo Alto trying to get our bearing. (I just realized - this is something anybody who grows up with GPS enabled smartphones will never have to do) A police office pulled us over to find out what we were doing, and then suggested (once again, really nicely), that we probably shouldn't be stopping in this neighborhood at that time of night (East Palo Alto, unbeknownst to us, was a very high-crime area in 1995) I guess my point is - Police pull people over when their spidey sense goes off all the time. And it can be all sorts of things that will trigger it. I guess I'm blessed with white skin, but the many interactions I've had with police in which they've engaged me because whatever it was I was doing seemed sketchy at the time, always ended up well. Though, honestly - they've got guns, so I've also been pretty sensitive to the fact that if I made them nervous they might shoot me.
- uptown 11y ago"Though, honestly - they've got guns, so I've also been pretty sensitive to the fact that if I made them nervous they might shoot me." That seems reasonable.
- fixermark 11y agoFundamentally, the problem with that approach to policing is that racism is inherent to human interaction. Without training to recognize it, unconscious bias will set off a person's "spidey-sense" because they perceive someone of a different skin color to be "out of place" subconsciously, which makes them keener to look for reasons to stop at a conscious level. This is to say nothing of people who know they're racist and don't care; I'm thinking specifically of people who haven't been trained in unconscious bias yet. As the officer, you're not even likely to notice you're doing it. As a person of the "wrong skin color" driving through a high-rent neighborhood, you'll start to notice real fast that your commute is disrupted all the damn time. My personal story: I'm white, but I used to drive a beater with crappy temperature control and was taking a new route home late at night while wearing a stocking cap. Got pulled over for ostensibly making a left on red (on a deserted road in the middle of the night, when I'm pretty confident the light was green). If the officer's real reason for pulling me over is that I looked like I was casing the neighborhood for a place to rob, I don't really blame him; I was dressed like one of the Wet Bandits from Home Alone. ;)
- a3n 11y agoMy 17 year old boy was driving his beater car the other day, with his girlfriend, and a county sheriff crowded up behind him, real close. He was trying to coax the kid into speeding. I've talked to my kid a lot about the relationship between the cops and citizens. He was very calm about it, and maintained his speed. The cop passed and left after a minute or so. Failing to signal. Infinitesimal failure to stop. Changing lanes just a smidgeon before the solid white line changes to dashed. These are all just entry points for cops to fuck with you, either just for the sake of fucking with you, or to escalate up into something that goes on their performance evaluation metrics. 'Cause you know that they get measured, and you can't measure "didn't pull that guy over because he wasn't doing anything." Their incentives are your peril.
- goodcanadian 11y agoLikely, he was just running the license plate and not trying to screw with your son at all.
- a3n 11y agoI doubt if he needed to crowd that close. In fact if he wasn't a cop, and a cop was watching, he could have been pulled over for following too close. What if a dog jumped in front of my son's car?
- goodcanadian 11y agoI have often been tailgated by police, and I agree that it is dangerous. However, it is common, and I never felt like I was being deliberately goaded. At worst, they may have been hoping for me to make a mistake. Usually, they just hang out for a couple of minutes and then pass (driving well above the speed limit, I might add, if we are going to enumerate all of the moving violations regularly committed by the police). And, I wish police would fine people for tailgating. I've never seen it happen.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago
- npizzolato 11y agoI have. The officer was following me for awhile, and he claimed I started changing lanes to get off a highway before I turned my signal on, which probably had some truth to it. My tabs were about 6 months out of date (it just completely slipped my mind), and I had heard they can't stop you just for that, so I assumed it was just an excuse to pull me over. When he got to the car, he claimed to smell a large amount of alcohol on my friend and me. It was like noon on a Saturday and we had not been drinking at all. He asked me to get out and do a sobriety test, which I did and passed. After that he just gave me a warning for the tabs, which I was not expecting considering how out of date they were. He never mentioned the lane change again after he first said why he pulled me over. Full disclosure, I'm white.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoYes, and ticketed. A Houston PD unmarked car cut me off in traffic and I switched lanes to avoid their car. I was ticketed for "Changing Lanes Not in Safety" by another officer who was following.
- blueblob 11y agoI have not, but I know people who have. They were all pulled over after finishing a bar shift by police officers waiting for people to leave the bar and make a mistake so they had an excuse to pull over a possibly impaired driver.
- jessaustin 11y agoOne time after a night drinking in Pasadena I noticed that cops were sitting just down the street from the multi-story garage in which I had parked. I slept in the car for a few hours and avoided problems.
- tripzilch 11y agoYou mean if it hadn't been for those cops you'd have happily driven home while under the influence?
- jessaustin 11y agoMaybe?!
- cs2818 11y agoYes, two different times in Texas. Both times late at night with no other vehicles on the road and both times no other violations. Was never ticketed for it, but did have to entertain the officer's BS line of questioning about where I was going and such.
- sehugg 11y agoYep, at 3 am and had to do the drunk walk despite not having drunk a drop that night. I've also heard of the "license plate light was too dim" excuse.
- tcfunk 11y agoNot a lane change, but for parallel parking. I was escorted out of my car and asked how much marijuana I was carrying. I wasn't carrying any, so I told them so. They searched the car and didn't find any, so then escorted me to the police station for further questioning. The investigative officer there quickly realized that I was not the person they initially thought. Overall a great experience.
- tobiaswright 11y agoYes. I never really ever know if it's because I'm black or not, because I have always been stopped for cause. And being the empathic sort, I'm always cool, because truthfully a cop doesn't know what they are getting into - and I'm usually pretty confident I do know the situation I've gotten into, a person just trying to do their job, which in this instance is being an officer. I'm going to make your job easy. I'm not so sure that's the case though these days. Everyone has a bad mood, a bad day or a sucky life, the only difference is some have a gun and the ability to lawfully leave me to bleed out on the side of the road. Is this the person I going to meet when I get pull over next time?
- nogridbag 11y agoI haven't, but it's happened to one person in my family. I have seen someone who was pulled over by the police, then let go, then make an illegal u-turn while turning back onto the road and was pulled over again within seconds :) Edit: I have been randomly questioned a few times playing Ingress at post offices at 3am.
- peg_leg 11y agoYes. I'm white, in a boring town, was driving a crap car at the time and was young. Got a warning.
- e40 11y agoNo, this is just what they tell you when they just want to pull you over.
- itbeho 11y agoI was on a two lane road once, in the fast lane, driving the posted speed limit right at dusk. I noticed car headlights coming up behind me at a very high rate of speed and realized it was a cop. I assumed there was a hurry to get to an accident or something. I switched lanes to get out of the way, but found myself pulled over instead. The cop kept asking "why did you change lanes like that?" And I kept replying that "you were doing what looked like 90mph coming up behind me, what reasonable person wouldn't?". Really felt like the guy was having a bad day and looking for someone to take it out on. He wrote me a ticket.
- fencepost 11y agoSounds like a time to go into court and seek clarification: "I just want to be sure of this, the official policy of the XXXX police/sheriff is that when a car is approaching rapidly from behind I should expressly NOT get out of that lane?" Of course, that smartass approach may get you more crap in the future.
- knodi123 11y agoI got pulled over doing 70 on a freeway in medium-heavy traffic because a cop noticed the inspection sticker on my windshield was 2 months out of date. You never know what kind of bug has crawled up an individual officer's ass on any given day.
- heywire 11y agoYes, just after paying at the toll booth. I am about 99% sure that I used my turn signal, as it is a huge pet peeve of mine, but there is always a chance that I did actually forget, or that I didn't get the lever all the way down. The officer had me come back to his vehicle, in the front seat surprisingly, and questioned me about where I was going, where I was from, where I was coming from, what I did for a living, etc. while he ran my information. It wasn't just friendly banter, it was an interrogation. In the end I received a warning. I had considered complaining when I returned home, but thought it better to let it go. For reference, I'm a mid 30's white male, and I was travelling with my wife and kids in a plain Hyundai Sonata. I've read reports of similar experiences.