21 ms·
Sandra Bland arrest video has continuity problems, anomalies
- ck2 11y agoWhile it is never a bright idea, it is certainly not illegal to be rude to a police officer. Assaulting them certainly is but no-one is claiming that in this case. What this is, is an ultra-common case of yet another cop "escalating everything always" because there is no downside for them to do so. They do it because they can, because they are taught power and control over people is everything and the slightest challenge should be met with extreme force. She should have never have been ordered to get out of the car, so this was a false arrest.
- chippy 11y agoAs an aside, in the UK being rude as in using offensive language directed towards them twice is illegal and I think classed as assault.
- lsiebert 11y agoIn the U.S. it has repeatedly been shown to be covered by the First Amendment. See http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/telling-the-police-to-f-off-risky-first-amendment-business http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/telling-the-police-to-f-...
- Joeboy 11y agoThere's section 5 of the public order act which is about saying / doing things "likely to cause harassment, alarm or distress" to the public, which has been interpreted as including police officers. I don't know anything about having to say things twice or it being classed as assault.
- thatBilly 11y agoThere was a 2011 ruling in England where the judge said that officers were so regularly on the receiving end of the "rather commonplace" expletive that it was unlikely to cause them "harassment, alarm or distress". The Met continues to arrest people for swearing at police as they rejected the ruling. I know that Police Scotland continue to arrest people for swearing at police but I'm not sure how/if it has affected forces in England and Wales. At the time it was reported that the precedent could likely quash any future charges in similar circumstances.
- DanBC 11y agoThey tried to include horses too, although the case was dropped: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/oxfordshire/4606022.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/oxfordshire/46060... There's 2011 advice provided to the Met which says that courts are unlikely to convict because officers are assumed to be robust: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-15816761 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-15816761 It's probably a bad idea to direct insults at officers (because no-one likes being called a fucking facist wanker) and results will vary by location.
- chippy 11y ago>twice I'm not sure, but I think that after the first time the officer should say "don't use that language at me" and therefore probably tells the citizen that they are causing harassment and distress. Then if they continue to do it, after the warning, it becomes an offence. So perhaps it should be "continues to use offensive language after a warning about the language has been given".
- richmarr 11y agoI was surprised by this, like other sibling commenters. I was under the impression that common assault is only enacted when the victim is threateningly contacted or injured, or has reasonable fear of that being about to happen. Maybe threatening language might play a part in that. Having a quick Google, the articles I've come across seem to indicate that swearing at police has in the past been interpreted as illegal, but nothing has mentioned it being classed as assault. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/8902770/Swearing-at-police-is-not-a-crime-judge-rules.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/8902770... http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/2010/jun/16/verbal-abuse-law http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/libertycentral/2010... Not a lawyer, obviously. Where did that opinion come from? Do you have a source?
- kriro 11y agoIt's illegal in Germany as well ("Beamtenbeleidigung" literally insult of a civil servant). The fines are pretty mild but it's a funny law (imo). The line isn't exactly clear. Some things qualify as insults, others don't. Iirc "Clown" qualifies but "Bulle" (somewhat similar to the US use of pig=cop) doesn't because it is considered common use now. The rulings usually seem arbitrary. [The same laws apply for insulting non officers btw.] Edit: Upper limit is technically one year in prison or a corresponding monetary fine (value depends on your income as is standard in Germany)
- hwh 11y agoThere is no such thing as a "Beamtenbeleidigung" in Germany, though it is a quite common myth. People in office enjoy no special rights in that regard. There is a difference, though, in the law process. Insults as a criminal offense need a personal demand for a penalty to warrant persecution by the state. For people in office, this can be replaced by a substitution demand by the state, supposedly to warrant respect for office in general. Then, there isn't a catalogue for insults and their penalty. That's because criminal law in Germany is driven by the idea that the thing to be penalised is the individual guilt, rather than an objective action. This has a lot of consequences, one of them being that your action is weighted by what you wanted when doing the potentially criminal action, i.e. the intent.
- wbhart 11y agoTowards the end of the video, the officer in fact alleged she had kicked him. It's not clear to me when that happened. Possibly her foot scraped his leg in the initial scuffle to pull her out of the car. Alternatively, it may have happened in the portion that is off video. Either way, the female police officer noted evidence of the scuff, presumably on his uniform. Incidental things like these seem to be taken as evidence of "assault" all too often.
- a3n 11y agoThe arrested woman is "lucky" she didn't get charged for the officer's dry cleaning.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- a3n 11y ago"Ferguson police beat a man and then charged him with 'destruction of property' for bloody uniforms" http://www.dailykos.com/story/2014/08/15/1321904/-Ferguson-police-beat-a-man-and-then-charged-him-with-destruction-of-property-for-bloody-uniforms http://www.dailykos.com/story/2014/08/15/1321904/-Ferguson-p...
- gutnor 11y ago> They do it because they can, because they are taught power and control over people is everything and the slightest challenge should be met with extreme force. Maybe they do it for more mundane reasons: because they are bored of nothing happening and just decide to check a car to break monotony. Maybe they are having a bad day and something that would not have bothered them any other day is pissing them off. The problem is that comparatively to other first world countries, the US society is quite violent. You put a small army of armed regular human being on the street in a country with a small to medium expectation of violence and stupidity will have dearer consequences.
- rayiner 11y agoThe U.S. is quite violent compared to many third world countries. Our homicide rate is almost double that of Bangladesh.
- happyscrappy 11y agoWithout blacks murdering other blacks in gang violence the numbers are roughly the same as other developed countries, as this article reluctantly admits at the end. http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/black-americans-are-killed-at-12-times-the-rate-of-people-in-other-developed-countries/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/black-americans-are-kille...
- tptacek 11y agoWhere by "roughly the same" you mean "twice as high", and by "black" you mean "black and hispanic", and, of course, the demography that creates those statistics and confounds simple comparisons like that is left entirely out of your one-liner.
- glenndebacker 11y agoIn Belgium it is a criminal offence to 'insult' a police officer, they call it "Smaad aan de politie" in Dutch/Flemish. I know because I got a verbalisation once and I didn't need to say a lot to get it. Thankfully I didn't need to go to court and got a criminal record that way. I once lived next to a guy who drank a lot and who assaulted his older daughter when he drank too much. We had thin wales so we heard the scuffles and the cries. We always called the police but they didn't do anything about the situation. To be honest Belgian justice is a joke, in a lot of cases involving violence they never prosecute anybody. After I while I got really fed-up after the x number of times the police came and did really nothing than telling the guy to be quit.. . I made - not saying that I was correct - remark that being a police officer in Belgium must really been the most pointless job you could do. Drive your bike without a light and you get fined, hitting your children and you get a free pass. That - and that alone - was enough to get verbalised.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoSame in NL, but people go around it by making it an opinion instead of a direct insult, then it becomes freedom of speech. As in, instead of saying "You're a dick", you go "I think you're a dick". Subtle, but apparently enough.
- tluyben2 11y agoI have heard plenty of people insult police officers in public and even spit at them in the Netherlands without them doing anything. I learnt in school it is illegal to do so, I have never seen any of them do anything about it in real life. Even without the subtleties; quite the opposite.
- gerty 11y agoPolice officers have constantly crown prosecutors (or their assistants) on the line and these are the people who really call the shots on whom to arrest and how to proceed whenever something's getting serious. Going by the description, dad/daughter affair should have definitely been referred to Tribunal de la Jeunesse and I bet it was. Belgian prisons are also overcrowded and justice system understaffed so that prosecuting small one-time offenses is definitely not a priority.
- prawn 11y agoPolice should be trained, and it should be a point of pride for them, to be ultra-cool in the face of upset or rude people. There should be no incentive for arrest in a situation like this, no power struggle, but instead they should be proud and rewarded for having deescalated any non-violent situation. Think about the famously robotic Queen's Guards in the UK. Insults or bait should roll off police like water from a duck's back. In this case, the woman was irritated because she was being penalised for a really, really minor infraction. And then she was defensive because persisting with the cigarette request and the demand to leave the car seemed unfair. And then she was rude because he was abusing his authority and he was too embarrassed to acquiesce to a member of the public (giving him the benefit of the doubt that it wasn't because she was a woman and a black woman). The police should accept in the first, explain in the second and then deescalate in the third stage of a case like this.
- DanBC 11y ago> Think about the famously robotic Queen's Guards in the UK. Insults or bait should roll off police like water from a duck's back. But that's not about de-escalation training. That's about focus on duties. You poke a toe over the wrong line and you're going to get aggressively yelled at, or shoved. https://youtube.com/watch?v=e65-wLp1yyI https://youtube.com/watch?v=e65-wLp1yyI https://youtube.com/watch?v=NKOj1sQh3Jw https://youtube.com/watch?v=NKOj1sQh3Jw https://youtube.com/watch?v=_bW4bRcEVEk https://youtube.com/watch?v=_bW4bRcEVEk https://youtube.com/watch?v=xDPK1kPWj1E https://youtube.com/watch?v=xDPK1kPWj1E These are armed soldiers, not police.
- prawn 11y agoI think it goes without saying that there's a line. And also that they're still famously robotic. The police should react appropriately when faced with violence or an especially difficult customer, but their focus on duties should be to minimise fiery situations where they can.
- FireBeyond 11y ago"Police should be trained, and it should be a point of pride for them, to be ultra-cool in the face of upset or rude people." They are trained in de-escalation techniques. The issue is that in so many of these videos, it's not the person they've stopped or arrested, but the police themselves being the ones _actively_ escalating a situation until a use of force is near inevitable.
- rhino369 11y ago>While it is never a bright idea, it is certainly not illegal to be rude to a police officer. Assaulting them certainly is but no-one is claiming that in this case. It isn't illegal to be rude, but the cop also doesn't have to let you off if you are being an asshole. She broke the law and he was going to be nice and let her off with a warning. Instead she was combative and he decided not to. He asked her nicely to put out the cigarette and she essentially told him to fuck off she can do what she wants. Nobody has to sit there as inhale your shitty smoke. Cops can order you out of your car for no reason once you got pulled over. It is definitely not false arrest. And I think the cop had totally reasonable grounds to make her get out. Would you sit there and get shittalked while someones blowing smoke in your face because she has an authority/anger problem. Being a dick to a police office who can still use his discretion to let you off is a really dumb move.
- akilism 11y agowhere do you get that he was going to be nice from?
- rhino369 11y agoHe said it was a warning in the video. Though I guess he could be lying.
- DanBC 11y agoNo, he does not.
- rhino369 11y agoYes, he does. 12:19 in this video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=762&v=yf8GR3OO9mU https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=762&v=yf8GR3OO9mU
- rmxt 11y agoA post facto warning isn't really a warning, is it? "You were getting a warning, but now you're going to jail." Why not admit the "warning" upfront? Maybe exactly like the one happening the first minute of the video?
- rogeryu 11y agoThe third video shows cars disappearing. It looks like they want to hide something. I see several episodes where nothing happens, no cars and no people in view. Why not copy those moments? Or is this done on purpose by an editor who cannot disobey an order (to make parts of the video disappear), but can sabotage the result by playing stupid?
- a3n 11y agoMy impression was that they looped it to make it long enough for the staged conversation that the officer was having.
- rickyc091 11y agoYep, looks like it's been edited. http://time.com/3967329/sandra-bland-video-continuity/ http://time.com/3967329/sandra-bland-video-continuity/
- themartorana 11y ago"that suggests the possibility that the video was edited before its release." Is there another possibility?
- ucaetano 11y agoIssues with the camera, recording medium, data corruption, etc. But my money is on editing.
- Phlarp 11y agoCan anyone present one other instance where an issue with the camera, recording medium or data corruption at any stage of the process between capture and youtube that has resulted in a video with these characteristics? I'd say your money is in the smart place!
- 11y ago
- leereeves 11y agoHas anyone here been pulled over for failing to signal a lane change?
- waterlesscloud 11y agoSure. It's something that happens all the time. It's an excuse to check for more serious violations. If everything passes a cursory check it'll be a warning, like he said, and you're on your way. Whatever else went on here, that part was not out of the ordinary.
- lsiebert 11y agoSure, but minor offenses are often a pretense for racial profiling, where the thing that attracted the cop's attention is driving while black. It's why young African Americans are more likely to be arrested for minor drug offenses, despite offending less then the average young white person. (see http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/04/the-blackwhite-marijuana-arrest-gap-in-nine-charts/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/06/04/t... ) And indeed if you look at the ACLU Report on disparities between whites and blacks for minor marijuana offenses, page 178 has Waller County, where this happened, as one of the ones with disparities in arrests above the national average. Note: It's a PDF: https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu-thewaronmarijuana-rel2.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/aclu-thewaronmarijuana-rel...
- themartorana 11y agoThis is important. Manufacturing a reason to pull someone over after the decision to pull them over is incredibly easy. The original decision is often rooted in racial profiling.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>The original decision is often rooted in racial profiling. // How can you tell? Surely the point you're making is that the real reason for pulling the person over is not the one given, how then can you establish it's "racial profiling". I've been pulled over (UK) by police for having a stop light out, reasonable as it's a traffic violation. They asked the usual sort of questions and I got a "producer" (notice to produce various documents at a police station in the near future). How could you establish that this was because the officer was acting racist towards me? Telling the race of a person from behind when following their car seems quite hard. Statistics could show that more of a particular race were pulled over but that race could constitute a greater proportion of the local poor who being less able to keep their vehicles in good order are more likely to be stopped. That would create an apparent bias were there was none.
- mdavidn 11y agoThe video and audio tracks were recorded separately, and the dash cam skipped backwards during playback. The officer's behavior was deplorable, but I'm not convinced the video was doctored.
- pjc50 11y agodash cam skipped backwards during playback How often does this "just happen"? It's not like someone jogging a CD player.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- EliRivers 11y agoThe audio is recorded separately. It is combined at a later stage. This is something you really could have figured out for yourself.
- buster 11y agoI don't know why you are downvoted. My best bet is that the equipment is some crappy cheap stuff and somehow the encoding process skips at some times for whatever reason. Maybe it's too hot, something overheats, buffers... or just a bug of some ancient software. I suppose this is just a bad choice in equipment. For example, in Germany CCTV cams in underground stations seem to have an incredibly bad black/white low-resolution quality and when bad things happen people are supposed to recognize some blurry face..
- ansible 11y agoThere are some evidence recording systems that are supposed to be tamper-proof. So the video while being recorded is digitally signed, and then the officer's recording system uploads it securely to the police servers when back at the station. This is to maintain a complete chain-of-custody, so that when used as evidence in court, it can't easily be dismissed or disregarded. This one... is apparently not? What's going on here?
- ealexhudson 11y agoI don't think you'd know from the released video whether or not it had been tampered with (in terms of the tech you're talking about); presumably if it had, it wouldn't be admissible in court for precisely that reason. This is PR, not evidence.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoDon't worry. The camera was just malfunctioning!
- roghummal 11y agoDid you read the parent comment? What does tamper-proof mean to you? It's digitally signed and then the officer's recording system uploads it securely to the police servers when back at the station. This is all to maintain a complete chain-of-custody, so when used as evidence in court it can't be easily dismissed or disregarded by the criminal's attorney. It can't be edited because there wouldn't be a digital signature!!!? Cameras will malfunction but not like you're saying they will.
- hias 11y agoRelax, he made an joke!
- roghummal 11y agoIn case someone takes his comment seriously, there's mine. In case someone takes my comment seriously they'd agree with the grandparent so no harm done. There's the chance someone would agree with the grand/parent ('malfunction...', secure, etc.), read my comment, and think... well that's ridiculous. Case study for "'/s' considered harmful"; Would-be PhDs take note.
- marincounty 11y agoI bought two cheap dash cams from Amazon. They shipped from China. They were 14.99 each. You get a cam, suction cup, and cig. Lighter plug. I bought two because I keep one in the in the car in case one breaks.(you need to buy a sd card). It's been a year, and no pullovers? The cam is holding up just fine. It loops. You will forget it's there. It goes on when you start the car. It will stay on when the officer tells you to turn off the vehicle.(need to program it though). Cops have stopped pulling me over for no reason. Before the cam, I was getting pulled over for driving an old car, or I was driving between 10 p.m. - 2:30 a.m.? I wish I had these cams when I was younger. Could have saved a lot of pointless questions, and aggravation? I'm a white guy who's been pulled over so many times for no reason--I lost count; I can't imagine what minorites have to go through? We should be able to drive without that constant fear of harassment. Harrasement is being pulled over for made up reasons? Cams have helped in my world. They have worked so well, I thinking about mounting a rear cam? "See them coming and going?" Sorry, if I sound jaded, but I live in a low crime area. Cops have become revenue collects here.
- zamalek 11y ago> I live in a low crime area > I'm a white guy who's been pulled over so many times for no reason Is there a correlation here? Where I'm from you don't get pulled over for anything. The roads are a free-for-all wild west: taxis stop in the middle of the road in front of you for no reason. So many people die on the road every year. If you do get pulled over for a misdemeanor there is a good chance you can talk or bribe your way out of it and carry on with your reckless driving. I would happily take a ticket for failing to indicate. That is different from racial profiling and hate crimes. Don't confuse hard working cops doing their job with idiots with badges and guns.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- titzer 11y agoSince you didn't indicate where you're actually from, I'm not sure what to make of your anecdotes. I'm from a small town in Indiana that has/had very little actual crime and yet a relatively large police force. When I was a minor I was harassed multiple times by police for violating curfew. Took a few rides in a cop car for nothing other than being out past 11pm. In 2004, some of Indiana's curfew laws were struck down by the federal supreme court, but that didn't stop the bastards, and new laws keep coming. Have a look at the mess here: http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/tag/curfew http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/tag/curfew Having been on the receiving end of (just a little) police harassment, it's very easy to see how aggressive policing has led to tragedies like this one and countless others. Cops deal with a lot of bad characters, but it seems they're too often looking for trouble when they harass people like this.
- anti-shill 11y agodisrepecting a cop....more americans are executed for this crime each year than for any other crime....executed on the spot, in fact...
- scotty79 11y agoNot sure why you're getting down voted. It might be true given the number of people killed by the police in the US for whatever reason: http://killedbypolice.net/ http://killedbypolice.net/ and number of people legally executed in the US for various crimes: http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/execution-list-2015 http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/execution-list-2015 Some police killings most likely could have been avoided if not for the disrespect given to the police.
- tzs 11y agoHe's probably getting down voted because his statement does not appear to be even remotely true, at least judging by the data in your first link. I picked a few at random from the July group, and the closest any came to someone being killed for "disrespecting" the police was a couple of them who were shot for pointing guns at police, which is certainly disrespectful. I have no idea why you are getting down voted.
- scotty79 11y agoI don't think that anyone would written in any formal document or non-fringe paper that killing was caused by disrespectful behavior. But I can't imagine that it was no factor in any of the killings. If you have a group of people that have right to kill someone for legitimate reason you can be sure, I think, that some of them will be less reluctant to exercise this right if they are distressed by disrespect shown towards them by this person. Take this guy for example (I just read about one at random): http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-man-wounded-lapd-dies-20150710-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-man-wounded-lapd... Unarmed guy who riding skateboard down the street was killed because he didn't obey commands from police and they were unable to subdue him. Technically he was killed for using potentially lethal weapon on police officer. For me if disrespect and police vulnerability towards disrespect wasn't a factor there, the policemen would back off after initial trouble and keep an eye on the guy while waiting for back-up.
- gmriggs 11y agohttps://youtu.be/qEGFaOeUm2A?t=31 https://youtu.be/qEGFaOeUm2A?t=31
- DangerousPie 11y agoHaving watched the two short videos I really don't see any obvious things they could have hidden there. The audio (which I presume is the important part) appears to keep on going, while a short segment of the video repeats. They also mention in the article that "The audio ends more than a minute before the video images do. " So to me this just sounds like some small parts of the video got repeated by accident, leading to a slightly "extended" video that becomes out of sync with the audio. But maybe I'm being too naive here, I don't actually know the backstory of this.
- lentil_soup 11y agowell, potentially the audio could be edited as well, which is much easier to fake than video
- duncan_bayne 11y agoOr, as I've read elsewhere, you pad unimportant sections of the video by looping, then cut out a few short important bits, and the overall length is unchanged.
- DangerousPie 11y agoBut the length is actually increased by about a minute from the sound of it. Unless they also cut some parts of the audio but then forgot to match the length up again, which seems like a really weird mistake to make...
- DanBC 11y ago> So to me this just sounds like some small parts of the video got repeated by accident, How? Is this an error for any camera or recording software? It feels like it can only happen after editing, and the fact that edits happened make people wonder about what was edited out.
- imaginenore 11y agoAudio is very easy to cut seamlessly.
- 11y ago
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoThe implication here seems to be that the dashcam video was re-edited before being released to the public. If true, oddly enough, I'm not sure a crime was committed, although it sure feels like somebody should go to jail. But I am not sure. Is there a law that says that everything the police releases to the media concerning possible court cases must be the same evidence that will be presented at trial? Or are they free to spin and edit things however they like? I believe they are. Assuming this line of reasoning, the LAT may have jumped the gun by releasing the story when it did. It would have been much more interesting to have let the video stand as a Press Release, then see if they tried to use it in court, then run the story. As it is now, we'll never know how that scenario would have turned out.
- roghummal 11y agoEdits in the middle should've been in NFO. Runtime is short. Good effort w/ the source. For a cam A3/V3.
- tomelders 11y agoI feel dirty up voting a joke, but it's pitch perfect.
- timboslice 11y agoNUKED - reason: stolen from P2P
- justwannasing 11y agoWhy is this on HN? How does it relate?
- jwdunne 11y agoI see this question a lot. I think we as a community can decide that by way of votes. The moderation team can also offer second judgement, which it seems to have passed. Liberty and actions of the police seems like a topic many hackers are interested in. The consistent votes on such issues lend credence to this.
- oneeyedpigeon 11y agoQuite aside from the fact that hackers are people too and care about all sorts of issues, this article is specifically about the video tape being doctored, so has a technical aspect that could lead off into discussions in several directions.
- justwannasing 11y agoThat you see this question quite a lot indicates a confusion among visitors and users.
- eloisius 11y agoHN frequently discusses topics concerning civil liberties.
- justwannasing 11y agoI see that. I guess I should send all my political friends to HN to post more such articles and comments cause where else but a place called "Hacker News" would one do that? I mean, I know I came here for just such topics.
- colinbartlett 11y agoThis is rehashed often. It's "news that hackers would find interesting" not "news about computers". If an article does not gratify your intellectual curiosity, I suggest just ignoring it.
- throwawayHN123 11y agoMore and more cases of voilent killings ... read massacare of african american people by the white americans and police officers..... Obama shd look in his own shitty country before giving peace lectures to India and the world.... USA the only country where its citizens are targeted by the govt and killed because they are black. The only nation which goes to war with every muslim and black country.
- throwawayHN123 11y agohope you are proud of yourself.
- logicrime 11y agoI really, REALLY want the cops to be at fault here, but I just don't know about this one. The sound seems to be mostly intact, unless there is some kind of offset because it does crackle and spit at one point. A lot goes on between the suspect and officer ON camera and I wonder what could've possible happened off camera bad enough to warrant being hidden when what's on the camera is already there. I mean, this guy pulled her out of her car and threw her on the sidewalk because she got a bit snarky over a ticket. Another concern is the absence of a timestamp. This I'm not as worried about because they probably cropped it out. It's definitely understandable, especially for public-facing video to crop out some of more sensitive metadata like time, officer info, car info, etc. It's not nearly as concerning as the video itself. Then there is the case of the actual jumps themselves. What makes me doubt is that they aren't just jump cuts, there's some stutter and back and forth motion for each cut, and there's also some video artifacts for each one. I despise the police, I really do. The very idea of police is repulsive and disturbing, in my opinion. That being said, I think LA Times is definitely suspect here for such a bait-y headline over what looks to be an actual video issue. I mean: "arrest video has continuit problems, anomalies"? No shit, the video is messed up. It also has the entire dialogue between the two leading up to the arrest, it even has a whole other stop from another time! I just don't see the possibility that they are hiding something, when there is so much on tape already.
- paublyrne 11y agoI despise the police, I really do. The very idea of police is repulsive and disturbing, in my opinion. You mean this in an idealistic sense? I was just remembering this morning an old friend who regularly used the word 'pigs' to describe police, and how I found it ridiculous. And I still do. How would a world without police be better than the one we have? It wouldn't. It would be a horrendous place where the strong, the violent, the aggressive, triumph over the vulnerable. I honestly can't understand your attitude.
- belenos46 11y agoAs opposed to this one, where only strong, violent, aggressive cops triumph over the vulnerable? Your point is taken, but I feel like it's fundamentally flawed.
- chmike 11y agoCould the dashcam video have been (amateurishly) edited to hide car's plate so that people present on the spot can't be harassed by journalists, etc. ?
- jvandonsel 11y agoWhat, no timecode? Has it been removed?
- IanDrake 11y agoIf an officer says "Get out of the car please." You can ask if it's a question or an order. If it's an order, get out of the car. White, black, asian, or hispanic, once that order is given, you're getting out of the car one way or another. If you really think the order was given unlawfully, take it to court where these things can be debated.
- techbio 11y agoYANAL
- IanDrake 11y agoI'm not. Though, if you ask an officer of the law, you'll be told there is nothing wrong with civilly asking for clarification and/or verbalizing that you disagree (but will comply).
- justaman 11y agoYou are 100x more likely to end the encounter in your favor if you do as the officer says. Do not, under any circumstance, make the officer feel uncomfortable. If you play nice, so will they. Always respect/practice the 4th.
- thomnottom 11y agoSo you really think that all of the people recently murdered by police officers would be fine if they had just "behaved"?
- freehunter 11y agoAll? No. He never said all, and that's an unfair way you're phrasing the argument. You're deliberately setting it up so that anyone who disagrees with you is immediately painted as blaming the victim. That's not what this discussion is about and you know it, so shame on you. He said you're more likely to. But in some cases, the situation could have been improved to the point where the outcome could have been completely different if the person had complied with the officer. I'm not saying the cop was right in any of the cases, but if I see a semi truck barreling down the freeway into oncoming traffic... I have the right-of-way because I'm in the correct lane, but you'd better believe I'm going to get out of that truck's way. Because absolute best case result there is that I will die a quick and painless death. I was in Madison WI when Tony Robinson was killed and saw some of the protests against the police. It was interesting to me that the spirit of the protests weren't harmed by the fact that Tony had assaulted people on the street then tried to kill the police officer responding to the incident. Sitting in jail innocent and alive is always better in my book than being gunned down in the street by a scared and trigger-happy cop.
- techbio 11y agoWho is accountable? Names. I imagine no one here is for abuse of power. How about use thereof?
- techbio 11y agoWho is accountable? Names. I imagine no one here is for abuse of power. How about use thereof?
- nicboobees 11y agoWould it be so hard for her to just do what he asked instead of blowing things up... I really don't understand the absolute lack of respect some people have for the law and other humans. Is it that hard to be civil?
- genericuser 11y agoHe could also respond to her question about why she should put out her cigarette with out going full Judge Dredd on her. Also she responded in a way that seemed to be in keeping with her civil rights.
- nicboobees 11y agoHe asked her nicely if she could put out her cigarette for his benefit. She in return started ranting about how it was her car etc. I don't care if she has the right to remain smoking in her car or not. Someone asked kindly for her to put it out, and she went full rant in return. I'm sure statistically speaking, if someone is a complete asshole and "resists" any attempt to be nice to the police, they're likely to be breaking other laws - carrying drugs, no car insurance, etc etc. If you get pulled over by the police, starting an argument and forcing them to escalate things isn't the best idea.
- pfooti 11y agoIf you get (illegally) pulled over by the (racist) police, what should you do? Submit to their power trip instead? Given that there's a lot of questions about the audio in general, I'm not sure how nicely he really asked - the entire veracity of the audio stream is under question here: the video skips around but the audio doesn't. That certainly lends credence to the "he was being nice" argument, except for the part where the "nice" could well have been added in post-processing. Ultimately, a racist institution staffed by racists most likely murdered a woman whose only crimes were (a) not signaling to pull over after the officer signaled her to pull over, for some other reason, and (b) not being polite to the officer in question. Until and unless you show me that police deserve politeness, the only reason to be polite to them is "because otherwise they may kill you". That is not only f'd up, it's literally terrorism. As in: these acts make us terrified and we are less likely to resist their authority. So, yeah.
- fixxer 11y agoNothing about this adds up. The video is flawed during both the arrest and around the time of death. Given her activities, saying this warrants further investigation is a gross understatement. The willingness of police to label death a suicide never ceases to amaze me. I was on the beach down in Florida a few years ago and found a dead girl with her hands tied. Cops showed up and immediately assumed suicide. Turns out she had drug issues and had a history to support the assumption, but no reasonable person would approach a situation like that with such strong priors. I'm not saying every crime scene is out of a Hollywood movie with a serial killer lurking in the shadows, but I would have really liked to see zero prior beliefs at that point. I'd sleep better knowing the people out there in charge of "serving and protecting" the general public viewed their occupation as a search for truth rather than some perverse version of The Office with guns.
- emodendroket 11y agoShows like CSI give the impression of infallible police with perfect tools to solve crimes but that obviously just is not the case. More than half of murders go unsolved (and that doesn't count the ones nobody realizes are murders) and we're seeing lots of evidence that innocent people end up being punished for them often enough.
- vinay427 11y agoBased on experience from watching The Wire, I would venture a guess that this is due to politicized statistics such as clearance rates that departments must meet for funding.
- jessaustin 11y ago...some perverse version of The Office with guns. Some days, every profession is "some perverse version of The Office with X". I don't mean to excuse LEOs, but rather to point out that the expectation that they're somehow different from the rest of us, is one of society's problems.
- indlebe 11y ago
- dudul 11y agoInstead of teaching kids how to code at school we should teach them law and what police officers are allowed and not allowed to do when pulling you over or showing up on your property, etc. I have no clue if the cop was right when he said that he has "every right" to ask her to put down her cigarette and step out of her car. Cops pull this shit all the time betting on the fact that citizens have no f-ing idea what they actually can and can't order them to do. "I will light you up!", just for that this guy deserves to be fired.
- DanBC 11y ago> Instead of teaching kids how to code at school we should teach them law and what police officers are allowed and not allowed to do when pulling you over or showing up on your property, etc. It's probably better to teachchildren how to safely interact with police, and how to safely gather evidence which can be used later to persue complaints against abusive officers. The fact that this is already a thing in some parts of the US should be a big flag that something is seriously wrong. https://youtube.com/watch?v=HkdWdefMvTw https://youtube.com/watch?v=HkdWdefMvTw It's baffling to me that when police accept communication problems are a thing that they then train African american youth to be compliant, rather than training police to not be assholes.
- rhino369 11y agoThe problem with teaching this is that is depends highly on the situation. There are not brightline rules that a person can easily understand. Are you being detained or arrested is not a bright line rule. You can go from one to teh other without anyone saying anything. And the rules for police differ. I'm a lawyer and I couldn't even begin to tell you the rules for my own state, let a lone some random place in Texas. Though one bright line rule is that cops can make you get out of your car. That is pretty much their discretion.
- dudul 11y agoThe fact that you are a lawyer and can't describe the rules is scary. I'm not calling you an idiot, this is a comment on the stupidity of lawmakers if what you say is true. I find it very scary that we accept a principle such as Ignorantia juris non excusat but don't bother teaching law and make it understandable to common people. And to be clear, I'm not talking about details to be used during a trial, but just day-to-day interaction with police officer / social services / etc. Can they really order you out of your car? Do they have to give a reason? Can they enter your home without a warrant? Can they really take your kids if you don't willingly let them in? Are they authorized to ask you about your profession? They will always use people's ignorance to scare them and force them to comply, but that's the direct road towards a police state.
- genericuser 11y agoSo lets look at what we have in terms of video / audio. 1)Repeated unimportant segments of video. 2)A fairly good sounding audio track. 3)An audio track which is not the same length of the video track. 4)The video issues do not start happening till over 20 minutes into the uploaded video, and then happen at multiple times over the next 15 minutes. What can we conclude about the video? Well I can't conclude anything, but I sure get a lot of questions. Could this be an issue with the recording of the video stream? I don't know seems like we might have some experts here on video recording equipment here that might be able to say if this is a type of problem that is even possible, maybe even some with knowledge of the type of equipment used in police dash cams. Has anyone seen anything like this 'just happen' in digital video before? I haven't but my experience is limited. Anyone else? Why is the audio OK but the video is bad? Well audio and video could be recorded separately, and if they weren't they are not hard to separate, and audio is much easier to edit. Could the video of been edited? Well sure it was probably at least cut for upload. If it was edited the editor really sucked. If the video was edited, why would the video be edited? Maybe it was cut to remove something that happened in one of the frames somewhere during one of the repeats. Maybe the audio was edited too and it was edited to more closely match the audio length (matching just as well as the video was edited). Maybe someone started editing the video to hide something in a missing segment and didn't finish or get to the audio before it was uploaded. What other things besides editing and recording failure could explain the video issue? I don't know. Do we have any experts here who given the available youtube video on the Texas Department of Public Safetys youtube page could do analysis on a more in depth level than watching it? I don't know but I think this question is why I see this belonging on Hacker News.
- ck2 11y agoThey are now claiming there were technical issues uploading it and are going to re-post it corrected. This is plausible. But is this quote really from the video or someone's imagination? If it is true, holy hell: "Why are you arresting me?" "Because you know your rights." "Because I can." "Because no one'll believe you."
- genericuser 11y ago
- cjdulberger 11y agoSelf-driving cars cannot get here soon enough. Police interactions as a result of driver error will be obsolete.
- krapp 11y agoTrue. The police will simply stop your car remotely, or redirect it to wherever they want to interact with you, based on whatever information about you and your driving patterns the car is required to provide to law enforcement. But yes, legitimate issues with driver error will be a thing of the past.
- xyby 11y agoAt what point are video and sound getting out of sync? At 12:50 the policeman slams shut the door of her car and it is in sync with the audio. At 25:55 the same door gots slammed, but no sound is to be heard. Maybe because the policeman is carrying the microphone? Is he that far away? At about 48:00 the door of another car gets slammed. Its clearly on the audio, but about 1 second too early.
- ytdht 11y agolooks like they edited out another 3 minutes... original, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBh3wzXd3vg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBh3wzXd3vg, new one, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaW09Ymr2BA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaW09Ymr2BA
- frogpelt 11y agoIs the audio the same? Is it possible the original audio stretched to fill the old "glitched" video?
- joyceking777777 11y agoHow the game/scam (alleged) works. USA the land of bullies. Remember software app, help desk and Unix System Admins? New Management flavor of the 2 year "Gartner Hype Cycle" is now TQM or TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT. Prof. Edward Deming - father of Quality Management. Reason why Toyota wins and GM with USA Ignition Switch cover-up loses. THE OPEN SECRET IS HERE: Principle Engineering: Use statistics and view of the total system and asking for worker input to get a 'total view' and work together to produce quality. Boss View (insert Dilbert Cartoon) -TQM means ZERO TOLERANCE or 'no broken windows' for the POLICE or tea party politician for GET TOUCH ON imaginary crime or Donald Trump celebrity entertainer. Mexicans (maybe a lot) are criminals and RAPISTS. Boss (like the small town BULLY dressed in police uniform) says ZERO TOLERANCE - no defects. Prof. Deming - the key rule of Quality Management is DRIVE OUT FEAR. Most workers want to tell the truth, except there is a GUN HELD TO THEIR HEAT figuratively. see salon dd oo tt com "Like Sandra Bland, I confronted an officer who pulled me over for driving while black." joyce king. The officer, IMHO does not have to say sorry, but he should say thank you. Thank you, Ms. Joyce King, night reporter for saving my job while I try to BULLY YOU wrong word, intimidate you can't find the word, substitute some other word. the SCAM is to yell at you and get you to yell back. Then, its 1.)disturbing the peace in a vacant shopping mall lot 2.)resisting arrest and police body slam you and 3.)use choke hold (choke you to death) - nope that is prohibited, but the hog tieing and leaving in the small puddle of water FACE down may be legal. 4.)accidental use of spray can for the surveillance cameras were 'accidentally covered with black paint' and the cell phone of the suspect was accidentally dropped into puddle of water. Obviously, there is no cover-up in this fictional story protected by the Constitution. Zero Tolerance for any BAD quality. and this starts with YOU