9 ms·
Buenos Aires Censors and Raids the Technologists Fixing Its E-Voting System
- quibit 11y agoSo they put a paper ballot with an RFID chip inside into a machine which then puts your vote into the chip, then you drop the ballot into a box? How is this any different from a regular paper ballot?
- de_Selby 11y agoI guess it would be easier to automate the counting. Still seems an odd solution though.
- demian 11y agoAnd even that's not happening. The machine also prints the vote on the ballot, and because of the known bugs in the system people are still counting them by hand.
- rtpg 11y agoI don't get it. How are we unable to make a reliable mechanism to increment numbers and then print the result at the end?!
- demian 11y agoA known bug is that the counting machines doesn't validate the number of votes per ballot, so you can cast multiple votes by rewriting the RFID chip with a NFC enabled phone. And even if they address that particular bug, because of the inherent nature of the political process, parties' representatives will always want to count the ballots by hand to prevent fraud. EDIT: As of this moment there is no way an argentine political party would accept black-boxing an election.
- Fargren 11y agoI know three people who do vote counting every year. They all agree that the voting went very smoothly, with less crowding than usual, and the counting took a third of the time it usually does. This is unrelated to the security issues, but to them, the benefit was very clear
- lucio 11y agoThis: http://www.laizquierdadiario.com/IMG/arton15789.jpg http://www.laizquierdadiario.com/IMG/arton15789.jpg vs this: http://ondabaires.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Voto-electr%C3%B3nico.jpg http://ondabaires.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Voto-ele...
- pmouzo 11y agoOne of the problems in Argentina's elections is that volunteers of political parties steal the ballots of smaller parties from the voting room, and since these small parties don't have the man power or monetary resources to restock the ballots, they lose votes. A better solution would be single paper ballot, but the ruling parties don't want this because they are who benefit for the current system. That said, this system prevents chain voting (a mechanism to make sure the votes that parties buy from low-income people are not changed).
- demian 11y agoThis is first and foremost a PR stunt by the BA City's goverment to push a goverment "innovation" bullet point.
- mahouse 11y agoAs anything the EFF writes, this article is heavily biased. There is a huge difference between "technologists fixing a voting system" and "technologists irresponsibly leaking the source code and private certs of a voting system"
- frandroid 11y agoWow, advocacy organization that supports freedom of speech and democracy writes about freedom of speech and proper use of electoral systems. I am shocked, I tell you, shocked.
- wslh 11y agoThat's true but the local government and the company were terrible in how they handled the issues. Even the University of Buenos Aires who did the security review couldn't find basic issues.
- llazzaro 11y agoUBA did not review the security. however the security issues were so obvious that it seems strange that they say nothing
- flebron 11y agoUnfortunately they did. You can see the request for review here[1], and the actual review here[2]. I know the guy who actually did it (Righetti), he sent an email to the department a few days ago. The quality of that review was absolutely terrible. [1] https://www.eleccionesciudad.gob.ar/uploads/resoluciones/adenda%20OAT.pdf https://www.eleccionesciudad.gob.ar/uploads/resoluciones/ade... [2] https://www.eleccionesciudad.gob.ar/uploads/OAT%20n%203-15-06012015204749.pdf https://www.eleccionesciudad.gob.ar/uploads/OAT%20n%203-15-0...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- coldcode 11y agoAny e-voting system that is not entirely open for inspection is inherently open to alteration. Of course if the intent is to allow the existing political leadership to manipulate the results in their favor it is working as intended.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAny paper voting system that is not entirely open for inspection is inherently open to alteration. Software systems are hardly unique in this respect. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJfj9ySYg0Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJfj9ySYg0Q
- danmaz74 11y agoThe difference is that making paper voting systems entirely open for inspection is inherently much easier than doing the same for an electronic voting system. Especially for non-experts in engineering and cryptography, that is, like, 99.9% of the population.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoApart from mass civilian surveillance combined with breaking in and entering on a large scale, how do users inspect a paper system?
- specialist 11y agoObservation works pretty good. You can be a poll inspector, a poll judge, a poll observer, watch the central count, attend the public certification hearings. Different jurisdictions have different rules, so YMMV. But the basic ideas are a) Australian ballot system b) verify the physical chain of custody c) private voting, public counting. Happy hunting.
- danmaz74 11y agoBy having representatives of their own party being present in every single place where votes are counted. At least, that's how it works here in Italy.
- pvdebbe 11y agoI'm just thinking, this e-voting fad will make it really easy for the modern-time hitlers and stalins.
- halviti 11y agoe-voting does not necessarily mean "100% digital" it's a relatively trivial matter to use a printer attached to a voting machine to create a paper-trail. even something like "choose your candidate, get a receipt, verify it yourself, and put it in the box" the election results would be instantaneous, and the paper trail would still exist for irregularities.
- pvdebbe 11y agoAgreed -- when done right, it's very secure. But pretty much all the software suffers from shortcuts one after another, ridden with bugs and backdoors. Someone will most certainly get to exploit the state of affairs before these systems are solid enough for good.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoOnly if it continues to be done wrong. A cryptographically open voting system with private keys would be much more difficult to rig.
- snuxoll 11y agoPublic key cryptography in my eyes is the only proper way to do electronic voting, but it has a severe cost - the lack of secrecy. As anyone knows, the lack of secrecy comes with even more severe ramifications, the purchase of votes, pressure from friends/family/employers, the potential to be arrested in a fascist government, the list goes on.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoThere might be some validity to that, but I think you are blurring the lines between a private key being issued to someone and others knowing their vote, which would only happen if other know their public voting key.
- higherpurpose 11y agoWe're at least decades away from making secure digital voting (if something like that is ever going to be possible). I also believe it will be somehow based on blockchain technology that can't be easily altered to fraud the votes. We mainly need to do authentication in a secure way that can't be spoofed or hacked (easily).
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoSo is arresting people who charitably disclose vulnerabilities gonna be a thing now? I find it hard to believe any society fifty years from now is going to effectively function by shooting itself in the foot to prove how much blood it doesn't need.
- tomjen3 11y agoWell this is a pretty unique opportunity - if they can keep their mouths shut they can just elect a better government.
- marcosdumay 11y agoDid they get a way to insert new candidates into the system?
- pjc50 11y agoIt's been a thing for a long while, including in the US and Europe. But this is Argentina. The vulnerabilities were most likely put there deliberately by the security services, of course they don't want them exposed.
- iwwr 11y agoThis is not a unique thing for that country and current government. It's illegal to challenge the validity of government-provided statistics and even the "Big Mac Index" is manipulated by forcing McD to sell something called "Big Mac" at a lower price. Basically, the IMF and other institutions were using unofficial data to make their estimates since the official data was so obviously bogus. The government responded by cracking down on those reporting the unofficial data. (As an aside, Argentina is also selling inflation-adjusted bonds, so it kind of makes sense to promote large underestimations of that number). So when the government put forward a voting machine, it became illegal to question the validity of its workings.
- edko 11y ago"This is not a unique thing for that country and current government". The city's government and the Nation's government are from opposing parties. This shows that they are both just as corrupt. "This is not a unique thing for that country" (alone) would have been more accurate.
- gosukiwi 11y agoBeeing from Argentina, this sadly does not surprise me.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoSad yet not surprising. Argentina, sadly, continues to devolve into a complete joke of a country. I lived there for over ten years. I love the people and the beauty of the country. However, Argentinians seem to suffer from a cancer that causes them to be easily manipulated into voting the absolute worst politicians into power. These politicians proceed to rape and pillage the country and make a circus out of the whole thing. When you can watch this from the outside and see it for what it is It is down-right sickening. You want to yell: Wake the fuck up! Will they for the upcoming elections? If history is any indication, no, they'll vote in the same pandering socialists criminals who seem to always be able to convince the masses money will rain from the sky. And nothing will change. What's even worst is to see the parallels between what happens in Argentina and the US political system only to see Americans fall prey to some of the same sick politics and not see the reality of what politicians are doing to us. That's another topic.
- wslh 11y ago> convince the masses money will rain from the sky. Indeed, the money rains from the sky to a lot of people. This is basic clientelism and works very well for the politicians.
- cag_ii 11y ago> ... manipulated into voting the absolute worst politicians ... I've never really followed an Argentine election closely, but I'm curious is they have options. In other words, Is there often a significantly better political representative that is overlooked, or is it more of a "lesser of all evils" situation?
- rebootthesystem 11y agoThe culture of crime and corruption in politics has such deep roots that it is hard to answer your question. Not sure. I mean, people quite literally get arrested, attacked, destroyed and even killed for opposing the powerful forces at the top. It's a slow motion tragedy being played out for the world to see.
- a_c_s 11y agoThe best thing about paper ballots is their simplicity: even children can understand how to count and monitor them. Nearly any citizen has the skills to participate and to spot fraud. In comparison only a small percentage of the populace understands programming, fewer still would be able to write a secure voting system and fewer still would be able to debug such a voting system (code is harder to debug than to write). Given the above and the high stakes of government elections I think we have yet to find a technology superior to simple paper ballots.
- slapshot 11y ago> even children can understand how to count and monitor them Except they have no error correction and admit ambiguity as to a voter's intent. That's all great and theoretical, but the inability of some voters in 2000 in Florida to fully punch a paper ballot led to a recount that under some scenarios would have led to President Al Gore rather than President George W. Bush. Maybe the occasional hanging chad is worth the other positive attributes of paper, but don't write off all the advantages of an electronic system (error correct, instant results, etc). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_election_in_Florida,_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_ele...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- harry8 11y agoWith the utmost respect, you can screw up anything. The florida voting paper and damn hole punching was and remains utterly crazy. Obviously so to the overwhelming majority of people in a way that anything electronic isn't and will never be. "This is really bad form design, look at this layout" - she said pointing to the piece of paper she was holding. Most people can assess the merit of that argument, and in the case of Florida, have done so in a reasonable manner - whatever their conclusion. "This is a bad electronic system" - 99% of people have to trust an authority to even begin to form a view on that which makes disinformation and propaganda of the usual kind, ie advertising and lobbying, more effective than it deserves to be based on merit alone. Now that's fine for soda purchases but not good enough to trust your democracy to.
- rwallace 11y agoThe push to e-voting actually surprises me - if it was just one country, I'd write it off as just one of those things, but the fact that it keeps happening in country after country. Generally speaking, most human behaviour can be explained by assuming that people value status and power above all other things. So you can expect those in power to try to keep that power. But e-voting surely does the reverse: it throws open the playing field, putting power up for grabs to whoever can hack the system, with no way to predict who that will end up being. So why do those currently in power want that to happen? (Not a rhetorical question: I'm actually curious about the answer.)
- evook 11y agoThere is no thing such as an unexpected outcome by e-voting for those in power.
- rwallace 11y agoHow not? Sure, the people who ordered the system installed might have planned to arrange a hack themselves, but once it's in place, anyone can hack it.
- evook 11y agoYeah, such a hack will become either a mess and declared invalid or something political motivated. The event horizon of political motivation can be calculated. Therefore planned ahead.
- rwallace 11y agoSo if I understand you correctly, what you're saying is, those who already have and are used to wielding power, are (whether rightly or wrongly, it's what their intuition tells them according to their experience so far) reasonably confident they can use existing power structures to manage what ever mess results and prevent it getting out of hand? That does sound like a reasonable explanation.
- 11y ago
- robertnealan 11y agoHas nobody created an open-source, non-tamperable e-voting platform yet (could give the blockchain a solid purpose)? It seems like something that would make for a great project - a voting system for the people by the people.
- abecedarius 11y agohttp://zesty.ca/voting/ http://zesty.ca/voting/ was a nice start.