18 ms·
How Microsoft Bing Censors the Middle East
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ewzimm 11y agoMore accurately, it's set as default and requires a user changing their region to turn it off. Still not great for freedom of information, but not quite as bad as mandatory.
- 616c 11y agoTrue of all the big players in the region, at least the Gulf. Source: someone who spends far too much time there.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoThose should stop doing so at one moment, leaving faulty governments choosing between sticking to their hypocricy and working internet.
- killwhitey 11y agoThey would almost definitely choose working internet for themselves and nothing for the general population.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoLet them try if they can get away with that.
- tormeh 11y agoRegimes like that already did and they already do. And besides, how do you ask shareholders to accept just pulling (which is what this would be) from a market on ethical grounds? No, you'd have to get a law from the US government to make companies take such losses on ethical grounds. Some companies might of course pull from the US market to avoid pulling from the world's dictatorships, but probably not the big American ones.
- mirimir 11y agoI wonder if disconnect.me provides access to uncensored search engines. And there's always Tor and VPN services.
- zodiakzz 11y agoI find that hard to believe. Doesn't Google take a hard stance on freedom of speech issues?
- partiallypro 11y agoShort answer: No. Long Answer: Not really, no.
- A_COMPUTER 11y agoSearch for a confederate flag on google shopping.
- mahouse 11y agoThey should have used the word "problematic" in the first paragraph so I could have closed the tab sooner.
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoBing Image Search has vast quantities of child pornography. Even when the original server is long dead, the images persist in Bing's cache. The International Telecommunication Union's Child Online Protection initiative advises Google of URLs that contain child sexual exploitation. I expect that it advises Microsoft as well but wouldn't know - Bing doesnt remove the items from their index as Google does. I discussed this with Clark County Washington Deputy C. Bull on Friday. She suggested I point the problem out to the FBI. I told her that the FBI obviously knows what Bing is doing but does not pursue it. I have some theories as to why but really I dont know. My concept of ethics evolved considerable a result of the 1986 Space Shuttle explosion. While most blame NASA for shady engineering I blame Morton Thiokol engineer Roger Boisjoly. He recommended the launch be scrubbed when he filed a safety report with his management. I regard Boisjoly as ultimately responsible because he knew the o-rings were out of thermal tolerance yet he failed in his effort to get the launch scrubbed. In his case the right thing to do would have been to have gone to the press. While law enforcement is tasked with busting child pornographers I hold our elected officials ultimately responsible. For that reason, this evening I will write to each of the Redmond mayor, city councilmembers, King County councilmembers, each of Washington's legislators, the Washington governor and our Senators. I would write to others but I am strapped for cash and so cannot purchase much postage.
- Someone1234 11y agoI want to know what you are doing that you not only ran across tons of CP, but cross-compared the amount of CP on Google and Bing? And are now telling tons of people about all the CP you've seen? I have no idea why you'd discuss this with a deputy (who has no power to do anything), but refuse to discuss it with the FBI (because they "obviously know"), I also don't know why the heck your post contains a strange offtopic diatribe about the Challenger Disaster, or why you've lamenting under $5 in postage. The whole post is super strange and disjoined. I don't even follow the thought process.
- MichaelCrawford 11y agoLaw enforcement officers appreciate the assistance. The reason I discuss the Challenger Disaster was to explain my ethical stance on who is really to blame when something bad happens. When a bad person does a bad thing I regard them as doing what comes naturally; those who I regard as morally reprehensible are the ones who were in a position to prevent the problem, or to fix it afterward yet chose not to.
- ManFromUranus 11y agoIf they censor too much it's "problematic" because they're overreaching and deciding for the people. If they don't censor enough then it's "problematic" because they're culturally insensitive to the local sense of decency, they're imposing western standards or somesuch. They're damned if they do, damned if they don't.
- thinkpad20 11y agoI think that's BS. They're an American company, providing a product that people can feel free not to use if they're so inclined. They're not imposing western standards; that's like saying McDonald's is "imposing" a western diet by selling hamburgers in Riyadh.
- cwyers 11y agoPeople have absolutely made that argument before.
- cyorir 11y agoAs examples, look at Kong Qingdong in China and Vladimir Zhirinovsky in Russia. Two of the better known people who like to make these sorts of arguments.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoIts called Cultural Imperialism. I'm not saying it makes sense, but you're underestimating human ingenuity for making silly arguments.
- kazinator 11y agoA better analogy might be a western outlet which, outside of that country, normally sells something which is considered illegal. "Damned if they do and damned if they don't" doesn't mean damned by the same parties. They are in hot water with the authorities if they bring in the contraband, and vilified by some of the local users and human rights activists if they don't.
- 11y ago
- blfr 11y agoDuring the Reddit debacle many people were pointing out that private companies are free to remove anything they want and it doesn't constitute censorship. So this is certainly not a free speech issue if MS goes above the bare legal requirements, right? They're just removing/hiding objectionable content.
- theseatoms 11y agoIt's not a legal free speech issue, but it is a free speech issue for those of us who like free speech.
- jstuxx 11y agoFree speech is overrated.
- kazinator 11y ago> There is absolutely no excuse for a company—particularly one that has made commitments to free expression by being a founding member of the Global Network Initiative—to regulate speech beyond that which is required. Absolutely is a big word. Here is a technical excuse: the search index is collected and classified by algorithms. The algorithms are not perfect in their classification, and so there has to be a margin for error. > Neither Egypt nor Lebanon, for example, block most sexual content or require intermediaries to do so. See, weasel word: most. So they do block some sexual content? If you want a fine-grained filter to just block that particular sexual content, you have to improve the robots. That costs time and money, and creates risk. Maybe it's easier and legally safer to just block all sexual content and be done with it. In other words, over-zealous filtering, or at least some of it, could be the consequence of cool pragmatism and nothing more deeply sinister.
- killwhitey 11y agoBing (and Google) block some sexual content everywhere. Try searching for child porn and tell me what come up.
- kazinator 11y agoA black van outside. Gee, thanks!
- throw7 11y agoYes, the default is "SafeSearch" enabled. Bing and Google filter for everyone... it's not opt-in. You opt-out, as would people living in "strict markets". I don't believe bing/google are required by law in the U.S. to do this (correct me if I'm wrong)... so the e.f.f. arguments are a bit hypocritical by not including, essentially, the rest of the world.
- kazinator 11y agoBut in some of these regions, you cannot opt out. Safe search upholds censorship laws.
- lucd 11y agosurprised ? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2138565 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2138565
- veddox 11y agoSeriously, pornography counts as "free speech" now? Please guys, can't we fight for something worthwhile? If I had to give my opinion, I'd say that I actually find it quite laudable that Microsoft bothers to heed local values. It shows respect (and a good sense for business), kinda like not selling pork in the UAE...
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI live in a harmonized country where we get to use a harmonized version of bing. It filters out many legitimate search requests, not just porn. You might search for something completely innocuous that happens to have the word girl in it (e.g. the TV series golden girls from the 80s), and it will be harmonized, I mean censored. The filters are necessarily inaccurate and will affect legitimate search queries. You probably wouldn't use them in your western country even if you were a conservative Puritan.
- veddox 11y agoI understand that it can be a pain for the users - but unless the filter out a lot more than the original article says, I find the label of "censorship" and "free speech impediment" highly exaggerated.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoAbout 5% of my searches are blocked based on keywords alone, and none of those are meant to be pornographic. I believe, and have found from my own experience, that censorship is impossible without collateral damage. It is unavoidable.
- harry8 11y agoYes absolutely everyting counts as free speech. That's the whole point. Neither you, nor anybody else gets to have an opinion on the content on behalf on anyone else. Porn is merely an example. Once you allow one through there's always a way to expand it. We've seen this often enough now for it not to be a simple platitude or a slippery slope argument. Of course in addition to trusting someone else's opinion you also have to trust their competence.
- anigbrowl 11y agoThere is absolutely no excuse for a company—particularly one that has made commitments to free expression by being a founding member of the Global Network Initiative—to regulate speech beyond that which is required. Your search results aren't speech. While I am opposed to almost all censorship, I can't get too worked up about this, because Microsoft understandably doesn't want to get prosecuted/ sued/ protested against in countries with much more conservative social norms. Of course, Bing is just a delivery service for information about what sort of things exist on the internet, but given the well-known human proclivity to 'blame the messenger' and Microsoft's global reach caution is understandable.
- makmanalp 11y agoMaybe this points to a larger problem - the primary way to navigate the web today is centralized search engines. So much so that when you disable the address bar search features in browsers, people stumble quickly. While search results aren't speech, they are how people get to speech.
- anigbrowl 11y agoAbsolutely. It's a real problem and if I were in a country where search results are censored (by the government) or restricted (by the search vendor) I would certainly be doing whatever I could to find a way around that. This is unfortunate because now all the legal risk falls on me (eg if I am caught using Tor or somesuch) and a search engine operator is much better able to bear the legal risk and uncertainty than individual citizens of a repressive country or region. On the other hand, I don't think the search firm is obliged to put itself or its employees in legal or political harm's way by exporting their home country's standards of free speech. Even in the US, I see Google is regularly blamed for providing results that are deemed racist or offensive even when those results are skewed by the behavior of users, deliberate or otherwise.
- sliverstorm 11y agoWhile search results aren't speech, they are how people get to speech. At least in the USA - You aren't guaranteed a platform for your speech, and you aren't guaranteed other people will listen to you. All you are guaranteed is that the government won't persecute you for saying it. So a private company that does not promote your speech, is not a violation of the 1st Amendment.
- joshuaheard 11y agoA lot of websites are censored around the world, and it's not just from search results: you can't access the actual sites. In the middle east, it's porn. In China, no Facebook. In France, it's Netflix. I see no reason why this is on Microsoft.
- it_learnses 11y agothe problem though is that they use strict Saudi Wahabi standards for relatively liberal countries like Lebanon and Egypt. Microsoft is going above and beyond what is required of them in terms of censorship.
- Lorento 11y agoDon't dating sites have an 18 year age limit despite different states having different ages of consent, etc? It's just easier than making a fine grained filter.
- it_learnses 11y agoNot sure. Although I have seen many sites and companies have contests where it's not applicable to certain provinces or states. Also I think states vs countries is a bit different. Why not then just apply the saudi standards to our content as well?
- briandear 11y agoNetflix is not censored in France. I'm sitting in my coach in Avignon right now watching Breaking Bad while reading HN.
- codeisawesome 11y agoYou beast, you.
- TheWoodsy 11y agoIf you want to come into my house and use the internet, that's fine. But you will do so through my firewall. If the EFF then writes an article about my 'restrictive' firewall. I'll tell them to politely fsck off. I am not condoning the filtering of search results, and never will. In the grand picture we all know that this censoring gig never works. But where does the EFF get this idea that they have the right to berate a company and insinuate that they disobey a governments rules/laws/standards in their own country? It's a bit much 'aint it?
- kranner 11y agoIf you read the article carefully, they are berating Microsoft for going above and beyond the specific legal requirements per country.
- sangnoir 11y ago>"There is absolutely no excuse for a company—particularly one that has made commitments to free expression by being a founding member of the Global Network Initiative— to regulate speech beyond that which is required" . You are misunderstanding the EFF - they are not asking Microsoft to disobey the government but for Microsoft to not go overboard with the censoring. Currently they are censoring more than they are being asked to ('beyond that which is required' bit). It's like they are adding more restrictions to your already restrictive firewall - restrictions that you didn't ask for. To answer your question: no, it's not a bit much.
- partiallypro 11y agoIf they don't censor countries will just block them, it's the same fiasco Google had with Google years ago. Frankly I think it's better to censor and be there than to not be there at all. At least then people can maybe find ways around the filters to get the information they deserve to have unfettered access to.
- leavjenn 11y agoI think what you mean is "Google with China"?
- partiallypro 11y agoYou are correct, I can't fix the typo now. Too much time has passed, I guess.