17 ms·
Wealthfront: Silicon Valley Tech at Wall Street Prices
- caseyf7 11y agoHas anyone seen actual performance of Weathfront portfolios? You would think people would publish their results, but they've been hard to find.
- btian 11y agoJust look at the performance of underlying ETFs.
- isoos 11y agoBe aware that published results are heavily skewed, and are sampling bias towards the successful portfolios. Actively managed funds do outperform the market from time-to-time, and they do get published. However, not the same portfolios (year-over-year), not the same fund managers, not the same issuers... WealthFront and Vanguard and others who do passive fund management: they do get about market average. Not newsworthy, except that it is better than every other alternative on average.
- timcederman 11y agoHere you go - with risk level 6: http://i.imgur.com/5nchgSq.png http://i.imgur.com/5nchgSq.png This compares to 14.4% for VFIAX (Vanguard 500) in the same time period. In addition to the lower return, it's 0.37% in fees compared to 0.05%.
- maaku 11y agoAnd the 500 index has a lower return from being top heavy. You would have gotten even better ROI with a broad market index like VTI.
- timcederman 11y agoThese are not my only two investment vehicles.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dcosson 11y agoAs an anecdote, I've had some money in both Wealthfront and Betterment for the past 2 years. Both seem to be performing about the same, though betterment has better (but still very lacking) metrics on performance. They both show you what your money has done, but since I didn't deposit into both of them exactly the same amounts at exactly the same time every time, I can't compare them. Betterment at least shows some basic metrics about the time-weighted return over given periods in addition to your actual return, though you can't put in custom time windows. And of course, neither show you total fees you've paid in a time period. The time-weighted rate of return on my betterment allocation of 80% stocks/ 20% bonds is -0.9% in the past 12 months and 12.6% total since May 2013 when I opened it. By comparison the Vanguard 500 fund VFINX is up 3.8% in the past 12 months and 22.6% since May 2013 and looks like it has a 0.17% fee. So, it definitely does seem better than Betterment in every way. Meanwhile the S&P is up 4.6% in the past 12 months and up 23.8% since May 2013. Betterment and Wealthfront are very exposed to foreign markets, which somewhat ironically have been doing worse than the S&P for basically the whole time these services have existed yet they seem to be growing fast.
- deegles 11y agoYou're not doing tax loss harvesting in both portfolios are you? There are tax implications to that. Also, comparing returns on different portfolios in different services is meaningless. You could have had a bond-weighted portfolio in one service and a stock-weighted portfolio in the other; saying that one service is better than the other because it had better returns makes no sense. The service you use can't possibly influence the performance of its underlying funds. You should compare them on factors like features offered, ease of use, fees, customer service, etc.
- Yhippa 11y ago10.9% since October 2013. Risk tolerance level 10.
- U6Gf8WQP 11y ago17.4% since early 2013, risk level 7.5. http://i.imgur.com/I9SDElU.png http://i.imgur.com/I9SDElU.png I don't think the number includes tax deferrals from loss harvesting. For example in 2014 I "lost" (harvested) about $40k -- note that my account ended in the black in 2014 -- that I paired with a short-term capital gain (read: high-tax gain), deferring those taxes and letting them compound until the far future when I am hopefully in a lower tax bracket.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 11y agoI don't understand the three first paragraphs (about A/B testing). I install an app costing me 1 dollar and then the developer use this profit to install an app ruining him/her? What?
- kenferry 11y agoHe's noting the irony of how punishing "your" (the developer's) margins are, vs how easily you hand your hard-fought cash over to the high-margin wealthfront.
- cbhl 11y agoI think the first three paragraphs are supposed to appeal to Silicon Valley engineers. The idea is that a lot of {Facebook, Google, etc.} employees spend their day doing a task with negligible world impact and then put their paycheck into Wealthfront for investment/retirement.
- gohrt 11y ago> install an app ruining him/her? it's a metaphor, imagining Wealthfront's fees as though it were the subscription fee for an app.
- thisisit 11y agoThe second para says it all: "Should he beat the odds, he’ll then take your 70 cents and plow them into another app on his phone. This app will not only charge him every day for the rest of his life, but it also increased his fee last year by over a dollar a month."
- pbreit 11y agoKey point: 99.9% of US individual investors would be wise to make a Vanguard Life Strategy or Target Retirement fund a core holding. Otherwise, the screed was a little nasty (a bit nastier than the Wealthfront post).
- kenferry 11y agoI've often wondered about precisely the author's issue – why do wealthfront, betterment, et. al. charge a percentage of assets under management? Is it just that no competitor has offered a flat rate yet, or is there intrinsically more work involved in trading larger sums? To this one point: > All these cases neglect to mention that you will probably only see the maximal gain if you are maximally messing up already, by needlessly churning your account to generate capital gains. As Vanguard’s founder advises: Don’t just do something; stand there. The author is listed as "Former Director of Product @ Facebook". If he received a portion of his compensation in Facebook stock, he needed to sell out of that position regularly to avoid being over invested. That should have had generated more in capital gains than tax loss harvesting could offset.
- x0x0 11y agoBecause why not charge high prices if suckers pay them.
- kenferry 11y agoThere are something like 10 robo advisors. If a competitor could undercut wealthfront and get more business, why wouldn't they?
- hayksaakian 11y agoif the increase in businesses does not offset the decrease in prices lets say you charge X instead of Y% now assume that on average, others are charging 2X after calculating individual percentages if you only get 30% more clients charging X instead of 2X you're actually making less money.
- gohrt 11y agoThe entire VC-based economy is designed around using capital investment to buy time to grow your audience with low proces.
- gohrt 11y ago
- digitalzombie 11y agoThere's a PBS video about this. It also talk about Vanguard being a very good mutual fund and every other mutual funds are making bank off of you through fees. The video also advocate either Vanguard mutual funds or ETF.
- rjst 11y agoYes, Vanguard is way ahead in this. However, if you’re not American, it’s not always the best choice, as your returns may be lower because of tax issues.
- frinxor 11y agothe short of it: Wealthfront markets itself as cheaper than vanguard etfs, but they actually charge 0.25% + ETF fees on top of that. one of my favorite quotes: "Here it is: If you open a retirement account, and you invest some of your paycheck each month into a Vanguard Target Retirement Fund, and you just…leave it…you just leave it right there until retirement… …you don’t do anything when the folks on CNBC announce that the sky is falling; you don’t do anything when Cousin Eddy calls from a secure underground bunker in the badlands and says that the fed is printing money and it’s time to liquidate and ammo up; you don’t think it’s a sign that your parrot said “fuhgeddaboutit” but you thought she said “get a nugget” and surely that must mean a gold nugget? and you looked online and noticed that the price of shiny yellow metal was crashing and wait your parrot is also yellow and I’ll be damned if that isn’t a sign to buy… … no, if you just leave it there to compound over decades…"
- cmdkeen 11y agoThe key thing with fees is that high fees are often a sign of a poor manager or poor client service. Vanguard can charge low fees because they have huge amounts of money invested with them, as do other successful asset managers. The problem, as the article points out, is that people don't understand compounding - and have been brought up to associate paying a bit more with better products. I work at a successful asset management fund, one that looks after Vanguard money. The vast majority of our staff's pension investments take exactly this strategy.
- solve 11y agoThis puzzled me that, for the past few years, YC has wanted so badly to invest in more or less traditional style wealth management companies. It's so extremely hard to outperform existing methods in terms of returns. For user experience, these are the kind of things that are best if totally automatic, with no interface at all. So I guess they just compete purely for growth and that's it - like the commercials for popular drugs on TV, it's an industry 99% about advertising? SV tech + extremely risk averse, mature, competitive space = doesn't seem to be a good fit.
- jackgavigan 11y ago
- gohrt 11y ago> the kindly rabbi who performed your bris mohel performs a bris, not a rabbi > It’s why you’re receiving 2% cash back on your credit card while your neighbor pays 12% on his. This is mostly because merchants pay a fee, and the CC company kicks it back to you. > I’m not asking why Wealthfront helps itself to such margins, which is obvious and perfectly normal, but rather why the market bears it AirBnB and Uber and real estate agents do the same thing [price-proportional fees, not cost-proportional fees or flat fees]... Anyway, it's not as bad Blake rants about. Flat fees hurt the least-wealthy customers. 1. It's progressive. Wealthier customers pay more. That's good for sociery. 2. It's not inherently a scam, anymore than airline tickets or home sales. Ultimately, they compete in the market, and have to price competitively. Companies will lower prices to attract customers (if competition arrives), but maintain their profit to stay in business.
- swang 11y agoOK I don't know shit about investing/financing and would like to change that. Where do I start? I read the article and nod my head and go, "OK ETFs!" But then I go and there are tons of them. Is the one he suggested the one I'm suppose to go with regardless?
- kozhevnikov 11y agoA common advice that I'm yet to follow myself is to start by reading sidebars on /r/investing and /r/personalfinance specifically their wiki and FAQ. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/wiki/faq https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/wiki/faq [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index
- j_lev 11y agoIn typical chicken-egg fashion there is no better teacher than having skin in the game, but just make sure you know what you're doing before you jump in. Personally I tend to encourage people to read Bogleheads' Guide to Investing first. That should equip you with everything you need in order to get your feet wet. Then, while you're checking your investments every day (exactly the way the book tells you not to do), start to read as much as you can about Permanent Portfolio. The reason I recommend this is because it allows you to learn the theory of (and indeed watch, if you decide to build your own Permanent Portfolio) different asset classes, and how they move depending on various macroeconomic factors. Finally, if you want to start stock picking I'd recommend getting started with Peter Lynch's books.
- mokn 11y agoRead "A Random Walk Down Wall Street". Gives a great intro to the history and theory behind investing for those wanting to learn.
- j_lev 11y agoGood one. Forgot about this one. Intelligent Investor is good too as per other commenter but I find that it's quite hard reading for a beginner.
- 11y ago
- w23j 11y agoHere is a shot at a back-of-the-envelope calculation of the sum of fees paid in his first example. I hope I haven't misunderstood. var gain = 1.08; var fee = 0.0025; var feeSum = 0; var s = 100000; for (var i = 0; i < 35; i++) { s *= (gain - fee); feeSum *= gain; feeSum += s * fee; if ((i + 1) % 5 == 0) console.log('year: ' + (i + 1) + ', saved: ' + s + ', fees: ' + feeSum);}; year: 5, saved: 145240.0514760841, fees: 1823.9448097195082 year: 10, saved: 210946.72552775557, fees: 5329.071699986484 year: 15, saved: 306379.13274362596, fees: 11677.706523607205 year: 20, saved: 444985.2101088223, fees: 22746.568357507604 year: 25, saved: 646296.7482230144, fees: 41538.4561823357 year: 30, saved: 938681.7298073637, fees: 72821.71593023202 year: 35, saved: 1363341.8275688116, fees: 124120.0285076505
- throwaway3830 11y agoSo about a month ago I inherited just short of $30k. I don't need it right now, and don't plan on using it until either I buy a house (maybe 5 years away?) or retire. My plan was to invest it with Betterment, because I felt like that was the easiest and cheapest "set and forget" solution. But would there be substantial upside in going directly with a Vanguard fund instead? I'm really new to this and the convenience of a dedicated interface like Wealthfront/Betterment feels valuable to me, but if I'm leaving substantial money on the table doing that I'd rather go to the extra effort of figuring something else out.
- mooreds 11y agoIf you plan to use the money in less than 5 years, put it in a savings account t. I like capital one 360 (formerly Ing Direct), but any one will do. The most important part of investing is knowing your time horizon--stocks or stocks and bonds are just too risky for any time.hirozion less than 5 years.
- gjm11 11y agoIf you plan to use the money in less than 5 years and know you will need about 30k then put it in a savings account or something of the kind. On the other hand, if you have no specific plans for that money, and you would just like as much money as possible in 5 years' time, on average you are likely (on past performance) to have more in 5 years if you put it into the stock market than if you put it into a savings account. (And if you know that in 5 years' time you will desperately need about 100k and have no other way of getting that money, go to a casino or something. Fortunately, that's a rather uncommon situation.)
- Danieru 11y agoOr just buy a bond etf that matches your horizon. If you super duper do not want any variance then just buy regular bond. Finance is complex because there exists a product for any need.
- srj 11y ago5 years is a bit of a cutoff point. Less than that you typically want a CD and more than that you want an intermediate term bond index. You could put 20k in CDs and 10k in bonds which would have the nice side effect of giving you experience.
- mooreds 11y agoI would love to see the proportional fee killed. Even Vanguard charges this (though their fees are smaller, they are still a percentage). But the fact is the effort required to manage $10M is not 10x the effort required to manage $1M (especially with software). So why do we pay 10x as much? Because we always have! That's the opportunity in front of Silicon Valley with regards to wealth management.
- amorphid 11y agoI wonder what Wealthfront's costs are per client per year. Do their costs have a variable component, or is a flat $X/year per account?
- srj 11y agoVanguard does reduce the fee in many of its funds as the investment amount becomes larger. The tiers are Investor, Admiral, Institutional, and Institutional Plus. Some of these you can get in a 401k plan negotiated by your employer. VIIIX for example is an S&P fund with a 0.02% expense ratio.
- mooreds 11y agoYes, I know about this. I realized after posting the comment that the way to get a fixed price index fund (where the fee is not tied to the asset size) is just to buy stocks directly. Once you pay the one time commission, you own the stock forever with no yearly management fee. Of course, that comes with other costs (you have to adjust yourself when the index changes, commission when you sell, etc).
- srj 11y agoWhich index? If it's an S&P500 one that's 500 stocks to buy. What happens when companies enter the S&P500 or exit it? You would need to trade again which means more commission fees. What if one company in the index grows considerably while another one falls in value? Do you rebalance between those two? More commissions. Index funds hide all of this and I would guess it winds up cheaper particularly if you include effort.
- jycool 11y agoAs much as I think the article makes great points (tax-loss harvesting seems oversold, and Vanguard is a much cheaper way to get a target date fund than Wealthfront), I gotta raise my hand here and point out the absurdity of this argument against proportional fees. Wealth management is like any business-- a combination of fixed and variable costs. And like many businesses, it amortizes those fixed costs against basically a variable fee structure because the value of the service to the customer (debatable as it may be for some investment products) is proportional to the account size. It's not an SV vs WS thing. Nobody charges according to the marginal cost of the service. Why does Airbnb charge a percentage of the rental cost? Why does Uber get a percentage of the fare? Why does the restaurant charge me the same for a burger at 10pm as a burger at 7pm (after all, the staff are already being paid for the day and ingredients already purchased)? It might sound good to say "hey, the software's not working any harder so the marginal cost is zero", but that doesn't work in almost any business.
- jackgavigan 11y ago> Why does the restaurant charge me the same for a burger at 10pm as a burger at 7pm (after all, the staff are already being paid for the day and ingredients already purchased)? Actually, it's not uncommon for a food vendor to drop its prices at the end of the day, e.g. https://www.itsu.com/about/sale https://www.itsu.com/about/sale That doesn't invalidate your point, though. I'd also suggest that the risk associated with a transaction should also be factored in. The cost of processing small (e.g. $100) and large ($100,000) transactions may be the same but the potential cost to me if I drop the ball is several orders of magnitude larger.
- mrgordon 11y agoYeah good points. Additionally, Vanguard is making money through securities lending which is also proportional and can offset much or all of the expense ratio. "In 2012 securities lending enhanced annual fund returns by more than 1 basis point for over 60% of Vanguard's participating funds, by more than 5 basis points for nearly a third of funds, and by more than 10 basis points for over 15% of funds."
- 11y ago
- hundt 11y agoThe author's points about advertising and hidden fees are well-taken. Regarding "Stop charging proportional fees": if Vanguard, who charges proportional fees, is operating "at cost" as the author claims, then what is all that extra money paying for? The implication is that technology could be a game-changer because it unlinks the size of the effort from the size of the effect, but surely that is already happening with Vanguard's 12-digit funds.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoLet's say we kill proportional fee and replace it with a fixed fee. Well, then people with lower balances will end up most likely paying more than they do now. Another issue, it is proportionally harder to execute a larger portfolio than a smaller one. So, proportional fee makes sense. Having said that, yes, it is true that it is not clear to me why as a Vanguard customer I should switch part of my portfolio to Wealthfront.
- gphil 11y agoThe only thing any investor can control with any certainty is fees and taxes, so you might as well focus your effort on minimizing these. For the most part, Vanguard funds are the best at this that I know of.
- matwood 11y agoVanguard definitely led the way, but Fidelity (maybe others) has low fee funds similar to Vanguard. Last time I checked, Fidelity looked like they priced their funds by doing Vanguard price minus .01 point.
- kmonsen 11y agoReally? This is quite new and contradicts that: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/best-target-date-funds-fidelity-vs-vanguard-2015-04-15 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/best-target-date-funds-fide...
- matwood 11y agoNot all funds obviously. I also use a boggle head portfolio so the target date funds are not much interest. For example, the total stock market index from Fidelity and Vanguard. FSTMX .10% http://financials.morningstar.com/fund/expense.html?t=FSTMX®ion=usa&culture=en_US http://financials.morningstar.com/fund/expense.html?t=FSTMX&... VTSMX .17% http://financials.morningstar.com/fund/expense.html?t=VTSMX®ion=usa&culture=en_US http://financials.morningstar.com/fund/expense.html?t=VTSMX&...
- vasilipupkin 11y agoWealthfront should compete not just on trying to execute the same old indices, but on creating new indices on the fly. For example, REIT Index Sans Illinois, Emerging Markets Sans Russia, etc. Infinite number of possible index portfolios. Anyone want to build that? send me a message
- thisisit 11y agoWhile the idea is interesting, I am curious what would be the market for a newer index? This combined with creating and maintaining a market to run this index, it will be an expensive proposition.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoWhy does it have to be expensive ? Imagine you live in Texas and already have high exposure to Texas real estate. It's reasonable to be able to construct a index fund ex texas real estate, as an example. Better tailor your investment options to your actual risks
- thisisit 11y agoNot from the customer front but on the operations front. To clarify, even if you have an index, there must be enough liquidity to run a market where your index is trading. In the early days with less liquidity the company will need to pick up some of the orders. This at the end depending on the value proposition might turn out to be costly.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoUS REIT index Sans Texas would be less costly because you would have fewer stocks to trade
- thisisit 11y agoAh ok. I see what you meant when Folio was mentioned. I was thinking something else. I was building something like that but don't have the tech capabilities so had stopped.
- somberi 11y agoA father, who is a banker shows his son "This is our Yacht and those are our brokers''". Son asks "Dad, where are the customers' yachts?". A book, written in 1930s, based on this quip still remains one of my favourite books about Wall street. Link: http://www.amazon.com/Where-Are-Customers-Yachts-Street/dp/0471770892 http://www.amazon.com/Where-Are-Customers-Yachts-Street/dp/0...
- Bostonian 11y agoHas someone created a web site that uploads your portfolio and makes tax loss harvesting suggestions for a fixed fee?Competition is what brings prices down.
- troydavis 11y agoIf you do want financial advice as an hourly service, it exists. In the US, look at the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors: https://www.napfa.org/ https://www.napfa.org/. Many provide hourly consulting, just like you'd pay an attorney or accountant. By far the biggest risk of doing this is not having a constant presence during bear markets to coach you to stay the course. If you're actually comfortable enough in the amount of risk you've taken, this is less of an issue. The best doc I found on where or how wealth managers can add value was written for wealth managers (by Vanguard, which provides custodial services): http://www.vanguard.com/pdf/ISGQVAA.pdf http://www.vanguard.com/pdf/ISGQVAA.pdf Page 4 has the table. The biggest benefit - in their analysis, up to 1.5% of possible value added - is coaching. Deciding what's right for you depends on understanding what parts of planning and executing you're actually comfortable taking primary responsibility for.
- dataker 11y agoWealthfront markets itself as an innovative fintech startup, but I see it as nothing but an asset mgt company that hired some developers to "prop it up". Not to commit an ad hominem, but I don't see tech-driven founders and/or a very strong engineering culture. https://www.wealthfront.com/management https://www.wealthfront.com/management
- robzyb 11y agoI work in the finance industry and only today found out about both Wealthfront and Betterment. Betterment is utterly awesome. Truly a product I'd expect to see from an innovative fintech startup. Wealthfront is... not.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoSo you just learned about Wealthfront and Betterment today and somehow you've determined that Betterment is "utterly awesome" and Wealthfront isn't? I hope that whatever your role in finance, it isn't related to due diligence.
- robzyb 11y agoI might've been a bit too black-and-white with my comment, let me clarify... Betterment seems utterly awesome. Truly a product I'd expect to see from an innovative fintech startup. Wealthfront did not. It was clear that Betterment cared about making a beautiful consumer-driven product. It was also clear that they've spent some time reimagining how personal finance works. Simplifying it. I also can't help but note that the fact that Betterment made me so excited (it really did) so quickly probably speaks very well of it. But then again, I'm a sample of 1. (Incidentally, I read your HN profile and rather liked the story in your 'about')
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoYes, these days it's really difficult to credibly market yourself as an innovative company without a pair of 20-something lumbersexual founders who haxored their way into an exposed-brick office in SoMa. If Wealthfront really wants to prove that it's tech-driven, it should stop sharing technical knowledge[1] and organize more hackathons. Preferably hackathons in which the beer and laptop stickers flow freely. [1] http://eng.wealthfront.com/ http://eng.wealthfront.com/
- icedchai 11y agoSo Wealthfront is for people who can't open their own Vanguard account and set up automated transfers/investments?
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoNot sure that 100,000k account for $20 a month is that good a deal. I have about that in my UK TD ISA and don't pay any account charges
- blufox 11y agoFrom The little book of common sense investing by John Bogle. "Thus, the recent era not only has failed to erode, but has nicely enhanced the lifetime record of the world’s first index fund—now known as Vanguard 500 Index Fund. Let me be specific: at a dinner on September 20, 2006, celebrating the 30th anniversary of the fund’s initial public offering, the counsel for the fund’s underwriters reported that he had purchased 1,000 shares at the original offering price of $15.00 per share—a $15,000 investment. He proudly announced that the value of his holding that evening (including shares acquired through reinvesting the fund’s dividends and distributions over the years) was $461,771. "
- dwaltrip 11y agoThat comes out to about 12% per year, compounded. Makes sense given the huge multi-decade bull market that began in the early 80s (2006 - 30 years = 1976). But certainly not something you can rely on. For comparison, with a 5% annual return, you get $64k. With an 8% annual return, you get $150k.
- maaku 11y agoS&P gains since inception are on the order of 11%. It is something you can rely upon (see: Trinity study on portfolio survivability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study)
- sharkweek 11y agoFor some absolutely insane reason I sometimes get the feeling that I can outpick a fund with individual stocks, because "Hey, I follow this whole tech world really closely! Surely I can pick some big winners!" It has been a somewhat expensive lesson that I have absolutely no clue what's going on, but every once in a while I just can't help but try. I keep a little fun money in individual equities, and the rest now sits safely in funds. My aggregate individual funds always lose out to what has been relatively steady fund performance.
- kelukelugames 11y ago
- rgbrgb 11y ago> the financial advisor who treats his esteemed clients to FREE! luxury box seats at the big game (* when you pay him $10,000 a year). Always be suspicious of lavish gifts from someone who's services you employ... often means you're overpaying. We see this in real estate all the time. A broker who just made $80k on a week's work will often send their client a $200 gift card or take them out to a fancy dinner to "celebrate" (and alleviate guilt?).
- akeefer 11y agoThis post kind of misses the main point of services like Wealthfront. You're paying 0.25% in exchange for automatic rebalancing, asset class diversification, and tax optimization. If the combination of those factors is going to increase your yearly return by 0.25% or more (say, from 6.8% to 7.2%), it's worth it. If they won't, it's not. It's silly to focus entirely on the fee aspect: the point of using Wealthfront is not because it's lower-cost, it's because you expect it to be better-performing from a total-return perspective. They may oversell themselves, and that's a valid criticism, but the OP fails to really analyze the raison d'etre of Wealthfront as a service. Comparing it to a single Vanguard ETF is not a proper comparison. The Vanguard target retirement fund for 2035, for example, includes four underlying ETFs (US stock, international stock, US bonds, international bonds), whereas Wealthfront portfolios typically have more like six or seven asset classes (differentiating between developed and emerging international markets, and adding in natural resources and real estate). Left to my own devices, I don't have the time or inclination to do the research necessary to do that sort of additional asset diversification myself, determining the ideal allocation and then avoiding too much drift while not incurring too much tax. I also don't have the time to deal with tax loss harvesting, which might not matter for retirement accounts, but does make a difference for taxable accounts: you're likely incurring some taxation issues when it comes to portfolio rebalances, for example, since that necessarily involves asset sales. If you have $100k in wealthfront, you're paying $250/year in fees. If tax loss harvesting can only harvest $1k in losses during the year that offset (or at least avoid) $1k in capital gains, that still pays for the wealthfront fees by itself (if you assume 15% federal and 10% CA state tax on long-term capital gains). So, sure, the fees you pay wealthfront compound over time, but so does the money you pay in taxes. (You do eventually pay the taxes on that gain, of course, but the money you save now compounds over time, so you still come out significantly ahead). So the question is: does additional asset class diversification plus tax optimization yield at least a 0.25% increase in your total return (net of taxes and fees) in an average year? I believe it does in my case, hence why I have my money with them. It's not because I'm some idiot taken in by slick marketing who can't do math and doesn't know about Vanguard ETFs: Wealthfront's core market is really people who can do math and understand what they're getting for their 0.25%. Similarly, you can quibble over asset-based fees over fixed fees, but that also misses the point: as long as they make me more money than I pay them, I come out ahead. If I come out ahead, why would I be complaining? If I don't come out ahead, then there's still no point in complaining: just don't use the service. Capitalism at its finest. Again, it's sad that the OP and most of the comments in this thread don't even attempt to tackle the real value proposition here. Just saying "Stick it in a Vanguard ETF and you'll pay less in fees" is not at all addressing whether or not the core value proposition is valid.
- hchenji 11y agoDoes anyone here use wisebanyan? They claim $0 fees and still do the robo advising (i.e., solving the portfolio allocation problem).
- arbitrage314 11y agoWealthfront is indeed a ripoff for the well-informed. For most folks, though, something that makes saving simple is something that will lead to HUGE gains over not having that thing in the first place. Without Wealthfront, most people would simply let that money sit in a checking account or in a user-made nondiversified portfolio (most people don't understand the incredible benefits of diversification, including myself most days, which is why we work at startups :) ). Therefore, I still believe the value of Wealthfront is positive, and likewise, I believe the value of most financial planners is positive.
- U6Gf8WQP 11y ago> Wealthfront is indeed a ripoff for the well-informed. Do you feel that this is universally true or situation-dependent? I consider myself reasonably informed and Wealthfront appears to be a strong, if not the strongest, option for my financial situation (young, most of my net worth is in a taxable account, direct indexing, regular expected capital gains to pair with tax losses).
- maaku 11y agoFirst of all, you are probably not taking full advantage of tax-efficient accounts. Are you contributing your maximums, including back door strategies? Second, you can do substantially better than Wealthfront with even an extremely lazy portfolio. Heck, put all of your funds into a Vanguard target-date fund (the laziest of the laziest) and you will do better than Wealthfront, with only 15 min of effort per year to rebalance. The kind of tax loss harvesting Wealthfront does is usually a pseudo-benefit. You're usually in a better position just holding until you need distributions for retirement. On paper it sometimes works out, but only when you make assumptions that generally involve timing the market to harvest without loss while avoiding wash sale rules. That said, if you can't be trusted or can't trust yourself to buy a simple lazy portfolio and hold for decades, then by all means pay the 0.25% annual fee to have someone else take the management keys away from you. As one of my coworkers said, Wealthfront is lazy advice -- telling someone to use Wealthfront is easy to do and usually gets that person into a better position than they otherwise would be, and requires minimal effort from me in advising them. But it is not the optimal solution out there and anyone can easily do better if they are willing to learn and capable of exerting self control.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>There are other options available that would enable you to stop working years earlier The only real option that enables people, on average, to stop working is automation.
- rgarcia 11y agoHere's my understanding: if you use Wealthfront direct indexing, you mostly hold stocks, so you pay a minimal amount in ETF fees. This means your expense ratio is pretty close to the Wealthfront fee of 0.25%. If you put everything in a Vanguard target retirement fund, your expense ratio is something like 0.18%. [1] So as long as tax loss harvesting adds a tiny fraction of a percent (~0.07%) to your returns, it seems optimal to use Wealthfront, no? [1] https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundId=0699&FundIntExt=INT https://personal.vanguard.com/us/funds/snapshot?FundId=0699&...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- maaku 11y agoWealthfront fee is ON TOP OF the underlying ETFs.
- asift 11y agoThis is correct. Also, tax-loss harvesting isn't the only benefit of direct indexing. Charitable gifting of highly appreciated securities is a potentially huge benefit that direct indexing has over ETFs (even better given that it doesn't ratchet down your basis like TLH or create wash sale issues).
- leadhacks 11y agoI ran some numbers and Blake's idea could bring the cost down by 40-60% https://medium.com/@bluf/the-robotraders-versus-blake-ross-a51ce36a8ae4 https://medium.com/@bluf/the-robotraders-versus-blake-ross-a...