4 ms·
Wait what? > Biology usually doesn't work. No. This is not true. Biology usually works, it's that the most interesting academic things tend to be on the ble
by dnautics 11y ago
Wait what?
> Biology usually doesn't work.
No. This is not true. Biology usually works, it's that the most interesting academic things tend to be on the bleeding edge, and that's where things are not robust.
Of course, I'm not saying that there isn't debugging to be done, but it's not THAT hard. I'm doing something relatively difficult literally in my garage right now (growing a strain with a doubling time of about 6 hours). I can reproducibly make the anticancer compound in one of my strains and am working on debugging and getting a second strain running. (https://benchling.com/ityonemo/f/cHjBceoz-project-marilyn/etr-etHejg9x-culture-test-2/edit https://benchling.com/ityonemo/f/cHjBceoz-project-marilyn/et...)
> Even the simplest wet-lab reactions take very exacting conditions to work.
Not true. For example I have done over 300 gibson assembly reactions and have taught an intern to do this, he made 50 constructs in 2 months, with time left over for him to biochemically test 25 of them. My procedure was literally, take 1 microlitre of each DNA (don't even bother measuring), and throw on top an equal volume of gibson mix, and then go. Worked nearly every time.
It is quite true that equipment requires a high capital expenditure and it's hard to start up, but those problems are able to be overcome. (e.g. http://blog.indysci.org/starting-a-lab-under-budget/ http://blog.indysci.org/starting-a-lab-under-budget/) For example, I have bacterial growth incubator that was being thrown out by herbalife when they upgraded their microbiological QC lab.
- searine 11y ago>it's not THAT hard. No, not hard, just crazy expensive. >Biology usually works Under the most basic circumstances. Most startups won't have a business model based on doing PCRs with a master-mix. >For example I have done over 300 gibson assembly reactions and have taught an intern to do this, he made 50 constructs in 2 months, with time left over for him to biochemically test 25 of them. Likely at a corporation with money to blow on facilities, equipment, and reagents. We are talking bare-bones start-up here. >I'm doing something relatively difficult literally in my garage right now If you want to make impure vitamins and cram them into pills, yeah I guess, but if we are talking even rudimentary biotech level work, then a garage just won't cut it.
- dnautics 11y agoDo you not understand how cheap a gibson assembly is? I priced it out, and each assembly cost on average $2 for the reaction $10 for the competent cells, and maybe about $30 in other costs. Now there is some infrastructure required: If you don't have a -80 to keep competent cells, you would require some tools to make competent cells (like a microfuge spinner) but that infrastructure is not totally expensive.
- bbgm 11y agoAll my experience working in and with biotech/pharma has taught me that your experiments will usually fail. The later they fail the more expensive. Biology is ridiculously hard and certainly not predictable. Aspects are reproducible and engineering-friendly, but most of it is not.
- dnautics 11y agoI think this is a toxic attitude. A friend of mine worked at a bioenergy outfit working on cellulosic ethanol and that was the pervading opinion. For years she tried to convince them that the problem was they weren't controlling their inputs, and finally they did her experiment after she made a statistical argument after a massive DOE setup failed. Turned out they were limiting in a basic metabolic requirement. It's too easy to blame biology when it is often just user error. Bio equivalent of pebkac They started getting reproducible results, then, major improvements, then the facility got shut down for political reasons and she lost her job.
- DaveWalk 11y ago> it's not THAT hard. I'm doing something relatively difficult literally in my garage right now That's great for your cell-based experiments; and many of the greatest biology discoveries were made with this toolset in the first half of the 20th century. But what about in vivo experiments with mice and rats? What about X-ray crystallography? What about high throughput screening and counterscreening in the range of millions done before a compound is even considered to be a drug candidate? This is hard stuff, and it's necessary stuff. Exacting conditions are absolutely essential to achieve the highest chance of reproducibility. Even so, it has been famously reported that somewhere around 11% of published findings can be reproduced independently[0]. [0] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v483/n7391/full/483531a.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v483/n7391/full/483531a...
- dnautics 11y agoA five armed mouse study for an anticancer drug runs in the 10-60k range (I can't give my exact quote at the moment). This is inexpensive. The expensive stuff is when you go into humans.
- DaveWalk 11y agoI guess if you're outsourcing it? In my time in academia I knew labs that burned through $25,000 per month in mouse cage costs. I can only guess what "five arms" you are referring to, but toxicity studies and efficacy studies often require different animals. Not just mice but transgenic mice, or nude mice with xenografts, etc. This has to be pricey to get the statistical power you need for a drug candidate. I've also heard that the FDA likes to see more than one animal, so either rats or monkeys may be dosed as well. It all adds up.
- dnautics 11y agoWell no one is going to get a drug approved for the FDA exclusively from the garage, but there is a reasonable amount of initial stage research that you could conceivably do from your garage. My project is to push that out to the 'xenograft' stage, which in my opinion is close to the limit, if not the limit. Full disclosure, I'm doing the chemistry in a rented chemistry lab space because I don't want to suffocate myself with chloroform. Five arms, refers to an experiment with three dosages, a null control and a positive control. Yes, you can outsource things, which is exactly what I'm doing (it's cheaper and more ethical), but also the model has become really good where you don't have to sack an animal for each time point. That cuts down on costs by a lot.
- timr 11y agoNo offense, but nothing you've described is what I'd characterize as "difficult". I looked at your benchling link, and it's stuff that most labs give to undergrad work-study kids to get their feet wet with labs. Mostly it's about having access to the right equipment. Ligation reactions are trivial if -- as you've noted -- you use a (relatively expensive) kit. It's just a matter of time and labor costs, and with these new tools, you can trade some money for time/labor. That much is true, but it's never really been the limiting factor in biology. It's the constant on the algorithmic complexity of research. When the parent says that "even the simplest wet-lab reactions take very exacting conditions to work", they're not really talking about transforming cells with plasmids and autoclaving plates. The conditions are exacting, but the equipment to provide those conditions is not exotic. The hard, expensive part of biology is the part where someone spends weeks/months/years using those tools to make a new construct that should work, but then doesn't work, because unknown. Then you spend months trying to figure out what factor you're not accounting for, then you give up and start over from a new angle. Then you repeat for 5-7 years, and someone gives you a doctorate. Saying that biology mostly works is like saying that self-driving cars are easy because we can reliably attach computers to the steering wheel and the gas pedal. It's the parts we don't know about that cost the money.
- dnautics 11y agoPerhaps I should qualify what I mean by difficult: growing something with a doubling time of 6 hours is fundamentally more difficult than, say e. coli (40 minutes) because you have to worry about things like sterility, because other things can outgrow you. This is one of the primary concerns in a garage environment. I mean, I'm not a complete idiot here. I do have a PhD in biophysics/chemistry/biology and four years of postdoc experience. I've designed expression constructs nearly from whole cloth; I've done spectroscopy on metastable peptides; I've produced, characterized and sent for testing a mutasynthesis product; I've improved an enzyme four-fold. Of course all of those things were done in 'real labs', but the last two were done under budgetary pressure where there was a strong emphasis on getting things done cheaply (UMD is not very well-funded, J. Craig Venter Institute was making a painful transition from hard money to soft money). A lot of those lessons I learned under budgetary pressure translate to doing things in the garage, except, more extreme. I think the primary obstacle to people doing garage biology is not that the biology is hard, but that there are generally two classes of operators, those who have little biology experience, and those who have worked under coddled environments. The real trick is to find things that are maybe a little hard, but not insurmountably so, but with one or two difficult pain points. And which are also interesting. The first class of operator is not generally capable of identifying those qualities, the second class of operator is out of the habit of identifying those qualities. Biology really does mostly work, you're just looking at a biased system where people are just throwing money at problems and also looking for reasons to justify continuing to throw money at them (so they have to do hard things). That also creates silly folkways like the 'biology is hard' trope which makes the operators miss obvious things because it's just easier to say 'biology is hard' than to think about the problem and figure out how to solve it cheaply and effectively.