12 ms·
Chinese stock plunge leaves investors scouring state media for clues
- jackgavigan 11y agoA month ago, the amount of borrowed money invested in Chinese stocks was over $300bn. Margin calls will be exacerbating this drop in prices: http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2015/05/23/2003618925 http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2015/05/23/2003...
- EliRivers 11y agoFrom the article, a small investor: "China’s stock market is really different from other countries" It's different this time. I'm sure I've heard that before. Anyway, something tangential but a little bit interesting; it seems that an accountant quoted in this story, "Yao Lina", sold all her holding in February 2012: http://s-aint.com/store/files/Bloomberg_Business_News_Headlines_15.08.2012.pdf http://s-aint.com/store/files/Bloomberg_Business_News_Headli... And also in November 2013: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-01-21/china-ipos-no-lure-as-investors-empty-trading-accounts http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-01-21/china-ipos... And June 2015 in this article. All Bloomberg origin, as far as I can tell. Sure, maybe she really does binge on cycles of all in and all out, but it seems odd nonetheless. If I had to guess, if she does exist, she's a reliable source for journos who need an "ordinary chinese citizen" to tell them she's bailed out completely, and give them a good quote, always on the same theme: “I have no confidence in the stock market,” “I thought the market was going nuts and someone was coming to manipulate the market... I have no confidence in the market because there are lots of speculators playing in it.” ...the government may take as long as five years to fix “structural” challenges in the economy that have curbed growth. This most recent article contains an odd change of tone, though. She's still bailed out (so she says, again), but also “China’s stock market is really different from other countries. The government surely has some measures to control the movement.” I'm sure I've heard that before; people sure that the magical government can somehow stop a market crash. It would be interesting to work out how well her quoted comments match the official PRC government line (and unofficial government line) at the time; if she exists, is she a government mouthpiece, or just someone the journos know is always good for a negative quote about the Chinese market, from the small investor? I wouldn't be surprised if all these Bloomberg journos ever saw of her was a controlled press release of suitable comments and sources from China, for them to mine from to make their story.
- curiously 11y ago"China’s stock market is really different from other countries" Yeah, just add an opaque, government overseeing and controlling all information of Chinese stocks. Nothing to see here folks.
- dak1 11y agoThat graph seems a bit sensationalist by using ~2800 as the base of its y-axis, and the stocks are still up for the year. It looks like the stocks are down about 20% from their high, which isn't that unusual for a stock market (and probably is appropriate considering how much stocks went up this year).
- rndmind 11y agoI agree, I think the headline is sensational.
- dang 11y agoWe changed the sensational bit to a more representative phrase from the article.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoA 20% plunge in the West would be a disastrous thing or at least generate thousands of news articles about it, why does HN give a double standard to autocratic states? I keep hearing about how the ruble devaluation and now this are all perfectly fine. I don't think one article from Bloomberg is so horrible. Hell, I don't even see this on the front page of google news. Where is this massive sensationalism? Hell, is this even an issue on a site where pretty much all its politics is sensationalism to extremist degrees? Interesting what we find fault with here. There's some real stupid bias on HN honestly.
- ars 11y agoThe figure almost doubled in 2 months, then contracted 20%. If your stock is that volatile then 20% is not really newsworthy.
- adventured 11y agoTheir market has been in one of the greatest bubble runs in the history of stock markets. It's extraordinarily significant to see it go parabolic for weeks, then crash 20% in ten or so trading days, particularly given the amount of margin Chinese investors had taken on in such a short amount of time. It very likely points to a further drop ahead. I don't think you'll be regarding a 40% drop as not being newsworthy.
- ars 11y agoThe graph is quite misleading by not being logarithmic - it makes the gain seem smaller than it really is, and the loss larger. A logarithmic graph will show that this drop is minor compared to the rise before it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- adventured 11y agoWell here's the five year: http://i.imgur.com/3vMDYlx.jpg http://i.imgur.com/3vMDYlx.jpg That's the setup to an inbound market disaster if I've ever seen one. Especially given China's falling corporate earnings and all the other blatantly negative signals in their economy right now. This market run occurred solely due to margin, and not due to growth; the outcome was always obvious ahead of time.
- refurb 11y agoWow! That market doubled in the past year? I knew it was hot but I didn't know it was that hot. It will be interesting to see where this goes.
- Havoc 11y agoPretty sure nobody uses logarithmic graphs for stock prices...
- ars 11y agoAll serious investors do. Anyone who doesn't is misleading themself, which is a good way to lose money.
- stephengillie 11y agoFunny, it never came up while earning a finance degree.
- skylan_q 11y agoThe stock market is up 35% since March. I don't understand what's being reported.
- adventured 11y agoThat the bubble has likely popped in Chinese equities. $2 trillion - roughly 20%-25% - has been shaved off their markets in just two weeks or so. One of the largest, fastest stock market drops in world history in sheer dollar terms. To put that in perspective, about 8%-10% of China's household wealth just disappeared in two weeks (80% or so of all investors in the market are individuals). The stock market run has been helping to bail out a lot of homeowners that had previously bet on the real estate market continuing to go up perpetually. If both crash at the same time, it's going to hammer China's fragile economy (that has shrinking across the board already: exports, imports, PMI, electricity usage).
- hacknat 11y agoIt's not surprising at all. There have been reports of construction companies rebranding themselves as tech companies and doing a public offerings at P/E ratios that would make the hucksters of Silicon Valley circa 1999 blush. It will be interesting to see how it affects the rest of the world. That's the unpredictable part.
- jahnu 11y agoHow exposed to China is the rest of the world? If it's not a lot then it kind of doesn't matter as much.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- perfTerm 11y agoThe GP talked about how it would affect the rest of the world and P responded to that. It wasn't any sort of discount on the suffering many Chinese persons might feel if significant financial loss is incurred through a dramatic correction of the market.
- jahnu 11y agoRight I am just talking numbers here. I'm sure we're all aware of how vaguely economic number relate to the human experience.
- galago 11y agoYour comment makes me wonder how stock ownership is distributed amongst the Chinese population. Are these losses borne mostly by wealthy speculators, or are retirement funds and small investors caught up in this? An index fund is an unsophisticated type of hedge, but it doesn't work very well if there's widespread accounting corruption.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- myth_buster 11y agoSurely the times are interesting[0][1]. [0] http://i.imgur.com/C77vR9t.png http://i.imgur.com/C77vR9t.png [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_you_live_in_interesting_times https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_you_live_in_interesting_ti...
- stephengillie 11y agoThe true insult is "May you live in boring times."
- tormeh 11y agoHistory is usually not that fun for the people who living through it. With the exception of the greatest minds in science, history is usually about people dying violently or at least suffering a lot. Boring times don't sound so bad to me.
- shostack 11y agoAnyone care to speculate how that might impact real estate (short and long term), particularly US markets that have seen heavy Chinese investment?
- Mikeb85 11y agoProbably not too much. These are just trading losses. The SSE is still up quite a bit for the year.
- Mikeb85 11y agoLook at a 5 year chart. The SSE was simply over-bought. Any trader would tell you that. Now why was it over-bought? Part of the reason is because of the Shanghai-Hong Kong market link, which drove massive amounts of volume into Shanghai, and traders took advantage by taking on large margin accounts. When the savvy traders started booking profits, the rest were left to try cover their positions. The Hang-Seng (Hong Kong) dropped too, but by far less because it was priced much better. Anyhow, this has nothing to do with the Chinese economy, or even stock fundamentals. It's just that equity prices were driven up too high by traders. http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=000001.SS+Interactive#{"range":"5y","allowChartStacking":true} http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=000001.SS+Interactive#{"r... https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=%5EHSI#symbol=%5EHSI;range=5y https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=%5EHSI#symbol=%5EHSI;...
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThe Chinese economy isn't doing that great right now, so people were puzzling over the stock market boom. But as you say, these two things are almost completely separated at this point. Now if someone could tell me where to park my RMB savings...real estate? Stock market? Under my mattress? The real problem is that investment opportunities in China really aren't that great.
- zhte415 11y agoEasy opportunities aren't. By easy: click a switch and send money somewhere. But financing is huge. A lot of people and businesses don't have sufficient access to a functioning banking system or capital markets. Invest in small businesses / people you know. You're in Beijing - move out to the places that aspire to be more like a developed city, and just rinse and repeat.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI have a job in Beijing and frankly like it; I'm not an investor or a business guy, I'm just a programmer/researcher/geek who is living the life he wants to. If I was in the states, I would just throw my money in safe investments and buy a house; here all of that is impossible (well, you can do things with the banks, but kind of dodgy). My best bet is just to transfer money back home and play the American stock and real estate markets like my Chinese friends are already doing :p Business and investment in China is absolutely crazy: your partners are more likely to screw you over than not, and in order to win you have to be constantly on your toes. When public construction SOEs are rebranding as internet companies, you can bet the smaller hole in the walls are doing the same! Every third-tier city wants to be like Beijing. For example, my wife's hometown in Hunan (Chenzhou) has big aspirations but very little to offer. It is just heart break waiting to happen. Apartments being built everywhere shoddily without central heating...who wants to live in those?