6 ms·
However, I don't think there's a conclusion to be made about the actual method used here. I suspect that it worked because it was different, not because it carr
by analog31 11y ago
However, I don't think there's a conclusion to be made about the actual method used here. I suspect that it worked because it was different, not because it carried a fundamentally strong signal. If everyone did this, project descriptions would be gamed even more than resumes—it would select for people who prepared for the selection process² more than anything else.
I find myself almost irresistably drawn towards the conclusion that people will game the hiring process, because it is a game. It has winners and losers. Everybody is trying to make themselves look better than everybody else, even to the point of making themselves look better than they really are: Job candidates, employers, internal and external recruiters, everybody who is selling a hiring product, etc. Everybody is trying to emphasize their positives and hide their negatives, while searching for the negatives of the others.
A drawback to "do your own thing" is that it is enormously inefficient for candidates, and the results may turn out to be based on the luck of a particular candidate guessing a particular employer's game is, or being generally better at games.
I don't know a solution. What strikes me is that as broken as the system seems, we still manage to hire good people most of the time.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThe funny part is, in good old game theory fashion, the prime motivator for hiding your negatives and trumping up your positives is everyone else is doing it, so you must as well just to keep up.
- cbhl 11y agoThe process being broken isn't a deal-breaker for companies, which can still hire from the 90% that can deal with the broken system. It's a deal-breaker for the 10% that are bad at playing the game / jumping hoops / resume writing / interviews, because they can't get a job.
- stcredzero 11y agoIt's not so rosy for companies. The situation is akin to the one in large companies and bureaucracies where all numbers and estimates in all communications become "padded" and largely fictionalized -- precisely because "everyone is doing it." In such broken games, signals lose their meaning, and everyone ultimately loses. In academia, someone observed this: "The revolutionary idea of one generation becomes just the stuff you say to get tenure in the next generation."
- marcosdumay 11y agoIt's also a golden opportunity for anybody able to hire those 10%. Maybe most companies shouldn't be different. But there's plenty of value in not being like everybody else.
- cbhl 11y agoYup -- I'm excited for the Starfighter CTF by patio11, tptacek, et al.
- vonmoltke 11y agoExcept many of those companies are simultaneously bitching about "lack of talent".
- cbhl 11y agoI am biased, but I think that if it was possible in America to graduate with virtually zero student debt and 20-24 months of industry experience in a five-year bachelor's program, despite having little to no savings prior to starting college, leading software companies wouldn't need to import developers and engineers on H1Bs and TNs. Immigration lawyers are expensive, you know.
- NhanH 11y ago> I don't know a solution. What strikes me is that as broken as the system seems, we still manage to hire good people most of the time. Interestingly, the simplest conclusion would be that everyone is good, most of the time. So if we throw hiring out the windows and pick employee randomly, we might still get to the same result. Which actually isn't too outrageous, since if we have 10% unemployment, wouldn't it mean 90% of people (or more, actually) have to be value added?
- jckt 11y agoWould that completely backfire once everyone knows the selection process is random?
- NhanH 11y agoIt's just a thought experiment, random definitely doesn't work since specialization does exist. But otherwise, what do you think would backfire?
- derefr 11y agoWorked for the Ancient Greeks! "Pick someone at random for the job" was the actual, original meaning of "democracy." Elections are a weak imitation.
- davemel37 11y agoTrue, but the costs (both direct and ancillary) of making a bad hire are so high that anything we can do avoid making the wrong hire would be worthwhile. You might be right that randomly picking candidates might be just as efficient, but I can't imagine anyone taking that risk.
- sireat 11y agoI think the European practice of having a candidate on a 3 month evaluation period(when it is easy to fire) and then having a job security afterwards seems a reasonable balance between employer and employee needs. It is hard to pull wool over someone's eyes for 3 months especially in a results oriented field like programming.