11 ms·
Warner Bros Suspends Sales of Batman: Arkham Knight PC Version
- thescribe 11y agoIt seems there are quiet a few issues with this port. I wonder if this is a result of rushing QA?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kevingadd 11y agoRegardless of how competent the studio was, if they decided they wanted to hit a ship date for the original PS4 game and the two ports no matter what, and the port wasn't ready, this is what you get. People in QA or Programming over at a porting house don't have the ability to tell a publisher to slow down.
- minimaxir 11y agoNot true: Iron Galaxy, who did the Arkham Knight PC port, also did the Arkham Origins PC port: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Galaxy_Studios https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Galaxy_Studios IIRC, that port had technical issues, but not to the scale of Arkham Knight.
- mqatrombone 11y agoRocksteady didn't do Arkham Origins. Rocksteady is only responsible for Arkham Asylum and Arkham City.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tacticus 11y agoTechnical issues is an understatement. the main storyline wasn't completable.
- oxide 11y agoWhich they eventually fixed, only to then say 'no more patches. We're moving on to DLC'
- kevingadd 11y agoStuff this dramatic would have been noticed by QA, and almost certainly known to the programmers. The publisher decided to ship it in this state.
- minimaxir 11y agoIt should be noted that Warner Bros also recently published MKX on PC, which had similar issues. http://www.gamespot.com/articles/mortal-kombat-x-pc-patch-pulled-after-erasing-save/1100-6427111/ http://www.gamespot.com/articles/mortal-kombat-x-pc-patch-pu...
- georgehotelling 11y agoSomeone uncovered a Steam ID that suggests the PC developer Iron Galaxy only received the game 2 months ago: https://steamdb.info/sub/45433/ https://steamdb.info/sub/45433/
- Negitivefrags 11y agoAll that means is that they started the steam integration two months ago. That isn't an unreasonable time frame.
- Adam_O 11y agoA lot of game companies develop their AAAs with PS4/X1 in mind and the PC port is more of an afterthought. Though not the case here, it is usually released up to 6 months after the console version. I believe PC versions of games are often done by an external (or at least different) studio, and they are also assigned less Dev/QA resources. The responsibility for the quality of the PC port does not always fall on the management in charge of the console version, so a lot of faults can slip through the cracks.
- tacticus 11y agothe previous 2 rocksteady (Batman AA and batman AC) games were developed concurrently for 360,ps3 and pc. the first party development resulted in an excellent game that was highly regarded on all the platforms. Origins was developed console first and ported by iron galaxy. the port was atrociously bad. you could not finish the game. the main story line was bugged so hard that you could tell that the developers had never done anything more than walk around the first mission.
- serge2k 11y agoNot at first though. They had to patch to get it into a good state. I had one game breaking bug with origins, but I found a workaround on youtube. I think origins get too much crap personally, I had fun. This port is one of the worst in a long time. This isn't bethesda where it is just bugs on bugs, they capped the FPS.
- minimaxir 11y agoThe suspension is likely happening due to many, many technical issues with the port: http://kotaku.com/batman-arkham-knights-pc-version-is-a-mess-1713351974 http://kotaku.com/batman-arkham-knights-pc-version-is-a-mess... The average rating for the game on Steam was 31%. Since this was the first AAA game to be released on Steam after the release of Steam Refunds, it's also suspected that a high number of returns could force drastic action.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- voxic11 11y agoI never noticed any issues with GTA V, its gotten quite good reviews on PC to http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/grand-theft-auto-v http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/grand-theft-auto-v
- evilduck 11y agoMight have meant GTA IV, which was a terrible PC port.
- frik 11y agoGTA IV was a port of the XBox360 version which has 3 CPU cores. GTA IV was the first triple A game that maxed out all three cores. Most PCs at release time still had dual (2) cores albeit a lot faster cores than the XBox360. So GTA IV never run fine on a PC with just two cores. Another thing was the bad driver compatibility with ATI/AMD graphic cards. For the nVidia cards there was the first time ever that they released a special launch beta driver specially for GTA IV PC. Beside that, to run at very high settings one needed a high end graphics card. GTA IV was with Crysis 1 the last PC game that pushed hardware to the limits. Even today both still look great, and with certain mods they look as great as GTA V (though in the later case the engine is more optimized). Nowadays GTA V is a XBoxOne port and it doesn't push the PC hardware to the limits, it uses just 25% of my CPU and 50% of the GPU running with 60 fps in 1080p.
- thejosh 11y agoAnd issues like these are why you should never preorder PC games. They have an unlimited amount of copies, so it's not like you will be waiting weeks for something. Is a tiny preorder bonus really worth the risk of gambling your money? Now Steam has introduced refunds, you can refund a game if you haven't played more than 2 hours, and a few weeks haven't passed.
- eru 11y agoIf it's a small company, you might want to give them money up front to help them keep afloat. Steam has early-acces games for that reason. (It's better than pre-order, since you get to play the unfinished game earlier, if you want to. If you choose early-access but wait for the official release before you run it, it's exactly the same as pre-order.)
- adamrezich 11y agoRight, but you should only give them money if the product that they have on Early Access is already fun, right? Take Rust (the game, not the language) for instance. They cobbled together what is now known as "Rust Legacy" as a sort of demo of what they wanted the game to be. Thousands of people bought it. Now Facepunch is using the funds from all those sales to completely rework the game from the ground-up. Now it's better than Rust Legacy, and only going to get better and more interesting. But if Rust Legacy wasn't fun, nobody would've bought it. TL;DR: don't preorder (including early access!) games purely on promise alone.
- lmm 11y agoWhat if what they have so far isn't fun, but you think it might become very fun if they were given enough money to finish it? Isn't that (sometimes) worth taking the risk on?
- ascagnel_ 11y agoTo steal an idea from Bungie, when it comes to games you want "thirty seconds of fun" -- a base gameplay loop (in the case of Halo, where it originally applied, it's the loop of taking out baddies from a distance, then the stronger baddies from mid-range, then mopping up the scattered weak baddies). An early demo (like the aforementioned Rust Legacy) is a proof-of-concept of that base gameplay loop, and if players like it, they can fund it. Once it's funded, they can build out from that base loop, and eventually you'll get a finished product.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoI'm not surprised they suspended it but I wonder why they even released it. A vast majority of games that are released for consoles end up having a delayed PC version so why didn't they just delay it even for a short time? For what it's worth the game is really fun to play on a console. Slightly off topic: am I the only one who had to open developer tools to hide the huge spoiler modal because no key combination / refresh / mouse clicking would get rid of it? That was frustrating.
- hudell 11y agoI was in mobile and I found no way to close that modal.
- breakingcups 11y agoShould've clicked the big link at the bottom of the modal which says "Continue to forums".
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoThis was not displayed for me, smart ass. They have the CSS so that it doesn't work very well at all resolutions. No matter what I tried I couldn't see the bottom edge of the modal.
- yaeger 11y agoI bet it was an executive decision. The game was already delayed. Twice. They probably decided to push out what they had for PC just so they wouldn't have to announce another delay. For the PC version only, of course. While simultaneously releasing the console versions. My guess is, they thought even though it is buggy, they can fix it with patches and will only get minor flack for this from the PC users. And that this would be the better choice than to anger every PC gamer by announcing the third delay. Well, now it is clear that this was the wrong decision. They both, underestimated just how broken the game was and how incomplete compared to the console version and they forgot about Valve's newly introduced refund system. WBGames can claim that they suspended this game for PC but if I were to venture a guess, I'd say it was Valve that suspended this game because they were tired of processing so many refunds. They would have said "A game that gets this many negative reviews and all are claiming horrible performance and missing effects must clearly be broken and therefore we shouldn't continue to sell it as it will only lead to even more refund claims." A couple of interesting things to note: 1. They removed the PC logo from all Arkham Knight pages. 2. The company itself tells people about how to request refunds 3. The company also asks for patience while this is being worked out The last two are somewhat contradictory to me. When a company tells customers on their own free will how to get refunds sounds like an admittance to failure and that they do not believe this can be fixed in a timely manner. And then they still ask for patience which sounds like they are working on a solution. Paired with them removing all PC logos from their promo pages for this game really seems weird. While this announcement was leagues better than the marketing speak of the first announcement they did, I think customers still need more, clearer information what is going to happen. People who deal in software already know this but the average customer has no idea how long such things can take. Therefore they should explicitly announce what they are going to do. To me, it doesn't sound like patches will do the trick. From all accounts, this pc version sounds broken by design and the root causes are stuck deeeeeep in there. So, if they plan to fix this, then they should announce that an entire rewrite is needed and that this takes time. While at it, they should also tell us who will do this rewrite. I am sure no one wants Iron Galaxy at this again. We want Rocksteady to do it. Because we know they actually can make a Batman game. As evidenced by the ps4 version of this one and the first two games in general. Both ran fine on pc. I already heard speculation that they might try and release this in the fall when they scheduled the SteamOS and Mac version of the game. One can only hope for the sake of the windows version that Rocksteady will not be busy writing these versions and continue to outsource the windows version to the same cracksquad that arsed up this time.
- archagon 11y agoWith my low-end computer (previously mid-range), I've found that even with driver updates and patches, launch performance in games never improves by more than a few FPS. Now, to my knowledge, the problem with Knight is that it runs poorly and is capped to 30. If the pattern continues and Rocksteady can't reliably get it up to 60 (a 2x gain!!), then what happens? The game remains suspended forever? (In other news, I was really hoping to maybe eke by playing Knight at low/30fps on my Macbook w/discrete Nvidia graphics, but I guess that's not going to happen.)
- rjbwork 11y agoHere's the thing: you're not the person who's raging out over this. Yes, you're part of the demographic who might be upset, but it's people like me, who have stuff like 2x(or more) 980/295x (or better), 3000+MHz DDR4, x99 Processors/Motherboards, all overclocked, with custom cooling solutions and hooked up to G-Sync/FreeSync displays, that are upset. While graphics are not everything, and I play plenty of non-AAA games, a good chunk of the rationale behind even buying AAA games is beautiful graphics and high framerates. With the shit drivers from NVidia, and the absolute tripe so many studios are pumping out these days, I'm questioning the ongoing viability of high-level desktop gaming solutions. Then, to have the absolute audacity to call a game AAA when it's hard capped at 30fps on PC is just an absolute act of spitting in our faces.
- archagon 11y agoYeah, it sucks. Unfortunately, it's been sucking for mid-range gamers for a lot longer than that! The idea that a gaming PC can last you for an entire console cycle is a dirty, dirty lie. I guess the bloat is finally seeping up to the high-end.
- efraim 11y agoA decent PC lasted a long time during the previous console generation but with this new generation and its unified 8 GB of memory the VRAM requirements on PC have gone up a lot. WB claims a minimum of 3 GB for AMD users to play Arkham Knight. A new graphics card with > 6 GB of VRAM will probably last quite a few years from now.
- ShardPhoenix 11y agoThat forum must be really heavily moderated/censored. Based on eg the Battle.net forums I'd have expected to see much angrier posts.
- minimaxir 11y agoThe corresponding announcement on Steam has what you're looking for: http://steamcommunity.com/games/208650/announcements/detail/145587678167685991 http://steamcommunity.com/games/208650/announcements/detail/...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TTPrograms 11y agoRuns great? It's hard capped at 30 FPS as far as I understand, and higher quality textures/effects were intentionally removed from the console versions. Not everyone is used to the difference in appearance, but that's hardly what most people would call "great" for a $60 AAA title.
- NeutronBoy 11y agoEspecially when you have 'ports' like GTA V, which in reality was a different version of the game for PC, which ran like a dream.
- dagw 11y agoThe 'price' you had to pay for that was waiting 6 month from the console version came out before getting the PC port.
- NeutronBoy 11y agoIt was over 12 months I'm pretty sure. And it was absolutely worth it. I already owned the game on Xbox 360, and was more than happy to buy the PC version.
- tomswartz07 11y agoIt was just under 2 years. PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 17 September 2013 PlayStation 4, Xbox One 18 November 2014 Microsoft Windows 14 April 2015
- anti-shill 11y agowas there a confederate flag on it?!
- beedogs 11y agoThey must've just run this one through a shell script to port it. Seems like they put the least amount of effort they could into the PC version.
- pervycreeper 11y agoSteam refunds, in conjunction with the recent political mobilization of gamers, will change the gaming landscape for the better, allowing developers and consumers to stand in a relationship that begins to approach good faith. This seems to be the first AAA reaction to the new situation, but we have already witnessed the complaints of Steam crapware/shovelware producers, as well as the exit from games of some bad actors (such as Tale of Tales).
- recursive 11y agoDoes anyone know whether the Xbox version is ok?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rkangel 11y agoThere's a nice side benefit here for the fact that I'm always at least 6 months behind games. I don't have enough time to play games as much as I'd like (i.e. as much as I did as a teenager), so I only play a few selected highlights, and given that, it makes no difference to me if I'm playing the cutting edge or what came out 6 months ago - it normally takes me 6 months to finish something. This has lots of benefits: You get the community consensus on what is worth playing, not the marketing hype. The game is usually cheaper. The major bugs have been filtered out.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoTotally agreed. Why pre-order to get the exclusive content when you can have it 6 months down the line in the "Game Of The Year Edition" - and usually much cheaper and with all of the bugs ironed out. What's not to like? :)
- Vaturius 11y agoI think this is an honest and fair decision towards the consumer base. Perhaps they can offer one of the two previous Batman games to make up for the time lost before the update arrives. Let's hope the patch resolves the issues.
- alexholehouse 11y agoTechnical question - I've seen reports that, "...people who have installed the game to SSD's are apparently getting better performance" [1]. Which implies, to me (both intuitively and having worked on a lot of high performance I/O limited use cases) that part of the issue is read/write speed from the disk? But if that's the case, what kind of software architecture makes sense for a game to have (apparently) real time data processing pulling resources from the disk? Obviously you need to load maps/games/cutscene etc etc, but this makes it sound like there is constant polling every n-th frame? [1] - http://www.pcgamer.com/batman-arkham-knights-launch-appears-to-be-a-disaster/ http://www.pcgamer.com/batman-arkham-knights-launch-appears-...