6 ms·
Paul Krugman Goes for a Knockout Against Scrappy Austerians
- comex 11y agoThe GIFs are clearly the product of some effort, but I would've preferred if the article itself were a bit more thorough. In particular, it mentions several debates between Krugman and other economists that seem to have a basis in more or less factual allegations - whether switching to a different month as a basis for a comparison would indeed seriously undermine one of his arguments, whether he failed to predict such-and-such (really, in general whether he's been as spot-on over the years as he himself claims), etc. What I'd really like to read would be a Politifact-style third party analysis of the disputes. Of course, there is no such thing as a truly objective fact check, but an attempt would at least give me some idea of the reality of the situation. I could try to do the research myself, but I don't know the first thing about economics, so I expect it would be rather difficult... doesn't prevent me from taking a casual interest in the matter.
- zurn 11y agoIndeed. This sounds like they just gathered soundbites from his opponents without any attempt at even-handedness, even though many of the issues have been followed by a lot of back-and-forth in public fora. Followers of Krugman's blog can recognise many counterarguments in the article which have been specifically addressed in his blog (and in many cases credibly overturned). Also it would be fair to let his side pick a share of the debate points.
- maxlybbert 11y agoThere are no GIFs, but I enjoyed the "Three Wrongs Don't Make a Right" article ( http://fee.org/freeman/detail/paul-krugman-three-wrongs-dont-make-a-right http://fee.org/freeman/detail/paul-krugman-three-wrongs-dont... ): "Krugman, armed with his Keynesian model, came into the Great Recession thinking that (a) nominal interest rates can’t go below 0 percent, (b) total government spending reductions in the United States amid a weak recovery would lead to a double dip, and (c) persistently high unemployment would go hand in hand with accelerating price deflation. Because of these macroeconomic views, Krugman recommended aggressive federal deficit spending. "As things turned out, Krugman was wrong on each of the above points: we learned (and this surprised me, too) that nominal rates could go persistently negative, that the US budget 'austerity' from 2011 onward coincided with a strengthening recovery, and that consumer prices rose modestly even as unemployment remained high. Krugman was wrong on all of these points, and yet his policy recommendations didn’t budge an iota over the years. "Far from changing his policy conclusions in light of his model’s botched predictions, Krugman kept running victory laps, claiming his model had been 'right about everything.' He further speculated that the only explanation for his opponents’ unwillingness to concede defeat was that they were evil or stupid."
- overgard 11y agoYeah, but why engage in thoughtful debate when you can show a gif of him punching people?
- zurn 11y agoThis guy doesn't seem very credible judging by the WP article about him or the one about his employer (He works for an oil money funded right wing climate-skpetic "think tank").
- maxlybbert 11y agoDo you have any complaints about the article itself, or do you simply stop thinking once you find out that you don't agree with everything somebody says, or everybody somebody gets money from? Did Krugman claim that nominal interest rates couldn't go below 0%? Did Krugman claim that austerity would lead to a double dip recession? Did Krugman claim high unemployment would go hand in hand with spiraling deflation? Did Krugman claim that anybody who disagreed with him was evil or stupid? Has Krugman now decided that, even though interest rates went below 0%, austerity did not cause a double dip recession, and high unemployment did not accompany spiraling deflation that he was "right about everything"? Did the New York Times ombudsman say that Krugman has a "disturbing habit of shaping, slicing and selectively citing numbers in a fashion that pleases his acolytes but leaves him open to substantive assaults"?
- zurn 11y agoI do change my default attitude toward the message once I find it is coming from someone working for a neocon think-tank. They have a history of being intellectually dishonest to put it charitably. For a hashing of the claims you might have a peek in the comments about this article on Reddit (spoiler: claims don't exactly get a free pass): https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/386ntm/paul_krugman_three_wrongs_dont_make_a_right_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/386ntm/paul_krug...
- maxlybbert 11y ago
- c2the3rd 11y agoOne thing to remember about Krugman is that his specialty in college was trade theory. That is what he studied as a graduate and what his thesis was about. He made landmark advances in that field, and I respect him for it. However, this also means he is not an authority on monetary or fiscal policy and his views on these things do not have the weight some think they do. He is widely published in mainstream news only because he is an talented writer.
- theophrastus 11y agoHowever beware the anointed authority; Greenspan was certainly that, and he denied the recession was coming, was already underway, and to this day has only grudgingly admitted that it happened. Krugman, among others, saw the danger early and tried to warn us.
- ende 11y agoYup. If anyone wants to read some high quality Krugman, check out his recent posts on TPP. I think he does a great disservice to his intellect by wading into political economy and his constant partisan mudslinging. I think it's the one thing standing in the way of him taking the baton from Milton Friedman.
- datainplace 11y agoI hate that Bloomberg is trying to be Buzzfeed. This could be the most amazing though provoking article of all time, but I'm not going to read it when it starts with an animated Krugman GIF
- overgard 11y agoYeah, it's entirely unreadable, but I suspect for the target audience reading is not the point.
- usefulcat 11y agoSpoiler: it's not.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThat page is truly optimized for lynx (or, in my case, w3m).
- EdSharkey 11y agoThe whole anti-austerity argument has always sounded to me like the left's version of "grow your way out of recession/depression" or "trickle down economics". Doesn't wasteful central government stimulus always just enrich cronies and banksters? The whole shovel-ready jobs being nowhere to be found/summer of recovery thing was kindof laughed off by the president, but that obscene $500bil stimulus still got spent.
- jbooth 11y agoSure, 'wasteful' anything is probably, uh, wasteful. But there's a long history of successfully executed stimulus, VERY MUCH INCLUDING the recent one which was supposed to lead to hyperinflation and the end of society as we know it, but actually was highly correlated with a very nice recovery from near total economic meltdown. Austerity has way better rhetoric, you can talk about wasteful spending and living within our means, blah blah, but the predictions have absolutely sucked compared to standard economics. Edit: other austerity greatest hits: * don't bail out detroit! * qe will lead to hyperinflation! * cancel infrastructure projects! * buy gold!
- wavefunction 11y agoRegarding quantitative easing, I would actually assign support for pursuing to the pro-austerity camp as it devalued the dollar and caused the average consumer's purchasing parity to decrease. It was austerity applied to the population at large to solve the problems caused by only a fractional portion of the population in the US.
- jbooth 11y agoBut it didn't devalue the dollar, inflation's been really low for the last 7 years. Honestly it doesn't make much sense, and should really make people hesitate to pursue deflationary measures. China's fiscal policy does serve to deflate the dollar, so that counterweights QE a little, but that much? Maybe, I guess?
- _yosefk 11y ago
- stephenboyd 11y agoYou know you're finally an adult when mainstream business news companies try to package themselves in a way that appeals to people your age. Are 16 bit-style animated loops like the "Dennis Hopper in a motorcycle jacket" for millenials? Are we going to see mutual fund ads like this in 20 years?
- overgard 11y agoThis is quite possibly one of the stupidest things I've ever seen. First off, the form. I did not appreciate the fact that hitting the down arrow on the keyboard made me scroll right, and the right arrow did nothing. I'm amazed by people that go to great technical lengths to fuck up scrolling. My browser works fine by default, stop doing shit to break it. Second, I can't even find the point of this article other than like, Paul Krugman wins at something and they have illustrated this by showing him punching people? Is that really the standard now? Jesus Christ. Even before this I thought Paul Krugman was generally an idiot, and while I don't know if he endorsed this nonsense, it doesn't help my opinion of him. Third, the animated gifs made this unfucking readable. Even if I wanted to focus on the light weight content, I couldn't, because there's this goddamn gif blinking in the corner of my eye every three seconds. If you're making me queue up an ad blocker to block a thing that's not even an ad, you've failed at web design.
- overgard 11y agoFor the downvoters: please explain your reasons, cowards.
- rsync 11y agoDo not discuss your own downvotes. Do not interrupt the actual discussion to meta-discuss the scoring system.
- overgard 11y agoI don't care. I'll do it anyway. When I disagree with something strongly at least I'll state my reasons. I rarely downvote people I disagree with if their arguments have obviously been considered. If we don't extend the courtesy of explaining ourselves to others, instead of learning from each other this turns into a popularity contest, and the value of the community is lost.
- dredmorbius 11y agoApplause, on all points. I've got the article open in w3m to see it's even worth reading.
- noobermin 11y agoSheesh, am I the only one who actually enjoyed the visuals? The idea of having economists in an arcade brawl is basically parodying their usual blogpost battles and treating it as if it were real fighting, so I found it humorous. The article itself, however, is queer--it ends in an unsatisfying ambiguity: apparently Krugman wins because he is both "ref as well as combatant". In fact, the article seems to imply he loses three arguments (there are three gifs of him getting hit) and wins two, although with Osbourne, it's a little ambiguous there who is right. So, 1.5/5...So he...wins?
- overgard 11y ago> Sheesh, am I the only one who actually enjoyed the visuals? Pretty much. The pixel art was well made, but the point of design is to convey an idea. The only point conveyed to me here was "I can't read this because things are flickering in the corner of my eye", and the parts I did manage to read did not seem worthwhile of the effort.
- sixQuarks 11y agoWhen you throw as much money at the problem as we did in 2008-09, of course there's going to be a "recovery". I'll believe Krugman was right only if we go another 15 years without a major economic collapse. I believe all we did following his policies is kick the can down the road, and will eventually pay a bigger price in the future.
- afsina 11y agoI read it as ".. Against Scrappy Austrians" and thought finally Krugman showed some guts to debate against Austrian school economists.
- Mikeb85 11y agoThe fact that anyone will still argue for austerity is mind-boggling. It's been shown to have failed. You can't slash spending and increase taxes and expect the GDP to go anywhere but down. Greece is the poster child. Most of the arguments made for austerity is for countries that modestly reduced some government spending in an otherwise positive economic state. And let's face it, every 'developed' country's government spends a vast quantity of money, far more than most will admit. Here's a list of countries' government spending as a percentage of GDP: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending#As_a_percentage_of_GDP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending#As_a_perce... The US is at 42%, Germany at 45%, Sweden at 51%, and France at 56%, and Denmark at 57%. Most of the countries at the lower percentages are '3rd world' or failed states... The idea that a 'smaller' government will lead to economic prosperity has no basis in historical reality.
- overgard 11y agoI have no strong opinions on austerity (I think this tends to be a european topic that I hesitate to comment on because I don't have enough information), but I don't think it's that weird that people might disagree. Somehow Keynesian economics has become the dominant ideology, and while I think that rational people can certainly have differences with regard to his economic views, I think it's weird that his ideas have essentially become a religion, where arguing against them relegates one to the "fringe". Of course, this article didn't help, because instead of advancing a thoughtful discussion, it tried to use animated gifs and "clever" web design to distract people from noticing that the content of the article was both vapid and internally incoherent. I know people are probably thinking, "why do you care", and I don't particularly, but I think this article is basically an insult to all of us. This is bloomberg essentially stating: "this is what we think of you, if you're reading this, we think you're the sort of person that can be distracted by shiny stupidity". My previous feelings towards bloomberg were mildly positive, but I suspect moving forward any articles they write I will have a more critical view towards. That said, hats off to the people that made the images. They are really good, and obviously the people behind them are very talented. I wish it had been attached to something worthwhile.
- 11y ago
- atmosx 11y agoI was disappointed, although I've read many of those debates (to some I could answer easily myself heh) but this nice street-fighter-like gifs and the short text without any sort of arguments/data is kinda ridiculous.
- bjterry 11y agoThis is interesting as an art piece, but I think it is easy to intuit from the presentation that the authors are not being very careful thinkers. The truth is that the question of austerity is a fairly complex one. The reason it seems so cut and dried is that the modal promoter of austerity has no training in macroeconomics and is making arguments that are clearly not supported by theory. That said, to portray Krugman as definitely correct on the matter of austerity is very misleading. There are basically two camps of people opposing Krugman, "mainstream Austrians" and market monetarists. Mainstream Austrians isn't really a category, but this is people who make arguments based on analogies with household budgets, and worry about hyperinflation from out of control spending. Most of them have economic theories that are not well-supported empirically. These people say austerity is better and will lead to stronger growth, possibly after a painful period of economic adjustment. Often these are head economists at small banks or other pundits that get a lot of airtime for their opinions. They probably don't actually identify as Austrians 95% of the time, but in this particular instance they are following Austrian thinking. The other major camp is market monetarists, whom Krugman is very dismissive of, despite the fact that their arguments are compelling and their empirical support is probably as strong as pro-spending Keynesians. In his arguments with market monetarists Krugman has been almost dishonestly evasive, initially claiming that the American austerity would be the ultimate test of market monetarist thinking, but then posting no follow-up eating crow after the test showed strong macroeconomic growth "in spite of" the austerity. The fundamental issue of austerity under market monetarist thinking is that of monetary offset. The central bank has an inflation target, and they are targeting it no matter the fiscal policy of the country as enacted by legislators. If the legislature authorizes dramatically higher spending, monetary authorities increase interest rates to slow down the economy and bring inflation back in line with their 2% target. If the legislature instead goes after austerity policies, the monetary authorities lower interest rates to increase economic activity and again hit that 2% inflation target. In America, when our austerity came into effect, our central bank started a round of additional quantitative easing, which is functionally similar to lowering the interest rate when it is at zero, and this lead to us having continued growth despite the slowdown in government spending. One of the things about monetary offset is that it only applies to countries that have independent monetary policy, i.e. they have their own independent central bank issuing their own currency. Market monetarists and Keynesians agree that austerity is a terrible policy for countries in the Eurozone, because they do not have independent monetary policy to make up for their decreased spending. The problem is that Keynesians also apply that thinking to countries that have independent monetary policy like the UK, Switzerland and the US. The fact that Krugman does not address this explicitly is one of the best demonstrations of his unwillingness to intellectually engage with his market monetarist opponents. It's much easier to bash on the people making the worst arguments on the other side, rather than those making the best arguments, and he is obviously very political in his thinking, and thus very tribal in his politics. Krugman is a very careful writer, however, so he rarely says anything that's outright wrong, he just chooses not to address the best arguments against his viewpoints, or says more by implication than by direct statement. For more on market monetarism, one can read the blog of Scott Sumner at http://www.themoneyillusion.com/ http://www.themoneyillusion.com/ or as one of the blggers at http://econlog.econlib.org http://econlog.econlib.org and in particular one can read recent posts at [1], [2] and [3] on this topic: 1: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/06/the_other_thing.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/06/the_other_thing.... 2: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/06/russ_roberts_vs_1.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/06/russ_roberts_vs_... 3: http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=29692 http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=29692